I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Ivor Scavdahl here. Commissioner Levy. Commissioner Mulder here. Commissioner O'Neill here. Commissioner West here. Commissioner Curiazzi here. Commissioner McFarlane here. Okay, Director Ford, do we have any agenda modifications this evening? We have no changes to the agenda. There is a...
A supplemental that's been given to you, or two supplementals tonight, one for the workshop on the lighting ordinance, the other is related to item F1. Okay, thank you. At this time, we'll take public comment on non-agenda items, so on anything that's not on the agenda tonight but falls under the jurisdiction of the Planning Commission, the public's welcome to comment. And if you are on the phone to address the commission, please press star 9 to raise your hand. And then when we call on you, you'll press... Press star 6 to unmute. So check first in the room. If anybody would like to address the commission this evening. I see none.
line so we have a couple of folks listening in but no hands raised at this time so I will close public comment on non agenda items and we'll move on to item e the consent agenda we have several items on the consent agenda this evening two of them are related to our action summaries the balance of the items are going to be continued to make sure we provide adequate public notice so what I'm gonna do first is take up the two action summaries I'm going to take those together so we have action summary from February 8th and one from February 20th and Commissioner would anybody like to pull those for discussion seeing none I'll check with the
public in the room and online. I don't see any hands, so those will remain on consent. I'm going to read off the next several consent items. I'll just read the title, ask the commissioners to hold, and I'll check with you after I've read them off since they're all a continuance items. I'm not going to pull on each one. Item three is MMF land conditional use permit. That's going to be continued to a date uncertain. Item four is Cooee parcel map subdivision, Humboldt Hills area, also continued to a date uncertain. Item five, California trout cannibal island restoration project conditional use permit, continued to a date uncertain.
Item 6, Farming Humboldt Dream Special Permit in the Corbell area will be continued to a date uncertain. And Item 7, Adopt a Vehicle Miles Travel Policy for Unincorporated Humboldt County will be continued to our April 17th meeting. Commissioners, would you like to pull any of those to discuss the continuances? Seeing none, check with the audience in the room. I see a hand raised online. Caller 7108, please press star 6 to unmute if you'd like to comment. Yes, I just had a question about Item 6. Is it a permit for the adjunct?
Is this address on Alder Point Road or is it somewhere in Corbell? The item is addressed as in Corbell area, is that correct? That is not correct. It is in the Alder Point area. It is in the Alder Point area. So we will make sure that that's correct when this does come back. Stand corrected and we'll make sure that gets noted properly. Does that address your question? Yeah, is there any idea when it's going to come back? Those are being noticed for the next hearing, which would be April 3rd. Okay, I don't know if you heard that. Yes, I did. Thank you very much. April 3rd. Thank you. Thank you for catching that for us. Thanks. Thank you. Thank you.
That comment, I don't believe we're pulling that item, so can I have a motion for consent calendar approval? I'll move. I'd also like a quick discussion after second. I'll second. I have a motion and a second. Commissioner Chiarazzi? I have a quick question to staff through the chair. Sure. Yes, please. Regarding the item 7, the VMT threshold analysis, I heard comment at the last public workshop for the EIR, for the Regional Climate Action Plan, regarding questions about providing the VMT analysis. I was curious if staff could, or I would just put out there, if staff could consider aligning the condiment period of the EIR. The RCAP EIR with the hearing of the VMT threshold document.
Yep. Commissioner Ford? Yeah. Director Ford. I understand what you're asking is to align the review period of the V&T threshold with EIR and bring them forward at the same time? Yeah, or at least staff recognize that public comment and that the V&T threshold, I think, is being brought as it's proposed now after the end date of the EIR comment period. I don't have a specific recommendation, but I just wanted to acknowledge that. Actually, you'll be right about the end date. April 5th is the end date. That's a Saturday, so it's actually April 7th for the RCAP EIR. We do consider these. While V&T is a component of the RCAP EIR, we do consider these as part of the EIR. Okay. So the last question? The last question was about the RCAP. The county threshold is really a different issue. If you would like us to bring them forward, we'll take the question.
At the same time or later we can. What we're really trying to do is establish a good methodology for screening of VMT and then develop a good methodology so people know what an analysis looks like for compliance with VMT and then also if there's a significant, potentially significant impact to identify what the mitigation would be. So we're really trying to put together a complete document. Through the chair. Yeah, thank you for that explanation and I definitely appreciate that. I just want to clarify that you see these as pretty separate enough projects that it's okay to bring them. We do. Yeah, the RCAP applies to all the jurisdictions within the county. It does address VMT. But it addresses. This is VMT from the perspective of.
of greenhouse gas reduction and so it has a slightly different nuance to it. The VMT thresholds that we're trying to establish really implement a study that was originally done without getting into too much detail here because I'm walking a fine line, is that for various reasons they had to be separated. Thank you. We have a motion and a second to approve consent. Any other discussion on the motion? We'll just have a voice vote. All those in favor signify by aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes. We'll move to old business. Item one, Humboldt Sanctuary Farm. We'll have a motion.
We have a brief staff presentation. Thank you, Chair Scavadole. Members of the Commission, good evening. I'm Stephen Santos, Senior Planner, presenting the Humboldt Sanctuary Farms Conditional Use Permit. The project is located in the Salmon Creek area and takes access off of Thomas Road. The project parcel is approximately 57 acres. It has a residential agriculture general plan designation and a U unclassified zoning. The conditional use permit is for 28,500 square feet of existing outdoor commercial cannabis cultivation with a separate 1,900 square foot ancillary nursery. On the other hand, on-site processing is proposed and energy comes from solar.
and generators. The conditions of approval for the project do include the standard condition to transition to renewable energy by January 1st, 2026, reserving generators for emergency use only. Estimated annual water usage is 300,000 gallons per year, which comes out to about 10.5 gallons per square foot per year. The water source is rainwater catchment from a pond that is estimated to be about 600,000 gallons. There's also an additional 9,900 gallons in tanks as part of the irrigation system. This project also includes some on-site relocation, restoration, and consolidation. The relocation and consolidation has already been completed and the vast majority of the restoration work has also been completed with exception of removal of some minor legacy infrastructure such as the water supply. The project is also a project that is currently under development. The project is a project that is currently under development.
Thank you. This is a slide of the site plan. The nursery is there on the kind of the northwest right by the farm entrance. And then there's two cultivation areas. There's the kind of the polygon that looks like a bird's beak down there at the bottom. That's cultivation area two. And that's all full sun. And then off to the east, that's cultivation area three. That is a combination of full sun and six greenhouses. We did receive two public comments. The public comment that we received regarding the permit involved noise, payment of taxes, power source, property line setbacks, archaeological review, and site suitability. The project is conditioned to conform to noise. The project is conditioned to conform to noise performance standards. And I just noticed a typo.
Oh there, noise not nose, I apologize for that. The project is current on taxes. With regard to power sources, I've already mentioned there is the standard condition to transition to renewable energy. I further analyzed the setbacks and the property lines, and I'm convinced that the greenhouses in Cultivation Area 3 that was on the east side do meet the appropriate setbacks to the property lines. And regarding tribal cultural resources, the project was referred to tribes, and the conditions of approval do have the standard inadvertent discovery protocol that was requested by Bear River. The second public comment that was received yesterday was determined not to have relevance to the land use permit itself, and staff has no further comment other than that the findings can be made for approval. Therefore, staff is recommending... I'm not sure if that's the right word. I'm not sure if that's the right word. I'm not sure if that's the right word.
The mitigated negative declaration adopted for the CMMLUO and the addendum that was prepared for this project, that the commission make all the required findings for approval and adopt the resolution approving the Humboldt Sanctuary Farms Conditional Use Permit subject to the recommended conditions of approval. And that concludes my presentation. I'm available for questions. Thank you. Commissioners, do we have any questions of staff as related to the staff report? Just a quick clarifying question. I apologize my iPad didn't charge to pull it up, but I wrote a note here. CO8A9 for riparian buffer. There was something about the state water board still needs to do a site visit, and there may be cultivation area changes or something like that. I just wanted to clarify that that was possibly could happen this season, so wanted to make sure it was on record if that is correct. The county coordinated. We did with the state water board and
Received some correspondence from them indicating that they it was a low priority for them to conduct a site visit and take measurements and that they were willing to accept the recommended 50 foot buffer that was part of the application's submittal. However they reserved the right to perform that analysis at some time and so that's why we left the condition in. So if that analysis ever occurs and it's determined a different buffer is needed then that condition is in place but upon approval the the applicant would not need to move any of the cultivation and would and would be able to cultivate in in all of cultivation area number two. Thank you for clarifying that. Okay we'll take public comment on the project. Applicant
If you'd like to address the commission, you're welcome to do so. I think he has a representative here. You have up to 10 minutes. Yes, I'm not going to say much. My name is Suzanne. I'm with Marco Advisors. I have been hired to help this individual, Mr. Cooper, through this process. And at this time, as usual, I let the planning department make their recommendations, and I'm available for questions. But I think the project speaks for itself. Thank you. I don't see any hands raised. Any other member of the public wish to address this matter or speak? Seeing none, I'm going to close the public hearing and bring it back to the commissioners.
Thank you. Is there any discussion? Commissioner West? I just wanted to quickly acknowledge that I did read all of the public comment that's associated with this. And the areas that we do have latitude, I appreciate staff making conditions of approval that met those concerns. And I just wanted to recognize that I hear the neighbors' concerns, but that is just not our jurisdiction otherwise. So I just wanted to recognize that their comment was heard. Thank you. Call for a motion. being as we regulate land use and not people i will make a motion to approve resident
resolution 25-012 and finds the Planning Commission has considered the mitigated negative declaration previously adopted for the commercial medical marijuana land use ordinance and the addendum that was prepared for the Humboldt sanctuary LLC project and finds that the proposed project complies with the general plan and zoning ordinance and approves the Humboldt sanctuary LLC conditional use permit subject to the recommended conditions of approval I'll second that have a motion and a second any discussion on the motion roll call vote please Commissioner scab dog yes Commissioner Mulder yes Commissioner O'Neill yes Commissioner West yes Commissioner Curiazzi yes yes yes yes yes Commissioner McFarland yes motion carries thank you thank you
That concludes old business. We're going to now move to item G1, which is a workshop. This is the first workshop on our Inland Lighting Ordinance. I want to let everyone know this is a workshop. We will not be taking action on this item this evening. We will be listening to a staff report. We will take public comment, and we will have a discussion amongst ourselves and with staff in order to seek kind of more clarification and provide direction to staff on this ordinance. And then it will come back to us in the future for a public hearing and eventually go to the Board of Supervisors. So with that.
Yes. Just a clarifying question to staff. The public comment in regards to this has been uploaded to so if anyone's following along, they can. Perfect. Thank you. There's only a couple people. Okay. Staff, whenever you're ready. Director Ford and staff, you have the floor. Give us a sec to get set up here. While they're getting ready, I should acknowledge something that has happened. Mr. Yandel has been promoted from senior planner to planning manager. He is now the manager of the long-range planning division. So just want to acknowledge that he's done incredible work and has earned this new position. And I just want to thank him. And so he's here.
Thank you. Thank you. See how I do with this. Can we? Let's get this going here. Director Ford, can I ask you a question before we get started? Yes. So the last time we had a workshop, some of us had Googled things and brought up what the decibels relate to. And afterwards, we had a legal counsel that told us we shouldn't be doing that. So I just wanted to clarify, for non-hearing items, is that still the case or is that only applicable to hearing items? It's primarily related to hearing items. But one of the things that becomes a danger is that if you're basing your comments on something that you Googled and have come to that conclusion, that could have you thinking something different for different reasons than what the rest of the commission has access to. And so I would just.
Caution that, even in a workshop. It maybe would be helpful if you have Googled things to identify the source, let everybody know what that is and to share that so that everybody has access to that and can look at that. Thank you.
good evening commissioners my name is Rianne Meagan and I will be presenting the draft inland ordinance on outdoor lighting If you'd yet go to that, it includes play mode before you hit share screen, so I'm going to share that one slide.
Thank you. Thank you. and I will my name is Rhian and I will be presenting on the outdoor lighting draft ordinance the intent of this ordinance is to maintain safety establish design standards for outdoor lighting protect and preserve our nighttime dark skies by establishing those reasonable design standards minimizing glare light trespass and light pollution we also aim to address community
complaints regarding nuisance lighting. As directed by the general plan, we aim to implement light and design guidelines and address the standard of light and glare that is found in the scenic resources of the open space element. By addressing light pollution, we aim to, sorry about that, light pollution means any artificial light emitted into the atmosphere, either directly or indirectly, which may have a disruptive effect on natural cycles and inhibits the observation of our stars and planets. This does have an effect on circadian rhythm and of all, or majority of organisms. Including humans. And this graphic shows how the sky is affected by light pollution.
Thank you. This is an example of how shielding can affect the light emitted from a fixture and also affect the nighttime sky. We are aiming to address light pollution by going fully shielded, which would be under this better of the graphic, or best would be fully shielded with a timer or a motion sensor so it's only lit up when it is needed to. Warm lighting. The concept of warm lighting refers to color temperature. The temperature max is 3,000 kelvins or less to be considered warm, and this produces less blue light than other higher temperatures of lighting fixtures. This is considered a good balance for outdoor lighting as it produces a warm yellowish light that is less likely to contribute to light pollution due to light. Less blue light.
Thank you. Foot candles were chosen as a measurement for this ordinance because you can buy a light meter that measures foot candles and it focuses on how the light is distributed on a specific surface. With the ordinance, the lights being fully shielded and directed downwards, lumens wouldn't matter as much as how that light is being distributed potentially onto neighboring properties. These are just some examples of what could be acceptable and what cannot be acceptable under the proposed lighting ordinance. There are some graphics that show... Fully shielded, which is what we are aiming for under acceptable and it shows how the different lights... That would be an example of probably a warmer...
Not sure exactly what the Kelvin measurement would be for that example. Ideally, 3,000 Kelvins or less. But it has that warm yellow glow rather than that bright white light, which is on the unacceptable side. Prohibited lighting. These are just some proposed lighting systems that could be prohibited. They are consistent with other ordinances found in California that we looked at while preparing this. Exempt lighting. Temporary holiday directions, decorations. We recognize that people may want to illuminate their flags, statues, objects of interest. So we are proposing to allow a very narrow beam of light to be directed on that object of interest and have that contained. We are proposing to change low-intensity string lights.
to be called a warm light string lights so you still don't get that bright white glow around it because they will be exposed bulbs and i do have a picture in a following slide of what i am discussing with in terms of those string lights other proposed exempt lighting is going to be a lighting installed and maintained by the county temporary construction lighting athletic field lighting and emergency lighting motion detector lighting fixtures will also be exempted we recognize how many people have motion detector lighting and see it as a necessity for security and safety and these fixtures are all exempted lighting is exempt provided there's no light trespass onto neighboring properties if someone is still found to be creating light trespass onto neighboring property and we receive a complaint you they may have to change that lighting
This picture provides an example of the warm glow or the warm light patio string lights. It's not as bright as it could be if it was just, we didn't hit that requirement of warm lighting. But there are string lights that do have that bright white light that may become more of a nuisance to neighbors. We do recognize that this is a popular trend of outdoor lighting now. So we wanted to recognize the trend. It does provide some ambiance, but also try to limit light pollution with exposed bulbs. And we did receive a public comment that string lights should not be exempted. So that's why we did change it to say warm light rather than low intensity. Another public comment. We're going to go to the next slide. So we're going to go to the next slide. So we're going to go to the next slide.
We received was just a question of low intensity. In this draft ordinance, low intensity was not defined, and we did change part of the code to say a max color temperature of 3,000 Kelvin or less to be consistent with that. And the figure on the left shows lighting facts. This should be on at least a good majority of lighting packages when you are looking at lighting fixtures or purchasing them, and it does show you what the Kelvin is. So this is something that should be accessible to the public. They don't have to guess what the temperature is. It should be on the label saying warm, cool, and ideal temperature. Other public comments we received were no lighting shall permeate or cause spillover onto neighboring properties. Or into airspace areas.
is and while it is noted throughout the ordinance we did add not to create light trespass to make it very clear that outdoor lighting fixtures shall not create light trespass and when it comes to airspace by requiring lighting fixtures to be fully shielded and directed downward we are addressing the concern of light being emitted into this airspace ideally there should be very limited to none if it is correctly shielded and directed downward other public comments we received were kind of in regard to design standards of residential and maybe some commercials areas however we chose to keep the residential requirements very simple we just want to limit light pollution by having fully shielded
It fixtures and not creating a whole bunch of complex design standards that someone would maybe have trouble understanding by doing roof overhangs, things of that nature. But that is open to discussion with the commission. One other public comment was not allowing exterior light to permeate beyond a horizontal distance of 20 feet. Once again, we aim to keep the regulations simple and straightforward with a common goal of preserving our nighttime sky and maintaining safety. But this is something that we could discuss in regards to design standards. The final comments were addressing existing lighting nuances, such as industrial yards causing light pollution and light trespass into residential areas.
And then common of neighbors' lights shining into each other's houses. And that would conclude my presentation on the draft inland lighting ordinance. Thank you. Do we want to take public comment now or do we want the commissioners to have questions of staff? Want to take questions? Yes. Thank you. So clarifying question. And they're under exempt as temporary construction. Definition of that, if someone is providing resources for a construction project that has to work at certain hours, does that fall under the same definition of temporary construction lights? Like where's the standard? Because I know there's a lot of times that due to, I don't see it so much here, but my experience in the Bay Area, there was a lot of projects that.
We had to run in the middle of the night and there was resource places and trucking outfits that had to have lighting for safety standards for their employees, you know, in their yard. So I just want to try to figure out where that's at, the definition. I'll tackle that. So there's two different kinds of things I think that you're bringing up there. One is an emergency, or not an emergency, but temporary, where they're out on a construction site working and that's illuminated. And yeah, under the exemption, we would consider that to be exempt because it is of temporary nature. If the commission's not comfortable with that and wants to put performance criteria around that, understand that we could need to do that. The other one that comes to mind as you raise that question is when maybe a yard is required to provide materials 24 hours a day. 24 hours a day.
Do they get to light up the yard while they're at work? And that's something that really we would think would need to be, we need to create a provision for that, I think. A separate provision that should have some kind of permit associated with it so that there's public notice. Can I ask a follow up there? I hear you. I'm just trying to think of like an emergency type situation, roadway slid out or some type of construction. I want to make sure we're covering that. And then also I want to make sure that we're also factoring in OSHA standards when we're talking about lighting in workspaces. Unfortunately, I do have a 40-hour OSHA class card in my wallet that I had to take. And I really enjoyed that class. Appreciate that. We will give some thought to that.
Because we hear what you're saying, and those are important. Commissioner O'Neill. This is kind of odd, but I know veterans that have PTSD, and they want their house illuminated, and I'm not going to question why. But if someone did have a medical situation, could they get a change or an exception? So thank you for asking that question. We're not trying to preclude people from lighting their property. We're trying to preclude people from lighting up other people's property. So if there's somebody that, using the example that you gave, has PTSD and they really want the area around the outside of their house to be illuminated, there should be a way for them to get there, provided that the light isn't glistening. There should be laryngons. Thank you.
Their neighbors windows and lighting up their yards. I have a variety of questions and comments kind of similar to what we just went through with the emergency one and I was wondering if what the best format because this could quite I don't want to you know monopolize the conversation but would it be better to do public comment and then go through like we did in previous workshops line by line and discuss it in that format so that your plan on going through the audience okay Okay, well then let's open for public comment. If anybody would like to comment on the ordinance as proposed right now, and remember, you'll have another bite of the apple as well, but if you want to help us try to...
Give staff direction. Please come on up. Introduce yourself and you'll have three minutes. Good evening. My name is Mark Wilson, and I'm here to represent the astronomers of Humboldt. If anybody knows the night skies and prefers the dark skies, it's our group. I am the vice president of our organization, and this is Russell Owsley. He's one of our board members. I live in McKinleyville, and he lives in Cotton. So I'd like to introduce our organization real briefly. We've been around since 1957, so we've had a long time to look at the night skies and how they've changed here in Humboldt County, some places for the better, some cases for the worst. And that's why we're all here tonight.
We're a 501c3 educational organization. We do a lot of outreach, educational outreach in Humboldt County. We work with schools, various youth groups. I was just down in Miranda at a 4-H thing a couple of weeks ago. We work with civic groups. We do public viewings. We work with, right now, the Redwood State Parks in southern Humboldt. Been doing quite a bit of things down there in the summer. We work with museums and nature interpretive centers around the county. And we also have a library telescope program here with the Humboldt County Libraries, where the public can go check out a telescope just like they can check out a book. So we have a lot of interest in the night skies. And, first of all, I'd like to compliment the staff for their very, very thorough work in putting this organization. So let's get this Ordinance together.
We're the member of a lot of different organizations, one of which is the International Dark Sky Association, which they have referred to in this ordinance, and they have very, very good guidelines on how to preserve the night sky, yet make our spaces at night well-lit and safe. With that in mind, one of the things that was brought up in their presentation and in the draft ordinance is a, referred to as intensity or the color of light, and it was recommended to use 3,000 Kelvin as the maximum limit. However, in the paper that passed around, I don't know if everybody's got it yet or not, this was just this month. This was just this month. This was just this month. This was just this month. This was just this month. This was just this month. This was just this month. This was just this month. Published in the Reflector, which is the newsletter.
of the Astronomical League, of which our organization is a member. And this was published by Dr. Mario Mata. And if you look at the paper, you can see that Dr. Mata is an accomplished amateur astronomer. You can look at his photos. Excuse me just a second. I think we're interested in what the gentleman has to say. We don't have a lot of speakers here tonight. Oh, I see the thing. That's okay. Well, I was just going to say, Dr. Mata is... Go ahead and continue, but probably should wrap up soon. Yeah, I just got it real quick. Dr. Mata is, as I said, an accomplished amateur astronomer and an accomplished physician who does research in the effects of light on human health with regard to the question about PTSD. If you read this, he'll have an extensive background in this.
and it's published papers and he has several references at the bottom. But one of the things he recommends is rather than the 3,000 cutoff limit, he recommends a 2,700 cutoff limit. And we would like to propose that as well as a change to, I think it's in the ordinance, 105.1.5.1 to reduce that light intensity down a little bit. So with that, I'll close and just say that we'll be around after you adjourn if you have any specific questions about our particular interest in keeping the skies dark in Humboldt County. Thank you very much. Thank you. Hi. Out of fairness, I'll give you five minutes. I don't need five minutes. I'm sure other people are going to get to some of the things that I wanted to bring up.
There will be other opportunities in the future. I think the one thing that I wanted to make sure to highlight is what seems like maybe some conflicting purposes of the ordinance, especially with some of the comments that were made, as well as some of the language that's in here. So under residential, let's see if I can find it. Under fully shielded for residential use, let's see. It says light fixtures that use translucent material to cover the light source may be acceptable for light bulbs of low intensity. It seems like that sort of defeats the purpose of it being fully shielded. I mean, if it's letting light through, then it's not shielded, right? So that seems like maybe it's an issue to think about. And then also everything in here that talks about intensity. It seems like light intensity is more about...
power output about how bright the light is as opposed to color temperature which is just the color of the light so you can have a 10 000 lumen red light and that's going to be offensively bright but you can have you know a little dinky one lumen blue light that's not going to be much of an issue um so that's something you should probably think about and also i guess the last thing i want to say is that um a lot of the light pollution that we are going to have i think needs to be understood as a cumulative effect so it's not just about what's on one person's property it's about all the different properties everywhere that are having light that is spilling out into the sky so it needs to be understood as more like air pollution or water pollution that is all kind of shared and not just
Thank you. Hello, my name is Sylvia Van Ryan. I work for Humboldt Waterkeeper as a GIS and policy analyst and I am now also our in-house light pollution expert. There is a few technical things going on in this ordinance that I think require a little more attention. For example, in section 10.1, sorry this is so long, 105.1.6.1, maximum illumination subsection 1, maximum illumination is regulated in foot candles in this ordinance. However, lumens, candelas, or watts would be easier for permittees to comply with when planning new lighting installations because light bulbs are labeled with the expected luminous intensity rather than illumination. Illuminance, or you could call it illumination, is better than
It's used to measure light trespass onto areas not intended to be lit. These light definitions are super confusing, and I know because I've spent the last two weeks trying to wrap my head around them. So just as a really quick overview, luminous intensity is how bright a lamp is or how bright a luminaire is. And then illuminance is the amount of light that's actually falling on a surface. So imagine if you're a permittee and you have to use illuminance. Now you have to go and get these light bulbs and measure how much light they actually put on the ground. Which also depends on how far they are from the ground. So I think that luminous intensity would be easier to use. And my colleague isn't here with the papers. I was going to hand you guys out when she comes out. I'll have her hand them out to you. But there's kind of a tricky way to convert between lumens and watts. And it depends on the type of light bulb. And I have a source for that if you guys are interested in hearing that later. And then also Dark Sky International, as someone mentioned earlier, is like the top nonprofit.
doing light pollution work and they actually have a municipal code template that's very well put together and they went through several rounds of revisions with lawyers and lighting engineers to develop all of the regulations in there so i highly recommend that planners work with that template to pull the relevant lumen amounts and etc because they have a lot of the same concerns that other commenters have had and cover that in those the templates and that's all i got for you thank you thank you who would have thought we were going to become lighting experts i'm looking to see if anybody online would like to speak and if so please press star nine to raise your hand If not, I will close public comment and bring back.
The Commission and I know some of you have lots of questions so I think Laura you've been waiting patiently. Could I offer? Yes. Could we put the ordinance? Yeah let's do that thank you. We're gonna share that. Okay. We made it. Go ahead and launch the...
So I'm new to going through this process. I'm used to just delivering staff reports. So would you like us to read these line by line? So basically what we can do is just go through and we'll give you an overview of what they try to say without just reading it line by line. Could you go ahead and just make that a little bit bigger by moving the bar down at the bottom? There you go. And then we'll just go through each of the sections. In this case it'd be 105.1.1. It's the purpose. And if anybody wants to talk about anything that's in that we can go ahead and discuss or receive comments on that. Not seeing any.
Thank you. No. Okay. Then let's go to the general regulations. My only question for this section that's come up so far is you refer to wildlife habitat. And I'm just curious how we're defining wildlife habitat. That's a pretty – it's very much open to interpretation depending on who you are. Thank you. We will work on a definition for that. Mine is a similar definition comment. So the 105.1211, when it talks about illumination for safety needs, I just feel like that's a potentially very open-ended term. And so I don't know how we qualify that, but that would be helpful. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay.
Two more lines down. Could I just respond to that a little bit? So you're right. In some cases, the individual statements on their own aren't adequate. But one of the things we felt necessary to work in here is that we're not trying to preclude people from having sufficient lighting to be safe. There's other statements in here that refer to the maximum amount of lighting necessary to achieve that purpose. So really those are kind of intended to work together, not just one statement captures everything. But there's a maximum amend there that occur, unfortunately, in different sections. I don't know if that helps. Do you think that still needs more work? I think we'll accept that and work on that. But I just wanted to point out that not.
One single section in here is really intended to carry the whole freight of the regulations. Yeah, that's helpful. I think it was more not necessarily like in this line that it needs to be defined, but a general thought to carry throughout is someone is kind of where that line is drawn when you read the other sections as well. Well, that's why if it's a path, it's going to be one thing. Yeah. If it's a parking lot, it's going to be something else. And that's what we'll we accept the comment. We'll work on it. And that dovetails perfectly into my next comment about two lines down. It talks about the meeting the needs of the area to be illuminated. And I just wasn't sure if, you know, there's, like, how is that established? Is it just based on what the applicant says? Is there some sort of.
criteria to review what is actually needed versus what is proposed just not necessarily looking for an answer right now on it now but something to consider Thank you. Somewhat similar comments on 1.2.2.2.1. So this is the directed downward and not toward, and it says other structures, and I found that that, I think, I'm assuming the intent was other off-property structures. So something along those lines. Thank you.
Thank you. Excuse me. Go ahead. Just wanted to piggyback on the other structures part, that same one. I just want to understand. If you have a light on your house and you have a structure, and are we saying we can't have a light that's directed towards your own structure on your property? Because that's how one could read that and that's how I read it. I just want to make sure we're looking at that from both sides of it. That's how it reads and we'll correct that. Okay. Because the intent is to make sure light stays on your property, or the subject property and not trespasses over is how I read the very beginning of the intent. Okay. That's a good catch. Thank you. Also, on these general regulations, when I was
Looking at lighting for residential use and lighting for commercial use, it didn't specifically reference back to these general regulations which apply to all lighting. And some people might read this like I did, which is, oh, lighting for residential use just has to be this. And we were, for example, when you were showing the pictures of the string lights, I was thinking to myself, you know, those should only be illuminated when those sites are occupied, which is in this general regulation. So if we could make sure that the residential and commercial also refers back to shall comply with all the general regulations and whatever is specific to those, I think would be helpful. Thank you.
Thank you. So some of this we went through in the presentation earlier in terms of prohibited lighting. And I just, not being a lighting person, just had a why next to mercury vapor and low pressure sodium fixtures. Or is there something about those? Because I suspect historically there are a lot of those lights around the county. And are they, what's the issue particularly? Just for education? Yes. So for mercury vapor lights, they are noted for having high energy consumption and also the potential of mercury contamination. Also, they emit UVCC, which can cause eye and skin issues. And City of Eureka and their lighting ordinance, they also prohibit mercury vapor lights. And then with low pressure sodium lamps.
It emits a monochromatic yellow light which inhibits color vision of the night. And both of these are more intended towards street lighting. And this ordinance isn't regulating street lighting. You know, county maintained street lights. This would be more for personal use or commercial, industrial. So these shouldn't, these forms of lights aren't really on the market anymore anyways. Some areas they may even be banned for sale. It's possible California may have a ban. I did not look into that. But it was consistent with other prohibited lighting through different jurisdictions. So would we be reaching back and asking people to retrofit? No. The only time that that may come up, and we'll get to this in a little bit, is when it's shining into somebody's house so bright that they can do finger puppets against their wall. As an example. That's not the only.
time yeah excuse me yes please do so don't want this to be taken the wrong way but i just want to make sure that i heard this correctly we are regulating property owners a certain standard but county maintained facilities aren't held to that standard did i hear that correctly we are proposing to exempt county facilities in this yes okay to be clear not new county facilities um i i would think that if there was a new county building that they would comply with this or i think if you were to look up under the exemptions that county facilities are exempted just like caltrans facilities would be exempted um i know we're not on the exempt lighting section but being as that came up um um maybe we could discuss that now
If we could stay on prohibited lighting until we're done with that section, I would appreciate that. I take it you have a question on prohibited lighting? I do. Comment? On the, where a special event is mentioned, I have a similar sort of definition question on how that is defined. I'm just curious if a special event could potentially be interpreted as a year-long special event that happens every year. I think the intent would be more, you know, related to a concert or an annual event or something of that nature. If you'd like to elaborate on that. Yeah, I think Mr. Yandel is right.
It really has to do with something that could be a recurring event. I think that part of the thing that we want to work into this, thanks for asking this question, really is part of the event permit that's issued that they need to address what the lighting will be and how the lighting will be utilized and screened. Thank you. Is that in on, I think, go ahead. But if you're in the business of doing special events like weddings or whatever, would that be different? Because it's a reoccurring, but they are special events. Right. So there are companies that go around and do weddings. But then there are places that are approved as event venues.
And they have certain things going on. They have restrictions on them. Currently some of those restrictions have to do with lighting. And so it just, in my mind, we're trying to carve out, not create a restriction here that would be so restrictive that somebody couldn't put up some lights for an event that happened infrequently. But say if that was an event venue that had special events 52 times a year, we may look at that a little differently. And so I think that's where it does require a little bit more consideration in terms of how we look at lighting associated with special events. What I was just getting at is I'm not saying they shouldn't be regulated. I'm saying they should be, but it should be defined in a way that you can kind of differentiate between the two and say, yes, we can put all these extra requirements in your permit. And they can't go back and forth. But here it says.
Special events. I feel like we're saying the same thing. I hear you. Yes. Yeah, I think following up, I agree. I think we're all saying the same thing. Maybe staff could consider adding a qualifier like infrequent special event or something along those lines. But I'm not, I don't feel like it's, I'm not pushing hard for that either. I'm just struggling a little bit. I'm reading it as we're speaking here. And may allow for any lighting systems that are prohibited. Sounds kind of broad. I think special events are just going to use the aerial lasers or search style lights or something. But so maybe just striking that word any way.
It would help me. It seems kind of broad. We'll work on that. They're going to come with a lighting plan in their conditional use permit, I would think, that would seek approval. So. Yeah. Okay. So now we're moving down into exempt lighting. So I just figured we'll go through them in order. So my first, and I'll stop after each one. First one with holiday decorations, I think that we need a definition of a holiday.
holiday because depending on every, I mean, you think the obvious Christmas and Thanksgiving, but depending on what you subscribe to spiritually, you could very well take that to mean anything. And I also feel like a lot of holiday decorations would trigger the ordinance. If you put up a flashing strobe light or something, and then you're now using this holiday exemption. And I also feel like with the holiday exemption, there should be a carve out for a nuisance issue. So I think a little bit of work on the definition there would be helpful. Can you help us think through how that would be defined? Oh, because I, we totally hear what you're saying, but you know, I, I hate to say it, but maybe it's part of my, the prejudice of my background in terms of, you know, the season between Thanksgiving and new year, where you see a lot of decorations.
up extending now even into late october but um you know and we all read that differently based upon our experience so are we limiting it to certain holidays are we i i'm not sure that i have a complete answer because i am a christmas light fanatic myself so i i totally understand um i guess my thought process was if if you can use a holiday exemption to exempt something like search lasers or you know some kind of novel display in your yard and you are celebrating a solstice or i mean i feel like but i also don't want to be um prejudiced to only allow that during a christmas season so my point is that if there's a way to carve the exemption to be a limited exemption to be a limited exemption to be a limited exemption to be a limited exemption to be a limited exemption to be a limited exemption to be a limited exemption to be a limited type of lighting
that doesn't include spotlights. Right, so it generally conforms with the ordinance and we're not seeing some concert level lighting for someone's holiday event. I think that's covered in the first sentence though. Provided there's no light trespass onto neighboring properties so it's going to be complaint driven but if somebody does something that's so offensive that it's glaring into your bedroom or... But straight up, your airspace isn't necessarily a neighbor's property. You might see some illumination but you're not going to see the source of the light necessarily if you're illuminating the sky. Okay, I think that's a... somewhat of a rare event.
Well, we see it with billboards all the time, with lighted billboards, that you see the halo glow from miles away. Okay. I have something to say on that one. Yes. I think it's fine, because I think if we get too, you know, drill down too much, it might be a problem. And just leaving it at that, and you say maybe reasonable or, you know, and then leave it up on a case-by-case basis, because, I don't know, someone might go, wait a minute, I'm going to challenge this and do this or that, and you can't stop me. So I just feel like it's okay the way it is, because it doesn't drill down too much, and it leaves a little bit of discretion. But I don't know how you would put that into wording, but I think it's fine. Because everybody has different holidays, and someone's going to challenge you if you...
Committed to Christmas or Thanksgiving or more like I think Halloween is a time when some people light up things. But if you keep it in your own property and leave it simple and then you can deal with it if someone complains. But if you try to narrow it down too much, then they will complain. They will challenge you. Commissioner West. I shared similar concerns when first the first pass as Commissioner McFarland. And for me, I found a lot of reassurance in the definition of light trespass just because it is so specific about viewing of the night sky and glare. And really that sentence when it refers to light trespass, like it can't light trespass onto a neighboring property. It's pretty specific about. The definition is pretty specific about preventing glare all the way around. So that's where.
For me, I don't mind how it's written. Commissioner Mulder. I would agree with Commissioner West there on the definitions. And then also the other thing, just the temporary holiday decorations. I'd be really cautious to try to define different holidays because there's so many different beliefs and religions out there and different people's philosophies. So if we tried to dive too deep in there, I feel that we could be possibly discriminating or leaving someone out, and then I don't want to open up the county for libel or anything like that is my fear. Yeah, I don't think my intention was ever to prescribe what holidays it's appropriate to decorate for. I do appreciate the comment from West on the light trespass. Maybe my concern is just a potential loophole for a nuisance to be created. So maybe it's a thought exercise, that county staff undertaken.
Maybe it doesn't need to be changed, but maybe with further discussion, just some sort of expansion on avoiding of creating a nuisance situation beyond trespass might be helpful, but definitely something to workshop and I'm not suggesting hard language now. Yes. Go ahead. Thanks. Yeah, staying on the holiday decorations, I was similar with Commissioner West. And I was initially thinking maybe adding a qualifier like low intensity, but I agree. I think it's okay as it is. I did want to, in terms of the sentence above regarding exempt lighting, so 1.4, where we have no light trespass onto neighboring properties, I wanted to suggest.
adding to that the public right-of-way so no light trespass onto neighboring properties and public right-of-way so for example these exempt lighting being projected out onto the street around the sidewalk yes would the same if if we use the language light shall not leave the subject property or something like that would that get the same definition so that way it would just cover I don't know I just was trying to think get back to the the purpose definition I think we could shorten the sentence so there's no light trespass and then work on the definition of light trespass which does say is already defined and limits it to anything beyond the property line or property boundaries so which would include the public right-of-way or others so
And I think could also include some provisions under the definition of light trespass that would help protect the night sky. You're concerned about things shining up. So if we work on that definition. Yeah, I think as long as the definition focuses not just on like beam lighting, but also that broader illumination that we see with billboards, then that would work for me. Thank you. Okay. Okay. That was just holiday decorations. So my next comment isn't until about the county and public facility exemptions. I'll pause in case anyone has one before that. Okay, so I'm definitely going to question this. I'm not, I would like to understand.
And the thought process as to why the county, other public agencies, recognizing that I do work for one, or public utilities, should be exempt from a county-created ordinance. I feel like if the ordinance is crafted in a way that the public can comply, then the county should also comply. We offered this as something for you to talk about, and if it's the will of the commission to remove that, we're fine with that. I will just say I do not look forward to issuing a notice of violation to my bosses. We'll issue it. My hope is that you would never get to the NOV stage, because you could work collaboratively before reaching that stage. So my suggestion here would be to not allow a carve-out. I think that public agencies, whether they're... Emergency response teams, et cetera, can follow the ordinance under the emergency provisions, and so...
That would be my suggestion. Is that a consensus? A compromise could be that all new construction moving forward. It's really hard to hear you. Isn't that covered by non-performing lighting in 105.1.8? All the county facilities are already built. Yeah, I've kind of closed public comment, but thank you. But right now we're working up here, so thank you. So I'll just kind of affirm that this absolutely would apply to new construction. And the existing facilities, unless they were posing in the same way that they were in the past, I don't think they would be able to do that. I think that would be a nuisance to somebody.
would not be subject to any kind of correction. So I'm hearing that 105.1.4.4 is going to be removed. It could be that it applies so that you don't have to fine the county. It could be that it would be incorporated into the new construction design standards or something to that effect so that they would install the appropriate lighting and not that you would have to fine them. I don't know if the county gets a permit for their own construction, do they? Yes. Also just to add, Commissioner O'Neill, if someone was to complain to the county about a facility, the county wouldn't immediately issue an NOV to themselves. They could just work through the issue before getting to the NOV stage, which has the fine. So the county could definitely avoid that. I'm sorry for being facetious.
earlier but that is correct we normally initiate enforcement action with a conversation and and then increasingly become more serious I think the county and other public agencies are all going to strive to comply with lighting requirements and that are pretty common today so I think we could strike this I'm in support of striking it and honestly I for you look less forward to you trying to inform other agencies that you don't have jurisdiction over that they're in not in compliance but um to Commissioner with Farland's point I do think that everybody should have to comply Just throwing my hat in there. In agreement, I do want to
I would like to encourage public agencies to lead by example. I think that this ordinance is worth leading by example on. And secondly, to staff, just confirming that safety, OSHA, other sort of regulations there, of course, provide a way for public agencies to provide the lighting they need to meet those regulations. So my next comment on the temporary construction lighting, I just want a clarification from staff. Is this temporary construction as permitted or is this somebody decides they're going to do some sort of construction on their house and, you know, that doesn't require a permit and now they've got it lit up? I think this more has to do with a large project that would be permitted. And.
due to the nature of the project needs to be completed in a shorter period of time. So maybe just some language to clarify that, because the hypothetical concern is that if a neighbor decides to take on a massive landscaping project that isn't enough to require a permit, and now they've lit up their yard to some excessive amount. But if you just added temporary construction lighting as consistent with permit or something like that. I hate to be out of your session. All right. Thank you. Go for it. I apologize to be argumentative here, but as someone that, when early 20s, bought a place, worked 60 hours a week, and then I would work. I'd get home from work, and I would work until 10 o'clock at night doing a landscaping project, increasing property values in the community I had the house in. So I would really, really not want to discourage that kind of behavior if that's what you're saying. If someone is...
Trying to do that, but also I'm mindful that there are neighborhoods and there's things when someone decides at 2 o'clock in the morning to replace the siding or windows on their property, and it may turn into like a two-month project to replace a window. So that balance in there. I just want to be mindful of both sides. I have something. Back to sort of the county, but maybe not. What about security? Like if there's a high need for security maybe around police stations or even nighttime bus stops, I know from reviewing cameras after there's been incidences, you don't get to see much if you don't have illumination. I mean, the video is worthless. So if there are areas of high public safety concern, and I'm not going to define. Yet what they are, I think that.
county could could they have additional lighting that would make security cameras pick up more of the incident if someone was standing by a bus stop or out in front of a police station or some other area where there's a high public concern absolutely with the caveat that they're not illuminating the night sky okay and there's not light trespass going on to surrounding properties i mean that's that's where we really wanted to be clear we absolutely are not trying to curtail lighting that would imperil public safety i just don't get that feeling though reading this as we're going along i don't get that feeling that we're sending that message but it may be just me i'm sorry we didn't get that across but that was one of the things on ryan's second slide she put in large print safety because we wanted to reinforce that
basic message that we do not want to imperil safety. We just don't want to have light going where it shouldn't be. So getting back to the construction situation. So I've got a question about that. So probably for me, I would look at that and think of a job that is mostly a commercial job where there's a limited time for period to, uh, finish it. I won't name any certain interchange where people are working or anything like that. But, um, commissioner Mulder brought up, you know, working around the house. So there may be times and needs where construction lighting is necessary. Maybe an exemption for temporary construction lighting shouldn't be.
exempt or it shouldn't have an exemption maybe there should be performance standards for temporary construction lighting so that there there's guidelines of what you can and can't do i think that seems like a fair compromise so if it's not otherwise permitted like a large scale construction project um so bringing up molner's example i think that would be a good compromise do you have suggestions as to what those parameters should be or this performance criteria um honestly i don't know i mean there's people that work at the mill that you know get off at three o'clock in the morning should they not be should they be entitled to be able to get home at four o'clock in the morning and work on their yard and you know put in that couple hours of work afterwards or but i i don't know i haven't thought it i haven't deep build like that just
I have experienced this neighbor and for me it's I think that there's it's much like noise where there's a reasonable hour that you can make noise at 10 o'clock it's the edge it's fine two o'clock in the morning at that point you're disturbing almost everybody and that doesn't feel I as much as I would love to support you like bettering your property at some point it's too disruptive to the neighborhood to be appropriate what if it was some sort of qualifier that's like within reasonable or non-nuance hours or something like that because I don't think because we're not saying that they shouldn't be allowed to work on their property like they could absolutely light it up to do what they need to do but if they're making excessive noise or lighting it up to a point that's um unreasonable that's all we're trying to get at
Thank you. I feel like these ordinances just can't address every what if situation. Okay? Um, if somebody's working late at night and their light is, it doesn't matter if it's temporary construction light or not. If it escapes the property, it's in violation of the ordinance. So I, I, I just don't think we can write an ordinance that's going to cover every, every scenario. That's, that's, we want to give the County staff enough of a guideline to be able to respond to complaints. And I think if a neighbor complained, um, under that circumstance that you're describing this ordinance as it's written, would give the County enough to say, Hey, you know, you work at night. Just don't let your light go across the fence line. But that comment would be.
Consistent with Director Ford's comment of just striking that exemption, because then it's already taken care of with the light trespass. Everything's taken care of with the light trespass. That's the big hammer. This could be a three-sentence ordinance. He's already told me like three times, if it stays on your property, you're okay. So I think that is more. That's a good point, how you bring it back to definitions. When we're trying to split hairs, and then if you go back to the definitions, I think that's a really good point. It does take care of that construction, residential, all that. Yeah. I think there's a lot that's appealing about that. I think we do have, or staff is proposing language that allows unshielded, such as string lights. So probably is worth addressing items such as those. If they were to go. Thank you.
to something as simple as what's being proposed. But in general, I'm intrigued by that proposal. Yes. I think when thinking about really, if we're thinking about really changing how this ordinance is addressed, it gets at my question of the public commenter who brought up the dark sky compliance template. And I was curious whether or not staff had a chance to look at that and how they thought that that might work with what has been proposed. Yes, we did review that draft ordinance provided by Dark Sky International. It was very technical, provided lots of lumens, watts, things of that nature. And we decided to suggest something that would be more standard. And straightforward for the general public to understand.
It was even heavy for me to read, and I'm the one researching this. So that's why we ultimately did not initially go with the Dark Sky International template. It was just very heavy on if you had a background on lighting, you'd be able to comprehend it. But the general public would probably have to do some of their own research to understand general provisions that we would be suggesting. What about all these exemptions? Were they in there? I'm not sure off of the Dark Sky International template, but our exemptions are consistent with many other jurisdictions in their lighting ordinances. Local jurisdictions or statewide? Combination. I can't remember what Eureka had, Arcata had, versus...
Like we looked at Butte County, Monterey County, things of that nature, and we compared those ordinances to see how Humboldt would fix and see how that would fit with our county and what would be consistent. But like low intensity string lights were exempted in at least a couple ordinances that have been adopted by different jurisdictions. There's nothing that we just decided to exempt that wasn't from other jurisdictions. Go ahead. The exempt exceptions listed are very similar to the city of Eureka's exceptions to your question. I wanted to bring up just the analogy of noise. I wonder if there's some use in looking at current noise ordinances. To see if there's something, there's some idea.
is there that could address some of the points brought up as well? Relative to addressing noise? No, in terms of like these scenarios around temporary construction and I guess maybe mainly around that discussion of temporary construction. We are working on a noise ordinance as well. Can hardly wait. And that is something that is a struggle, frankly, because it's like part of noise is the quality of quiet hours. And so how do you regulate that? Yeah. So through the chair to staff, and I don't want this question to be taken the wrong way, but we're looking at light ordinance and noise ordinance that will be...
Most particularly during the night hours, I would presume. As far as I know, we're in budget deficits. So I'm just curious, is staff getting additional staff, or is the building department getting additional staff to work during the night to address these, or is this next morning so then we don't have staff to potentially verify the complaint? Okay. So presumably a lot of this will be addressed as part of new construction. So if we can get the design and the fixtures correct, then that's done. And so that doesn't require a lot of enforcement. The place where we may have enforcement or existing nuisances, we haven't got to that section yet. But unfortunately, yep, that will require staff to work during the night hours. So we have to be able to go out and visit places after.
Okay. But it sounds like the more important intent is to, moving forward, construct things in a way that doesn't get light trespassed and doesn't affect the neighbors. Correct. So, okay. Thank you for that. Okay, are we through exempt lighting? No. Unfortunately, no. I apologize. No, I just want to bring us back to that and get through this section. Thank you. I just wanted to address that during the presentation, staff had suggested on the low-intensity string lights to replace low-intensity with warm and to address a public comment. And I guess I was going to say that I think I'm fine with that. I think the string lights are generally low-intensity. I think that's the intent of that term. And I think defining as warm. Makes sense. Thanks.
with that intent. I actually noticed that and I scratched out low intensity and put in a warm light and we'll look into the 2700 kelvin as well. I just to throw my two cents in um mulled over this one a little bit because I think that's generally true except for um cafe string lights vary quite a bit in their intensity um but I do think that getting back to um that beautiful first line that if it does get too bright then the then getting back to it being light trespass will solve that problem. Okay, I have one last one, sorry. The athletic field lighting used within a school campus, I was under the impression that schools were regulated by the state, so we wouldn't have jurisdiction here anyway. And so on that note, I would suggest just strike.
that full exemption because I don't know why a private park would be exempted. And I do, you know, we had the conversation about amending the light trespass definition to get the, you know, the airspace above, and I think that would help. But on the same note, I would just suggest striking that exemption. We have private schools like St. Bernard's. They're not state regulated. Or they might be in some capacity, but they're not state schools. So why can't they comply with? Because when you have a football game in the evening, they have bright lights for safety purposes. So special event? For football games, they do. I don't know what else they play at night, but I know. Baseball, tennis, track. So do they get special event permits for those or no? No. For a private school, it would be part of the use permit. Typically. Oh, yeah.
Unless it's principally permitted use within the zone. So then it's already covered by the permit. It could be. I think it's, yeah. I mean, we could strike it, but I think that the thing that we put it in there primarily because sometimes people object to lighting of athletic fields. And so it's easier to have it in the ordinance that, yeah, we're not going to touch that than to have it questionable about whether or not we're going to enforce against it. What if it just says when in use? If the intent is to allow football games in baseball, which is great, but we just. Don't want the areas to maintain lit for unreasonable. So you, you live in McKinleyville. One of the things McKinleyville hide.
So they turn on the lights so people can walk at night there. Yeah, so that would be considered when in use. Because the walking, I see what you mean. And so it's a thought exercise. That's my suggestion. But staff recommendation is paramount. I say leave it alone. Because you don't know how long ago they permitted St. Bernard's. It could be, you go back and look at a permit, and it might not necessarily be in there. And I think that schools should have the right to light up their fields for people that walk in the evening or jog or have a game or whatever. I don't think we should be that restrictive. I'd rather tell the county that their lights are out of compliance than deal with the high school. But what about the private park? That could be in relation to softball league, or women's softball league. Something like that. Where they do need...
Have the lights on to do league play. That's where that kind of comes from. Okay. I mean, there's like redwood fields. Most of that lighting is trying not to trespass over. I mean, I've designed some of those ball field lighting systems, and they're external facing in. Generally, it's hard to control the glow, but they do make enough to try to control it from escaping off the property, like onto neighbor properties. But you're not going to control the glow. I don't think they're going to leave it on anymore, and they have to. They have to pay a PG&E bill. So I just don't think we need to. I don't think we need to go there. Just leave it as is. Okay.
I agree with Commissioner O'Neill. Okay, we're going to move on to lighting for residential use. Commissioner West. Generally, this is the first time we see foot candles used as a part of the discussion. So I just wanted to, I thank you, by the way, for defining it in the presentation, because I feel like it's, my number one question was going to be, how does the layperson know how to measure that when they feel like something is too bright? And you did provide a great example that you can get a light meter. But I would be curious for you guys to explore more.
and commonly used metrics for brightness. And is this also, I think we heard from a public commenter about luminous intensity of lights and just trying to understand where that related to this. One of the things we did, and maybe, Rand, help me if I didn't remember this correctly, but we only used a foot candle measurement relative to commercial uses. That's correct. Because it is common for commercial designers to develop a lighting plan and identify the foot candles like within the parking lot. That's pretty standard. It is under residential use also. 105.1%. 10.6.1 maximum illumination.
That's commercial. Oh, I missed that. I'm sorry. Thank you. So we were intentional about not using foot candles in relationships and residential uses for the reason that you just identified, is that that's a little bit too esoteric for somebody putting lights on their home. Am I reading it correctly then that we also don't talk about a maximum illumination for residential use? Yes. That really is the light trespass. And again, I think that the change there that was made based upon a comment that was made earlier is, you know, the translucent material with the color temperature of the light.
2700 Kelvin. It says 3000 right now, but it's up on the screen. Sorry. Thank you for clarifying that. Commissioner Kirozzi. Yeah, I appreciate the discussion around not being too technical. I do agree that's very important. To the comment we heard around what is appropriately measured, at least my understanding and research that I did, that I think foot candles is an appropriate measure because it's measuring the amount of light that is perceived, essentially, that's falling on a surface area. And I think that's ultimately... from a neighbor's perspective, that's really what they're going to care about. So I think foot candles really does capture what a neighbor is going to care about.
Whereas if you get into wattage ratings on bulbs, then it gets a lot more complicated to get back to that thing that a neighbor is going to care about. But I did have some concern around excluding a maximum illumination for residential because I was curious how staff would address complaints. And I was wondering if I was thinking that something that would be objective, such as what's under the commercial use, would be useful. And there are tools very readily available to measure foot candles. And in fact, I believe you can even download an app on a phone to measure foot candles. So I think it might be useful to consider maximum illumination to address complaints. Thank you. So in the normal residential
context you're not going to have a large grouping of lights like illuminating a parking lot illuminating a car dealership illuminating an area where people gather that's why commercial is treated a little bit different than residential in residential it really does come down to a simple idea of you know get lights that are shielded get lights that are warm and and place them so that there's no light trespass that's the simple logic of the residential component if you want us to require foot candles we can but that adds a burden to our residents to try to demonstrate that
I guess can you clarify that the it makes it easier for staff to respond to a complaint if there is not a numerical value so in the context of a residence it's really easy to go and see is the light screened is there light trespass you know is it a warm light those are all very objective and the foot candle measurement is objective but it requires technology and so then you're putting a resident perhaps in the position of having to demonstrate that they comply with that rather than just looking at the light and determining is it shielded is it warm that makes sense I think I just I think it is possible to get a fixture that meets all of those
requirements and is a very high wattage rating and so the resulting foot candles at the property line could still be significant particularly if there's reflection off of the structure it's illuminating say it's coming off of the house that it's illuminating so yeah and again i think we that we start to go down scenarios like identifying particularly scenarios particular scenarios i just wanted to to bring up if that would make it easier for staff to respond to complaints and it sounds like i'm hearing director ford say that it creates an additional burden meaning that staff could not respond to the complaint until that person brings no we i'm sorry i didn't mean to to say that we couldn't do it we can absolutely do it it just adds an additional degree of
complexity to something where I would present for consideration that they're regulating the fixture regulating the glare ready regulating light trespass or the things that we care about and if those fundamentally grasp what we're concerned about in a residential setting do we need to add an additional criteria that that's what I'm trying to say and if you want to add it that's fine we can do it I'm not arguing that it can't be done I'm just questioning getting back to our premise keeping it as simple as possible for people does that add a degree of complexity that is necessary Yeah, and I'm comfortable with the no light trespass. So I think you could walk onto the neighbor's yard, hold up a white piece of paper and say, light trespass.
Or not, so. Okay. I'm trying to see if we need to take a break or if we're okay to keep going here. We've been going an hour and 45 minutes. I do have one quick comment. Let's try to get through this section then. Okay. On the residential, I just felt like the fully shielded section, that fully shielded needed to be a complete sentence. I just found it odd that 1.5.1 just said fully shielded. Okay. I'm okay to keep going or take a break either way well we're through residential and partly through
I don't know if we want to tackle, I'll pull the commission, you want to take a break? I'm good. Hour on. I do have an hour commute. Okay. Hour and five. I think for me, if we have a couple pages left, if we think we're going to be diving into it in a lot of detail, I'm up for a break. But if we think that there's less questions on this half than the first half, then. There'll be questions. Let's take a five-minute break. We'll be right back.
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Okay. We're through residential.
So did we get through lighting for commercial use? I think we have a couple more comments and thoughts here. We also received a new comment, I believe. Okay. I think this person spoke. I believe they spoke about it, and this was the handout I think they were talking about. Someone was going to bring it. Oh, she said. Yes. It addresses the same items. Thank you. So we have the handout. Thank you. You feel free to do that if you'd like to. Thank you. Okay. Okay. Are we on commercial now? We are. Commissioner Curiasi, I'll start with you.
Yeah, thank you. I have three comments. One, I think just was already addressed by the public regarding the use of Kelvin with respect to the word intensity. And I think staff caught one of those items, but it's also in parking lots. Kelvin is temperature, intensity is different. On hours of operation, it says significantly dimmed. And I was curious, since we're already using specific definitions with foot candles, that maybe perhaps we could use those same definitions of max illumination at the property boundary for hours of operation. Maybe significantly dimmed. Maybe the fact that it's already there in commercial is okay and we can leave significantly dimmed.
as it is, but I wanted to bring that up. And so I have one more comment after that, but I'll stop there. Could I just ask a clarifying question on that? Which would be, is significantly dimmed too vague? That's what I was thinking. I just didn't know what significantly dimmed would mean. Let's just work this way. So Commissioner McFarland. On that one, I would just maybe staff could look at, we previously saw we passed a permit for a billboard that had this similar issue and had to be dimmed at night because of neighbor's complaint. So if we can mirror something like that that we had previously agreed to and was voted on, I think that would also help me with the significantly dimmed portion. And then the second section, and again, not necessarily need an answer tonight, but just a thought.
exercise on what essential for security or safety means, like how are staff going to evaluate that when someone puts in an application for development? Is that, you know, based on just what they're saying they need? Is there some sort of criteria? So just something to think about. Commissioner Mulder. First off, there's a piece of paper, part of the floor or the roof just dropped off from somewhere up there and went down there. It caught my eye out there. I thought someone was throwing something. But on a serious note, back to the essential for security or safety security, the way I've talked to many business owners and with the downturn economy, the money they spend to illuminate everything, to deter theft, outweighs the theft that they incur if they don't illuminate their storage yards and all those kind of things. And. And so I would want us to be very, very cautious.
This when one theft of thousands of dollars could be detrimental and put them out of business. I just want to make sure that staff is factoring that in. And then also when we're setting these policies, we're factoring that in. Thanks. I could just respond. Our basic thought on that was kind of like the difference between something where there is stock in an open area versus a parking lot. And so you don't maybe need to keep the parking lot lighting on while people are going in and out of the building for a commercial center. But then. You do want to see areas. You want to let law enforcement see areas where there is stock on hand so that you can see if there's somebody in there. And we do get that. The comment was made earlier. You can't envision every single.
incidents of how things will be. But that was our basic maybe to fundamental thinking. Low illuminated areas lead to potential graffiti and things like that. I know there's a business in Southern Humboldt that doesn't have illumination at night. And it's been graffitied on multiple occasions. So that's just factors that the property owner might want to, you know, just have an illumination stops people from using that parking lot to possibly do illegal activities, exchanges. And then does that make the county a co-conspirator if we regulate that lighting? Also, if you have security cameras, it doesn't help if you don't have lighting because you can't you can go back and look at those tapes and you can't see anything without lighting. I think within reason. And so if the.
light is too bright you're going to create more shadows and the videos are harder to review so i think i think there is a within reason there's a happy medium that can be met and i i think the intent is just to not create a nuisance to the rest of the society but definitely respecting the property owner the business owners you know need for security we're back on to the as long as you're on the property and i've viewed a lot of cameras and in the evening and theft and things going on in parking lots and you need lights so we went back and forth on this and thought that we would put it in because we knew there would be a discussion am i hearing that the preference is just to omit that section which section the hours of operation i i think that based on the previous permit we did about the billboard i think that we came to an agreement with the billboard and we're going to do that in the next few days and i think that was a reasonable solution there with the hours that the billboard for the church needed to be
operated so i think if we can come to something like that then i would be fine with leaving the hours of operation in so i appreciate what you're saying that a freestanding sign for the church is a single incident that we can completely put a box around this is trying to address innumerable potential situations and maybe since commissioner o'neill just threw my words back at me it's a matter of it not going off site not like no light trespass no glare and do we want to regulate the hours of operation of lighting as long as it meets those other criteria can you so i think the when we say no glare to clarify it's not a matter of whether or not it meets those other criteria it's not a matter of whether or not it meets those other criteria no glare means glare from the light source itself it doesn't that term doesn't address
reflection off of surfaces on the property. So it's... If it reflects off the property, I think it does affect it, yes. I think that would be useful to clarify, because I think glare, in terms of lighting engineering, has a specific term, and I thought it referred specifically to the light source itself. So if the intent is to, which I personally tend to lean towards, also addressing light coming off of the property onto neighboring properties due to reflection, then I guess I start going back to foot candles again, although I also agree that, at least, especially in the residential side, you can hold up a piece of paper and say, kind of get close enough. Thank you. Thank you.
I think you can strike the hours of operation. I think it's confusing, going to be hard to enforce. It's not adding anything to this. I would agree. The no light trespass, as you mentioned earlier, covers, and Commissioner O'Neill re-mentioned again. I think if we focus back to that, probably could shrink it down to like four pages. Some things sound better when you're talking about them in a private room than they do in a public hearing. I will note that a lot of modern security cameras are motion detected. The light turns on with the camera. You can actually even talk to the trespasser. Through the chair, I'd like to say something. Yes. I used to work with... I used to work with security cameras years and years and years ago. And there's cameras...
out there that have infrared arrays built in the camera and you could have complete black darkness and at night it looks like it's daytime out there literally yeah they do make those yeah so if if we were to keep the hours of operation they could choose to install cameras that have that function and it would look like daytime i just wanted to go to say that thank you for new but you're not going back and making everybody retrofit or exempt because those things are expensive and i think i guess i took um that comment more of that property owners have options yes there are other options other than just solely um relying on on visible light christopher west um thinking about new construction versus um
Existing issues when it comes to commercial lighting. We had several public comments that were complaining about instances already in the community. Are there tools that we can build into this to help? There's a section down below that we haven't gotten to yet. It needs some work. I'm going to warn you up front. It needs some work. We recognize that. But we do want to strategically be able to address those. Maybe just trying to move through the commercial. The last thing there is the parking lot lights. That's more of an encouragement than an absolute. My question was exactly that. Why are the motion sensors only encouraged and not mandated? What was the thought process there for consistency with the rest? I think that we are trying to build in.
It's something that we think is a good idea, but was aren't weren't sure that it should be a mandatory requirement And So it is functionally there for the Planning Commission to talk about I Was and this this doesn't relate to my Generally having comments regarding parking and parking lots. It's just simply Why are parking? Why is this specifically called out for parking lots as a number of the items there? For example the lower temperature I my understanding already applies and then motion sensor lighting Would we not be interested in Encouraging property owners to use that one appropriate anyway, so I guess I'm curious what staff's thoughts were on calling out parking lots specifically parking lot lights typically do not have
motioned sensors and so it really is starting to talk about keep in mind the other requirement above for parking lots does have the regulations of foot candles adjacent to the residential areas adjacent to right-of-ways this is getting into saying that even though you can probably do that by screening or shielding the lights and directing the lights and doing all that that doesn't necessarily address the type of bulb that you're using and if this is where when that picture was in the presentation that showed high light trespass all the way over to very clear dark sky standard which is because the lamp was off because it was motion sensors and
And so there is a spectrum here, sorry for the pun, that exists in terms of the amount of light. And the best way to control light is to not have light when you don't need it. That's an ideal. Whether people are ready, whether developers are ready, whether commercial centers are ready, whether retailers are ready to not be able to have lights on around their building or not, is probably a very different question. And I think one of the things I've heard in the discussion today is that it's important to really make sure there's sufficient lighting to discourage vandalism, crime, theft. Yeah, I think, thank you. I think just that makes sense, but I personally feel like the argument you just gave and the fact that you're saying that there's a light in the light, I think that's a very different question.
fact that it's not specifically binding it's more of an encouragement could reasonably apply in general rather than specifically parking lots that was kind of my thought if it's just an encouragement not a mandate can it be parking lots walkways loading facility you know not as just sort of any surrounding outdoor area if it's only an encouragement yes Is that a consensus? What is it? Can you repeat it? The suggestion was for the parking lot section, because it's only an encouragement to use motion sensing light, it's not a mandate, would be to expand that to walkways, loading docks, any outdoor space around a commercial building since it's only an encouragement. As well as the bulb temperature, both of those are on that. .
Okay with that, as long as it's only an encouragement. I have some concern about safety in those spaces. And, you know, walking down a long pathway or walking across a large parking lot and having the light only illuminate when you get to the sensor, there could be somebody or something there that's a threat to you that's not illuminated until you actually trigger the light to turn on. So I wouldn't want to be mandating that or taking responsibility for that. I think it would be up to the commercial property owner to make those types of decisions. I agree. I was thinking the same thing. Like every time I go to the ATM at night, I think someone could be hiding there waiting for me, and I'm not going to know it until I get there if the light doesn't come on. Also, was it the general manager?
I've been in a casino for a number of years, so I'm pretty familiar with what goes on at night in parking lots. And there's a lot of stuff. And having deterrence is people thinking they can get away with it if the lights don't come on. They do a lot of things out there. Yeah, and I think that's why the suggestion wasn't necessarily to change the word encouraged to mandate. It was to leave it as encouraged, and it was just to expand the area. And then the property owner, so it would be site-specific, could choose the sensitivity that they turn the motion detection on? I just think saying it's encouraged, it's kind of they're already going to do it or they're not going to do it. I don't see where it really matters if you put encouraged in there because this is for permitting purposes, so it's sort of an unnecessary word. Well, yeah, there's two options. You could strike it all together, or you could...
work in some kind of incentive whereby they could have a higher amount of light that could apply to an area if it's motioned. That makes more sense because this is a regulatory thing, so everyone should be encouraged to do what they should do, but they're only going to do what they have to do or want to do unless it's something like what you just said. I'm not sure most of the sensing lighting makes sense in a parking lot. I'll just say that. Also, imagine you're driving in and driving out, so you're ding, ding, ding, ding, ding, ding, ding, you know. Lights on and off, it just doesn't seem like it makes that much sense to me. I'm fine chalking this up to an idealistic attempt to accomplish something and just removing it. Okay.
I'm not really too for the motion sensing lights and then when it comes to expanding that idea to walkways, pathways, and all those kind of things I'm concerned about safety. Do those lights illuminate quick enough to provide safe path of travel especially when it comes to ADA compliance and those type of things so I'm just I'm really really concerned about trying to do a good thing but potentially making a safety hazard and the parking lot lay-and-wait thing is something else like really really concerning for me. So it Jero could I suggest a consensus to just either play with it more or delete it? I have a quick suggestion is as it sounds like the motion sensing seems to be the higher concern with their I also do like the color temperature piece of it. I think it's a good idea to have a motion sensor that's a little bit more of that as well. Would there be interest in retaining the color temperature because that does have dark
I have no issue with that. Agreed. It's just the motion sentence I would strike. I think we have consensus there. Is that fair? Yeah. And that applies to more than parking lots, just the color. Yes. I think we're okay with that. I would say if you're going to expand that to walkways, that you need to make sure that we educate that we're meeting enough lighting and illumination. Yeah, absolutely. Absolutely. I think the color temperature is different from intensity, which maybe in here staff used color temperature and intensity together, and they're completely different. You have a majority. I'm a coin flip. I wouldn't say yes or no. For me, the issue is just the motion sensor piece.
So I'm in support. Okay. Are we good to move to conformance review? Yes. Okay. So what we just tried to do here is just identify that these for new construction are going to be reviewed as part of a building permit process. And I tried to give particularly for to address both residential and commercial, what they're going to need to give us so that we can efficiently complete that review. Obviously, we want to know where the lights are going to be. We want to know the site plan. We want to know the type of fixtures and what they're producing, the type of bulb, the type of shielding. And how they. Disperse light and a normal cut sheet for a light fixture shows that. And then.
How the lighting plan fits within a potential landscape plan because one of the things that often conflict is the landscaping and the lighting. And you noticed that there was a public comment to only allow the lighting to go 20 feet beyond the fixture. In a parking lot, that's really difficult then to provide adequate coverage because a normal parking space is about 18 feet long. So if you put it right in the curb, so you cover the parking lot or you cover the parking spaces, but you don't cover the parking aisle. So that's pretty simple. That's just the technical review part. If there's something more we should be looking at. I just had a quick comment about the second one, the cut sheet fixture. Did you want to specifically call out? Temperature?
on there or no we can i just thought that would be helpful Do you think I'll sign that? No. Okay, then we get down to non-conforming lighting. And what non-conforming lighting does is this is a situation where there's an existing fixture. And this existing fixture shines into somebody's house. And, you know, I think we need to work on this a little bit. But there's a question here for the commissions. First, should we be tackling non-conforming lighting as a nuisance? And obviously we are presenting that it should be.
But then we need to tie a good boundary around what the director of planning and building is going to take on in terms of addressing a violation. Because is it any complaint that I get tired of my neighbor and I don't like the light fixture they've got on the side of their house so I'm going to lodge a complaint? Or is it something that, you know, when I walk out in my yard, their motion detection light comes on and suddenly my whole backyard has daylight. Or it's shining into the house. And I know that's more of a suburban kind of problem. When you're on a 40-acre parcel, you probably don't have to worry about that. And when we're on a 40-acre parcel, we probably don't have to worry about that. And when we're on a 40-acre parcel, we probably don't have to worry about that. Is that the way it works? If you've got a problem with the DB you don't have to be curious there or anything else. I'm saying it has to be proprietary in quality, really. Yeah, just start with nothing built specifically designed for you. You need to know your park as a whole. You need to be theproof. Well, it says may, so that means it may not, right?
It's not an absolute if I make a complaint about you that you're going to go along with it. Correct. You have been a director. You understand what it is when you get complaints and you need to make decisions. And you understand that there's a whole range of things that can be complained about. But what kind of complaints for an existing light should we really be saying, hey, you're a nuisance. That light's a nuisance. Well, it says the director may require, so you may not, too, if you decide not to, right? Yep. It's not absolute that if someone comes in and complains that you're going to be on their butt telling them they have to change everything. I agree. They could change the light bulb and they would be okay. I mean. Or lower the intensity or, you know, there's a lot of things they could do.
It wouldn't require them to retrofit their light fixtures. So first, go ahead, please. So here, I'm just a little concerned if it's a structure that we permitted and allowed someone to do something to, then changing the rules after we've already allowed them to. I'm concerned we may be overstepping someone's rights, but I could be wrong, and I'm open-minded to want to see where I'm wrong, potentially. And then the other part with the language I'm uncomfortable with is it says if there's a complaint, it doesn't define a process in which that complaint would be verified or amount of attempts or something like that. Because...
I trust you and I trust that you're going to be here. But the way it does read is if somebody filed a complaint against their neighbor, technically that wouldn't have to be verified by the way it's written, the way I read it. So I just want to make sure we're cautious in the way that we write this that something would have to be verified in some sort of – some way to measure that. So that way it's consistent. Agreed. So I also want to comment on that because I'm reading this maybe a bit differently. I'm seeing – the way I read this, 8.1 and 8.2, the subsections, only apply to any lighting fixtures installed after the enactment of this section. That's the stuff. Thank you.
Anything prior, the first sentence says, anything prior to this is legal non-conforming. You're right, it does. Okay. So, I'm saying, yeah, anything prior is legal non-conforming. Any after, should you get a complaint, first you would have to determine, well, is that lighting fixture after it's come in? You're right. Right? And then you could act on it. So, the question is, to me, is, do the legal non-conforming have to comply with light trespass requirement? The way this is written, no. Correct. But that's not what we were intending to do. That's what I'm asking you, right? So, you know. Okay. And it.
I think stating that last sentence isn't necessary, right? The whole point of the ordinance is to apply to anything installed after, so you don't need to restate it. And then it's just confusing to state it under a non-conforming section. Well, I'm not sure if that's the whole—that's what I'm trying to understand. What is the intent here? The intent here is that if there is something that was installed before this ordinance was adopted and that is a nuisance, that's why I think we need to spend some time defining what a nuisance is. Because even just a little bit of light trespass, I don't really want to go be telling somebody that they have to change their lights. Correct. It has to be something that just is—like, that's obscene. Yep. So we got an email, and they gave us an example of a situation. I think that's a great example. It would be before this is passed. Then we say, I'm sorry. We can't even touch this because this—
was before we passed the ordinance or is it considered a nuisance and you can do something about it i'm confused and thank you for bringing that up commissioner o'neill that that is precisely the struggle that that i think we wanted to confront here and in that struggle i think that's a good one to start to wrap our heads around is you know that's an example of what should probably be considered a nuisance that does need to be addressed yes it is non-conforming but that is a nuisance that's impinging upon somebody else's property the enjoyment of their property i mean if i can't go to bed at night because a neighbor has such a bright light that it's uh shines into my house and illuminates my house like i had brighter than if i had the lights on that's not right you you
Commissioner West. I have a question for staff. So to that point, do you have some suggestions on how you might address like thread that needle between what a minor complaint and a major complaint? Yes. We will, we'll, we'll build the box around this and bring it back. And thanks for pointing out that it, yeah, I mean, it seems like you might be able to again, find some foot candle measurement or something that if the light trespass does exceed some certain level, that's egregious, right? Even if it was legal, nonconforming commissioner curiosity. And this book.
I want to add another example, personal example. If I walk in my neighborhood on the sidewalk, there's a particular house that is a motion-triggered floodlight, no shielding. And even when I shield my eyes from it, it's still difficult to see where I'm walking. So that's another example. That's good. Thank you. Since you're reworking the section anyway, I was wondering if we could add something to help kind of advance the current nonconforming, so like an incentive, a positive reinforcement, because the original, the 2017 general plan item E for incentives does call for that. So I was just wondering, because it would just, you know, if you have, I'm just going to use the parking lot as an example because it's easy, but if there's a way to encourage those folks to change the lighting rather than waiting. I mean, I'm not saying until the parking lot is rebuilt or the lighting is.
be permitted then i think that would be really beneficial have any thoughts on how to do that how to encourage them well they're wasting energy lighting up the world so maybe it's partly financial so yeah i i thought too if like maybe informational handouts or something could go with their energy bills or i don't know be posted in the hardware stores and people shop for lights or maybe there's some sort of partnership i know you guys are short-staffed and really busy but a partnership that could be set up with some of the utility providers to encourage these large users um if there's some i don't know that they would agree to a rate incentive but if there's something there like maybe there's some grants that the utility provider can get can offer to help the parking lot upgrade into this new compliance okay thanks you Yes.
So I just, I want to bring back, because this letter we received today, I didn't really properly read it and I'm rereading it again. And I just realized that it's been referenced a couple of times in tonight's meeting. I would like us to caution that even though it's an email, we be careful of using the word complaint because I don't feel staff has verified this. So I just, I want to be careful. And if we use the word complaint, I would hope that the property owner that is mentioned in this is also notified potentially if we do use the word complaint. I just, I want to make sure we're giving everyone fair opportunities. If this is verifiable, that would be disturbing if I was that person. So I want to acknowledge that also from the letter. Words, for some reason in my mind. I use it just as an example. Like if someone came in with that situation.
We had that writing in the ordinance. How would it be resolved? Not naming anybody in particular, but if you did get a complaint like that, it would be for a situation that was prior to what we were just talking about approving, and I wanted to understand where would it fall. Okay. So you're going to rework that section? We are. Okay. Any comments, concerns with the definitions? I got the comment already on glare. We'll take a look at that. We had wildlife, too, came up as wildlife. Wildlife, yep. And I do get the reflective part. We'll give some serious thought to that. And then there was the recommendation on the appropriate terms to use consistent with. Yes. Yeah. It's fine. One more clarifying question.
If we do rework the language where it would, this would help me, if we do change the language where it would be imposing something that's already been permitted potentially, can I please be shown like where to see that we have that authority? I just want to make sure we aren't overstepping. Like I said in my earlier comment, I have an open mind and I want to see that if that is the case, but I just, for my thought process, I need to read that language. And it doesn't, it would just be for me, so it doesn't have to be presented to everyone, just something I'm asking. The other term that came up was special event. I don't know if that. And then light pollution. I just. It seems like the light pollution is where we're trying to.
to find the dark sky requirements and I haven't read all of the information that was presented to us tonight, but I would hope that our light pollution definition aligns with some sort of national or international standard as it relates to dark skies. And then we talked a fair amount about light trespass to make sure that however we define light trespass in here lines up or aligns with all the comments that we made tonight about both residential and commercial properties and what our expectations were there. So each of us. Might reread it at some point in that consideration because we're hinging a lot of our.
regulation on these definitions. Thank you for that, Chair. Earlier in the sections, we got ahead of ourselves reading stuff, and then you pointed out that what we were talking about really was irrelevant because of the paragraph ahead of time. Right. I'm sorry. Are there any other comments on definitions? Not on definitions, but I have a question after. Okay. So this is the inland version, and just noting the effects of light on marine life are often more severe, so I was wondering when's the coastal version coming, and do we anticipate it to be significantly different from what we've seen tonight? Not be significantly different. I think we did catch your comment just now about the marine. Impacts, and that will be work into the wildlife.
Thank you. Do we have another question? Commissioner Kiarazi? I have a couple questions to staff, just general overarching questions. One, addressing the public comment, and two, just a question of mine. Around looking back at the purpose and noting light pollution as well as enjoyment of night sky, I'm curious if there's appetite by the commission to apply going back to encouragement. Like, in general, lighting temperature less than 2700 Kelvin, you know, should be used in general. Like, maybe using some sort of language of when appropriate and feasible or addressing, because I think color temperature is a, specified only in very specific situations and that.
Color temperature does, when you're, cumulatively, when you're looking at light pollution and dark sky, I think, at least, I would be interested in considering that. And then secondly, using, I use the word cumulative, there was public comment around noting that light pollution is a cumulative effect. It's not, it's sort of, yeah, if you have a target threshold of low light pollution in general, but if you're only regulating it at each individual property, then cumulatively you're creating potentially light pollution when you didn't intend that in the first place. I don't know how to address the cumulative part, but addressing the color temperature might help go a long ways around dark sky intention. So that's a comment maybe just being.
put into the general regulations section that applies to everything around color temperature. I would support that. Specifically just for the color temperature, I think that, especially if we look at shipping ports down in more metropolitan areas, that's definitely one way, additionally shielding, but that's one way that they've combated the cumulative effect because they cover a massive area. So I would support that. I just wanted to clarify, you meant less than 3,000 kelvins, not less than 2,500 kelvins when you were speaking, correct? I meant 2,700, and that goes off of the public recommendation to set 2,700. Okay. That's what I thought you meant. I just wanted to clarify that. As far as implementing it in, I would want to see that and kind of reread it because I'm already at the end of it now. It's hard to go back to the beginning.
Would that make sense? So I'd want to see that there and then read through it before I could say one way or the other. So we're giving you the direction you needed? We have the direction we need. Okay. Sort of like making sausage sometimes, but good. It is. All right. So we'll close this item. There are no items pulled from consent. Do we have a report from the director this evening? Yeah. I want to follow up on some of the things the commission has been involved in and looked at. And those went before the board. The first was the short-term rental ordinance. And the board did approve that, although they modified the proposal for the ag zone to be between, between 2.5 and 10 acres.
would require a special permit and home shares on parcels less than five acres would be allowed and then they increased the separation between units from the 300 feet the Planning Commission identified to 600 feet I do have a question for you we set the fees for for that what the what's the fee for standard permit so for the administrative permit we just defeat a new fee schedule just went into effect and I believe that's $240 now $240 and then if they need a special permit it's about $2,700 I think there was a newspaper article or something like that I don't know if they need a special permit something I read where they totally misquoted
cost of the standard permit at the special permit cost. So I misunderstood that. So I just wanted to thank you for clarifying that. Yeah. And then they also took action on the modification to the CCLUO to allow indoor cultivation in the business park zone. And then that needed to be applied through a Q zone. And down in Redway, there are seven lots that had applied to receive the Q zone. That was approved as recommended by the Planning Commission. There were also two Williams Net contracts that the commission had looked at because they required lot line adjustment. And I believe a coastal development permit. And those were both approved as recommended by the Planning Commission. Good. Thank you. Thank you.
You have a question on the director's report? Okay. It sounds like we have two meetings in April and I just wanted to confirm. It's looking like we will, yes. Commissioners, anything else? I was busy working Tuesday and was unable to listen in to the meeting. I've been searching online and I have yet to find a link to watch the recording. Is there a possibility that I'm not searching properly? Have you looked in the or the insight system? I have not looked there. I went to the part of the website where it's set up for the climate action plan and I was scrolling through there because I would assume the link would be on that spot. The place that I go is go to the Board of Supervisors agendas. And then it will give you a list of meetings.
in 2025 and then you can go and look at that meeting and I was just trying to pull it up real quick see if I can be that quick. 318 does not have their video available. Thank you Laura. So that's not up yet. Okay so eventually the 318 from that was done for the climate action plan and will be up. Correct. Okay. Thank you. Commissioners any discussion items? Could I just give one more heads up? Yes. So we are bringing the VMT discussion forward on the 17th of April. Yes. The regional climate action plan EIR comment period is due to close April 7th. Then we'll be putting the EIR together targeting or the final EIR together.
targeting to bring that to the commission in june so i just wanted to put that on your radar that you know it's probably a good time to start looking at both of those documents now because it's a it's an awful lot to swallow in a short period of time when you bring those to us and again there's public comment there um but we are not certified in the final eir so those don't have to actually be addressed by staff directly that that evening that we're reviewing it or will they need to be we will have the final eir for the planning commission consideration to give a recommendation to the board on okay there may be comments at the public hearing about the final eir but that's those aren't incorporated into the final eir those would be comments that you would then weigh and determine whether or not they're appropriate
You find the final EIR to be adequate or not? So we will have staff and a supporting cast of experts here to help answer those questions that might come from the public? We will have the EIR consultant available online. Okay. That was a budget decision. I apologize. Okay. No, that's fine. Okay. They'll be watching online, and they'll have their staff and experts there to be able to explain to us where that question is either covered or why it wasn't. Yes. Okay. Good. Yes. So you were including the VMT threshold in that comment as well? If you were, as far as I'm aware, that draft document is not available for us to look at. No. Is that right? The VMT threshold? No. We are...
We're still refining it. So the first time we'll see it, we'll be at that meeting? On April 17th. Okay. Well, or the Friday before, yeah. All right. Okay. I won't be here April 17th. I just want to put that on your radar. I will be on a flight to Europe. Okay. Sorry. All right. Okay, I think that concludes us. You good? Okay, meeting adjourned. See you April 3rd.