and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Mr. Giannini, welcome tonight. Take roll, please. Ivers Gobdall. Present. Noah Levy. Present. Peggy O'Neill. Sarah West. Here. Jerome Karazi. Here. Lorna McFarlane. Here. Todd Fulton. Present. Thank you. Director Ford, do we have any agenda modifications this evening? We have no actual modifications to the agenda. There is a letter that was submitted late yesterday.
Yesterday on the dais, I think was also sent out to you. It is for item number G3. Thank you. At this time, seeing no agenda modifications at this time, we take public comment on non-agenda items. So if anybody in the room or on the phone would like to address the commission on any matters that are not on this evening's agenda and that are under our jurisdiction, now's the time to do so. Please approach the podium or indicate by raising your hand online, and I will call on you, and you will have three minutes to address the commission. So I'll first check to see if there's anybody in the room. And I... Seeing none in the room, but I do see we have some...
Hands up on line. So the first one is caller with the number ending 3053. I think you press star 6 to unmute your phone. And you have three minutes. All right. You're now muted. So caller 3053, is it star six, right? You're unmuted now. Just want to confirm you can hear me there in the chambers now? Yes, we have you now. Thank you. Thanks. You got a little bit of technical difficulty, just a little delay lag time in the star six, but thank you for hearing me.
Thomas Mulder here speaking. I just want to bring up a couple of things that I just saw in the headlines. Yet another project that was spent countless hours, years in the planning department and planning phases is not going to be built in Humboldt County. So I just want to bring a really big red flag that in Humboldt County it seems like we get projects. We continue to condition them and condition them until everybody feels warm and fuzzy inside and then they don't get built or they get voted down on appeal at the board of supervisors. So just want to remind you the message of over-regulation and over-condition continue to drive away business from Humboldt County and it continues to make us in an economic downturn. It's really, really unfortunate. Humboldt County seems to file suit, not file suit, but follow suit with the situation that we're in right now. So I just want to bring a big red flag that in Humboldt County City of Eureka.
Just really want to remind you the city of Eureka on 3rd Street down there near Sisu. If you want to watch open drug use and crack being consumed, that's where you drive. That's actually where I take teenagers whenever they want to see what drug use is like. And just today, great city of Eureka going to the planning and building department which is in the city within the city of Eureka. Pull in the parking lot, get mean mugged by a group of four individuals smoking a blunt, openly consuming alcohol. So think about following suit of city of Eureka. Think about the over-regulation. And please don't condition things so my grandchildren don't have an economic future in this county. Thank you for the opportunity to speak. Thank you. And the next caller is identified by the yellow line. is Jax.
And it looks like, I think they were unmuted, so try, there you go, unmuted now. Hello, hi. Thank you, there's a bit of an echo. Okay, how is that now? That's better, thank you. Okay, great. So I am calling about the recent headlines about an Amazon distribution warehouse, and I just, I know it's not on the agenda tonight, but I just want to make a statement on that and also ask, like, how to get it on the agenda, where else, like, comments are being taken on this, how the other steps, like public input and the different reports on it. So I'll just read here some of the reasons why I'm against it. Amazon is one of the most exploitative corporations there is. For decades it has been clear their model is to undercut F&O, everyone in the market, forcing them to lower prices to compete, and eventually driving enough...
People out of business that they have a monopoly and start raising prices again. Any money spent buying things from Amazon goes directly to Amazon, not local businesses, and avoids local taxes our community relies on. Allowing them to add next-day delivery will only shift people away from buying from local stores. They support ICE, they help weaponize the military, perpetrate illegal union busting and unethical labor practices, and are one of the biggest polluters in the world. This is not the kind of economic development our county needs. A project of this scale affects so many aspects of our community and different local industries. It must be stopped until there can be a thorough public comment and research into all the ways letting this warehouse be built will be antithetical to the county's goals of bringing sustainable and economic development that lifts up everyone in the community, not just one billionaire, and protects our environment. Thank you. Thank you.
So I just, if I could get an answer to the question, how to get this on the agenda so that it can be discussed. Yeah, thank you. We'll take that after public comment. Okay, thank you. Okay. And I was checking to see if anybody else, I see no other hands raised. So I'll close public comment. And Director Ford, I'll ask you if there's anything. I'm sorry. I walked a little late. I did have a question. This is the Elk River. Yeah, we're not there yet, but it's coming up on the agenda. Relative to Amazon, there is an application submitted. It's currently deemed incomplete, so it's not actually being processed yet. The project planner is Steve Lazar.
If you'd like to submit comments to the county, you can submit them to Mr. Lazar, and he will bring forward all comments once it does enter into the public review cycle. Not knowing what's going to happen until we get all the information, it's really hard for me to say what all the public points of discussion will be, but it will require a public hearing at this planning commission. Okay, thank you. Yes? You said the planner's name, but you didn't give an email address. So the email address would be slazar, that'd be S-L-A-Z-A-R, at co.humboldt.ca.us.
Thank you. So that closed public comment. And at this time, next agenda item is election for the chair and vice chair. And I think typically we've had a practice of rotation. I think that's kind of up to the commission, but we do have a practice for rotation. So I'd entertain a motion if somebody has one, and we could take them together or separately, however the motion maker would prefer. I'll go ahead and make a motion first for chair. I nominate Commissioner West to serve as the next chair, if she's willing. I'll second. I'd be happy to serve if you'll have me. Okay. But I also want to acknowledge that if somebody is...
I'm really excited about the prospect of being chair. I would love to hear them out and give them that opportunity also. Thank you. So we have a motion and a second. Do we have any discussion or comments on the motion? Just I think Commissioner Scalabelli, you've done fantastic. I do like the tradition of rotation, so that would be in favor of Commissioner West as well. Okay. I think we can, I'll just call for a voice vote on this. All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Hearing none, congratulations. And do we swap positions now, or should I take up the next item? I would encourage you to take up the next item, and then you can swap positions. Okay. So. For Vice Chair.
So we need a nomination or a motion for a vice chair. And again, I don't keep track of order in these things, but I think Commissioner Curiazzi is next in line. I'd like to motion for Commissioner Curiazzi to be vice chair. I'll second. Any discussion? Commissioner Curiazzi, you're willing to serve? All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Hearing none, congratulations to you both. I'm sure you'll do a great job. And I just want to second what Commissioner Curiazzi said, that Chair Scovedale, you've done a terrific job, and I can't believe it's been a year already. It does fly by. Thank you.
Give me pointers of evidence. So you might want to just, there you go, switch your nameplates. Ah, okay. All right. And with that, we will take up the next item, F, the consent agenda. Typically, all the items listed under the consent agenda are taken as one item unless a commissioner or a member of the public wishes to pull the item. So I will first pull the commission to see if anybody wants to pull the item. I will go through each item on the list. And so then I will pull the audience.
And if you are in the audience and you'd like to have an item pulled, please raise your hand. If you're online and you would like to have an item pulled, you can go ahead and raise your hand on Zoom. Or can you raise your hand on the phone or do you need to star six to un... No, you need to star nine to raise your hand on the phone. Okay, and with that, I'm going to start going through the items on the agenda, consent agenda. So item one, review and approval of the December 18th, 2025 action summary. Anybody on the commission wish to pull this item? Seeing none, anyone in the audience here tonight? And anybody online? Okay, seeing none, item one stays. Item two, review and approval of the January 15th, 2026 action summary. Anyone on the commission wish to pull this item? Okay, anybody in the audience? Or online? Okay, anybody in the audience? Okay, anybody in the audience?
Seeing none, item two stays. There are only two items on the consent agenda tonight. I'll go ahead and make a motion to approve the consent agenda as published on the agenda. I'll second. Let's go ahead and do a voice vote. All those in favor, please say aye. Aye. Moving right along to public hearings. G1, the Elk River Estuary Planning Area 1 Restoration Project. Good evening, Commissioners and members of the public in attendance. Tonight, we're going to discuss a conditional use permit for the Elk River Estuary restoration.
project and that is the presentation that the project applicant will be giving once I get done with mine how do we switch the screen there we go that's that's my presentation so I'm just going to run through this presentation this is a project summary the project is essentially a large ecosystem wide restoration project of the Elk River estuary running from highway 101 up to showers Road essentially what we're looking at here is the Elk River Valley the Elk River is the largest estuary or tributary to Humboldt Bay Humboldt Bay of course is one of the largest estuary habitats in the state
California. Essentially, the history of the area is going back thousands of years. The area was inhabited by the Wiyot tribe. There was a large village located at the mouth of the Elk River, which is known to the Wiyot tribe as Hiksori, which they also named the river. But in 1849, Josiah Gregg and his expedition arrived in the area, had a dinner of elk, and named the river the Elk River. The project aims to restore portions of the estuary and surrounding lands to conditions that more resemble
those that occurred back before settlement by the white settlers. So there's 13 property owners involved in the project, a total of 43 parcels, which combined have an acreage of 984 acres. Parcels are owned by California Trout, which is the main project applicant, the state, the Weah tribe. These parcels will be subject to extensive habitat restoration and enhancement actions. Some of the other parcels will have lesser amounts of restoration, and some of the parcels will have very little and maintain their agricultural productivity. So this is a slide showing the overview of the project.
It's a little hard to pick out the details from this graphic, but we'll go into the project components in the following slides. So there's five project components, including infrastructure removal and replacement, estuary design enhancement, vegetation enhancement and management, beneficial sediment reuse, and public access enhancements. The infrastructure removal and replacement component of the project includes the installation of, I believe, 13 or 14 new tide gates. These tide gates are designed to allow for the passage of fish. They're kind of like the old ones are kind of like on-off switches, and these ones are more like dimmer switches. You can see there's a little gate on there, and they can adjust the...
the flow so fish can go back and forth easily even if the tide is going in or out. Also included is large woody structures installed in the banks of the river and the floodplain. This provides habitat for fish. The project includes public access features including, and we'll go into that in another portion, but it also includes removal of fences, barns, culverts, and buildings for the purpose of restoring these areas to kind of pre-development habitat values. Another component of the project is estuary design enhancement.
Looking at here is a graphic from the 65% design plans for the project in the Confluence area. The project is divided into 11 project sub-areas. And so the Confluence area is down near the Confluence of Swain Slough and the Elk River. And what you can see here is the red shaded areas will actually be excavated. And the blue areas, the fill will be piled. And what this is essentially doing is increasing what we call the sinuosity of the water channels that enter the rivers and the sloughs, which will increase the habitat value for fish and wildlife. Also, you can see the little blue spot is an island within a tidal. Pond. And.
And that'll be good habitat for birds. So this is just an example of one portion of the project. And you can see a little inset of a picture of a tidal pond. And these ponds are, according to the applicant, very important habitat for juvenile fish, especially coho salmon and other salmonids. This is a large component of the project is vegetation enhancement and management. The swain slough is habitat for the eelgrass. And the project includes enhancing and expanding the areas where eelgrass can live, I guess. And eelgrass is an important cornerstone species for kind of nursery of.
larval fish, crabs, mollusks, and things like that. So that's happening. And on the left, we see some pictures of existing conditions of drainage ditches. So when they came in to do the dairy farming in the area, they dug straight drainage ditches to get the water off the land so the cows could graze. These drainage ditches have kind of become silted up due to the fact that the ditches get filled up with these willow, clonal willows, and they capture all the sediment. And over time, the farmlands have been subjected to nuisance flooding because the willows capture the sediment. And this kind of situation is not... It's not a great habitat. So we're going to... The applicant proposed...
of changing the vegetation in those areas. A big part of this project is the beneficial sediment reuse. Again, we have kind of a heat map of the way that they're going to move the soil around in the project area. So this is one of the sub-areas. And you can see the dark red is going to be a new tidal channel off of the Elk River. And that sediment gets reused to reinforce existing levees and or create new eco-levees, which will protect the remaining farmlands in the area. So that's what's happening with the sediment reuse. And also included in the project is public access enhancements on the right-hand side of the screen.
You can see the plan there. There's two non-motorized boat ramps planned, parking areas, I believe there's two, and several trails that will be open seasonally, and some will be open year-round, with the yellow dots signifying kind of wildlife viewing areas for the public. So with every conditional use permit, we need to review the project for compliance with the California Environmental Quality Act. In this case, it's kind of an unusual CEQA situation. The county is acting as a responsible agency. And the State Water Resource Control Board is the lead agency. The State Water Resource Control Board...
The board published a programmatic EIR for large-scale habitat restoration projects in the state, and they determined that this project fell underneath that programmatic EIR. They completed an evaluation of the project and determined that with mitigation, the project would not have substantial impacts on the environment and was therefore compliant with CEQA. As a responsible agency, we've reviewed that determination and found it to be valid and are recommending approval of the project on the basis of CEQA. In that review, we identified some issues that needed to be...
Evaluated to some degree, as did the applicant, and one of which is the historic and tribal cultural resource. The area, obviously, a long history of human habitation by the tribal people. The tribes were consulted. The Wea tribes were consulted and have been consulted. From the beginning of the project, the applicant will discuss more about the timeline in terms of how long this planning process has been underway. But the tribe is an applicant on the permit and has a parcel within the project area. So they're going to be participating in the project throughout the execution of the project. The tribal cultural resource investigation was performed.
Essentially, the area does have a long history of dairy farming. So when sellers came in, they identified it was full of elk, and they identified the area as a very valuable grazing area. And at one time, there was 30 or 40 dairy farms in the valley. And the cultural resource investigation determined that that was a historically significant resource. So there's established a district to memorialize that dairy use, because that was a big part of the settlement of Humboldt County. And the project does include the demolition and removal of certain barn and farm structures. The project's conditioned to record those structures as part of the history of the area and have that archived for historical purposes. Thank you.
General plan policies. So part of our task is to determine if the project is consistent with general plan policies. The project is in the coastal zone. The bright purple line demarcates the coastal zone and that is subject to the Humboldt Bay Area Plan. Outside of that is the Eureka Community Plan and then overlaying all the area is the Humboldt County General Plan. One issue that we need to discuss is the policies in the general plan for the prevention of the conversion of agricultural lands. Although there will be some conversion of agricultural lands from agricultural use to habitat use, the staff may determine.
that overall that conversion is not significant on the basis of the project as a whole will preserve and prevent disturbance and destruction of ag lands from sea level rise and essentially the siltation of the drainage facilities and the nuisance flooding that's occurring in those areas. And the, let me just kind of catch up with myself here a little. So we made the determination that there's really no impact to the no net loss policy because the project will secure the quality of the agricultural lands in and around the project area. Zoning. Zoning. Zoning. The bulk of the project area is agricultural exclusive or agricultural.
Excuse me, Agricultural General. This is, in those zoning districts, habitat restoration is a conditionally permitted use, which is why we're here reviewing a conditional use permit for this project. So although this restoration is not an agricultural use, it is not inconsistent. With zoning, the activities proposed are mostly within wetlands, streamside management areas, and habitat protection combining zones. And these areas allow for the activities included in the project with a conditional use permit. So getting to our recommendation, staff recommends that we adopt the resolution, Attachment 1,
Which does the following? Finds the Planning Commission has considered the programmatic EIR certified by the State Water Quality Control Board and the determination made by the North Coast Regional Water Quality Control Board that there are no anticipated impacts to the environment that cannot be mitigated to a less than significant level. Finds that the proposed project complies with the general plan and zoning ordinance and approves the conditional use permit as recommended by staff, subject to the conditions of approval in Attachment 1A. So I think that will conclude my presentation. I have some additional slides and information on the historic preservation items if we want to talk about that. But I'm just going to kick it to the Commission and see if there's questions. Thank you. So. We'll start with Commissioner questions.
Any ex parte communications, I forgot to ask for that at the top. And then we'll go to opening up the public hearing and hear from the applicant, as well as any members of the public who wish to speak, both in person and online. And then we will close the public hearing and bring it back to the commission for discussion and a vote. So with that, commissioners, does anybody have any? Chair, if I could, just really the public hearing is open. Oh, great. Thank you. And it's public comment, slight difference, but this whole process is a public hearing. That's helpful. Thank you. Thanks. Okay. Commissioner Fulton. Yes, I have several questions. I believe in reading that thing, you're going to remove upwards of 30 title gates. Is that correct? There's at least 15 that are going to get. Replaced. So not all.
are going to get removed. There are some tide gates that are getting removed, but the bulk of the tide gates are being replaced. Okay. The second question is who's going to be responsible in perpetuity for maintaining these tidal gates? Well, the property owners would be responsible for that. If somebody else has a question. Commissioner McFarland? I had a question about the eco-levies. So just clarifying for the public record that these are levies that are not certified by the Army Corps of Engineers, right? I believe that is true, yeah. I think they're just – I think Darren can speak a little more about the eco-levies. But essentially they are – they're eco because they're reusing sediment from other parts of the project. They're not fill brought in from elsewhere.
So it's basically shifting sediment from one area to another to protect farmlands, and also allow for the tidal interchange in the estuary areas. Right. I just want to clarify for the record so there's not the impression of prolonged flood protection. And then the last question for that is, who's maintaining those in perpetuity? Is that also on the landowners, or is that on Caltrout? Well, Caltrout is a landowner in the project area. So they own two parcels in the project area at least, and they may own more by the time this is all done. But it would typically be the property owners would maintain those levees because the purpose is to secure the farmlands from tidal flooding. That brings on another question that I had that she had mentioned. Was there a study done on...
I guess it would be upstream flooding because you're putting in a levee made of silt, which is not going to be very conducive to preventing water from backflowing. It's made of silt. So what studies have been done to assure that surrounding properties aren't getting flooded due to this type of restoration? Well, there has been a great deal of engineering performed for the project. There's the 65% engineering plans, which I believe have been developed to carry flood water and tide water more efficiently than the current situation. The current situation is historic dikes and culverts that have been silted in a large part due to historic logging further up the watershed. All right.
And that sediment has clogged those and reduced the capacity of those culverts to move the water off the landscape. And so, you know, to answer your question, I'm not a geotechnical engineer, and I did my best to understand all the entirety of the project. It is a large project. We do have the engineer, the applicant's agent here tonight. Perhaps they can speak to the technical aspects of the design. But certainly the preservation of the remaining ag lands has been considered, and the existing situation in this area includes seasonal flooding and flooding based on, you know, tidal. Interchange and things like that.
that so it's it's not um it's not to say that this is going to fix everything for everybody but it will certainly improve conditions in some direction for for most is my belief okay with with that much uh soils and sediments being moved around and new channels being created what kind of studies have been done to assure that our bay aquaculture is being protected because there's no mitigating factors to the bay once it's been contaminated um the project is conditioned to you know operate only in dry season so flooding um will will not be a factor from may 15th to october 15th which will be the operating time period now um um um um um um um um um um um um um um um um um um um um um um um um um um um am um um um um um um um um um
What is the guarantee that no soil will enter the bay? No, the what, because we don't know what's under that ground as you disrupt it and move it. I mean, back in the day, folk used to splash down that and timber used to come out and all sorts of sediment and what have you. But once those ground is disturbed and opened up, the first rains that fall are going to flush out whatever's in that ground out. I'm not saying there's any contaminants in there, but we have a pretty pristine bay here in Humboldt County that is probably one of the only places on the West Coast where we raise oysters from seed, essentially. So I just want to make sure that there are tools in place to make sure that that isn't going to be contaminated due to a restoration project to the biggest tributary in Humboldt Bay. Sure. And I think the lead agent. Is the Regional Water Quality Control Board and they they're.
Our purview is monitoring water bodies and water courses for quality of the water. And they have included in the project mitigation and monitoring protocols to ensure exactly what you're talking about. Now, I think sedimentation of the bay is a natural process that has occurred for eons. So I don't think stopping all sedimentation is the goal of this project. But I agree that, you know, the protection of the aquatic resource of the bay is crucial to our ecosystem and our aquaculture. And I believe that the mitigation measures are in place to protect that going forward. And, indeed, project components, including fencing the tributaries off from livestock, will have beneficial impacts to water quality. In other words, you can't just put a lot of water in a bay and just put a lot of water in a bay.
Won't have the cows in the creeks or the cows in the sloughs, stirring up sediment, and obviously fecal chloroform comes out of cows. And so, you know, like the Little River up in the Trinidad area, that one's polluted or has been in the past polluted from cows. This project includes fencing and exclusion of livestock from those tributaries and sloughs. So I think overall the project has been well designed to protect water quality. Thank you. Commissioner Scaptal. Thank you. Through the chair, a couple questions, if I may. First one, and maybe this goes without saying, but I just want to hear it. All the property owners, I'd like to hear if all the property owners are supportive of the project. Of the work on their property to the extent we're doing different work on these.
Private parcels. Yes. All the property owners that will have work done on their properties, submitted applications to our department, signed applications that they are essentially co-applicants to this conditional use permit. Okay. Thank you. And then it seems like there's at least part of this project is similar to the project that was conducted on the west side of 101 recently. Is that true? Yeah, that is true. I mean, it's kind of an upstream continuation of that work. That work was conducted, I think, on the Eureka side of the border. And that was an estuary restoration project. This one pretty much starts Highway 101 inland. But we have the results. I mean, that project was constructed and seems to be successful and performing well.
And that one is even closer to the tidal interaction area. I mean, there will be tidal interaction with this project, but that one's closer to the bay. Thank you. And then I would also like to hear maybe from the applicant a little bit more about these eco levees. That was kind of a new term for me as well. But I think I understood them to be helping to manage the tidal flows, but not flood flows. So, in fact, they could be designed to allow water to go over the top during a flooding situation, but on a non-flooding situation would help control tidal flows into the sloughs and estuaries. We're trying to manage that. So, that's my understanding, but maybe we could learn a little bit more about those. Sounds good. Commissioner Kiryasi. Thank you. Thank you. I have a question regarding.
Starting the just the terms of the conditional unit use permit. I was a little bit unclear on It does a conditional use permit and include the allowing the conversion of existing AG exclusive zones or are we saying that On an at net as a whole we're actually preserving or gaining AG exclusive zones Can you clarify that? Well, the zone will not change the zone stands the same the the use in the zone will change from Well, you know in fact the the applicant did submit an act of agricultural conversion analysis and that was in the attachments, let me get which one but the Think that was
Thank you. Yeah, attachment 4A. But I guess your question is? Well, in that attachment, it was saying that a conditional use permit would be needed for the potential loss of land zoned ag-exclusive, as well as a special allowance for AG. But the way I read the resolution, it sounded like there isn't a net loss of land zoned as ag-exclusive, but there is for ag-general, and I just wanted to get clarity on that. Thank you. I don't think so.
So I think the important thing is that the conditional use permit is needed for the use, not really for the conversion of ag lands, because the habitat restoration is just not a principally permitted use in almost all of the zones on the property. So but there is a no net loss ag policy in the general plan, right? And so in our view, based on the analysis, this is going to protect and preserve the functioning ag lands. And so it's not really a net loss. It's actually going to enhance the existing agriculture. And so we don't believe that it's really a conversion of ag land. While some ag land is getting converted essentially back to habitat like it was originally, the net result is going to be to protect ag lands from some of the, impacts from sea level rise. That's clear.
Thank you. That helps. And just to reiterate back what you said, the conditional use permit is for the activities itself, not for the gain or loss. Correct. Okay. Thank you. Okay, seeing no other questions, we're going to go ahead and move to public comment, starting with the applicant or their representative. Typically, we offer the applicant or their rep ten minutes to go ahead and address the commission and answer commission questions. And then at the end of public comment, if you wish to come up and address anything that was commented on, we'll invite you back up to the podium then. Thank you. Is this on? Sounds like it's on. Great. And so I have a slideshow presentation that I brought with me this evening. I just want to start by thanking you for inviting me here to hear my presentation. I also want to start by just commending the planning department staff for doing tremendous work with us.
Over the course of the past several years, we've been engaging with the Planning Department on the overall Planning Area 1 project area, and then most recently the conditional use permit that we're applying for for the first phase of our restoration program, and sort of got behind the eight ball in terms of timing, and they've been able to expedite this project through the Planning Department permitting process really well, so just want to commend the staff for doing that great work. My name is Darren Maru. I'm the North Coast Director with California Trout. I'm the representative of our project team that includes several local engineering and planning consulting firms, technical experts, and also using public funding from the Coastal Conservancy, the Wildlife Conservation Board, and soon the NOAA Coastal Zone Management Program to implement the first phase of our restoration project. Andrew.
asked me to discuss some of the historical and timeline issues and public engagement that our program has gone through over the last more than 12 years and so I'll start with that. Talk a little bit about sort of the broad purpose for this work in what we call planning area one and then I can focus on some of the actions that are proposed in the conditional use permit first phase of restoration that we're proposing for this coming summer construction season. So this is our timeline of when I and my organization Caltrout and our partners have been involved in the Elk River. We started by invitation from the regional water quality control board to be involved in their TMDL their sediment TMDL program. We began in 2012 fundraising and conducted a feasibility study looking at the feasibility of sediment dredging or sediment remediation in the Elk River all the way from headwaters down to the bay. That's that's the timeline of what we're doing. Elk River recovery assessment that was completed.
in 2018. Alongside that, the regional board was conducting its own staff process for the TMDL program that ended in 2016 with adoption of that TMDL program into the basin plan. We were sort of collaterally part of that regulatory program, but we're not a regulatory agency. We've been providing technical support to the regional board. In 2018 through 2020, we started or implemented what we call the Elk River Stewardship Program, which was basically a major public outreach process to discuss the findings of our feasibility study with the public, mainly focusing on what we call river adjacent landowners, those landowners who are affected by the Elk River, its sedimentation, and where we would need to have permission from them voluntarily to work on their lands to implement some of the recommendations from our recovery assessment. That phase of public outreach and engagement resulted in our 2020 Stewardship Program. Elk River Recovery Plan
and that outlined the broad vision for restoring the Elk River not only in terms of its sediment aggradation conditions but also the habitat loss agricultural dysfunction everything that you know was part of that valley and those landowners that were grappling with and are grappling with the history of land use in this area in that recovery plan we introduced what we call planning areas it's about a 2,000 acre footprint of the Elk River Valley all the way up to the to the headwaters forest and into Humboldt Redwood Company property it's too big for one planning engineering design phase so we broke it up into four planning areas you can see those in the colors in the in the map on the right and primarily right now we're working in planning area one which we define as the lower valley and estuarine portion of Elk River that extends from highway 101 up to showers Road including the Alexander sea mist dairy that's at the upper end of the valley there
We are proceeding into planning area 2, which is the green outline area that extends all the way to the confluence of the two forks of Elk River in a separate phase of funding. It's about two years behind our planning area 1 activities, but tonight I'm just focusing on planning area 1 and happy to come back and share any more information that you would like on our overall program. In 2023, with funding from the Wildlife Conservation Board and the Coastal Conservancy, we completed what we call a 10% design report. It's a conceptual design for restoration, sediment remediation, vegetation management, all the actions that we're proposing that had support and buy-in from the landowners. And so that was brought to the public through public meetings and discussions with agencies and so forth. Then we proceeded on to where we are today, developing the 65% designs. And conducting our sequel analyses and obtaining all the permits for planning area 1.
which is that yellow area to the northwest portion of the valley. If you can go to the next slide, please. I just want to take a step back and address why we're doing this program in general, not only tearing off the Regional Water Board's TMDL program, but we know that coastal wetlands, including Humboldt Bay, are threatened by sea level rise and the land uses that have occurred over the last 175 years. We're sort of all grappling with some of those relic issues, and I cite here a study from 2018 estimating that nearly all of those coastal wetlands throughout the Pacific Northwest will be lost to sea level rise if we don't proactively address those conditions. We also know that Humboldt Bay has the highest relative sea level rise in California, and that's because the sea is coming up and the land is subsiding from tectonic activity, so that relative sea level rise rate is really overwhelming, and I'll show you why. It's just overwhelming the conditions in the lower Elk River Valley right now.
And some of our local planners, like Alderaan Laird, who I've worked with for many years, recommends what we call a managed retreat strategy. You've probably heard this term before, but sort of pulling back from those historic land uses and letting the sea come in and reclaim what we reclaimed a century and a half ago. And then also the last point here is we have a lot of aquatic species that are vulnerable to sea level rise and that habitat degradation that's occurred from our land uses. And so enhancing those adaptive capacity conditions so that the land can evolve with climate change and sea level rise that's coming in is our approach in this project area. So that's kind of the broad view of why we're doing this. I'd love to share this photograph because it does two things. It helps us orient to where we're talking about in the lower Elk River. So you see Highway 101 traversing across Elk River Road up. You see Pine Hill Road that goes up the Martin Slough Valley toward the Municipal Golf Course.
At the very lower right of the photograph is the confluence of Elk River as it heads out and the railroad bridge that's now the Hickshory Trail there. And you see the sort of apex of land use in 1948 when it was all agriculture. And it was just every stitch of land used for grazing out there. And that was really productive and important for Humboldt County, but has over time proven unsustainable. If you go to the next slide and you see the condition in 2025 from this Google image, you see the brown coloration of these green pastures that represents tidal inundation and seawater intrusion taking back this land. And it's unstoppable. We've seen this for over a decade. It's advancing pretty rapidly because of that relative sea level rise that's happening. This photograph also shows a really great contrast on the left-hand side. The west side of 101 on that City of Eureka's project site that was built in 2020.
You see the slough channel that was constructed there, and that property is now on a trajectory toward recovery because the saltwater is coming in as a natural function. On the right-hand side, on the east side of 101, the CDFW Elk River Wildlife Area was taken out of ag production, and it's been fallowed for several decades, but it hasn't been restored. And so it's just kind of laying there dysfunctional, and you see that kind of gold spot of hypersaline water setting out there. It's not functioning ecologically, and so part of our motivation is to help some of these public lands toward more ecological conditions. Go to the next slide, please. Yeah, and so sort of 10 years of study, we've come to the conclusion that these lands aren't functioning very well for any of these lands. We have flooding and sea level rise impairing agricultural productivity or wholesale taking them out.
of production and threatening those land values. So imagine if you're a landowner with those ranching or dairy lands, if you want to sell this land that's perpetually flooded every winter, the land values are going down and they're not going to be able to take that value back out of that land. So we're helping them in that regard. And I'll talk about that land acquisition part in a second. The community infrastructure hasn't been maintained over time, so all those culverts and tide gates and ditches and bridges that were in there, that were placed over a century ago, haven't been maintained. And so we want to come in and help with that drainage infrastructure, which will result in improving and protecting the agricultural lands that are still viable. And so that community infrastructure is at risk, and we hope to help it along and help the other agencies prepare for improvements as well. And then that relic drainage infrastructure is really impairing the recovery of habitat in this area, and so we're trying to give it a head start and bring it along so it can recover and maintain.
maintain the viable habitat as sea level rise comes in, climate change, and so forth. It can evolve with those conditions. This is a video. I don't think we need to play it, but it's a video of the property at the very western end of the valley. I took this photograph during the king tides in January, and on the right-hand side of that photo, those two posts that are sticking up out of the water, is the tide gate. The tide gate is being inundated, overtopped, and that water is flowing over the protective dikes onto the ranching lands that are still potentially viable, but it's only a matter of time before too much of that salt water comes into the lands, reclaims it, reduces that productivity. They have a timeline, and it's almost up. I'll talk about that particular parcel as well in that land acquisition discussion. This is just an example of what's been going on. We'll continue to go on.
into the future. Next slide, please. Yeah, there you go. You see, just it was tremendous and shocking to see how much water was coming over the dike onto the ag lands. So, just to boil down in a nutshell what we've been studying for the last, you know, four or five years and trying to develop plans to respond to, these are our key strategies. A managed retreat strategy and property acquisitions where those landowners are willing. It's all voluntary, but we have had several landowners come forth and be willing now. In order to mitigate the loss of some of the ag land values, we were able in the past acquisition to give some land back to the Weot tribe, and I can talk about that. And then again, trying to protect those remaining viable agricultural lands. We want to implement an adaptation strategy where we can start to protect some of those community infrastructures like the road. And the water lines, utilities, public lands, and so forth. And then improve that natural drainage pattern so some of those.
ag lands can persist further on into the future. And then, of course, my motivation and my organization's motivation is to increase the ecological resilience of these lands so they can support salmon and steelhead, tidewater goby, all the different fish and aquatic species that are out there, and maintain those conditions into the future. Next slide, please. So this land acquisition and land back part of our program arose out of that stewardship process we went through where we had pretty extensive discussions with the private landowners. And so the colors in this map are the different land ownerships. The green is the CDFW Wildlife Area that's been owned by the state for a couple decades now, and it kind of formed the core of public lands where we knew we could do some restoration, at least to start, knowing we had to protect surrounding agricultural lands. But as we proceeded through those conversations with landowners, it became apparent that...
They see the writing on the wall and took the opportunity to engage with us toward land acquisitions. So the brown parcels were the first phase of acquisition from the Pryor Family Trust. Robert Pryor and his wife Louise passed away during our acquisition process, but his son Chris continued on with us. We did a 1031 exchange, so they were able to take the value of the land and reinvest it in another place. And we ended up with four parcels that totaled 175 acres. One of those parcels on the west side of the valley was given directly to the Weot tribe. They call it Shwanishgook. It had in that loud 1918 ethnographic study a name there and documentation of a fishing camp historically, and so they are the owners of that parcel now and a partner in our restoration to come. The two other parcels are owned by Caltrout, and we'll hold them through the rest. We'll hold them through the rest of the restoration or soon transfer them to...
CDFW Wildlife Area ownership. So they will become part of the Elk River Wildlife Area. Caltrout's not going to own them for long, but we're sort of in transition right now. And then the other, the gold-colored properties, you can kind of see how they're in a strategic location in the middle of the valley. And many years ago approached Greg Shanahan about acquiring them, and at the time they weren't willing to relinquish ownership. But middle of last year they came forward and agreed that they would be willing to sell those to us. And so we are in negotiation. I asked Greg if I could present that tonight to the commission to let you know that we are currently in negotiation to acquire those lands. So we would, we being our project team and agency support group, be able to do the work on all of those properties over time. And we have seven. We have eight phases of restoration planned.
And significantly totaling almost 400 acres of land where we can conduct some of this restoration and seal overrides resilience and infrastructure protections. So that's our plan going into the future. I think I have one last slide. Yeah, so just kind of narrowing down into those two parcels that Caltrout purchased from the prior family trust that are along Swain Slough. So you see Elk River Road and Pine Hill Road that goes up toward the municipal golf course. This is the first phase of the restoration that's being proposed for this summer and is the subject of our conditional use permit. And so we are proposing to remove levees, restore those tidal slough channels, re-vegetate with native flora, put in some infrastructure protections, the brown dotted line. And along the boundary of the project is our eco levee. And so just to address...
One of the questions, an eco-levee is a levee that has a more gentle slope that can be vegetated and allow, as sea level rise comes in, the transition of habitats up to that top of the elevation of the dike. So it's essentially a dike that's gently sloped that can be vegetated to provide habitat for some of the sensitive species and so forth. So that's what an eco-levee is. We're also, through Caltrout's ownership, proposing to deed an easement along our property for the county to eventually widen the road and raise the road elevation if needed in the future so that it can be raised to not flood. So we just initiated that conversation with the planning or the public works department recently. Hank Seaman's aware of our ownership here and our future ownership. And so... As we own the property, it was purchased by the state. We're happy to help accommodate the county's future...
opportunities to raise that road surface and prevent flooding there. And that would extend essentially from the bridge that crosses Swain Slough all the way to where Elk River Road goes up the hill. We will have control over that whole road corridor, so that's not insignificant. And we hope with the funding that we have from the NOAA Coastal Zone Program to begin construction in 2026 with your permit authorization and blessing. So that's the last slide. I just want to thank you again for hearing our presentation. And I can take any questions that you like. Thank you. Does the commission have any questions at this time? Yes, sir. Can you just touch on the eco-levy concept, how that actually works? So picture the parcels that are out there in different land ownership. One of our key obligations is to not affect a landowner who doesn't want to have tidewater flooding his property. And so building dikes. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
key strategy for that. If we build a steeply sloped dike, it functions less well ecologically, and so having a more gently sloped dike allows vegetation to occur on that surface of the dike. So it's essentially a water control structure that has a more beneficial ecological condition to it. Thank you. Commissioner McFarland? I had a couple questions. So my first one was, it's kind of hard to read on the diagram, but your levee, are you in the Caltrans right-of-way, or are you ending before when you hit 101, or is there not a levee on that side? We're not encroaching into a Caltrans right-of-way. There's Hubbell County right-of-way along Elk River Road. But where the CDFW Wildlife Area abuts up to 101. So is your project going? We're staying outside of that right-of-way. Okay, so I guess my follow-up question is...
Is the project designed in a way in which Caltrans could change the hydraulics of their system and your project would remain functioning? And I'm partially getting at are you using any of this project, or is anyone using any of this project for CEQA mitigation, either upland or sensitive natural species that would be essentially flooded out if Caltrans changed the hydraulics? I don't know how they would change the hydraulics. One day if they were to raise the road or something, would that still be consistent? I just want to make sure that whatever future for that road is, is consistent, could handle more water. Our obligation is to design a project and to address one of the questions that came up earlier, how we've assessed flooding. We have hydraulic modeling in our industry. An engineer is obligated to write a letter to the county flood board.
Certifying, it's a stamped certified letter that we won't increase flooding in our project area. And so that's a constraint that we have to stay within. I'm not a hydraulic engineer. My understanding of this project area is that with the bridge and the breadth of Elk River, there's plenty of capacity to pass water out. What's slowing the water down right now are the dikes and levees and dysfunctional infrastructure, the culverts and tide gates and so forth. And we're going to improve that, but it all flows out through the Elk River, and I don't think it affects 101 at all. Okay. But so there's no upland mitigation on the site? No. There's no sequestration? Okay. Commissioner Fulton? Yes, I did have a quick question. Could you bring up the slide where it showed the levees? Yes. We're going to have to ask
trip to get that powerpoint back up um trip are you able to yeah it's gonna we're gonna have to find the slide that the commissioner fulton is talking about here just give us a whistle when you see what you're looking for there i think the slide was in the county slide oh it's in my presentation no it was in his it was towards the end it's where it showed the the brown lines of uh this one that one does show the levy next one keep going right there yeah your your brown lines there where your proposed environmental levy correct so within the boundaries of those levees are they going to be subject to tidewater flooding they will so the so essentially that ground
Not the roadside, yeah. So essentially that ground will be taken out of ag production. You can call it ag exclusive all you want, but it won't be used for grazing or anything agricultural because it will be subject to tidewater, correct? Correct. Correct. And I don't know if the county has records. If you go back to the photograph in Google Earth, it's been out of ag production. In other words, the landowner that sold it to us stopped their ag use on the land over a decade ago because of the intrusion of seawater onto the property. The intrusion of seawater. Was that because they were not allowed to maintain their levees and the culverts and tide gates? I don't know what their choice or the decision was. Because I found that's usually the problem is the permitting process to help fix your ground isn't conducive to maintaining it. So now we end up with a mess. Most of the pasture surface on that property is about elevation 5. It's very low. And so in addition to...
Seawater overtopping levees, groundwater is coming up and it's saline as well, so it's... But because the infrastructure is so dysfunctional, we have now allowed the brackish water, I guess we could say, to come into those lands and ruin that grassland, correct? I would say that's part of the process, but it's not the overriding factor of the process. So groundwater, groundwater is coming up regardless of how you surround it with dikes and levees. So I guess what my point is, is basically your proposed restoration project will essentially take that ground out of ag use. It's already out of ag use. Not all of it. Those parcels have been retired from ag use. Okay. I just want the county to realize that once you lose ag ground, you will never get it back. Agriculture is a huge commodity in this county still. So once it's gone, it'll never come back. Thank you.
Any other questions? Mr. Scaffold. Yes, so that picture in the upper right corner? Yes. Is that those same parcels that we're looking at to have the levees around them? Correct. And that's tidewater coming into that land that it's been doing that for over a decade. It's not an insignificant issue. I recognize that. So, and is that the area where there are the, we'll call them floodgates or tidegates, but they're being overtopped? That you showed in the video we didn't see, but were you... No, that, so if you see on the other side of the road, the greener pastures at the western end where there's like kind of a white speck, that's a barn that's out there, that tidegate drains that. It's the Pedrati Ranch that Greg Shanahan owns. That's where that...
like it is. So that green, we call it the pizza pie parcel, because it's shaped like a pizza slice, that's the last viable pasture right now in this footprint. And what I showed you in that slide is happening to it, and it's doomed. It's only a matter of time. And that's why the landowner's coming forward to sell that land. And so while we're talking about that parcel, that's a piece where people kind of park and maybe even trespass now. No, it's a wildlife area. It is a wildlife area. So that's where the duck hunters are hunting, and that's still going to happen. That's still a lot. We are going to expand that significantly, yes, through CDFW land program management, yes. Okay, thank you. And the public access will be expanded. We haven't been able to catch up on the designs for the, well, we don't own it yet, but there would be significant opportunity for expanding public access to that land. Thank you.
Thank you. I guess one more quick question while we have you. Thanks for the presentation. I just wanted to ask a question about monitoring, since that did come up in our questions initially. I've reviewed the vegetation and aquatic resources monitoring plan. Sounds like, I guess I have two questions. First of all, is it strictly the case that the monitoring will be up to each landowner or will Caltrout, as the lead force behind this project, maintain some monitoring responsibilities out a few years beyond project construction? And then the second question is, as this project is, the lead agency is, of course, the regional water board, are they, I don't see water quality monitoring per se mentioned in that monitoring reports, but I'm wondering. I'm wondering if water quality monitoring
Quality monitoring is actually part of their purview as lead agency to monitor for sediment levels, saline levels, any other pollutants that could be unearthed in the course of moving dirt around. So two questions, I guess. To your first question, the Coastal Development Permit from the Coastal Commission will have monitoring requirements for each phase of project that we construct. And so we do, as the applicant of that permit, take on that obligation. It usually extends about three to five years from project construction, and it does include vegetation monitoring. The Coastal Conservancy, who is a funder of our project, also has the CRAM. It's a bioassessment for wetlands, so we'll be doing CRAM. We're required to do it before and after each wetland restoration project phase. Mm-hmm. Okay. And where? Where we can. We like to do monitoring. It's...
hard to find funding to do monitoring. We will be focusing on fisheries monitoring. We're already conducting monthly seining and minnow trap surveys to identify coho salmon and steelhead use, tidewater goby and so forth. So we're already doing that in the lower Elk River and hopefully we'll continue. We tend to put a piece of the implementation grant fund toward monitoring. The grants last three to five years so we can do some of that monitoring post-restoration and then that involves reporting and so forth to the different agencies. So yeah we will be doing that kind of monitoring. Will that include specifically water quality monitoring? No we've done water quality monitoring both in groundwater wells and then in surface water for salinity and water elevation as information to guide our designs, our engineering designs and we can continue to do that. We can use some of that but we're not
obligated to by our permits and so it kind of depends on the funding that we have available we do have some funding in our coastal conservancy grant right now to continue that water quality monitoring we've maintained five stations with do salinity and temperature and then water elevation throughout that whole planning area one footprint i can't say i could promise you we're going to continue to do that we like to collect data it's interesting no no i do understand that it's hard to fund long term but it does sound like you've you've been gathering a fairly extensive array of monitored variables basically so thanks for hundreds of pages of reports of baseline data and that sort of thing yes okay well thank you um i'm gonna turn it over to um folks in the public who'd like to address the commission but i will invite you back up at the end if there are any questions okay with that um members of the public who are in the audience
If you'd like to address the commission, please approach the podium. Please come on up. And if anybody else would like to address the commission, please form a line behind the gentleman approaching the podium. Good evening. My name is Roman Salazar. I am one of the residents of the Elk River Valley. First of all, I wanted to thank Darren, Couch Rout, and the other participants of Couch Rout. They've been extremely helpful, and in the past notifying residents, reaching out to us, holding meetings over the last few years. So it's been extremely helpful to a lot of the people who live in the valley. So thank you. The first question I have with regard to, and this is a very, very multifaceted, difficult situation, so I'm going to keep it distilled down to what I think, speaking on behalf of the Tanglewood Homeownership, is where we're at, is there a number of concerns in terms of our residents and Acosta Community and other statuses that are part of this product? So what goals or objectives stand before us?
Association, which is a number of homes that are over the Berta Bridge, which directly cross about an eighth of a mile past the showers location where phase one or plan one will take place. Most of the homeowners concerns are obviously the flooding and access. Over the years, we've been informed of two things. Access over Humboldt Hill, the possible permitting of a development at the top of Humboldt Hill where we watched trucks go and a road go in and then a road get locked with not a whole lot of information as to whether or not Elk River residents would have access or an alternate access. Other... Other than Elk River Road. Elk River Road, as Darren pointed out, goes from 101 through the...
entire valley up to the end and there are many access points where there are hundreds of homes. Ours is one of the first which is over a wood cover bridge, birder bridge, floods every year. We deal with it, stay home for a couple of days. But in the last year we've seen engineers out at Elk River Road saying that they're doing surveys. We're not sure if it's Caltrout, the county, California, the state. We don't know. Just out there saying potentially they're looking at the possibility of raising Birder Road off of Elk River Road. We've heard that they're going to raise Elk River Road. We've heard that they're going to open the gate from Humboldt Hill over. Is there any information out there that any of the residents could access on a regular basis to understand what potential access there would be to the hundreds of residents that have to cross both Birder Bridge and Zane Bridge which traverse the Elk River. So my question is, is there any information out there that any of the residents could access
is really access. Any plans for access for any of us to know how we're going to get over the Elk River Valley during this restoration? So what we can do is we can take your question, and we cannot have a dialogue with you, but when we take it back to the commission, we can ask your questions for you. Great. Thank you very much. And I didn't clarify at the start, but public comment is typically limited to three minutes. You're good. Oh, thank you. Okay. At this time, is there anybody else in the audience who wishes to address the commission? I have some information I could share that pertains to his question. At the end, if we could have you come up, and we'll sort of have you address everything at once, if that's okay. Okay. So not seeing anybody else in the audience who would like to address the commission, I'm going to move to online. And just as a reminder, star nine to raise your hand, or if you're on Zoom, raise your hand if you would like to speak. And I will call on you. I don't see anybody online. Okay.
So then we will move back to the applicant who, if you'd like to come back up to the podium now. Sorry to have you sit down and then come back up. I just wanted to mention that the Regional Water Quality Control Board has provided some funding to Humboldt County Public Works Department to assist the county in assessing three different places in Elk River that are prone to flooding. And that's the Elk River flood curve, the Zanes Road Bridge, the other covered bridge that's in the valley, and also Berder Road. So Public Works hired our engineer at Northern Hydrology and Engineering, and they're proceeding. So some of the surveying that might have been conducted out there is related to that study that the county is initiating to look at flooding at those three different infrastructure sites. That's what I can tell you. Thank you. Okay. Okay. And with that, we'll close public comment and bring it back to the commission for discussion. Thank you.
And a vote. I guess I just want to respond to something that Commissioner Fulton mentioned, that once ag land is taken out of ag production, it generally does never go back. And that, of course, has been the trajectory. And we have a no net loss of agricultural lands policy in the general plan explicitly. So but from all that I have heard tonight, and I've actually been following the issue of title incursion and grazing loss and all that in Elk River for a long time, it does feel that this solution represents
I guess I'm not totally clear about the exact acreages involved. I understand in principle that by doing this restoration, by creating these eco-levies, the idea is to reclaim or preserve the most viable parts of the ag lands for those purposes. And because so much of it has already been marginal or lost, depending, I guess, on your definitions, that analysis that you sort of walked us through that's in the staff report, does that satisfy the requirements of the general plan policy? I mean, it seems that there's only a certain amount that you can do to preserve the ag lands for those purposes. And that's to prevent the natural loss of certain types of estuary ag lands. But I guess what I want to be clear about is...
Is the design here being done to essentially wall off and preserve those sections that are deemed viable, keep them in the potential ag production, and it's only those ones that have already been lost, are not viable, have not been in production for some time, that are going to be given back to the tidelands, the wetlands? I know that's kind of a rambling question, but there was a line in the staff report that said, you know, the Planning Commission must make certain findings in light of this policy. And I guess I was just wondering if you could elaborate a little bit more on the quantitative nature of those findings, like the acres lost, acres gained, acres preserved. Yeah, it is a very... interesting question, because you talk about the loss of agriculture.
natural lands and typically you would think of that loss being to development but in many ways this project is the opposite of development in other words it's the reversion of development to a natural state for instance orton creek was culverted and i'm not sure when but this is a creek that comes down from i guess the herrick road area neighborhood up there and it was culverted and has been culverted for a long time and it's silted and it backs up and it's a failing drainage situation which leads to upstream impacts the project includes the daylighting of that creek and the restoration of that creek bed for habitat use unfortunately that restoration will result in fencing off you you
up to 11 acres of lands that may have been used for agriculture in the past. So is it a loss or is it an ecosystem gain? And I think our viewpoint was that we're not saying it'll never be agriculture. If it becomes a path-critical item, you could graze cows on that 11 acres right up to the bank of that creek. There's nothing stopping a future civilization from doing that necessarily with this project. It's not like it's getting paved or concreted or built into housing or whatever. So it won't be used under this proposal for agriculture, but it's not saying in 50 years or 100 years if something happens and we really need that 11 acres, for grazing, it could be there for grazing.
So I think that was kind of the nature of my impression of the project and the findings, with also the understanding that the pressure from the ocean coming up, you know, that's a loss in some ways, but it's also a force of nature that can't be stopped. So not, in my opinion, really agricultural conversion, more just nature happening, you know, the way the world works. In terms of subsidence and sea level rise. So I don't know if that answers your question, but it is a philosophical judgment. And sometimes your commission is asked to make those judgments. So I don't know if Cliff or Director Ford has any input from there. Well, that was helpful, but if there's any additional comments. Okay. It sounds like...
What I'm hearing, though, is in the opinion of staff, we have, and from what we've heard, from what we've read, we have the facts before us to justify making that finding that is required for that particular policy. Correct? That is correct. Okay. Thank you. Before we get too far down the road, I did want to bring back the public commenter's question to staff and see if you had anything more to add to the question about, I believe it was mostly regarding access and roads. Well, the road in question is not in the project area for this conditional use permit. It is in that general area. We don't, we haven't had correspondence. We haven't had correspondence with the Department of Public Works in terms of their survey work on identifying alternate.
Access points to that Tanglewood area. So, unfortunately, I don't have much to add beyond what Darren had said about there are surveyors out there looking at the issue of access to that neighborhood that encounters flooding. Okay, thank you. I'll just make a couple comments, and I'll start with, you know, I like this project. From the fact that it's restoring the area, helping with the flood control situation, providing some public access, has the support of the property owners, which is important to me. And, you know, with respect to the Berger Road and the whole Elk River system, from my somewhat limited knowledge, but generally flood control, projects have to start where this one's starting.
At phase one at the lower end of the watershed, you can't fix the upper end of the watershed and send more water down in the lower watershed until you fix the lower part. So it has to start here. And I think the people that are working on this project, the engineers, have taken into consideration the future work and the other phases that are going to be done, ultimately upstream, when they're doing this project. I certainly appreciate the other commissioners' concerns. It's frustrating for landowners, particularly landowners that are trying to maintain their own property, to not be able to afford or be able to get through the gauntlet of permits that are required to maintain levees and dikes and tight gates. And then ultimately, after losing the battle, have public agencies and nonprofits come along later and say, well, we're going to have to do this. And I think that's going to be a big part of the work.
and take over the land and do projects. So I understand that, and I kind of don't know what to do about that situation here to make it easier for people to get those types of permits. It's kind of a separate issue. But I think in this case, you know, that horse is already out of the barn, and this project is beneficial to a lot of landowners, not only here but others upriver, as the full project gets developed. And that's why I'm supportive and just want to make that point. Thank you. First off, I'd like to thank you all for your presentation. It's not that I'm not in support of this project by any means. I think it's a great thing. I think it will. It will help enhance water flow from the Elk River. But I have lived here all my life.
I have seen what productive ag land along the Elk River has gone from being a productive bull pasture, right, which wasn't that long ago, to being swamped, to being now purchased by the state, correct? It's owned by the state, who has done nothing to mitigate the flooding or to repair the damaged infrastructure. And I think I heard a little something that you'd mentioned that once you get this project gone or done or close to it, you're going to turn it over to CDF&W. My concern is that CDF&W is controlled by a budget that's throughout the state, and once they don't have any more money to maintain the floodgates and the tidal gates and the culvert repairs, what's going to happen? We're going to be right back to where we started from. So I personally would like to see some assurances that this project, which I think is a good project, I think it's well-meant, is going to be able to be maintained. That is my only concern.
Hello! I'm going to show you how to make a Commissioner McFarland. Well, I agree. Working for the state myself, budgets are frustrating. I think it would be a little hard to assure that level of funding now. And as it's not a mitigation project, Caltrout wouldn't be required to turn the property over to CDFW with an endowment. So I think we'll just have to hope that the budget gets sorted. But on that note, with one typographical error to the conditions of approval number four, I just want to make a note there. The sentence isn't complete. So if we can fix condition number four, then I would be happy to make a motion to approve the permit as presented. And that's in the staff report.
Yeah, thank you, Commissioner McFarland. That correction is noted. That should read, the permittee shall secure a demolition permit for any structure over 120 square feet in size from the Humboldt County Building Department for demolition. Then with that caveat and correction to number four, I would make the same motion. There's a motion on the floor. Is there a second? I would second that, but I don't want to stop Commissioner Curiasi from commenting as well. Let's go to some discussion. Yeah, I think it's fine to discuss after the motion's been made. I'm also overall in support of this project. And maybe just to reiterate or repeat what's been said here, my view, I've taken a similar view where we're already seeing loss. I can't speak to the specific reasons on why we're seeing. Inundation and if it really is simply that land.
were not able to secure the permits they needed, then that is frustrating and that would be useful to hear if that is an issue. But assuming that what's presented is true, we've lost those ag lands, we're also gaining upriver, as has been said, by managing freshwater flows. So I am in support as well. I did also want to request a modification to finding four. The cultural resources section, if staff could add, mentioned that of engagement with tribes. There's no mention of tribes in the cultural resources section, so I'd like to see that codified in the resolution as well, if commission is okay with that. I would put that question to the motioner. Yeah, of course. I thought that was covered.
in the inadvertent discovery but if it's not then absolutely add it it is but i think uh the inadvertent discovery has the boilerplate you know if resources are discovered but in the cultural resources section under finding four we just talk about sort of um settler resources and we don't talk about the engagement that's been done with tribes as i think is significant and should be noted or i would like to see it noted agreed commissioner scaptal yeah i'm now understanding the issue and have a bit of a concern as well um regarding the maintenance of the facilities that are being installed and um i think uh you know relying on hope it's not going to work for me um that um if we're proving to put in some significant amount of resources that are being discovered and that we're not going to be able to um i think um if we're proving to put in some significant amount of resources that are being including tide gates and levees including tide gates and levees
To preserve ag lands, essentially is what I'm hearing, then don't we have some obligation to make sure that those structures and levees are maintained to some level to make sure that that actually happens in the future and that we aren't losing more ag land at some point in the future? So can we add a condition that requires the applicant to develop a long-term maintenance plan as a part of the program to submit to the county? This is a conditional use permit for restoration, and if it's the commission's concern to ensure that long-term maintenance is provided, I would add a new finding that that is a concern and that there needs to be maintenance provisions for the tide gates and other things that may be of concern. To the commission. To the commission, and then add that condition.
Okay, and again, I think the applicant may have applied that some of that's going to transition to the actual landowners, but will those landowners have a long-term permit as a part of this project that allows them to actually even do that maintenance? Because that oftentimes is the obstacle, is they can't get back in to do the maintenance that they need to do. Yeah, I think that's a fair observation, that maintaining the work that's been done shouldn't be considered new work, but is an ongoing process for this particular project. So we have a motion on the floor. I don't want to attend to that, but I also want to make sure everybody has their time. So I think the process now would be for us to clarify that you're asking, to amend the motion to add in that additional condition, correct?
I understand the concern and I would be amenable to an amendment such as what director Ford just described in that the property owner has a long-term permit so the development isn't considered new they can maintain it in time that portion I'm fine with I'm not in support of some sort of maintenance guarantee or financial guarantee from the developer or the restorer whatever you want to call them in the long term because that would be atypical of how we yeah I didn't I didn't intend to say that I said to have a plan for maintenance if that plan says to be maintained by the individual property owners then that's the plan as long as the individual property owners know that they're agreeing to that as a part of this plan. I'm not saying that they're not going to agree to this project that they're taking on some maintenance
Which they probably, a lot of them already have, but again, the challenge for them is oftentimes being able to actually get in there to do the maintenance. Yeah, I think that would be fair if we can condition this to allow for some sort of programmatic or some sort of pre-approved. So in addition to a new finding, if I could, through the chair. I would add a condition that prior to initiation of any work, the applicant shall submit for review and approval a long-term maintenance plan that includes provisions for allowing property owners to maintain the improvements. If I may add, Director Ford, I'd like to see that maintenance program discussed to roll with the land. Should the land change?
hands that that permit continues to run with the land it just doesn't dissolve because somebody it changes hands with somebody we can add that language no problem okay and so i wanted to say that first but um just kind of bigger picture permits run with the land okay sorry okay so um so for clarity of everything we've talked about can we reiterate what the motion on the floor is and then i'm going to check with both of you to make sure that you're good with all the changes we've made and we'll go from there i i did have i wasn't quite finished with my comments so i did have one other modification as well if but we would you like to clarify what's been done said so far um i think that commissioner mcfarlane do you feel like you're you're following along with all the changes so far or would it be helpful to reiterate what's happening so far i've got notes i've also
and director for taking notes so I'll let let you finish your comments in case there's another addition and then we'll summarize the the last one I think is pretty straightforward just on finding seven the language of the finding itself says conforms with all applicable standards and requirements of these regulations and I'm just being nitpicky here instead of saying these regulations can you specify what it's complying with and then it's you know somewhat repetitive but we're addressed we're clarifying what regulations were addressing in finding seven Is that an acceptable edit? For staff, we can absolutely clarify that. That makes a little sense.
Okay, so, and please jump in if I have any of this wrong. So right now we're looking at approving the, so this is a motion to approve the Elk River Estuary Planning Restoration Project as opposed with the following four edits. One would be the correction of the typo in the conditions of approval number four to specify the demolition permit at whatever building height is required. The second would be in the number four of the findings, edit that to include tribal engagement. The third would be to add a new finding saying that prior to any work, the applicant must submit a monitoring plan, including provisions for allowing property. Owners to maintain the development in the future. And the last one would be an edit to finding number seven, changing the term.
Regulations to specify what regulations are being conformed with. All right, and with that clarified motion, I... I just want to be clear. You said monitoring plan, and I want to make sure it says maintenance plan. Thank you. Sorry. Yes. Thanks. I do have a quick clarifying question to staff. And just to clarify, I guess I'm completely in support of adding the condition where we're allowing the landowners to maintain this infrastructure, and I'm just double-checking that's something we can just simply do. Like, I'm assuming there's a permitting process that has to happen with that. Before grading permits or anything are issued, there needs to be a permit that's applied for. Okay. And so that's why I mentioned...
prior to any work issuance of any permits or any work and then that is the catch point that they need to do that before either of those triggers are reached they need to submit for a permit to do that work and then you for review and approval yes right okay so there presumably there are additional conditions to that permit process i i i'm i'm curious what benefit the landowners gain from this additional the benefit is that it makes it clear that in the future if there are like a breach in the eco levy that the property owner would have the ability to repair that so that the land that has been preserved conserved for agricultural purposes can continue to be protected that makes sense i'm just i'm curious they would still have to go in and apply for a
permit to do that work? Possibly, but possibly not, depending on the significance of the amount of dirt that needs to be moved. Yeah, I guess that's, it's, yeah, that's interesting. I think I'm still in favor of it. Yeah, I just want to say one of the things that really does is that, you know, Caltrout will be around for a long, long time. We all know that. But if they're not immediately engaged in this anymore, and so then the property owners are left to their own devices to deal with this, this gives, frankly, staff and others in the future an understanding that it was, is the commission's intent that property owners be allowed to continue to maintain that. Those facilities. That makes sense. So technically, presumably. Yeah.
The planning department or the building department could deny a request, but with this intent kind of codified in the resolution, it makes it, you have to be very specific on the, much more specific, presumably, on the reasons why you're denying that particular work. Right. If, well, we wouldn't deny anything that is being redone in conformance with the original plan. That's the objective here. It's maintenance. If they want to come in and add four feet of fill, being facetious, to the top of the eco levee, that would probably be something we'd look a little differently at. Yeah. And the mechanism at which they do that work to restore it to its original condition would be up to the landowner. That wouldn't be something that you would have to approve.
If I might add, I think everything would have to be in conformance with the environmental documents that we're already reviewing and approving for this project. So you couldn't step outside what the permitting conditions are for the original project. Yeah, and I think, and again, I don't think I'm opposing this at all. I'm just sort of getting clarity. So would this also be a, the landowner would have the ability to just simply do that work if they were, if for some reason that work went outside of the original environmental documents, it would be a sort of land, neighbors are reporting something and then. So if somebody went outside the approved permit, that would be a violation of the permit. And. I mean, every really good immigration procedure we've ever done, whether it's a criminal process or experiences of criminal activity. That are simply Fair to state. Yeah.
We would approach that from one of two ways. It would either become something where our post-approval monitoring team would be contacting them and saying, hey, that was done not in accordance with the permit. You need to restore that. Or it could be a code enforcement action. The issue I'm concerned about, a common issue is after a storm event, silt or debris builds up against the outside of the flood, of the tide gate. It has to be removed in order for the tide gate to operate properly. If the landowner can't get in to remove that, the project fails. So those are the type of issues that I think we need to be able to do. And some tules start growing up in the silt because he doesn't see it for a while or whatever. It just gets harder and harder for the landowner to be able to.
Go back in there and do work. Commissioner Fulton. Yeah, I think that totally makes sense. I think I just wanted clarity on what the landowner is allowed to do under this condition and where the county would have to actually still be involved. So it sounds like, yeah, they would be able to go in, they'd be able to remove that sediment if needed. They're actively doing that. If for some reason their activities are falling outside of the permit, it's just sort of as any other permit, it would need to be reported. Okay. Excuse me, Director Ford. I don't want to sound like I'm splitting hairs, but there comes a point to where we're allowed to repair and then we're required to repair. Because if a levy breaks and you have a derelict landowner who doesn't choose to fix it, it could have some pretty adverse effects to the entire project. So I mean, I know we're kind of splitting hairs at this point, but...
I want to make sure that this project, if it's if it's passes and it goes forward, I would like to see it stay in a relatively decent shape. Absolutely understand. And I think that was one of the discussions that the commission, frankly, has been struggling with and maybe hasn't quite landed on is there's a fine line between allowing maintenance and requiring it. Thank you. And right now the language we have allows maintenance but does not serve. Correct. Commissioner McFarland. Which I'm supportive of. I don't want to put that burden onto a landowner for if they can't afford it, but also to should they decide they want to allow a levy to fail and allow that land to be converted, if that's their prerogative, it's their private property. So I would be hesitant to make it a requirement. Because these are... These are...
We discussed these eco-levies. They're not Army Corps certified levies that are built in with housing developments behind them. So it's just a bit of a different situation. The problem with that is if you allow your property to flood, which it's your right, right? But what about the neighbors whose property is being affected because of your decision? That's their choice. That's their court of law. That's their problem to deal with. I don't think that is our role to decide. That becomes a civil suit between two owners. And is this flooding an act of God? Is this flooding purposeful? I don't think that's on us. Commissioner Leamy. I'll just very briefly add. And I agree with you about it doesn't seem practical and certainly not our standard practice to require laws. And that's right. This question counts. It's important thing to point out is that it can be any of the things that You力 in the kimber that we say. Well, I always make that point that. It could have been rainstorms, rainwater elements being melted. It's done together. We think in the perch here in the center there's an residual thank you. And that's also a fallen paint on the, What could have happened? You could hear pretty many things are falling apart, but the only option that would just,
something like this. But I do think that this is a case where in addition to the minor changes, minor but significant changes we've made to the conditions, the applicant is hearing this discussion and obviously has given this thought. But I think that we would, I would just urge you as the organization that may or will eventually, excuse me, hand over the portions that you now own to the state of California, to CDFW, to give some thought to what would be the best ways to guarantee or help support the likelihood that infrastructure in public ownership is maintained in the long term for the benefit of the project. Which again, having invested the amount of effort that you guys are putting in this project, I'm sure you would want that to happen. But that is a concern that we're not necessarily able to regulate into this permit, but we encourage you to take that up. And my suggestion there would be find someone who needs CEQA mitigation who will pay an endowment.
And there's your funding guarantee. I'll just add to that the failure to maintain tight gates is a failure of the project. Okay. So we have in the service of process, we have a motion on the table and I didn't actually clarify with you that you're okay with all of the amendments that have happened. I re second that motion. Okay, great. Any further discussion before I call them? Okay. I'd love to do a roll call vote on this, please. Iverscobdell. Yes. No, Levy. Yes. Sarah West. Yes. Jerome Karasi. Yes. Lauren McFarland. Yes. Todd Bolton. Yes. Okay. Motion passes. All right.
It is coming up on 8 o'clock, so I'm going to call for a 10-minute break, and we will return at 8.05 to take up item G2. We're muted. We're muted.
Thank you. Thank you. All right, we are Recording in...
Progress. Okay, we are back. We are ready to take up item G2 before staff does their presentation. Does anyone on the commission have any ex parte communications that they would like to share? Yes, go ahead. I'm just saying I did visit the site earlier this afternoon. I did not talk to anyone, however. Okay. I was going to make the same disclosure. Drove around, just took a closer look at the site. Okay. Wonderful. Okay, then I'll turn it over to staff. Good evening, commissioners. Steve Lazar, I'm the planner assigned to this project. I have a PowerPoint I'm going to run through fairly quickly and go over the project. So we have a use permit and a coastal permit that are being requested by the applicant. The project is located at the Brake Hut, in the Brake Hut area. And we are asking both the law enforcement agency and ta of the law enforcement association over here to come to share their performance with us. And as Paul and Gary will mention, the consensus here and the consensus on the other part of this is that the response behovah. Okay. My sub performances are to follow the procedure. PRES. All right.
Permit a coastal permit deal with after the fact permitting. This is sort of spawned by ongoing monitoring of the site and engagement with the Coastal Commission as I'll get into in a minute. The property is bisected by a jurisdictional boundary which causes there's dual authority where the state has jurisdiction over the more westerly portions of the site and the county retains jurisdiction over the easterly. So in their ongoing enforcement efforts the county's been engaged in helping the landowners sort out violations and so this is sort of born of that process where we revealed there was a caretakers unit that had been constructed on the property without required permits and also that there was signage in excess of historical levels. So those are the two topics of the two permits that are being requested. So this is a vicinity map showing the area we're talking about the break up property is circled in yellow.
Here's another view of it and it's important to make that distinction that that while there is a coastal permit it only covers areas on the eastern side or the bottom of the screen of that line and then overlaid with the satellite image you can see how the more into the areas more interior to the bay or retained by the state and that has to do with a landform that once was at this location so the caretakers units circled in orange and I and I guess I'll point out at this point that the zoning and general plan for the property is industrial general and allows all the uses that are at the site with the exception of the signage that requires a use permit and I I'm sorry I will say there are some retail uses like the bakery that the department has acknowledged there's non-conforming uses surrounding retail that is an understanding of the area and it's a very big issue and I think that's why we're allowed use in the in just real general zone but that's not the topic of discussion
In green is one of the areas of signage. In yellow, we have another building with signage. And also in red here, that's an area where signage is occurring. So we're going to talk about the caretaker's residence real briefly. This is a photo of it from earlier today. It was built sometime between 1988 and 2000. That's from satellite imagery. You can see here, this is the zoning regulations. Caretaker's residences are a conditionally permitted use in the industrial general zone. And then in yellow and in the corner of the screen, you can see the location of where it is. It's interior to the site, surrounded by development and a fairly domesticated area. In terms of making the findings for approval, there's sufficient infrastructure on the property for a far greater amount of sewer. And then the water use is currently the situation.
with current tenancy. So the caretaker's unit shouldn't have any problem in that department. And for the reasons we mentioned, it's a fairly tame area of the property, so there's not any issues with coastal resources. So moving on to the signage elements, this kind of brings about that the county planning commission and the board of supervisors have recently adopted new signage rules. You made a recommendation to the board, and the board adopted them, and they are now in effect. So that happened during the processing of this permit, so we've had to kind of retool our analysis around those regulations, and I'm going to go over that. You can't really see it very well, but what I've done is using Google Earth, I kind of tabulated the amount of facade linear feet, because under the new rules, the amount of signage an owner can have is a kind of base level. Principally permitted.
out is based on the linear foot of the facade. So for simplicity's purposes, if you have a 100-foot wall, then you can have two square feet per 100 feet, but no more than 100 square feet on any given wall. So a 50-foot wall would have a maximum of 100 square feet of signage, and a 1,000-foot wall would have a maximum of 100. The only way you can exceed that is with a use permit. So in the case of what we're dealing with here, we have over 1,455 square feet of current signage at the property. 1,500 is being requested by the applicant under the use permit. It's roughly a small, modest increase, and I'll go over it in a minute. Mostly the signage is divided between three of the main tenants. And we have to also acknowledge that there is a non-conforming signage condition in the sense that there was some
Signage on the property historically that didn't need to comply with the regulations both the current ones and their prior versions and we would recognize given the past permitting and history of uses that 970 square feet of signage on the property is sort of baseline and is allowed to remain So it's really a difference between there and 1500 that the Commission's being asked to entertain today and this is just a historical photo from the 70s provided by the applicant showing the kind of how the property was occupied when it was it initially was mostly in service of like a lumber yard and lumber products processing Much more lumber focused and then over years since that time it kind of morphed into the current assemblage of uses So look looking at each each building and I was case-by-case basis. So here we have the bakery the fronds warehouse and retail and you can see how You know, there's a hundred
feet of linear feet on one wall line and 90 on the other. You can also see how it compares to historical levels, the mill yard when it was an occupant of that building and much of the site. And then here you see like the allotment that would be the base amount under the current sign regulations would be 100 square feet for each of those wall lines. And then here what we have is roughly 845 square feet. And I think if you compare the two, the earlier, the 93 photo and the 2025 photo, they're roughly comparable as far as the total signage. So it's really not a departure from historical levels in the case of this building. But it is well above the allowed amount under the current and new regulations. And then there's just sort of breakout in the table. So moving to the next building to the bottom right of the screen, in this area, the gable end, you can see there's a lot of different walls.
Lines collectively they would give you each 100 square feet of signage and looking at the current signage it's roughly 442 square feet along one of those cables. So it's consolidated on one wall line so it's over 300 square feet larger than what would be normally allowed under the new regulations without a use permit. And you can see in the 93 photo there was no signage during that milliard era. So if we look at the kind of tabulation here collectively there could be approaching 400 square feet of signage if you were to use each of those walls. They're only using one wall well one and a small portion of around the corner. And so it's not a huge departure in terms of the total amount of signage it's just confined to one area of the building. And then lastly this is towards the rear of the property and this is used by Baseline Garden Supply. And you can see this is a. Roughly 150 foot long wall line which represents 100 square.
feed allotment so this is an increase of over 300 square feet again above what would be allowed principally permitted and then this is just a historical photo from 93 to show that there was no signage during that milliard period so there is a master sign plan that's been prepared for the applicant and we are recommending that the commission approve that and that will give flexibility to the applicant moving into the future to kind of play with the signage allotments amongst tenants at the end of the day there's no more than 1500 square feet and that's just a small amount more than what you see on the ground today and then what they've done is essentially allocated it based on lease area with you know you know for instance 4061 that's the largest assemblage of buildings and that's the ones that have i think it was 400 square feet of signage and then the the the so they can they can mix and match but at the end of the day there won't be more than 1500 square you
We think that's a reasonable approach, and it's consistent with kind of the approach outlined in the sign regulations allows for that, the new sign regulations. And then I'm not going to read through all this, but this is kind of speaking to the language in the plan that governs how the tenants are to be controlled by the master sign plan. And then I want to get into one other signage element. This was born partly to address some of the concerns of the Coastal Commission staff from the North Coast Office, who, when the trail came in in the last year and was completed, part of the trail included basically a fence line along the periphery of the property where it abuts the edge of the trail right-of-way. And along that fence line, there's been some newly installed signage for controlling trespass to the property. And the Coastal Commission staff have concerns about that, and they want to see...
that removed or relocated or both. And we've been in discussion with them. We don't have a final plan at this point, but because it's going to require a coastal permit or at least an interpretation or a determination of whether a coastal permit is required, there's some ongoing discussion. So what we have in this sort of master sign plan is the concept, which is... I think I have a photo here. Yeah, this is looking towards the north of the property, and that's the area where coastal access actually... Let me go back to the earlier slide, where we want to basically funnel any kind of public access. There's not a formal public access facility on the north end of the property, but you see the area in the north... I guess it would be the northwest corner, but that area of tideland, that used to be lumber. That was a restoration site, and I think Supervisor Madrone was heavily involved, and it was a mitigation bank for a project in the city of Eureka in the early 80s. So that area is owned by the state of California, Coastal Conservancy, and managed...
You talked about it the last item, ongoing maintenance. Well, they have the right to come in and manage that restoration site. And so there's kind of an implied public access through that. That's the way the Coastal Commission views it. So consequently, they see the no trespassing signage as counterproductive to providing and accommodating public access. So essentially where you see Building 4061, some kind of signage in that area and possibly around the corner that would tell people, okay, you're going the wrong way, you've got to go north if you want to access the restoration site. That's the concept. So we're asking you to kind of buy off on that tonight. I know it's not a formal plan, but I think it's in general concept consistent with what the Coastal Commission and us have been discussing. And directional signs like that are allowed for. You can see the language below. So somewhere. Some targeted trespass signage towards the southern end of the property and some directional signs that would funnel any kind of public access to.
northern end and possibly an area identifying for parking and that and so yeah these are photos looking north and then this was a photo of it earlier today you can see there was a sign up already don't know that has a permit but it's on a neighboring property and that's for the restoration site and so moving into sequel for a second I think it's okay so we were saying that we determined that there's two different exemptions that kind of cover the range of activities the class one exemption covers in a minor alteration of existing private or private property and then the other exemption covers the range of public structures that's essentially what the signage is and it can't involve any expansion of use it's a flush mounted application in most cases and
It doesn't affect the intensity or footprint of uses on the site. So we believe that the Class 1 exemption covers the signage. The Class 3 exemption is appropriate for the caretaker's unit in that it's a new, small facility, and it's pertinent to the existing uses of the site, the commercial and industrial uses. So given that, we are recommending that you approve the project tonight. It does comply with the newly adopted and effective sign regulations. The increased signage is largely driven by the changes in tenancy that have occurred over time, where we have a much more diverse assemblage of tenants, and it's consequently a greater demand for signage. The scale of the signage, while it is rather large, given there's almost 70,000 square feet of buildings on the site, it's really kind of modest in that context. Our sign regulations don't give any weight to that, but I think that's partly why it doesn't seem overwhelming.
And then lastly, doing things like this that allow a landowner the ability to continue to manage and operate a property that, you know, they're trying to attract tenants is a valuable and important economic benefit that comes from approving development of this sort. So it's not trivial. Last, with the caretaker's unit, we believe it's warranted. And there's clearly adequate infrastructure given there was flow studies and analysis done of the septic system. And we've been engaged with environmental health on that. And it's not in an area that was problematic for development purposes. So with that said, I will remind you, you always have the option to go in a different direction than our recommendation. And in this case, we believe, you know, that could involve modifying the total amount of signage or the area devoted to signage or adding or deleting conditions of approval like you did with the last item. Or lastly, you can always deny the project if you don't believe you can make the required findings. However, we don't recommend. Given.
the evidence. So with that, I'll end my presentation and I'm open for questions. All right, I see Commissioner McFarland and then Commissioner Karagazi. I just had a quick question about the directional signage for the no trespassing. I get the public access to the northwest corner, but if the rest of the property is an industrial park trying to attract commercial, you know, trying to attract buyers, what's the point of this no trespassing signage? I think I missed something. Through the chair, it's a fair question. I think from what I got in the discussions, this came about during conversations with the Coastal Commission, and what I heard the owner say is that with the introduction of the trail, they really have a greater amount of concern about people seeing this as a place that they can park to take off from, or, you know, it would just be a much more accessible situation.
The zoning regulations control. So it's an opportunity to disclose the whole of the action, even if some of it is principally permitted. Okay. Can you, so the way I recall the new signage ordinance is that the hundred square feet is only applies to the front, the road frontage side of the building? And so I was curious why you were picking multiple sides of the building. I picked the sides that were visible from the road, not any sides that were west or on the west side. So I picked basically things that face south, north, or east. Yeah, I guess I wouldn't have interpreted that as frontage. But I also recognize the highway does kind of curve.
around the property. But yeah, I guess I just wanted to flag or ask that question. One question is the 1,500 square feet, can the property owner, we're already proposing that it looks like they're allowed to have that 1,500 square feet distributed as they would like, I guess in compliance with their master plan. And would in the future, would they be able to just take all that 1,500 square feet and put it into a single sign? Or how much flexibility do they have with that 1,500 square feet? Through the chair, no, they would not have the flexibility to consolidate other than by tenants. And right now, the way the composition of tenants is, there's just certain situations where they're slightly above what the allocation would be. And they have in the master sign plan that when, when leases are up for renewal, that they'll be required.
to bring them down. So we're comforted by the plan's pretty rigorous in the way it's drafted, and it definitely doesn't allow for consolidation under one tenancy. And then one last question. Do we have any sort of, like, coastal aesthetic or, like, scenic route things to consider? Yeah, there are specific maps in the coastal zone that define coastal view areas and coastal scenic areas, and this is conspicuously outside of the neighboring ones to the north and south, and it's not coincidental. There are general policies in the Coastal Act that are for protection of coastal views. We think, given these are all flush-mounted to existing abilities, they're not introducing new distractions, and they're not without historic precedent. Those are the findings in the resolution that reflect our analysis. Yes, Commissioner Levy. Thank you. Just a quick basic question, because we are still... Excuse me. Still fairly new. Thank you.
this post-sign ordinance era. Can you clarify precisely why this is even before us when there's not, as I understand it, a proposed change to the existing signs, or is that actually not the case? Is it to do with the fact that there was an unpermitted residence, they're sort of cleaning up the permits on the property at large, and so the old signage is now being considered in light of the new sign ordinance? So it is up for discussion because, and I ran through it pretty quickly, so you'd be forgiven for not catching it. Let's just pick 1993 for a moment. 1993, the mill yard was the primary occupant of the site and had roughly 940 or 70 square feet of signage in service of that. We view that
period as it was already out of compliance with our local sign regulations, our predecessor ones, but it goes back to the site was developed in the 50s and there were predecessor tenants and we had approved use permits and the coastal permits had been issued. So we viewed that as not conforming but legal. But then at some point between 1993 and now, we got to 1400 and change of signage, which is far above what was there and could be argued was legal. So that's up for discussion. I think that is clarifying because I think I was comparing it to what is legal now under the ordinance just made law a few months ago, but you're saying that under the predecessor ordinance, it was still well beyond what was permitted and so not legally non-conforming. And most importantly, sorry, through the chair. There was never any engagement with us when it was developed. So it would have required.
Consultation that never happened. Okay fair enough. Thanks I'm not even sure why this before us today. I still don't quite understand that and if the applicant was Needed to get permits for the signs that they already had that were grandfathered in pre-ordnance Had they come to us at the time the signs went in they wouldn't have had to comply with this today sign ordinance, correct? So why are we asking to comply with that now? Sorry, let me let me try to Incorrect, so The rules prior to to the new regulations were three square feet per linear feet of frontage not wall And the that caps out at 300 square feet under the prior rule
So they were well in excess with the 900, but then they increased beyond that without consultation with the county, which was further increasing the nonconformance. So if the new rules hadn't been adopted, we would still be bringing to you a discretionary permit to increase signage above historical levels. It's just now we have new rules, and if anything, the floor went down. So it went from 300 to 100 per wall, and they're on each wall. So it's just gotten less conforming. All right. And then the other comment I have is regarding access to the parcel that's apparently being maintained for public. To me, it's a maintenance easement, right, that we're now, because we put a trail in front of it, are proposing to allow the public to access that area on bike or foot, whatever, however, or roadside. Roller skates. Roller skates.
skateboards or however they're using the trail. If that were any other development project we'd ask you to put in a sidewalk and a bike lane maybe ADA parking in a restroom if it's going to actually be public access. I don't particularly like the idea of a commercial industrial park now being pushed to provide public access through their land because we put a trail in front of it and there's looks to me like there's a lot of frontage where if you want to trail access to that particular piece of land they could go through the process to connect the trail on the northern northerly portion so that we don't have a conflict a safety issue with the public and the industrial commercial use. So so so
We need to condition it as we'd condition any other project that's going to have bicycles and pedestrians going into that area. Through the chair. I think I misspoke earlier in that it's really not the applicant's goal to provide a public access point. They're not being required to. In discussions with the Coastal Commission, it was suggested that directional signage might help achieve the applicant's objectives of not having people come onto their property that are not supposed to be there. Or if they are coming onto the property, go to the appropriate areas. It may not be the final version of how do we deal with this, but that is what we were discussing with the coastal staff. Because the coastal staff doesn't like to see no parking, no access signage, because it frustrates that. That goal of the Coastal Act. So there's a tension there, and it's just trying to solve it through targeted signage and potentially directional signage.
But maybe not because it's ultimately subject to engagement with coastal staff. Yeah, it's just that if we're directing somebody into an area that is unsafe or isn't suitable for bicycle or pedestrian traffic, then we're not meeting our objectives. If I could, I completely hear what you're saying, Commissioner Schapel. One of the concerns I have is we may be getting outside what's really before the commission right now, which is not whether there should be access to that area or not. We're really talking about the signage that's there. And if there is a public access point that's required, that will be an entirely different process. Okay. But this came to us because the applicant wants to put up. A sign. Well, I think. Limits access and we were told that the Coastal Commission is having an issue with that. Correct.
Correct. So I want to be clear, at least in my commentary, to let the Coastal Commission know that we have some concerns if they're going to try to push access through that way, that they need to make sure that they, if they're going to support a trail and provide and encourage access through private property or commercial industrial space, then they're going to need to comply with the requirements for that. Message received. Okay. Commissioner Fulton? Okay. Any other questions for staff before we go to public comment? Okay. Well, at this time, then, we'll move to the public comment portion. First, we're going to invite the applicant or the applicant's representative up to the podium to speak. We traditionally give you about 10 minutes, and may ask some questions of you, and then we'll open it up to...
The general public, in person, and then online, and then once everybody's had a chance to make their comments, then if there are any additional questions or you'd like to address anything that was said in public comment, we'll invite you back up to the podium. Okay, excuse me. Good evening, commissioners. Thank you for having me. My name is Kristen Orth-Gordoneer. I'm an environmental planner at GHD. I'm the applicant's representative today. Mr. Hess and I have been working for a bit over a year to bring his property into compliance with both county and coastal policies. We have been working diligently with Mr. Lazar, who has been incredibly helpful in sorting through the site's long history of supporting local businesses as well as development. And we're continuing to meet with the Coastal Commission as well.
address some of the access concerns and any other concerns they have on the project so more meetings to come on that but this is a great first stage to help us get get the property into compliance and i you had some questions that i could just kind of start to address um the signage master plan for the no trespassing comment um it does include both no trespassing and also like patrons only only parking so we do want to you know encourage people to park in the appropriate locations um let's see as far as the coastal and aesthetic questions the signage master plan does include restrictions on things like reflections and lighting digital signage things that are flashing things that we thought could disrupt any sort of you know coastal resources so we did include those restrictions um as well and then um i have a question um in the face of I realize that as we have came to the second let's see for the
Coastal access question. There is a requirement for an easement on the property to the coastal access conversation came about mostly because actually of the state coastal conservancy's marsh project and access to that not related to the trail that was recently put in. When that project occurred the state coastal conservancy's project there were conversations about creating an easement on the industrial property to provide coastal access. That easement was never recorded so we're now in talks with the coastal commission on recording that easement. You brought up some interesting points about location that maybe we'll talk to them about you know like northern access and we're obviously considering safety and potentially conflicting uses with with the industrial uses that are occurring on site and providing people with safe public access to that kind of northern portion. So hopefully that starts to you. Get at some of the questions you are.
I'm available for any other. Go ahead, Commissioner Karazi. Can you clarify, do you know if the easement discussions were related to specifically maintenance or for public access or for both? It was actually for monitoring of the site. And coastal has alluded to additional coastal access being kind of implied. Thank you. Okay. I'm not seeing any other questions from the commissioners. So thank you very much. And I will at this time invite anybody. There's no one else in the room. So we would traditionally invite folks up to the podium, but seeing no one in the audience. I'm looking online to see if anybody is interested, but I'm not seeing anybody online either. So we will go ahead and close public comment.
Get back to the commission for discussion and consideration of the vote. Commissioner Kirozzi. Kind of going to Commissioner Scavdahl's comments and maybe looking to staff to see if I'm formulating this correctly but I guess I had reading this agenda item I'd assumed it was kind of similar to utility needing access to a project like PG&E needs access and so you have a bunch of signs saying no one allowed don't come in then it could potentially be confusing and is that kind of where this is coming from keeping it to the signage portion. I think the agent mentioned what I was trying to say earlier which is that in meetings with coastal staff they interpret the access easement for maintenance or not maintenance but monitoring purposes to be. Broader than what.
others might read it as and consequently any signage that would that would discourage the public's access to the northern portion of the site would be you know contradictory to that interpretation there's a struggle there if it's helpful context for projects I've worked on the Coastal Commission always considers historical informal access to be something that has to be maintained and it doesn't have to be moti modal or as you were saying Commissioner Scavital by pedestrian it can be a single use single type use it could be just pedestrian the access type can change like maybe historically cars were going somewhere and now it's only pedestrians but on all projects I've worked on historical informal access is seen as something that has to be preserved But getting back to the science square footage.
Which I think is the crux of the issue. So we're really looking at like a hundred square feet difference, right? 14 something to 15? Technically from 900 to 1500, but right now it's sitting at 14. Okay. Could I just jump in for a minute, Chair? I think one of the things that the commission also needs to kind of replay the tape to the discussion on the sign ordinance, which is to allow these master sign plans to deviate pretty freely from those sign areas that are principally permitted. And so this is not unintended to allow this kind of creativity and expansion of sign areas. So I just wanted to say that you spent a lot of time working through that and developing that as part of the ordinance. Which I don't know if you're going to know this, but...
We did deviate on the U-Haul signage. We increased their, you don't know that total, I mean if it wasn't some obscure number right? Some massive number. It was a pretty, it was more signage than just would have been allowed for individual tenants, that is correct. But that is a center that did have a prior, it wasn't called a master sign program at the time but it was really converted to a master sign program when it came back to the Commission. And so that's when, because there's multiple tenants in there, the Commission modified that to allow for U-Haul. I really appreciated the way that we approached the sign regulations because it did allow for us to consider context in situations such as this one where they believe Mr. Lazar said that
The signage that's up there doesn't quite feel as big as it would otherwise because of the massive amount of building and space. And for me, that's really helpful context when considering this particular conditional use permit. I think based on that and the fact that the applicant's agent confirmed the other considerations in the ordinance were accounted for, so the lighting, the flashing, the distraction, all of that, I would feel comfortable. I'm making a motion to approve the project as presented with a minor edit to one of the conditions of approval, just a typographical error. But before I make the motion, is there anything anyone wants to add? Question here. I'm supportive. I think I'm a little bit hesitant to sort of setting a precedent of counting three of the conditions.
Four sides of a building. I think we just sort of leave it as the frontage is the starting point, and if we want to increase it, we can. And I am in support of the amount of signage. I went out there. I don't think it's excessive at all, plus it's an industrial site, and I think the signage being proposed is appropriate. And then I did have a question regarding, because this also includes the caretaker unit, I'm assuming it looked like they have to apply for a building permit, and the building permit will address all the health and safety requirements there for a building. In that case, I'll go ahead and make a motion to approve item number two, breakout industrial park caretaker's unit and expanded signage, as presented in the staff report with a minor edit to condition of approval number five. There's an asterisk after evidence, but there isn't a . I'm sorry.
Legend later in the document to explain the asterisk. There's a bullet which might be it but so with that minor edit that's my motion. I'll second. Okay I have a motion and a second. Is there any more discussion before I call a vote? All right may we please get a roll call vote. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Wonderful. Motion passes. Okay. And that brings us to item G3. And while staff is pulling up their presentation, does anybody have ex parte communication? Does anybody have ex parte communication regarding this item?
Thank you. Well, I guess I should note that I was on the property once or twice many years ago, but under the current owner when it was just getting started as a bamboo nursery. Chair West, members of the Commission, good evening. My name is Steven Santos, senior planner, presenting the Plant Humboldt LLC project, which is a special permit for an existing wholesale and retail cannabis nursery. And the project also involves a zoning reclassification from C1, neighborhood commercial, to AG, Agricultural General. The project is in the Brysland
area and here's a close-up from our GIS coming up and it's been in operation as a nursery since 2005 where it was a bamboo nursery and then converted to a cannabis nursery around 2012 it takes access from Bryce on Thorn Road which is County maintained and we can tell from this photo that the main issues that we analyze the staff were setbacks to adjoining neighbors there was a setback to a school bus stop as well as setback to streamside management area and I'll get into all of those later in my presentation so I'm gonna proceed with this presentation sort of in two parts because this project has two parts so I'm going to talk about the different parts of the project and then I'm going to talk about the zoning reclassification first and then I'll talk about the nursery so as mentioned the zone reclassification is from
See one to A.G. and three findings need to be made that the reclassification is in the public interest that the reclassification is consistent with the general plan and that it does not reduce residential density. So I'll go through these one by one. It is arguable in the that the project is within the public interest because a nursery it's OK for a nursery to operate on the site a non cannabis nursery. So it makes sense to allow a cannabis nursery that's already operating to continue operating. And there is a need for cannabis nurseries to support the local industry. There are other cannabis operators. There are other cannabis operations permitted cannabis operations in the vicinity and there would be no impacts on roads or adjoining parcels. And this parcel was actually previously zoned A.G. and then it was rezoned to C1.
to facilitate the construction of a mini storage that never got built. So the proposal is basically to put it back to what it was back in the day. As far as general plan consistency is concerned, I just want to also point out that there is no general plan amendment requested or needed. We're just talking about a zone change. For the rural community center RCC land use type that applies, the nursery would be considered as general agriculture, so it's allowed. And the proposed AG zone is consistent with the RCC designation per the zoning consistency matrix from the land use element of the general plan. So it is consistent with the general plan. The proposal is consistent. And there's also, staff believes there's no reduction in residential density by the proposed rezone. It does not. It does not reduce the residential density. Thank you.
Any parcel below the inventory parcels not included in the inventory and the reason AG would actually make family dwelling a principally permitted use. Moving on to the to the nursery as I mentioned before this is an existing nursery which is a little bit unusual. It's for 10 thousand square feet both wholesale and retail approximately 160 thousand gallons per year of water is estimated to be used which would come from an existing rainwater catchment pond. The pond has a capacity of approximately 250 thousand gallons and power is provided by PG&E. Here is a copy of the site plan for the project and we see the polygon in green down in the southwest corner. That is the. Can. Of this nursery. Pretty much snuggled into that that corner.
There and the corner of the curvature of the road. The adjoining neighbors all provided setback waivers in terms of the distance that needs to be between a cultivation site and residences. The school district provided a setback waiver to the bus stop which was an extra bonus because under the CCLUO with the special permit we could have granted a waiver to the bus stop. But the fact that the school district provided one in writing is a bonus. And then a biological assessment was provided prepared by a qualified biologist that supports a reduction in the stream site management area. That biological assessment did make a series of recommendations and all of those recommendations are included in the permit conditions of approval. So this graphic is from the biological assessment.
The blue line is the creek, Redwood Creek, and the green line is the high water line. The purple lines are where the streamside management area boundary is right now, under current standards and regulations, and we see that right now the site is not quite operating under compliance when it comes to the streamside management area because part of the driveway access and the, let's see if I can use my cursor as a pointer, no, it's not working, and then the parking area, which you can see kind of flush to the west side, are within the streamside management area, and then the existing streamside management area also cuts through the residence and some of the curtilage of the residence. The gray line just to the east represents the recommended alteration of the streamside management area. And so this would...
allow the parking area to be compliant and everything else to the west of that proposed gray line. This recommendation and the biological assessment has been reviewed by staff and it's been reviewed by California Department of Fish and Wildlife and both support this this recommendation. It's consistent with the existing site conditions because we need pretty much get west of the proposed new boundary. Its compacted and disturbed and is part of my operation. No public comment received on the project. Late yesterday afternoon we did receive a letter from the applicant approved by crews in St Josem Naturall Reporting Center inveceor is here or online making a written request to remove recommended conditional approval on the new policy where roads and normal transportation and the� So this is a modification of the proposed gray line and its four to nine square foot Пp nogle counties that were in full as far as pictures up to 25 and close. A8C and I've
We produce that condition on screen and that portion of condition 8 is that a physical barrier demarking the location of the revised stream site management area be constructed. This specific condition was made at the request by city FW. The applicant stated in their letter and I'm summarizing here that the proposed fence or physical barrier I'm calling it a fence but the language is physical barrier would block nursery parking and parking behind the residents make turning around more difficult block access to non-public part of the nursery where storage and loading occurs. Make maintaining vegetation for fire hazards would be more difficult and not provide a benefit as areas not wildlife habitat. Before I get into staff response. This is to the applicant request I want to bring.
This graphic back and point out that. If the commission chooses to adopt the staff recommendation and the biologist recommendation to reduce the streamside management area it will actually increase the available of the parking area and make it compliant. It will take the residents and the curtilage around the residents outside of the streamside management area. So having said that I also want to point out that if it's the applicant's intent to park behind the residents there should not be parking within the streamside management area. And so part of having a physical barrier is to just make sure that as the site's being used day to day and customers are visiting and things like that to make sure that development and impacts and uses and operations aren't occurring. Within the management area. As far as making things.
more difficult to turn around. I've been on site. If the commission approves the reduced streamside management area, it will actually allow that full parking area that's open and exposed to be used. So there's going to be adequate space to turn around. As far as blocking access to portions of the property where storage and loading occurs, again, storage and operations should not be occurring within the streamside management area. And as far as maintaining vegetation for fire hazard being more difficult, the physical barrier does not necessarily have to be constructed where it prevents any and all access. I mean, gates can be built and things can be done to allow access if it was needed. And I'm not really sure what the fire hazard would be. And if it were to occur in that area, it would be within the streamside management area. And there would need to be some additional consideration.
and consultation if that were to occur. And finally, that the area is not wildlife habitat. Well, the whole purpose of the streamside management area, as everyone knows, is to protect riparian ecosystems and the services they provide, whether it be wildlife corridors or direct habitat, things like that. So the fact that there might be some portions of the reduced streamside management area that aren't serving wildlife, the fact that there's a buffer does serve those purposes and policies. So staff is not recommending that the commission remove that condition for a physical barrier. Because, again, having been on site, it would be really easy to park a car or back into or store something in the SMA without something marking its location. So. Staff is recommending the commission consider the final.
EIR adopted for the CCLUO and the addendum prepared for the project make the required findings for approval according to Humboldt County Code approve the plant Humboldt special permit subject to the conditions of approval and recommend the Board of Supervisors approve the rezoning of the parcel from c1 to AG so if the Planning Commission approves these recommendations there will be one more step for me and the applicant to go to the Board of Supervisors to complete that zone reclassification and that concludes my presentation available for questions thank you it's just I think a moment of clarification before we do Commissioner questions um I believe we have the applicant on zoom Michael just and we will get to the applicant in the beginning of public comment after Commissioner questions just I see their hand is up and we will will come to you shortly with that I'm gonna turn it over to Commissioner questions thank you
I have a few questions, clarifying questions. First off, you said it was originally zoned ag, correct? And then rezoned residential so they could put in a mini storage, is that correct? Partially correct. Through the chair, it was originally zoned ag and then rezoned to the current zoning, which is C1, neighborhood commercial. Okay, correct. So and then am I to understand that they have a permitted marijuana grow on there for 10,000 square feet? Is that what I saw? Up until December 31st of 2025, they were operating under an interim permit, but all interim permits have expired. And so the action, if the commission approves the proposal today, they would be given a special permit to continue operating. In a C1 zone.
Once the AG rezone is affected. But they got permit for C1 currently, correct? They were allowed to continue operating under an interim permit because they were pre-existing at the time. Okay. If I could, Chair. One of the things we did, and I know this is probably hard to start to get your mind wrapped around it if you haven't been doing it for 10 years. But is that when we came to the point in 2018 when the state was going to start issuing licenses, they weren't going to issue licenses unless there was a local permit. So in order to allow our cultivation industry to get state licenses, we issued interim permits based upon what was existing at the time. Okay. And there was a whole...
cycle of things that we did to demonstrate what was existing. And so this is a little bit unique because it's a nursery, but they did get an interim permit. And so some of what we did is for the interim permits, we didn't prove that there were little lots. We didn't prove that they could, that the zoning was correct. We really waited until the actual permit was being processed to prove all that. So now that we're coming forward with the permit, all of that is being proved. So in that permitting process, which they were granted, was the pond permitted as well? The pond was preexisting. Preexisting? Yep. When it was ag or was it developed during the C1? It was developed during the C1. And part of the contract. The conditions of approval for the nursery would be that the applicant would need to get an after-the-fact grading permit.
for the pond. Thank you. Go ahead. Thanks. Yes, just want to follow up on the question of the physical barrier along the reduced stream site management area. I know it's a small parcel. It's tight. But I don't recall that typically being a requirement of or even a recommendation of CDFW review of cannabis projects to actually put a physical barrier up to demarcate the street, the SMA. I guess I just wanted to understand a little bit more either from your perspective or from CDFWs why they felt that condition wasn't. I don't think that's as important in this case when I don't think that would be a standard condition. Through the chair, I have sort of a two-part response.
I mean one is one of the things that was noted by both staff and CDFW during a joint site visit was that there were uses and operations occurring right up to the top of bank. And as you mentioned, the site has a funky configuration and is kind of tight. So it's really easy to step outside the boundary and operations are occurring within the boundary now. And so part of the reasoning as I understand it from CDFW is it'll help ensure that that does not continue. But it's also my understanding, and I'll let my planning manager clarify if I'm wrong, that in other instances in which the county has granted a special permit for reduced SMA boundary, that it's not unusual for that. To include some sort of demarcation or barrier.
Okay. So we know, so the owner knows and the people using the site know exactly where that is. Even though you're under X foot from the creek, we've got a fence that sort of shows that this was done on purpose. Okay. Just a quick follow-up on that because it's been a while since I looked at the details of it. Obviously, you can't construct buildings in, you can't pave. I mean, I know you can't do those things, but what uses are permitted, if any, of a streamside management area? Other than, let's say, ecological restoration, that would probably be permissible. That is probably the best description of what you can do in the SMA. Okay. So, I mean, my question was simply about, like, yeah, if you're, I can certainly understand the logic of not parking vehicles. Vehicles, you know, drip hydrocarbons and so forth. But if.
If you were storing some sort of organic materials associated with your nursery in the flat area that's actually the SMA, that's using the site in an inappropriate way. That is correct. Commissioner Scadola, does he have his hand raised? I'll hold my comments until after the public hearing. Okay. I see Commissioner Curiazzi. Thank you. Can you repeat, did I hear that you said that the school district did not have to issue a waiver for the 600 feet from the bus stop? Under the CCLUO, with a special permit, a reduction in the setback to a school bus stop is possible. Under the CMMLUO 1.0, you have to get a waiver or you can't get a reduction. But in this instance, even though we're under 2.0, we've got a reduction. We've got a reduction. We've kind of got belt and suspenders going. Right. Okay.
And then I was curious, does a waiver from a neighbor still apply if that property transfers ownership? So say the new neighbor, that new person owner of that property has some issue. Yes, once the permit is issued and vested, then the findings have been made. And then lastly, to clarify in the school district, if at some point the school district had concerns, is under 2.0, can they push back on the distance from the bus stop? If the commission, through the chair, if the commission approves the permit, and then at some future date something happens or it's operated in a way that is causing potential impacts, then once you receive that communication from the reporting party, we would evaluate that to determine whether it represents being out of compliance with the business.
permit terms and conditions. What about when the permit is in compliance? Not a trick question. Yeah, yeah. Well, then it would stand. The operation would be able to continue operating. As long as the operation operates within the terms of the conditions of the permit, then it gets to continue operating. We would treat any complaint seriously, but the first check would just see if it's operating within those bounds. And if they are operating within those bounds, then they get to continue to operate. So it's in with our jurisdiction to decrease that 600-foot setback simply, and so we're basing that off of the current owner. So with regard to the residential setbacks, yes, the commission is able to make the existing findings that it's in compliance with the setbacks because of all of those. Neighbor waivers and the same.
thing applies for the bus does the setback to that bus stop because you have a written waiver from the school district I guess what I'm trying to well a waiver isn't required under 2.0 it is for residential setbacks but it is not required for bus stop I apologize yes specifically for the bus stop so in the in case of the if if the school district had a concern so let me rephrase if we were to have a waiver from the school district it's simply the Commission deciding it's okay to reduce that setback from the bus stop and we're basing that off of trust in the current owner if at some point there is concerned by the school district it sounds like there is not some sort of there's not a recourse for that school district through the through the chair I want to write a report on that I'm sorry I'm sorry I'm sorry I'm sorry I'm sorry I'm trying to work within the city time and thinking about all these other things and it's a that's what my point is I'm a Mister Mon 6000 okay so the första among each of you I'm a buddy and I am a member of the Association focused on geggos and periodic issues so I first sort of included around restraun ang malign 92
I'm answering a hypothetical because the construction of your question doesn't apply to what's before the commission because we have the written waiver. But the decision whether or not to reduce that setback without a written waiver ultimately would be the decision of the commission. But it would be based on analysis conducted by staff whether it could be justified such as having a thick canopy and vegetation in between the cultivation site and the bus stop. Another factor might be what exactly is going on at that cultivation site. This is a nursery. These are baby plants. They're not flowering. They're not creating smell. There's nothing there. There's. It is intoxicating. So that would be another potential consideration under the hypothetical. Could I phrase this maybe a little differently? Once the permit is granted, that permit.
and entitlement to the permit holder. As long as they're operating within the bounds of that, people can have concerns. But those concerns, as long as they're in compliance with the permit, are not grounds to change the permit. Yeah, thank you. That was a helpful discussion. Thanks. Commissioner Fulton, I believe you had a question. Yes, I have just one other quick question. And it can't have an implication depending on the conditional use permit, but you mentioned a residence on the property. The question that I have is, were permits sought to build the residence? And if not, does changing the zoning change the permitting requirements after the fact? Excellent question. Through the chair. The first thing I want to point out is the status of the residence is not part of the project. It is before the commission.
The status of the residence is that it was built without permits. If the zone is changed from C1 to AG, one of the positive side effects of this action would be it will be easier for the property owner to get that residence permit. Thank you. Okay. I want to acknowledge that we're getting a little bit tight on time, so I'm going to be holding everybody to their time limits. With that, I'm going to move it to public comment and specifically open up with our applicant and or their agent, who I believe is online. I see one person with their hand raised, and I think that is our applicant. So with that, I believe your name is Michael, but please correct me if that is not how you say your name. Please go ahead. You have ten minutes.
So, uh, if you are briefer, that'll be a gold star. Yeah, I'm, uh, can you hear me here? We can, yes. Okay, because I'm just parked on the side of the road out in the middle of nowhere. Um, I mean, this is all fine except for the fence thing. I'm telling you, it's, it's, it makes no sense. It's seriously, and I'm, I absolutely, vehemently disagree with the characterization that it would not be a problem. It would be a massive problem. It, you know, there is no, it does not moving, that right now there's, there has been for 25, 30 years, um, a fence along the top of the bank. It's been there forever. And we've been using that parcel the same way it's been used for 100 years. This is what I put in the written notes that didn't get, didn't get, the summary didn't get across. For 100 years, probably since Bryson was found, that area has been, there was, uh, some old timer came by a couple years ago and pointed out where a building used to be, used to be a cabin, right? Where one of the places we park. Um, it was, uh, it was.
The mule yard, it was, you know, I've had, we've had the cannabis nursery there. Publicly, this would be our 11th year if, you know, I was out of business this year. I had a regular nursery there for a decade before that. This is no change, nothing has changed whatsoever. The fence is there, and you want me to move the fence 20 feet. I defy anybody to go there with a tape measure and measure off a 20-foot strip and say, oh, well, that is clearly a buffer. If you look at it, it's really not. The flat upper part terrace there doesn't really communicate with the creek in a sense. Like the repair area starts over the bank. Making a buffer there, it's not a buffer. It doesn't do anything. I mean, if you dumped a gallon of oil in the middle of the driveway, it's still not going to run over there. I mean, you could dump it at the end. I mean, just, I don't even know where to start with this. You could dump where we sometimes park, where I have cars, trailers parked. You could dump a bucket of oil there, and it's not going to make it into the creek.
You could go 20 feet back and dump it, and that's not going to change anything. It's not like we're even dumping oil. There's nothing going on that is a problem there. But it does dramatically restrict access, and you can't, I mean, having these kind of broad statements just don't do anything. You have to go there and see it. I could walk you through. And, yes, you can turn a car around in the driveway, but not a trailer. It screws up. It screws up. But, no, it does so much more than. And in terms of fire hazard reduction, it's not going to be, I mean, if you think it's going to be a buffer, there's no buffer. It's going to be scalped bare like it is now. I'm not going to let brush and weeds grow up there. Like I said, I'm assuming, I put this in the written thing I said, and I'm assuming DFW thinks that for a buffer or whatever, that there's going to be vegetation there, but there's not. I'm not letting vegetation grow that close. I'm not letting vegetation grow that close to structures, to the sales office, to anything. I mean, it's, no, it's going to be scalped.
there right now i just mow it um or part of it's the gravel hardpan gravel driveway um the other thing is like it i really object to the characterization that moving the sma line is going to increase parking it's like no it's not because it's kind of ridiculous to have this whole area i mean you know the majority of the properties you can see on that map is in the sma i mean it's basically a non the whole place is non-existent it's non-viable if you left that there meanwhile look at the map bryceland road is closer to the creek and right through the sma it is closer to the creek itself to the actual water than my driveway or the place where we park our trailers or turn around or anything like that is i mean bryceland road itself and there's unfiltered culverts that runs that drain bryceland roads all the oil the tire rubber everything that wears off that drains it straight unfiltered into the creek you know which doesn't happen from our driveway i mean it filters all through the whole bank vegetation and it's a long ways away it's like i said it's just it's a massive expense
massive hassle it'd be a huge eyesore you know having this big fence kind of right in the middle of everything and it dramatically reduces a lot of access and you have to go there and see it you have you know i i i don't even know what to say it's like like that is that it is it's the thing about dfw is they've always been hostile to cannabis and they always want to put some or other regulation that frequently can't even be justified you know and this is one of those like all the other things that they were i've never actually done virtually everything except the you know the retroactively get a pond rating permit but all the other stuff that's in that recommendation i actually already did moving the fence um where the bank is collapsing because dfw wouldn't let me fix it years ago um you know yeah all that stuff's already been done all that small stuff but you know having to put a big fence right across the middle of it it doesn't make sense it really really doesn't make sense and i i you know
Nothing else. I want people to come walk there and, you know, I want somebody to walk me through this logically. Show me how this is going to work because it just doesn't. And just a thing on timing, it's not a matter of like, can't really wait because we were up against, you know, work against our planting season. We start ideally planting, you know, if we get our new state permit. It's this complicated, but we're consolidating three former permits into one micro business permit. So we're kind of in this, this is the last step of this process. Then we have our state thing. Then we got to get our seeds planted and we're a seasonal nursery. We're outdoor. We start planting March 1st-ish, rougher, you know, pivot cake. And we're closed this last year by July 22nd. You know, we're only open for a few months and then we're gone. And there's nothing on site. There's no, there's nothing on site. No cannabis, nothing. And the thing about it, we're up against a deadline. If we can't. If we can't plant soon enough, we'll, we don't operate this year. And if we don't operate this year, then we're done.
So, I mean, it's not like I would just say, well, let's just put this off another month and let's get DFW out there and let's go walk through and let me, you know, show you what I'm talking about, but there isn't time for that. So I honestly, I have no idea where to go with this. I just, that's all I got to say. By the way, my understanding, and it's been years since I've dealt with all this, because we did all that a long, long time ago when this first started, but my understanding is the state requires a waiver from the school. So whether the county does or not is not even that relevant because the state requires it. So anyway, you can ask me any questions you have, but that's all I got to say, I guess. Okay, thank you. And I also want to acknowledge that it's always tough. It'll be the last hearing item of the night when our meetings go along. So thank you for staying with us through the late hour. And commissioners, do you have any questions of our applicant, Commissioner Scavedon?
No, I don't have the applicant. Okay. Anybody have questions of the applicant? Okay. And I also want to acknowledge that we'd open up public comment to anybody else, but there's no one else present in the room, nor do I see anybody else online. So with that, I'm going to thank the applicant for taking the time to appear before us and make comment, and I'm going to close the public comment period, and I'm going to bring it back to the commission for discussion. Can I request staff put the map back up, please? Thank you. While we're doing that, can I make a couple comments? Please. Yeah, I think we're tight on time, so that's great. So I just want to note that the applicant's biological assessment showing the streamside management area and the fence line is dated May 19th.
19th of 2025. So there's been known where this boundary is going to be for some time. CDFW doesn't routinely provide a waiver to the streamside management areas, so I think they've done so. But I don't dispute anything that the applicant said as far as the constraints that it's probably going to put on its property or operation. And I think condition already does say this, but maybe if we can make it more clear, if the applicant, biologist, and CDFW agree on the location of the fencing, that that would be okay, at least as far as I'm concerned. So if the applicant's proposal to go out and walk around the site, if the applicant's proposal to go out and walk around the site, that would be okay.
with actual with CDFW or their biologists and stake out the fence line and agree on that that would be okay with me and I get it that it's an eight and a half by eleven figure or photo and they're drawing a very broad brush line so maybe there are a couple spots where the fence line could kink a little bit or something and save a little bit of already you know graded parking area or something like that that the wildlife agency might be amenable to I don't know but I'm reluctant to make a change at this level of the commission to something that's already been agreed upon between other permitting agencies and the applicant's own biologist submitted you know six months ago I agree do you think there's a way to you know to make a change to the commission I think there's a way to condition that that they have to
this year as long as they have the meeting with CDFW and maybe maybe the fence doesn't get moved until mid-operation or something like I don't know I don't know how much work is going to go into it yeah I don't know I think that's a risk that the applicant would be taking if they started operating a nursery and then found out that next year the fence has to move and I don't know I think I would want to know personally but that's I'm just suggesting that if we can word our documents such that as long as the biologists and CDFW agree where this fence line is going to go on a streamside management area that we would support that but I don't I'm not in a position to adjust it from the podium at this time yeah so we'd be agreeing to the conversion
to ag and agreeing to a reduction in the SMA based on what CDFW and a certified biologist can come to agreement on? Well, the condition as it reads right now says subject to the approval of the planning department and CDFW. So it kind of already covers what I'm saying. I'm just saying that, and so if CDFW takes the lead, I'm sure the county is going to follow along and say, yeah, it's okay. Well, I think if I could, Chair, sorry, just to jump in maybe to help this along. It's really to show the physical barrier demarcating the physical location of the revised stream site management area as identified in the bio report. Okay. So I think what you're really talking about is in the 8C there, giving another option for...
The location of that may be reconfigured to the satisfaction of the biologist and CDFW. And just add that on to 8C? Yep, at their discretion. Yep. That's what I'm proposing is the best we could do. To play devil's advocate real quick, to reconfigure but not change to be any more limiting than it already is. Not saying that the biologist or CDFW would necessarily come back, but I think to your point, we're not trying to open the door for CDFW to further limit. So the language could be to allow a greater encroachment to the approval of the biologist and CDFW.
Yeah, not speaking for the applicant, but if I was the applicant, I'd go out and flag a line where I wanted to put the fence line and ask CDFW and the biologists to come out and see if that met their requirements. And if it didn't, adjust it. Through the chair, I just want to throw out there that I think CDFW would absolutely be willing to go out in a situation like that just to make sure before any investment was made that the alignment is in an appropriate spot, and I would be happy to accompany them as well. Okay, I want to make sure that I think Commissioner Chirazzi had asked to pull the map up, so I wanted to be attentive to that. But if there was any more discussion along the vein of this particular item. Well, it is on this point. I don't know if I had my hand up first, but I'll just try to be brief. I mean, first of all, I think what we have done that's sort of comparable in many cases is given a longer time to...
come into a compliance with a condition that was going to be onerous given tight timelines, particularly if there's some question about whether it could be negotiated to a different solution. So that's just one flag that I think that divorcing it from the 90 days that we require these other things to be done is reasonable given this, and I like the way this discussion was going. I also just want to sort of point out that the language that's here is a physical barrier demarking the location of the revised stream site. As you said, it doesn't say a new fence. When there's already a fence back there, barrier implies a fence, but demarking implies a line, if you see what I'm saying. And if there were some way that you could just put stakes in the ground and spray paint or a row of white rock, and sort of have like, it's kind of known that this is a stream site management area, but if I got a...
Turn this trailer around and it needs to cross that white line for, you know, that's kind of a very temporary incursion. But finally, my understanding from what he said, and I guess from the letter as well, is his proposal is that the fence that is there should be the fence. He doesn't want to have to build a new fence because there's already a fence closer to the edge of the bank that he's asserting is sufficient for fencing purposes. So, got it. Real quick, just to throw some context, based on my recollection of my site visit, the current fence is a deer fence. So, it's metal stakes and some barbed wire. Yeah. And he could leave that there and use some other method or reuse those materials. That would be fine. Commissioner McFarland? My comment was I was going to say I was supportive of Scavdall's amendment.
If you wanted to make a motion with the, I just had a little confusion on the conditions of approval. B12 says if monofilament netting is used, then BMPs, yada yada yada. But then C12 says no monofilament can be used. I know it says no for erosion control, but it's a little misleading. So if in B12 you mean if monofilament is used for purposes other than erosion control, it's just, they're a little confusing is all. So your interpretation of the interplay between those two conditions is spot on, that monofilament cannot be used at all for erosion, and if it's used for any other purpose, they must follow best management practices. Yeah, I would just suggest saying if it's used in B12, if monofilament netting is used for purposes other than, because if you read it quickly and you don't read section C, then you think, oh, I'm going to throw down this. I saw I put monofilament in it.
But anyway, I'm happy for the motion. Commissioner, can you ask me? Just a quick clarification, though. But when you read the full language of B12, it also says at the end, C also condition C5. Yeah. I just had a question regarding the applicant's comments around wildfire management in the 100-foot buffer. And so is the intent of an SMA to allow it to vegetate and grow naturally? And does that impede on that 100-foot buffer of existing structures? And so is that applicant simply going to go across that line and weed whack it and keep vegetation down? Does that just defeat the whole purpose of where the SMA is in the first place? That's kind of what I was wondering, if it looks like it's in 100 feet, which is kind of wild. I was wanting to bring that map up, if that's helpful. The intent of the SMA is to have it naturally vegetate. Fire clearance would be...
for flammable vegetation, which usually isn't going to coexist within riparian habitat. So if the applicant's intent is to weed-lack the SMA, that would probably be a violation of the SMA requirements. I guess plant life in a riparian area, if it is riparian plant life, is it okay that that buffer is 70 feet instead of 100? Okay. Personally, I'm looking to the qualified individuals who have commented on it already, the biologists and CDFW, and if it was good with them, then I feel comfortable with it. I just say it's probably also important note he mentioned he's seasonally operative so if
does weed whack during the fire season you're going to have grasses and whatnot which in theory help filter the water come back before the wet season and then he wouldn't be back to march where you know so because he's seasonal i can see how that wouldn't be the end of the world because he's not mowing it year round yeah i mean he said he's not on the property but yeah okay um we're getting a little bit tight on time so does anybody have more discussion or a motion they'd like to put on the table director ford did you understand my comments and do you have a suggestion do you do you think that's already covered in uh section eight all right i would or should we i i would modify hc or a8c
To add an additional sentence that reads that the demarcation can allow a greater encroachment into the SMA to the satisfaction and agreement of the biologist and California Department of Fish and Wildlife. That captures the essence of my comment. Thank you. So having said that, I will make a motion. May I just interject with a quick question relevant to that because I like where you got us to. But I was suggesting that perhaps the 90-day timeline for that item could be pushed back to allow, you know, get through the early part of the season, get through this spring, basically. And when the – to deal with that six months.
down the road or something like that, maybe even a year. Do you have a proposal? Well, I guess what I'm suggesting is simply that we not impose it while he's trying to get this season started, but sometime in the later part of, I mean, what day is it now? If we said six months from now, I think that would push it outside of the time that would. Right now, eight covers three items, I think. I can't remember what all three of them are, so I don't know if we're willing to adjust that or just item C. Does staff have feedback on that question? Yeah, I think that actually Commissioner Levy raises a really interesting point because often we do give people a little bit more time to come into compliance. And so with this, even though it does cover more than the average, it does cover a lot of the time that we're going to be doing this. So I think that's a good point. I think that's a good point.
um that applicant has been operating under the current conditions and giving them another season to do that and then come into compliance prior to you could say march 1st of 2027 makes sense to me is that a motion i'll make a motion that the planning commission adopts the resolution finding that we consider the final eir and the addendum that was prepared for plan humboldt llc fines proposed project complies with the general plan and zoning ordinance fines proposed project does not reduce residential density for any parcel below the inventory adopted in the housing element and approves plant humboldt subject to the conditions of approval as amended and
Attachment 1A. I have a second. Okay. I hear a motion and a second. Any discussion on the motion on the table? All right. Let's go for a roll call vote, please. Who seconded? Commissioner Fulton. Seconded. Ira Skobdahl. Yes. Al Levy. Yes. Sarah West. Yes. Jerome Karazi. Yes. Lorna McFarland. Yes. Todd Fulton. Yes. All right. Motion carries. And with that, we will move on to item H, items will for consent. There were none. Item I. Thank you. At the last meeting, the commission had asked.
Staff to prepare a letter addressed to the board regarding maintaining courtroom security and somehow funding came through and so that is being maintained. So we're not presenting you with a letter this evening because it's already been addressed. I don't really have a report from planner. We'll defer to planning commission discuss some items tonight. Commissioner Farland. I said one thought based on the last permit. So as a conversion from residential to ag and do we keep like a ledger of when we do that because our previous permit with the Elk River one of the concerns was losing ag land so do we keep a ledger in the county of when we convert to ag land so we could use it as like a pseudo bank for the no net loss. So yeah great question The short answer is not right now but the
Another kind of particular nuance to this is that the general plan policy isn't about the zoning. It's about prime farmland, prime ag land, loss of ag land. And so it would, even though this will be zoned AG, whether or not this is actually ag land that would qualify under that general plan policy has really not been determined. Okay. Yeah, I guess because it seemed like there was a little bit of discussion about the land in the first permit. It's already been flooded, therefore it's not really being used as farmland, even though it was zoned. Yeah, that's why I'm trying to separate the zoning and the land use designation from the actual use. And I was going to say this before. I didn't want to belabor it previously, but one of the things that we're starting to confront,
More and more with sea level rise is that long term, if we let things just go their course, we may lose that ag land anyway. But in some cases where we're seeing restoration projects come through that actually create a barrier and that actually preserves ag land, we may lose a little bit in the short term, but in the long term, that ag land then becomes more viable. And so there's an interesting balance that we're struggling with here with sea level rise. Any other planning discussion items? A very quick one if I may. And I apologize because it's past 930 already. But I just wanted to bring up Director Ford.
This item about the old growth trees in Redway that were cut down and simply because I've heard, you know, it's a subject of some interest and concern from some people. And I read the articles that I could find where you explain some of the thinking, but I guess I just wondered if you could give a brief summation of kind of where you came out after that in terms of how that situation would be handled going forward. So we I'm going to have to give you a little history here because otherwise it won't make sense. OK. We had some trees cut down out off of what was Harris Street by the PG&E substation. And we felt like that was a violation and had CAL FIRE and other registered professionals. And we had some of the national foresters come and.
unceremoniously instruct us that we have no jurisdiction there and pointed out where in the forest practices act so that's where we came to the conclusion that if it's something that's being done under a permit that's issued under the forest practices act we don't have the ability to add to or take away from that there is a kind of as i've gone through this there's a competing provision in the california code of regulations that is not law it's the administrative procedures for cal fire that says they're going to check with the local jurisdiction to see if it's consistent with land use and zoning so the question that then i have is why are you going to ask if the local local jurisdiction is going to be consistent with land use and zoning and so the question that then i have is why are you going to ask if the there's no jurisdiction there and so i've been engaged in discussions with cal fire it's like okay
This is what you told us. Here's what your California Code of Regulations say. And there's a there's a discontinuity there. And help help me understand. So I haven't gotten a clean, clear answer yet. I'm still working on that. And then I'm also led to believe that other counties have adopted provisions that allow them to regulate things even when there is a permit or an exemption being issued under the Forest Practices Act. I have not gotten confirmation of that yet. So it's a work in progress. So that work was done under just a three acre exemption? No. It was done under a hazardous tree exemption. And so even at that. We didn't sign a sheet saying, yeah, it's consistent with land use and zoning. The only thing that we did is we signed a paper that said, yeah, it's consistent with land use and zoning.
thing with a hazardous tree exemption the only thing that's required is you notify the county that you're going to take these trees down don't care what you think and and so that's what actually happened there thank you our next meeting is scheduled for march 19th so we don't have a first meeting in that is correct okay all right and with that we are adjourned you