I'm going to go ahead and call this meeting to order. If you need an agenda to follow along, it is right by the door. And with that, we'll salute the flag. the flag of the United States of America, and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. May I get a roll call, please? Commissioner Scabdall is absent. Commissioner Levy? Here. Commissioner O'Neill? Here. Commissioner West? Here. Commissioner Curiazzi? Here. Commissioner McFarland is absent. Commissioner Fulton? Here. We have a quorum. Wonderful. With that, we'll move on to item C, agenda modification.
Director Ford. We have no modifications to the agenda other than if at the chair's discretion you may want to move an item up onto the consent calendar. There are two things on the dais. Correspondence we've received from the public for item E2 RPL investors and also item F3 life plan Humboldt. So staff is proposing to move a public hearing item 1 F1 to the consent calendar. It should have been acknowledged on the consent calendar. It is just a renewal of the ordinance I believe. It is really an extension of the ordinance. It's a pilot program and there currently is one operation that's taking advantage of this and so we do want to support that. And this is not proposing any real changes. There's a slight change to the coastal ordinance just to make it.
Consistent with the inland somehow the inland ended up being a little bit more restrictive than the coastal and and so we're just making them consistent and that's the only change. Okay since it's on the public hearing section I'm going to check with the commission to see if anybody objects to moving it to the consent calendar. Great okay that doesn't look like it so I will go ahead and add it to the consent calendar. So with that we will move on to item D public comment on non agenda items. This is the time where the public may address the commission on items that are not on the agenda for the evening. So if you do have a comment on an item that's specifically on the agenda we will get to that when we consider that item. If anybody who's interested in commenting could please approach the podium or star nine to raise your hand if you are online. Good evening. I'm Laurie Barnwell with chalk mountain ranch chalk mountain ranch is a family.
owned and operated timber and cattle ranch in Bridgeville. The Bridgeville Quarry owned by Goat Rock Ranch LLC and operated by Mercer Frazier is on property adjacent to Chalk Mountain. Mercer Frazier has been accessing the Bridgeville Quarry without appropriate permits and conducting work on land owned by others without permission. They've removed riparian buffers, conducted unauthorized road work, and removed and destroyed state-mandated timber harvest erosion control features. Mercer Frazier has shown disregard to best management practices and compliance with local and state laws and regulations. This has led to increased soil erosion, sediment-laden runoff, and potentially contaminating nearby streams. Mercer Frazier's actions have left Chalk Mountain Ranch legally and financially responsible for implementing all corrective measures and to restore the affected areas and were subject to all issued notices, fines, and violations. Mercer Frazier's actions have already led to quatro- Hug supremo gentrification network, Tang Group with reform Marian Maureenline, Chalk Mountain Ranch receiving a state water board violation, as well as a violation from the
State of California Department of Forest and Fire Protection on our Forest Legacy Easement. The County of Humboldt Conditional Use Permit for surface mining as issued does not include the property or the roads the APNs for Chalk Mountain Ranch are not on that permit. Mercer Frazier does not hold the CUP required State Water Board 401 water quality certification for industrial activities or a lake and stream bed alteration agreement through the California Department of Fish and Wildlife. Mercer Frazier does not hold the CPU required North Coast Air Quality Management Permit to operate for their rock pressure and screen on site at the Bridgeville Quarry. Mercer Frazier's required storm water pollution and prevention plan and their Department of Conservation Reclamation Plan do not cover the property owned by Chalk Mountain Ranch or our roads. Chalk Mountain is urging the County to issue a formal stop work notice to Mercer Frazier Company at the Virginia Department of Fish and Wildlife. Chalk Mountain is urging the County to issue a formal stop work notice to Mercer Frazier Company at the Virginia Department of Fish and Wildlife. Restricting
all the access to the quarry across chalk mountain property until a comprehensive review of operating guidelines and permit compliance is conducted we seek assurance that all operations meet legal regulatory standards and protect local resources before access is restored ensuring compliance and environmental protection i have a packet free to view this evening i'm not sure who wants to take that and i thank you for your time thank you and i should mention um we will be limiting public comment tonight on all items to three pivots Good evening, Barrett Barnwell with Chalk Mountain Ranch. Chalk Mountain Ranch is a family owned cattle and timber ranch in southern Humboldt County established in 1884. I am the fifth generation that own the ranch along with my brother, cousin and mother. For the last 142 years it's been in operation and managed to be passed on to the next generation. This has
been obtained by properly managing the natural resources which feed cattle, grow trees, and support natural wildlife. Chalk Mountain Ranch has partnered with local, state, and federal agencies throughout the years, constantly striving to maintain the best resource and land management. We have assisted the county throughout the years in maintaining county roads during storms, allowing the county to use ranch roads and resources for their projects, and storing its expensive construction equipment behind locked gates on our property. Chalk Mountain Ranch has been an integral part of the growth and building of Humboldt County, an economic driver in livestock and timber, an economic supporter of business and people in southern Humboldt County. In 2000, the Goat Rock Ranch put in the Bridgefield Quarry. There were agreements with the original landowner for temporary access, at which point they would create their own access through our ranch. Times have changed.
And property owners have changed. Mercer Frazier and Goat Rock Ranch LLC now have refused for the last four years to enter into a contract or agreement with Chalk Mountain Ranch for access and use to the quarry. So in December of 2024, they did irreparable damage to Chalk Mountain Ranch property, whereas it stalled our harvest plan. And we got a violation served from the Water Quality Board. This held up our timber production for the 2025 season, impacting us financially. In August of 2025, Mercer Frazier, on a weekend without any permission from the landowner, removed 48 dump truck loads of dirt in a Class 1 stream zone that is a steelhead and salmon spawning ground. And due to the environmental damage estimated, $150,000.
The gate was locked. Since this occurred, Chalk Mountain Ranch has researched activities of the Bridgeville Rock 40. Humboldt County issued permits expressly states that the road maintenance or road work is required to be approved with the property owner, which both have mentioned incidents were not approved with Chalk Mountain Ranch. Additionally, Mercer-Fraser lacks numerous amount of required permits stated by my sister-in-law. There have also been permits issued by the county that lack the required information for approval. In February of 2026, Chalk Mountain Ranch had a meeting with John Ford at the planning department. The lack of required permits, permits without proper documentation, permit violations, and financial impacts to Chalk Mountain Ranch were discussed. After three weeks, the county took no action. The day Chalk Mountain Ranch discussed this with John Ford, the next three days, county dump trucks were... ...for accessing this rock quarry. So, without an immediate action by the county...
uh these permit violations and environmental damage will continue mercer frazier has continually shown they have no intention of complying with the permit and regulation these regulations and permits are to be to prevent this kind of environmental damage and safeguard all parties state county i'm sorry can you please wrap it up but yep we've limited to three minutes and chalk mountain ranch from unnecessary lawsuits and court battles i urge the members of this board to take great concern with this incident research and apply the permit regulations as they would to anybody else thank you okay seeing nobody else in the audience and oh please approach the podium anybody else who would like to speak um please approach the podium and line up behind her um this is regarding org and the proposed development on the six variants okay so this item is um scheduled as i believe
on our agenda so we will be taking public comment for it um when we open the hearing for it at that time so give us i have i uh the note that i got it was six o'clock tonight so it's not tonight it is tonight yes um it's just a little bit later in the evening okay what time uh we'll we'll work through our agenda items and when we get to that item so unfortunately i don't have a specific time i would if i had to guess i would say 30 minutes but it really just depends on all right i thought i thought we were supposed to speak now but oh no please come up in a few minutes Okay, I'm not seeing anybody online and nobody else in the audience. I'm going to go ahead and close public comment and just a quick moment for staff if they wanted to respond to public comment at all. It's not the practice to respond to public comment. Okay, now we'll move on.
And the consent agenda. This part of the agenda, I will go through each item and query the commission and the audience to see if anybody would like to pull any items from the agenda. If the item is not pulled, we will consider all the items on the consent calendar together under one vote. So I'm going to go ahead and start reading off the items. And please raise your hand online or on the commission or in the audience if you'd like for an item to be pulled and for a reminder, online it is star nine to raise your hand. Okay, item E1, review and approval of the February 16th, 2026 action summary. Okay, seeing none, it'll stay. Item number two, RPL investors, LLC, coastal development permit, conditional use permit and special permit extension. I think this is the item that the member of the public wanted to come and talk to. Okay, we will pull that off of the consent. Thank you. Thank you, Callan.
Item 3, the forward tentative map and coastal development permit extension. Seeing none, it'll stay on consent. Item 4, the Pele parcel map subdivision coastal development permit and special permit. This is a continuation. Okay, those seeing none. Item 5, monument quarry CUP SMP mining reapproval. Okay, see that one will be pulled. Item number six Russ quarry CUP SMP mining re-approval that one is also And then that brings us to the public hearing item number
For one, that we decided to move on to the consent calendar, inland and coastal safe parking, safe shelter, pilot program, ordinance amendment. So I didn't hear an objection from the commission, and just making sure nobody in the audience wants to have this item pulled and nobody online. There is a hand up on that. Oh, there is a hand up. Thank you. Okay, we will go ahead and retain that in our public hearing section. Instead of considering as a part of the consent calendar. Thank you. I move approval of items 1, 3, and 4 from the consent calendar. Second. Okay, with that, let's go ahead and have a voice vote. All those in favor, please say aye. Aye. And now we...
We'll move on. Items that are pulled from consent, I typically go to the end of the agenda after the public hearing items. So we will take up items 2, 5, and 6 at the end. Actually, 1 is technically still a public hearing item. You are correct. Yep. So we will take 2, 5, and 6 at the end of the agenda, but we will leave item F1 where it is and take it. Does that sound good? Yes, thank you. Okay. So now we will consider item F1. This is the Inland and Coastal Safe Parking Safe Shelter Pilot Program Ordinance Amendment. Just one moment while we pull up the presentation, my apologies.
Thank you. Chair, if I may, the public commenter may be reminding that the agenda item that they're interested in commenting on was pushed to the end of the agenda. I noticed that they were inquiring, although they're not listening currently. The item that they were wishing to comment on got pushed to the end of the agenda? It was on consent, so it goes later. Okay. Did you follow that, that we will be considering a couple of items, and then we will be considering the item that you were interested in speaking of?
Alright. All right, good evening. Oh Sorry about that. Okay. Could you pull also item two? Public hearing? Public, excuse me. That item was pulled, yes. Thank you. All right, good evening commissioners. My name is Megan Acevedo and I'm presenting the safe parking safe shelter pilot program extension
Thank you. Thank you. While we're waiting, does anybody have any ex parte communications regarding the site? We're having technical difficulties.
Faculties. Okay, the purpose of the ordinance. This ordinance implements implementation measure HIM56 in the general plan housing element. And it allows a government agency, religious institution, nonprofit charitable organization, or private nonprofit organization to operate a safe parking, safe shelter site, which provides homeless individuals and families living in a vehicle or outside, a safe place to park or sleep at no cost.
This will also extend the provisions of the adopted ordinance to January 1st, 2036, which is in line with State Bill 1395. The original approval by the board was on June 7th, 2022, and they adopted the Inland and Coastal Pilot Program ordinance. The Inland became effective within 30 days of the adoption, and the Coastal still requires certification from the Coastal Commission. And then on January 9th, 2024, we extended the Inland ordinance for an additional two years, which was, again, in line with State Assembly Bill 1395. They also extended their government code. So the amendments that we're making...
With this approval, we are going to extend the provisions of the Inland and Coastal Ordinance to January 1st of 2036. We are updating language to include current building code for emergency housing standards in both ordinances. And we are updating the Coastal Ordinance to include a provision to restrict the disposal of gray water or black water from recreational vehicles at sites, unless they have approval in a management plan. And that is to be consistent with the Inland Ordinance. And that concludes my presentation, and I'm available for questions. Thank you. Anybody have any questions? Okay. With that, we will go ahead and take it to public comment. First, we will do public comment in the room. If you're interested in making a comment on this item, please approach the podium and form a line. Then we will...
Go ahead and take folks who are interested in commenting online. If you are calling in online, please hit star nine to raise your hand. I do see we have one person already raising their hand online. Okay, with that, I don't see anybody approaching in the room, so we'll go ahead and move to online. Right now, I see caller 9992. Please go ahead and hit star six to unmute and share your public comment. You have three minutes. Caller 9992. Oh, looks like you're unmuted. There it is. Yes, there it is. I'm sorry for any confusion because what you proposed and this entire parking and safe parking and all that is important. I'm sorry. I raised my hand. We're having a little bit of a problem.
trouble hearing you would you mind um speaking up a little bit my hand in i agree with all of it i raised my hand there because i can't participate over the phone in this manner and the zoom meeting keeps showing up there is no meeting okay thank you so there's no way to participate if you would like to um participate and make a comment you're welcome to do that on the phone right now it's not regarding this subject oh um okay i understand what you're saying now thank you apologies okay okay um well hopefully um raise your hand again when you are ready to to call in on the next item um with that i don't see anybody else online who has their hand raised so we will go ahead and move it back to the commission a um
Can I check maybe if or should we confirm if the zoom is or is not working? Is that what I heard the caller say? I mean clearly the phone calling in is working I think. She is on a phone. Right yeah so I'm wondering if the she's saying zoom isn't working. I do I do have other people. Okay so it looks like it is okay great. Okay, any other comments or questions about this item from the commission? I do have a question for you. The first year was two-year. The second one was a two-year. Why the 10-year jump? So government code, sorry, I can't remember the specific code section. It allows a local agency to adopt a local ordinance.
safe parking, safe shelter, and use building, it's lesser building code standards for emergency housing. And the original code only allowed that till, the last extension was till January 1st of 2026. So it expired at the beginning of this year. And then they extended their code through the state bill, Assembly Bill 1395, to further allow local governments to use emergency building standards up until January 1st of 2036. And so we're just following in line to continue allowing the use of the emergency housing code for this ordinance. Thank you. If there's no further comment, I would move.
that we adopt the resolutions recommending that the board of supervisors take the following actions find the inland and coastal safe parking safe shelter pilot program ordinance amendments are exempt from sequa find that the inland and coastal safe parking safe shelter pilot program amendments and extension comply with the general plan local coastal program and coastal act find that these amendments and extension are in the public interest and so adopt an ordinance amending ordinance number 2729 approving the minor language amendments and extension of the inland safe parking safe shelter pilot program and amending the title and so forth and adopt an ordinance so amending these codes that's good enough second wonderful we have a motion and a second let's go to the next one let's go ahead and have a roll call vote please
Thank you. Commissioner Levy. Aye. Commissioner O'Neill. Yes. Commissioner West. Yes. Commissioner Curiazzi. Yes. Commissioner Fulton. Yes. Motion carries. Thank you. We've had a little bit of discussion around agenda modifications tonight. So just to be extra clear for the public, we're going to now consider item F2. And then we will consider item F3. And then we will move to... You might say what those are. You might say what those are. Thank you. Okay. Item F2, the Humboldt Bay Harbor Recreation and Conservation District extension of the interim permit is item F2. And then item F3 is the life plan of Humboldt, policy map subdivision and special permit. And then we will move to the items that were pulled from consent. So that was consent item number two. Pull back to where we were on that. Which was the RPL investors' outlay. RPL outlay.
see coastal development permit conditional use permit and special permit extension and then we will consider item five from the consent calendar which was the monument quarry cup smp mining re-approval and then we will consider item six from the consent calendar the rust quarry cup smp mining re-approval so we have quite a bit to get through so with that i'm going to move us to item f2 while we're waiting for staff to pull up their presentation let's go ahead and do our ex parte just for transparency i don't think it has any impact on this item but i am a member of the heavy lift marine terminal advisory committee for the harbor district but that this item doesn't pertain to that so i have a little bit of a lengthy one for this one um um i was employed with plan west partners the applicant's agent at the time this permit you
It only came before the commission. I did not work on this particular project to my memory, but I did work on other projects for the applicant. I'm very familiar with the site that this permit is at and have toured it extensively. The site has been open to the public quite a bit, so I imagine most folks have a lot of familiarity with it, but I don't know that I have any special knowledge to report beyond that I have been on the site quite a few times. And it's really neat to stand on top of the building that's quite a few stories up and be able to look over the bay. Okay. Okay, we're ready to provide a staff report if we could have a screen share. I'll let Cliff see what he can do.
New computer yesterday. You can see we're having some problems. There we go. Okay, without further ado, Steve Lazar, I'm the planner assigned to this. This matter is an extension of a previously approved permit. As Chair West was mentioning, this appeared before the Planning Commission roughly seven years ago, and the applicant for that project is the Humboldt Bay Arbor Recreation and Conservation District. They refer to the property as Redwood Marine Terminal 2, and they are requesting a three-year extension of the previously approved permit.
approved coastal permit and use permits there was two different coastal permits and use permits that were approved for the site I'm just trying to advance the slide. Maybe I have to do it here. Okay. Okay, we'll make it work. So this is a kind of a zoomed out map showing the project site location on the north spit. You know it's roughly positioned equidistant from Samoa and Fairhaven so it's up for debate what area you'd call it but it is a hundred acre parcel formerly associated with the pulp mill. The pulp mill closed in 2008 and in the years following the Harbor District acquired the property. Here's a another view from the from the harbor showing kind of the the two different parcels.
And the pulp mill lies on the westerly portion of the site. And then the easterly portions that were associated with the pulp mill are the areas that are the subject of tonight's permit request for the extension. They're occupied by a variety of uses I'll go through in a moment. And they are mostly interior uses although exterior storage of vehicles on the northerly portions of the site also is a use. And then it's important point out that there's two different permit. There was an application made into the interim use provisions that we're going to be considering this under weren't in our zoning regulations until 2017 roughly they were had to be certified by the Coastal Commission and at their heart they are a way of allowing for the glut of coastal dependent industrial properties to be used for kind of temporary uses and that's what we are. Doing here in this situation. And so.
Permits were applied for roughly in the lead up to the adoption of the regulations and then shortly after that and they were both taken up by the planning commission in 2018 at the same hearing. So they were approved at the same time. And the three-year extension request is to allow for both permits to be extended into 2029. So in this view, you can see kind of the buildings a little closer up. And there's several different warehouse buildings. And then I've kind of colorized them and flattened them here to kind of parse out the different occupancies so the commission can see how that plays out. So here, the areas in blue are areas dedicated to actual coastal dependent uses, salt manufacturing and the mariculture facility that lies in the bay. And then, of course, the interior space in the mariculture, you know, the storage and warehousing stuff is in that blue box. But that extends all the way. That extends all the way out into the harbor.
You can see it's not using all of the site, but it is using a number of areas within the existing structures. And then these are kind of the applicant that has provided this exhibit. I've just sort of overlaid it to kind of show the breakout of users. And they largely, if you were to boil them down, kind of involve storage of materials and equipment. There is some kind of processing activities associated with a delivery service that operates from the site. So you could call it a true warehousing use. None of these uses would be allowed without the interim use provision because the coastal dependent industrial is such a tightly controlled zoning district. For good reason, because it's to preserve our port and coastal dependent areas. So we'll kind of zoom into this area here. And this is showing kind of what they call the shops and stores building. And you can see the kind of breakout of users. Not all of the space is currently occupied. But the permit allows for. Okay.
variety of uses to occur at the site. And then these are just some photos I took yesterday when I visited the site. None of the uses are manipulating the interior environments in ways that are permanent. There's fences that are put up in some of the structures. This is a boat repair business that occupies one of the portions of one of the buildings. It's all stuff that if needed to be removed very quickly could be. Nothing is really entrenched. And it's important to note that the interim use provisions require that leases include provisions for uses that say that you can be given six months' notice and have to vacate if a new preferred use comes into play that would be coastal dependent. So it is a challenging kind of thing for the tenants. Okay. So this is looking west towards the former pulp mill, and the areas in the foreground are kind of areas that are occupied by...
Some of the uses I was just referencing. And then looking kind of north in this case, you can see some of the vehicle storage that occurs on the adjacent parcel. This is looking more towards the harbor. And this is the area kind of to the left is the area associated with the aquaculture and mariculture operations. And then this is a view of kind of the from the west looking, sorry, from the south looking north at some of the buildings. And then you can kind of see there's a lot of decaying infrastructure that isn't in use right now and really is tied up depending on a new anchor tenant, which is. So just going to kind of zoom in really quickly at the site and just explain why in staff's opinion, looking at the findings that have to be made to approve and renew the interim use, the findings are very specific. The interim uses have to be able to coexist with existing or future coastal dependent industrial
material uses and other priority uses. You know, we have existing coastal dependent uses at the site that have operated for the lifetime of the permit thus far and don't appear to be interfered with by the uses that are there at this point. So I think that's the strongest evidence to support the commission granting the renewal. And it is important to point out that, you know, there's very limited durations that are allowed. So for the first iteration of a permit request, the maximum duration is seven years, and that's why we're here tonight is it was approved in 2019 and we're renewing it. They're asking for renewal. And then the maximum increment under the second renewal is three years. And at that point, there has to be a revisiting of the allowance. So it's designed to really kind of make sure that we don't get too far out in allowing other uses that could potentially interfere with more preferred ones. But I think the fact that the site's operating fairly smoothly, I visited the site, I didn't see any evidence of conflict with the conditions of approval, or the kind of underpinnings of the...
The interim use provisions, I feel confident recommending approval. And then I want to point out that there was a CEQA document prepared by the district as the lead agency, and there were addendums drafted in the wake of the original adoption to cover some of the iteration changes to the uses at the site. And some of the mitigation measures involved protecting certain areas that are sensitive on the property. It was a requirement for a rare plant survey, and there was a reference to an osprey nest that wasn't known whether it was an occupied nest or not, but to evaluate whether or not it could coexist. And interestingly, during my site visit, I was able to verify that it is, in fact, coexisting quite well. This was yesterday. So we don't believe there's anything that changes the CEQA findings. The previous environmental review and mitigation measures that were adopted. by the district remain applicable and extending the permit for the interim uses.
Another three years doesn't challenge those the affection effectiveness of the mitigation measures. So our recommendation tonight is for approval of the request for granting an additional three years. The interim uses are in our opinion consistent with the approved permits and the interim use regulations based on the way they're being operated and the site being occupied. They fund the district's management of the property and kind of courting new industrial tenants. They're fairly minimal in terms of their footprint and they clearly show the ability to coexist with current CDI uses. So for that reason we recommend approval. Of course the commission has the latitude to go in a different direction and should you choose to do so possibilities include revisiting the request and maybe a smaller permit term instead of three years a lesser amount or adding conditions or amending conditions or if you don't feel comfortable making the findings you could deny it though we would recommend it. Thank you.
If you do go in that direction to continue this matter so we can address that. So with that, I'll end my presentation and be available for questions. Thank you. So I noticed in your pictures that the building is sort of deteriorating in one place. The roof has got a hole in it. Are they not required to maintain the building for health and safety? That building is not currently occupied. That portion of the site through the chair is not one of the buildings that is in use. So those areas of the site are largely insulated from the current uses. But even then, it's sort of an eyesore. It's sort of an eyesore, isn't it? It certainly isn't pleasant to look at. But as far as the conflict with the permit or the requirements of the permit, it isn't required to be kept in good repair. It is. About the areas of the site that are targeted for interim use.
Director Ford? Yeah, thanks. If you look at those buildings, you're right. They don't look great. And as part of the previous Nordic approval, those were to be removed. And so one of the things that we're struggling with right now is making sure that there's something happening in these facilities so that there's income coming in so the facilities can be maintained while, as Mr. Lazar said, so that future tenants may be able to come in and really upgrade what's there. And so if they become too much of a nuisance, we can take a different action. The county has chosen not to pursue any kind of action at this point relative to those buildings. So there's a no-go? Nobody in that building? Because it looked like when you were showing there was some activity to one side. Is that a separate building or just a separate part of the building?
Correct. It is a separate building entirely. It just looks kind of in the way the angle of the picture was. So there wouldn't be any requirement that they demolish that part of the building since it's not being used and it's not in good repair? We have not gone in that direction just simply because it may be that if somebody came in in the future, the bones that are there in that building could be reused. And so there's a desire to encourage industrial development, coastal dependent industrial development at that location and preserving as much of the resources possible as part of that agenda. Okay. Any other questions? Okay. Go ahead and take it over to the public. At this time, we typically invite our applicant up to the podium.
like to say anything, they are welcome to present. If not, we will go ahead and open it to the rest of the public. If you'd like to comment on this item, please approach the podium, or if you are online, please raise your hand, and if you're calling in, it is star nine to raise your hand. Okay, I'm not seeing anybody in the audience approaching the podium, and I don't see anybody online with their hand raised, and it looks like the applicant doesn't want to make any comments, so we will go ahead and bring it back to the commission. I'm just curious since director Ford you you mentioned the Nordic project which had been permitted for this site or part of this site in any case correct so I just was curious if I thought that was just important to first of all just highlight that fact and and I understand that there's
I think about these uses that we're extending that would prevent another significant coastal dependent project from being developed there. If, in fact, that project had not sort of pulled the plug, the company had not pulled the plug, I should say, would we be at a point where we wouldn't extend this now because it would be sort of turned over to their uses? Actually, the Nordic project would not have utilized all of the area. So some of those uses in the existing buildings would remain there. Got it. Okay. Yeah, because it's a big site. Yeah. All right. Thank you. I just thought I'd mention through the chair that during the site visit, I was speaking with Chris Mickelson from the district, and he mentioned that they actually served notice to some of the tenants, in the lead-up to Nordic proceeding with their project. And so the mechanism is there.
I will second. We have a motion and a second. May I please get a roll call vote? Commissioner Fulton. Aye. Commissioner Curiazzi. Yes. Commissioner West. Yes. Commissioner O'Neill. Yes. Commissioner Levy. Aye. Motion carries. Okay. Thank you. With that, we'll move on to item F3. Life Plan of Humboldt, Parcel Map Subdivision, and Special Permit. And while staff is getting this presentation ready, do we have any ex parte communications for this one? Yeah. I do have one ex parte. Okay. So an employee from the applicant had contacted me a couple of weeks prior to the item being agendized concerning specifically.
the Hiller Road exception that they had filed. And so when they had done that, I just simply notified them that that would be ex parte communication and encouraged them to file their concerns with county staff. There it is. Good evening. My name is Michael Holterman. I'm the assigned planner for the Life Plan Humboldt Subdivision Special Permit Application. That's record number PLN 202519246 in the McKinleyville area. There we go. So the project is located in McKinleyville. That's between McKinleyville Avenue and Central Avenue along Hiller Road. The parcel was recently returned to the City of McKinleyville.
...re-zoned along with several other properties as part of the McKinleyville Town Center Q-Zone Ordinance. And environmental impacts for the project were assessed as part of the EIR adopted by the Board of Supervisors for the Q-Zone. So these are the three topics we're going to be going over briefly. The subdivision itself, the wetland consolidation and restoration under the special permit, and then I'll hand it over to Bob Bronkel, county surveyor, to go over the exception request for the widening and paving of Hiller Road. So here we have the tentative map. The project consists of an approximately 15 acre parcel being divided into an approximately 13 and approximately two acre parcel. Resulting lots meet the minimum parcel size, minimum lot depth and width, and conform to the requirements of the current zoning regulations and the Humboldt County General Plan. The project was referred to other agencies who recommended approval or conditional approval.
And the recommendations have been included as recommended conditions of approval for the project. Here we have the wetlands in their current state. Blue shows the three parameter wetlands and green, it's a little harder to see, but that shows the one parameter wetlands. The applicant is proposing to consolidate the existing wetlands as well as introduce new wetlands, and so the conceptual footprint for that is shown on the right. Mitigation includes creation of three parameter wetlands at a ratio of 1.5 to 1. Created wetlands will be dominated by native species, they have a low target invasive plant cover, and created wetlands will show an improvement in quality over baseline conditions. Maintenance and monitoring will occur over a five year period to ensure that objectives are met. So we just went over the mitigation and monitoring, and we're also going to go over the adaptive management strategies as well as briefly the success criteria.
So adaptive management strategies include adjusting weeding methods, supplemental planting or replacement of native species that are not doing as well as expected, supplemental watering, minor regrading, or erosion control, additional erosion control. And that would be dependent on a variety of factors that may or may not occur, including multiple drought years, sedimentation, things of that nature, particularly aggressive invasive species. Success criteria includes a creation of 28,000 approximately square feet of three-parameter wetland that hosts at least 70% relative cover of native wetland species and supports wetland hydrology. So now I'm going to turn it over to Bob, and he'll go over the exception request for the widening of Hiller Road. Good evening. My name is Bob Bronkel. I'm the Humboldt County Surveyor, and I'm representing the Public Works Department tonight in regards to this project. The first slide before you.
is to give you a perspective of what the current conditions of Hiller Road look like. This is a Google Street View image from Central Avenue looking west down the road. Hiller Road is an 80-foot wide right-of-way, which is exceptionally large. At the intersection, it is developed to its fullest extent with curb, gutter, and sidewalk on both sides of the road in that particular location. Next slide. As part of the McKinleyville Town Center project, there was a proposed concept for how Hiller Road would be developed, and this includes adding medians, left turn pockets, a Class 1 bikeway, 8-foot wide sidewalks along the road. That's the vision that is currently in the process of being approved for the McKinleyville Town Center project.
Town Center. Next slide please. The project is requiring the subdivider to go ahead and widen and expand the existing edge of pavement on Hiller Road and according to the applicant's engineer the widening would be plus or minus 13 feet and what this would essentially accomplish when the subdivider goes ahead and widens the road and adds the infill paving and the curb gutter the landscape strip and the sidewalk they're effectively building the south portion of the right-of-way which will eventually become the eastbound travel lane. So these improvements are necessary in order to go ahead and construct the ultimate cross-section that's planned for Hiller Road. The department
does not believe that the improvements, the infill paving improvements constructed by the subdivider would need to be torn out when the ultimate improvement is constructed. It is important to note that the medians, left turn pockets, and other improvements shown on the right side of the slide, that's to be done in the future by others when funding does become available. But this project has been conditioned to begin fulfilling this mission of seeing Hiller Road come into its ultimate configuration. Next slide, please. One of the options that this project will present itself by widening the road ahead of the rest of the future improvements is that the there's an opportunity to temporarily install a class two bike lane with
painted buffer within the area that the applicant's going to go ahead and widen. This will provide bicyclists with a large bike lane plus a large painted buffer all from the existing edge of pavement. I believe this concludes my slides. Actually, not quite. There's two more. There are some concerns and questions regarding the ability of public works to go ahead and require certain subdivision improvements to be constructed. That authority rests within County Code 324-1. It's a rather long read, but the gist of it is paragraph B and C. B essentially states that any road lying within the subdivision shall be constructed. The standards in the appendix and part C is off-site.
improvements may be required by the director. So that essentially covers all on-site and off-site improvements that are necessary for a subdivision. Next slide. This slide is to go ahead and demonstrate that it's not an unusual ask by Public Works to have developers widen and install a curb line in its ultimate location. Starting in the upper left, that picture is of Washington Avenue. That's Jim Furtado's school Washington Terrace project. And that project widened the road by roughly 13 feet, installed curb gutter, plus an 8-foot wide curb line. It's a 9-foot wide walking trail. They installed about 1,000 feet of frontage improvements, including off-site.
From School Road to the northern edges of the subdivision. The upper right-hand corner is Hiller Road. There's been a few developments along Hiller Road, and as those projects have been developed, those projects also went ahead and widened Hiller Road, including infill paving to its ultimate condition. The lower left picture is a subdivision in the Campton-slash-Ridgewood-ish area where Walnut Avenue was widened with a curb gutter sidewalk put in. And then in the lower right, that is the Humboldt Hill area where a parcel map subdivision went ahead and widened the shoulder of the road. It's an installed curb gutter sidewalk along there.
Thank you. So this is a portion of the McKinleyville Q-Zone ordinance. It's the same document that Bob had referenced previous in the slide with the cross-section for Hiller Road. And this is just to highlight the timing. The ordinance requires that improvements be constructed at the earliest practical stage of development. I just thought that was important to bring up. And next we'll move on to staff recommendations, which will conclude the presentation. So staff is recommending that the Planning Commission find the EIR, did assess the environmental impacts of the proposed project, and therefore no further environmental review is required. The proposed project complies with the general plan, community plan, and zoning ordinance, and that the Planning Commission approve the subdivision and special permit subject to recommended conditions of approval and deny the exception for the road widening and paving. Staff's available.
for questions. Thank you. Any questions for some? Thank you Mr. Holterman, Mr. Bronkel. Just a quick question. On the part of Hiller Road that we're discussing now, is there any existing bike path either on the south or north side of Hiller at present? In some areas along Hiller Road there is a shoulder that could be used for bicycling but the road is not developed with class two or class three bike facilities at this time. So there's no, as I understand it, no paved marked bike lane on Hiller there. Correct. Thanks. Okay. I have a question regarding clarification. Is it required that the applicant be able to use the road on Hiller Road? Yes. And dedicate a certain
portion of the north part of their parcel as an easement towards this hill or road development did i read read that correctly and if so is that is what's the actual length of that what's the distance from you know distance north of that portion of their parcel that they have to dedicate good question one of the standard conditions that public works imposes on projects is to go ahead and confirm that right away dedications have been properly dedicated and in the event that there's a deficiency in a prior dedication that a solid dedication is made as part of the project in this particular case it's my understanding that the hillar road right away is an existing 80 foot right away along the road and the applicant would not be dedicating any public road right away beyond the existing 80 foot right away right
The project does include provisions to dedicate an adjacent 10-foot wide public utility easement adjacent to the right-of-way. There is some concern if that easement is needed, and Public Works has modified the requirement for the PUE to be needed only in cases where a utility company needs to go ahead and put facilities. So as the project is developed and the applicant begins designing the improvements and working with the utility companies, the need for placing utility infrastructure in that area will become evident, and only in those areas would a PUE be dedicated, and that will be dedicated on the parcel map. I have a question.
Looking for layman's terms. So you've, you want the infrastructure put in for the bike lane, the curbs, the sidewalk at the expense of the developer. Is that correct? Is that what I'm hearing? Yes, the roadway frontage improvements for all subdivisions are installed at the expense of the applicant. Is that, is that a request or a requirement? It's required by county code. Okay. Thank you. Any other questions? Okay. It looks like no other questions at this time. We will move to the public comment portion of this agenda item. Public comment is typically three minutes. We usually start off with the applicant who has a little bit longer to present if they would like to. Do we have an applicant representative in the audience today? Or online? Yes, please. Is Emma Haskett online?
No, I don't see an Emma Haskett online. Oh, okay. I guess you guys are early. I guess we thought we were going to be here later. She had a whole nice presentation. Okay. So if you're presenting for the applicant, we typically allow 10 minutes for the applicant to make a presentation if they would like to. Yeah. If you are not presenting for the applicant, then please limit your comments to three minutes. I'm the formal applicant. I'm Anne Lindsey. I'm president of the board of Life Plan Humboldt. Emma Haskett's our project manager, and she did have a prepared presentation. But I don't know where she is. I guess she thought you weren't going to get to this so quickly. It's at the end of the agenda. Anyway, that in contention is not the sidewalk and the bike trail. We've actually been fundraising amongst the community for that, and we think that's a good idea. It'll benefit our residents. What we're concerned about is the, I think it's, eight or 10 feet widening of hill or road.
and paving that in order, because otherwise there would be an empty spot between where we're putting the sidewalk and where Hiller Road currently starts. We feel it's out of proportion, there's a disproportionate share of expense put on us to actually repave a county road. And there is actually legal precedent in other areas where they've gone for a proportionate share. Now, Emma had, according to the Environmental Impact Report, the vehicle miles traveled and the usage of the residents of Humboldt Commons and affordable housing there are going to be less than 5% of the total traffic on Hiller Road, yet we're burying the entire cost. The entire. All those improvements that we're.
required in development to put in by the county include nursery way, the midtown trail, the bike trail and the sidewalk and with this it would total 1.5 million dollars. We are the our construction costs are going to be paid by entry fees that we're charging residents and we're projected to have at the start about 100 or 109 resident units. So 1.5 million dollars would raise each entry fee by 15,000 dollars. We've been struggling to keep our entry fees affordable for mid-income residents and 15,000 dollars is a huge jump. Putting the paving alone would also add would add another at least another 200,000 dollars which would be 2,000 dollars per entry fee.
The entry fees pay the construction bonds. The residents also pay a monthly fee, but that'll pay our ongoing. We have long-term bonds for our operating expenses. So that's the issue at hand. And as Emma submitted a formal report requesting that we actually leave it fallow, the area fallow, we can sod it and mow it. My concern is if you look at that, it was perfect. Emma was going to show a picture of Hiller, what it looks like. It's hugely wide up there in front of the Church of the Abbey where they were required to widen the street. The long-term plan for Hiller Road is to narrow the traffic and slow it down. It could be 20 years before that nice picture that was shown. So that was adopted with a...
Q zone ordinance gets enacted. And so meanwhile, the car is going to be zooming by. It would be a lot safer for everybody if it were not paved. Thank you. Okay, and with that, we'll invite anybody else who would like to make a public comment on this item. If you're in the room, please approach the podium. If you are online, please raise your hand. And if you're calling in, it is star 9 to raise your hand. Please do so now. If you would like to say something regarding this item, this is your opportunity to do so. Please approach the podium. Each person will have three minutes to speak. Okay. Good evening. My name is Evelyn Doyle, and I'm a family nurse practitioner and have worked with elders for over 50 years. And I know that mobility is a big question.
and concern, and if you're going to be widening that road, do you know how long it takes to get a walker across that street? So I'm thinking of the safety for our elders. I plan to be a future resident there, and I'd like my area to be safe. The idea of putting in plants and putting in sod and such, that would help our elders also have something to do with gardening, and they love working with the soil, so to have activities for them to be able to do and have a beautiful space in which to live, with the wide roads, with the ability to have a bicycle path, and to have a place where they could walk and feel safe doing that. I have worked up in McKinleyville there by the safeway, and there has been a lot of fast traffic that goes down that road, and so... So making it so it's not so wide might be a very good idea, especially as it gets busier in that...
area and I would just say that having we need senior housing that's for sure I'm pretty sure you guys know that but we already had a couple of fundraisers trying to raise up enough money just for the curbs and the sidewalks and stuff like that they were grand fun sorry you guys missed them but you know it was also we raised quite a bit of money in doing so so there's a very big community support for doing this and I am on a very tight budget mainly social security now as many of our elders are so having to put on this extra burden makes it really difficult for people to be able to move forward and be in a place where they feel safe and they feel part of the community and I am hoping that y'all will work with the Humboldt County Commission here and get this working because we can do it thank you
Thank you. Hi, I'm Laurel Stifler. I'm a McKinleyville resident. I own a home right across the fence from the Life Plan property, and I will be one of the residents there. I am always more than willing to pay my share of anything, and I will be a resident there because I don't have many other choices. I'll be a resident there if I have to be in the smallest unit, but I'm just hoping an exception can be made to keep the costs down. There are people who are going to move in there who are selling houses that are much more expensive than mine, and just hope that an exception can be made. Thank you. If anybody else would like to speak in the room, please approach the podium. And if you are online or calling in and you would like to speak, please raise your hand now. Good evening. My name is Beth Matsumoto. I'm the director of the Life Plan.
I am with Rural Communities Housing Development Corporation. We're the nonprofit that's sponsoring the affordable housing development that's planned for adjacent to the Life Plan Humboldt and I guess it's called Humboldt Commons Development. I was hoping to hear Emma's presentation, so I wasn't sure if maybe you could let the Zoom go on and then can we come back afterwards or is that not how you run things? Unfortunately, no. We only have one public comment period. Great. Sorry I'm late. I didn't know you guys were going to go so fast. I just wanted to echo Anne's comments and I guess paving the road is a big deal, adds extra cost. The housing is sorely needed in McKinleyville, especially because the Life Plan Humboldt project is actually creating an affordable housing asset. So it's important to support and ensure that they can afford their development so that we can actually create. That affordable housing asset for the community which will serve.
Oh and very low income seniors in McKinleyville. So thank you. Anybody else in the room who would like to comment. OK. Seeing none I'm going to turn it over to the online callers. And it looks like I am seeing Emma Haskett now online. But as somebody already spoke in for the applicant. But if you would like to if you or anybody else would like to speak please raise your hands and I will go in order. And as a reminder it is star nine if you were on the phone to raise your hand. I'm not seeing any hands raised. So I'm going to go ahead and just one more time because I heard that there might be somebody online. But I'm going to close public comment here shortly if I don't see any hands raised. I know she's online. But she doesn't have her hand raised. Emma raise your hand.
Hello, can you hear me? Okay, yeah. Hi, you can go ahead. I'm so sorry. I was having a lot of technical difficulties. Is there a slideshow still available? If you could keep your comments to about three minutes, I think we can do a slideshow. Wonderful. Okay, can everybody see the screen? Yes. All right. Well, apologies again for the delay. My name is Emma Haskett, and I'm here on behalf of Humboldt Commons. Next slide, please. Are you able to go to the next slide? Or can I do this myself? And then I'll give you a couple of extra minutes since we're having some technical difficulties.
Okay, I'm glad I'm not the only one. It looks like we are unable to do it. Are you able to do it on your end? I don't believe so. Doesn't look like I have control. I think we promoted you to panelist. Someone has control. Oh, there we go. Alright, so I just wanted to start by saying I share the same goals. Humboldt Commons shares the same goals as everyone on this commission and the county. We all want safer roads for McKinleyville. We all want responsible development that benefits this community. And we'd all love to see the McKinleyville Town Center come to life. So we're asking that you please help us make that happen by granting an exception to the county requirement that we widen Hill...
road. Next slide, please. So here I'm trying to give you a whole picture of what's being asked of us for the public multimodal infrastructure that the county is requiring us to build as a condition of the subdivision. This site plan shows phase one, which is in the middle section, which is part of the Humboldt Commons we plan to build by 2029. We currently don't have a construction timeline for phase two. And the L-shaped polygon in blue on the east side is the second parcel in our subdivision. And everything highlighted in red is the county required improvements for Humboldt Commons, which includes the nursery way extension, the midtown trail connection, and full curb gutter and sidewalk along our frontage with Hiller Road. The county is also requiring us to build a new road that is about 12 feet wide along our frontage with Hiller, which is almost 15,000
and 400 square feet of new pavement. Next slide please. So this is all going to cost a lot of money. Our budget currently allocates $575,000 to Hiller Road improvements, which just includes curb gutter and sidewalk, $550,000 to the nursery way extension, and $175,000 to the Midtown Trail. The county is asking us to pay an additional $200,000 to widen Hiller Road, which brings our total county required subdivision improvements to $1.5 million. So again, we're just asking you to grant an exception to the additional requirement to widen Hiller Road. Next slide please. This slide is to help illustrate our actual impact on Hiller Road. Our type of facility generates about 2.4% trips per unit per day. Phase one will have 109 units, which will
generate approximately 262 daily trips and Hiller Road currently carries about 3,000 trips per day between McKinleyville Avenue and Central Avenue. That means our development will be responsible for about 8% of traffic on this stretch of road. So we are responsible for about 8% of traffic and the county's environmental impact report also says our impact is less than significant. So to summarize this entire slide seniors simply drive less than other people. Next slide please. And the next couple of slides I'll go through really quickly. This is just looking West on Hiller Road and the red line represents our our westernmost property line. So you can see in front of the the developments to the left here that the road has been widened approximately 20 feet from the property line and the road has been widened and it's mostly used for parking. And then the next slide.
And then traveling further down on Hiller Road, you can see the sidewalk ends and the road narrows again for a short stretch. Next slide, please. And then again, the road widens in front of the next development, creating a very large shoulder. Next slide, please. And finally, here is Hiller Road and McKinleyville Avenue intersection, where the sidewalk ends and the road narrows again. So what I'm trying to show here is that beyond the cost, this piecemeal paving doesn't make practical sense, and there's a safety concern. Adding 12-foot feet of pavement next to the existing travel lane creates an abnormally wide, unstructured shoulder with no clear purpose. The wider road has already encouraged faster driving and created confusion for both drivers and cyclists. County staff have also confirmed there is no need for a new road. No funding and no timeline for the ultimate Hiller Road boulevard design that the...
paving is meant to support. It could be 10 to 20 years before anything is built and in the meantime this is not a good use of limited non-profit dollars. Humboldt Commons is instead proposing to restore this 12-foot gap to its existing condition as a maintained vegetated buffer which is a safer more practical solution until the county is ready to build. Next slide please. So the county code allows the commission to grant an exception if three findings are met and let me walk through these really briefly. If you could very quickly walk through them please. What's that? Oh I'm sorry we are pretty much at the end of your time so if you could please wrap things up. All right well these are the exception or these are the findings that we have found and we asked the commission this is the first development in the McKinleyville town center. We are the ones leading
The way we are already investing over a million dollars in county required subdivision improvements to make that happen. And we're asking that the requirements be proportional to our actual impact, which is exactly what the law requires. So we respectfully ask the commission to grant this exception and approve our subdivision application. Thank you. Thank you. OK, do we have any questions for the applicant? Really quickly. This is, I guess, towards staff. Towards staff. Is there any precedent for postponing those improvements to a date in the future, but still putting that financial burden on the applicant, but not at the onset of the project? I mean, I've done projects before and been required to spend millions of dollars on things that had nothing to do with the project, and that's how the county funds things. But in this case, since there.
isn't other development yet could there be a postponement but you know that they might come back and ask for an extension but maybe in a better position down the road i think that's possible i would point out to the commission though that the property immediately to the west of this site is widened so it would be a continuation from where it's been widened at the church all the way to central and and i didn't really um comprehend or catch what the adverse impact would be if they don't do it i've been on that road a lot i've ridden my bike on that road you know it's a fast road because it's going downhill as you go down towards the church but um what would have what would be the adverse impact if they didn't widen it because you know i heard what they had to say and it had to do with finances but um
If I could just talk a little bit, this is a very difficult situation and, you know, everybody is supportive of Life Plan Humboldt, absolutely. I think part of this thing that is normal is the first lane of traffic, curb, gutter, and sidewalk are normal improvements for development. You've developed enough property, you know that. And so when it comes to orderly development, what do you want that area to look like? One of the things that's being presented, and I would ask you to think about this, is to put grass in there and maybe some other plantings and that would look nice. Encourage people to be there. That's the public right-of-way. That's putting them in the public right-of-way where cars are, as has been testified, going by too fast. That's...
Not something the county wants to take liability for. So, I mean, I'm just trying to give you a larger picture to think about because obviously if it's not done now, it'll be harder to get done later. And we are doing a planned development and we want it to look a certain way. And, you know, so I'm for not waiving it. But if there's a postponement because of finances at the beginning of the project, there could be different alternative ways that it could have been funded. I don't know. I'm not involved in that project. But I've done projects where I've had to spend several million dollars on stuff that had nothing to do with the project that I was building. So... Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. But that's how you get improvements done.
And so there are some options there to think about. You've probably done this before. Some of the reasonable options, I'm not sure that we didn't condition it this way, but it's to require the improvements to be done with the development. That's quite often done so that you're not breaking things up as you're hauling heavy things on and off the site. You could extend it beyond when the development occurs. There are some complications with that because then there is a driveway that goes out onto Hiller. And so you'd have a strange kind of extension of pavement that goes over to connect to that. And depending on what it is, whether it's gravel or more of a gravel, it's a good idea to extend it. It's a good idea to extend it. If you grasped its mode, you would have something that is in the public right-of-way that...
It is very different from the finished street. And so part of what we try to do is create orderly development. And yes, there are some improvement requirements associated with this parcel. And I understand this is a nonprofit and it's difficult. And so those really are some things for the commission to think about is when should it be done. And it is almost easier, and I'm going to stop talking and ask Mr. Bronkel to talk a little bit about this, but it's harder once you put in like the curb gutter and then the sidewalk than to come back in and pave that. Because you're now trying to match something that's, has to be regraded and rethought through. And it is a planned development.
It's unfortunate, but that's, you know, what we were looking for is a town site development. I'm a McKinleyville resident, and you want it to look the way you planned for it to look from the very beginning. And if you make one exception, then you're going to make another exception, and pretty soon it's just not going to ever be what you planned it to be. Really quick, for the sake of process, I just want to acknowledge that I did not see any other public commenters online or in the room, and that I closed public comment. And then I believe, Director Ford, you said you wanted to turn it over to Mr. Bronkel for a comment. Thank you. The project has been conditioned where all of the improvements, this includes Nursery Way and Hiller Avenue, to be tied to time of occupancy for the project. And that affords the greatest flexibility for the applicant. Thank you. Thank you.
and delay those improvements right up to the point when people are just about ready to go ahead and move in. Normally with a subdivision project, the road improvements need to be constructed and completed before issuance of a building permit. But because of the nature of this project being essentially a commercial type project, it's appropriate to go ahead and tie the improvements to time of occupancy. So that's one benefit that will help the applicant out as they move forward. During the public testimony that was given for the project, one of the items that was repeated over and over again was the speed of traffic along the road. And there is something that could benefit this project. But, uh, and it could be done in a way that allows
flexibility to the applicant but does not create a requirement. The County of Humboldt has a speed hump policy for installing speed humps that requires a lot of legwork by the applicant to go ahead and do that. Historically the Planning Commission has taken upon itself to include requirements for the construction of speed humps with certain projects and what I'm suggesting to the Commission tonight is rather than requiring the construction of speed humps to control speed that the Commission may wish to consider allowing the option that should the applicant find that traffic is going too fast and they need a safer way for their residents to cross the street to get to Safeway that they are pre-authorized to install
all up to three speed humps along the road and that avoids the need to go through the formal speed home policy but allows them to install this later on should they the applicant determine that it's in the interest of the deeds of their residents and their community that they're building another topic that was brought up was Nexus and proportionality the furtado project on Washington Avenue was approximately 30 lots and they widened the road and did improvements for about a thousand linear feet this project is plus or minus 100 units and their frontage is about 1,300 feet in both cases is about 1,500 feet in both cases those projects fit within the established nexus
and proportionality requirements for improvements for the project. And then lastly, there was a discussion about planting grass or leaving the area fallow between the existing edge of pavement and the newly installed curb and gutter. And frankly, that creates a safety issue that public works can't support on a county-maintained road. Thank you. Commissioner Levy. Can I ask you to follow up on that last sentence, why it would be create a safety hazard to allow gravel or grass as a temporary boundary area between the curb and gutter and the existing paved road? Certainly, if a car were to go ahead and come off the pavement, it makes a recovery.
Every back onto the paved road more challenging. One of the greatest incidents of collisions on our roads are run-off-the-road collisions where vehicles leave the travel way. Thank you. So I think what I struggle with, I'll give a little bit of background. One of the things I struggled with when approving the town center plan to begin with was the width of Hiller Road. And it's interesting that we're, who knows why there's an 80-foot right-of-way, but there is. Maybe, I don't know if it's beneficial for staff to go into why that is. But regardless, we're clearly...
The trying to use up that space and the part of what the town center plan is doing is trying to use up that space in it, but also in a way that argues that we're slowing down the speed of traffic. However, it claims to do so by proposing 13-foot wide roads, and that's an exceptionally wide road, in my opinion. There is no evidence that a 13-foot wide road will slow down traffic even to the current posted speed limit of 35 miles an hour, let alone, I don't know if a slower speed limit is planned or designed. So that's kind of fundamental to one of the things that I'm struggling with here is we have a town center that's trying to induce pedestrian activity. We have a McKinleyville community plan.
And that is arguing a safe environment. And even the road design manuals listed in the conditions by Public Works clearly state, argue for narrower road lanes on urban collectors and local roads. And so when we're asking a nonprofit affordable housing developer to start the pavement process for something that, in my opinion, there's no documentation that will create a slower vehicle speed and an increased safe environment for pedestrians and bicyclists in an area where we're looking to increase substantially the density, the activity from pedestrians. We... It states specifically that this is going to be a place for community gathering. It is mixed use. It is high-density residential.
and hill or road really does cut through right through the middle of this even more so i would argue than central and so i i'm coming at it from from that perspective where i would really like to find a way to i guess delay this improvement and and leverage leverage that i guess that you know in existing planning documents such as the community plant the mckinleyville community plan it allows for entertaining alternative road designs specifically in section 4260 um and uh... the public works comments or or the conditions for the requirements state
There's nothing intended to prevent approving alternate typical sections. I understand that we are constrained in what was approved in the town center plan. However, the town center plan itself also states that there is room, or I should say the EIR for the town center states that there is room for minor modifications to the cross sections of Hiller and Central. So with all that, I'm struggling to require, I'll just kind of repeat where I started. I'm struggling to require a non-profit affordable housing company that is trying to kick start the town center to pave and put in, start the permanent infrastructure for something that I personally know actually will not achieve what is sought after. I think also
I will say the speed hump idea, I think it's a great idea. I don't think that is a fair ask to add an additional cost onto an applicant for achieving a safety requirement that clearly isn't there. We've said that, Mr. Bronkel has said that the right-of-way is exceptionally wide. Commissioner O'Neill has stated that it already is a fast road. I would argue there's already a lack of safety. I assume that were speed data and daily traffic counts taken on that road, you would see the 85th percentile exceed well above the posted speed limit. And I don't think that's the intent here. So it seems unfair to put an additional option of increased expense on an applicant. That's already struggling to meet the current.
I think speed humps are a great idea. I would put that on the county. So I guess with that, I'm really struggling with denying the exception. But however, I'm recognizing I do agree that the precedent there is to require these improvements on project developers. That's the way we do things. I'm not interested in changing that precedent at all. And we're already putting in curb, gutter, and sidewalk. I think that it's absolutely necessary for that to happen. And I guess I'll bring up one last point. In the public works conditions in their letter, they do state, that the widening of Hiller Road may require
the reconstruction of the existing road to provide a uniform centerline grade compatible with the proposed curb grade. And so that reads to me that as they go down the line, they actually could be asked to completely reconstruct Hiller Road itself, at least on the stretch that they're on. And so all of this put together, I'm struggling with how to require improvements that we know are needed. But in the context of a cross-section design that I know won't achieve the low vehicle speed limits that are intended, and also is putting an additional cost burden on this applicant. I apologize for leaving it a bit open-ended. But I'm not ready to just simply accept staff's recommendations. Commissioner O'Neill.
Why not have the county look for funding to assist the project? I would think that a crosswalk like they have at Little Pond and Murray that flashes would be a good addition. There's a lot of improvements that could be done to that road on a road project through HCOG funding or some other source of funding. Every project that I've ever done, I had to find funding for it. Nobody found it for me, but I did partner with the county, got funding and was able to do that. I don't know where their funding has come from so far, but there's low income tax credit funding, there's HCOG funding, I don't know if there's HUD funding anymore. But there's... Yeah. I'm not saying that...
I haven't already looked for all that, but the county could assist. I don't know what your priorities are on your H-Cog list, but that whole road could be improved as a project, which would be several million dollars and would assist all of the future residents along there that want to have projects. I mean, that's something that if that's the desire of the commission, that can certainly be done. But I would just caution that the H-Cog list is not just the county's choice. That is something that the greater county comes together and decides what the priorities are. I'm just, you know, as a McKinleyville resident, I'd like to see more attention given to McKinleyville when it comes to improving the roads. That's where you want to put everybody. You want to put the homeless people there. You want to put low-income people there. You want it to be your increased housing, but I don't see a lot of money.
coming back to mckinleyville for the amount of taxes that we pay um and i i mean we don't have an accounting of it we bet we asked i know madrone was looking into how much taxes we pay versus what we get back but a project like this that benefits low-income residents should be a priority of the counties if you want low-income people to live in mckinleyville then help us out so what would that look like that would look like the county looking at you have public works i i know but let's take it one step at a time so it would look like this applicant not installing those improvements i wouldn't let them off the hook they're still required that those improvements happen but the county could look for assistance in in doing a project that would assist them i i i mean ideally that's a wonderful idea what happens if we can't find funding. Well you said you're putting the improvements off to the end.
into the project. I would assume it's going to be a two-year project. I don't know. So we've got two years to find the funds. I mean, that's all I do. For 50 years, that's all I've done, and I know it's possible. I don't want to be argumentative, but you know how long it takes to submit an application when the NOFA comes out, when you can go ahead and get that in to get it approved and then get the money to be able to spend. And I'm not suggesting that we I feel like we need to say that it needs to be done, okay? But I'm also saying it would be really nice if we could in some way have the county assist in trying to locate funding to do a much bigger project than just in front of this project. Do a lot of the improvements that we'd like to see for the town site plan, but it's never going to happen if we don't say let's do it. You are right about that.
Thank you. And I'll shut up. Commissioner Levy. I don't want to repeat what others have said, but I think this is a really valuable discussion that we're having. I certainly do understand that the way public improvements get funded, get done, is by tying the requirement of a section of it to each new development. I agree with Commissioner O'Neill that I don't therefore support granting a straight up exception request that would sort of relieve them of that obligation. But I also am concerned by some of the particular points that Commissioner Curiazzi brings up, which to me signal that in the time it will take to find funding, further refine the plan, and actually build out the plan, and actually build out Hiller Road.
I think there's a decent reason to believe that there may be some wish to re-evaluate some of the widths and designations in that road profile. I know it's certainly not a sure thing, but the idea that we might actually have to resurface or grade the paved part down the road, undoing what might be required here. And the other thing I want to just point out is that while it's certainly a very relevant example that Mr. Bronkel raises about the Furtado development for a smaller number of units, you know, and 70 or so percent distance of the longer distance here, they did their share. But A, that is a commercial development which has the ability to sell those units at market rate. And I know we've all considered. The idea that when you add those requirements to the cost, it raises the cost of housing.
You know, and so that's not something that developers like to do, but it's, I guess what I'm trying to say is that I think there's a stronger equitable argument to be made here for Life Plan Humboldt to reach some accommodation with the county, whereby, if not relieving them of the burden to do that, we could at least defer when that has to happen. Because let's just all remember, too, I thought that slide that Emma Haskett put up was really helpful to see the total bill of costs that are essentially for this project, but they're funding county public improvements and transit, you know, particularly the nursery way extension, I understand it. That's a big cost they're taking on that will, in fact, help. Implement the build out of the town center. So it seems to me that they really are bearing.
At least their fair share and I would argue perhaps more of what will go into what will need to be funded to accomplish the town center goals. So perhaps there is something to be said for postponing the timing by which this additional paved roadway part requirement comes into effect and seeing if in the meantime there could be some joint effort to raise the funds to do it in a more unified manner. You could even make the argument, just for the sake of argument, that by a section like this getting done at the expense of this non-profit development reduces the likelihood that we can find the wherewithal to do... do a unified project with county sponsorship. Maybe that's not true. But all things being equal, this is...
The sort of development that would be better done at one time rather than piecemeal. Obviously a lot of things, curbs and sidewalks and all those things do get done piecemeal, but nobody would suggest that's the ideal way to do it. So for all those reasons, I'm interested in looking for some accommodation, if not a full exception grant, then some other accommodation to this applicant. Commissioner Fulton. I, although I do sympathize for any developer that has to subsidize or pay for anything that the general public gets more use out of than the developer, but I question, I ask the commission to think about this from a developer's point of view. Would we be having this conversation if this was a regular developer, or are we making, um,
exceptions because of their nonprofit status. If it was a regular developer doing this exact same project, we would be having these conversations in regards to who pays for what. I only ask that you just think about that before you make your decision. I sympathize with all parties involved, developers and nonprofits that have to pay for these things, but that's the regulations. That's the rules in which we have to live by. So that's just my comment. I asked myself that same question. I think fairness is really important when we make these kinds of decisions. And similar to some of the other commissioners, I'm feeling a little bit torn. And I think for me the conflict is not necessarily – this is a great project. It has a lot of value to the community. But no matter who was developing it, I am also struggling with the – I think it's a great project. I think it's a great project.
The dissidence between wanting a slower road that is pedestrian friendly and an 80 foot wide road footprint. Those two things in my experience don't necessarily go hand in hand. So I also don't have a great solution to move this along. I am also hoping we can find some sort of compromise in this respect. Thank you. If I could just respond a little bit, I wish we'd had this discussion as part of the town center because we wouldn't be having this discussion now. I mean, we did approve that cross-section, and that cross-section is being reviewed by the MCMAC for their review and approval in terms of what Hiller should look like. So if it's not approved, I don't know.
It's the commission's desire to see the lanes be narrow or the right-of-ways there. If it's the commission's desire to see the lanes be narrowed down, that can certainly be done. That's one of the reasons I think Commissioner Curiosi is right. We did put in a pretty large island that allows pretty nice turn lanes. There's also room on the north side of the road that not only has a landscape strip, but it has a 10-foot bicycle trail. It also has a widened area for people to gather. So there's room. So the question then becomes, if you don't want it to be a 13-foot wide lane, got it. We can narrow the lane. But where does... Where does the improvements begin?
end and what do you want those to look like? Those are great questions and I think personally I remember some of our other projects in McKinleyville that have come forth when people are when development isn't required during the initial process and somehow people forget that the right-of-way is not developable property and it's really hard to pull that back later down the road. We struggled with that as a commission. I'm sorry a public oh thank you. Yeah. We have struggled with that as the commission in the past when looking at projects so I resonate with wanting to do wanting to make sure that whatever is going to happen with this piece of the road is not kicked too far down the road. Down the road. Anyways. Other comments from the Commission? I don't think we should be modifying
I'm applying the plan that we just approved on a case-by-case basis. I mean, if you didn't want the road that wide, then we should have brought that up a long time ago. It is a right-of-way. You'd have to reduce the right-of-way for everybody all the way down the road. I don't think we should be doing that piecemeal. The only thing that I would recommend is the timing of when they would have to do this, and you would give them some time to raise additional funds. You've already said they're not required to do it to occupancy. I don't know if we could go beyond that. I would stick to our plan. If I could, just to throw something out for the sake of discussion. Sorry, Commissioner Chiarazzi. But what would be an appropriate period of time to extend that improvement? Five years? And I know you talked about... Five years of working with the county also to see if there's alternative ways to fund it. Okay. Keeping our idea...
out for what's available as it comes in and putting in an application. And sometimes when there's a sense of urgency, there might be a foundation that might step up and help out because they know they need that help. I don't know what the finances are going to be once they're open or whether or not they'll be able to save money or borrow money or what, you know. I would look for funding during that five-year period, and if not, they better be planning on what the alternative is because they're going to have to pave it and do what they need to do to comply with their permit. So you would still, if I'm hearing you right, and I'm just really trying to help you get to a place where you can formulate a motion, is that the obligation would still be upon the commons, but there would be an agreement, an obligation, or first and then it would be extended, and then there would be direction. For staff to work.
with the commons and other developers along that route too that might come along in that five-year period to just do the entire improvement to the road that needs to do the entire that's it that's well i mean to a certain extent i mean i i don't even know if a million and a half dollars will do what they want to do you know that's their estimate it could come in much higher than that so you know design it get an engineer's estimate um you know and go forward with what you can afford you know in a grant application to do and maybe they end up only having to put in a match you know to get everything done yeah i i don't know that this is something that is completely supported by all the commissioners but if it is when we get kind of close to an idea i would ask if we could take a break and allow us to brainstorm a little bit and i'll offer you a condition we are coming up on our typical break time um
Is there more that you want to say before we go on to break? I just would support taking a break and letting them. I like where Commissioner O'Neill's proposal was taking us in general. I would, of course, want to hear from the other commissioners as well, but I would support taking that suggestion. Okay. Commissioner Curiazzi? Yeah, thank you. I think just before we break, I just want to address the very good point of the wish that we had discussed this prior, and I definitely recognize that as a fault of mine, and I think just still getting my feet under me. But it was something I absolutely struggled with. Is it too late to – I absolutely see the argument there. For me, it is a question of safety, and so that's why I'm holding on to it, and that's why I'm having the courage to bring it up now, I guess. But I do apologize for not bringing it up. I'm bringing it up during the discussion at the town center.
And it is a good point that we should not be piecemealing things. I didn't get a chance to weigh in on the McKinleyville Town Center. I was out on maternity leave, but will respect the decisions of the commission at that time. Okay, let's go ahead and take a 10-minute break, 11-minute break. Let's return at 8.05, please. Thank you.
Thank you. Thank you. All right. I'm going to bring us back from our break. And I'm going to give the floor to staff if they'd like. Yeah. So what we'd like to do is add a condition. And forgive me for not having it completely written out, but it would include the following provisions. That the interim improvement would include a buffered bike lane that would be striped by the county. And the rationale for that.
is that there's more funding available for improvements that are bike and pedestrian related than just vehicular related so we want to make this a pedestrian improvement and and then secondly the lane widths I'm not sure that that cross-section has been formally approved by the MCMAC I know that the director of public works has been working with the MCMAC so the the final lane widths will be determined by the MCMAC and then we'd like to add into the condition that there will be flexibility to allow shifting within the cross-section based upon the approved design of the roadway by the MCMAC and the Board of Supervisors and then what we'd like to do is to require that the applicant be granted five years from the issuance of building permit
to have the improvements constructed and that there would be a subdivision agreement and bonding required with that which is a normal deferral of improvements and then the condition would also include that county will seek funding to improve the full cross-section improvements for Hiller Road for the length of the project. So basically we would end up with a full cross-section improved basically along the shopping center on the north and the Life Plan Humboldt on the south. One thing you may wish to consider in regards to the seeking the grant opportunities is to allow the grants
Opportunities to be for either the full build out or for the buffered bike lane interim condition. That may afford different grant type opportunities that are out there to achieve a possible greater success. Hold on one second. I heard somebody make a motion so I want to give deference to. I make a motion to agree with what he just said. Okay. And all the other recommendations. Okay. And then Commissioner Curiasi. I guess so we're not hearing a second or I'm not offering a second. Okay. Should we wait for that first? Yes. Let's finish hearing if this motion has a second and then we'll go to other comments. I would second. Okay. All right. I have a motion and a second. Any discussion on the motion? I apologize. Can you repeat what? You said Mr. Bronco one more time. I don't know.
I appreciate it. Director Ford was proposing that the county will go ahead and seek grant funding for the full cross-section that is ultimately being recommended by MCMAC and approved by the board. And I'm suggesting that there be an or statement in there or seek grant funding for the interim condition, which would be the widening to add in the buffered bike lane along there. Awesome. Thank you. Can I also request amending the... Furthermore, well, first, I very much appreciate what staff is proposing. I agree. I'm feeling a lot better about this. Can I suggest an amendment or to include... I'm still concerned about what the Public Works...
It says that it may require the reconstruction of the existing road. So would staff be amenable to that? That would not be put on this applicant. If, as you're going through this project, it looks like you have to provide a uniform centerline grade compatible with proposed curb grade, that is suddenly a significant additional expense. So can we try to ensure that that does not get put on this applicant? I've had the opportunity to personally walk the entire length of Hiller Road. The crown on the road is at an appropriate grade. I'm not anticipating that there would be a need for that. Public Works is okay with that being eliminated. Okay, so for process sake. Yeah, I just wanted to ask a clarifying question about the motion. I know we've now got a motion. Motion made in the second, but I wanted to...
Sorry, we actually have a motion and a request to amend that motion. So those should be acted on first. Okay. So I think the first question is, Commissioner O'Neill, were you including what Mr. Bronkel was suggesting as a part of your motion also? Okay, and you were seconding and advised on that. But can I still ask a clarifying question just because I may or may not have any further amendment. I just wanted to make sure I understand the original motion. Just give me one second to clarify with Commissioner O'Neill that are you? I said I would like to make a motion that would incorporate the recommendations that John brought up into the original recommendations. And the suggestions of Mr. Bronkel, correct? Yes. Okay. He's staff, so staff. Okay. And then would you consider Mr. Curiazzi's request for an amendment to your motion? Was that part of the original permit? Yes. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay.
to pave the road there was a comment in the public works comment that if the road improvement didn't meet the existing grade that they may have to do additional grading and paving of the existing pavement section and what mr bronco just mentioned is that he does not believe that needs to be done and is fine with removing that condition that's fine and yet if you do get grant funding and that's required then you can do that and then as a secondary are you okay with the proposed amendment today that's correct okay great okay and now uh sure okay but just so i'm clear i thought there was no need for the amendment because it was mooted by mr bronco's response is that not the case uh i i guess i i would my preference would be it be struck which sounds like staff is a little bit more open to that but i think it's a good point i think it's a good point amenable to you but it's also on public record
I'm not sure if I heard staff saying it, so that's fine. It amounts to the same thing. Okay, so sure. Thank you. And I just wanted to be clear, I appreciate the work you guys put into that, but can you clarify what the, does the, there was a mention of the interim buffered bike strip. Just so I'm clear, is that connected in any way to the curb and sidewalk? And does the effect of this change in the conditions that we've requested mean that all of those improvements from bike lane to curb to gutter to sidewalk may be put off for up to five years while joint funding is sought? Correct. Okay. If you guys.
can live with that because I know we had notions that were maybe sounded good to us but are more problematic to public works about do the sidewalk now put the paving off till later that sounds like is not a practicable way to go so because I guess what I'm saying is it seemed that they were they were committed to doing the curb and gutter budgeting fund raising for it and all that and that's going to need to happen and I don't think we're questioning where it would happen only the timing of what happens next to it right that's a possibility there could be a possibility that if the MCMAC decides to narrow the lanes that things could come in a little bit so there might be a benefit to just waiting to see how that finally shape shakes out right in any case I'm fully in support of of the motion as I now understand it and thank you for for helping us you do a grand application and it's required
that you have a match sometimes it's required that you put in a 10 match and that might be a partnership that you um work together that's what the york tribe did with public works to to pay bald hills road we would put in the match and we would get the you know maybe 80 of the funding so you might be able to leverage your funding spend less but get more i'm going to uh risk complicating things by adding an additional request to amend the motion um if uh so what i'm proposing is if we're excuse me um if we're putting in this bike lane so we're paving um and uh regardless of what the road widths end up being i think that the um the the the road widths end up being um the road widths end up being um the the road widths end up being um the landscaping strip is probably going to be put off is what it sounds like to me. There's a landscaping strip there. So we would still...
effectively have a pretty significant width of asphalt including that bike lane so i would like to request that if that is done that like the the quick build style of you have the sort of white flexible bollards or something that is very low cost essentially it the reason i'm bringing this up is it addresses the safety concern it it creates a perceived narrower road whereas a driver even though it's painted a driver will see a 24 foot or a 23 foot or a 20 foot lane and and will drive accordingly so i don't know how commission feels about also making sure that road widths even when there is in the in the situation where you have a bike lane you've paved you have bike lane and then you have a paved uh existing lane i would just defer that to the public works in the county to work all that out i don't
I think we need to work out what they need to do. I think they know what they need to do. They, normally I agree. I guess maybe I, thank you Commissioner O'Neill. I think I would be comfortable at least providing that recommendation instead of amending the resolution, or the motion, thank you, requesting staff consider that, what I had just said. So instead of a motion amendment proposal, it's just a recommendation to staff. I support that recommendation as well, but don't think we need to attach it to the formal motion. Any more discussion? All right, let's go ahead and may we please have a roll call and a vote. Oh, I'm sorry, can we pause that one moment? Could I request staff repeat what our motion was?
Motion is one more time if that is that's okay. So the the motion is to Basically approve staffs recommendation Which would include a formal denial of the exception request? but with modifications to the improvement requirements to Include that in the interim a buffered bike lane be Striped by the county in the area that's widened if that only that area is widened That the lane widths will be determined ultimately by approval of the MCMAC and Board of Supervisors that there be flexibility to allow shifting of approved curbs and lines subject to approval by the MCMAC and the Board of Supervisors That the requirement for installation
The regulation of the widening be extended for five years beyond building permit issuance, but that requires a subdivision agreement with bonding for the improvements. And then within the condition, it's very unusual for the county to condition itself, but this is what's being done. The county will seek funding for the full cross-section of improvements for the length of the property, or if grants allow for just a widening needed on the south side of the road, that would satisfy this condition. For the buffered bike lane. For the buffered bike lane. Thank you. And just for clarity's sake, one more time. If you are unable to secure funding, the applicant will still.
be responsible. That is how it's currently written, yes. Thank you. Okay. May we please have a roll call vote? Commissioner Levy. Yes. Commissioner West. Yes. Commissioner Fulton. Yes. Commissioner Curiazzi. Yes. Commissioner O'Neill. Yes. Motion passes. All right. Thank you all. We're going to move on to our next item. That finishes all of our scheduled public hearing items, and we will now move to G, items pulled from consent. And if you remember at the top of our meeting, we pulled items to
Five and six from consent and we'll take them in order First up is item 2, RPL Investors, LLC, Coastal Development Permit, Conditional Use Permit, and Special Permit Extension. While staff is pulling up their presentation, does anybody have any ex parte communication for this item? Were these items pulled by people in the audience or on the phone? These items were, I believe, a commissioner pulled all three items. Yeah. I was just wondering if there was a full presentation required for every one of them or if there was just questions. In the case of number two, there was also at least one person in the audience that wished to comment on it.
And we had received some public comment for item two also. It does agree with a good process point for items five and six. Commissioner Curiosi, would you like a full staff report for each of those? No, but I do have some, they're not minor corrections. I do have some discussion. So I don't feel like I need a presentation, but maybe the commission might benefit from one. Okay. Thank you.
For anyone who may be following online, we're having some technical difficulties and staff will be presenting the item shortly. Thank you.
Thank you. No, it's not. Whenever you are ready, staff. I see it. No, it's not. Just go ahead and give the presentation like that, sir. If you want me to try to pull it up.
Thank you. That might be it. Have you guys migrated to Windows 11 yet? Because if not, look what you have in front of you. No, thank you. I think let's just go to this. I'm sorry. You can see part of my presentation there. Good evening, commissioners. I'm Michael Kine with the Humboldt County Planning and Building Department. I am going to be giving the presentation for the potential renewal of the RPL Investors LLC Coastal Development Permit, Conditional Use Permit, and Special Permit Extension. This is the sixth iteration of the extension for a project that was originally approved on October 2, 2014, under PLN 8926 CDP. This conditional use permit consisted of
Of 152 unit transit habitation facility, RV park, campground, and lodge, also known as a commercial center, and a gas station. Hey, that looks good. Thank you. The special occupancy park would include 82 RV sites, 48 camping sites, 12 model cabins, 10 cottages, 3 bathhouse, internal trails connecting to the existing Redwood Creek levee trail, an open playing field, and the commercial center that would be built as a traditional lodge style. Can you go back one slide? Thank you. Okay, this project is up in Oreck. You can see it in orange on the map there. It is along Highway 101. Here is the original site plan as approved in 2014. The zoning is...
dependent commercial recreation. Again this is a two year extension of the following of the project as I mentioned earlier it also would have an on site wastewater treatment system and water is provided by the OREC CSD. It has been approved for 12 special events with a maximum of 100 guests and also was approved for potential of 50 parking spots. During the public comment section for this project we received two public comments one of which was concerned about the tsunami evacuation route. As you can see in here the yellow is the tsunami zone. The red star is the location of the RV park. In 2007 OREC received a tsunami ready designation which provided funding for the community.
It updated its evacuation signage, gave money for community outreach and public noticing, and also a 24-hour warning point and emergency operations center. During the initial project, this map was developed as the evacuation route. The nearest established evacuation point from the site is the Oryx School Route, identified by the Redwood National and State Park Tsunami Ready Contingency Plan. It would take approximately 13 minutes from the park, from the preserved park, to the spot on the map that is shown with the orange circle. The conditions for this project also required that the resort place signs with the Oryx School Route. The Oryx School Route is in the resort itself for evacuations.
informational brochures given to every person who was staying at the park in case there was any issues and it gave them vast information regarding earthquake hazards and tsunami preparedness and then all staff would be trained in tsunami evacuation as well another comment was concerned about wildlife habitat motor vehicle used increased pavement and runoff flooding concerns from Redwood Creek increased lighting and noise both commenters wished me to let to mention that they had communicated these concerns over every previous extension and also during the original project back in 2014 based on our findings staff recommends that you make sure that you have a safe and safe environment and that you are not making all required findings
We prove to approve the extension appeal and one nine four eight five and adopt the resolution approving the extension for the CDP CEP and special project subject to the recommended conditions of approval. You have any questions please let me know. Thank you. Commissioners do you have any questions for staff at this time. I do. I I seen this project. I approve of it but I'm a little concerned over 14 years worth of extensions. Is somebody ready to move forward at this point or are we going to kick this can down the road another two years. That would be a question for the applicant. They to be honest they never gave me any information when I contacted them. There was absolutely no communications other than the initial application request. They created this us account or we tried it and I'll tell you quickly it's going to happen with the próximo coating of cốp keys. But I feel like everything's going to work so that makes the students установ their full passe who'll believe in everything that was said to be important because no one else really has the reinEvery more important is. The students. Yourcej right now what it's going to do is make this can down the road to an Milan firm for some grants. I say all right then the person who signs this can stay on the firm. What if. We have.
I actually vaguely remember when this first came to us in 2014, but I just want to be clear. There's been something in the news recently about a tribal-led development in Oreck that would put in a gas station and market, and that is a totally separate project from this. Is that correct? That is correct. Okay. Just wanted to, because on its face it sounded a little bit like it, but I see no reference to the tribe. So, all right. Thanks. Commissioner Curiazzi? In responding to public comment as well that it had brought up on the recently passed lighting ordinance and dark sky, I wanted to clarify if they would be required to comply with that, I'm assuming. Correct. Because that's in. Yes. Thank you. With respect.
The tsunami zone. I did not see the specific tsunami zone on the map. And generally my understanding is that in the past 10 years or so, a lot of the tsunami zones in Humboldt County have been reevaluated. Is that something that staff looked at again as a part of this application? The map I used was the most current one from 2024. Okay, thank you. Any other questions before we move to public comment? Okay. At this time, we will move to public comment. Typically, we invite the applicant to speak first and give them a little bit more time. Do we have an applicant either in the room or online? Wonderful. If you could please approach the podium. So just if folks aren't familiar with our process, we will give the applicant an opportunity to speak for up to 10 minutes. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. And then we will, once they are done speaking, open up public comment to everybody else.
Anybody like to speak three minutes? If you would like to speak and you are online or on the phone, please raise your hand and you can raise your hand on the phone by hitting star nine. So with that, I will turn it over to our applicant. All right. Hello, my name is Bogart Levesque. I'm general manager for Elk Meadow Cabins. We are owned by RPL Investors. Let's see. So first thing, why is this thing been taking so long? There's been change of ownership right around COVID. The original plans that were drawn up by LACO were very developed. There's 150 spots. Through this whole time, we've talked to different engineering companies. We're working with Witt Church moving forward here soon. And the plan is. To pare it back quite a bit. It's not going to be anything that extensive. This first steps we've been talking with.
Outrans, just getting the encroachment permit, getting an entryway onto the property, doing a parking lot is kind of phase one. And then from there, seeing where we're at. So it's definitely, we're not going to be, and what we've heard before is you can pare it back a bit as long as you're not like expanding beyond the plans. It's kind of what we've been told. So that's kind of where we're at. We're trying to finally be breaking ground this year, at least in the parking lot, getting the encroachment permit. And taking care of sort of early phase one. So just to keep people not in the dark about all this, we're just trying to get started with this. And it's taken 14 years, but we're finally about there. So that's about all I have to say. Thank you. Is there anybody else in the room who would like to address the commission regarding this item? Is there any questions or anything? Or is that not part of this? We will take the rest of our public comment.
A comment and then if we have questions at the end, we'll call you back. All right. Thank you. I wanted to say two things that came up that I want to just briefly address. The tsunami is an escape plan. I worked at the Oryk School when we took the kids out on that route. And if you have any questions about it, I can give you a lot of details. It's not a 13-minute for a lot of reasons that have to do with the area, which I know very well. And the other one is that the EIR was originally – I was on the board in Oryk when they did the EIR for the wastewater plant, and that was the EIR that they used for – they just took it for this project. It's a pretty old one, is my point. I wrote something kind of corny, and I'm going to say it reflects me and my shortcomings.
but also my life and my deep, deep, deeply held beliefs. And it's hard to express this in a forum about development, but I will do it nonetheless. So please excuse the corny writing. But I started out because it's the sixth time this has gone around, and it's a different era now. We're living in different times when it originally was started. I've been against it from the get-go. We love the shiny news so much we hardly notice the reality it floats on. Hopes and dreams are vitalized, but do we even pay attention to what precedes it? Currently, Oreck is a carcass of failed motels, trailer parks, and outdated tourist attractions. Redwood National Park is an attempt to preserve and honor what is left of an ancient Redwood forest and its surroundings. It's a gem of the natural world.
world. Anything surrounding the park that is not of its own creation is a distraction from the innate beauty and awe of the natural wonder. We need to think carefully about those additions. The zoning for the town of Oreck reflects an old mindset of lumber, industry, extraction, jobs, and the infrastructure to support those endeavors. When initially creating the zoning, little attention was paid to the natural environment, and the subsequent review didn't change much. It is now understood that we are the cause, okay, this is me, but this is well known, we are the cause of mass extinctions, human beings, of species and subsequent unraveling of the web of life. What is the point of natural preserves? It is to preserve and showcase what is left. Oreck no longer is a lumber town, accelerating the extinction of natural. resources.
OERC now represents more or less an attempt to preserve what is left. The motive for this proposed development are all wrong for extending the well-being of the park and its preserves. Too much development, too much asphalt, too much noise, wow, too much light, and too much concentration of people. I'm sorry, I have to cut you off at three minutes. I will acknowledge that it sounds like you're reading your public comment that you sent in, which we do have. We received it before the meeting. Yeah, my point of being here is to make sure that everybody reads it carefully and doesn't just brush over it, because I'm obviously really concerned with the environment, and it's really easy to just kind of shut down. I'm sorry, I do have to cut off your whole comment at three minutes. I'm very opposed to this, and I have been, and I'm not the only one. Thank you. Thank you. Okay, I'm not seeing. Anyone else in the audience? But I do see a hand raised online. Grant, you can go ahead.
and speak your public comment. You have three minutes. Okay. Well, I'd like to speak my support of the project. I've been living in the Oreck area for 30 years, and I currently am involved in guiding people in and around the National Park, and we definitely do not have enough places for visitors to come and stay within the community next to the park. The majority of the people either stay in Crescent City, potentially in Trinidad, Eureka, and McKinleyville and Arcata, and they're driving a long way to come visit the park. We're losing lots of money from that community. One of the prospects of having the park was that it would support the community, and that's been hit or miss, but this company's been trying for quite some time, so I completely support this project, and I would encourage them to keep it at the level that they applied for because I believe there is going to be demand, and it's... It's a great location.
To have people staged because of its previous uses and access to 101 and water and to other businesses directly in the area. And do you have any other, you have about a minute 40 left, so if you are done with your public comment. I am done with my public comment. Wonderful. Thank you. Okay, thank you. Okay, I don't see anybody else online or on the phone and I'm seeing no one else in the room. We typically, if we have questions for the applicant, invite them back to the podium to ask them, do we have any questions for the applicant? Or does the applicant have any comments they'd like to make based on the public comments that were heard? If you do, please come to the podium. I don't really have anything. Okay. Thank you. Okay, I'll bring it back to the commission. And that finishes public comment. I know a little
A little bit about tsunamis, especially in that area. That whole orc was underwater in 1700 when there was a tsunami that came from Japan. And there's historical accounts that have been documented where they found shells clear up on the mountain and stories that were passed down about people, tribal people up there, you know, performing ceremonies to bring things back to the way they were. I would, you know, you wouldn't make it if you had 13 minutes to get up that hill. You'd have to book it. And I would like to see the pared-down plan. That's what I would like to approve. I think that this is way too much for that area, which is a very beautiful area. And I'd love to see orcs. Some day look a lot different than it does right now. But this is...
It's very ambitious and he says they want to pare it back, but if we permit it as it is, then there's no guarantee that it would be pared back. So I agree with the speaker that it's really not appropriate. Commissioner Cariazzi. Commissioner O'Neill, can I clarify, are you concerned that the evacuation location can't accommodate the number of people that could potentially be at this location? Yes, and that, taking that job, I mean, if it was me, I'd run straight across and up the hill, you know, I mean, I'd go straight through. I wouldn't care what the designated paths was if it took me 13 minutes and if I could run in five minutes, I'd be going the other direction. But a lot of people that are going to stay there are not, you know. They're not going to be aware that you don't, you know, if there's a tsunami off the coast, you only have a few minutes before the water comes in. And if it can, you know.
inundates all of Oreck, the whole town is going to be underwater, not just a little area by the creek. And then you have, you know, the creek there, river, whatever they call it, that water backs up because it can't, you know, can't go out into the ocean. And so then you get flooding from that also. So it's even worse. And so if people are there, then you've got hundreds of people camping in that site. They're not going to make it any more than they're going to make it if they're out on Samoa, you know, the same difference. Do staff have an image of the tsunami zone? Am I remembering correctly saying that? And Commissioner Kiryasi, why? Thank you. Thanks. Yeah, I guess I agree we should be concerned about evacuation, but I'm also wondering, I mean, to the, when referring to the seven, to the seven, the 1700 tsunami, I guess that sounds too much.
like we should not be considering any more development in Oreck? Is that kind of where? Yeah, that's what I would say. Anything that's going to concentrate that many people. I mean, I'd like to see Oreck, you know, clean up and be a more beautiful place in the Redwood National Park area, but this is just too many people in one place in a vulnerable area, I think. I appreciate that. I think maybe I'm not, I don't know if I'm quite comfortable fully agreeing with that. That feels like a very big decision, I guess, but I really appreciate your insight. Would it be possible to get the tsunami map onto the big screen so that? Thank you. So I think...
Do we have other comments from the commissioners? I think we have to rely on the best possible data that we have, and this is the best possible data that we have. So I don't know that I would go so far as to consider no development in OREC, and whether or not one develops in the tsunami zone is a very existential question. So I appreciate the chance to be able to look at this in relation to – it's hard to tell from this map. Is the entire property within the tsunami zone? Pretty much, yes. But right on the edge of it. Right on the edge, so just to the east of the property line would be the end of the zone. And so I don't understand, then, how the – how the tsunami evacuation route takes –
13 minutes. Walking, it takes 13 minutes. I double-checked it utilizing Google Maps, and there was an initial study in 2012 saying it took 13 minutes, and that's walking. But you would be out of the tsunami zone before reaching that destination. It's 13 minutes to the evacuation site. Right. That doesn't seem to mean necessarily, in as much as you can predict a tsunami, that you would be walking all that way. That was the standard they were using in the original application. Okay. Original approval. You're hitting at the right point there, which is that the evacuation site is where they want people to end up, but they're going to be out of the mapped tsunami zone much earlier than they would be by walking to that site. Okay, thanks. I see you waving your hand in the audience. Unfortunately, our public comment period is closed, so we can't take... Any further public comment from the audience?
We have to rely on what staff reports. I'm sorry, we can't have any back and forth. I understand your frustration, but we can't have a back and forth with the audience at this time. Does the commission have any other questions and comments? Well, yes. I mean, I take the commenter's point. About the majesty of that park. But this would be quite a different issue for me if we were talking about carving up some bit of relatively pristine nature to put this project in. That said, as the same commenter noted, Oreck is to a certain extent a carcass of dead or dying motels and RVs. And the like.
The only way that that status will ever change, in my opinion, is from wise and appropriately scaled development to take place there. So I do think the originally approved project was bloated and oversized for what the real demands and sort of potential probably is. Here's where I just wanted to turn to staff responding to what the applicant's agent said that, you know, they acknowledge that the new ownership has determined that this is a bigger, that the permitted project is bigger than what they want to pursue, they say. But that it's easier to simply extend this permit and do less of it than to draw up a whole new project at this time. At a different scale. And I guess I just wanted to get the staff's take on that particular comment from the applicant.
I think, you know, that makes some sense. But on the other hand, I think the commission does have the ability to apply a conditioning. And that condition could be as simple as approving the extension with a certain percentage reduction. And that would reduce the size of the project, allow the extension. And seemingly be consistent with the applicant's intent. Okay. And then a follow-up question, which actually relates in part to a difference. Okay. Actually, I found where it was. In the Ford tentative map extension request, there was some interesting language. On page four of that stuff.
report, which I don't recall seeing all the time, and it caught my eye. And I just want to read that language because I'm curious about the relevance to this project that we're now considering. Under the alternatives to staff recommendations for Ford, not for this project, there's language that says, as clarified in El Patio versus Permanent Rent Control Board, no findings under Section 66474, findings for approval and denial of maps, may be reconsidered or revised during the extension process. Conditions may only relate to timing, procedural compliance, or enforcement of previously approved conditions. Now, that is maybe a more specific point about approving a subdivision map, but I just wanted to understand if we have the ability to make new findings that would justify imposing different... Different conditions. Different conditions.
more limited conditions on this project than was permitted earlier. Yeah, there's two sets of regulations that really apply in planning related permits. One is the Subdivision Map Act, which the parcel map, and Ford parcel map, no relation by the way, would fall under, and that's why we quoted that. And then there's development permits that do not fall under the same regulations as Subdivision Map Act. So the extension of a development permit, you do have the flexibility to make findings, to recondition a project or add a condition to a project to conform it better to current circumstances. Thank you. That's very clear. Commissioner Curiazzi?
I guess if we're going to entertain applying a condition to scale back, I guess I'm a little bit confused how we would be justifying that. Yeah, so I'm interested to hear the arguments, but I'm not leaning towards that at the moment. I think we've, I remember seeing this come to, come to here two years ago. It seemed to comply with everything that is required. I do appreciate the discussion regarding tsunami evacuation. I think I'm leaning towards where the discussion went, where I'm not particularly concerned. And I had one more thought and I forgot it. I think we can bring the applicant back up for a question.
Would you come up? I have a question for you. In regards to your comment earlier about reduction in size, would you be acceptable to reduce or eliminate certain portions of the campground? I'm having a hard time with a gas station in a tsunami zone. Totally. A few of those inclusions are completely, were just a part of the original plan. There's no plan for the gas station. There actually used to be an old gas station right next door. We actually purchased an easement from them so that we can enter onto that corner of the property because it made more sense when we talked to Caltrans, rather than creating a whole new entrance off of the 101, to use an existing one from the gas station there. So you had no plan for a gas station, no plan for a waste treatment plan or anything. That was part of the original plan.
plan that I think OREC came to us about. So those are not inclusions. If there's other ones that you guys were wondering about, happy to. So in your reduction of size, what percentile are you thinking? 20%, 25, 50, 30? Yeah, I would say 50 to 75% of the total. I mean, we're still working all that out. It might be more of a campsite rather than an RV site to begin with. So I would say somewhere between one-third to two-thirds of the original size is probably safe to say, is what we're going for. Thank you. While we have you up there, have you or the owners or other parties in this project been in touch with the staff? Currently, I may have misunderstood what Mr. Kine said, but it sounded like he said that apart from the...
Request for an extension. There was no new information provided by the applicant. Yeah, I'm sorry if I missed that. I don't know what happened there. When I reapplied, I think I talked with someone about all this. And I had just started this job when we were taking over as the office manager right when we were getting this permit renewed two years ago. And it was scary because I had just started and everything, but it just went through no problem. So I was assuming when all this was happening and from talking with different engineering firms, we talked with Brown Designs, an architect who was originally attached to the project. And everybody we had been told had told us that you want to just renew this permit until you break ground. So there's aspects of this that we're just trying to... continue this process being...
You know consensual with all of the what is required permanent wise And then from there work on the project and make sure we're staying in balance of what's required of everybody. So Thank you. It's valuable that you're here tonight. Thank you for being here tonight. Thank you Is it possible to get an extension on them coming up with a new plan? So then we give them an extension on the project. Yeah, you can continue it tonight. They've submitted their application for an extension. So They've held their place essentially So how long would it take before you would have a firm that plan on what percentage and what you want in or out of? Your project even more firm that on paper. Yeah. Yeah totally and so the property owners They're very much one foot in front of you to the other on this We've talked extensively about what what is this gonna look like? What if we do this long would it be? That's a great question I would say
I think hopefully we would have something this year, a firm design of what we're looking for. So six months? Sure. I think we could do that. So if I'm hearing you right, you'd like to continue this off count to a date uncertain with public provision that if it's not done within a certain amount of time, that it'll come back before you. Come with a new plan. I mean, and I will just say, I also pretty much agree with what Commissioner Curiazzi said personally. I'm content to know that the plan is changing. It is downsizing. It has not reached its final form. We have extended this, essentially confirming our original approval of this five times already or however many times. I'm willing to do.
The same this time, having heard what we've heard and having told the applicant what we've said, that, you know, next time you come before us, we really want to see new plans developed. So I could go either way is what I'm saying. It's somewhat unusual to postpone it out indefinitely, but I guess we could do that. I will say, personally, I'm very amenable to the visitor accommodations as they are. I think that it's, on its whole, while there is quite a few sites, in my view, it's often what people ask for in reductions to bigger projects. Like, it's not a hotel. It's not multi-story. It leaves a lot of open space. Visually, it's less impactful when you're driving by. So I wasn't personally, before this conversation, inclined to scale back the project at all. So I just wanted to throw that out. I don't know if it's out there.
My personal opinion, I do hear the tsunami zone gas station concern. And I have a couple more questions for staff on the tsunami zone when we wrap up this piece of the discussion. Is it possible to comment on the tsunami stuff? Sure, and then I think we'll have you sit down so we don't have to reach back and forth. Absolutely, that would be very quick. The levee trail runs right along the northern part of the property there, and the plan is to have at least a way onto the levee trail, and then from there it's a straight shot to the school. So it should be, I mean, depending on how fast you walk, you can get to the school in under 10 minutes, I would say. Thank you. Okay, thank you. I would just say that I have an agreeance with Commissioner O'Neill in regards to a continuance for six months or so for them to come up with a plan that they can present to us so that we have an idea of what we're voting on, what the conditional use, what the permit would entail.
as opposed to this grandioso scale back and then maybe we maybe we get what we ask for maybe we don't for clarity's sake what exactly are you do you envision us asking for me yeah i would just like to see a basic floor plan kind of what he has there minus what what they're taking out and whether they're using the entire footprint but not maybe having everything so close together whatever whatever design they come up i just would like to see their design so i i am more comfortable granting a conditional use permit on what is in front of me as opposed to his word on what they're going to subtract because he doesn't know what the owner's going to decide currently anyway i mean is that is that fair to ask um yeah it is absolutely absolutely fair for the commission to uh ask for more information you
are making a finding that it's not detrimental to the public health, safety, and welfare. And so whatever information you need to feel comfortable in making that finding, you should be asking for that. Commissioner Kyrgiosi? I guess I definitely appreciate where you're coming from. I guess the way I've seen it is we're approving something if they do something smaller, it generally can have a smaller impact. So it provides something for them to have flexibility and grow into. However, I do very much appreciate the gas station comment, and I do agree with removing that. At the end of the day, particularly if the applicant is agreeable to what you've proposed, I'm okay with that as well. I have a question for staff. Thank you.
Generally, have we really looked at conditioning many projects when we permit building and development in the tsunami zone? I didn't see any, unless I missed it in our conditions of approval in this, I didn't see anything addressing the tsunami zone. There isn't a whole lot. If I could share my screen real quick, we actually have a little bit more detail. And so actually half of the property is outside the tsunami zone as mapped. I think, I mean, as we've seen in the county in the last couple of years, this is a real threat and we're learning. And I would be, I think, interested in thinking about asking applicants to maybe do some signage, just particularly visitor. Visitor accommodation developments where you have folks coming in from out of the area who maybe don't understand our hazards like our residents.
...do. Acknowledging where the tsunami line currently is with some signage would perhaps be really helpful when we consider visitor accommodations. In this original project, that was a condition and recommended. Okay. Yes. So I guess I prepared an issue of a motion to accept staff's proposal as as written but if that is if that does does not win votes then I am interested to hear a second or a different proposal so I'm putting forward a motion it for what is what is offered sorry clarifying by staff but removing the allowance for a gas station if that can be so easily that's simply done
I would second that motion. Any discussion on that motion? It wouldn't get my vote, but it's okay. I'd be content with that motion and that one change in what is in the conditions permitted or what the scope of the development would permit. So if there's no more discussion, I'm going to call for a vote on this and see if it passes. Laura, may I please have a roll call vote? Do you have a motion to second? Yeah, I believe Commissioner Chiriazzi made a motion, and then I seconded the motion. You seconded it? Yeah. And then I guess just for clarity's sake, Commissioner Chiriazzi is proposing motions to approve the project as is with the additional condition of removing the gas station from the development proposal. Approved to your extension of the... Permit that was already approved. Correct.
Okay. Roll call, please. Commissioner Fulton? No. Commissioner Curiazzi? Yes. Commissioner O'Neill? No. Commissioner West? Yes. Commissioner Levy? Yes. Motion passes 3-2. Okay. Well, thank you all for a robust discussion on that one. Yeah. So, John, I have a question. This is something that's been bothering me for a while when we talk about tsunamis, and I was wondering if in the future if there was ever an opportunity on our agenda that we could have a presentation. There is a Redwood tsunami work group, and they're active in that area. We have, you know, a geology professor at HSU, if she's still there, that's world-renowned. But I don't agree with those maps. There's two different types of tsunamis. There's one that comes from, you know, like Japan.
And then there's one that comes right off the shore. If one comes right off the shore, you have a few minutes, and it would not stop at the boundaries of that map. So I think it would behoove all of us to be better educated. I made myself educated and worked on it because I had to, and I met with people from Japan after they had their last big offshore tsunami, and everything that they planned for, and they planned very, very well for tsunamis, went out the door. None of it applied. So I think this group should be more educated because we do approve these permits, and when you say, oh, all you've got to do is have a trail, well, good luck. Good luck. You have to go up really high to get away from a tsunami zone. You have to be at least two miles inland, and you have to be 100 feet up in the sky. You have to be at least two miles inland to get to the hill.
And that takes a while. And even areas that are designated as tsunami-free zones would not be tsunami-free zones if one of these big Cascadias, which is what happened in 1700. There was a Cascadia one that happened off the shore here. And those go 500 miles an hour, and they're like 50 miles, 75 miles offshore. So that's how many minutes you have to get. And you've got to get oriented. And you've just gotten knocked over by a big earthquake, and you've got to have the wherewithal to get up and run immediately. A lot of people just, you know, they're disoriented. So I think we all need to be better educated for our own safety even. A lot of people think, well, I'm going to be at home. You know, you might be driving through Oreck when it happens, and you need to know what to do. But that would be if we ever had a time to do something like that, and the work group would be willing to make a presentation. Running into a little bit of a danger here because this.
isn't agendized and so we can absolutely look to bring a presentation back okay thank you okay well with that we will take up our next item really quick i appreciate that commissioner o'neill and i would support that i would appreciate that as well thank you okay all right um now we will take up um item number five from our consent calendar go back and read this one item number five monument core ecup smp mining re-approval and while staff is pulling up that presentation um do we have any ex parte okay foreign
March 19, 2009. March 19, 2009. To clarify, I'm certainly happy without a presentation, if that is okay with the commission. Ah, that's, I had to say I didn't want it for it to work. And I was leaning towards a presentation because I thought one of our audience members was interested in this item, and she was interested in a different item. So if.
If you're okay with no presentation and if staff would like to skip the presentation, you're welcome to. Yeah. So if that's a, I can bring up my comments on this. Thank you. A quick, just a quick minor one out of the way that the date on the resolution is incorrect for today's meeting. But I bring this up wondering if it would be okay or appropriate to add a condition of approval to this. I'm looking to staff to require that the off-road fleets are in compliance with the California Air Resources Board regulations, specifically the off-road and heavy-duty regulations. There are already state regulations. I would like to see them. I'm explicitly mentioned in the condition of approval. Similar to how the asbestos and air toxic control.
Regulation is mentioned as a requirement in the conditions of approval. I think you can do that. One of the things we struggle with is that in Humboldt County many of the fleets are just really not current and while we want to see them brought up to date if you put a condition like that on some of the operators you would shut them down. So there's a balance there. Certainly we we want to see the the fleets brought up to current standards but the manner and how it's done maybe rather than saying all at one time maybe giving them some time to do that. I just declare just simply
simply that they're in compliance. So, for example, the Air Resources Board grants time extensions. Humboldt County has already granted a low-population county, so it extends that timeline. It just simply is saying in compliance with CARBIC regulations. Okay. I think they need to do that anyway, but, yeah. I agree they do. It feels repetitive, but I think it's also important, and I think there's precedent for restating requirements to comply with state regulation. Commissioner Levy. Thank you. I have a simple question, I think, but this quarry, the Monument Quarry, is owned by Humboldt Redwood Company. Are they also using this quarry? I mean, and if so, it would be nice to know what, what additional use this will add on top of the .
Existing use of the landowner. They do not use this quarry. This quarry was leased out to a different company last year. They never used it either. The county got it back. Got it. Hence the re-approval, I should say. But no, I don't think they've actually done any quarry work here for several years. They only do it maybe two or three times out of the 15-year period. Okay. But the Redwood Company does not use this property for any reason that I'm aware of. Okay. So in other words, and I appreciate that clear answer, in other words, the amount, the total of 35,000 cubic yards over a 15-year period, is the total amount that would be permitted for extraction from this site? Correct. Okay. Thank you. That reminded me, I did have a question. Same question, but clarifying it. In a slightly different way, is this on top of...
What was 35,000 cubic yards already extracted in the previous permits and is this on top of it? No, this is the original 35,000. They have not reached that. So there's still, there's just a continuation of that amount. if staff or if the Commission is amiable to my request for that additional condition of approval I'd like to move to accept or to approve this with that added condition yeah it's a requirement that fleet fleet vehicles that are doing the actual work all equipment that they're in compliance with the California Air Resources Board regulations So I believe we have a motion on the floor. I'll second that. Any discussion?
Laura, may we please have a roll call vote? Commissioner Fulton? Yes. Commissioner West? Yes. Commissioner O'Neill? Yes. Commissioner Levy? Yes. And Commissioner Curiazzi? Yes. Motion passes. Thank you. Okay, and that brings us to item six. I think we can forego the staff report on this one also, and Commissioner Curiazzi or other commissioners have questions? So I had pulled this for the same Air Resources Board requirement request. Okay. And that's it. And I'll just ask the same request about use of the quarry, Russ Quarry by the landowner or others.
Same answer. Same answer. The property owner does not utilize any of the rock from that quarry. Thank you. Did you open public comment? Oh, shoot. Thank you for the reminder. I did not open public comment for the other one. However, we don't have anybody in the audience or online. How do we remedy this situation? Yeah, just unfortunately get to go through the motion and see if there's just ask the question. Okay. Is there anybody who would like to comment on this item? Are we talking about the rust quarry or the monument quarry? Okay. Okay. We'll open the floor for both. For either the item number five, the monument quarry CUP SMP mining re-approval, or the rust quarry CUP SMP mining re-approval. The floor is open for public comment. I'm not seeing. Anybody in the room.
And I'm not seeing anybody online, so we will go ahead and bring it back to the commission. Thank you for catching that. And we have a motion and we have a second. Do we? No. Did you make a motion? No. I was just about to. Okay. I'll move to accept the Russ Quarry project as proposed by staff with the added condition of approval that the fleets doing the work are in compliance with the California Air Resources Board regulations. I'll second it. And Commissioner O'Neill seconded. And now may we please have a roll call vote. Commissioner Levy. Yes. Commissioner O'Neill. Yes. Commissioner West. Yes. Commissioner Curiazzi. Yes. Commissioner Fulton. Yes. Motion passes. Okay. That concludes. Our items pulled.
From consent and brings us to H, report from planner. We don't have anything startling to bring to you tonight. So given the hour, I'll just stop right there. Okay. Item I, planning commission discussion items. I'll just announce that I will be out of the area on a work conference for the, I believe it's the April meeting. Yeah. The second April meeting, is that right? Yes. There's only one. Oh, thank you. There's only one. Well, that's what I was actually going to note as well. So there is no April 2nd meeting, I take it. Right, it's the 16th. It's just the 16th. Unfortunately, I will also be out of the area on April 16th and will most likely miss that. Okay. No problem. All right, as expected, I will not be able to visit you now on April 24th. I probably could have come by that if it was my past. So with that, as I messed up my s account pretty bad, I will see you guys at the Q&A, or I don't believe that I have done and will send you guys aou in case you decide if this is a good or a bad idea. Thank you.
Thank you. I can confirm I will be here. We've got a chair. Okay. I think the only other thing I would add in the Planning Commission discussion items is I didn't jump in earlier, but I agree that tsunami preparedness is incredibly important and would love to hear a discussion about it. And it's also tsunami preparedness week next week for anybody who wants to think about that more and participate. There's a lot of resources and a lot of community activities online. Anything else? Okay. With that, we will go ahead and adjourn this meeting. Our next meeting is April 16th, 2026. Thank you.