Humboldt County Planning Commission
Thursday, April 3, 2025
The agenda


6:01 p.m.

Thank you. To the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Commissioner Scavdahl? Here. Commissioner Levy? Commissioner Mulder? Here. Commissioner O'Neill? Here. Commissioner West? Here. Commissioner Curiazzi? Here. Commissioner McFarland? Here. Thank you. Thank you. Director Ford, do we have any agenda modifications this evening? Yes, good evening, Chair. We do have two things to bring to your attention at this time that one will require later action. On the consent calendar, item E2, which is...


6:02 p.m.

In the new Harris area, there is a supplemental to correct a typo on page 4 and to modify a condition of approval, A12. And then when you get to it, item number 8 under new business, or actually that's on consent. So item number E8, we need to pull off of the consent calendar and continue that to April 17th. And that's the extent of the modifications. Thank you. At this point, we take public comment on non-agenda items. Anybody that wishes to address the commission on matters that are not on. This evening's agenda, but are under our purview.


6:03 p.m.

Please do so now. You can approach the podium if you're in the room or you can raise your hand by pressing star nine on your phone if you are on zoom. I'll just check around the room first. I don't see anybody approaching the podium. Do we have any hands raised online? No we do not. I do not see any. Okay I'm going to close public comment on non-agenda items. And move to the consent agenda. On the consent agenda these are items that are generally routine that are approved by the commission on one consent vote. But if anybody would like to discuss any of these items that are on consent commissioners please let me know by raising your hand. Anybody in the room that would like to pull an item off a consent for a question or discussion please raise your hand. And anybody on zoom please do so by


6:04 p.m.

by again pressing star nine. I'll read through the consent items and then check to see if anybody has any comments as we go. First item are our March 20th action summaries for the commission commissioners. And okay so that'll stay on. The next five items I'm going to take together as they're all interrelated conditional use permits for five separate parcels in the New Harris areas that are all interrelated. So I will I'll pull for comments after I read these five off. The first is Hog Trap Farms parcel number 218071003 and this is the the project area. Now we're going to look at some of the other parts of the team that we've had to release like Director Ford indicated.


6:05 p.m.

We have supplemental information on. Next project is also Hog Tramp Farms, LLC, parcel number 218190001. Next project is Finmark Farms, LLC, parcel number 218081002. Then we have Finmark Farms, LLC, parcel number 218081006. And the last one is Finmark Farms, LLC, parcel number 218051008. Commissioners? Yes. Commissioner Curiosity would like to pull those, or do you have a question? Both. Okay.


6:06 p.m.

We'll pull those off of consent, and staff will make a staff report on the collective project. I think that was my question to staff, is that I'm just interested in a report on the collective projects rather than necessarily going through each individual one? I've asked staff to do that. They'll do a report on the collective, and then we can ask questions on the individual projects if we have them. Is that okay? Okay. So we'll pull those from consent and take them up later in the agenda. Item 7, Cooee Parcel Map Subdivision in the Humboldt Hill area. Okay, we'll pull Item 7. Item 8, Farming Humboldt Dreams Microbusiness in the Garberville area. That's the one we've got to pull and continue. Okay, so pull those. We'll pull those off of consent, and we'll take a separate action to continue that to the 7th.


6:07 p.m.

Okay. Item 9, Cultural Ranch, LLC, Buck Mountain Ranch Zone Reclassification. Commissioners looking for hands in the room? And I do not see any hand raised online, so that will stay on consent. Item 10, California Department of Fish and Wildlife Conditional Use Permit on the Cannibal Island Restoration Project. I see a hand raised. Would you like to pull that for discussion later? Yeah, I'm new to this. I just wondered if there's going to be discussion on it or if I could speak for a few minutes. There will be if you would like there to be. So we will pull that off.


6:08 p.m.

and come back to it. Thank you. Yes. That's the end of the consent items. Somebody was keeping track. I'll make a motion to approve items 1 and 9 on the consent. I'll second. I have a motion and second. Everybody is okay with 1 and 9 remaining on consent? I'll take a voice vote. All those in favor, say so by aye. Aye. Aye. Opposed? Okay. Are you ready for the next one? We can take, we can, yes, let's do the item that we're going to continue. I'll make a motion to continue item 8 until April 17th. I'll second that. I have a motion and a second. You have a public comment on this one. Oh, we do.


6:09 p.m.

Okay, thank you. Should we have, can we take that public comment now? Yes. Okay. Caller 7108. Yes. Thank you. I was calling, this was on the agenda at the last, but in convention meeting and it got bumped up to today. I'm wondering why it's getting bumped up again. There was an internal glitch and we put it in the paper, but it was not sent to the surrounding property owners. That's why we're continuing it to the 17th. So we're going to send out legal notices to everybody within the normal mailing radius. Okay. So it's a noticing. Yep. Noticing. Noticing matter. Okay.


6:10 p.m.

Hopefully it'll work out for next time. Thank you. All right, thank you. Thank you for your patience. Do we have a motion and a second? All those in favor, signify by aye. Aye. Okay. We're going to now move to item F, the public hearing on a project, and then we'll come back to the items that are pulled from consent. So we have a staff report, I believe, on the Fisher parcel map subdivision. And while you're pulling that up, I will disclose that I did do a drive-by site visit of this property. So I'm going to go ahead and do that. All right. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. This is a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video of a video


6:11 p.m.

Nice to see you again. My name is Chris Lowe Hefner. I'm here to present this permit application for Fisher Minor Subdivision Coastal Development Permit and Special Permit. So this property is located in McKinleyville, a little bit north of the Mad River, about 400 feet north of the school road and Fisher Avenue intersection. The property has got a land use designation of residential estates, as do most of the surrounding properties, and a zoning of residential single family. The tentative map that was submitted with this proposal shows the parcel being about a little over an acre in size, 49,250 square feet. And per zoning, the minimum parcel size is 20,000 square feet. Part


6:12 p.m.

Parcel 1 is proposed to be 35,950 square feet and Parcel 2 at 13,300 square feet. And the Parcel 2 is under the minimum size, does indeed require the special permit for the lot size modification. And just going over the exceptions table in our zoning code per Parcel 1, lots are not able to be larger than 1.8 times the minimum lot size. So in this case, that's 36,000 square feet. And it's proposed to be at 35,950, which is in the allowable range. So it does conform with code. And for Parcel 2, it's subject to the minimum standard, which is a reduction by 50%. So in this case, it's a 10,000 square foot minimum. And the proposed size is 13,300 square feet, so also in conformance with the exception table. And staffs. Spine. Spine.


6:13 p.m.

Things in regards to the special permit are essentially that this would allow for a primary residence to be located on each of the parcels. It essentially adds a turnkey house and property to the local housing stock, which, you know, given the housing shortages in the county, is a net benefit to this proposal. Furthermore, the findings that we went through show that it's consistent with the general plan and the county code. There are no negative impacts on the housing element, nor do sensitive resources, no risk to public health or safety, nor do properties or improvements in the vicinity. And staff is recommending project approval as conditioned. On that note, there were a couple of exception requests submitted by the council. One was submitted by the applicant in regards to the public works conditions that they had on the project. There's a curb gutter.


6:14 p.m.

sidewalk and landscape stripe that is generally part of these types of developments. However, the applicant has submitted a request to remove the landscape stripe for a couple of reasons. One being the development south of the property that is slowly moving north that does not have a landscaping stripe. It's just curb gutter sidewalk. So the removal of the landscaping stripe requirement would fit with that existing development. And the applicant also had a previous building permit for the ADU that accounted for the curb gutter sidewalk, but not the landscaping stripe. So it seems appropriate to not have that landscaping stripe. Can you move the mic so that you're speaking exactly to it? Indeed. So Public Works has supported this idea to remove the landscaping stripe and has provided language in their document to reflect that, should the Planning Commission agree with that. Decision.


6:15 p.m.

Thank you. The other exception request submitted by the applicant pertains to the drainage feature that has been conditioned. And I am not an engineer and I understand that Public Works is not going to be here so I will do my best to relay the information that they gave me about this circumstance. But the condition is to essentially install a drainage inlet on the west side of Fisher Avenue that goes underneath the road and connects with the existing drainage inlet which would subsequently flow south along Fisher Avenue and drain down into the pastures. The applicant submitted an alternative plan to pull some of that water into his property but Public Works does not support that decision or plan. And there are a few reasons for that. Public Works referenced the McKinleyville drainage study that was done in 1928. However, when the comments were made, no comment was made of the information as the official tigers tonightイ basically looking for another intrusion into the plumbing system they were doing. But as soul分散化 to a final agreement established in 19 King in 1888, the property was given a blanket to the parents in person in which said to reenter their nied and all five neighbors had their son, Is the man's one child. And he announced that he would Cไมي۔ And would standing in the right way 확인Ha!


6:16 p.m.

Lee calls out dislocation. Quoting that document, flows from the north, a pond up on Fisher Avenue, approximately 400 feet north of School Road, which is indeed right in front of the subject property. And what tends to happen is essentially from Wolf Avenue all the way down to the subject property, water from stormwater will drain southward and collect in front of the subject property's house. The road is crowned, so water will flow west or east, and the water flowing west will generally flow into some of the adjacent properties that front Fisher Avenue. However, over time, people have built up driveways, added landscaping and fence and other things that have effectively become little dams and prevented some of that flow from going into those properties and subsequently continue south and ponds in front of the subject property.


6:17 p.m.

The applicant has suggested that there could be an alternative to the drainage inlet, namely pulling up water onto his property where it would drain sufficiently and relieve some of that ponding. However, there's not really a way of separating the the water that collects on his development from the curb gutter sidewalk construct from the road drainage. And so there's the potential of there being quite a lot of water that actually drains onto the subject property. And it's Public Works' conclusion that it's really not in the best interest for the applicant nor for the neighbors to accept stormwater runoff from the public road. Further, as as they quoted in their response to the exception request, the county typically requires a road system road system to be built to county standards and in this case the drainage inlet is required to capture the water that collects on the curb gutter sidewalk. So that's a good Croatia.


6:18 p.m.

drainage from the west side of Fisher Road. And so they subsequently do not support the exception request in this case. We also did receive public comment about this project. We received a comment from the neighbor immediately south of this property in regards to the special permit. Her comments were concerned about the interpretation of the special permit guidelines and how we came to our conclusion that it would be a net benefit for the county to have additional housing. And we tried to assure her that that was a net positive. I understand that she's probably going to provide more comments and clarify that a little bit. Additionally, she did reiterate support for Public Works' condition about the drainage inlet because she was concerned about the potential of ponding on that applicant's property and then flowing south onto her property. And causing potential


6:19 p.m.

issues for her. So with that, staff does recommend that the commission make the required findings for approval of the minor subdivision, the coastal development permit, and special permit, and to adopt the resolution approving the minor subdivision, coastal development permit, and special permit subject to the recommended conditions of approval. And as I alluded to earlier, staff are prepared to make the change, at least if the planning commission agrees regarding the landscaping stripe. And then we'll look forward to your decision on the other exception request. Thanks. Commissioners, before we go to the applicant and the public, do you have any questions of staff? Could you bring up the map again where the lot split is? Thank you. Sorry, the tentative map or the? The one that's


6:20 p.m.

The tentative map. Is it possible that the lot could be larger? Is there any reason why it can't be larger? The smaller one? Are you referring to parcel two? Can that one be larger? It could potentially be a little bit larger, but the way it's proposed is essentially right down the middle between the two existing residences. There's a primary residence on parcel one, as shown, and then there's an ADU on parcel two, so it's kind of splitting those two. Okay. Commissioner Chiarazzi? Can you elaborate a little bit more what landscape stripe means, or can you just describe that? Is it gutter, then curb, then sidewalk, then landscape stripe? Can you just elaborate on what that looks like a bit more? I think it varies from cities, and counties, but as I understand, it could vary depending. I would consider the long-term type Kaitlin. Yes. When the new Split 그건 in large plate Holk potatoes would just dollar that down. Yes. Is Chiarazzi a larger care package than the previous one? No. Is gera the potential size? Are you assuming it would be larger? Yes. Can we also estimate, because our AP is being driven down, what's the slide showing they are different? Some of the small items, we're looking at some good mulch bins, houses,


6:21 p.m.

It is, in this particular case, it goes curb, sidewalk, landscaping, stripe, and then property. To clarify, so the applicant is looking, is that landscaping, stripe, and easement request, or does that landscaping exist on the property owner's boundary or inside their property? It is part of the easement. However, in this particular case, he's already got a fence where that landscaping stripe would be, and that was already part of a previous permit. So it would be, you know, that fence and the proximity of landscaping stripe would be problematic in that sense. Okay, this time if the applicant has anything to say or wants to approach the Commission you have up to 10 minutes.


6:22 p.m.

And after we hear from public comment, if you have anything else to add, you could come back up. Okay, thank you. Yeah, could you put up the first slide that I have? I'll wait while she finds it's not important in the beginning. Dave Mazerve here. I'm the owner at 1664 Fisher. I'm working on this massive subdivision, you know, dividing a parcel into two small lots and I hadn't realized quite how massive it was going to be. First I'd like to address the objection from my neighbor about the lot size adjustment. As Chris said, the code allows to divide it into something that's half of ten thousand.


6:23 p.m.

thousand feet and something that's no more than 1.8 times 20,000 feet. So I'm doing that and the reason I'm doing that is as he said because of the location of the houses on the property so that I can have a small lot around the small house that I built in the front and have the existing house have a larger piece of property with it. I don't see any way that this negatively affects the neighbor and my understanding from Chris is that it's the three-quarter acre parcel to the west is not subdividable anyway because it's under two 20,000 square foot lots so it couldn't be subdivided in the future. So I'm doing that and I'm going to continue to do that. So I'm going to continue to do that. So anyway that's you know.


6:24 p.m.

And it also says specifically the code states in order to better design and cope with difficulties due to topography and other natural or man-made features. So the code does allow for using man-made features to determine, like a house, to determine the size of the lot. So yeah, I want to divide it into the quarter acre and the three-quarter acre. Regarding the landscape strip or stripe, actually the understanding I had of it was that it was road, landscape stripe, and then sidewalk. As he said, I did get a permit to build the house, which had the fence on it. The permit was approved, and it's set up for just a sidewalk. And also, if the sidewalk were set back there, the sidewalk would jog by my neighbors. To the left. To the right.


6:25 p.m.

the south and would also dead end into a mailbox collection at the north end and all the fences up the north, up on the west side of there. So I'm glad that Public Works is willing to look at that and say that it's okay not to do that. So the biggest issue for me is the Public Works requiring the 18-inch drain across from Fisher Avenue, across Fisher Avenue from my sidewalk and gutter on the west side to the existing drain on the east side. In the road there, there's a sewer main, which is pretty deep. There's a water main, which is maybe three feet down. And then there's a gas main, which PG&E won't say how deep it is for security reasons. But everybody says it's 18 to 24 inches below the road surface.


6:26 p.m.

So there's really no way to fit an 18-inch train on top of it, and also, well, I mean, without rerouting the gas line. And also, well, I'll get into it, but the, you know, by my calcs, 18 inches is huge. That's a little early for that one. I was, so my main point, I guess, is one thing that it would be super expensive to put a drain in underneath Fisher, an 18-inch drain, and it's not my responsibility to provide drainage for all of Fisher Avenue and future developments. So this is what Public Works came up with, and they called it the ponding, and they referred to the 19th. 1992 McKinleyville drainage.


6:27 p.m.

study and said up there that the ponding is present, specifically calls out ponding, site visit confirmed that this ponding is present. And you can see the ponding there. Now Chris didn't realize this, but it's very clear, as I'll show from other photographs, that that ponding does not come from the north. There is absolutely no runoff on the west side of Fisher Avenue. From the north, even in heavy rains. And that ponding comes from the school road area and comes down and ponds up there because it can't make it into my driveway because I didn't like having a bump in my driveway for the ditch that supplied it. So that will go away and, as I said, only deals with the about 300 feet to the top of the rise towards school road. So that ponding is missing.


6:28 p.m.

not from the north. And if you, the next one, yeah, this is just the McKinleyville drainage stay, says install a pipe network on Fisher, flows from the north, pond up on Fisher Road. Well, that flow is not from the north. That flow is from the south. And it's much slighter than what it could be. And the only reason there isn't ponding or isn't any water from the north is that there are no sidewalks, and the ground everywhere around there is super porous. You know, I did a PERC test, and the engineer couldn't believe how quickly the water went into the ground. Now, if we could have the next slide. This is looking north. The house and the fence I was talking about are on the left.


6:29 p.m.

There, we're looking at the east side of the road, and that's the drain down at the bottom. This is two days after a heavy rain, one day after a heavy rain, and you can see that the water is still flowing like crazy down the east side of the road. This water actually comes from three-quarters of the way up to Montana, which is the road a quarter mile up there at the top of the hill, and it continues to flow because it comes from a lot to the east side of Fisher and flows onto Fisher, onto the Hammond Trail, and then down here. And while it gets more, there gets to be a lot more of it when it's really raining hard, but this is after it rains and it's run off from a spring or something on that property. I want you also to notice that there's absolutely nothing, no water to the north.


6:30 p.m.

on the west side of the road. Next slide, please. This is what that ponding just south of my property looks like when it's really pouring. And you can see from this that it's coming from behind me, which is to the south. And it basically, my driveway dams it up a little bit. And before I put gravel in my driveway, it used to just run out there and disperse on my land, which is what my proposal is, is to take this water kind of as a favor and deal with it and also deal with any water that I create in terms of west side runoff and put a six-inch drain underneath the side, walk and put in right against my south boundary.


6:31 p.m.

put in a leach area to take that water. And this won't, it's, that, the intention for that drain is not to take future drainage from the north if that occurs when development occurs up there, because I don't believe that's my responsibility. It's certainly my responsibility to take care of the drainage from my property. There is absolutely no water that drains, as the engineer's report says, there is no water that drains off of my property onto the road. So the only water I'm going to be creating is from the sidewalk and gutter that I have to put in. And then I'm also willing to take care of this water, which amounts to, I figured it out for the hundred year flood and for the hundred year rainstorm, and it works out to 20 to 30 gallons a minute if it's actually raining half an inch an hour. So a six inch pipe will easily.


6:32 p.m.

more than take care of that. And my basic... I need you to kind of wrap it up. I am. I see the time. My basic argument is that it's, according to the code, it's my responsibility to take care of any drainage onto the road that I create. It is not my responsibility, according to the code, to take care of situations that are off my property that are not dependent on anything that I am doing. And I'm perfectly willing to cooperate with the county. Let me just finish up. Ten seconds. I'm perfectly willing to cooperate with the county on putting in a drain onto my property and perhaps having drains required for future sidewalks up above. Or if it were possible to do it, I would... kick some money into...


6:33 p.m.

We'll fund for when they really need to put in a drain across Fisher. That is not necessary now. My property isn't going to make that. My subdivision isn't going to make that necessary. So thank you for listening, and I appreciate your being here. Thank you. Would anybody else in the room like to address the commission? I see we have one hand up online. Ella, if you'd like to, you have the room. Hi, can you hear me okay? Yes, we can. Thank you. All right. Hi. Yes. So I own the property to the south where that flooding in front of my house driveway and on the curb of the sidewalk is occurring.


6:34 p.m.

It's been a problem since I was the person who installed the sidewalk when I built an ADU. And Public Works asked the property owner, which was not Dave at the time, to put a little ditch there to allow the water to flow. And that's gotten filled up by gravel. And so it's become more and more of a problem. I have some concerns. I guess I would rather support Public Works, who has done the research on this and have a proper fix for the long term on our street. I plan to live here the rest of my life. And I'd really like to see that this whole drainage issue dealt with. I'm concerned that the fix that Dave Meserve is recommending may not properly solve the problem for the long term. And I'm concerned. And that I'm concerned.


6:35 p.m.

needs maintenance who's going to do that when he sells office property since he is a developer builder and doesn't live there and intends to to move along um so um i do support the public works plan for for a fix on that and i'm happy to answer any questions about the flooding if you at some point want for me and as far as the lot size modification um what you know what really gets me about that is um this exception there's a minimum i bought the property because i wanted open space around me i bought it back in 2001 i wanted it over an acre i like that the properties to the north of me were large and um that i would have um you know and that the minimums uh lot size when they were split was 20 000 square foot that means they could only be split in large sizes maintaining space around those um so um um i and so i i i there's there's nothing


6:36 p.m.

So using the exception, I just don't understand the application of the exception when there's not any difficulty in being able to split behind the mobile home and have the two units on the front and have another 20,000 on the back. There's nothing, the exception to lot size section specifically says in order to better design and cope with difficulties due to topography and other natural or man-made features. Well, I know Dave is saying that the reason is because, you know, now you want to split both of them into have two lots that have primary units. That's not going to increase housing stock because there's already two units there. But he purposely bought the property two years ago with the stated intent to us neighbors that he was going to subdivide it. And then he chose last year to build that ADU where it's located. So he created the man. He made conditions to then be able to survive it off.


6:37 p.m.

And now wants the exception. Thank you. I think we understand your point. Thank you. Anybody else like to address the commission? I'm going to close the public hearing on this and bring it back to the commissioners. Yes. A couple questions. That was very kind of you, Chair, to allow the extra time for the public speaker as you did the applicant. I just wanted a couple questions for staff. I do believe we've had a couple of these in the McKinleyville area, but I could be having a bad memory. Do we have an idea ballpark of how many of these exceptions we may have done in the McKinleyville area in the past? I guess what I'm trying to say, this isn't the first one. It's not the first one.


6:38 p.m.

In my recollection, we may have done two over the last four or five years, but we also don't have that many subdivisions that come through in McKinleyville. So maybe two out of, let's just say, 10 would have an exception. But it's not the first one. Correct. Thank you. Can I ask a couple more questions? Sure. I heard testimony of possible elevation issues for the 18-inch culvert. And so I was just curious if there's allowability in the design that maybe they would have to put in multiple smaller culverts if there's elevation issues between the utilities. If that's something in the conditions would be allowable because I kind of read it as it would be a plan submitted to Public Works. And Public Works would be. I would probably accept it. So normally when they get into the design phase, that's when that kind of.


6:39 p.m.

flexibility and judgment would be applied during the actual engineering review. Okay. Thank you for that. Chair, I think we offered to the applicant that they could come back and repeat. We did. You're right. Thank you for clarifying that. And I'll have to reopen the public hearing if the applicant, if there's anything else you wanted to add or address with respect to the other speaker or the comments that were received. Yeah, I guess mainly the emphasis is that the drainage that is in front of Ella's house there is coming from the south. And it amounts to building up behind there at, like I say, the peak of 20 to 30 gallons per minute at a super storm. And it's going to be very easy to take care of it. Before she built the site. And then after she built the sidewalk, it actually ran.


6:40 p.m.

directly onto her property because that's the way it works there before you build a sidewalk. And actually the lowest point in the road is 10 feet south of my property line on the road. It's just an inch lower than in front of me, but it's interesting to me that Public Works didn't require drainage since that was the lowest point on the road. Again, I'm willing to drain it onto my property. I'm not willing to drain the whole road because I don't think that that should be required of any property owner to take care of a quarter mile of drainage to the north there. So that's my thoughts. Thank you. Now I'll close the public hearing for the second time. Thank you. And thanks for pointing that out. Appreciate it. Yes. Kind of a follow-up on Mulder's question. Thank you.


6:41 p.m.

When you say that public works will address the feasibility of the drain, have they considered, so his comment was more on the size, have they addressed the gas line concern? I'm not sure. I can't respond to that. That is something, though, that when the engineering drawings are received, that would be reviewed and looked at, and then if an alternative design or something needs to be done, they would figure that out during that engineering design. This is just a tentative map. So this is not the engineering, the formal engineering, by any means. This is simply just a matter of a request to allow a subdivision, and then before the map is recorded, that issue would be evaluated. And so it's possible that the alternative design could cost more than the current proposal? What's the alternative design? Whatever the engineering department would come up with. If they came up with something.


6:42 p.m.

something else to mitigate the to not like I guess if they decide an 18 inch is their suggestion and they say that that means the utilities have to be relocated would that cost I don't think they would would touch the utilities I think they would do something different with the drainage and do we know we heard like two different comments about the source of the water base there was the source was from the north in the study but then there's observation saying it's not coming from the north was any of that ground truth or did we stick with the study well I mean some of the commentary that you've heard tonight even by the applicant is that this a low point the road so the water drains to this point and I think what Public Works is saying is that in order to have orderly development allow this additional use of this property this drainage needs to be addressed I think I can


6:43 p.m.

help if as I said I made a site visit so if you could put the picture back up that shows the curb and gutter and the ponding that we just saw I don't know if that was the applicants that one so you see the red curb and you see less and less red curb as it moves south because it's flowing to the south or excuse me to the north there it's coming from the south it's flowing to the north it's blocked by the driveway which the applicant admits is the low point when we extend the curb gutter and sidewalk from the end of the red stripe now it's going to continue and have a driveway there and continue curb gutter and sidewalk down to the end of that open fence the wire fence the water from the north end is now going to drain to the south because the roads going up if other parcels do the same thing as this gentleman is


6:44 p.m.

planning to do and also subdivide in the future. They will also add curb gutter and sidewalk to the north and the water will come to the south. The applicant's proposal to drain the water onto his property, while generous, is, I understand Public Works' problem with that. The Public Works is responsible for maintaining the drainage alongside the road. If the applicant's engineer would have to demonstrate that the property could even percolate and take that much water, Public Works would likely require to have to own that or have an easement for maintenance, which would make the lot actually even smaller. It's problematic from a lot of different perspectives. So there needs to be a... There needs to be a drain put in there at the low point that drains the water across the road into the existing drainage system.


6:45 p.m.

And to Director Ford's point, the future engineer will need to figure out if that pipe will work. They make oval pipe, they make flat arch pipe, they make box pipes. They can do a lot of different alternatives if there are utility constraints to try to wiggle through. That will be the designer's challenge in the future to work with Public Works on a solution. So that's my observation. When I was out there, it does flow to the applicant's point, it does flow from the south. Thank you, Chair. That's all absolutely correct. I'd just like to add one more point, is that for the county to accept a design that redirects flow onto somebody's property. Yeah, it's not going to be very difficult. Yeah, well, then that's the county's liability. Correct. So as I'm saying, the county would ultimately have to own that property. The applicant would have to de-own it.


6:46 p.m.

that property to the county for some sort of infiltration basin right i just it seems pretty complicated yeah and uh probably more expensive and more work than putting a pipe across the road that was really helpful thank you so i think director for this next answer is going to be no but the caller mentioned that the previous property owner had a ditch on their property that the county had asked them to install to capture water so that wasn't a formal easement correct no i i don't think we we we we know that okay um you did hear testimony that there was gravel added there yeah i just wanted to check if it was a formal easement but it sounds like no okay thank you and then just kind of clarify the the creation of adus on properties you know we don't have a lot of say in that as my understanding that's why it's state law um when they when they stay on the property they're not going to be able to do that so i think that's a good point um when they when they stay on the property they're not going to be able to do that so i think that's a good point property they can be used you know as a rental


6:47 p.m.

unit or a short-term rental or whatever the property or a guest unit or whatever but by creating the two separate parcels those properties can actually go to the market as for for future home buyers as two separate lots correct which i think is the point of the staff's recommendation is what they're trying to say is why that's a community potential community benefit um so and i understand the caller's frustration with maybe um you know diminishing lot sizes but the adu is already there and that requirement is kind of outside of our control you do get the benefit of extending the sidewalk and the curb and gutter and solving the drainage problem by the fact that the developer is proposing to subdivide if the absence of subdivision the adu would still be there


6:48 p.m.

The sidewalk and the drainage, the sidewalk cannot be installed and the drainage problem would not be remedied. So that's why I kind of I find myself in support of the subdivision and supporting staff's recommendations to eliminate the landscape strip but maintain the drainage structure. Can I make a motion? Can I ask my fellow commissioners a question? Do we have any feelings or sentiments towards fixing the drainage on one applicant versus his suggestion of creating a community fund? Just trying to see what people's thoughts are. My thought is if the public works recommend it, then we should. They don't come in here very often telling us that they want us to do something, and if that's what they're recommending, then they're engineers, and they have a responsibility, and I think we should go along with it.


6:49 p.m.

I'm not questioning the need for the drain. I'm just questioning putting the payment on one applicant versus creating the fund. Like, I don't know if we've ever done something like that or just kind of. We've never done that. And then you'd have to have, you know, a road association or something to hold that money. And it would be very complicated. You know, it's when you subdivide things and you're going to sell them and you're going to make a profit, you sometimes have to absorb some of those costs. And it could get a lot more expensive. Then what he's being asked to do. Yes. Question to staff. In a subdivision, obviously this is a smaller subdivision, but any time there's any drainage or improvements, that falls on the developer, usually your access points or the project. Is that correct or incorrect? That is correct. Okay. Thank you. So with that, I mean, it's a burden. It's a financial burden. I do hope.


6:50 p.m.

the class a general engineering contractor's license so i understand the cost i understand materials are way up um but if that's a requirement in our county code so we allow for smaller lot sizes and and these other uh things to allow this but then if we're adding a requirement i don't see how we can just say no there i mean we've seen pictures of there's a drainage issue there so i i'm in support um of staff's proposal with you know getting rid of the landscape stripe and moving forward in that way but i i don't feel i could support the applicant's idea because i i mean i don't feel that there's sufficient evidence to support that exception request if there is a detailed engineering report and the saying the partial could handle it that would it would be different but i think that's


6:51 p.m.

where I'm leaning so I would actually make a motion to adopt the resolution attachment one which does the following finds the planning commission has determined that the project is exempt from further environmental review pursuant to section 15183 projects consistent with the community plan or zoning the state sequel guidelines and as a responsible agency agrees with the lead agency's findings and makes all the required findings for approval of the fisher partial map subdivision special permit and coastal development permit and approves the fisher partial map subdivision special permit and coastal development permit recommended by staff subject to the conditions of approval and my motion includes removing that landscape stripe I'll second the motion I just want to say I appreciate the walkthrough of the drainage responsibility for the public education and also to do diligence to the the applicant's comment other comments on the motion second yep just


6:52 p.m.

Quick discussion regarding the landscaping stripe. There's a reason in general that Public Works and Sidewalk Design recommends that. It can help with starting to move from just accommodating people that have to walk to accommodating people that would like to walk or want to walk. It just creates a better, more enjoyable environment. So hearing that the fence line was permitted during house construction, I would request county staff to just, when they're permitting fence lines, right on the property line to consider those potential future improvements on the frontage and allow for that space. That's a good point. I would note that there is a landscaping strip on the other side of the road, so it does help a little bit. It's not hemmed in totally. But to your point, good point.


6:53 p.m.

Yes. Just clarification on the motion. You're proposing to accept Public Works staff recommendation with the removal of the strip but not accepting the applicant's proposal regarding. Correct. 100%. I just have a question. I don't think you always have to get a permit when you do a fence unless it's a certain height. Is that correct? That is correct. Yeah, that's a great point. In this case, it sounds like it was involved in the permit, but that's an excellent point. Okay. We have a motion and second. Could we have a roll call vote, please? Commissioner McFarland? Aye. Commissioner West? Aye. Commissioner Curiazzi? Aye. Commissioner O'Neill? Yes. Commissioner Scavdahl? Yes. Commissioner Mulder? Yes. Motion carries. Thank you.


6:54 p.m.

Chair, my nose has started running. I was going to ask if we could, you can see I'm coughing. So staff, if you could maybe tee up the consent items pulled from consent while we take a break and we'll be back at 7 o'clock. Thank you. Thank you.


7:01 p.m.

Thank you. Order. Recording in progress. Okay, we're going to hear from staff first on these five conditional use permits for five projects in the New Harris area that are interrelated, I believe. And then we can ask questions on the combination or the specific projects individually after staff report. Chair Skabdal, members of the commission, good evening. My name is Stephen Santos, senior planner. And tonight we're going to set a record and talk about.


7:02 p.m.

Five projects at once. So here we go. Just a quick clarification that it's four conditional use permits and one special permit in the New Harris area. Thank you. Understood. Okay. So as I just said it's in the New Harris area which is in the southeast corner of the county. And here's this graphic I prepared using our GIS to try and show the adjacency of the five projects. The five white polygons indicate the individual permit applications with the permit application numbers annotated. The blue splotches also indicated by the yellow arrows are the three rainwater catchment ponds that make up the backbone of the area. And the orange is the irrigation system. And the reason these five are being brought to the commission together is because they're interrelated.


7:03 p.m.

Two ways. One is they share an irrigation system, the three rainwater ponds I just mentioned, and then they all process their harvested cannabis on the same parcel, which is the parcel that is outlined in orange. Now, why is that parcel outlined in orange and another parcel outlined in yellow? Well, the parcel is outlined in orange has actually already has an approved permit. Could you speak a little louder or closer to the mic, please? Thank you. Okay. Um, the parcel in orange already has an approved permit and already has a location and a structure approved for processing. So we're not altering that entitlement tonight. And the reason the other parcel that is highlighted in yellow, that is owned by the permit applicant, but, and, but there's no cannabis entitlement going there, but water lines will be passing through that parcel. So that parcel is listed in the.


7:04 p.m.

conditions of approval for the condition that deals with having to establish easements for the for the infrastructure so that's the explanation of the different colors on this map so again the two interrelated issues are a shared irrigation system the three rainwater ponds and processing occurring on the already approved site that has the orange boundary i'm going to go through the individual projects really really quickly in real summary fashion just to highlight some of the differences but for the most part these are very similar and kind of standard cannabis projects i'm going to start with 13336 and i'm going to kind of go from southwest to northeast this particular project is the only project that is being approved under 2.0 the ccluo the other four are being


7:05 p.m.

And under 1.0. The reason this one is being done under 2.0 is because the applicant requested to convert an existing outdoor area to mixed light. And we would consider that new cultivation, even though it's going in a spot that's already disturbed and already being used for cultivation. And the only way to do that was through 2.0. So this is the one project that's a CCLUL project. The other feature that makes this project somewhat unique is it's the only property that borders BLM land. So this is the only one out of the five that we referred to BLM. And we did get a BLM response on this one, expressing some concerns about, um, Northern spotted owl habitat. Um, we received some additional in response to that. The applicant provided additional evidence provided.


7:06 p.m.

by a registered professional forester. The cultivation areas, the closest cultivation areas are at least 900 feet from BLM, so well beyond the 600-foot minimum. And because they're all occurring in areas already disturbed that had already been used by cannabis, there was no northern spotted owl habitat that was being implicated or impacted by the proposal. And so even if we had referred the other projects to BLM, I think it's safe to assume that we would have gotten a similar letter from BLM and would have been able to make the same findings as we did on this one, since this one is the closest. So really quick, that's the entitlement in terms of cultivation, no separate nursery, processing next door, and PG&E power will be required to be through a renewable energy. Thank you.


7:07 p.m.

as you know is a 2.0 requirement. Okay, this next project, 13337. Real quick, here's the summary. Very similar, no separate nursery. Same rainwater catchment system. Processing next door to the south. PG&E power, no generators. For these remaining four projects, staff is recommending as part of this presentation that the commission add an additional condition of approval that isn't in your original packet to be consistent with the supplemental that you received for the project that I just covered, 1336. So this additional condition of approval mirrors the exact language that we provided in the supplemental. And as I was preparing the PowerPoint, in consultation with my manager, it was determined it was...


7:08 p.m.

Good idea just to be consistent across all the permits. So that's, I'm making a recommendation today to add that condition to the other four projects. So there might be a question already brewing in your minds of like, wait, Stephen, how can you condition a project that's already been approved when it comes to processing? And we're not doing that. We're conditioning the permits that are up for decision tonight. And the structure of that condition is processing cannot occur on that adjacent parcel until the conditions that were already adopted for that parcel have been satisfied. And those conditions are A7 and A9 and just relate to permitting of the structure and making sure that there's appropriate wastewater facilities. Okay, next project is 13367. Very similar profile.


7:09 p.m.

outdoor cultivation, no separate nursery, rainwater, etc., etc. This particular project, the operations plan called out using generators for power. So this project has the standard condition to require transition to renewables by January 1st. And again, adding the condition of approval to be consistent. The next project is 13365. What I'd like to do at this point is acknowledge and apologize that there is an error in attachment to the location map. And that is because that location map was created when the application was first provided. It had a different APN and a different configuration. And so while this application was... It was making its way through the cannabis permitting process.


7:10 p.m.

An existing lot line adjustment that had been approved got processed and finalized that changed the configuration to this rectangular configuration with a new parcel number. So the parcel number that's in the staff report, that's in the notice, that's in the resolution is the correct parcel number, that is the correct configuration. It's just that location map and attachment to is outdated. Okay. Quick project profile. All existing cultivation. This particular project does have a separate ancillary nursery within the 10% threshold. And then everything else is very similar to the other projects. PG&E power, no generators, and processing on parcel three. And again, the recommendation to add the same condition of approval to this one as well. And then finally, project 13374. And then finally, project 13374.


7:11 p.m.

This one is the also has its own separate ancillary nursery again at that 10 percent threshold and then everything else pretty much looking like the other the other permits. And again the recommended condition of approval no written public comment was received on the this constellation of projects. Therefore I'm going to try and roll in all the individual recommendations into this one slide that the Planning Commission consider the MND adopted for the CMMLUO and the addendums for the four projects that are under 1.0. Consider the final environmental impact report adopted for the CCLUO for the one project that is 2.0. Make the required findings for approval per Humboldt County Code and adopt the five resolutions approving the hog trap.'. Mr. Waters speaking. Questions. Second.


7:12 p.m.

Special permit subject to the conditions of approval, including the conditions that I've recommended tonight in the staff PowerPoint. And that concludes my presentation. And the applicant's agent is present here tonight. Okay. Thank you. Before we go to public comment, commissioners, do you have any questions of staff on the report we just heard? Sarah? So you're suggesting when it's time to make a motion to make a motion for all five at once, correct? I will defer to my director on what the proper. In this particular case, you can. If you want to address them individually, you can. But obviously we put them on consent, believing that they were essentially there. And so if you want to make a motion to follow the staff's recommendation with modified conditions for all five projects, that would be fine.


7:13 p.m.

So on the ones that have the generator, they would also have the option of extending PG&E if they wanted to rather than do the renewable? Or is that not an option? I don't know what the PG&E availability is out there, but certainly if I received documentation that they've served the parcel with PG&E and were using PG&E for power, I would sign off on that condition. So that doesn't have to be added. That would just be a given that if PG&E, if they wanted to extend it, they could? Because it seems like it's already on some of the parcels, right? Yeah. The substance of the condition is to get off the generator. Right. And so if they get off the generator to an acceptable source of power, such as PG&E, we would sign off on that condition. Commissioner Curiazzi? Thank you for that presentation. And I'm pretty sure you said this, but I just want to double check on the project that is under 2.0.13.336. The new cult of... The new mix... Mixed light.


7:14 p.m.

The location of that is an existing site that had cultivation prior to 2016. It wasn't just a cleared location. Through the chair, that is absolutely correct. It was used for outdoor cultivation with an interim permit through last year. Just one more question. Can you confirm for me the total water storage available on all of these sites? Exceeds, just tell me that it exceeds the total irrigation requirement on all of these sites. Confirmed. Thank you. Okay, I see no more questions for commissioners. I'll open the public hearing and if the applicant is here or their agent is here, please either approach the podium or raise your hand if you'd like to speak.


7:15 p.m.

Thank you. And is 10 minutes enough? You don't need, do you need 10 minutes per project or can we do them all in 10 minutes? No, we can do all in 10 minutes. All right, thank you. I really just wanted to say thank you guys for being here today and looking at everything and let you know that I'm here if you guys had any further questions. Thank you. And if anybody else in the audience or on the phone would like to speak, please either approach the podium or raise your hand by pressing star 9. I don't see any other speakers in the room and I don't see any hand raised online so I am going to close the public hearing I assume the applicant has no no rebuttal to the no comments that we've received


7:16 p.m.

Back to the commission. Yes. Through the chair, I just have one catch on in the draft resolution for 13336. In finding four, it's just in evidence C, you're listing the wrong square footage. You're listing the square footage from the other hog farms. Properties of maybe given the complexity of this, maybe just kind of going through one more time and making sure that I'm sure there was some copying and pasting, but then you also had to correct things for each individual project. So just recommending that maybe do one more pass. Through the chair, just to clarify, that's finding number four. Finding four and evidence item C.


7:17 p.m.

You listed the wrong square footage. That is correct. I apologize for the error. So let's acknowledge and we'll be corrected. Thank you. Yeah, and just maybe go through one more time. I imagine this was complex, so I appreciate all of the work going through and doing all five of these projects. Was that your motion with the... That was I'll make a motion to adopt these five projects together and also to include the additional staff recommendation of the condition of approval as presented. I'll second. I have a motion and a second. Any discussion on the motion? Could we have a voice vote, please? All those in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Thank you.


7:18 p.m.

Thank you. Okay, we are getting through a few notes here. It was first it was seven remaining are seven and was it ten? Yes. Yep. So Commissioner Curiazzi you pulled item seven. Would you like a staff report or to waive the reading of the staff report? It's up to you. I think my so my reason for pulling this item is really around the request for exception to the installing curb gutter and sidewalk. And so I'm happy to go through my argument.


7:19 p.m.

Comments or I can is staff do you have a report and are there photographs there? Let's have a staff report so we can then be on the same sheet of music. Thank you Okay, if we could bring up that PowerPoint. My name is Steve Lazar. I'm the planner assigned to this project. And I have a report that really focuses on the exception, not the rest of the findings in expectation that that would be a point of discussion. So this is a parcel map subdivision, a minor subdivision in the Humboldt Hill area. I'm going to go through a few slides that just kind of show the location to give some context. So the red parcel is the parcel that we're talking about tonight. You can see it's located along Humboldt Hill Drive in the upper portion of the Humboldt Hill area. Looking a little closer, it's at the intersection of Skyline and Humboldt Hill.


7:20 p.m.

You can see parcelization in the vicinity. And then here's the zoning and land use. It's R1 zoning, ordinarily a 6,000 square foot minimum, or 5,000, but in this portion it's 6,000. And then the density of one to seven units per acre. You can see that this is located within a former subdivision. The Humble Hill area isn't one single subdivision. It was a series of subdivisions over a series of years. So this was the earliest subdivision in that area, and I'll show you in a moment. So parcel lot 28 from that subdivision. Here's an aerial photo. Here's the tentative map, and here's a close-up of the tentative map. Essentially what's happening is we have a single-family home and an accessory dwelling unit that was permitted in the early 2000s that are being parcelized by the creation of a new boundary. So separated onto their own parcels. But I want to take a minute to just explain that the reason this is before you tonight is because an exception is being requested. It could be approved ministerially.


7:21 p.m.

Under the Senate Bill 9 provisions that were added to the government code in 2021. And just because we don't talk about this with you because Senate Bill 9 subdivisions don't appear before you, just to explain kind of how that works, to be eligible for an SB 9 lot split, you have to have a single family residential zoning. You have to be able to accommodate parcel sizes of at least 1,200 square feet. So you can see considerably less than the 6,000 square foot minimum would otherwise apply. And it has to be in an urbanized area or urban area cluster. There are some exceptions for prime farmland, wetlands, things that will kick it out of eligibility, even if it meets the above standards. Looking at this area, the areas in yellow are urban areas or urban area clusters. And you can see the city limits of City of Eureka. So most of the Humboldt Hill area is within an area that would be eligible for a ministerial approval for subdivision, including this parcel. And then here you can see how. So portions of the upper Humboldt.


7:22 p.m.

Hill are outside of the urban area, but this one's firmly within it. So the exception request is for removal of the sidewalk frontage improvement requirements that are being recommended by Public Works as part of the conditions, the draft conditions of approval. You can see here the frontage of the property and the areas that would be affected by the sidewalk should it be installed. Along Humboldt Hill Road, there is a retaining wall that's already in place that potentially might be affected by the alignment of the sidewalk, and that was one of the arguments made in the exception request submitted by the applicant's agent, that that could be expensive if it required relocation. You can also see we're dealing with some slope coming up. Skyline is what you see on the left side of the screen. I have a couple of reviews just to kind of show. So here's looking down Skyline Drive and showing the frontage in that area. And you can see across the street, across Humboldt Hill, there is sidewalk in the vicinity, but it's on the opposite side of Humboldt. And then here, once again, this is looking down Humboldt Hill Road.


7:23 p.m.

showing the sidewalks that are the area where the sidewalk would be installed should it be required. So looking at this area a little closer, you can see the edges of the Country Club Estates subdivision there and where the parcel is located. And then looking at the vicinity of it, so once again, up towards the top of the screen, you can see the parcel. What I've done is I've outlined the areas where sidewalk exists at this time, and this was an exhibit in the staff report. The green is to show a feature that they're calling kind of a multi-use pathway. It's not a formal grade difference. It doesn't have a curb. It's more of an extension of the shoulder of the right-of-way, but it is identified in transportation planning documents as a pathway, and I can speak personally that it is used by people in the subdivision. But you can see on the east side, so looking towards the top of the screen, that's east, down at the bottom of the screen west, no parcels on the east side currently have, sidewalks in the interior of the subdivision, whereas on the...


7:24 p.m.

Westside, they do. And the reason for that is essentially that you can see in the colorization of these, those are all different subdivisions that were occurred at different times. The subdivision where the parcel's located was approved in 1952. The next subdivision occurred in 1953, 57, 59, 63, and then later, 83 and 94. So it's not a coincidence that the later subdivisions included improvements as part of the build-out. It's just a matter of the timing of these earlier subdivisions in the Humboldt Hill area. So looking at, you know, the sort of consequence of the lack of sidewalks in the vicinity, the reason for staff's recommendation in the report and in supporting the exception request was that it was unlikely that we would see a network of sidewalks given the magnitude of the deficit. It's an area that's really completely devoid of sidewalks, but for the limited ones that occur on Humboldt Hill Road. And so it's a matter of the timing of these earlier subdivisions in the Humboldt Hill area. And, you know, it's about 309 parcels in total.


7:25 p.m.

that are currently in that camp. And of those, this is where we should clarify. I think in the staff report, we made it seem like subdivision was unlikely, but having looked closer at SB 9, we can see that, and part of the reason why we said it was unlikely is because there's the little statement, fault runs through the subdivision, and would ordinarily, prior to these changes in state law, require a fault evaluation report for any subdivision, which is a pretty cost-prohibitive requirement. And now, looking closer at the language of the law, it's pretty clear that as long as the future development is subject to seismic safety requirements that are already built into the building code, that a subdivision can occur under those urban lot split provisions. So actually, there could be a lot of subdivisions in this area, but they would have to comply with the standard requirements that would be improvements along the frontage. And I think that's where we should focus at this point. So you can see here, most of these parcels,


7:26 p.m.

eligible for resubdivision, whether that would actually occur is still speculative. And so I guess what I wanted to focus on, before I move on to the next slide, is that the frontage improvement requirements that are being suggested by Public Works would be standard for any urbanized area. Their position is always the same. They try to be consistent about requiring sidewalks wherever the conditions are meant to be an urbanized environment, which for them is anything that has parcel sizes under an acre. And I should say that there's been, there was some back and forth. Commissioner Curiazzi wrote to us yesterday, and we had some back and forth. But the lion's share of the conversation with Public Works was about when sidewalks are required. And they can be required outside of a subdivision. They can be required of just a building permit. But as you probably know, building permits for accessory dwelling units are, under state law, prohibited from requiring that type of improvement. So it's a question of, how do we do that? And I think that's a really important question. It would really be mostly subdivision that would


7:27 p.m.

generate this type of a frontage improvement in the Humboldt Hill area. So that's why I'm focusing on the future development potential in this slide. But Public Works is essentially holding the line. They've been consistent historically to say that we recommend sidewalks wherever it's an urbanized environment, even if it's just going to be the one sidewalk, because the belief is incrementally it will provide for potential build-out, even if it takes years. And every sidewalk is reducing the overall burden on the taxpayer should that ever be tackled with a larger fund. So we've looked at it, and we thought that the exception request findings could be made. I'm going to move through this slide. It's similar to the project you saw earlier tonight. This is in an area where under CEQA, if you have an EIR that covers the area, you don't have to do subsequent environmental review. So the findings or exceptions that are listed in the staff report, that there has to be special circumstances or conditions, that the exception is necessary for the preservation and enjoyment of a substantial property right, and that granting it will not be detrimental to the public or insurance.


7:28 p.m.

to other property owners in the area. So we believe that the evidence is outlined in the staff report and resolution is there, mostly that there's really no sidewalks at all in this location, and the likelihood that they would come incrementally seems slim. It's not that public works does not support that, because it's not consistent with their approach of just uniformly requiring it of all development when meeting those tests. But ultimately, the discretion lies with the commission, and that's why this is here, and I want to just use that to kind of remind you that even if you deny the exception request today, the subdivision can proceed under the SB 9 provisions regardless, because that's a ministerial approval. It doesn't require your approval. So the real purpose of this coming to you tonight is for an exception to those frontage improvements. That's the basis for this. And with that, these are the suggested motions, but I'm certainly, before we get into that, open to any questions you might have. Do you have an opinion?


7:29 p.m.

I mean, you're adding hardscape and gutters and all that. If it could create even a drainage issue, because what we saw earlier, when you have permeable surface, your drainage may not be as great. If you just put one house with sidewalks, you know, where's the water going to go? You might create a bigger problem. And what we're not recommending is that the commission deviate from standard conditions that always require the developer to address localized drainage concerns. Those are in there, and they're completely intact. And public works, as I think the director mentioned earlier, in the post-tentative map approval stage, always has a back-and-forth with the developer on hammering out those details. So really the only thing that would be on the table tonight would be to remove the installation of sidewalks within the right-of-way frontage. But dealing with drainage issues. One of the things that I think is pointed out in the staff report, public works still, even if the commission chooses to waive the sidewalk requirements, wants to make sure that


7:30 p.m.

the developer and subsequent owners maintain the frontage along Humboldt Hill so that it doesn't interfere with drainage and it doesn't interfere with passing of people because of that green stripe that you saw. That's still a walkway for people even if it doesn't have a sidewalk. So does that answer your question? Not really. Maybe you understand what I'm saying. If you only put in a small stretch of sidewalk and gutters, you're creating water that's going to flow on a hard surface to the next neighbor and not be permeable on your property. So unless you have a complete sidewalk all the way down the road with drains and it's all designed to work properly, you might be creating even more of a problem for your neighbor because it's not going to drain into your soil. It's going to pass down to the next person. I see your point, and maybe the director wants to. Yeah. So that is something that does get looked at as part of any improvement plan. You may require. I recall that we worked on a.


7:31 p.m.

subdivision in mckinleyville and part of the concern there was that that whole street up until that point had curb gutter and sidewalk and the curb gutter and sidewalk was not across the frontage of that particular parcel and so the water ran down that gutter and then emptied onto that parcel and the concern was is that as the water passed that site that what it's really doing is now conveying it to the next parcel down and and that was developed and that may create a flooding problem for the the house that was there that's what i'd be i mean i love sidewalks because i'm like to walk and not fall down but if you only had one little stretch of it i think it could create a problem unless that's really been looked at well i i would say in this particular case that there's not that much sidewalk much additional impervious certainly not that much sidewalk but there's not that much additional impervious certainly not that much additional impervious certainly not that much additional impervious here to really create a significant difference


7:32 p.m.

in terms of runoff. The water that's coming down the hill is already coming down the hill, so it won't change that. I should also disclose that I did a drive-by of this project as well. Any other questions of commissioners, staff? If not, we'll open a public hearing, at which point the applicant, if they're here, or can approach the podium. If you have an applicant, if you'd like to speak and address the commission, you're welcome to. And you have up to 10 minutes. Okay, I'm the applicant's agent, Michael Pulley. I'm the surveyor with Points West that prepared the tentative map. So thank you, Commission, for your time tonight. I don't know if you can bring back up the tentative map for me.


7:33 p.m.

But while you're bringing that up, I want to say a lot of thanks to Steve Lazar for the analysis that he gave you on the sidewalks out here. In the exception request I wrote you, I kind of detailed the same thing. It's like we've got just a couple patches of sidewalk, most of them on the western side, which if there was going to be a cohesive walking path, it would make more sense for the improvements to be on that side of the road than to require this. One of the reasons I wanted you to look at the tentative map is there is already concrete curb and gutter along the frontage of Humboldt Hill, and you can see that it wraps around onto the skyline drive. There's two drain inlets in that area already. So to your concerns, Commissioner O'Neill, there's not going to be really any. I mean, the drainage impacts would be taken care of already by the concrete curb and gutter. Unfortunately, construction of the sidewalk would require removing or altering those concrete curb and gutter. Those drain inlets as well as the concrete retaining wall kind of, you know, at the.


7:34 p.m.

South end comes into what would be the right-of-way where the sidewalk would be constructed, so that would have to be demoed or altered in some way to create sidewalk in that area. And the other along Skyline Drive, where the frontage along Skyline Drive is, there's no sidewalks at all on Skyline Drive for its entire length. Any sidewalk that would be constructed there would be about a 12% to 15% grade, so it would be rather useless in my mind, and would take away from some off-street parking possibility there that currently exists. So I'm just asking that the commission, like Steve said, curb gutter sidewalk is a standard condition from Public Works, and I agree that curb gutter and sidewalk is usually an amenity that you want to see as part of a development. I have plenty of projects where we, you would not argue against curb gutter sidewalk. I...


7:35 p.m.

survey and design plenty of curb gutter sidewalk. But in this particular instance, I think it's pretty clear that the requirement for curb gutter sidewalk really doesn't make sense in this area and would make the development of this parcel much more costly, perhaps prohibitive for what he's going to get out of it. And again, like you saw previously with that other subdivision, we're basically creating two standalone parcels that can be sold and increasing that housing stock yet again. So thanks again for your time. A question. Yeah. On Skyline, you mentioned how steep, it's steep, the street itself, and then isn't, aren't the homes up, or is that property above the road? Yes. Yes. And is there, are there large trees growing in there, that section, or is that, it looked like it was pretty heavily landscaped, but I. There's, they're not. Trees, it's large, like shrub vegetation. Yeah. Okay. And it does.


7:36 p.m.

Still pretty steep up there to the property itself on the edge of Skyline. So that's where I pulled some slopes just to see what even a potential sidewalk would look like in there and came up with that 12 to 15 percent. Thank you. All right, thank you. No further questions at this time. Anybody else want to address the commission? Please come on up. I'm John Coy, property owner. Thank you for your time and for your great work and showing everything. I just want to say thank you for all you guys are doing. They're not trees, but the shrubs have been there since the 50s. They're this big around, and they're right in front of the property. We would lose all of that. All that would be torn out. You see the ring of brush and trees. I call them trees because they're 15, 20 feet tall. So all that would be torn out, and it would run into the sidewalk and run into Richard Miller's old house.


7:37 p.m.

daughter owns it now we did sidewalk just run into a dirt pile because it's everything on the upside is steep going down on the other side it's steep going down so try to put sidewalks in there you really it's you got the high side and the low side it would be it would be different than everything else there the way it's designed thank you all right thank you I don't see any other commenters in the room, and I don't see any hands up online. Mr. Pulley, you're representing the applicant, and I think that was the applicant, so I don't think a rebuttal is necessary. So I'll close the public hearing and bring it back to the commission. Mr. Kiarazi. Yeah, thanks for the discussion. I think I'll go into a little bit more detail, but I think what kind of.


7:38 p.m.

overarching perspective or where I'm coming from is that in general we're putting the development of this public infrastructure on property owners and we're intentionally taking an approach of piecemeal development and so we can see evidence of that in other properties, properties across the street and so other properties have put in this infrastructure. They have complied with the requirement and I think I'm struggling just in general with we've already taken a stance as a community and as the county of we're not doing publicly funded large projects to put in connected sidewalks. We're relying on a piecemeal approach to begin with. And then now we're being asked for exceptions to that piecemeal.


7:39 p.m.

approach. And I just, in general, I'm not really comfortable at setting that precedent. And walking through a bit more, we have three sort of items we're supposed to address when an exception is being brought. The first one is that there needs to be special circumstances. And I think generally the root of that argument was that there is no connectivity. And while I agree that a sidewalk sort of standing alone in front of the frontage property of one property with no connecting sidewalk on either side is not useful, or it has limited use, that's, again, the approach we've chosen to take as a community to fund this public infrastructure in the first place. The argument, I think, that there is unlikely to be development of frontage improvements on neighboring properties to help create that network. I don't completely


7:40 p.m.

I think in discussions with some emails with staff, there are other permittable actions that property owners can take, including additions of garages, if I understood that correctly, or other improvements to the house and the property. Subdivisions are not the only trigger for frontage improvement. And item two, or reason two that we have to address for an exemption is, you know, this is necessary for the property owner to enjoy their right as a property owner. And so they're arguing that this exception is necessary. I think, again, we're presented with a similar situation that we just had where they're improving the value of their property. And sometimes as a developer, you are required to... To put in some funding. And I just don't see that...


7:41 p.m.

an exception is necessary for their enjoyment of their property. And then part three, where we're supposed to say that the exception would not present a detrimental impact to the public. I think our whole reason for putting in this public infrastructure is for safety and public welfare. And we now know, after the 50s, that this is also for public health. And so, again, while I agree that a small stretch of sidewalk may make that a difficult argument, I'll just repeat for a third time or fourth time, that we're choosing to take that approach from the outset. For developing public property. So I guess I just don't really...


7:42 p.m.

I don't agree with the arguments that staff was made, nor for the representative, for the applicant. And I think overall, if we're going to agree to an exception here, that my preference is that that would be taken from a community perspective, rather than from we're going to grant exceptions for some property owners, and then there's going to be a rotation in commissioners, and then new commissioners won't necessarily agree. I think if we're going to argue that a sidewalk should only be on the west side, let's do that from a community perspective, and sort of create an expectation or an understanding for property owners down the road. Right. Like, we're going to grant exceptions for some property owners, and then there's going to be a rotation in commissioners, and then there's going to develop this property in this particular way. It's just, I don't.


7:43 p.m.

Addressing it through this piecemeal approach just doesn't quite make sense to me. The exceptions through a piecemeal approach. And then my last comment is I would say all of that really applies to Humboldt Hill Road. I think for Skyline Road, I agree the road was never constructed to allow walking in the first place. That's a tougher road to think about. And so, again, you know, I would be more open to waiving the exception for Skyline. However, I think it would also benefit that in general can we say or can the county say Skyline will not be under that particular requirement from Public Works should permits, you know, or subdivisions be requested in the future. Thank you. Any other comments? Mr. Mulder. So I have a little bit different approach.


7:44 p.m.

Looking at this, I feel that we're trying to provide affordable housing and by affordable housing we have development standards that we can make exceptions from. I heard testimony that it would cost, it would drive up the cost. There was a retaining wall and also there's elevation issues that would drive the cost up. So in my mind, I've read through that and then also hearing the testimony and then I'm like, okay, well that makes exception requests. It makes sense to, okay, now we can have affordable housing. Some people we've heard testimony of complaints about ADUs, but also I look at that as possible affordable housing. Now there's a smaller house, smaller square footage. So the likelihood of that house being sold or that lot being sold for a lower price is a lot higher. So I'm comfortable with allowing. This exception request because I feel.


7:45 p.m.

It goes towards our general plan and our goals to have affordable housing. And I also hear that walkability and stuff like that, there's been many a times up here where we've approved. And there's been many a times when we've also required, most notably in the McKinleyville area, where you look at, you know, there's sidewalks in some areas and no sidewalks in other areas. So, I mean, you could probably talk about this for days. But in this particular instance, I'm supportive of staff's recommendation. I have something to say. The Elmquist-Priolet fault causes a lot of shifting in the ground also. And if you start putting in sidewalks in that kind of area, you could, and especially if you're going to go, you know, several years in between this piece is done and this one's done. Five. Ten. You know, you could have a lot.


7:46 p.m.

lot of uplifting of concrete, which could be even worse than walking on, you know, down the side of the road because I like to trip and fall. I do that quite a bit. And I would say in because of that, I'd be hesitant to put sidewalks in because they could end up being a trip and fall kind of situation as they shift. Whereas your, your ground is not going to be a biggest problem. So that's just, I'm a little familiar with that earthquake fault because I've done some studies in that area. Thank you. Commissioner McFarland. I just want to point out that on a previous project we heard tonight, we talked about that development often comes with an associated cost, right? And that is putting in this public infrastructure. And so I, I just want to caution us on taking one stance on something and then taking a completely different stance on, on a permit. Thank you.


7:47 p.m.

Right after I mean generally as these projects have come to us previously since I've been on the commission We have supported the addition of sidewalks for the community benefit And so I definitely open to looking at you know the site specific necessity And if in that if the site specific You know conditions require a community approach like was suggested then I think That makes a lot of sense like for example, if all of skyline Is not going to see sidewalks then this shouldn't be coming up again So I do think a consistent approach from the commission is needed Good and I as I did indicate I did drive by this and I did drive through the skyline neighborhood and it's Some neighborhoods are conducive to sidewalks some just aren't I Think that this kind of rural residential neighborhood that skyline represents


7:48 p.m.

It would be difficult to have sidewalks in there, and I think it actually, you know, it's narrow, it's deep, it's up and down, and the houses are set back. It's actually kind of sometimes nicer to see some of these neighborhoods without so much hardscape and infrastructure, but that was just my observation when I was out there. On the Humboldt Hill Road area, also there's a sidewalk across the street, and there really isn't a sidewalk on this side, although down the hill a ways, there's what I would call a widened, paved shoulder, if you will, demarcation. So it's also a steep section of Humboldt Hill, so I don't know that there's a lot of sidewalk traffic there in that area. There's probably some, or bicycle traffic, whatever, but I didn't see any when I was out there. So... Personally, can...


7:49 p.m.

also support staff's recommendation in this case. Yes, Commissioner West. So I'm hearing from Commissioner McFarland and Commissioner Curiazzi a need for sort of a cohesive idea of what the community is going to look like in terms of sidewalks. And I'm curious from staff's perspective what tools we really have at our disposal on the commission to do that. Because I agree with that theory, but I don't know how much that we can really apply that in this decision. Like a long-term plan? Yeah, it is a matter of developing some kind of plan for the neighborhood. And you can't really do that from a proposal that's right in front of you. And so part of the struggle here, and Commissioner Mulder captured this correctly, is that it has been the practice of public works.


7:50 p.m.

to recommend sidewalks, but then giving the commission the option to not require them. And so there have been many, many, many exceptions granted since I've been here. Perhaps the last few instances sidewalks have been required. What I think we would recommend and what we're trying to do is take a rational approach to the circumstance and the situation. Is it beneficial to have sidewalks? Yes. Is it expensive to put in sidewalks? Yes. Yes. I think something that perhaps Commissioner O'Neill brought up in the last meeting is that if there were an effort, if there were an effort to install sidewalks here in Napa,


7:51 p.m.

It's not even desirable based upon the circumstances. It would be easier to do that as part of one poor, to just put in all sidewalks and have everybody have the same responsibility in that if they were going to do some kind of Prop 218 effort to fund that. But it's unlikely that people would want to pay for that, really, on that street. I mean, you could disagree with that, perhaps. Do they ever consider walking paths? Like, you know, they're putting in a path in between Arcata and Eureka. It's not a concrete sidewalk, but a walking path is in some of these more rural areas. One of the things that this commission has done in the past is to require kind of an improved surface to keep people out of the mud, but not actually pour a sidewalk along that area where the sidewalk would be. Because I could see that on Humboldt Hill.


7:52 p.m.

road that that could be an advantage along that road because that's a main road but not a sidewalk concrete that might crack you know if this ground shifts who's going to maintain it well the maintenance it's this the county road so this gets back to so if they put in a walking path though with the county maintain that or is that acceptable that's that's part of the struggle i think the public works department this is a public facility for them and so they are looking to have the facility improved to the the normal standard for an urban street I'm just going to address a few points. I think I wanted to just reiterate that we did just


7:53 p.m.

require the installation of drainage for a previous application for arguably all of the same reasons that we're arguing to not put in sidewalk. So I feel like there's quite a contradiction there. I think sort of pointing out that we didn't see anyone walking or biking in an area that doesn't have facilities for walking and biking isn't an argument to not put in facilities for walking and biking. And I also want to point out again that there are neighbors immediately in the vicinity that did put in the cost to put in this infrastructure. And also the neighboring property adjacent just to the north where that retaining wall kind of continues onto the neighboring property, it looks like it was installed and maintained in a way to facilitate this. And so that property owner took that effort. And so why should this neighboring property.


7:54 p.m.

receive an exception for that. Thank you. So are you amenable to only having it on one of the roads, or do you want it on both the roads? I am amenable to granting the exception on Skyline with that comment, again, of if there's a way to take sort of a higher level or a community-based approach to that. Commissioner Mulder. So I apologize. I forgot my notes, so I'm diving back in here. I look at things site-specific. The hearing we had earlier, there was evidence to support that we needed the drainage. There was evidence to support the sidewalk. Here, I feel in what I read in the staff report, I don't have my notes in front of me, but there was evidence to support cost prohibitive and then also the other exceptions to grant this waiver. I feel that, you know, in this county,


7:55 p.m.

We want to ask for development. We want to ask people to come in and then they come before us and they ask for an exception that has the findings and if it's not approved it may make the project unbuildable. So then we say hey come in and build but then we don't grant the exceptions allowed under code. So we're saying don't build but then come in and build. So it's challenging for me. I don't believe there's lines outside the building and planning department every time I've gone there lately that's usually you're one person ahead of you at the counter. It's not lines like when the cannabis industry came on there is lines out the door. I feel and maybe I'm wrong and I'm going to ask. I'm going to ask staff to correct me that we're kind of in a slump for housing and the county is kind of trying to it would be good for the county to meet its arena numbers.


7:56 p.m.

to promote housing and promote subdivisions of this nature. So I just, if staff could clarify possibly that my interpretations are correct. We are behind in our RENA obligations for sure. So to piggyback on that, if projects that meet the requirements for these exceptions are continuously denied, would that negatively affect or potentially negatively affect RENA numbers? I wouldn't go that far. Wouldn't go that far? Yeah. Because some people absolutely do like to live in developments that have sidewalks, have places to walk, and like that amenity. So I wouldn't draw that hard of a line. And this is a situation where I think was pointed out, it was developed in the 50s. It has that vibe to it.


7:57 p.m.

Many of those subdivisions at that time did not have sidewalks. Some people like that. I guess I'll go back a little bit. If developers or potential developers see it as possibly challenging and a little too cumbersome to continue developing, I feel, and this is my opinion, I feel that it could deter people from coming forward. For developments. And I will say I still hear out there in other rural areas that it's still easier for people to develop without coming forward because of the roadblocks in place. Just to do a simple AOB addition for an AOB house, you could be $10,000 just in engineering and permit fees. So food for thought.


7:58 p.m.

Whatever you spend to develop, you're going to pass on to the person you sell the property to, so it goes towards affordability of housing also. The developer is not going to just eat it. He's going to pass it on to the buyer. And then who can afford it? I mean, I built an ADU, and I don't even want to tell you how much it costs. And it doesn't have sidewalks, and it doesn't have a driveway. You know, so. To create a sidewalk in space that's not.


7:59 p.m.

and connect to any future sidewalk in the foreseeable future or in a neighborhood that doesn't have any sidewalks. So I see them as completely different, and I don't have any concern about making that distinction between the two projects that came forward tonight. Yeah, I appreciate all of the discussion up here and putting the time towards this. I think, thank you, Commissioner Scavdahl, I think my rebuttal to that would be how did that piece of sidewalk to connect to get there in the first place? And it was because a requirement was put on whoever developed that property. A larger new development that came in, put in that first piece, that piece of sidewalk. You're correct. It wasn't individual single property owners that came along that did that initial one. But. It did get put in that way. I think we've hammered this one.


8 p.m.

I was just wondering, the one thing we haven't discussed was Director Ford mentioned the improved walking path that isn't a sidewalk but is still an improved path. So I just wanted to bring that up again. Is that something that would be amenable? Is that something that is not amenable? I just don't feel like we've discussed that part. For me, it feels very arbitrary. I mean, it doesn't change my opinion on drainage being more important than walking. I think they're both important. So my understanding, and I'm going to ask staff to correct me, the exception request in this area is to make a pathway, a retaining wall, and mature vegetation that was installed. In the 50s, it would have to be removed. And that's the way I read the staff report.


8:01 p.m.

And if I'm misinterpreting something, I would ask for a little bit of help here, please. My interpretation is that we still have the condition that the landscape... The question was directed to staff. Can I have staff's response, please? So, just to be clear, you're asking whether the... Without the sidewalks, it would necessitate removal of vegetation? If we've heard a couple commissioners say maybe walking path instead of a sidewalk, my interpretation of what I read, and I don't have my notes in front of me, is it would still require the retaining wall and mature vegetation to be possibly taken out. Is that correct or not correct? Yeah, I would just speak to the testimony we heard from their surveyor, which suggested that in certain areas along Humble Hill Road, that might be required for a pathway of any sort, regardless of whether it was a sidewalk. Okay. Okay, Commissioner Kiarazi.


8:02 p.m.

I read that there's still a condition to remove the landscaping on Humboldt Hillside, even if this exception is granted. And I was trying to speak to that earlier. They want to make sure that there's unobstructed pathway of any sort, but whether it's improved or not, they don't want landscaping to prevent pedestrian travel along the edge of the right-of-way. So in that case, is Humboldt Hill Road paved over to the retaining wall? Not 100%. I think we have a slide that shows it. I think there's a grassy shoulder. Okay. We're trying to pull it up right now. If we could share the screen one more.


8:03 p.m.

Pull that up. So hopefully folks can see it's a little dark, but you can see that there is a curb at the edge of the paved surface, but there's grassy area that would still be within the right-of-way. I'm coming back. I just want to, I think, quickly comment on where I stand on this, just so we all kind of, I think I'm the only one who hasn't really said. This one's a tough one for me. I do really resonate with why.


8:04 p.m.

ability and wanting sidewalks. I think for me this one comes down to the sidewalk on the other side of the street and as a pedestrian like I hear what you're saying that like it starts somewhere and if you don't start with one like the next one's not going to come but I think in this instance I see the sidewalk on the other side of the street and if this property were on the other side of the street I would come a different way but I lean towards granting the exception in this case. I call for a motion. I'll make a motion to adopt the resolution attachment one, which says the following, finds the project consistent with development density and policies established by an existing community plan and general plan for which an EIR was certified, and that no additional environmental review


8:05 p.m.

is required per section 15183 of the state CEQA guidelines and make all the required findings for approval of the partial map subdivision and exception request and approves the COI minor subdivision and exception request to frontage improvements as recommended by staff subject to the conditions of approval of attachment 1A. I'll second that. I have a motion and a second. Any discussion? Could we have a roll call vote, please? Commissioner Scavdahl? Yes. Commissioner O'Neill? Yes. Commissioner Curiazzi? No. Commissioner McFarlane? No. Commissioner West? Yes. Commissioner Mulder? Yes. Motion carries. Can I make a recommendation? I think that a recommendation to Public Works that they take a look at that community because it is such an old,


8:06 p.m.

communities older older than me in some cases and that they look at a walkability plan for that community that we could follow so that we could be consistent in building you know sidewalks or pathways or something for that area in the future and be consistent so that you would build infrastructure that makes sense and not have it just be haphazard I mean they may say well we don't have the money to do that or maybe they can have an intern look at it or something but at least if we made that recommendation for an older community like that because there is a lot of people up there and you know walking is good and walking on a surface that you know is safe is important too and it may be that it's a trail system you know it's not full-on curbs and gutters and all that because of the the environment up there but just pick it up you


8:07 p.m.

A great idea. But you hit on two things. Is money and land use. Division of Public Works currently does not have an engineer. And that's fine. But if you have a project on a list and something comes up that it fits and there's funding available, then you can go after it. If not, but at least we made that request. Is that something the commission wants to vote on and give direction to us to forward that recommendation? Personally, I feel we have a lot of things coming our way and funding shortages within the county. But I don't see the budget and I don't make those decisions. It's a good idea. I'm not directing them to do it. I'm saying if they have the resources. I'm not saying you have to have it done by, you know, take it away from some other budget. But sometimes funding. Funding pops up and it could.


8:08 p.m.

Do we have a Humboldt Hill community plan? If we were going to go down that pathway, that's where I would head. It's through a community planning process of some sort. Commissioner McFarland? I was going to say the same. Is there like a hybrid option where the county could put the call out to communities that if they want to form groups for neighborhoods to make recommendations of the consistent view that they see, and then that would take some of the burden of the recommendation off the county? I don't know if there's some hybrid option. You should probably, if you want to talk about this, agendize this. But I will say that what that does is creates an immense amount of work because then you have to receive the input from the community. You have to evaluate it. You have to do the engineering work on it. I mean, I don't want to be defensive. But public works is scraping by to try to maintain.


8:09 p.m.

In Rhodes, it's obvious. You would have to get a planning grant of some sort if there is funding available for it, because this would cost you quite a bit of money. I'm not suggesting that they take it out of their existing budget and jump right on it and get it done by next week. I'm suggesting that it just be put on notice that it would be something to be considered in the future if funding becomes available for that. And it may not be their existing funding stream, but some other fund that comes up. Some of those funds do come through the state. Thank you. I want to move on to the next item. Maybe we can, if there's more on this, we can take it up later on. These people have been waiting patiently. Can I make a very quick comment? Sounds like you're going to. I would support agendizing this discussion topic to give a bit more guidance to staff. Thank you. Thank you.


8:10 p.m.

Okay, can we move to item 10, Department of Fish and Wildlife Conditional Use Permit for the Cannibal Island Restoration Project? And at the risk of redundancy, I'll just say this one more time, since GHD appears to have done a lot of work on this project, that I'm no longer affiliated with GHD in any way, shape, or form as an employee or owner, and have not been for some time. Thank you. Hello, I'm Portia Salcedo, the assigned planner for the California Department of Fish and Wildlife Conditional Use Permit for the restoration of the California Department of Fish and Wildlife.


8:11 p.m.

of Cannibal Island and the surrounding area within the Eel River Estuary. The project is, the site is located approximately three miles west of the town of Lolita, at the westernmost extent of the Eel River Delta and estuary approximately one mile inland northeast of the Eel River mouth and the north side of the 3000 block of Cannibal Road. There are 21 parcels involved in the project. The project is approximately 795 acres, so agricultural exclusive natural resources within the Humboldt Bay Area Plan. The conditional use permit is required in this area because the wetland restoration and habitat.


8:12 p.m.

Management are conditionally permitted uses in these zoning districts. The project components will include removal of an abandoned two-story residential structure, deepening 5,000 linear feet of existing dikes, and removal of failed culverts, and currently separate full and muted tidal areas. This reconnection of full tidal area exchange to approximately 500 acres to formal tidal marsh habitat and construction of intertidal lagoons with tidal marsh ridges and intertidal channels to create diverse tidal habitats. Inset channel rock grade control will be placed along 20-foot sections of the channel at the existing road crossing along the Sinistraro. Lane to provide passive management to the tidal...


8:13 p.m.

Construction of new earthen setbacks for the levee, approximately 6,000 linear feet long, clipped with up to two gated culverts to separate tidal wetlands from agricultural lands. The elevation of the existing road for approximately 2,500 feet and an installation of up to four graded culverts. The relocation of approximately 200,000 cubic yards of excavated sediment to be reused within the project area. Treatment and removal of dense flowered core grass. Improvement of public access and visitor experience and all post-construction management to maintain project objectives. So the primary goal of the Cannibal Island Restoration Project is to restore and expand the natural environment. The National Estuarian Functional...


8:14 p.m.

and processes that promote recovery of the habitat for native fish, invertebrates, wildlife, plant species compatible with surrounding work lands and public access. The proposed project, including watershed management, fish and wildlife habitat management, and wetland restoration is consistent with the uses allowed under the Eel River Area Plan and with uses that are allowed in environmentally sensitive habitat areas or ESHA. The proposed project would not conflict with the Eel River Area Plan because management for watershed and management for fish and wildlife habitat are considered compatible with agricultural operations under the Eel River Area Plan. These impacts of the restoration actions have been determined to be less than significant with the identified mitigation measures implemented. Which are covered in the staff report.


8:15 p.m.

So the recommendations for staff is to find the project, or from staff, is to find the project exempt from further environmental review present to Section 21080.56 of the state CEQA guidelines, which provides a statutory exemption for certain restoration projects, which is also called SERP. Make all the required findings for the conditional use permit, and then suggest that you approve the restoration, the resolution, sorry, approving the California Department of Fish and Wildlife conditional use permit subject to the conditions of approval. And so that's it, and we're available for questions, and I think there was a question. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Any questions from the commission of staff? Is there only one house out there? That's the only one that they're, yeah, a single story. How old is that house? Um. So. The process. You'll be able, it'll be slice. Lei a. Yes. All right. And what, what risk can I have for my project by a house that I think is worth for? Simply put, we're impossible. And so what would pay for? Of stainless steel, what do you mean by transferable, that is judicial, does that mean this is missile? That's what we're talking about here. That's an iron conscious mind.


8:16 p.m.

I actually don't know. Look. Commissioner O'Neill, I'd suggest that we move on. We'll look, but we're going to have to dig into those. It's not really. I worked out in Table Bluff and I heard stories about some of the people from the rancheria having to go out there and rescue families when it flooded. And it was pretty harrowing, some of those stories. So I would suggest that there shouldn't be any homes out there. Yeah, this is definitely going. So it might be one of those. So we'll open public hearing. I don't know if there's a representative of the applicant here. I see online. OK, so Mr. Ray. If you have any comments or would like to address the commission, please do.


8:17 p.m.

Thanks for listening to my testimony. I actually don't have additional testimony at this time, but I'm available to answer any questions that arise from the commissioners for that. I'm having a little bit of a hard time hearing you, but I think you said you're available if there's questions after other comments, and we'll give you that opportunity at the end. So thank you. Is there anybody in the audience that has a question or would like to address the commission? Please approach the podium. You have three minutes. First of all, thank you for being here and taking time for everything you do for the county to make it a safe place to live. My name is Peter Baer. I own property right next to this project. I lived out there at Cannibal Island for 16 years. I'm now living at... And Alton. And I have basically three concerns about this.


8:18 p.m.

I am a farmer and a rancher and I decry the loss of pasture and I was wondering if Fish and Game had any could mitigate that by opening up some other ground say on Cockrobin Island that they have. The second one would probably be bigger than that would be the dike that they're proposing along the road will definitely hinder the when it's flooding it will definitely hinder the water from reaching the ocean and it will back up on my land on my neighbor's property there that will be a I was wondering if they had enough or if they had taken that into consideration because I've also rescued people from out there on Cockrobin Island in the 95 flood and it gets pretty deep. you


8:19 p.m.

And the third one is the road getting there, all the construction equipment and all the traffic that will be on that road in the future if it's going to be used for what they propose it to be used for. The road needs to be repaired, needs to be built up, needs to be repaired. That's all I have. Thank you very much. Thank you. Mr. Ray, I'll give you an opportunity to respond to those comments if you'd like. Yeah, thank you. So, great questions. I appreciate those as well. So, with regard to the first one, the loss of pasture, at this time, California Fish and Wildlife does not have any plans to open up additional pasture. As a function of this project. However, the pasture. The pasture for the land on the San Pablo Island Wildlife Area is not currently being used as pasture.


8:20 p.m.

Yeah, it isn't suitable at the current time for pasture because of the tidy influence that is there. And additionally, the parcels that we're working with neighboring landowners to purchase that are within that project area boundary, the portions of those parcels that we're hoping to acquire and are working towards that with the landowners are also not good quality pasture at the current time because of those tidal emissions. And so the sections of the private landowners parcels that we won't be acquiring will be defending a little bit better with some of those levies. And so we think the actual quality of the pasture in that section of Pampo Island, outside of the project area, is actually going to improve. So what I'm specifically talking about is Miss Hansen's property and Lester Hedrisini's properties.


8:21 p.m.

will be divided as we purchase portions of those. So the portions that currently aren't very good pasture will be retained as wetland, and then the portions that currently function well as pasture will be protected further with setback levy. With regards to the levy and the gates, and also the road raising in terms of floodwaters, that's an excellent question. We have considered those things. The designs aren't finalized for that yet. We're at about 65% design, but it's on our mind, and we've spoken to some of the adjacent landowners, and we happen to include you in that discussion, Mr. Baird, as well, to get a sense of some of your concerns a bit further. But in short, we have considered that. We think that the gates we're putting in place are gonna be...


8:22 p.m.

to convey that water across the landscape. But again, that is, those plans aren't finalized yet, and that's going to be a significant part of the next phase of this plan. And then with the sort of the final, I think the final question was about improved, or excuse me, about additional traffic usage. The impact to Cannibal Island Road, I think, was the third question. Yes. So with regard to that, I think that that's absolutely right. I think that, you know, as part of this project, we plan to improve the road for a section. And, you know, I don't think that CDFW considers itself responsible for considering for improving the entirety of the Cannibal Island Road. But we're interested potentially in having, honestly, with the county about the section that...


8:23 p.m.

It goes beyond the cannibal island wildlife area and how to the craft farm, public usage area to think about the food and stuff. Thank you. I have a question. Yes. So as a part of the planning for this project, was there any community meetings to listen to the community's concerns or to mitigate them? Can I just close the public hearing? Yeah, you can close public comment. Yeah, close the public comment. Okay, thank you. So your question is to staff. Yeah. So that would be a question to the applicant, to CDFW. So this is the first public hearing that has been associated with the county's action. Typically with something like this, they would meet with, you know, have a smaller meeting with some of the surrounding landowners and listen to their concerns.


8:24 p.m.

before it would come to us. And so that's my question to the person on the phone. So we are not aware of any meetings that have happened. Again, that might be a question if you're willing to reopen the hearing to at least allow the applicant to answer that question. I can't imagine the applicant hasn't met with the property owners that are affected by the project. And you don't need to reopen public comment to ask the applicant a question. You can just do that. Mr. Ray, the question on the floor is, have you met with the adjacent property owners prior to this hearing? Yes. We've met with the adjacent property owners, and we also actually have plans for some more in-depth community meetings, too. As we get into this final stage of the planning and the design of the project, we're going to be looking at the planning and the design of the project. We're going to be looking at the planning and the design of the project. So they're all saying... Thank you.


8:25 p.m.

getting additional funding to help us do that and part of that planning phase will involve all the conversations with um local randoms so is he saying yes they did but they plan on having additional meetings does that need to be one of the conditions that they have additional an additional meeting as they get closer or do we just say that's going to happen i guess it would depend on what you're trying to accomplish with the condition i mean it's it's great to have meetings but sometimes meetings for the sake of meetings i don't know why there's three concerns brought up at our meeting if they've already had meetings and considered those concerns maybe the question should be to the person who asked the questions well i i think i would maybe redirect the question to say are those things that the commission wants to


8:26 p.m.

That's just part of the conditional use permit. Because obviously the member of the public has concerns, and even the applicant, if I heard him correctly, indicated that those were good questions. Right. And so it would be appropriate for the Planning Commission to ensure that those issues were looked at and addressed. That's what I was trying to say. Thank you. Commissioner Moldar. So I'm looking at this, the coastal development permit, so the commission could add extra conditions of approval if they heard testimony they saw fit. Is that correct? That is correct. So the coastal commission will be processing the coastal development permit. We can't really speak to what that process is going to look like. They will determine that. But presumably,


8:27 p.m.

If there are hearings, that would be another opportunity for that to happen. So the way I read everything is all this construction material is going to access along that roadway. That's a decent amount of material to be moved, so there's going to be decent-sized equipment. If they walk an excavator, steel-tracked excavator, across the road that's already deteriorated, I've seen it happen in other places within the county. A deteriorated road becomes more deteriorated. So it sounded like the applicant said they're going to improve this 2,500-foot stretch, but they didn't have any plans of anything else. So I have one member of the public that's in agriculture. It's something we support in this county. So just want to flag that as something the commission might think, think about.


8:28 p.m.

This is a governmental agency, so things might be different, but there's still an agency. I misunderstood that question maybe, or maybe I didn't, but I thought that the traffic was the traffic that was going to occur after the project was done. But I also agree with what you brought up, because I think I've seen that happen also. But I'm not sure. I thought what you were trying to address was that the people that would be coming down there more frequently now because it's a recreation area as opposed to what it was previously. Both. Both? Okay. Yep. I think we heard there were three, the loss of pasture, and we heard from Mr. Ray that they're not going to mitigate by creating new pasture, but they are. Okay. Defending and improving adjacent pastures by...


8:29 p.m.

Creating this project and preventing, I think it's saltwater intrusion onto the pasture, so they're doing that. There was a concern that the dike would hinder water flow, and the response was no, it won't, because there are going to be culverts and floodgates there. There is a section of road that they're going to repair, but I think there is a concern that this project, in my opinion, should leave Cannibal Island Road in a condition equal to or better than it exists today at the completion of the project. So it would be detrimental to the neighborhood or the people along Cannibal Island Road if the construction equipment, the accesses and the contractors building this project leaves Cannibal Island. I think that's the worst condition on the road and the worst condition it is today. I agree with that concern.


8:30 p.m.

I would be supportive of a motion that included that. To piggyback on that, I would hope a governmental agency such as CDFW would not want to leave a roadway creating more discharge than it was because of their construction activities. So I would hope they would hold themselves to the same standard they hold everyone else to. So hopefully someone else makes a motion this time. I mean, I'm happy. I'm generally very supportive of the project and appreciative of the work CDFW does. So I'm happy to make a motion to approve the project as proposed with the amendment that the road will be left in a condition of at least the quality it is now. We can work on that language of an appropriate quality. And then. I just said equal to or better than. Yep, that's fine.


8:31 p.m.

Do we have a motion? Second? Are we going to include or just assume that there would be additional meetings with the adjoining landowners as the plans become more refined? I personally feel like if they're meeting with property owners and plan to continue, especially as they're acquiring property, I feel comfortable leaving them to do that on their own. But if the commission feels that we need to add that, I'm amenable. I guess we could just take their word for it. There's a motion on the table, and I will second that motion. We have a motion and a second. Any other discussion? Roll call vote, please. Thank you. Commissioner Scavdahl.


8:32 p.m.

Yes. Commissioner O'Neill? Yes. Commissioner Mulder? Yes. Commissioner Curiazzi? Yes. Commissioner West? Yes. Commissioner McFarland? Yes. Thank you. Motion carries. Thank you. I think that concludes items removed from consent. We have a report from the director this evening. Just a couple things, make it really fast, is that the climate action plan EIR review period is closing on Monday. And we'll be putting together the FEIR over the course of May. And trying to get the final EIR back out on the street with any revisions to the regional climate action plan. Late May. Late May with the intention of being in front of the commission.


8:33 p.m.

in June. So we're also putting on the street, hopefully middle of next week, the town center EIR. So that will be coming at you as well. Okay. Should be a busy summer. Yep. Thank you. Sure. Commissioner West. I was just curious. I was thinking about it as we were reviewing our cannabis permits earlier. This commission at one point discussed trellis netting, monofilament netting, and asking the supervisors to look at some changes to the cannabis ordinance. Has that? Actually, we, I think, believe that there is sufficient latitude to just start that back with you. And so we'll just be bringing the ordinance back to you. And I think the planner who was assigned to it has been a little caught up in some other things. But we'll be focusing on that shortly.


8:34 p.m.

Okay. Great. Thank you. Commissioners, anything else to discuss this evening? No. Meeting adjourned. See you April 17th, those of you that can be here. So I have a, I wanted to ask you a question. I want to ask you a question. I want to ask you a question. I don't know if you can hear me. Okay.