Thank you. Okay, now that we're recording, I will call our meeting to order, and please stand for the flag salute. You may be welcome. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. So, can we please get a roll call of commissioners present? Commissioner Scavdell? Here. Commissioner Levy? Here. Commissioner Mulder? Here. Commissioner O'Neill? Here. Commissioner West? Here. Commissioner Curiazzi? Here. Commissioner McFarland? Here. Exciting, everyone made it. Director, do we have any agenda modifications? We do. We're going to...
I ask you to pull item 2E2 off the consent calendar. It's Humboldt Heritage Farm Management LLC. It's shown as being continued to January 16th. We're probably not going to have enough items to have a meeting on that day, so we want to continue that item to a date uncertain. Okay. And then the supplemental for? We have a supplemental for organic liberty with three additional conditions. There's a second supplemental for organic liberty expressing support for the recommendation to adopt the mitigated negative declaration and approve the project as recommended. And just to clarify, that added conditions of approval, if approved and left on consent, that would just be added in there, correct? Correct. Okay. Thank you. So we got those. Public comment on non-agenda items. Is there anyone in the room that would like to?
speak on non-agenda items please come to the podium seeing no one make it to the podium on zoom please raise your hand if you want to speak on non-agenda items seeing no hands raised we will move to should be consent yes consent agenda so i'll start off naming the numbers and if somebody wants to see that pulled off of consent and talked about please raise your hand if you want to see it stay on consent which means that'll be whatever the action recommended is which all these are approvals i believe so we'll start number one is there a review and approval of november 21st 24 action summary anyone on the commission want to remove that anyone in the public want to remove that no okay item number two will be pulled um for staff recommendation
Item number three, Mystic Mountain Farms LLC conditional use permit in the Bloxburg area. Is there anyone on the commission? Commissioner Scavdahl would like to see that pulled. Okay. So, we will move to item number four, Organic Liberty California LLC conditional use permit and special permit and zoning clearance certificates. Anyone on the commission? Yeah, that's the one with extra conditions. Anyone in the public? No one on Zoom, so that will stay on consent. And that's it. So, I need a motion, or I would like a motion for items one and four, I believe. Chair, I would move approval of items one and four on the consent agenda. I'll second. Any discussion? We'll do a voice vote. All those in favor? Please say aye. Aye. Anyone opposed? Motion.
carries so now we go to public hearings which we don't have any public hearings so now we go item g items pulled from consent we would start with number two and that would just be staff is just asking us to continue it to a date uncertain is that correct that is correct okay motion before I take the motion I'm just gonna open up public comment if anyone wants to comment on the date uncertain continuance or potential continuance please come to the podium if you're in person seeing no one make it to the podium on the zoom not seeing anyone now we can go for a motion I'll motion to approve item e to also excuse me with a date uncertain okay
You're good with that second. Okay, we will do a voice vote. All those in favor, please say aye. Aye. Anyone opposed? Motion carries. Okay, so now we are item number three. Commissioner Scavdahl, you asked for that to be pulled. Do you have clarifying questions or would you like a full staff report? I think we can do it with a clarifying question. I just am trying to make sure that we don't have some confusion on the water storage requirement. And I note that CDFW, their referral, noted that there were two 50,000 gallon bladders on site that they wanted to have removed and replaced. I think as I read their comment, they were saying that they wanted to have two 50,000 gallon bladders on site. And I think as I read their comment, they were saying that they wanted to have two 50,000 gallon bladders on site. And I think as I read their comment, they were asking for a minimum of 70. And I think as I read their comment, they were asking for a minimum of 70.
thousand gallons of storage to replace those bladders. The staff report notes that the bladders are 20,000 gallons each. And reads in the staff report, it says, if the applicant chooses to replace those bladders, they should be replaced with hard-sided tanks. And then the condition actually says, condition number three says, remove the two 20,000-gallon bladders and replace with hard-sided tanks for 40,000. So I'm trying to understand if we're actually, first of all, are they 20,000 or 50,000? And are we meeting CDFW's requirement? For the 70,000 gallons of storage.
adding by only replacing with 40,000 plus the 50 that were already there. We're under the impression that there are only 40,000 gallons of water bladders and CDFW recommended less storage than what they believed it to be. So we are recommending replacement with the full storage that we are under the impression that it is. I think it would help if we, on condition three, modified it to say replace the two 20,000-gallon bladders with 40,000 gallons in hard-sided tanks for a total storage of 90,000 gallons. So if we could just add that, I think that would satisfy. CDFW's comment and...
Would you be just a bit more clear? Thank you. Okay. Are there any other clarifying questions? Because, well, technically we'll open the public hearing. We're going to ask some clarifying questions, and then we have to open it up to African if there's anything. I do have one clarifying question. I did not see mention of water storage for fire suppression on this. Did I miss that, or is that included in their site plan? I'll admit I do not recall. Let me take a look at the plan.
Thank you. That may be worth adding as a condition. Are there any other clarifying questions? Okay. So the public hearing is open or has been open with the clarifying questions. There is no staff report. There was a couple clarifying questions from the commission. If the applicants out there, they have the opportunity to speak on this or present on this. I'm not seeing anyone. Anyone in the room is the applicant? Anyone on Zoom? Anyone want to speak on this project at all? Seeing no one move, I'm going to close the public comment and bring it back to the commission. Looking for a motion with Commissioner Curiazzi. Apologize. I do have a discussion item. Okay. It's really, I'm kind of using this as.
A scapegoat to talk about it, but I'm sort of a question about process in general to staff. This is regarding the renewable energy requirements, and I've noticed a difference across projects. Some projects will have a condition saying a renewable energy plan will be submitted, and I see other projects where renewable energy transition will be achieved by a certain date, and I was curious if what the CEQA requirements are around this and if all projects are required to transition or are some allowed to just submit plans. To the chair, that's a good question. So it's not really... It's not really a CEQA question at this point. Especially for the cannabis projects that were under the first ordinance, there really was no requirement.
to transition to renewable energy under the ordinance or under the CEQA document that was adopted for it. However, over the years, it's been a very consistent practice from the Planning Commission to want to phase out generators. And so we've started, and this goes back probably four or five years now, requiring a condition that they phase out generators if they're using them and transition to renewable on-site energy if PG&E is not available. More recently, especially with some projects that have maybe more energy use, we have started asking that they submit a plan that demonstrates the energy budget. I think it's probably fair to say that we still could get a little bit more consistent on that approach. However, our approach has primarily been for mixed light and for energy-saving energy-saving projects. And other types of cultivation activities that require more power that we see that.
I think even given that approach, this is for outdoor, so I don't think that would be something we would necessarily recommend. Got it. Thank you. Any other? Sorry, I skipped past the discussion. Any other discussion? Yeah, I mean, just I appreciate the question because I have also noticed some inconsistency on that. In this case, it seems pretty clear that they shall develop and fully implement a plan by January 2026 is what I'm looking at here in Condition 9. So I think here we have the language that would suggest that they have to actually do it, but I'm not sure that that's always been quite worded the same. Thank you. Any other discussion? I'll make a motion to...
To approve the Mystic Mountain project as proposed with the revisions to clarifying the on-site water storage as Commissioner Scavedal had stated. With the fire suppression or without the fire suppression? It would be for a total of 90,000 gallons with 5,000 of that, I think, being for fire suppression. I mean, 2,500 is the requirement, technically. Is it? I thought it was 5,000. 2,500 of that. Building code could be different, but as far as I know, it's 2,500. Okay. 2,500. Stand corrected. 2,500. Okay. And that's condition number three revised, correct? Correct. Okay. We got a second? I'll second. Okay. Any other discussion? Okay. I'll do a voice vote on this one.
All in favor please say aye. Aye. Anyone opposed? Motion carries. So now we've gone so now we will adjourn as a planning commission and then we have to convene as a building appeals board and bring up item j building code appeal and I will say in all my years of following the commission and being on the commission this is new to me so I'm all ears. Thanks. As the chief building official gets ready to present this just give you a little background on this and the building code there is a provision to allow for appeals where somebody disagrees with the determination of the chief building official and so in in the building code oftentimes that's a very technical committee for lack of a broad range of technical people within the community. The decision was made to
give this assignment to the Planning Commission. And so the municipal code, or the Humboldt County Code, identifies that the Board of Appeals is the Planning Commission. So you're appointed to do this. That's why you're convening as that body. And in this particular case, the chief building official is designated within the County Code to not only implement the Uniform Building Code, but also the Health and Safety Code. And so those are probably the primary provisions that are at play tonight. And this is based upon substandard housing. And so I'll let Chief Building Official Keith Ingersoll make that presentation. Can I make a clarifying before we open this? Well, it's open, but is this similar to Planning Commission where staff presents, and in this case, the appellant gets 15 minutes up to 15 minutes?
15 minutes. Is that how the process goes? This process is actually not that formal. Okay. So I do notice, I believe that the appellant is on Zoom. So I'm going to go ahead and invite them in to be a panelist. And so given the fact that this is an appeal and the appellant has the basic right to present their information, I'm going to invite them in to be able to present this. You can ask them questions. You can ask the staff questions. The building inspector that looked at this, Rob Edwards, is also here to answer any questions that you might have or that the appellant has. Okay. So same thing, somewhere in that 15 minutes. I would follow the same basic parameters, but I don't know. So I would encourage. I would encourage you not to be really super strict about that. Sounds. If things are kind of going on.
too long you have that discretion thank you for that clarification ask a clarifying question clarifying questions yes are we the end all of decisions here or is it like the planning commission where the appellant can also elevate to the board of supervisors after i believe you are the deciding factor here that's thank you for that clarifying question that's what i heard the director say is where the appeals board all of a sudden so um i will turn this over to staff now good evening uh yeah we have an appeal hearing here before you uh on a case for uh substandard housing and uh basically we're gonna this slide here would be the topic and it sets out the focus for the presentation uh do not share you you you
Thank you. Can you unshare it and then share it again? Yeah, yeah. And this will communicate the primary subject.
Thank you. And so we're communicating the primary subject of this appeal. The parties involved are Lucas K. Bode. Can we pause for just one minute? We got some microphones. Thank you.
I'm going to try this. Try that. It's not picking up now, right? It's not showing. Testing. Yep, they're working now. Okay. Okay, yeah, we're gonna communicate the primary subject of this appeal. The parties involved are Lucas K. Bode and Katie Rocky. The objective of today's presentation is to argue for the upholding of the notice and order of substandard housing in order to vacate. The appeal was filed on October 29, 2019.
24 and it's essential to assess the reasons behind the appellant's dispute within the context of community safety. We can kind of go through the pictures. As you can see, we have unsanitary conditions in the kitchen area. Yeah, same area kitchen, unsanitary, substandard conditions. That's the kitchen as well. And here we have a hazardous electrical panel where everything's open. It could be an arcing hazard. Somebody touches a hot wire. It could... be very dangerous and could kill somebody.
Thank you. And we have the garage here. And we have the garage. And we have the garage here with the vehicle and different parts. It's kind of a fire life safety issue. The residential garage is not meant to be like an S1 auto shop occupancy. And this is another area of the garage with similar issues. And here we have a bathroom fan pulled down, it looks like. And more debris that are kind of blocking exit ways. Fire life safety issue. And more accumulation. More accumulation of items that kind of inhibit somebody from being able to exit.
room if they need to in a fire situation. Similar there. That's a bathroom facility there. Looks like they have some sort of an on-demand water heater sitting there on the ground. That's good. And they have a can light that's over the shower, which is a shocking hazard because it doesn't have the waterproof trim on it. So if you're taking a shower and water splashes up, you know you can get electrocuted that way. And here in this restroom we have a non-op water closet and then we have the outlet dangling out, which is an electrocution hazard there as well.
That's showing a different point of it pulled out. And then there appears to be some mold issue on the top that would need to be cleaned on the ceiling. And more electrical poking out that's a fire life safety issue. And additional electrical there, which is all this is a health and safety violation. And the steps there, they just have a lot of stuff on top of that guardrail. So if you're trying to exit in an earthquake or something like that, that stuff can fall in and then you're going to get trapped or you can't get out of the structure. Okay. Okay. Okay. And this is another room that has, you know, a lot of items there that are inhibiting being able to.
Well, to exit easily in an emergency. Similar items in this room as well. We have a gas fireplace that has debris on it and around it, which could be a life safety fire hazard issue. That's just other items. And here we have debris on the deck that's kind of inhibiting that door, you know, from fully opening. And more additional items in the backyard that are kind of encroaching on that green build area. And here we have the sewer pump lift. They have it coming out. And they're running a wire through the plumbing pipe. And it needs to get put.
in with an alarm and you know put in the code to where it's going to make sure it's going to work and there's another view of that and then here in this picture we have a foundation footing of that deck that's a two-story deck and the footing as you can see has been undermined uh they've dug around it excavated around it so it's kind of uh compromised a little there and then in here this is a room that's under the structure all kinds of miscellaneous electrical hazardous there's a water closet up in the air in there yeah that shows how you get in there Enemy
And then there's another footing on that deck, main point load of that, and it's been undermined and excavated. There's another picture of that deck. As you can see, the footing has been excavated quite a bit around that deck pier. Similar there, and debris, fire life stuff. Similar there, too, inadequate foundation on this one where they undermined it as well. I have some interesting electrical that's kind of dangling down there. That's definitely a fire life safety issue. More of the same. Then there's a little better picture of how that was excavated.
For some reason, that grade should have been up to where the only thing you see is the cylinder coming out of the ground. Same with that one, too. We have extension cord electrical. You know, that's a fire hazard. Plugged in and rolled up like that, it could actually heat up and cause a fire. Additional items in the way there in the yard. More of the same there. And here, the foundation underneath, it's on a step foundation that's undermined considerably the footing in the crawl area. And this has some interesting plumbing.
This is all unpermitted stuff that's happened here. Water line. It's just more of the same going under that under the house there. And then this you can kind of see that dirt line up on the foundation there has been excavated down and which is undermining the structural integrity of that footing which is holding up that that house. The whole residence. Just more of the same. And here's where that water closet sitting up on top of a deck you know and you have like a step to get up there I guess to use it which is totally non-compliant that was all unpermitted unsafe unsanitary health and safety violation. There's another picture.
view of it. And then here you can really see where that line that's underneath that footing there has been completely excavated down. It looks like they chipped and cut at it to make more room on what they were trying to excavate under the building. And that's more of the same. You can see where that dirt should be up, but it's excavated down and there's the hazardous electrical for the lift pump for the entire house there. Needs to get updated. So the property was inspected on September 26, 24 by Building Inspector Rob Edwards. The inspection was carried out.
was requested in response to a search warrant executed by the Humboldt County Drug Task Force, understanding the need to address potential serious violations at the site. The inspection revealed significant violations of the 97 Uniform Housing Code, the 21 International Property Maintenance Code, and multiple sections of the Health and Safety Code. These violations pose serious health and safety concerns and risks to the occupants and need to be addressed to the entire compliance with the safety standards. Key issues identified during the inspection include unsafe plumbing in the basement area, crawl area, and inaccessible bathroom that poses fire hazards. Evidence of mold dampness appeared to be evidence of some road damage, potent infestation, and structural hazards near the...
Foundation. Each of these conditions compromises the safety and livability of the dwelling. Further hazards include electrical dangers from exposed wiring and unsafe gas fireplace conditions, along with structural concerns related to weakened foundation footings. Additionally, solid waste obstructing access poses risks to both safety and sanitation, highlighting the urgency of remediation. It is recommended that the building appeals board adopt the resolution to uphold the notice and order of substandard housing in order to vacate. This recommendation is based on the substantial health, safety, and structural risk presented by the conditions identified during the inspection.
Hello everyone! Today I will show you how to make a beautiful, easy, and easy Christmas tree. I will show you how to make a beautiful, easy, and easy Christmas tree. I will show you how to make a beautiful, easy, and easy Christmas tree. I will show you how to make a beautiful, easy, and easy Christmas tree. So in conclusion the protection of community safety is paramount in upholding the notice and order will not only facilitate the necessary remediation of these hazards but also contribute to the broader effort of maintaining public health and safety standards within Humboldt County. So I invite any questions or concerns that the appeal board members may have. This serves as a time to kind of clarify any issues. Commissioner West. Are we technically not commissioners right now? How would I address? Probably appeal board members. Appeal board member West. Can you talk a little bit about the appeal board members?
A little bit about what happens from here if we uphold the order. The tenants have to move out, and then are there given time to remediate all of the issues identified? Yes. The issues totally can be remediated. It just needs to be done. The vacate order was put in there as a safety measure for the electrical. It was a big concern there. Fire life safety working in that garage. If the garage caught fire, it would end up roaring through that place. So the vacate order would hold, and then the applicant would, property owner would work to remedy and do all the corrective measures. And then they would call. We'd go out and re-inspect it, sign it off if it was good.
and then we would release that order. And that's typically how it works. I have a couple questions. One is sort of a follow-up on my fellow appeals board members' question. I don't see anything in here about criminal charges as part of the remedy for this. That's not what's being contemplated here. No, that's separate. We were strictly there for substandard housing conditions as the building division for the planning and building department. Okay. So what we're doing, what you're doing, has nothing to do with any criminal process? No. My other question, though, I was just ‑‑ I certainly ‑‑ I've reviewed the materials, and there's certainly a number of times states that this inspection occurred in response, to a record.
request from code enforcement related to a search warrant by the drug task force. I just was sort of curious what originally gave rise to that. Was there reports of, you know, concerns from neighbors, from tenants, from anyone like that, or was this sort of an unrelated matter that led to the search warrant discovering this? As I understand it, this had been a house that has been monitored for some time for drug activity and different things. And so they knew there were some standard housing issues in there. And so when they did the warrant, they brought us in when they, the day of it, so that we can address those items as well, separately from what the sheriff's department was doing. Got it. Thank you.
So it says that the appeal was filed by these two individuals. Are they also the property owners, the tenants, or renters? Lucas Bode is the property owner. Were they the residents also? Yes. They're not renting it. That was one of my questions. My other question was, are there any other outstanding issues with the county that we should be aware of, like delinquent taxes or anything that's relevant to this review? Not that I'm aware of. Are there any other clarifying questions? This has been opened up. So now at this point in time, the appellant, I don't see the appellant on Zoom. If the appellant is present, you can make your way to the podium and present.
Thank you. Hi, sorry, I'm super nervous talking in front of people. I just got out of the hospital too, I'm sorry. So, to start with, the warrant that they came in on. So, I mean, if you really want to start, the police have been hitting my house since we had a tenant over two years ago who has no connection to us whatsoever anymore. And she actually went to prison, got clean, her probation let her off early, she moved to another state. No connection to her whatsoever anymore. And she actually left us with a $46,000 debt during COVID for the...
rent and so um we're not on good terms and she uh for some reason they're obsessed with the fact that she is still somehow connected with the house and they've come through probation searches and warrants which i now realize i should have been more on it with asking for warrants and stuff from people because they don't normally give them to us and uh this last one i was luckily or dd was luckily on it and so i have I'm sorry. Yeah, I'm trying to give them the one that I want them to look at. That way I don't give them a whole stack of photos that aren't relevant yet. But yes, thank you. There, just not to interrupt you, but there also is a mic and a chair if it's easier.
for you to sit that would honestly be easier thank you so much and we can move on this out of the way thank you so much yeah absolutely and then this is the chair i'm so sorry okay did you stay here thank you so much yeah no problem so It's on? Okay. Testing. Okay, so the one photo I don't have is a picture of our security cameras, which I can find on my phone. It was well before 10.30 that they were already at my house and they served a warrant.
that they wouldn't give us and so everyone was in cuffs and my roommate Didi asked them for the warrant repeatedly and they said they'd give it to her. So when they left I called the next day and asked the police department and they had no idea what I was talking about. I asked task force the next day and they wouldn't return my call which I repeatedly called them for three days. They had arrested Luke the day that they came and I was stressed that obviously we were going to have to leave the house and he's been through a similar situation in Fields Landing so I bailed him out of jail with money and as soon as he got home the packet of papers they gave him they slipped the warrant in the back of the papers which this I can pass around. It has no warrant number, but it also says it's for 10 34 a.m. On the date that they came and uh, I know for a fact Lucas.
He's also the only person that they're suspect or whatever they want to call it when they came to the house that they were looking for. And like I said before, they've hit the house at least probably 20 times. I was already going to file harassment charges because it's gotten ridiculous. It's made our life pretty hard and they have never found anything. I think a couple people have had personal drugs on them at times because we've all been struggling. But all of us are at ages right now. So we're all recovering and don't have drugs. And again, they came and when I bailed Luke out of jail, they're not charging him now either. And so, yeah, that warrant, I don't think is legal at all. So I think the entry was warrantless. And even if it wasn't. It's a criminal warrant. They're not allowed to come in on a criminal warrant. And I thought it had to be an administrative warrant.
They have to ask you first if they can enter. If you say no, then they have to give you two weeks notice and then serve you a warrant. And they didn't do that. They piggybacked in on task force again because task force really wants to, has targeted us and really wants to take the house out of the picture. And so they literally, they brought them in, even though they've also been to the house many times and never had a problem with anything. This time they, when they couldn't find anything like usual, they said, don't worry, we brought code enforcement this time and they'll find something to shut it down. And so that is the warrant that they brought. So yeah, I'm trying to move, moving for the matter to be dismissed because it was a warrantless entry, warrant obtained later.
than it should have been and also because there's no proper inspection warrant nor probable cause to believe the building was internally or structurally substandard. Present motion is to dismiss and I have that right here. Thank you. I'm sorry would it be easier if I give you the stuff just in an order? Oh that's fine you can talk and I can come again. Um um we have also been working with uh Warren Black already um and so we actually had him by probably less than a week ago and he checked out the vehicles and the front of the house and checked it off and I've been working with him on doing the backyard and I thought we would be done today however there's been a lot of rain lately and then I ended up in the hospital for the past five days which uh wasn't planned and I'm not sure if I'm going to be able to do that again.
And obviously, and so I have, due to that, need more time. And we've been working on the inside as well. It's just, it's obviously taking a little bit of time. My boyfriend is a contractor. He's built many houses around here before. And the people, I can't prove right now who the complaint is, but I know it's a gentleman on the street that everyone there on the block has a restraining order against him. And he has had a tiff with Luke's dad. It goes back that far. And so he actually squatted into the house and ended up suing her mom when his dad hung himself to get the house for cheaper. And he just, yeah, I'm not going to go down that road. But he is the person that calls the cops all the time and began even all this stuff, because they get sick of the greasy wheels. I realize that. And so he knows calling and doing that stuff or taking pictures. And again, I've filed for a restraining order with him.
And because of that, I think my neighborhood can actually, as a whole, we want to make him leave more than us. So that says a lot, I think, right there. They're giving him a lot of power to run with just because he's annoying. Yeah. So then, substantial compliance. I have been complying with stuff, so I have photos from the front and some pictures from what's finished. I'm sorry. I know you just got up. And so now the only things out front before the three working vehicles is a axle, I believe, that Luke is going to make a trailer for so that Mini X.
In the backyard, we'll have a trailer to be moved because they want it moved off the property. I think there's two of every copy is the problem. I apologize if I put doubles in here. That's double, yeah. Thank you. These are doubles. Okay, beautiful. Thank you. And Like I said before, Luke is a contractor. His dad, Rob Bodie, was well-respected and good at what he did. They built many houses around here, including his whole family.
His uncle included. And Luke is an intelligent contractor. He knows the codes. He built the house originally with the intention of one day making a basement in it. There was a small basement in it, but he expanded when we lost the place in Fields Landing. And we were homeless because we didn't want to kick out the tenant until she stopped paying us because I didn't want to lose the house. She was paying the rent at first. And then so we made a small living area downstairs. And, yes, the toilet and stuff, we put stuff in so it was up to some sort of standard quickly, but he's taken it out. He knows it wasn't up to standard to keep it there, you know. But, again, the cops have been in there multiple times and never said anything about any of it. So all of a sudden, you know, it's odd that it's a problem. But do not enter unsafe to occupy. So, again, Luke has built many. I know he built.
Rex Bones, part of Rex Bones house. I know he built part of Virginia Bass's house. I know that The person that signed off for the house originally is Keith and so I have the original The original dude I'm sorry. I am. I just, I had all day just today to do this stuff and I apologize cause I just got out of the hospital. But, um, I don't have that one right now. I just have the one for do not enter, but we can look it up. Keith is the one that signed off the house when Luke originally built a house 10 years ago. It's not that old. He also built the foundation. I don't know exactly the footing, but he went down deep, built a large foundation that goes.
All the way to the house next door is one large foundation. The house is definitely sturdy. He might not have done perfect precision because he's not, you know, but he definitely knows what he can and can't do, and I don't think he built a basement that was going to become a problem when he knows the codes already. He's been building houses since he was in high school. You know what I mean? His dad started the building trades program, and he's done nothing. And, yeah, he's good at what he does. So, yeah, the allegations of substandard housing was made in part by the same county employee that signed off on the final inspection of the house when it was completed in 2012, Keith. Present final inspection notice, which I'm sorry I did not bring. We are obviously. We are obviously willing to enter into a.
compliance agreement for any additional steps that the commission um that the commission wants to take to it with us i've already been working with warren black and he has been we've been making progress and he's i thought we were doing good and we were doing it as quickly as we could but um yeah moving out of the house i think is unnecessary because it's not i mean we just had a 7.0 earthquake the house is definitely structurally sound he knows how to build a house you know and uh i find like yeah just kind of funny that it's even so then What's this? Is that the inspection record? Yeah, here's the original inspection record card from when he built the house. I'm sorry, I forgot it.
Thank you. Can you please pass the information that was given to us can we give that also to staff as it goes along so that way staff is aware of what's being presented and not to interrupt I just request that council reads the last page of that warrant. Yes. Sorry to interrupt you. No you're fine thank you. And just to note I'm not trying to hold like strict at 15 minutes how much time you need to present like no no I'm just letting you know like I understand so I'm not gonna gavel you down at 15. Thank you. Yes, I just want to make sure that all of your presentation is done. I want you to give all your presentation, but there might be, or is it distracting if you're interrupted and questions are asked? No, you're fine. Okay.
Appeals Board Member West has a question. I just wanted to make sure that I was following along correctly that Lucas Bodie is the one who has construction background and who was also the owner of the house, right? Yes. Okay, thank you. And he's my boyfriend. Okay, thank you. A follow up on that, is he a licensed contractor or does he not have a license? He's been a licensed contractor. We're actually getting his license back because of the situation. But he just stopped doing jobs outside, you know? And so he still works on his house. I didn't think you thought owners could do that, especially like owner builder, you know what I mean? I don't know enough about this stuff myself, but he's getting it back right now. I actually started the process. I just haven't finished it because I need to get some more money. I have a question. I guess it's a legal question. Do you have to have a warrant in order to get it back? Do you have to do a building inspection? So I don't want to ask any questions.
Questions of staff only of the appellant at this point in time because I don't want to ruin their due process for presentation. Sorry to cut you off. I'm pretty sure it is illegal. They need to, like I said, it has to be an administrative warrant. They can't piggyback in on a criminal warrant. And they need to give you a head, like ask you, and no one consents. And then they have to give you a two-week head notice of giving you the warrant. And I've had this already happen in Fields Landing, so I remember very well how that went. So this was, like I said, just kind of I felt like very secretive with task force and thinking we wouldn't do our due diligence to figure that out, you know. Right.
Well, and that's the other part too, the foundation, because they originally owned the house that he built, the two houses next door. So the one right next door, the foundation is connected. That house has been sold to someone, and the house after that is the gentleman who screwed their family out of the house, basically. And the one right next door that has the same foundation, technically, if you were to condemn our house, you would have to condemn that house too. So it's a single foundation but two separate lots. I'm going to let him answer this because he knows more about this than I do. Do you have any more for your presentation? I think I'm done. There might be one more person that wanted to say something but that's it. So as the the appellants say I'm under the impression that
You're Katie Rocky? And you are Lucas Bodie? Bodie, yes. Great. So you are the appellant, so you are part of the block of time, and then any other members of the public are allowed three minutes. Okay. That's separate because they aren't named. Okay. Unless, that's the way I read it, and I'm going to ask the director if I understand that. It is within your discretion. Okay. That's kind of how I'm reading it, unless there's... But they do have the opportunity to come to the podium and speak, or sit down and speak if they prefer that. Yeah, I think... And then after, the other clarifying thing is after public comment, if there's anything that's brought up that you want to rebut, say someone stands up and says all kinds of stuff that you don't agree with, then you have the opportunity to come to the podium again and, I don't know if the term rebuttal, but to clarify. Thank you. You're welcome. So at this time, I'll ask any other members of the... Public...
Present to make their way to the podium and you'll be limited to three minutes. Yeah. You are allowed to sit there the whole time if you want as well. You don't have to get up. Thank you. Hi, my name is Michael Acosta. I'm a friend of Katie and Luke's and I just wanted to say I hope you make the right decision in this case. I think sometimes this county confuses condemnation proceedings with abatement of nuisances. Condemnation is when you ask when the building's falling on somebody, you wouldn't let them stay even one more night. If there was a fire or earthquake and a building was condemnable where you had to give an order to vacate, you wouldn't say, well, the building's condemnable, but you can stay one more night even though the roof might fall down. The notice they got said that you have to be out within 48 hours. There's no provision for that. What this is is a nuisance case. And in a nuisance case, it's not business as usual to order people to vacate. What the business is.
usual has been has been to find people or do it for them and build them. It's not ordering people to vacate their homes. So this is not business as usual. This is an unprecedented notice that was received this time and I've reviewed a lot of abatement notices. This was an unprecedented one. We also had the opportunity to look at an old nuisance letter from 2017 and it was much kinder gentler agency back then apparently because it wasn't called code enforcement back then it was called compliance assistance and the people would get a letter from compliance assistance and they were given 30 days to respond not 10 days or two days in this case. So it seems like it's getting more aggressive and it's really about gentrification about squeaky wheels who are trying to cause gentrification. That's the bigger overarching picture. It's not about compliance of this house. If it's feces from rats, if it's garbage then ask them to clean it up or find them or do it for them and build them. But don't please don't create more homelessness in Eureka, California. Thank you.
Thank you. Is there anyone else in the public that wants to speak? Seeing no one. Anyone on Zoom? We have one participant. I'm not seeing a hand raised. So I will close that portion and go to the appellant and see if there's anything you want to add or clarify before we close the public comment portion. Thank you. Yeah, sorry. Hi, I'm Lucas Kane Bodie, and I built the house that we were living in with four other residents. Keith here inspected this house and signed off on it in 2012, I believe. And I agree that my district... ...justices were dirty.
Last I checked, that wasn't a code violation. And I feel like my Fourth Amendment rights are being violated. And there's... I used to look up to the building department for suggestions on how to build a house, but I've lost all respect for how they're operating. These abatements and people losing their homes because of lack of funding. It's sad.
I don't believe that this house is condemnable or in any violation at all. There's yes, there's repairs from my, I was incarcerated for eight months and my tenant previously left a mess for me to clean up. What can I say? I'm working on it. Yeah. The majority of these, my dishes are clean and the backyard is getting cleaned up. I don't know.
Is there anything you would like to add? Like I said, we are working with Warren Black. We've cleaned up the front. He checked it off. And in the warrant, the picture that they have to come to the house for it being not up to standard is a picture that is up to standard. So I find that very funny, too. But yeah, that's it pretty much. I'm sorry. Are there any clarifying questions? For the appellant? Okay. So at this time, I will close public comment. And I will actually, because of the being brought up that the Fourth Amendment rights were being violated and then also the warrantless search and I didn't go to law school, but I did read that last page of the warrant, which I just want to see what legal interpretation of those are before we proceed any farther in the hearing because I don't want to violate anyone's rights.
Jeff, Chair, if it would be acceptable to you, there are a number of things I think we want to respond to, but I'd like to see if you'd be willing to take a break and allow us to formulate our thoughts. I think it would be appropriate to take a 10, maybe 15-minute break, so that way we can have a real thoughtful presentation. If it's deemed that we need to continue or anything like that, I think that would be the intelligent thing to do. So, the Building Appeals Board is on a 10-minute recess, which may go to 15 minutes. Thank you.
Thank you. And then once the building official makes, we'll come. Recording in progress. Okay, so I'm bringing us back at 7.35 p.m. We have lost the one attendee that was following us on Zoom. But, staff, I will turn it over to you now. Okay. I apologize if the explanation I'm going to give is a little bit, well, it was a little confusing. So, ask questions, and I apologize. This is a really interesting situation and one that I've never encountered or thought about. And so we're going to try to muddle through a little bit and give you the best advice.
We can. This search warrant says on its last page, any information obtained through the execution of this warrant that is unrelated to the objective of the warrant shall be sealed and shall not be subject to further review, use, or disclosure absent in order from the court. The warrant doesn't specifically define what is the objective of the warrant, but it's a search warrant, and it checks certain boxes for the kinds of evidence that it's going to go search for. But then it includes this language. It says officers shall be allowed to bring other government agencies onto the property, including members of Humboldt County Code Enforcement Office. This will be for the purpose of examining the residents for violations of building codes, as there have been numerous violations visible during previous search warrants. So the court has authorized the code enforcement or other government
officials to inspect. Whether that means it's part of the objective of the warrant and therefore usable I think is really unclear. I also think that because there is an inspection warrant process and a statute that requires notice or an attempt to get consent and then pleading to the court that you were unable to or that it would be fruitless to try, that a search warrant or an inspection warrant for the purposes of looking at these codes contemplates a level of notice that a criminal search warrant doesn't. So for those reasons we appreciate the fact that this appeals board is in kind of a weird position being asked to make findings on evidence that I think is cloudy at best. In a criminal proceeding they would say you know fruit of the poisonous tree is poisonous. If the search warrant is bad so is the evidence.
That doesn't really apply to an administrative proceeding like this. I think technically you wouldn't be violating anybody's specific rights to move forward. However, we appreciate that that is probably not ideal or what you would want to do. To further kind of complicate this, the only thing that's really before the board right now is whether or not these violations exist and whether they threaten life, limb, or well-being of the occupants. And so to continue this out or to not make that finding is a safety matter that you kind of have to balance against these evidentiary issues. What we...
think is the best is to go get an inspection warrant and do it over again and i guess whether to continue this matter or just drop it all together would be maybe what do you want to do john just drop it i would say it would be dropped because it would be beginning a new process all over again and if that were appealed that would come back under a separate deal so what i'm hearing is it'd be best if we don't take any action or are you asking us to take action to drop it i think we would be withdrawing the county be withdrawing its order okay so at this time what i'm hearing staff is the staff is withdrawing its order okay okay okay okay okay okay okay okay okay okay okay okay okay okay okay okay okay okay okay okay okay any clarifying questions any clarifying questions any clarifying questions um yeah um yeah um yeah
In terms of the process, should there be another appeal, I would put or propose that images that are offered during a presentation be provided to the board in paper form rather than posted publicly both on TVs and on Zoom because we're entering a person's home. So I would like to suggest that that change in process be made. That would – never mind, I'm not going to – I will try to respect that a little bit, but part of the struggle that in asking the Board of Appeals in this case to make a decision, it's important for you to understand and to see and for everybody who's watching to understand what you're struggling with. Okay. And what the violations are.
And unfortunately, it is in somebody's home. We're not insensitive to that. The only thing I wanted to add to that is I hear you, but I don't want us to be taking away someone's right to participate electronically or via Zoom unless we had an order to make it only in person. And then they're technically allowed that evidence as well. So one wrinkle. Well, it doesn't necessarily solve that issue, but while the Plenum Commission is governed by the Brown Act, the Appeals Board really isn't. And so while it's still a public proceeding, it doesn't necessarily need to be broadcast or the records produced here don't necessarily need to be disclosed outside of the proceeding. So maybe there's just some work about. Procedure of the Appeals Board.
as kind of an adjudicatory body that we can ponder between now and when an issue comes back up. Okay. I'm actually somewhat relieved to not have to make what would be a really difficult decision tonight and a pretty impactful decision for the folks that are living in the house. That said, I hope that they take note that there's some pretty serious deficiencies in that home. The electrical system and I think the building official was generous in saying that there's just a cover off of the panel and there's some things and some exposed wiring. You know, there's wiring tapped into a 50 amp.
Breaker that I can see there that shouldn't be there. There's some foundation issues on that house, and you have some cracking around some of those column supports, and you have some plumbing issues. So hopefully these things can be resolved and repaired, and it doesn't end up back here. So that would be a great outcome, I think, for everybody. So sometimes maybe technicality can turn into a little bit of a windfall and an opportunity. So I hope that's the outcome here. Any other comments? This is an awkward question, but the appeal, did the appeal cost the appellant money to file? Yes. Yes, it did.
Thank you. How does the county withdrawing the appeal impact that? I understand where you're going with that. We'll look into that. I really wasn't expecting this. We've never encountered a situation where we go out on criminal warrants frequently and have never run into this. Thank you. I have something to say and I agree with Ivor. I'm glad we didn't have to make a decision that based on the evidence that was presented to us you need to take it very seriously and the fact that you come from a construction background and have knowledge of proper construction techniques you have to know that what we saw in those pictures was not okay and so take it very seriously.
I don't want to see you back here. I don't want to see anybody homeless, but you know it sounds like you've had some health issues and other issues that you've been challenged with, and I understand and I respect you for working on those issues, but take it seriously, and we don't want to see you back here again. Okay. Any other discussion? So staff has withdrawn the original notice, so thank you for deliberating, and I appreciate you getting the evidence and everything that was presented and taking the sidebars and making sure that we get the answer that we need to move forward properly and not violate anyone's, potentially violate anyone's rights. I like to use that word potentially instead of violate. And so at this time, I will adjourn the Building Appeals Board, and we get to put our commission hats back on and reconvene as planning commission.
And the report from Planner. Chair, if there was something I wanted to talk about, it's not in my head anymore. Okay. I totally, there was a lot of things that kind of came at you sideways a little bit ago, so totally understand it. That's my question? Commissioner West. Commissioner again. You briefly mentioned potentially not having a meeting in January. The January 16th meeting, yes. Okay. And we wouldn't have our first meeting of the month either, correct? Correct. Second is after the New Year's holiday. Right, so that is correct. So yes, no meeting in January. If I may, is it okay to bring up about your, well, I sort of feel like everybody else should sort of be on notice in case there's not.
Sorry, I just, you know, we have a sort of awkward process, it seems, around at-large commissioners being reappointed. And as I understand it, Commissioner West's term ends on January 31st of 2025. And then the practice is for the board at that time to list the opening and keep it open for 30 days, I believe, to see who might apply. Which I don't really understand why it has to be done that way. And it means that we lose one commissioner for that month, possibly a little bit more than a month. And then they have their meeting to... Decide it. And in this case, I just want to note that we actually elected her as...
Vice Chair. So we just have to sort of be aware that that's coming in February, that we would have a gap when I guess she will not be with us. So. Commissioner Levy, thank you for that reminder. I had committed to looking into that. I forgot about it last year. I mean, since this came up last time, I was like, we should try to tweak the timing. So maybe that's not happening that way or something. Yes. I've not gotten a clear answer on why it's done like that. I thought it was originally done on case law and then that was rolled back. So I'm not sure if it's just one of those things that we've always done it that way or what it is. Yeah. Okay. Well, thanks. We actually have Ivor. Thomas and Noah expiring Jan 30.
first 2025 as well okay but they get reappointed by their respective if we do revises I mean that that's instantaneous assuming they do reappoint us there's no there's no delay so but never know anything under report else planning Commission discussion items anyone have anything well I I was going to announce that hey I won't see you in January because my son's basketball schedule came out and I would be missing some meetings because I do want to see his sporting events but I guess it'll be a coin flip when that first February comes up and I'll kind of look at his schedule where he's at and had a conversation with them he did tell me this morning that I could probably miss one of his games there'll be
With that, I'm going to adjourn us with my last meeting as chair at 7.50. Okay. Thank you, Thomas. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you. Thank you.