Humboldt County Planning Commission
Thursday, June 26, 2025
The agenda


6:03 p.m.

Thank you. Thank you. We'll open the Planning Commission meeting and we'll start with a salute to the flag. of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible.


6:04 p.m.

With liberty and justice for all. If we can take roll, please. Yes. Commissioner Scavdahl? Here. Commissioner Levy? Here. Commissioner O'Neill? Here. Commissioner West? Here. Commissioner Curiazzi? Here. Commissioner McFarland? Here. Commissioner Mulder is absent. Thank you. Thank you. Director Ford, do we have any agenda modifications this evening? No modifications this evening. Thank you. At this point, we'll take public comment on non-agenda items. This is when members of the public can address the commission on items that are not on tonight's agenda but are pertinent.


6:05 p.m.

to the commission's jurisdiction and we'll start with members in the room and then I'll go to anybody that's online on zoom so please you have three minutes hi my name is sunshine sarasata I live in red crest in homes flat and I just wanted to support I did hear something that there was maybe an amendment to the ordinance for micro business and I'm I'm definitely in support of that anything that we can do to make it easier to get a micro business would be very very helpful but what I'm here for today is to ask that we also add another amendment to the ordinance and that is is that ag exclusive that it it doesn't matter the size of the parcel if you live on ag exclusive when I looked in red at the definition of ag exclusive zoning it says in there that actually having an agriculture


6:06 p.m.

operation comes even before a residence. So living there and not being able to have an agricultural operation in cannabis doesn't feel like it is in accordance to that definition. And also, if you look at it too from the perspective of the state, the CDFA considers cannabis to be an agricultural product. And if this was any other crop, it would be principally permitted because this is ag land. So with that, and also perhaps even the 30-foot setback, that could possibly be exempt on ag exclusive. I would also consider that too. And so that's why I came here today. Thank you.


6:07 p.m.

Thank you. Is there any other members of the public that would like to address the commission this evening? And Director Ford, I don't know if there's anybody online. I see no hands. Okay, thank you. I see nobody else, so I'm going to close public comment. Director Ford, I don't know if there's anything that you want to say in response to the comments that we heard this evening, or just take that into the record. Take it into the record. We are working on an amendment to the ordinance, though. Thank you. Yep. Okay, we'll move to the consent agenda. These are items that are before the commission.


6:08 p.m.

For consent, which means they're generally straightforward, but if anybody on the commission or in the room or on Zoom would like to pull an item for consent, then we will pull it off the consent agenda and take it up after the public hearing later in our agenda. So I'm going to read off each item on the consent calendar and then check to see if anybody has any questions or comments on that and would like to pull that item. The first few items are our action summaries. So the first one is the April 3rd, 2025 action summary. Commissioners? Okay. And I don't know if public would generally comment on the action summaries if I need to check with public on that. They could. Okay. Well, I'll check. And I see no hands raised on that. And no one on Zoom. No one on Zoom. Okay. The next one is our action. April 17th, 2025 action summary. Commissioners?


6:09 p.m.

Looks like we're all good. No hands in the room or on Zoom. Next are our May 1st 2025 action summaries. Again, commissioners, we're all good. I see no hands in the room. We'll stay on consent. And the May 15th 2025 action summary. So all four of those action summaries will stay on the consent. Next item is item five. West Haven Community Services District general plan conformance review for the acquisition of a portion of a parcel. Commissioners, I see anybody in the audience. See no hands on that item and nobody on Zoom, so that'll stay on consent. Item six, Riverside Community Service District general plan conformance review. Commissioners, we're okay there. We're okay there.


6:10 p.m.

No hands in the audience or on Zoom, so that stays on. Item 7 was the Humboldt Regional Climate Action Plan and CEQA greenhouse gas emission threshold. That is proposed to be continued until August 7th. So does anybody have any concerns or questions regarding that continuance to the August 7th meeting? Commissioners, no. Anybody in the audience? I don't see any hands. So that's all of the consent items 1 through 7. They all stay on the consent calendar. I have a motion, please. Chair Scavdell, I would move approval of the consent agenda. I have a motion from Commissioner Levy. Second. Second from Commissioner West. No discussion on the motion. We'll just take a voice vote.


6:11 p.m.

On this, all those in favor of approving the consent agenda say yes. Yes. Any opposed? No. So the consent agenda is approved. Item F, public hearings. The we are up, Inc. Planned unit development permit, conditional use permit, special permit, and line adjustment. In the McKinleyville area, we'll start with staff report. Director Ford, to you. Thank you, Chair Skavdal, members of the commission. Good evening. My name is Stephen Santos, senior planner, presenting the project. We have shared our screen. I'll wait for it to catch up in the room. All right. For commissioners that were here in July of 2023.


6:12 p.m.

Might remember that you make sure your mic is on it is on I'm seeing a green light is that better really intimate with the mic. So commissioners that were here in July of 2023 might remember that an earlier version of this project came before this body and was approved. That approval was appealed for two primary reasons. One was concerns over traffic coming from Weir Lane and the other was for noise from special events that mostly happened at the community center. So in response to the appeal the applicant withdrew the permit and went back to the drawing board to address those concerns and made some significant revisions to the project. And that's the project that is before you this evening. So here is the project site. Thank you.


6:13 p.m.

Consists of four legal parcels off of Central Avenue and we're up lane. The previous project was only on the large eastern project. So one of the things that has changed since last time is the acquisition of the three parcels next to Central Avenue. The parcels next to Central Avenue are commercial designations and zoning and then the large parcel is residential. I'm going to do a broad level summary now of the project. It consists of 70 housing units. The previous project had 50, so the number of housing units that are being proposed has increased. And that consists of three specific areas of housing. There will be 13 attached cottages, 17 courtyard apartments, and 40 units in . . .


6:14 p.m.

The community center. The community center will be a four-story mixed-use building. It will have a commercial kitchen and lots of different multi-purpose spaces for meetings, training, social events, classes, crafts, and other things that support the residents. And we'll also have some retail space. The project also includes some agricultural uses, orchard, greenhouse, barn, livestock, and these uses are integrated into the supportive housing project for the benefit of the residents and the community. The project also includes special events, which will occur both indoors and outdoors, as well as outdoor open spaces. We have open space with walking trails. Here is the project site plan that shows the layout. The community center...


6:15 p.m.

is there right next to Central Avenue. That's another big change that happened. The community center used to be up in the sort of the northwest area of the parcels, but now it's been moved further away from the residences next to Central Avenue. And so we have the community center right there on Central, and then the courtyard apartments on that northwest corner, and then the cottages clustered just to the southeast of that. The agricultural uses will be primarily, as you see, in the south center portion of the parcel. That's where the barn and the greenhouse will be. But as you can see, the bulk of the site will be reserved for open space. Before you leave that slide, please, can you point out where the outdoor event area is? So most events will take place in the community center.


6:16 p.m.

Community center which is will be in the western most part part of the parcel of the project site near the community center. So the indoor events will be inside the community center and there are some renderings that are in the staff report package that also show what that outdoor sort of amphitheater area also looks like. And so a lot of the events will happen in that space as well. But there could be events centered around the agricultural uses. So obviously those would be where those are taking place. Right. But the typical outdoor events or the wedding venue or those types of things would that be just to the right of the community center building there. Correct. And the and the sound wall that's being proposed is that on that south property line. Correct. Okay.


6:17 p.m.

And since we're asking about it, you mentioned the outdoor amphitheater. I can't, I couldn't identify exactly where that is. Is that right next to the community center? Yeah, I may not have, that was my word that I just inserted because that was sort of the vibe I got from it when I looked at the renderings. But, you know, it's tiered. But, yes, as Chair Skabdahl asked, it is immediately to the right of the community center. Got it. Okay, sure. Okay, thank you. All right. Moving along. So the We Are Up project is considered a quasi-public use under Humboldt County Code because We Are Up is a California public benefit corporation. It is also a 501c3 nonprofit under the Internal Revenue Code and will operate and provide recreational, educational, and social facilities. So that qualifies the project as a quasi-public use, which enables some other features of the project. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.


6:18 p.m.

Entitlements include a conditional use permit which will allow the multifamily units within the R1 zone through the quasi public use and the conditional use permit also allows temporary uses under the code which we are going to refer to as special events. The special permit does entitlement does a number of things. It allows for the wetland relocation and enhancement per the stream side management area and wetlands ordinance and the WR combining zone. It also provides several exceptions. It provides an exception to the 35 foot height limit for the courtyard apartments and would allow them to be built up to 40 feet. This allows for those structures to have less footprint. The exception will also allow the exception to the height limit for detail.


6:19 p.m.

Detached accessory structures and what we're referring to there is the barn and the greenhouse. The barn will exceed the 26 foot height limit by about four feet. It also provides an exception to the maximum gross floor area for detached accessory structures, which in the code is 1500 square feet. And the barn will be 2112 and the greenhouse 2880 square feet respectively. And it's staff's conclusion that these agricultural uses are integrated into and support the supportive housing mission of the project. And so the exception is appropriate. The project also includes a planned unit development permit. The planned unit development permit has several threshold criteria. One is there needs to be a public


6:20 p.m.

interest and then one of additional three criteria need to be met. The project is in the public interest and not just one but all three of the criteria for a planned unit development permit is met. More than four dwelling units are being proposed. There's residential and non-residential uses being proposed and it truly does provide a better means to carry out the intent of the general plan especially when it comes to housing. So with the PDP it will allow more than four units, sorry for the typo there I just noticed it, within the R1 zone. It allows clustering of the units to maximize the open space on the project site and it is also going to provide a reduction in the setback to interior parcel lines following the lot line adjustment and I'll get into that next. Thank you.


6:21 p.m.

So as I just mentioned, there is a lot line adjustment. This table is reproduced from the staff report. The three small parcels are going to get a little bit larger. The very large parcels are going to get a little bit smaller. And basically, doing the lot line adjustment will help facilitate funding for the various pieces of the project. One of the resultant parcels will be dedicated to all the access and parking. One parcel will be dedicated to open space. Then the other two parcels will divvy up the housing units. So here is a map of the lot line adjustment with the proposed development also shown. And what I mean by earlier when I said that there's a relaxation of the setback to interior property lines, you can see that the community center and the courtyard apartments, all are kind of snubbed.


6:22 p.m.

A little bit against that interior parcel line the setbacks to the exterior property lines and all the adjacent property owners stay the same are not going to be altered at all and and that setback reduction will be fine because on the other side of that interior parcel line is going to be parking spaces and internal access. So there's three project elements that I want to also kind of go over one is there are you know wetlands on the site we have that WR combining zone there's approximately eight point eight four acres of wetlands on the project site approximately point three one acres are proposed to be relocated filled approximately point three six acres are to be relocated. To be created and an additional zero point one five acres of riparian enhancements are also proposed in the form of riparian vegetation.


6:23 p.m.

and removal of invasive species. So when you take that all together, the total enhancement ratio for this aspect of the project is 1.6 to one. This slide is from the wetlands study and just shows in the cross hatched areas which wetlands are going to be filled and then where the other wetlands are. And so we see that the main wetland complex, W1, is for the most part remaining intact and being protected. And so I just want to also point out that the wetland enhancement is going to occur in those little donut holes that will help sort of then create a more contiguous wetland complex. So I'm going to go to the site plan again. This shows that those green areas right in the center.


6:24 p.m.

center is where the wetland creation is going to happen. So these next two slides, I'm going to talk about access and noise because this was what was brought up during the appeal. One of the key changes in the project is primary access will no longer be from We're Up Lane to the north. It will now be from Central Avenue. In addition, a gate will be installed at We're Up Lane and will be closed during special events. So that is condition of approval E2. Traffic analysis that was provided concluded that the project represents a 67% reduction in vehicle miles traveled compared to other similar types of allowed development in this area. This is due in part because, many of the residents aren't expected.


6:25 p.m.

to own and drive cars. And lastly, in consultation with Public Works, in particular in response to the special events, the project will upgrade the traffic signal at Central Avenue and construct an ADA accessible bus stop. On the topic of noise, I mentioned this earlier, the community center has been moved away from the residents to the north. So it's closer to Central Avenue. A noise assessment concluded that noise impacts from special events would be below the standard set in the general plan, which is 65 decibels. This conclusion was for the homes to the north. But the study did find that one residence to the south would experience noise level of...


6:26 p.m.

68 decibels. So that's why the project also includes a design feature that was discussed a little bit ago of a six foot wall that's going to be approximately 210 feet long along that that southern property line to achieve compliance with the county's noise standards that are in the general plan. Moving on to environmental review. This project has the benefit of a recent court case from 2024 Hilltop Group versus County of San Diego and that court case was examined by the county and we saw that the projects that are consistent with policies for which an EIR was certified shall not require additional review. And so in the staff report packet there is a very extensive long list of the projects that are consistent with policies for which an EIR was certified shall not require additional land use ordinance that goes through the county.


6:27 p.m.

county policies in the general plan, in the McKinley Bill, community plan, etc., to determine whether this type of development was considered in those programmatic EIRs and whether it's consistent with the standards that resulted from those processes. One of the things that Court Case, you know, encouraged, not encouraged, but led us to do is have the lead agency examine if the proposed project had any impacts that were peculiar that were not analyzed in previously certified programmatic EIRs. And we concluded that there weren't any. Now, with the exception of the temporary impact of special events that may have been may be 68 decibels to the residents to the south, then we have that project design feature of the sound wall that then...


6:28 p.m.

brings the project back into compliance with applicable standards. So as I mentioned in this last bullet, if an impact is identified, such as that 68 decibels during special events, it can be addressed by the imposition and compliance to uniformly applicable policies and standards. So as proposed and conditioned, the project will be compliant with applicable general and community plan policies in Humboldt County zoning regulations and standards. Therefore, the project is exempt from further environmental review pursuant to the Public Resources Code and the CEQA guidelines. I also want to note, other than the letters of support that were included with the staff report, we didn't receive any written public comment in response to the policy. So we will not receive any written public comment in response to the policy. So it is staff's recommendation to find the project staff


6:29 p.m.

...exempt from additional environmental review to find the proposed project complies with the general plan and zoning ordinance and adopt the resolution approving the We Are Up project. And that concludes my presentation. I'm available for questions. Thank you. Before we open the public hearing, I'll ask commissioners, do you have any questions of staff regarding the report? I do. On another project, I remember, I think it was in Ferndale, they were going to have wedding venues and we put time restrictions on music. Is that something that could be appropriate here? Because that's the one thing I could think of that could be allowed into the evening. And also, could the barns be used for special events or is it only going to be restricted to the community center area? So the... The answer, through the chair, the answer to your...


6:30 p.m.

Your first question is there is a condition of approval that limits the time of special events, how many special events per month and per year can occur, and then when it comes to sound, all of those special events must conform to the general plan noise standard. While it is contemplated that most events will either happen inside the community center or near it, it is contemplated that some special events, community events, or events involving the residents could occur in other areas of the property, such as the agricultural use area. My understanding of that time limit for outdoor events was 10 p.m. That is correct. Thank you. Yes. I have a couple questions, so in no particular order. You said that the traffic signal in Central would be upgraded, and I was just wondering if a


6:31 p.m.

A roundabout or other traffic calming devices were reviewed when the signal was decided to be upgraded. Through the chair, I don't know if other traffic facilities were evaluated. I was reliant upon the comments received back from Public Works and what they recommended based on their review of the project. So I guess that would be my first suggestion is if we could potentially look into that to see if a roundabout or some other design would be a little bit safer than traffic signals. I mean, I walk that section all the time and you have cars turning right on red or you've got a green walkman okay and then you've got at the same time there's a green light and you've got people crossing. So I'd just be cognizant of the pedestrian safety in that area, especially given the proposed development. And then I was wondering if you could elaborate on the wetland ratios a bit. You had 1.6 to 1. How was that number decided? I think it was 1.6. I think it was 1.6. I think it was 1.6. I think it was 1.6. I think it was 1.6. I think it was 1.6. I think it was 1.6. I think it was 1.6. I think it was 1.6. I think it was 1.6. I think it was 1.6. I think it was 1.6. I think it was 1.6. I think it was 1.6. I think it was 1.6. I think it was 1.6. I think it was 1.6. I think it was 1.6. I think it was 1.6. I think it was 1.6. I think it was 1.6. I think it was 1.6.


6:32 p.m.

That number was arrived at by also including the area of the riparian enhancement, the riparian vegetation and the removal of the invasive species. When you add all of the work together, that's how you get to 1.6 to 1. Even if you take that out, it's still above 1 to 1. Okay. And then just a quick clarification. The community center would be events that are either special events or events for the community, right? This wouldn't be like a public – they wouldn't be hosting public workshops or events, classes, things like that that are listed? They could. It could include weddings. Okay. And then I was just wondering, and I'd like you to weigh in too, when you had the map up that had sort of the topo lines, it does look like the stream and then the wetlands and maybe this is really small, it all drains to where the barn is. Is that where it's supposed to be built? No.


6:33 p.m.

Was is that correct? Did I read that correctly or is it off to the side? Through the chair the project materials do include in the technical documents do include a site drainage plan and there will be detention basins just south of those wetlands and in between the wetlands and the agricultural areas. Okay that's helpful. Okay thank you. Thank you. Thanks for the presentation. I was curious if the number of electric vehicle charging stations seemed low to me. I'm curious if that is in compliance with the current building code. I don't know if you have a thought off the top of your head. Through the chair, you stumped me.


6:34 p.m.

Yeah, I did not look at that. So one of the things that will happen is that when building permits are issued, it will comply with the building code. Okay, that makes sense. It's part of one of the conditions of approval, but the conditioned amount is oddly low, so I don't know why the condition is there, but that sounds good. Okay. We'll open the public hearing and we'll start with the applicant if you're here, if you'd like to address the commission. And you have up to ten minutes. And after we hear the rest of public comments, if there's something that you would like to address at the end, we'll welcome you back. Sounds good. Did you get the little thumb drive thing? Is that? Oh, perfect. Do you want to start? And I'll just like do that one.


6:35 p.m.

Okay, so we're excited to introduce you to the new and improved project for We Are Up Housing and Community Development that has the power to transform lives and strengthen our community and promote economic vitality. Rosalind Carter said there's only four kinds of people in this world. Those who have been caregivers, those who are currently caregivers, and those who will be caregivers, and those who will need caregivers. Personally, I fit into all of those categories. I was the caregiver for my husband, Roger, from the time he was diagnosed with cancer until he passed. My mother, who lived in Humboldt County until she was 96, enjoyed her family, and I've often relied on my daughters. I've been the legal guardian of my granddad's house since he was a little boy. I've been the legal guardian of my granddad's house since he was a little boy.


6:36 p.m.

My daughter, Jayden, who has autism since she turned 11. She's now a few months from 18, and she longs for the things her peers have, friends, independence, and a sense of belonging. I feel a responsibility to give her as much independence as she can manage. We don't exactly know how much that is right now, because she's growing in her abilities every day. We do know that every one of us can do something, whether it's a smile and a wave or living almost independently. Every one of us will need help from our community at some time. With the increasing diagnosis of autism and other intellectual disabilities and the aging of America, it's critical that we find models that work now and also be as self-supporting as possible. It's... You know, it's very expensive to maintain these projects, and we...


6:37 p.m.

No budgets are tight at times and you just can't leave people. So that is a big part of the design to create a model that is self-sustainable. If all of us will need care for a loved one or for ourselves at some point in our lives, wouldn't it be wonderful if that care was affordable and accessible so that caregiving could be a source of comfort and joy rather than stress and financial hardship? Our economy is powered by caregivers who are so often unseen. Not just an individual or a family issue, it's an economic and social issue. Treating it as such could pave the way for solutions that boost economic growth and resilience at all levels of society. Many caregivers are unable to work at a... job that they are qualified for because they always have to stay available to take care of the children.


6:38 p.m.

At a momentary crisis, many seniors and people with disabilities could also contribute more than they are able. Building a modern caregiving system would unlock progress for women who do the majority of this caregiving in the United States, and most of it is unpaid. This can have long-term effects on their health, their careers, and financing a care system built for today's needs would allow women to step into their full selves and contribute more to our economy. We see so often that people are siloed in our society. Seniors living in senior housing, people with disabilities living in group homes, students living in dorms, Republicans on one side of the aisle. Democrats on the other. Democrats on the other. Democrats on another. How can we come together as a country when we have so many walls between us? The We Are Up Project has brought diverse groups.


6:39 p.m.

of people together at a time when we need community the most. We have a broad spectrum of support from seniors teaching Tai Chi to timber companies, and you don't get much more diverse than that. We have support from parents who worry every day what will happen to their adult children when they're no longer able to care for them, and some of the same young adults longing for a place to call home. When we're faced with a caregiving challenge, we quickly learn that we are more alike than we are different. We Are Up is designed to be a community within the community, providing job skills, training, on-site, and a place for the community at large to come together. It's designed to be a place where everyone can contribute and everyone can receive the supports they need. Next.


6:40 p.m.

A place where we can plant seeds that grow food and grow our residents' ability to be part of the community. We Are Up will have a commercial kitchen where the food we grow can be turned into value-added products that will help support the organization long-term and provide jobs, where people can learn to design labels, package the food they make, and sell it to local stores, restaurants, farmers markets, and in our little retail area. They can learn how to work towards a goal and lessen their sense of isolation. With that same food, the community at large will be invited... That's okay. Yeah, that's... Oh, we're still back there, but it doesn't matter. With that same food, the community at large will be invited... could be invited in for a brunch, or pick up a meal to take out. Giving even...


6:41 p.m.

different types of jobs to our residents. A gathering space for all of us to come together for special events. And perhaps most importantly, it will give the community the opportunity to know our residents. Because when you know someone, you tend to care about them a lot more. And the isolation that seniors feel is real. And the isolation that people with disabilities feel is really real. And we'll be more apt to support our most vulnerable neighbors. Oh, go back, because I think we skipped. So for those of you who have not walked the site, it's almost a magical setting. From the busyness of Central Avenue, you can now see all the way out to the fairy circle, as we call it. Because we couldn't figure out why that little stand of trees was way out there. Our residents who may have difficulty driving will have a bus. Stop right on. Stop right on.


6:42 p.m.

the northwest corner. They will be within walking distance of restaurants. Grocery store is right next door. Open door has a health clinic. And when you look at the beautiful open field and the circle of trees two-thirds down, you immediately feel grounded in nature and surrounded by the peace that nature brings. This will help our rural residents feel more calm, lessen anxiety and stress. The project will keep about 80% or more of the large parcel as open space. here i think we're on to the next one we all know that we have an extreme shortage of housing in the state but accessible housing that's also affordable is almost non-existent as we age we all need


6:43 p.m.

modifications and this all of our housing will either be accessible or easily to made be made accessible the 70 units of housing contain a mix of studio one two and three bedroom units so that those who need extra support either physically or financially or emotionally can have a roommate there are carefully designed amenities for residents including this open patio that faces the meadow special meeting rooms just for residents and makers space and the retail store will give them social opportunities as well as job opportunities next it's important to stress that we're up is not just housing it's not just a farmer garden or an open space it's an ecosystem of care where all the the the will work together to produce a model that can be replicated a model humboldt county


6:44 p.m.

can be proud of and where residents will find a sense of belonging and an ability to contribute. It's a place where families will know their loved ones are safe even when they're no longer able to care for them in their homes. Everyone needs to have a purpose and be part of something greater than themselves in order to thrive. As most of you know, we have redesigned the project to address the concerns of our neighbors to the north who were worried about noise and traffic. We were able to purchase three additional parcels to the west fronting Central Avenue, redesigning the site plan to move the community center and commercial kitchen as far away as possible for the residential area. Somebody asked about the amphitheater, and this is kind of what it is. There's a natural slope, and so we have some seating built in and places where people could sit on the ground. We have a lot of space for people to sit on the ground, and so we have a lot of space for people to sit on the ground, and so we have a lot of space for people to sit on the grass. My granddaughter loves grass. My granddaughter loves grass.


6:45 p.m.

to perform as they all a lot of her friends take dj lessons so i can see them out there singing to each other or having a pizza uh parlor um can you just cancel that i don't know how much more presentation you have almost done okay and uh i'm sure the rest of your commissioners are okay with continuing okay thank you okay please sorry um so we've engaged the services of rana creek who helped kashbusha design a more ecologically and visually appealing project runoff will now be handled by a series of ponds uh seasonal ponds next um so our neighbors aren't faced with some of the man-made wetlands that we've had to deal with um and it's designed to fit into the existing landscape our primary entrance will now be a little bit more of a central rather than through the neighborhood


6:46 p.m.

And we've added the 20 units of housing to bring it to 70 units with four furnished units reserved for friends and family to support residents. So like if your child or your parent is there and you are visiting from out of town, you have a place to actually see what their living situation is like. So we can next slide. We can skip this one because I'm over time. So these are some of the real people. That this will help. My granddaughter is under the Our Neighbors. She had a farm stand selling cookies she made because she wanted an Apple Watch and I wouldn't buy her one. And she earned that watch. There's Claudia, Lima, and Christopher, Wendy, and Henry who asks me every time he sees me, when can he move in and can his girlfriend move with him? And on the bottom is a bunch of kids.


6:47 p.m.

at a Special Olympics conference showing off their gold medals, and Caden and Tate Naylor. So, I mean, they're real people, and they're fun, and they're just so kind. So they deserve everything we can offer them. Questions? Thank you. Okay. I don't know that we'll have questions at this time, but we'll bring you back later if we do. At this time, if there's anybody else that would like to address the commission on this project, please approach the podium. And you'll have three minutes. Good evening. I'm Wesley Chesborough, and I'm first as a resident of McKinleyville. I'm here to support We Are Up. I live in the neighborhood a few blocks up on Bella Vista, and I think that this project has all kinds of attributes. It is a great use of the property. It provides housing while at the same time preserving open space. It helps CommunitySearch.


6:48 p.m.

helps contribute to McKinleyville's further development as a rich, full community, which there's many things, the town center efforts, the efforts to build the senior housing project. I think these things are all converging to help McKinleyville evolve in a really wonderful way. Also, I'm here as your former state senator who chaired the Senate Committee on Developmental Disabilities and Mental Health and had a great deal of experience and education learning about the issues around disabilities. I have worked on, unfortunately not for Humboldt County, funding and development of housing for persons with disabilities elsewhere in the state and am very aware of the importance of providing that kind of housing. You know, the greatest limitation on people with any disability is society's inability to see their capability and their potential. It's not the disability itself. It's the limitations and the lack of support that they need in order to fully live a full life, and this housing.


6:49 p.m.

project is an example of offering that those kinds of opportunities. And then finally I think we all know that we need housing in this county and to the extent that seniors move there and free up other housing and we're able to increase the overall supply we're helping to solve a larger problem as well. So I'm an enthusiastic supporter and I encourage you to approve the project. Thank you. Thank you. Good evening, members of the Planning Commission. My name is Mallory McCurdy, and I come before you not only as the treasurer of We Are Up, but as an aunt, an advocate, and a believer in what is possible when we invest in inclusive, forward-thinking community design. My niece has autism, and in her, I see a world that is not just a world of autism.


6:50 p.m.

of untapped potential, potential that often goes unseen in traditional planning of a community. Our vision for this community is to create a place where people like her and like so many others, from seniors to essential workers, don't just have a place to live, but a place to belong, contribute, and thrive. This is not just housing. This is a community. A community intentionally built to reflect the diversity and strengths of people with disabilities, older adults, and members of the working force who too often fall through the cracks of affordability and accessibility. As the head of the agricultural portion of this project, I want to highlight how transformative that piece can be. The farm won't just grow food. It will grow purpose, connection, and healing. We envision day programs across Our county and withstop путins Withstop siete Siet Guun Cet rectiter Cluv Refugee Cast Roberts Berks time Specialist Auditor Director Member Director Tre расск Tuning Prof strat Prof değild Rescue Stephen Directoryleri Secretary Director Department Secretary President Departmentor President Speaker Vice Chairman Major Director Dean Chair Staff Chair Senator Deputy Director Secretary Sister Secretary Secretary Stuart Dean


6:51 p.m.

where individuals of all abilities engage in meaningful, engage meaningfully, caring for animals and plants side by side with local students through partnerships with the FFA and 4-H chapters. Imagine young people learning not just agriculture, but empathy and leadership through those partnerships. This farm will be a calm, nurturing space where someone who might struggle in traditional work environments can find peace and dignity through their contributions. Where elders can find fresh air and companionship. Where children and teens can learn life skills that go beyond textbooks. We are designing this project not just with people in mind, but with all of us. With all people in mind. That includes sustainable land use, integrational interaction,


6:52 p.m.

action and long-term impact. I respectfully urge you to approve this visionary plan, not just for what it is today, but for what it will live, what it lives, what it will live up to and uplift tomorrow. We have a rare opportunity to say, it's all right. We see you. We value you and you belong here. Thank you for your time. Well that last speaker kind of got me emotional too. I'm here to speak to you on behalf of We Are Up and just ask you to approve this project. I've been a little bit involved with it both as a volunteer and in helping Mary with other projects, but what is amazing about it is that it's a project that we're doing together.


6:53 p.m.

about this project is the diversity of what it brings to both the community and to what it will bring to the residents. I think We Are Up has done a phenomenal job to design a project that meets all the requirements of you know your county plan and met the requirements and mitigated issues that neighbors had. They've really bent over backwards to make a project like I said that meets and has dealt with all any concern anyone had about it but beyond that it's a beautiful project. You've seen it. I have toured some different housing that has been developed in different areas of the Bay Area in particular for individuals with intellectual and developmental disabilities. This exceeds anything I saw and provides more activities and enrichment for those individuals who will live there. We Are Up is the


6:54 p.m.

The IDD residents for the seniors and other workforce people who may be on site. I think they're looking at one-third, one-third, one-third as far as residents. Creates a community that, as Mary mentioned, does not isolate people but integrates people. The public use of the facility will further integrate the residents into the community. It brings a lot to the community of McKinleyville and enhancements of just the resources it brings. One thing I come here as is a retired person who ran the Humboldt County Employment Training Division at one time. What this offers to the residents, particularly the IDD individuals, in job training is very real. And it offers facilities, commercial kitchen, retail stores, farm stations. Stands, you know, serving people during events in the...


6:55 p.m.

Community Center, it offers all kinds of activities and ways of providing job training to individuals who can really take that training into jobs outside of We Are Up at some point and I find that aspect very encouraging. I'd love to see that happen that more of these individuals can work within the community than maybe people realize and this gives them that opportunity to learn skills in a safe environment that's you know supporting them as they learn. So I think that's it. I didn't really write anything down so I'm ad-libbing here but I just would hope you will approve this. Thank you. Good evening commissioners. My name is Colby Smart. I'm the deputy superintendent of schools at the Humboldt County Office of Education and I am so thankful and grateful.


6:56 p.m.

be able to support this program and I wholeheartedly support We Are Up's proposed project and recognize the positive impact it will have on educational opportunities and the broader community. We Are Up's dedication to fostering an inclusive environment in Humboldt County is not only invaluable but it's truly inspirational. Collaboration with community partners is a core value at HCOE and it's been a true pleasure to work to be working with Mary on how our two organizations among many many others might partner moving forward for the benefit of learners regardless of their age or circumstance. These partnerships really do help ensure that programs are accessible, sustainable, and relevant. We Are Up is modeling how community-driven efforts can create transformative and inclusive opportunities for all. We Are Up is a program that is committed to building transformative educational pathways and lasting positive


6:57 p.m.

change. I fully support their mission and vision for Humboldt County's future. I really want to thank you for your commitment to building a brighter and more inclusive community and I can speak that this project adds to the full trajectory of students. At HCOE we have two primary programs that support students with disabilities. One is our Glen Paul School and the other one is a special beginnings which specifically supports youth who have autism and I can't imagine, I should say I can only imagine the comfort and the excitement that parents will have knowing that their children once they reach their end of their formal educational journey will have a place to continue to thrive. So thank you very much. Thank you.


6:58 p.m.

Thank you. Good evening, Commissioners. I'm Tori Starr. I'm the CEO of Open Door Community Health Centers, and I'm also a board member of We Are Up. I'm really protective of my time just because of how busy my job is. And when I heard about We Are Up, I jumped on the opportunity to actually contribute because it's not a housing project. It's building a community, and that's such a rare thing for us to be able to do. I want to talk a little bit about the health aspects of the project. So Open Door serves 60,000 people a year. 13,000 of those are Medicare patients. So we're really engaged with the senior population. And every day in our work, we see how housing is not just a social issue. It's a health issue. Without safe, affordable housing, no individual, regardless of their age or ability, can fit. I actually fully support their physical and mental health.


6:59 p.m.

mental well-being. That's why I'm here to express our enthusiastic support for the We Are Up project. This initiative does more than build housing, it builds belonging. It is thoughtfully designed, sustainable, intergenerational community where people with disabilities, especially those with on the autism spectrum, can live, grow, and thrive alongside others, including our rapidly aging senior population. We are facing an urgent crisis. The fastest growing segment of houseless population is seniors. And individuals with disability continue to face enormous barriers to stable housing and supportive services. These are the very individuals who benefit most from environments of connection, understanding, and community. And this is precisely what


7 p.m.

This project delivers. We cannot treat health in isolation from housing. We cannot stand by as our most vulnerable neighbors fall through the cracks. The We Are Up project is exactly the kind of forward thinking, compassionate solution our region needs. I urge you to approve this important project for the health of our community and for the dignity of every person who calls Humboldt County home. Thanks so much. Thank you. We're going to pause for a 10-minute break, and then we'll pick up here. And I think we have some people online also that might want to speak. So let's take a little break, and we'll be back in 10 minutes. Thank you.


7:10 p.m.

Thank you. Bring the meeting back to order, please. So continuing the public hearing on the We Are Up project. Again, I'll ask, is there anybody else in the room that would like to address the commission? Thank you. Please come on up. Hello. I am Sierra Braggs. I have spent the last 17 years working in the field of services to people with intellectual and developmental disabilities, which is more and more made up of people on the autism spectrum. And my primary role has been looking at how we create more inclusive communities. How do we make services better? Because one of the things that happens with isolation is that people actually get abused and they get hurt. So not only do we have the...


7:11 p.m.

health conditions, but we have people actually experiencing harm. And so I worked at Rubber Coast Regional Center for the past 10 years. I left in January and I was at Rubber Coast Regional Center when I met Mary and the We Are Up project was just getting started. And I've gotten to see over the last, I don't know, four or five years, the project has really changed and it's become more than just a place where people will live. It's going to be this beautiful, vibrant community that you've, you know, you've heard so much about tonight. And I can tell you, I've, we helped to fund several different affordable housing projects in Mendocino County, Lake County, and this was our first one at RCRC that we helped to fund in Humboldt County. And there's nothing else like this in the state. I suspect there's nothing else like this in the country. It is truly what we need moving forward.


7:12 p.m.

There are 200 people with intellectual and developmental disabilities who live in the McKinleyville area that don't have any access to regional center services in their part of Humboldt County. Most of the services are in Arcata or Eureka or down in Fortuna and Rio Del. And so We Are Up is also going to provide this opportunity for the people who live in McKinleyville and who maybe want to experience community inclusion in McKinleyville instead of coming to Eureka or Arcata to do that there in McKinleyville, which is really exciting. And We Are Up recently just received funding from Rebel Coast Regional Center in addition to building the housing to actually develop this community inclusion service that will use the greenhouse as kind of a base to help people. experience community by doing things that you have a shared interest. It's kind of hard to make friends. You make friends by doing things repeatedly with people who have a shared interest with you. And so anyways, I just wanted to.


7:13 p.m.

I enthusiastically encourage you to approve the project. Thank you. Is there anybody else in the room that would like to address the commission? Good evening. My name is Kash Boodje. I'm the architect for the project. Like everybody else, I've been living this for the last five years, I think. Really intimately, maybe not as much as that in the last year. We have tried very hard in the last design since July 2023 to be a good neighbor as we try to create a sense of belonging for the future end users. We like the project to also feel like it belongs to the site. And we try to locate most of the proposed structures in places that already have been disturbed.


7:14 p.m.

The majority of the wetlands that are being filled, almost all of them, are actually man-made and the results of run-offs. Of the 70 units, six of them are not going to be wheelchair accessible. On a sloping site like that, that was really a nice challenge to take on and at the same time make it look like if it belongs and it's not ramps and all that kind of stuff. The reason we have gates is because of the fact that we want the residents to be free to roam on the property because there are runners with IDDs. So that's one thing about the gate because sometimes there is a notion of the gate of communities and whatnot. But the neighbors also requested to not have traffic flowing during events. Only 35 parking spaces are for residents. That's the percentage of the residents that we assume might be driving. Because they're not going to be driving. Because of the seniors and IDDs. So the majority of the parking that's set aside is requirements because of the potential.


7:15 p.m.

gathering that we are seeing. When you go above 151, you need to have 35 EV stations, 9 of them chargers, 26 of them plug-ins. That's July 2024. Who knows what it's going to be when our turn comes up. The courtyard apartment is elevator accessible, again, to make it sure that it's all wheelchair accessible for the units. We started by designing the units first for the residents. Then we started putting those footprints of the units into the forms that became the buildings. Then at the same time, those decks that we have, the rooftop decks that we have, is also places where some people can be safely outdoor, but necessarily out running around in the field. There's a lot of little intricate details throughout this project that have made it look and feel the way it does. I'm here. I'm going to be sitting here if you guys have any questions that come up. Thank you. Thank you.


7:16 p.m.

Thank you. All right, I'll ask again. Anybody else in the room? Not seeing any hands or anybody coming to the podium, we'll go to the Zoom participants. And I see we have one right now. If you are on Zoom and you want to make comment, please press star nine to raise your hand. Excuse me. And I see we have Humboldt Area Foundation. Actually, my name is Kathy Johanson. I'm not here representing the foundation. I'm here representing myself. Thank you. I'm a private senior citizen in Humboldt County, current resident of Eureka. And although I am currently employed, I'm personally concerned about future things. I'm going to care as I age and face physical disabilities as a natural.


7:17 p.m.

progression of this stage in life. I cannot even fathom what life would be like if I faced intellectual disabilities. So that said, I'm here today in favor of We Are Up as a planned development, and I'm not directly involved in the project, and although I'm not a resident of McKinleyville, I am aware of it by association. But quite frankly, I'm in awe of the inclusive foresight of the founder and those directly involved. In part, but not because of, I have met family members also with intellectual disabilities, so it really speaks to my heart. Specifically, I find this project to be very thoughtful and the first of its kind in our area, supporting community in a way that has not previously been considered. The the, um, organization took feedback and elevated the project.


7:18 p.m.

project into the renderings that you've seen today. It's creative, insightful housing development for special needs populations and of course, as you've heard, provides more social facilities and recreational opportunities in a multi-use environment, not only for the residents but for the entire community in a really very thoughtful, complete design. Quite remarkable from my perspective and it's something that McKinleyville residents have expressed interest in, at least the ones that I know. In addition, as a person who has managed special events throughout the county over a number of years, I appreciate the additional event space and the facilities that are in our more northern areas outside of Eureka and Arcata. Moreover, I see that partnerships and possibilities beyond even the city of McKinleyville are very, very important. Thank you. I think that's been what has been conceived of at this time.


7:19 p.m.

are inherently possible as this project continues to evolve and move forward and I continue to be impressed the more I hear about this project. Finally, tonight I'd like to leave you with a quote, blessed are those who plant trees under whose shade they will never sit. That is how I view this project. There may be some of us who never get to enjoy it to its fruition. I frankly hope that I am, but I urge you to support this project and I thank you for your time and consideration. Thank you. I don't see any other hands up right now. I'll ask the applicant, although I don't think we heard any challenges or questions regarding the project. But if there's anything that you would like to add.


7:20 p.m.

to add or clarify after hearing all of the if you have questions okay all right thank you then we'll close the public hearing and bring this back to the commissioners for any comments or questions on the project I'll just say I'm ready to make a motion if nobody else has anything else to add Yeah, I don't know that I really have any questions. I am very much in support of this project. I just want to commend Ms. Keene and the team that she worked with. This was already a really good project, I thought, two years ago. And even then, it seemed like it had done a lot to accommodate the concerns of .


7:21 p.m.

neighbors and various issues of access of noise and things like that. And yet still, you know, it had a few people wanting to express those concerns. So, you know, I know it was appealed, but I'm pretty confident that it could have been approved then. The fact that you chose to withdraw it, seek a way to get access from Central Avenue, which was obviously a game changer, really did a lot to make this an even better project. And it's been very thoughtfully designed. It is a model for our community. I look forward to seeing it come to fruition. Commissioner West. Similar to Commissioner Levy's comments, I also thought it was a great project the first time around. Although certainly the house was packed with folks both in support and against. And I think I'm excited to see you have added so many more units. I think this is an incredible project.


7:22 p.m.

And it speaks well that we haven't really heard any opposition tonight. So thank you for all of your work. Yes, Commissioner Curiazzi. I also have a fantastic project. I'm really excited that I get to be part of this motion tonight. I do want to pivot a little bit and take the opportunity to recognize that this is one of the first sort of initial attempts at implementing a VMT threshold that we discussed. It hasn't been approved by the Board of Supervisors, but was used as a guide to look at the VMT impacts. And I did have one comment on the approach followed, just maybe a concern. I have going forward to staff. I noticed that in some of the arguments made, there was a...


7:23 p.m.

Comparison to other potential multifamily unit projects that could be developed in McKinleyville and and it struck me as an approach of picking a worst case scenario and saying well we're doing better than a worst case scenario. So I think I would urge staff to really focus on we look at the per capita VMT of the project and we compare it to the per capita VMT threshold and we really stick to that and not start getting into the weeds of potential worst case scenario comparisons. But other than that I completely agree the VMT is quite quite a bit lower than the thresholds and it's a fantastic project. I had a couple of questions related to kind of fire and life safety. The the gate and I understand we're going to have a gate.


7:24 p.m.

which I think is great to control access and limit people that are attending some of these functions or at the venue from entering or exiting through the neighborhood. But I want to make sure that that gate is going to be designed in such a way that emergency access and fire still has access through that. And if people do need to exit the venue and can't for some reason exit onto Central Avenue, that they can exit. So I think that's just more of a design detail to make sure that we have that. And then with respect to the building height, because we're making an exception to a 40-foot building height, and I didn't see any comments from fire department directly in here, but will the fire department be able to? Serve that building in that street.


7:25 p.m.

structure at a 40 foot height. And I just want to make sure that we've met that criteria. We did circulate it to fire. I don't believe we got negative comments back on the height. So one of the things that is typically done, obviously these kinds of facilities are heavily sprinkled. Yeah, I know it's going to have all of that. And I'm sure that they'll be able to serve that. But I just want to make sure that we're not going above a height limit and having a fire department can't service a building. So they didn't comment. We did circulate to the fire department. Chair Scavdola, I can confirm we did refer the project to Arcata Fire Protection District and they did not respond. They will also do a plan review. Correct. Okay. Okay.


7:26 p.m.

Thank you. I can respond to that. On the first item, the gate, there's no gate at Central for the vehicles. The gates are only proposed at V-R-Up Lane. I personally shared the plans with Ed Laidlaw at Arcata Volunteer Fire Department before I actually finished up the design development process, and I shared the height of both structures with him directly, and access and grades and site plan and building. Okay. Thank you. And I know they'll also review the design. Okay. And I also, you know, we supported this project the first time around, and sometimes as commissioners we find ourselves in the position of reviewing projects that meet all of the planning criteria and zoning requirements, and we approve them over the year.


7:27 p.m.

objection of the neighborhood at times and we find ourselves in that position which is uncomfortable but but sometimes we have to you know we have to do that because the project does comply and this one did and we approved it but you listen to the neighborhood and brought us back an even better project which I commend you for that doesn't often happen here so pretty amazing so congratulations I really appreciate that effort so with that I think somebody was okay then I'll make a motion to approve public hearing agenda item one we are up incorporated planned unit development permit conditional use permit special permit and lot line adjustment as for the project that is in place. Thank you. I move that the proposed with the minor amendment to review the applicability of the proposed traffic signal to traffic signal upgrade to determine if roundabout you


7:28 p.m.

or other design is more appropriate given the projected traffic volume and pedestrian use I'll second it so we have a motion from Commissioner McFarland in a second can you repeat your out of the amendment again please it was to re-review the proposed traffic signal upgrade to determine if a roundabout or other design feature was more appropriate for the projected increase in traffic volume and pedestrian use could we put some balance on that because we we look at that a little bit and it's not going to fit in the right-of-way and so I mean can we put a limitation on it that if it requires additional right-of-way acquisition that roundabout is immediately determined to be infeasible yeah I think the county's building and planning department can use best judgment to determine if there is another measure to help the pedestrians in the traffic flow and if not


7:29 p.m.

then your best judgment is fine thank you okay so we have a motion as i understand it it does include investigation of a roundabout followers or other feature just ensuring that the proposed traffic zone upgrade is the most appropriate upgrade for the projected increase in traffic and pedestrian use okay and we have a second from commissioner o'neill any other discussion on the motion could we have a roll call vote please Chair Scavdahl? Yes. Commissioner Levy? Yes. Commissioner O'Neill? Yes. Commissioner West? Yes. Commissioner Curiazzi? Yes. Commissioner McFarland? Yes. Motion carries.


7:30 p.m.

Thank you. Thank you. Okay, I've got to find my spot here. Thank you. We had no items pulled from consent. Can I just thank you all? Also, I know this was a special meeting for you, so I appreciate that. Thank you. Director Ford, do we have a report from? Yeah, just a couple things. As you noticed tonight, I apologize. We didn't have the regional climate action plan, but we're still working on responding to comments and didn't want to release something prematurely. I figured you would rather have us take the time and give you something complete than rush and give you something that was rushed. So we are... Thank you.


7:31 p.m.

Working hard on that. I just wanted to share a little bit that Town Center from McKinleyville is also moving towards you. I anticipate taking the version that could be used to make a recommendation by the MCMAC and the final EIR back to the MCMAC, McKinleyville Municipal Advisory Committee, on July 30th. And then anticipating that that would be in front of you on August, I think it's the 19th. And so we're working towards that. So in August, you're looking at having two pretty heavy items. Two separate agendas. Two separate agendas. Thank you. Yep. I think maybe I'll just... Share with you a little bit that the Board of Supervisors...


7:32 p.m.

Supervisors at the meeting this week did modify the code enforcement proceedings to clarify how we assess penalties and the maximum limit, the maximum level of penalties. Basically, just to address either process things or just put appropriate bounds on things. And that's all I've got right now. Okay. Is this for Director Ford? Correct. Yeah, a couple of clarifying questions. Okay, please. Can you reiterate the date you'll be taking that to the MCMAC? July 30th. And actually, I lied. My second question is maybe more to staff and the commission. Would there be possibility and interest in a workshop to help digest? Because I know these are both complex projects, and I would be interested in a workshop.


7:33 p.m.

if there is interest availability and if that's a possibility on staff side. We could have a workshop, and that has been discussed. One of the things we're trying to balance is Life Plan Humboldt now has property control, and so they're ready to move forward, and they're waiting on adoption of the town center. And so if we were to schedule a workshop and then a hearing on that, that that may project it out for a while. And, I mean, it's not that I'm happy to schedule a workshop if that's the commission's desire, but that is the thinking. I do have a conflict with the second meeting in August. So I will not be here. On the 19th? Correct.


7:34 p.m.

I think it's actually the 21st. Is it the 21st? It's whatever the second meeting in August is. Okay. Thanks. I stand corrected. It's the 21st. Yeah. I know I have a conflict. We talked about that. We've talked about it a little bit, and there is a possibility that I will also be out due to medical. Yeah. Would there be a better date then to do that? Who? I'll just chime in while you're thinking of dates. I'll be out for the first three weeks of September, so pushing it to the first meeting of September. I'd prefer not to just because I am a McKinleyville resident. That week is going to be hard for me, John. So I could move it to the. Could we go back to the 28th? Probably. No, of August.


7:35 p.m.

Or even the 14th of August, I know that would mean two back-to-back weeks with this item, but if that worked better for people, I believe I would be available either of those alternative dates. I would too, and I would, I'm finalizing some plans right now, so I think the 14th would be safer, but I could probably make the 28th work. I'm sort of similar on that. I could do that. You know, just timing-wise, to turn around from the 30th, and not knowing what the MCMAC is going to do, and then I'd have to really notice it before the MCMAC meeting to get to the 14th.


7:36 p.m.

I see. That's problematic. So... For lack of a better solution, maybe it would be worth, I'll offer this, to have a workshop on the 21st, and then, boy, there's no good answer here, is there? Thank you. I mean we could also I think it depends on attendance and who else we think is gonna be there but we could retain that date and then just ensure that we have a second backup chair should we need it


7:37 p.m.

The 21st. The 21st, yeah. If Commissioner Scavdahl is gone, then I have to be out for medical reasons. We'd have to make sure all the rest of the commissioners could be there. Yeah, we will do a survey of quorum and just make sure that we can do that. I would like to have a full commission for that, obviously, because it's a pretty big item. Okay. Does it have to be on a Thursday? It doesn't have to be. The struggle is we really need to check with other people that are using this room to make sure that we're not moving into somebody's space. I'm open to a non-Thursday if it does work that way.


7:38 p.m.

Not on Thursday? Any day. Any day, okay. Sign me up. Well, how about you pull commissioners and we'll see what we can do. I don't think we can decide it right now and Thomas isn't here. I don't think I can be here. There's a possibility I could squeeze it in on the 20th, but it would be hard. That would be Wednesday. Like would the 18th or 19th be better? No. Okay. Okay. No, I'd be coming back and leaving. Oh, yeah. No, no, no, no, no. Okay. Sorry about that. To try to make Wednesday work. What's that? To try to make Wednesday work. Oh, yeah. It's really not a good week for me. It just turns out that I just have conflicts all week. Okay. We'll take a poll and see what we can do.


7:39 p.m.

We can do. Okay. Thank you. All right. Anything else, planning commissioners, for discussion this evening? Putting the same question to the climate action plan in terms of a workshop. Workshop on that as well, yeah. Is there interest in doing that, or is there similar time constraints on that one? No, there's not the same time constraints on that. We can make the August 7th meeting a workshop, if that's the commissioner's pleasure. If we do that, that means we're probably not going to come back to the climate action plan until sometime in September. Right. Okay. We were trying to only have the climate action plan on an agenda. I mean. Right. And I know that's a heavy lift. I would advocate for that. I also felt. Advocate for. A workshop. A workshop. Yeah.


7:40 p.m.

I felt like the VMT threshold was sort of similarly complex and could have benefited from a workshop. Well, ultimately it took us two meetings to get through the VMT threshold because we didn't have a workshop probably. Right. I would support that, particularly for the RCAP, the idea of a workshop first before the actual hearing. It makes sense. I wasn't sure if there were timing requirements that that would weigh against, but I appreciate that you raised the question, and it seems like maybe that one way. It doesn't have the – well, the timing pressure there in my mind is that 2030 is marching upon us. Yes. And I'd like to get some of this stuff in place. Yeah, we're not going to have – we're eating up the runway on actually. We're implementing. Right. Right.


7:41 p.m.

Activities. The workshop itself, the format is typically a staff report. It's functionally similar to a hearing. We still have to take public comments even though it's a workshop? Yep. So the disadvantage is we're going to march a group of people up to the podium twice. And I don't mean that in any way to be disrespectful. It's the process and certain groups of people are going to want to address the commission during the workshop and they're going to come back and address the commission again during the hearing. Based off of the online chatter I've seen, it's also possible we could have a very long public comment period. We will. To get us there in the first place. We will. Two of them. So for that reason. I'm not.


7:42 p.m.

that inclined to go through a workshop process i i guess i mean the the point of a workshop is to kind of understand what you're working with right and yes and so from our responsibility just you know i i agree that's that's we will be listening to a lot of public comment um i guess i'm arguing from our responsibility and really needing to understand what we're voting on i have in other public forums attended workshops that are limited to staff and commission as just a technical forum workshop where we're reviewing a document understanding the format understanding what and not taking public comment so that's why i'm asking the question if we have to you know if we have to do that i think that's a good question do that twice


7:43 p.m.

We need to take public comment. Okay. This, you probably, the answer is probably no, but could you do like a, the start of the meeting on a Wednesday and that opens the meeting and you have public comment? And then you like pause, you don't actually adjourn the meeting, but you take a long intermission until Thursday at 6, and so it's still technically one meeting with one set of public comments. Is that legal? Well, so I think, so to the point of Commissioner Scavadal is that once people have made comments on something that remains static, you don't get to repeat that comment. Whereas if you do a workshop and in a public hearing, you can comment twice on the same topic. If you're doing what you're saying is that like on Wednesday, we go through and then the commission says change this and change this and change.


7:44 p.m.

this, then on Thursday they get to comment on all that stuff that's been changed. And again, my understanding, we've circulated the EIR on the Climate Action Plan. Right. You're getting comments. You've addressed those comments, and now we have, we're reviewing. We know what the issues are. Yeah. I mean, we know what the concerns are. But in order for us to approve the final EIR, we're going to hear public comment during the process. We're going to have to hear back from staff that those public comments have been addressed in the EIR in order for us to approve it. Do you need time between the public comment period? And for staff.


7:45 p.m.

I have to review all those public comments and come back to us and say, yes, they've been addressed in the EIR, or no, they haven't, and we have to go address something else. I would like to think we will know the document well enough to be able to respond to it. Yeah. Okay. And at that point, if commissioners are commenting on something that's going to cause modifications to that document, are we sending you back? Potentially. If you're asking for something that was not addressed in the EIR? Yes. Yeah. We would. We would be going back and reevaluating the environmental work that we've done. Yep. Okay. I think I lean towards...


7:46 p.m.

Favoring a workshop, I think with very visible issues with a lot of public input, it doesn't hurt to have more opportunities for public process. And especially if we do, it's likely we're going to end up with two meetings anyway, so to me it makes sense to do a workshop. I also think the potential advantage of the workshop is going to be getting commission, and I think this is to Commissioner Curioz's point, getting commission aligned and up to speed on all the issues so that you aren't maybe getting some last minute questions or curveballs. That absolutely is a benefit of a workshop. You get to kind of find out where all of the big holes are before you get into the hearing.


7:47 p.m.

Yep. However, if we have a room full of people and it takes us hours to get through the public comments section, we're really not going to get a lot of commission dialogue. No, ironically, we only received four letters on the EIR. Okay. We didn't receive a lot of comments. So they're really, I mean, I don't know if people are tired, if they're worn out, or if they don't care. Or there are certain groups representing their interests that are commenting. Right. Yes. Well, one group consists of about four or five different groups, and their letter was intense. I guess I also agree 2030 is marching towards us, but also there is nothing stopping jurisdictions from implementing the recommendations in the Great Climate Action Plan. When anything happens, it's not the itself that counts as important, is it. It's a power that has to become something else. That's what is important. When anything is done with the class motto, it's coming. And I think it's important that we have a message across the board that our municipal Büchner hive has something to do with bunch of homework. We have to provideacz tune and so on and so forth, to really show our community that we can unite together. And we have to all get a affordable conversation so that we're spending time together. With that I just want to say very, very much appreciate you comments. Questions have come in for a few minutes. Sure. Thank you very much everyone and for all your ideas. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.


7:48 p.m.

We don't have to wait for it to be. There's power and benefit in being adopted, but it's not preventing those. I want to just point one. If you're not aware of this, this is a critical component of the regional climate action plan. It's looking at having a regional climate action committee. And some of the discussion to this point has been that will be HCOG. And HCOG is preparing to step into that role. But, you know, formalizing that really is reliant upon getting the initial blueprint done. Okay, sounds like we're leaning towards a workshop. We'll do a workshop on August 7th. Okay. Thank you. Anything else, commissioners?


7:49 p.m.

Thank you. Not for me. All right. Meeting adjourned. Thank you.