Humboldt County Board of Supervisors
Tuesday, December 17, 2024
The agenda


9:01 a.m.

Thank you. Thank you. Everybody got their Christmas shopping done? Oh, hell no. We will move on. Start this thing. Roll call, please. Supervisor Wilson. Present. Supervisor Arroyo. Here. Supervisor Madrone. Here. Supervisor Bushnell. Good morning. Chair Bone. Ho, ho, ho. All right. Salute.


9:02 a.m.

To the flag, please. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Looks like you're duck hunting over there. You got a lot of camouflage working. No, it's fine. I don't need to see her. Good morning, Chair Bone. We have a couple modifications to the agenda today. Items D2, D4, and D22 are being pulled for discussion and also for the situational awareness of your board and the audience. Item J3 will be heard immediately following our return from closed session slash lunch.


9:03 a.m.

One more time. D2, D4, and D22. I didn't get any of those right. All right. Go on to the consent calendar now. Is there any public comment on the consent calendar? All right. There's none on Zoom. There's none? We have one at the counter. Is this on? Okay. It is. My concern is with item number 21, dealing with roads. And for one thing, this is titled in a very misleading way. It says roads in the Oreck and Arcata areas. And I looked through this list. I found numerous roads that weren't anywhere near Oreck and Arcata. Some of them were near Trinidad.


9:04 a.m.

As I read through this list, a map would have been very helpful, because some of these roads are really long. If they say it's 3.25 miles into the road, without a map that doesn't mean very much. I thought it was particularly strange that Scenic Drive was on there, Patrick's Point Drive was on there. And I was wondering why these parking restrictions were put in place. I mean, are the roads really that bad that they're undercut, and if somebody parks on the side there, they're in danger of going over the edge? Or were there other more subtle reasons? Like some of these, on Patrick's Point Park, a lot of people park on the road and walk into Sumeg Park, because it's an $8 fee to get in. And if you're with a family, you know, you've got some kids, it turns into a bunch of money. It's much cheaper to park on the road and walk in. I'm wondering if this... These changes are going to interfere with that.


9:05 a.m.

I was wondering about scenic. You know, a lot of people, as the name implies, go on scenic to look at the scenery. And as they're driving through, it seems like it would be a lot safer if they could just pull over to the side of the road, which people do anyway, and look at the scenery than trying to look at it while you're driving. I hate being behind someone who's trying to do that, you know? And the other thing I was wondering is, were these restrictions put in place to discourage people who live in their vehicles from parking? If so, that sets a rather unpleasant light on our county's treatment of the homeless population, or I should say houseless population, I guess. You can't forbid people to park overnight unless you have someplace else where they can go. Let's not forget that due to the unforeseeable circumstances of life, anybody might find themselves having to live in their vehicle someday. Thank you. Thank you. And seeing no one else, I'll bring it back to the board.


9:06 a.m.

I'll make a motion for the approval of the consent calendar minus number two number four and number 22 second and I will note that any of these parking restrictions in the coastal zone are appealable to the Coastal Commission All right, let's move to President McDonnell. Yeah, I see Director Mattson is on Zoom, and I was wondering if he could respond to the concerns about the parking that were brought up. I can't turn my camera on it seems but we are only adding two one at the specific location on Jackson Ranch Road and one up in Oark all the others are existing already that's just for the new


9:07 a.m.

Two new ones fit in the county ordinance. Great, thank you. All right. Daly, it's been moved and seconded. Supervisor Arroyo? Yes. Supervisor Madrone? Yes. Supervisor Wilson? Yes. Supervisor Bushnell? Yes. Chair Bone? Yes. Motion carries 5-0. Thank you. This will be time for items pulled from consent. 2-4-22. I think... I'm not sure who pulled them. I pulled two. Are you going to do... Number 2 or number 4? I pulled number 4. Okay. Would you like to start with number 2? In order, yeah, please. That'd be great. Great. So we have a certificate of recognition here for...


9:08 a.m.

Mary Ann Hansen, who has been appointed to the Early Childhood Policy Council. It's a gubernatorial appointment. Is it? Senate appointment. Senate appointment. Thank you. A state appointment. So this is very exciting for us. And I know there was some info about it in the local news, which was great. And it would be great to hear anything you'd like to share with us about that role and what you do for our community. Thank you. And I believe there's some slides. Yeah. If we can. How do I do that? It will happen magically for you. Oh, that is amazing. So first I want to thank you, Supervisor Arroyo and Chair Bone and supervisors for taking a little bit of time out of your super busy schedule today. She's got it. Oh, there it is. Oh, my gosh. Oh, you were going for it right. This is amazing. So let's make sure I know how to do this.


9:09 a.m.

Okay, I'm going to be quick, since I know you have a packed schedule. So this committee, this council, is tasked with providing advice to the governor's office, to the legislature, and to the superintendent of schools. So I appreciate the opportunity to just sort of add our rural voice. I think that this is the third state committee I've served on. This is the one that's gotten the most attention. And what I've learned so far is that rural representation on these state advisory boards is really lacking. And so I'm looking to your board to help me stay informed about what the issues are in Humboldt County, as well as our commission and our other advisory committees, because I feel like that perspective of the rural California is just so important. And I'm going to go ahead and start. Thank you. And for me, and I think for most of us,


9:10 a.m.

Child care, child and maternal health, first fives and funding disparities for small counties are really top of mind. And so I wanted to just give you guys, whoops, there we go, just give you a quick couple of numbers about how families are doing in Humboldt and in California. And I feel like the, you know, somebody really wise told me last week, well, this is great that you get to give input. Now let's see if they'll listen, right? And I think it's just super important that we recognize that while your board has some power, there are lots of issues that we need help with from the state. And so frame that as I go through these points. Humboldt County is doing better than the rest of the state in terms of availability of child care. Five years ago, we were at 24% of families looking for child care.


9:11 a.m.

care, we're able to find license slots. We're now at, in 2021, we were at 35 percent, so that's better than the state, but that still means that about one out of three families can't find child care if they need it, and I know that members of your board have had experience with that in the past, or family members who have, and the ARPA investment that your county made helped keep us from making this an even deeper crisis in Humboldt. People wonder, well, what about state funding for subsidized care, since child care is so incredibly expensive for families? I've got a little bit more about that. There are only slots for about 11 percent of the families who qualify for subsidized child care, even though the state has invested more dollars. If you're a state that has a lot of subsidized child care, you're going to have to make a lot of money for subsidized child care, and so we're going to have to make a lot of money for subsidized child care. If you have, if


9:12 a.m.

you go to apply, you're going to be on a waiting list, a huge waiting list. So there are almost two million children waiting for some of those subsidized slots in California. Now let's get to Humboldt a little bit. If you go to the Women's Well-Being Index, you'll see a comparison of the annual cost of child care for a school age and an infant as a percentage of the median women's wage. In the county. For Humboldt, we are at the bottom. So for a woman earning a median income in Humboldt County, that's right in the middle of the highest and lowest. The cost of an infant child, of infant child care and the school age slot together would take about 74.2 percent of that median salary. This is something that we need help with in our state, right? Where is the median salary? Where is the median salary? Where is the median salary? Where is the median salary? Here's the median salary.


9:13 a.m.

Where's the money for a family to cover basic necessities like food and housing if 74% of your income is going to go towards taking care of your children while you work? One of the reasons that might be so high is that Humboldt is tied with Trinity County for having the highest percentage of women living in poverty. And so if you're wondering, oh gosh, back to that other slide, is it because our child care is just so expensive? No, it's more related to the fact that we have the highest percentage of women who are living in poverty. And that isn't something that we as a county alone can help. Things like child tax credits or child care tax credits could be incredibly meaningful for families to address some of those issues. Parents can't pay, but child care providers can't stay. Minimum wage has...


9:14 a.m.

But the state reimbursement to providers for subsidized care has risen at a significantly lower rate. So child care providers are leaving the field, and TK only exasperated that because some of the most qualified providers went where they could earn a living wage, right? We are doing some things better than other neighboring counties. When this map was done in 2022, we had 61.2% of our babies with positive maternal child health indicators, like early and timely prenatal care, normal gestational age, et cetera. And you can see that we're surrounded by Trinity and Mendo and Shasta, other counties whose numbers aren't doing as well, but it still isn't high enough. But where I do want to call out Humboldt is that despite the fantastic...


9:15 a.m.

efforts of our public health and their home visiting programs. When this map was constructed out of the 44 counties that were assessed, Humboldt County had the highest infant mortality rate. And this is where I would like the Early Childhood Policy Council to broaden its focus a little bit from child care into these other really important child and maternal health issues. Because home visiting is incredibly important in reducing infant mortality. Infant mortality is death before age one. And specifically this number, because our BIPOC population numbers are so small, you can't get exactly what that number is for Latinx families or for black families. However, we know that the number for white women and their babies is better. It's 5.61. And so that points to, given the, if you do the math, you can get a better number. And so that's why we're doing this.


9:16 a.m.

if you do the statistics, that we have some real disparity, particularly between indigenous and white infants. And then we have one other issue in our county, and I would be remiss if I did not mention it, that First Five Humboldt and other First Fives across the state are having to make deep cuts to services. We are super glad that fewer Californians are smoking and that flavored tobacco has been banned, but over the three-year period, 2022 to now, we are down about 34%, so $330,000 of the $900,000 that we used to get from tobacco tax dollars, and that's going to lead to some deep cuts in services that you're going to see soon from First Five Humboldt. So I just want to end by saying that all of these things are things that I would like, to see the Early Childhood Policy Council address, and I also want to thank the board for their support.


9:17 a.m.

to ask your board to share with me on a regular basis your thoughts. I'll speak up as much as I can, as much as I love public speaking, but I'll speak up as much as I can with the Early Childhood Policy Council, but I really need your support and your help to help me raise our voice of Humboldt and rural California. Thank you. I appreciate Supervisor Arroyo for bringing this forward, and I think it was in 2018 we had the head of First Five and some of the board up here in Ferndale for our annual RCRC meeting, and they were our featured speaker, and it was, and there was out of every county, they were all just nodding their heads going how important First Five is. I know my time on the First Five board was great. Now having three grandchildren, you and I talk a lot because I need stuff, but it's fun stuff, and I can't think of another person that's going to represent Humboldt. I think it's going to be better for Humboldt or the state of California better in this position, so I'll bring it to the board. Supervisor Arroyo.


9:18 a.m.

Thank you. Thank you. And I also want to thank Supervisor Bushnell for encouraging this to be on the agenda so we could feature it. This is really important information. I am curious, just logistically speaking, how often does the council meet and what are good points to sort of provide that input on an ongoing basis that you're looking for? And how might that be structured in a way that wouldn't challenge us with the Brown Act? We can figure out some of that on our end. Absolutely. I think that, well, I know the council meets four times a year. And I would be happy to give you a heads up ahead of those meetings and folks can email me individually with concerns. In fact, I encourage anyone who has an investment in young children to pay attention and make sure their concerns are shared. So thank you for the invite. Great. Supervisor Bushnell. All right. Thank you for the presentation.


9:19 a.m.

I just always feel so thankful for you and that Humboldt County young families really prosper more because of you and First Five and the commitment that your agency has to to all of our young people coming up so thank you and thanks for being willing to do this I know it's added to your plate and it's not the great public speaking that you love you do a really good job at it. We're gonna have you back every week I think. Anybody else? With that I'll see if there's any public comment on this item. Seeing none I'll look for a motion. I'll move that we provide the certificate of recognition and accept the report. Second. Been moved and seconded. Thank you. Supervisor.


9:20 a.m.

Is there a drone. Yes. Supervisor Bushnell. Yes. Supervisor Arroyo. Yes. Chair Bone. Yep. Supervisor Wilson. Yes. Motion carries 5 0. Thank you. Thanks, Marianne. And for the next item, we'll bring up our clerk of the board, Tracy D'Amico. I believe this item was pulled by Supervisor Bushnell. Thank you. I pulled this item just to give direction to


9:21 a.m.

Our clerk that when it returned there's going to be an item that returns in January and I would like for we have a lot of committees and some of them we don't know what they do or they don't report to the board and so I want just to on the 7th when it comes back to have a little information about which one's mandated which one isn't so we could have a robust discussion at that time. Sounds great. That's it. Do we need to vote on that? I guess we need to vote on that. Okay. Sure. I appreciate you doing that and I think it'll be a great chance to evaluate the efficacy we've urged sort of our entire county to focus on efficiency and clarity of mission and get real clear about what we need to do versus what we like to do so that we can make informed decisions about it. So I think this is tracking with what we've.


9:22 a.m.

directed everyone else who works within the county to do. So on the 7th is the typical, the first meeting of January is when I bring the board protocol to the board and also the quarterly report showing the vacancies. This Maddie list is the vacancies for the entire year that were mandated by the state to make available so that people are also aware. We go above and beyond and do it quarterly as well. So I will bring that item with a list of structure for those boards and commissions. Thank you. Of course. I'll make a motion to accept this item with the direction given by the board. I'll second. Then moved and seconded. Is there any public comment on this? Seeing none. Supervisor Madrone? Yes. Chair Bone? Yep. Supervisor Bushnell? Yes. Supervisor Arroyo?


9:23 a.m.

Oh, yes. Supervisor Wilson. Yes. Motion carries 5-0. Thank you. And now item number 22 from, I don't know, Sheriff pulled it. Yeah. I didn't pull it. Destry pulled it. Oh, gotcha. Destry pulled it. I didn't think a deputy could pull an agenda item. Oh, gotcha. Okay. I'm here to, I guess, answer any questions they had on this. Yeah, well, I believe that Destry Henderson did provide some input on that. Didn't want to see a loss of the position for our deputies. And so I thought it'd be good to have a conversation about, you know, what your perception is of why you're recommending eliminating one deputy versus creating a position in the. Right. So, yeah, I did receive.


9:24 a.m.

Investigator Henderson's email as well and I share his concerns because over the last couple years we have had deputy sheriff Positions deallocated, you know out of our budget. We've started out a couple years ago with 85 positions We're down 15 positions that are unfunded and that have been deallocated and so this has caused further concern about you know shrinking deputy sheriff positions when our really, it's it's the need for deputy sheriff's is growing and And and so, you know, we get emails every week regarding Homeless camps drug houses those kind of things and we're trying to supplement those with our existing staff with our existing duties and And still trying to limit overtime and exposure where we can But we're trying to do our best with those and so we recognize one thing that we're in a We're in a tough budget time We've been reminded of that


9:25 a.m.

last several years and with the budget numbers coming in, I guess we're $15 million in the hole, so to speak. And so this is one of the things that we thought that we could do at the Sheriff's Office to help with that. Though it's minor, it is something. Right now, our coroner's office is currently staffed with a deputy sheriff position and three deputy coroner positions and a sergeant. These are our investigators that go out and do all the death investigations. There's about 400 plus death investigations a year that they do. And just to remind everyone, as far as coroner's office and investigation, they're investigating the manner of death. How did this person die? What made this person die? And then along with a lot of times, investigators, if it's a homicide, determine the mechanism of death. They can tell that someone died of a gunshot wound and that's what the autopsy will say, but how that person died, was it a suicide? Was it homicide? Was it a homicide? Was it a suicide? Was it a homicide? That's going to be up to the investigators.


9:26 a.m.

So it's our coroner's office and the subject matter experts that are there are crucial. And whether it's a deputy sheriff or a deputy coroner, each of them need to be trained to that level of what the expectation is. So with current, when talking historical, when we first took over the coroner's office, we believed that it was going to be easier to hire deputy sheriffs to fill the deputy coroner positions than to hire deputy coroner positions and to have cross-trained deputies. And I think in an ideal world that works. But we found it is more difficult to hire and maintain a deputy sheriff at this point in time. And so deputy coroners, we believe, are easier to recruit and to provide this specialized training because they are there, again, for the long haul as well. These are experts over time. Many of you know one of our deputy coroners, Charlie Van Buskirk. He's been doing the job for 30 years. He's been doing the job for 30 years.


9:27 a.m.

He's the expert on the North Coast regarding death investigations and it's something that he's learned over time. So that's one of the things that we look at and so we decided to go this route. It's hard to give up a deputy sheriff position, but I think it's the most responsible thing to do right now. And so that's where we are. And I'm taking a shot in the dark. First chance you get, you're going to put one back on also or move someone or to put them out in the field, right? Well, I mean, we still have positions to fill, right? Understood. Yeah. So the reason why we have a vacancy is because Deputy Chad Zek retired. And so he's retired and this provided us an opportunity to backfill a deputy coroner position. Okay. Supervisor Madrone? Yeah, thank you, Sheriff Hansel, for being here. I may have... I don't know. I misheard this, but I thought I heard you say that it was harder to hire a deputy sheriff.


9:28 a.m.

They're a deputy sheriff, then a deputy coroner. So why wouldn't we keep the deputy sheriff and hire a new deputy coroner, using that logic? Well, that's what we're trying to do. So we're trying to hire a deputy coroner. That's what we're doing. And so... By eliminating the other position? Well, by deallocating that position. I mean, I would rather add a position. I'd rather add a deputy coroner position than keep a deputy sheriff position. That would be ideal in my world. But coming to you right now and saying, can I have an extra position in my budget, is not an easy thing to ask. And that wouldn't be approved by the CAO. And so, again, I'm trying to recognize that we have a budget deficit and trying to be responsible in that area. And so... Okay. Thank you. That's the reason why.


9:29 a.m.

Okay. Supervisor Rowe. Thank you. A couple of thoughts slash questions. I recall that we have had some challenges around the public administrator's office and those duties being something that we had limited capacity for in the past and have received some public critique about that. And I believe a grand jury investigation as well at some point. Not in this current cycle. And so I was wondering if you could add any thoughts on that to the mix. For sure. So when the sheriff's office took over this coroner's division, I guess it was about nine years ago, essentially, we took a standalone department and then put on the sheriff's office. It was. Many things that we discovered when we took that over.


9:30 a.m.

About policies and procedures that need to be updated and provided to. There was a Department of Justice investigation into the public administrator side and how things were not done correctly. We've exposed that. We have now hired a public administrator that is working with our deputy coroners and is doing a fantastic job working with county council to clear up those estates. There are many estates that the county can do through the public administrator's office, and we are currently doing those. The deputy coroners will work hand in hand with our public administrator to help clear out these estates and do the job of that public administrator. So that policy procedure and process is in place, though our employee, Jair, is brand new essentially. He's been doing it for a year. It's going to take a while for his expertise to get there and for us to become efficient because there's been several years where we haven't done that. So he's making up for lost ground. We are clearing estates. And the policies have been made.


9:31 a.m.

Yeah, thank you. And through the chair, I just have one more question around this. So you said you had unfilled positions for deputy sheriffs, is that correct? We still do, yes. We are actively still recruiting, and we just got four out of the police academies right now. We're sending two more in January, so we're very excited about that. But it is getting better. We have a lot of applicants, a lot of qualified applicants. And so we do have a bright future, so to speak, I think, when it comes to deputy sheriff ranks. Okay, but I appreciate the bright look at it, but it sounds like you still do have the capacity to hire additional deputies. We do, yes. Okay, well, I appreciate you coming and talking with us today. And also I appreciate it being brought up for discussion so we have a chance to have this conversation. Yes, for sure. Thank you. I want to thank Sheriff Downey and Sheriff...


9:32 a.m.

for the trade-off when we had the problems at the coroner's office nine years i think i was the only one here and and just you know the big white corvette always pops out just so everybody knows the deputy that bought the white corvette brought it back and it was ended up going to john's used car and wreckers because nobody would buy it because there was no value in it so but we didn't hear much about that afterwards but there was no criminal charges or you know there was house cleaning housekeeping issues so we appreciate everything you did on that open it up to public comment now oh excuse me um thank you for um coming and talking about this item and i i can imagine well you're doing exactly what our board asked by deallocating one position and moving that to where you need you you need to fulfill that and so i appreciate that i do understand um you know why the item was pulled and we don't want to lose it um given the fact that you have room to


9:33 a.m.

hire more deputies that that'll be good and it was at the academy graduation the other day for a different reason but saw your new incoming people and so congratulations on that thank you and i just really do appreciate that you've heard this board and that you are reacting appropriately even though it's not comfortable losing deputies and that's not what we want to do that's right thank you i appreciate that thank you yeah public comment this is on the sheriff's item this is on the sheriff's item please hi hi you guys know me i'm alexander profant um after hearing that presentation i felt compelled to speak uh i we missed the public comment i would also like an opportunity to speak in regards to the public comment a little later but my suggestion after hearing what um the sheriff's office just presented to you is for you to find in your budget a public comment that you would like to hear from the sheriff's office no one wanted to hear any public opinion you can contact our required public comment director and happens to be listening this evening um and this is uh i'm thinking of uh this is a question that this censorship operator should be going to so that in this caseĆ­d like to know more about what's going on when the sheriff defeat the sheriff of achi


9:34 a.m.

budget, whatever the sheriff's office requires. I have no problem asking you to find the money for him and for the sheriff's office. We need law enforcement now more than ever. And I would suggest the sheriff's oversight committee suggested by the grand jury was conflicted. And I think that that needs to be investigated. I'm not quite sure who would investigate that. However, I would say that the sheriff's office is doing a bang up job. And I think right now we need more than ever to empower law enforcement to do investigations in this county. Thank you. Thank you. And with anybody else? Chair Brown, I have one on Zoom. Okay. Caller 7718, I'm going to unmute you. You have three minutes. It's Tawatsky calling from Bahia de Quinoa, Mexico. Ditto to what the prior speaker said.


9:35 a.m.

percent uh the public is uh is very adamant everybody i talk to just about everybody except the people violating the law that we continue to fund the sheriff's department to our fullest ability uh the coroner's office i hear nothing but compliments on people who are dealing with um with a deceased family member on how compassionate and how well they are treated by the coroner's office and i think that that is something extremely important they don't just deal with the dead that they deal with having to deal with the living and their time of grief a strong support to moving forward with this recommendation uh we recently had a death out at the blue lake power plant facility out there where a homeless person died and uh you know i appreciate the sheriff letting us know what the circumstances were of that death sooner we know when we hear a rumor uh you know of what caused the death um and uh so anyway i strongly support moving forward with this recommendation um i think that we are moving forward with this.


9:36 a.m.

Any other of these suggestions as they come forward in the future should provide one of our most critical things you provide us, which is the ability to feel safe in our own homes. And I appreciate the service that's provided to both Trinidad and Blue Lake by the sheriff. Thank you for my opportunity to speak. That is all, Chair Bowman. Seeing no one else. Sheriff, I appreciate the input. Destry heard you loud and clear. So with that, we'll bring it back. I'll make a motion for staff recommendation. I'll second. Supervisor Arroyo? Yes. Supervisor Madrone? Yes. Supervisor Bushnell? Yes. Supervisor Wilson? Yes. Chair Bowman? Yes. Motion carries 5-0. Thank you. Okay, now we will have...


9:37 a.m.

Public comment on non-agenda items. We have a time set, so I'm trying to... Good morning, supervisors and everyone watching and behind me. My name is Joanne McGarry. I'm a resident of Arcata. I am trying to make a commitment in the new year to come to more of these and wade through this intense schedule or agenda that you have. And it's a hard read for people who are, you know, just regular old citizens. So, I don't know, it would be sort of nice to sort of find a way to make it more user-friendly, but whatever. I know a bureaucracy likes to do things like this a little opaquely.


9:38 a.m.

Talk about three things. Emergency preparedness. I carry this bright orange go bag or backpack with me all the time. And I spoke to you before about the challenges of coming into this building as a person without a vehicle who takes the bus places. And I was not carrying this bag with me the day the 7.0 earthquake hit. And I subsequently went to Blue Lake last weekend to an emergency preparedness class. And I've decided that as much as possible I'm going to try and carry things with me so that I can transport myself on foot in a tsunami warning and have some supplies. But that will restrict me from entering this building if I don't have a safe place to put these items that I might need as an emergency. So revisiting how we are stripped down, literally, coming into this building, it just seems... It seems difficult.


9:39 a.m.

right now for the commoner, the common folk. Secondly, climate change, the plan's happening. I spoke up at other meetings of other government boards. We know what we need to do. We don't need to wait for a plan to happen. Please, for the new year, just really commit to reducing greenhouse gas emissions. And Supervisor Bone, I just want to kind of share with you, I know you had a great truckers parade this past weekend, but if we're trying to reduce greenhouse gas emissions in the future, we really need to revisit those types of events that burn fossil fuels. And so there's, climate change is really important, so let's think about all that. And finally, I'm a Section 8 person, and I have 30 seconds left. I'm trying to get Section 8. It's really hard to get a birth certificate in my county I was born in, Los Angeles, but I don't know if...


9:40 a.m.

The challenge with real ID is going to be the same for people trying to get birth certificates through this county. It's a really arduous task, so I think somehow how we can help that process. And I found out that the Section 8 vouchers are being discontinued in Humboldt County for the time being, so I'm concerned about that. So thank you. Thank you very much. And just a small thing, not for discussion, but the security at the front is for the courts. The county, we help with it, but it's provided for the courts. We don't rate as high as a judge being protected, so that's why that's out there is for the courts, because the courts are upstairs. Most people don't realize that. Next. Thank you. Alexander Profant again. I'm here today to present to you a Christmas greeting in the form of a holiday card and an excerpt from a podcast.


9:41 a.m.

home by Henry Wadsworth Longfellow, which I'll follow up with. Also, I apologize for personally handing you my last comment versus filing it with the clerk before presenting it to you. I was a bit flustered after hearing the comment made before mine that day. So I do have comments here for the clerk to get. If you could get them and pass them out, that would be great. It's a difficult thing to come here week after week to beg for help in recovering my property, my, our homes, our homestead, our land security, our private forest land. Yet it is the responsible thing to do for various reasons. As oversight which is required in this county, in my humble opinion, would be to hold local attorneys to account for their bad act or actions and other persons who are or were elected or appointed officials who have abused their power. When the abuse legal process has caused the civil part of the judiciary to be used to cause what I am alleging are


9:42 a.m.

criminal acts, it makes evictions of persons affiliated with the stolen property terrifying and terribly confusing. One might wonder why I sued persons in civil court instead of pressing for criminal investigations from the start. The simple answer is that when I and my husband actually offered above and beyond what was alleged to be owed to these pretended lenders and they did not want money, there was obviously a problem. And I will say that again. When people are deemed borrowers and those borrowers are trying to tender money to pay something off and the people who allege they have a right to redeem a home do not want it, something is wrong. So one of the big pieces of misinformation that I know does not get shared is that many of us could afford to pay a whole bunch of things, including these alleged loans. The people who committed fraud were not interested in receiving the money.


9:43 a.m.

One might wonder why I did that, because the attorney generals in two states were not willing to investigate these crimes. Instead, they actually sent us letters telling us to go hire private attorneys. Well, we had never been in this situation before, so that's exactly what we did. And here we are years and hundreds of thousands of dollars later with no recovery of our homes. We are here to try to mitigate damage. So, before I leave, I will read you a part from Christmas Bells. I heard the bells on Christmas Day, their old familiar carols play, and wild and sweet the words repeat of peace on earth, goodwill to men. And in despair I bowed my head. There is no peace on earth, I said, for hate is strong and mocks the song of peace on earth, goodwill to men. Then peeled the bells more loud and deep. God is not dead, and doth he sleep, not doth he sleep. The wrong shall fail, the right prevail, with peace on earth, goodwill to men. Thank you. Merry Christmas, and thank you for all that you do for the county. Thank you very much.


9:44 a.m.

Thank you. Next. How come? Good morning. My name is Peter Profont, Alexandra's husband. Last week I submitted a comment that was unable to appear, and I wish to read some of it into record. Part 2 addresses accounts that lie. The issue is being minimized as mere typos to be reductive about actual impacts to anyone being subjected to false narratives such as you can't afford something or can't afford to pay. These monies offered above and beyond what is owed ought to be outright or refused. That's the issue that's affecting me. Persons like myself, my wife, and it means to interfere with our enjoyment, a rightful enjoyment to multiple types, a property.


9:45 a.m.

Both papers, Humboldt County letter dated on 3-21, these are included in the previous submission. And the Lineberger letter dated of 8-20-24 alleges a pattern of practice where accountants that lie are being used to damage me and persist to interfere with accountants. It informs of false fee schedules being added to things such as vehicular registrations and motor vehicle department. Anyway, this is, it's all written out here. I'm not very good at public speaking, as you might see. But I'll just skip to the last paragraph here. And that is, these papers illustrate an instance of false accountings and databases and records damaging me and my record.


9:46 a.m.

record and slandering my credit and name. The accountings I allege were then used to fabricate false judgments entered into the county records and into the office by a Mr. Dustin Owens. On record is a bogus abstract of judgment using similar numerals which I allege are now causing more falsity to further encumber my timber property and more false debt derived from what judgment exactly. Is there nothing that there's nothing in the court docket suggesting an abstract came from any judgment? And yeah there's over four hundred and thirty thousand dollar judgment against us but it's not there. It's just an abstract that got issued by Dustin and that's offensive seeing how I've been warned off my property. And threatened for a number of years.


9:47 a.m.

I'm just here to let you know, bring you up to speed about that, and I expect we'll be back. Thanks. Thank you very much. Okay, with that, I would like to bring the 930 time set. Chair Brown, I have one more public comment. Caller 7718, I'm going to unmute you, and you have three minutes. I'm in the process of doing emergency preparedness where I'm at. The ocean is a short stone, sirway. We just got done hand shoveling probably 30 yards of cement out of an area that gets filled in when they have hurricanes down here, which they have every so often. I don't want to do that again, so I'm raising my wall 16 inches higher as we speak. That's preventive. I did want to thank Joanne and the prior speakers for speaking. I do want to emphasize that there is


9:48 a.m.

There's a fear out there. Justify what happened to these last two people who spoke. They're actually selling insurance regarding that stuff to protect you from that. I don't know their exact circumstances, but anyone who owns property should basically be probably working with these people to understand what's going on to make sure it doesn't happen to the rest of us property owners. I would take that seriously, and anything you can do as far as accounting can help preclude that. How would you feel if all of a sudden you felt your property was being taken away from you illegally in a criminal act? I would hope the county would have their back some way on this. I did wish to wish everybody a Merry Christmas, except for anybody who steals horses, and I will be talking about that topic a little bit later, probably when you're going into closed session. There's a related item there. So anyway, thank you for the opportunity to speak. Merry Christmas to all. Have a very nice Christmas and New Year's, I believe. I don't think we have another meeting until afternoon. So take care. Stay out there and enjoy your friends and family. Thank you.


9:49 a.m.

I'm not going to speak. Feliz Navidad. All right. Seeing no more, I will bring this forward and the sheriff on the animal shelter. Adoptable animal of the month. Thank you to Supervisor Arroyo and the board for providing this opportunity for us to highlight one of our shelter animals. We have Rob Patton, one of our animal control officers, and Brandy, a spayed female who's available for adoption. So this is something that I talked to Natalie about, Supervisor Arroyo, and just something that we. I heard she's adopting it. Well, we hope so. But I just want to highlight one thing, and then we'll turn it over to Rob, is the fact is our shelter is at capacity, both for cats and for dogs. And so we really want to highlight how we adopt animals and what the county can do to help out. We have a tremendous amount of volunteers and also rescue organizations. That partner with us. But still.


9:50 a.m.

We're at overcapacity, so we really need to adopt some animals to make sure that they are safe out there. And it is fairly financially able for most people to do it as long as they can care for it and show proof that they can take care of it. Yes, for sure. Okay, Rob, I'm going to turn this over to you and highlight Brandy. Thank you. Thanks for having me today. It was nice of the sheriff to ask us to come. I tried to pick a dog that would be receptive. She's done really well so far. She's kind of typical of a shelter dog. Brandy, you want to come up here? You can see it. She does want to come up here. I can walk around behind you if you want me to. Okay, all right. She's a mix of who knows what. She's got a little shepherd, maybe a little pit bull. And she's done really well on some outings she's been on. So highly adoptable.


9:51 a.m.

at this point. And, uh... Where are you going, Rex? Over there? What, are you going to hold her? I'm going to take her out. Hold tight. She's going to be chair dog of the day. Hold tight. I got it. Come here. So, you're probably familiar with the shelter. I do animal control, so I'm in and out of the shelter, but we have adoptions, we have fosters that are available, adoptions for dogs run. From about $150 to about $220, depending on the size of the animal. Cats are less than that. They're all spayed, they have shots, rabies shot. They have a microchip. And so, our status, because the last year and a half we've been kind of understaffed and overwhelmed with animals, we continue to try to find ways to adopt animals out. You can...


9:52 a.m.

Call the shelter for information. You can go online. Our website is 24petconnect.com. See every animal, dog, and cat in the shelter. Adoption process can start online. It starts with an application. Shelter staff likes to make sure your situation is one that's copacetic with adopting an animal. And you can come in and see certain animals. If you already have animals, you can bring them in to meet the animals you want to potentially adopt. And that's kind of how it goes. Our hours are open right now, Monday through Friday, from 10 to 4, Monday, Wednesday, Friday, and from 10 to 7, Tuesday and Thursday. How many adoptable animals do you have right now? Right now we have over 60 at the shelter. Well, that would be animals total. We have about probably two-thirds of that are adoptable. And there's many in foster.


9:53 a.m.

situations that are adoptable also. And how is the animal shelter funded? We're funded through your tax dollars. And donations? And donations. We just had a big fundraiser on Saturday for our emergency medical fund because when animals come in and they have an issue, injury, skin issue, we don't have a lot of money to spend on them. So we raise money through our emergency medical fund. And people donate. We have a big fundraiser. That helps pay for broken legs. Any kind of issue that might come in. One thing to say, vote Brandy. I'll... May I, Chair? I'm happy to cover Brandy's adoption fees for whoever would like to adopt Brandy. And I look forward to seeing her be in a great home. She's quite a dog. She's been up here giving our chair many, many kisses. And why...


9:54 a.m.

her tail very hard. I don't know if everyone could hear the whacking sound of her tail. She was playing jingle bells. Well, thank you. That's very generous. Thank you. Now, I'm open to any questions. I hope I can answer. Just want to thank you and all the staff there in the community for their support for the shelter. Really appreciate it. Thank you, Supervisor Arroyo. Thank you. This is, yeah, I am a very serious pet lover. And I just was heartbroken to hear that you're at capacity and that so many wonderful pets need homes. But it's also a great opportunity for those pets to find a good loving home who, you know, haven't had that stability in their lives and the opportunity to be the best pet they can be. So I know our community. Really loves the animals. And one of the challenges for the community is


9:55 a.m.

is housing that doesn't allow for pets and so I also want to urge landlords in the community to allow for pets to the extent possible because these are people's companions and it'll help help ensure that you know these pets have great homes. George Wilson. Yeah thank you for bringing this and highlighting I've we have many or have had many and we still have a few free family members come from the from the county shelter I just want to thank you for the service been wonderful always we've always found a lot of love from that from that from that place and I also want to say that we had some strays in our neighborhood that were unadoptable or you know but the shelter found us found us and we're still in a good place to live. We have a lot of people that are around actually our neighbor.


9:56 a.m.

The connectivity with someone to come in and help them get them spayed, at least. So in terms of, there's some cats. And so that was very helpful, and I really appreciate the services, both the volunteers and the paid. So thank you. Thank you. With that, I'll see if there's any public comment. Probably want to step to the side. Brandy, you can stay right there and lick the hell out of her if you want. Hi, my name's Joanne McGarry. In my prior life, in a prior century, I worked for 16 and a half years at the San Francisco Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals. I worked in administration, but I handled a lot of dogs and cats while I was there, fostering and helping in adoptions and all that. I haven't gotten as involved in animal welfare up here when I moved here 13 years ago.


9:57 a.m.

But one of the things I have noticed, and it's not that anything the Animal Control Department can do, but I was a court-appointed, sworn-in state humane officer, and actually one of my assignments was to investigate elephant abuse at the San Francisco Zoo. But Humboldt County currently does not have state humane officers, and they can only be employed by non-governmental animal welfare groups. But there's a lot of chatter on Nextdoor and things like that about livestock issues and humane conditions, and many times, with especially the high capacity at the shelter and a lot of the work that has to be done by Animal Control, I really do think it would be wonderful to promote that humane societies here consider having a staff member become an official state humane officer and make sure that they're not being exploited. Thank you.


9:58 a.m.

than one in our county to help with those kinds of issues and free up the animal control for other things in the sheriff's department. Spay-neuter ordinance two is a very controversial issue, but I really do think we need to revisit the concept of licensing and making sure that as many animals as possible get spayed and neutered and stop the local puppy mill production. And catios for cats. That would do a lot to help. So there's a lot of animal issues that I would really think a state humane officer could help with. And I also think that working harder to educate people about pet ownership and the responsibility is really important. So I hope Brandy finds a loving new home. Great. Thank you. Seeing no one else, I'll look for a question. I don't have anyone on Zoom. That's perfect.


9:59 a.m.

Thank you. I'll make a motion to accept the presentation. I'll second it. May I make an additional comment, Chair Bone? No. Yes. I wanted to offer, I'd love to have an ongoing shelter animal of the month that the board is designating, but I think it's probably fairly stressful for the animals and the staff sometimes to come into this space. Brandy's doing great. But I wanted to offer to go up to the shelter and meet the dog and do a little something there, if that's easier for you all. It allows you to continue with your duties at the shelter. Would that be helpful? Of course. Okay. But we could always feature a quick photo of the animal of the month and talk about them briefly and then do it that way. So I wanted to propose that moving forward. But thank you so much for bringing Brandy down here. She's a great.


10 a.m.

dog and I know she really loved licking Rex Bone's face. I got liked it too. Nice dog. My dog when I get home is going to be very very bad. Thank you guys. Hey it's almost 10. I'm gonna slide. I what? Good. Oh but you want to make a motion? It's made a motion. Vote. Supervisor Bushnell. Yes. Last meeting it'll be a lot easier from here on. Yes. Chair Bone. Yeah. Supervisor Wilson. Yep. Supervisor Madrone. All right. Motion carries 5-0. I'm gonna slide in Gary. I'm gonna slide in. I won because I have volunteer firefighters here and they already put enough time in so if I could have Petrolia, Salmon Creek, and Miranda and I want to recognize two of these fire departments are in Supervisor Bushnell. District. Chris made the motion.


10:01 a.m.

contact with me so that's how i got but uh coming up and tell you what's tell us what's going on guys that's a hard act of follows you don't have to come up and look me in the face i'll look at it that way we missed that part over here but uh yeah i'm dan gribby and i'm the chief of the salmon creek volunteer fire department also the uh president of the board of our newly formed salmon creek volunteer fire protection district and we're here to uh thank the board of supervisors for originally putting the measure z uh to a vote uh you're the ones that made that happen and also to we'd like to thank the voters of uh humboldt county for approving that measure and also humboldt county fire chiefs association and the southern humboldt fire chiefs association all of whom made it possible for our three departments to receive two three brand new type six fire engines which are basically quick attack type fire engines they're very useful


10:02 a.m.

In the rural areas that we live and our goal in our little fire departments is to get to fires and medicals quickly and be able to at least slow it down or stop it before it becomes something big. And so these fire engines that we received are exactly perfect for that role that we have and that we need. So very thankful for receiving that. And also, you know, the other measures, the things that we've received over the years, personal protective equipment for our firefighters and things like that are just invaluable. And on that note, I just read, I think, where volunteer fire departments are basically survive. They say normally in the country today, 80 to 100 thousand dollar budget is for a normal volunteer fire department. Well, I can guarantee you that our three departments right here aren't even close. To that. So we rely on bake sales and.


10:03 a.m.

Donations from our communities and our communities are very supportive of us. So we're very thankful to be able to receive equipment like this to help with our mission. So thank you very much. Chief Andre Stanley of Miranda Fire Volunteer Fire Department and we'd like to thank the board. It's huge, huge for us to get these new Type 6 engines so we appreciate that. We did have to cover our cost of sales of tax and registration of $16,000 to $17,000 and also the cost of engine radios, department decals and some other operational gear for our apparatus. Miranda Fire was lucky enough that we could cover those additional costs, although some departments may struggle to cover those additional costs if awarding apparatus in the future. Please take this into consideration in the future funding, although we are sure that many other departments


10:04 a.m.

Other local fire departments could use new type sixes as well. This new type six will be an amazing asset for responding to calls from Miranda Fire, to all in-district, out-of-district, mutual aid, state park, BLM, Caltrans, SRA, CHP, sheriff, and other non-district responses, as well as being able to join OES strike teams in the future and help greater area. Miranda Fire did not have a type six engine for years previous to this Measure Z funded engine, and we encourage the board to keep approving funding for assets like these for our local volunteer fire departments. Miranda Fire runs on $20,000 budget a year from our district. This barely pays our bills and many years running the deficit. With operational compliant costs and needs rising, things like fuel, PG&E, insurance, and other department needs, keep us running but are also costing more.


10:05 a.m.

Like other local volunteer fire departments, Measures E funded PPE, gear, and department needs has been instrumental to keeping us safe and to maintain operational capacity. Like Miranda Fire and other volunteer fire departments, we would not be able to afford these instrumental and crucial items from our own funding or fundraisers. We ask the board to prioritize volunteer fire departments' needs when approving funds in the future. Thank you again for approving the funds for this much-needed Type 6. Miranda Fire Department and our community, thank you. And thanks for your time today, and have a great Merry Christmas, Happy Holiday, and a good New Year. We appreciate you guys very much. Thank you, guys. Chris? Chris Gilda, Petroleum Volunteer Fire Chief. Yeah, thank you very much for the approving of the funds. This is the first new vehicle for Petroleum Fire since the 50s ever.


10:06 a.m.

Pretty amazing. It brings us, now we have one vehicle which is NFPA compliant and we have a bunch of other good vehicles. They're solid but they would not fit NFPA compliance standards. So as chief that's like one of my goals is to bring us into full compliance. It's a long way down the road and it's a funding issue. And the apparatus grants are the most competitive grants that are out there. And for ultra rural departments like all of ours, we just don't have the call volume, don't have the population to compete in those. And so the Measure Z funding is crucial. And yeah, it's three down, 37 to go. More departments. So we could really use it.


10:07 a.m.

these apparatus. So once again, thank you. Very much appreciated. Twelve years later or so, it's still nice to see Measure Z is working. Not to the level it was, but it is working. I know the difference it made when you got air packs, the PPE equipment, so you could go out and help on a bigger scale and have the equipment available if you wanted to help out in these local fire department fires out in the hitherlands. And I think our own McCraig from Cal Fire would like to reiterate that, I bet. Good afternoon board and administration and legal counsel. I would like to express my appreciation as a cooperator of these three fire departments and all the fire departments in this county as well as a citizen for your investment in what you've provided here. This is a tremendous asset that will be used well.


10:08 a.m.

by all three fire departments and as a Cal Fire Unit Chief and the Cal OES Operational Area Coordinator for Fire and Rescue of Humboldt County, I appreciate what you've done for all of us. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. McCray. Supervisor Bushnell. Thanks for coming up. I appreciate it and good luck on getting the decals on your truck today because he brought his truck. I also want to thank the Measure Z Committee. So the Measure Z Committee, as you're aware, does recommend to our board and then our board adopts their recommendations or changes. They do a lot of hard work so that we don't have to and that was what that intent of that committee was for when Measure Z was adopted. What year, Rex? I think it was 2014. Oh, 2014. Yeah, we started in 2013, the ground rules. Yeah, so they've done a lot of hard work and recognized fire as well. I appreciate the commitment.


10:09 a.m.

of the local fire departments in my community. I have 18 of them and so it's a heavy lift for them and it's you know around all the time but especially around the holidays it's can be very traumatic and our local people just go out and do what has to be done so I appreciate you guys's commitment to the community. Mr. Vice-Minister. Thank you chair yeah thank you all for all the work you do in your districts and I do also appreciate what you said about the voters supporting measure z you know it's not easy times for people to want to tax themselves but I think the recent results from our election show Humboldt County steps up and they supported all the bond measures for the schools as well as measure o which is going to make the roads a little better so we don't beat our equipment up as as badly and response times will get better instead of dodging all the potholes it will take time to get there but that also means that public works won't be coming to measure z for money anymore so I think you can


10:10 a.m.

understand what that might mean for fire, for law enforcement, and other important things in the community. So I want to thank the voters for supporting Measure O as well in a tough economic time. But without you guys stepping up in your departments and all your volunteers, we wouldn't be able to do it. So thank you. Measure O will go a long way in making that truck last a little bit longer too, as a full-on crystal tell you. Supervisor Wilson. Well, I associate myself with all those comments. And just a point of, I didn't realize that the wildland trucks were type six. So I just want to, you're saying type six, I had to look it up. Oh, that's what those are. I remember. So anyways, I just want people to know that the type six truck is the wildland truck that you see. Thanks for bringing that up. And I apologize. Chris sent me pictures and I didn't get them to the, yeah. Anyway, is there any public comment on this item?


10:11 a.m.

Yes, I have a caller. Oh, go ahead. Come on back up. I just want to make a quick reference. As you guys talked about Measure O, I heard schools, I heard sheriff. Let's talk about the basis of our society, which is emergency services, law enforcement, and schools. And let's just keep funding it and keep our county going. Thank you guys so much. You got it. Caller 7718, I'm going to unmute you. You have three minutes. Hi, I raised my hand on the other topic. I'll just say congratulations to the Royal for sponsoring the dog. Thank you very much. That's all Thank you Any other public comment saying none, thanks you guys for hanging around


10:12 a.m.

get you in there sooner or so. Thanks. Appreciate it. Have a good holiday. I'll make a motion to accept and file a report. Second. And speak to that civil society costs money, so thanks for everybody for stepping up. And civil society costs even more. Supervisor Arroyo? Yes. Supervisor Bushnell? Yes. Chair Bone? Yep. Supervisor Madrone? 10-4. Supervisor Wilson? Yes. Motion carries 5-0. Now I'd like to bring up our 10 o'clock time set. Thank you for giving us a few minutes there, Gary. And the Buckeye. Oh good, you brought the boss. Absolutely. I wouldn't do this alone. So we have a PowerPoint, I think.


10:13 a.m.

There's a clicker down on the table as well. Oh, perfect. Thank you. First of all, Chair Bone, Supervisors, Administration, thank you for the opportunity to be here. We're here to represent the Buckeye. I'm the current chairman of the Buckeye, and Christy Moore is our executive director. Christy? So the Buckeye, if you can see, that's a great specimen tree. I think that's down in Bear River when the founders of the Buckeye found that tree, a big, resilient. You don't see Buckeyes that big very often. So I think that's why they selected the name Buckeye, because of this big, resilient tree that they found. So that's been our symbol. So we're primarily about maintaining the open and working lands of Northwestern. We're in California, and if we go to our mission and vision,


10:14 a.m.

statement. It's about the working lands open spaces in northwestern California. They're viable, they're conserved for the perpetuity for the future, and our mission is stewardship of working landscapes through shared experience, hand-on education, and collaboration. And I hope you'll, hopefully you'll see that as we go forward with our presentation. So the history, we started in 1999, and one of the questions I'm sure is, well, why Buckeye? What about Farm Bureau? What about cattlemen, cattlewomen? We work collaboratively with those folks. We're more hands-on, local, direct, whereas those other organizations tend to be more tied, they're also certainly tied locally, but they're also tied to statewide organizations. So Buckeye is pretty much pure local, farmers, ranchers, and timberland owners and resource professionals. We are a 501c3 organization, so we don't really get involved in advocacy much. We're really more about collaboration and reaching out. So on the


10:15 a.m.

Chair, Dean Mullen is the vice chair, Pasture Sal Canici, Kate Howard, Dana Hunt, who is also with our CFO, so to speak. So you can see we've got a good mixture of folks who are on there who are steeped in ranching and forestry. Our directors, Scott Downey, Brenda Goldstein, Blake Satterly, and Bushnell, all folks who are ranchers or who are resource professionals. All right. Christy. Thank you. Yeah, I can multitask. So we're just going to go through a few things that the Buckeye is doing currently. And one thing we're... Who are you? I'm sorry. I'm Christy Moore. I'm the executive director with the Buckeye. And I also live on a family ranch in Neyland. So the scholarship program we're really proud of.


10:16 a.m.

We're able to award multiple scholarships every year depending on donations to the fund to local youth that are promoting ag and natural resources. You'll see later some photos of last year's recipients. We also have the Buckeye Seed Grant program, and this is for students K through 11th grade. And the projects that come through this program are really inspiring. We've got steer programs, sheet programs, a little bit of everything, and this is one of my favorite programs here. We also have the Buckeye Stewardship Award, and this is a way for the Buckeye to recognize not just Buckeye members, but folks in the community that are promoting working landscapes and open spaces, and the behind-the-scenes. And the behind-the-scenes work that they're doing.


10:17 a.m.

Many of these recipients you may not have heard of, many you have, but like I said, there's a lot of behind-the-scenes work that goes on to maintain these open spaces. We'll be announcing at our 2025 annual dinner that our Stewardship Award recipient for next year is Jean and Ginger Sarvinsky. They are well known for their innovative practices on their farm. And speaking with Jean recently, very humble, and says, oh, you know, we're not up to very much, but they are up to a lot. So we're looking forward to hosting a ranch tour of their farm in May. So be looking for that date. Another award is the Buckeye Young Steward Award. This is our most recent award because we also want to give recognition for the,


10:18 a.m.

younger generation that is making an effort to advocate for the type of work that the Buckeye is doing. And then I'll hand it over to Gary. So these are kind of our priority things we've been involved in. One of the things is Great Redwood Trail. We have folks who are members who are likely to be impacted by that trail as it goes forward. We've been involved with the technical advisory group. We've submitted comments. We've looked on the plan in the draft PTIR or PEIR. We've also hosted a question and answer session here a few months back in May, I believe it was. And we're looking at trying to mitigate any potential impacts and potential alternative routes. We're also on the elk working group. This is a group with landowners, Humboldt, Del Norte, and I believe Mendocino County also, and also working with the agencies about how we can get along with elk and how we can, you know, where they interact with elk.


10:19 a.m.

with the ranching community. Succession planning, we had a succession planning workshop here recently. We'll go into that in a second. We also are setting up a speaker series with Cal Poly Humboldt. We have had the Working Lands Persistence with the Redwood Rise program. One of the great things we've done are these ranch tours, and we'll go through a couple of those here in a minute. Community presentations and doing outreach panels. We're still working on setting up these quarterly network happy hours, just like it sounds. Climate action, we provided, I think, pretty substantial comments on the Humboldt County Climate Action Plan, thinking about how that could potentially impact rural landowners who oftentimes rely on propane and internal combustion generators and who are oftentimes off the grid and are also probably the ones who are the first people to lose power and who are the first people to lose power and who are the first people to lose power. So keeping that in mind, we're trying to make sure that those folks aren't adversely impacted by changes.


10:20 a.m.

that may come out of that plan. We already went through the scholarship program. Annual meeting's a great time. I encourage you, if you haven't gone to one, please, we'll make sure you're informed to attend. They're just a great social event, and we've really, really enjoyed putting those on. We also have great communication. We have the emails, the broadcast emails that go out as need be. We have two to three newsletters, and then, of course, informational meetings and workshops. So this is the Marshall Ranch Homestead Tour. This was back in June of 2023. Folks from Salmon Creek were just here. This is in that same vicinity. Great turnout. You can see that. Wonderful. A lot of these are fourth- and fifth-generation ranches. So be able to go out. These folks love showing off their ranches. They love showing what they're doing, and they're just great tours.


10:21 a.m.

Homestead Ranch tour. This is the, again, the down to Bryslin. And this again was the Marshall Ranch. And this is the Fredrickson and the Mullen ranches. Now the great thing about this particular tour was that those are all Humboldt State students. I'm sorry, Cal Poly Humboldt. It's a tough one to break. And that's the Science 100 class. Those are all incoming freshman students who are either forestry, range, or fire management students. And this is a lot of times the first time they've been out on a working ranch. A lot of these students are from Southern California. And so we had, I think, what, four professors with us from Humboldt. And broken down into range and soils and forestry. And they all broke up into different groups and went through stuff. It was really a great tour. And I think the students really enjoyed it. There were also producers back. There were also producers.


10:22 a.m.

that attended the workshop. So it was open to Buckeye members as well. So it was a nice mix. Yeah, so we had another, like, probably 10 Buckeye members here. 15. Yeah, yeah. And there's a little warm that day, so we found shade. And those are Jeannie and Mr. Fredrickson. Again, that same tour. Succession planning workshop. Do you want to cover this? Thank you, Kristen. So these workshops have been really fun for me to craft and put together. And our first series was about why to start the succession planning process. And so we kind of called this the nuts and bolts of succession planning. So especially with large landscapes, there needs to be planning way far in advance to make sure that these properties aren't. Fragmented in the future. So.


10:23 a.m.

So we had a speaker lineup, Amy Hunt, Scott Hunt, Dan Erisman, Jack Rice, Laurel Dahlstedt, George Peterson Insurance, and some local landowners that are well respected. And we started with some presentations about, you know, again, the nuts and bolts of succession planning. And then we broke up into a roundtable discussion where everyone shared personal stories about their experience. So that was really powerful. And it also leads into series number two, which is actually the hardest part of succession planning, is having that difficult conversation with families, heirs, or with your professional team of what the future plan is. So that's coming up on January 30th. And we talked about the Buckeye annual meeting and dinner. So this was 2024's. Meeting held in April.


10:24 a.m.

At the River Lodge. At the River Lodge. So we start with a membership meeting where Rex and Michelle spoke, along with Kurt McRae and Jeff Stackhouse, and a Cal Poly Humboldt Forestry student, Audrey Gomes. We focus on recognition throughout the event, and our keynote speaker is our Stewardship Award recipient. That's what the event is mainly focused on, is, like I said, the stewardship work that's being done on local properties. So on the left, you can see our 2024 Stewardship Award recipient, Duane and Karen Fredrickson, presented by Mark and Dina Moore. Our Young Steward Award, Rebecca Searcy. And our Scholarship and Seed Grant recipients, who also volunteered at the event and did a great job. So our 21st. 2025 annual dinner is scheduled for.


10:25 a.m.

February 22nd. Again, we'll start with a membership meeting that we encourage everyone to attend, and then we'll follow up with a great dinner, New York Strip with Pete Bussman, and recognize our scholarship seed grant recipients, as well as our other award recipients. And then, as you're going through the community, you know, it's nice to put a face to a name, and so this is our current lineup of board of directors. Gary, our chair. We have Sal Canici. Jenny Mullen, the current ag teacher at Eureka High. Kate Howard is our secretary and working laborer. And then, as you're going through the community, we'll follow up with a great dinner, and recognize our scholarship seed grant recipients, as well as our great dinner, and recognize our partner biologists. Dana Hunt is our CFO.


10:26 a.m.

And Britta Goldstein, Scott Downey, Blake Satterly. Blake and David Bushnell joined the board last year. They've been great additions. Both ranchers with professional careers that bring a lot to the table. Myself and our wonderful communications interns. So both college students that help with the website and communications and keep us up to speed. All right. Thank you for that. I know a famous comedian said never follow kids, dogs, and I'm gonna add emergency service people to that. I'd like to thank the emergency. I wish they were still here because they're they're almost always the first responders to problems in our world. I know. I'll get to him in a minute. And then they don't have to do anything.


10:27 a.m.

They don't have the helicopters, they don't have the aerial tankers, etc. Cal Fire comes in, obviously, and gets there as soon as they can. But oftentimes, not always, but oftentimes, the rural volunteer fire department folks are the first people to show up, whether it's a medical emergency, whether it's a fire, whatever. And our Buckeye members really appreciate them. So thank you for supporting them. Thank you for supporting with the equipment. That's a big deal. We're happy to take any questions. And I certainly appreciate the time that you've given us to be here and kind of introduce ourselves. And I would suggest, if you have an opportunity, please make it to the annual dinner. I've been fortunate to go along before I was on this as an auctioneer, and it's quite a lot of fun. And the one thing I have always is we learned a really hard lesson about 40 years, 30 years ago, about succession planning with a local rancher. And succession planning. Unless you want to give it all to the government, maybe one.


10:28 a.m.

One of the most important things you can do, and you guys have done a great job on that. Probably the greatest way you can lose open space is to not have it properly planned going forward. Exactly, exactly, because it gets broken up. So that sounds like we're Yellowstone. Anyway, I will bring it back to the board. Supervisor Bushnell? Sure. So just being in the last couple of years more active and more involved with the Buckeye through my husband and attending your annual meetings and some workshops, I appreciate the commitment that the Buckeye has for open lands and ranches and conserving open space in Humboldt County and beyond. I appreciate the work that Christy does and the board does. I see, you know, through my husband a lot of e-mails come through, a lot of suggestions, thoughts, and ideas, and a lot of work that the Buckeye does. And so ranching is my heritage. I grew up on a ranch, and it's back far, far, far, far, far, far, far, far, far, far, far, far, far, far, far, far, far, far, far, far, far, far, far, far, far, far, far, far, far, far, far. Five generations.


10:29 a.m.

in Southern Humboldt. You know, my grandfather was a great-grandfather. Great-grandfathers were ranch owners. It's not the way of life today, but it is still a great way of life, and so I really appreciate that commitment that the Buckeye has. Thank you. Supervisor Royal, then Wilson. Thank you for coming and sharing some of your accomplishments and goals and who's part of your organization right now. I just wanted to thank you for reaching out and meeting with me recently. I really appreciated the time and the understanding of more of what you're doing, and unfortunately, I already know that February 22nd, I have another commitment, but so I will look to go to that in future years, and thanks for, you know, having a great, robust newsletter and, you know, sharing out information. This is not a community. The ranching and working lands community is not necessarily one I'm directly connected to, so it really helps expand my knowledge. Thank you. Thank you.


10:30 a.m.

Thanks, you guys. I always appreciate the work of this organization and its members, especially those that I communicate with often, the Moors. I want to just ask a question about the elk that you brought up. And so can you just summarize the change that we've seen recently? I think people are now seeing elk down in Blue Lake. We've even seen one on Humboldt Bay. We're seeing it expanding into all these watersheds. What's your projection about that? Because I think many people are just unaware of this as an issue. The issue is the conflict often between the elk and with the cattle. And the two bulls don't always get along well. So there are often...


10:31 a.m.

problems with that but probably the bigger problem is the elk don't pay any attention to fences they just go straight through them they do a lot of damage and that's that's becomes problematic they don't interact well with the cattle so the trying to figure out how how there's better coexistence and looking at programs that dfw might have department of fish and wildlife may have to assist the ranchers and work with the ranchers to to try to mitigate some of these issues kerry can i add one thing um elk eat a ton of grass and they they compete with the cattle and and not only do they wreck havoc on the fences but they eat the feed that the that the ranchers are very dependent on and that's one of the issues in um you know out out in your area they have a herd of a hundred elk out there and they can wipe them out with the fresh grass and not leave that for the cattle and so that's one of the specials that we have to be aware of and that's one of the things that we're trying to And I think that's one of the things that we're trying to do is we're trying to make sure that's biggest issues. What I was trying to get at was


10:32 a.m.

Do we have a projection in terms of numbers, like that change? As far as the number of elk? Yeah, and where that expected population, because you just mentioned like, oh, now it's Mendocino, and we're seeing it in Marin County as well. So is there? The Marana and the Marana Cores are the Tule elk, and these are the Roosevelt's. But the DFW has been working hard to figure out just what the populations of elk are. We all know as we drive up and down the highway, you can see the different, just about every different drainage has an elk herd in it now. And you can, I think, I guess the other day there's probably 80 in that Blue Lake herd now. Very substantial down in the Christie Field. And they're trying to get a handle. They have an elk management plan they're putting together that they've been working on, and that's still going forward. But trying to get a good handle on just how many elk are out there and where those different elk populations are and how they're going to be managed. And that's something that they've been working on for the last several years.


10:33 a.m.

That's continuing. So before they can really, really solidify that plan, they really need to have a better estimate of the population. So I appreciate organizations like yours that are really looking to educate people about these issues and about working lands and its interface into these natural systems as well and how that management is challenging at times, and I appreciate that. Thanks. Do you have anything to add on the other? Yeah, a little bit. And what has happened over time is elk are grazing animals and private landowners are managing their lands for optimal grazing. And so we're seeing these herds concentrated on private lands. And that's, like Michelle said, they're consuming a lot of forage. Most ranchers have a rotational grazing plan put in place. So they graze down to a certain height.


10:34 a.m.

remove the cattle. When that grass starts to grow, it's like candy. So the elk see the cattle leave and they say, oh perfect, that's the good stuff. So that's kind of the conflict that's arising. Obviously these ranchers, that grass is what is sustaining the herd that, you know, then they sell for their income. So a lot of changes in the elk working group. We don't have any goals for the group. The group itself is going to collaboratively come together, look at the situation at hand, and we have a lot of different participants from different perspectives that are then going to come up with what things we think we can change to improve the situation. And Carrington Hilson of CDFW, she's got all the specific numbers as far as growth and population changes. Thank you.


10:35 a.m.

Thank you. Just to put it in perspective, we put the elk on a watch list so they'd come back like this, and we did the same thing 20 years ago with the Aleutian geese, and now they're going to soon drop the limit, I think, on those, because 16 Aleutian geese equal one cow. So what they're doing is they're competing with our local dairy market for the grass, and unlike, well, they still do it, but the big problem with the geese is they soil the ground pretty bad, too, because they just do what they do after they eat all that fresh grass. But that is a good example, because there were some solutions that came up that were innovative, working with the ranchers, working with DFW on the Aleutian geese, and I think those are kind of some of the hope we have going forward, that we can come up with some mitigating solutions. The extended season on private lands so we could push them to public lands is where they wanted that. There are some innovations. Okay.


10:36 a.m.

I hope the wolf isn't one of them, but did wonders in Yellowstone. With that, I'll open this up to public comment. Chair, I have one on Zoom. Caller 7718, I'm going to unmute you. You have three minutes. I have a little bit of rame land down with the Christie family down there. Yes, the elk are quite prolific, as we all know. That's the main area for elk. They do tear down all the benches. I don't even bother to try and keep benches in on my portion. Christie's do on my 18 acres I have down there. It should be made notice to you people also out there, although they say there aren't wolves. I know people who go hunting and there actually are wolves out there. They find signs of them and see them. Also, the coyotes are coming back. So a lot of the animals, the predators that normally downsize the herd are returning. They're following the herd and Mother Nature is taking


10:37 a.m.

Of course, I understand the lack of feed and the concern of the ranchers, and I strongly support methods being brought forward to protect their livelihood of having the livelihood. And I also do strongly support, in fact, it's really big in England right now. There's big protests because they want to tax the families on inheritance. If you don't have the correct estate planning, you will lose your small farm or ranch or even medium size to a large corporation because we can't afford to keep them. Thank you for my opportunity to speak and support the Buckeye in what they do. I'll make a motion to accept the presentation and thanks for coming. Kristy lives way out in Neyland and so she drove a ways and Gary you don't live so far but thank you for coming. I'll second. I move to second it. Do you hit your head on vacation Gary?


10:38 a.m.

Thank you. Let's just say that my new wood stove and I are trying to work things out. And thank you, too, for Cal Fire for putting the fires out after the rural department shows up. We appreciate that. Supervisor Wilson? Yes. Supervisor Madrone? Yes. Supervisor Arroyo? Yes. Supervisor Bushnell? Yes. Chair Bone? Thank you, and Merry Christmas, you guys. Thank you. Thank you. Really appreciate the time today. Thank you. Hey, Gary, if you could e-mail us all the past winners of the stewardship award so everybody has a – It's on the website. Is it on the website? It's on the website. It's pretty impressive. It's pretty impressive seeing the families and how stretched out they are amongst the whole county. Thanks, Kurt. And also, Rex, thank you for your involvement over the years.


10:39 a.m.

an auctioneer that's obviously a huge, huge benefit, and that's how we fund all those scholarships. So, thank you. I'm going to run this over to H1, our CAO's office. Thank you, Chair Bone. This is your annual presentation of the public hearing to amend your fee ordinance, and for you today is Shannon Folk Carlson, Administrative Services Manager with the County Administrative Office, to present the fees to your board. This is Shannon's first time presenting to the board. It is. Nailer sailor. Hello, good morning. I am opening the public hearing. Actually, Scott reminded me that three times. It's going to be so good when you're up here at chair, because I like you know. All right, you ready? Yeah. Kaylee, do we have the press?


10:40 a.m.

presentation perfect oh awesome um good morning chair born chair born i've been starting so great good morning chair bone and members of the board my name is shannon falk carlson i'm administrative services manager presenting the 2025 fee schedule for possible adoption authority for accounting to establish increase or decrease fees and charges comes from california government code 54985 which allows counties to set fees and charges to recover the reasonably necessary cost for providing a service product or for enforcing a regulation the authority to establish and update planning and land use fees comes from a different section california government code 66016 but with a few differences and effective dates and process to change a fee or charge Quadrants Robert Co dette I'm�� East America poney michael


10:41 a.m.

It is similar and the focus is on recovering the cost of providing the service. The reason we are here today is because both the government code sections require at least one public hearing. As I mentioned, all fees except planning and building fees are effective no sooner than 30 days after adoption. County practice is the Monday following 30 days, which is Monday, January 20th. Planning and land use fees require a 60-day period for effectiveness, which would land on Saturday, February 15th. So we are rolling forward to Monday, February 17th. This is a brief overview of our proposed fees for 2025. Last year fees totaled 1,187 total fees. This is less. 39 deleted fees. For this year, which will be discussed.


10:42 a.m.

in more detail in a couple of slides, which leaves us 1,148 total county fees. This is reflective of 12 decreasing and 370 increasing and 28 new fees. 50% of the changing fees have less than 10% increase or decrease, and 35% of increases are less than $5. This leads us to county fee trends. A majority of fees are reflecting no changes. There are a small number of new fees. There are very few decreases in which mostly are due to staffing changes and updates to productive hourly rates. Last year's fees were similarly distributed to this year. The number of increasing fees is fairly stable as several departments increased their fees by CPI to account for increased costs.


10:43 a.m.

Inflation. Due to some stabilization of inflation, the increases by CPI were not as high as they have been the last two years. Notably high percentage increases are primarily due to staffing promotions and recalculations of productive hourly rates and evaluation of time spent administering services for fees. This is primarily in planning and building and environmental health. These are a list of the department programs with increases or decreases this year. Like I mentioned previously, there's 370 increases and 12 decreases. A large portion of the changes this year are attributed to CPI increases in fees in aviation and productive hourly rate updates for staff times and fees in planning and building, environmental health budgets, and the public health clinic, all of which have a large number of fees to review and update.


10:44 a.m.

update annually. Also of note, public health administration submitted increases to ambience permit fees, which have not been updated in numerous years. Concealed carried weapon fees for sheriff have increased notably due to changes in government code PC26190, which removed the cap on renewals and modifications in addition to costs for additional staff time to meet new requirements for review of social media accounts for applicants. Building inspection fees for agricultural exemption processing and agricultural exemption penalties per structure were also increased based on the analysis of building inspector and permit technician staff time required to perform the service. This represents the new fees in the proposed schedule. Of note, the assessor added new fees for secure


10:45 a.m.

and unsecured property tax reports. The UC Cooperative Extension created two new fees to open up their small conference room as a rental space in addition to the large auditorium in the agricultural building. And aviation added fees for commercial vehicle operators, expired but not returned badges, and event and staffing fees. And then this slide represents deleted fees, which are typically just cleanup of obsolete fees from the previous year. The primary source of deleted fees this year is environmental health and aviation. Of note for the Public Defender and Conflict Council was the deletion of the expungement fees pursuant to AB 1869, which limited allowable administrative fees. And that leads us...


10:46 a.m.

To the end of the presentation and with that I am happy to answer any questions I am able or turn it over to department heads. Great. Bring it back to the board. Saying nothing. I will open it up to department heads. They got nothing. We'll open it to public comment. Three for three. You nailed it. Bring it back. Supervisor Arroyo. I want to publicly share a positive comment that I received recently about one of our departments and it's loosely related to this item but I just want to take this opportunity to share it which is that a local contractor told me the planning and building department is the best they've ever been as far as customer service and their experience working with them. And I thought it was really great to.


10:47 a.m.

Share that. I've already shared that with Director Ford, but I thought it would be good to publicly state, especially since planning and building has some changes as part of this fee schedule. So I will. Do I need to read the entirety of this into the record? Or can it just be staff recommendation? Great. I'll move staff recommendation. Second, and I do want to note that I had some questions about some of the fees, especially around planning and building, and Director Ford was able to answer those for me yesterday. I encourage anybody in the public that sees these, and if they do have questions, to reach out to those department heads or to the county administrative office to get those answers. Supervisor Wilson. Just to thank staff for their continued hard work on keeping these things all updated. And helping us function. Thanks.


10:48 a.m.

Thank you Chair Bone. Nice presentation, well done. And yeah, I agree, I think planning and building, public works, all the departments are doing a great job with this. For the public, you know, we're just trying to recover costs. We're not trying to make any money here. Just trying to run the county. We've got a budget deficit and this is just trying to make even on the cost of staff time, etc. I also want to give a shout out to Karen Clower. She's doing a lot of, might be almost considered triple duty right now on many levels. And there were some concerns about hanger fees and other aviation increases. And Karen did a fantastic job of responding to those concerns with a lot of detail. Nobody's ever happy with increased fees and stuff, but when you understand the background, it really helps. So I want to thank Karen for her work on that. Karen who? I don't know. Karen's not making any money. No, ditto on that.


10:49 a.m.

Yeah, there are some issues, and they've been brought up. Thank you for highlighting public planning and building. I've been hearing that for years, and John's done a great job for what we're dealing with. Tom, with the limited efforts his crew has talked about responding this weekend, I would call them, and I would have one of his road guys, I would call, or Steve, and I'd say, hey, there's a slide on Wildcat, and then I'd get a picture of a truck at the Wildcat, and I'd got the thing 17 minutes before. So it's just they responded all weekend. The leads out there, the supervisors, Supervisorial guys were out there, and the level of road delays was minimal. So that was great, and that goes along with all the other, you know, not all our departments react to emergencies. But they do react to the needs of the, how's that go?


10:50 a.m.

The fabric of the community. Does that work? Does this have something to do with fees? Yeah. Okay. Yeah. We're thanking them, warning them. And then the other thing I wanted to verify is Supervisor Madrone said, we're not allowed to make money. We don't make money. We do have to cover our costs. And so that's where these come in and having to raise these fees. And even so, then they're minimal. So with that. Supervisor Arroyo? Yes. Supervisor Madrone? Yes. Chair Bone? Yep. Supervisor Bushnell? Yes. Supervisor Wilson? Yes. Motion carries 5-0. Thank you all. Thank you.


10:51 a.m.

Thank you. I'll close the public hearing. Right? Yeah. Okay. And then I think we'll go to, let's have, no, Mr. Ratson show up, come up here for unmet traffic. Yeah, I shouldn't. Really? Talk quick. There is another one. No? She's holding her doesn't she? She's holding her. Okay. Yeah. Up there. Okay. That makes it shorter, doesn't it? We're going to have to download that, so you're knocked out of the box now. Oh, he has a thingy? Yeah, he has a thingy.


10:52 a.m.

Unlike most departments that send it in early so you can yeah whatever yeah whatever. Yeah Good morning Chair Bowen, members of the board,


10:53 a.m.

and director of public works this morning we have a department report on regarding the unmet transit needs uh this is an ongoing annual h humboldt county association of government's process but we they also ask all the cities and the counties to get the information out there comments and and concerns can be submitted to hcog to the end of the month okay so overview of the unmet transit needs process um this this is funded by the transportation development act this is a one-half cent sales tax that we all pay uh to the state of california and then it is divvied back out to counties and cities to provide transit an unmet transit need is a public transportation need that is not met by the current public transportation system the unmet transit need process identifies and evaluates the adequacy of existing public transportation services


10:54 a.m.

and locally the process involves public hearings, releasing online survey, receiving comments by email and phone calls to the Humboldt County Association of Government office. At a minimum unmet transit needs are requested trips from residents who do not have access to public or specialized transportation or private transport services, requested trips from residents who do not have the resources to travel to medical care, shopping, social recreational activities, education, training and employment or proposed public transportation, specialized transportation or private transport services that are identified in a regional transportation plan. There is sufficient broad-based community support. This means that persons who will likely use the service on a routine basis demonstrate support. There is reasonable to meet criteria, the service must be operationally feasible and functional, and the services must be in compliance with the requirements of the financial largest


10:55 a.m.

...sustainable, must have adequate roadways and must be safe to operate, and sufficient funding available from identified funding services to cover the service's marginal operating costs for at least three years. The service must be projected to meet a minimum marginal farebacks return ratio of 10% within two years. And it cannot compete, cannot compare unmet transit needs with the need for streets and roads. One of the allowances for the TDA funds is if you don't spend it all on transit, you can spend it on other things, including streets and roads. But that is actually not part of the overall consideration unless you end up with money left over. The performance of a service found to be reasonable to meet and that is implemented is regularly evaluated in the first one to two years of service. So this process, the public comment period continues through December 31st. This is 2024.


10:56 a.m.

That includes all of our agency public comments, online survey, public comments by email and phone. In January, these comments are compiled by the Humboldt County Association of Governments. Late January, February, they prepare to issue a draft unmet transit needs report. March and April, the Social Services Technical Advisory Committee for HCOG makes recommendations on draft unmet transit needs report of findings. And transit providers review the draft unmet transit needs report of findings to see if they can even implement any of them. Public review continues through March and April of 2025. And in May of 2025, HCOG adopts the unmet transit needs. Final report with public responses by the board of HCOG. Known transit needs that have come up many, many times.


10:57 a.m.

times are more frequent service earlier and later service during weekdays, Sunday service on Redwood Transit System and later night service on Friday and Saturday between Arcata and Eureka. Just as a summary of the ridership, as you can all see, we were doing pretty good in 1920 and then COVID hit and everything changed. We are finally starting to climb back up to our pre-COVID numbers. We're scratching our way, but the numbers continue to rise every year. So we've got differences on the different kinds of programs, the different dial-a-ride, Willow Creek, which has become a very, very popular route. And so again, everywhere where we saw drops from COVID, we actually have seen an increase above the COVID levels in the Willow Creek ridership. So that route is, turned out to be very, very popular.


10:58 a.m.

The other ones, again, are climbing back to pre-COVID. In total, there were 480,300 total passenger trips on HTA in fiscal year 23-24. HTA is one of our primary sources that we fund. The Willow Creek, can we own that up to school transport, a lot of that? Oh, yeah. There's a lot of kids that commute back and forth from Willow Creek into Arcata for school. Perfect. And I've actually got retired employees that live out there and start using the service now, especially in winter because it's safe for the driving in the snow conditions. Yep. Appreciate it. So, again, here's our ridership projections. Again, we are climbing out of the COVID hit and starting to get back to good ridership. Arcata Mad River system, again, we're showing the same thing. And really, the last year has shown a very significant jump in ridership. Again, this is a very significant jump in ridership. Again, this is a very significant jump in ridership.


10:59 a.m.

This is post-COVID. Kids coming back to Cal Poly that were out for the years studying remote are now back on campus. What we're looking to, what HTA has going further on is adding hydrogen fueling station and hydrogen buses, development of the intermodal transit center in Eureka, and was recently awarded an $18.7 million grant to expand the fleet of lower emission vehicles, improve information for transit riders, and increase frequency of service. There will be implementing the unified branding in Ferris so you can get on any route and you don't have to pay for the different RTS or HTA. It'll be an integrated system with a tap to pay, and then the microtransit system is starting to get implemented in the greater Eureka area, and there are plans to move that up. We're going to be moving that up into McKinley Villa.


11 a.m.

well just as a note the North State Express this is the route that was set up by HTA to take people down into the Bay Area with multiple transit providers that launched in early 2024 you can see it's got a number of different agencies all cooperating so that all of our systems connect together to get from Humboldt to the Bay Area and at that if you'd have any questions about transit or would like to provide input you can email hcog at info at hcog dot net or call them directly at 707-444-8208 and I do need to note for the record that you know I Natalie Rowe did get a public comment sent over to Public Works about transit needs in the the Arcata area and that could possibly become a micro transit issue similarly to what we're looking at earlier in the year. Hopefully that's something we can discuss right now.


11:01 a.m.

to get a mainline bus route. Those are the kinds of things that we need to refer to HCOG to think about and discuss and see if they can be funded. With that, that's the end of my report, and I'm open to any questions. Perfect. I'll bring it back to the board. It's advised from Joe. Thank you, Chair Bone. Thank you, Tom, for your presentation. And I saw this at Humboldt County Association of Governments the other night as well. Yeah, we hear a lot we have for years about Sunday service and express service between McKinleyville, Arcata, Eureka. I know there's going to be some microtransit starting up in McKinleyville in the not-too-distant future. I want to thank the Coalition for Responsible Transportation Priorities for helping kind of help move that process forward as well as you and your staff and HTA in looking at that for McKinleyville. It's so sprawled out that it doesn't really work to have transit, but microtransit. Express routes between McKinleyville, Arcata, Eureka.


11:02 a.m.

would be a great benefit to to McKinville. Yeah, the Willow Creek service has been fantastic. I want to thank Klamath Trinity Net. You know, they kept it going as a nonprofit for years, working with HTA. The pandemic really put an end to that, but it was really HTA and the tribes that stepped up. They're bringing people in from Wichita and Lower River, as well as Hoopa into Willow Creek. And yeah, the high school students, the families are using that a lot. So really great service there. Last thing is, could you speak a little bit about how the Measure O process is going to work in regards to transit? You know, as a board, we did say that we wanted to allocate some amount of money, not half or anything like that, but significant funding. And so how do you see that process evolving in terms of supporting some of these unmet transportation needs? And so the way we have laid it out in all of our presentations.


11:03 a.m.

There will be an allocation committee set up by the board that would determine annual, hopefully five or ten year allocation plans. Leaning heavily on the unmet transit needs process, the information, we recommended it go through the social service technical advisory committee for HCOG because they deal with transit heavily. But that is a yet to be set up allocation and we are working with the CAO's office to gather stakeholder input at this point in order to come to the board with a recommendation on a committee makeup. Great, thank you for that. Supervisor Ruff. Thank you. I just want to note something that has come up at this board before and as we kind of consider the process moving forward. HCOG's regional transportation plan has some very robust transit targets and so we've talked before about.


11:04 a.m.

How Humboldt Transit Authority has had a lot of success in receiving capital improvement funds, which has been phenomenal. We've been really grateful that state and federal funding has gone to so many capital improvements. And we do currently have funding for operations at the level that we are currently operating. So the systems we currently have in place are funded for, you know, at least the next couple of years. That said, the HCOG goals and the unmet transit needs process really surface some other needs for transit. So if we are to increase ridership and meet some of these goals, that will inherently require more operational funding. And so that's where I think this, you know, need for additional funds comes in. So I think I just wanted to clarify that point and note that, you know, we're nearing 500,000 riders.


11:05 a.m.

year. At one point we were upwards of 600,000 riders a year, but that's actually a very incredible recovery. And a lot of other transit providers have not seen quite that level of recovery. So I want to applaud Humboldt Transit Authority staff and, you know, drivers and mechanics and all of those who make that happen. And, you know, express appreciation to voters in supporting Measure O, which will, you know, have a portion of support for transit and will be really helpful in meeting those transportation goals. All right. Yeah, I too am excited because I don't remember this board. I know I talked to HTA and they say they're pretty well funded, and then they got $18 million. And are we spending our whole half percent that we get from the state? Or are we, because I noticed they have leftover money. They can't go to roads with that. That's all you said. So are they spending all that now? We've had a


11:06 a.m.

Basically a one-time windfall, I think, last year. That was a one time that went to roads. But for several years now, the vast majority of all of this money is going, of the county share, has been going to transit with a small cutoff for parks. Okay. And I agree. Transit's very important. We need to do our transit. But if we're meeting most of our unmet transit needs, but then we're going to go out, and I don't mean this in a negative way, in over 12 years, I have never got, well, I did get two phone calls about unmet transit needs. I average five to ten phone calls a week about roads. So until we get these roads fixed, which was the main promise behind Measure O, and I will stand behind that because I don't remember all these board meetings where we said, otherwise, I'm going to stick to getting the work done that needs to be done on the roads because that's where I'm having my issues. I'm not. Seeing bus service, you know.


11:07 a.m.

In the places that a lot of my areas I serve and the ones that have, have been. Now with this $18 million being able to put these people on, you know, get more, utilize it more often. I look forward to that. But I donated to Measure O, I supported Measure O, and it was for roads for my 20%. I'll open it to public comment. Hi, my name is Joanne McGarry. I am a car-free resident of Humboldt County on purpose for cost, some reasons, and also truly for climate change. I am an early adopter of the future way we're going to need to get around and it won't be in individual vehicles whether they're fossil-fueled or


11:08 a.m.

electric and I could talk longer than three minutes on this topic and I did share some input at previous meetings about this. So I'm going to target you again Supervisor Bone about what I discover and what is helpful for me in unmet needs. I want to participate in a lot of things out in your district. Ferndale, the Humboldt County Fair, can't get there. You spent a lot of money for the bleachers for the horse racing a few years ago to fix those up. I can't sit in them because I can't get on a bus to get to the county fair. I was cast in a play at the Ferndale Rep. I decided not to do it because the transportation was difficult. I live in Arcata. I wanted to go to Scotia. on Saturday night to an event, and I took the Willow Creek bus to the emergency preparedness class during the...


11:09 a.m.

day at Blue Lake actually missed the first couple of hours because the bus schedule was such. And then when I got home, I was saying, maybe I'll hop on the last bus to Scotia in hopes I could get back with a ride from somebody that was going. But there were no buses to Scotia, and I could have taken a bus to Scotia and participated in that event. So I could talk about a lot of things, but I want to go to Jersey Scoops in Lolita, and the buses don't go there. As often. So I have to spend half a day getting an ice cream cone at Jersey Scoops in Lolita because there are not enough buses going to and fro. I've been to a Redwood Trail workshop in Fortuna. I took the bus to in the rain. I had to walk a distance to get to the location where that was happening. I guess I want to say that there's a lot of unmet needs, and there's a lot of need for, in a climate-changing world, for us to stop driving.


11:10 a.m.

So many cars that are actually harming the roads. If we had more people in fewer vehicles getting to the places where people want to go and where people want them to go, organizations, governments, you know, we can do this. But I applaud that they're having this public hearing and roads are important, but public transportation to everywhere in our county for people like me who want to participate in a lot of things throughout the county. We need to do better. Thank you very much. There is none on Zoom. Okay. Seeing that, anything else from the board? All right. Do we have a motion? I'll move to receive the comments.


11:11 a.m.

And forward them to HCOG. Second. Moved and seconded. Supervisor Madrone. Yes. Supervisor Arroyo. Yes. Chair Bone. Yes. Supervisor Bushnell. Yes. Supervisor Wilson. Yes. Motion carries 5-0. Thank you. And with that, we will adjourn the closed session as soon as county council reads it in. I will have a strict five-minute break because we do have council in waiting and in the chambers. Chair, 10 minutes. I don't even know why I say anything. Thank you, Chair Bone. It is the intention of the board to meet in closed session, pursuant to California Government Code Section 54956.9.


11:12 a.m.

9d1 in order to discuss existing litigation in the cases of OB versus County of Humboldt Humboldt County Superior Court case number CV 2200 748 a K versus County of Humboldt Humboldt County Superior Court case number CV 2 2 0 0 8 8 2 JK versus County of Humboldt Humboldt County Superior Court case number CV 2 2 0 1 6 2 1 MR versus Humboldt County Humboldt County Superior Court case number CV to 20 1622 Lindsay idler versus County of Humboldt Humboldt County Superior Court case number CV ii ii 6 7 5 and Bea versus County of Humboldt Humboldt County Superior Court case number CV 4 0 2 0 2 9


11:13 a.m.

And the Potter Valley Hydroelectric Project, Federal Energy Regulatory Commission Project Number 77-285. It is also the intention of the Board to meet in closed session pursuant to California Government Code Section 54956.9D4 in order to discuss the initiation of litigation in one potential case. Is there any public comment on anything we're going to discuss? I have someone on Zoom. Caller 7718, I'm going to unmute you and you have three minutes. In Sawasky there's a disturbing trend towards more and more litigation being filed against Humboldt County. Are you ending up in court prior to settlement? I concur a lot of it's a problem with the lawyers we have, some which I call shakedown lawyers who are not...


11:14 a.m.

I strongly wish that those lawyers would make their best effort to settle these things out with you in a good manner. So this is a message to the lawyers out there. Their reputation is greatly diminished when they're not willing to work with the county in settlement. On the other hand, I hope the county is using competent in-house staff to try and pre-settle these things. Historically, I understand under a prior administration, these things were frequently settled out by the CAO. And county councilmen, we return to that, thereby saving the county a lot of money. I think there are, what, six court cases being discussed, but you're filing one additional one here, potentially filing a case to litigate yourself. So I highly recommend that we do whatever we can. We're bleeding out on these things and don't know how to fix it, but I think it takes a cooperation between the community to pressure the shakedown lawyers to cease and desist. Maybe they need to be countersued. There's nothing better. There's nothing better than seeing the law. There's nothing better than seeing the law. There's nothing better than seeing the lawyer. There's nothing better than seeing the lawyer.


11:15 a.m.

stressed out because he finds out what it's like to be sued and the stress that puts people under. So hopefully you can make that happen. Thank you for your opportunity to speak. I appreciate your input. Seeing no one else, we will go into closed session at 1125. Thank you.


2:14 p.m.

you you I see five of them. That's kind of why I was hoping for county council. I'll let the CAO report out.


2:15 p.m.

Oh, there he is. It's really good, but I don't want to eat it. Everybody like their cookie? All right. Very good. Give hands for the cookie or the cookie maker. There you go. Please report out. Thank you, Chair Bone. There was no reportable action taken with regard to items G3 through G10. Certainly glad we waited for that. All right. It looks like we're going to go to DEI. Human Resources, please. So, thank you, Board. Director of Human Resources.


2:16 p.m.

Michael Hannon. So unfortunately, the consultant that we're going to have come today via Zoom, he's had an emergency in his family. He's not going to be able to be here. So we're going to actually ask to continue this item to probably a date in January. However, we do have a number of folks here in the crowd who came to make comment. And so I will take public comment on this item. Perfect. Good afternoon, members of the board, county staff, and co-workers. My name is Ariel Hilton Bridges, and I'm here on behalf of the Queer Affinity Group. I joined the Queer Affinity Group in February of 2023. When the group first started, the chair at the time set the groundwork for this group to be organized and impactful. We have a meeting once a month, an agenda...


2:17 p.m.

out the week before the meeting and we try to use our time to make a positive impact for our co-workers. We value the thoughts and perspectives of all in the group and utilize a majority vote for new officers and any initiatives that the group takes. I volunteered and was voted in as the recorder at my first meeting. As the recorder I would send out minutes and to all members of the group so that those who are not able to attend would still be able to see the progress that we had made. In August of 2023 the chair of the time stepped down and asked me to take over and I have been the chair of this group for a year and four months now and I am so proud to continue to lead a group of such kind understanding and capable individuals. This group has accomplished quite a bit since its inception. We helped public health with their gender identity and sexual orientation survey questions. We have hosted two learning corners. The U.S.


2:18 p.m.

queer history and demystifying the acronym. We drafted and composed a letter sent to department heads about extending the telework policy utilizing survey results from the Latinx queer and indigenous peoples affinity group and we have compiled community resources and set up a SharePoint site to provide easy access to resources for employees. We have hosted guests at our meetings such as staff from economic development and public health, our AFSCME union representative Drew Redden, the director of human resources Zach O'Hannon, the racial and cultural equity manager Neftali Miller Rubio, and the deputy director of DHHS employee services Paige Plummer. All this to say that folks in this group are willing to put in the time and effort to make the county a more accepting and inviting work place to work. We know that there's still a lot of work to be done to achieve that and we will be here to do


2:19 p.m.

it. I enjoy and value hearing from my co-workers across all areas of the county. This group makes me want to be the best person that I can be. They encourage me to strive for policy updates and changes that will benefit everyone who works for the county, not just those in our group. Being the chair has helped push me out of my comfort zone and encouraged me to be a more involved community member. I am so thankful that these groups exist and I hope that they can continue to grow and flourish. Thank you. Thank you very much. Good job. Hello there, my name is Christopher Musgrave. I'm the chair for the neurodiversity affinity group and I guess I would say my biggest job is to provide this explanation for what we are.


2:20 p.m.

I guess to say, I don't know, it's tricky to not fall into a lot of the clinical stuff that sort of turns people off this stuff. But it's, you know, it's people that live with conditions that affect how they see the world, how they feel, how they manage their emotions. And it's people that, and it's sort of an emerging movement to try to live more authentically with that, not try to, just try to hide that, try to not be normal. And it's really been a fascinating ride for me. I didn't really identify with any condition for a long time. Something that I just sort of masked, as we say. And yeah, so it's an effort to try to...


2:21 p.m.

you know, have dignity and safety at work with having this identity. I would say, no, I'm very thankful for the amount of support, the amount of leeway that we've been getting. We've been giving, like, you know, time to meet and talk about our issues and sort of develop different ways we might better represent ourselves and, you know, advocate more for ourselves, how we, how work can be accommodated for different types of conditions and sort of, you know, exploring what's worked well at the county and what can do better. Yeah, so I know I really do appreciate the continuing support and to, you know, let us figure out what we need to do. Thank you, guys. Thank you very much. Yep. Hello, good afternoon.


2:22 p.m.

Tony Stenhouse, I'm a chairman for the Indigenous Peoples Affinity Group. I didn't write anything down this time around because I'm less nervous. And I just wanted to say I really appreciate you guys giving us a safe place to go talk to with our fellow peers. It really does mean a lot. When we tried to raise awareness on misandembered Indigenous people, it became somewhat political. Someone made some nasty comments, and we were backed by you guys and Natalie. So thank you for hearing us out, hearing our voices, looking at us when we talk to you, stuff like that. I wanted to acknowledge the land we're on. We're on We Are Tribes land. Thank you so much, though, for letting us speak, letting us meet, and giving us two hours just as members and three hours as chairman, co-chairman, and secretary. These groups, if you heard us talk recently, these groups mean a lot to us as the Cherry People and society. So I can't thank you enough.


2:23 p.m.

I won't keep saying it, but I think you guys got the point. But again, I just wanted to acknowledge Lameron. I wanted to see the presentation to kind of have more of an idea if we're going to be able to keep these groups, because that is somewhat of a fear that we have coming up with the next administration. And if you guys could address that somewhat, just let us know if this is something we continue to have. I didn't see anything in writing that this is going to be taken away, so I'm totally just jumping the gun. But we appreciate you guys so much. Thank you. Tony, just so you know, this is the next administration as far as the county goes. All right. They keep putting us on this federal level, not just. Anyway. Is there anybody else? Okay, that will bring back the public comment. I'll make a motion that we continue this to sometime in January. Do you want to date? I'll make a motion that we continue this to sometime in January. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.


2:24 p.m.

We're going to need to work with the consultant to figure out the date, so sometime in January. I'll just make a motion that we continue this into the future. I'll second that, and I did want to comment on the Latina Affinity Group, Latinx Affinity Group, which I am delighted to be a part of. I don't see anyone from that affinity group here today, but it's been really lovely for me, too, to have that space to connect with other Latinx community members. Sometimes I feel a little bit lonely for people that have some similar cultural traditions or challenges, or even challenges in our personal or family lives. Around. You know, some shared aspects of culture, and so I found it really valuable, and I, too, echo what folks here said, that it's a valuable space, and I think it will be.


2:25 p.m.

continue to be so, so I just wanted to share those thoughts as well. Great, thank you. With that, Supervisor Majoran. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I know, you know, we hear a lot of thanks for what we do, but frankly, what you all do gives us the courage to be more open-minded and more inclusive. So thank you for what you do to help us. Appreciate it. All right. Thank you to a date later to be determined. Great job, Dr. Clark. Again, you were riveting. You had us on every word, baby. Supervisor Wilson. I still have to take everyone's. Yeah, go ahead. Supervisor Arroyo.


2:26 p.m.

Yes. Supervisor Madrone? Yes. Supervisor Wilson? Yes. Chair Bone? Yep. Supervisor Bushnell? Yes. Intermodular controller or? If we could move on to the first quarter budget report for fiscal year 24-25. That'll work for me. Before you today is Jessica Maciel, Deputy County Administrative Officer, who will give you an update on where we ended fiscal year 23-24, provide some projections for the ending of the current fiscal year 24-25, and some initial projections for the budget conditions beginning for fiscal year 25-26. And with that, Jessica has a presentation. If you could.


2:27 p.m.

load that for her and she will take it away. Thank you CAO Hayes. Organized here. Thank you Kaylee. Good afternoon Chair Bone and members of the board. I'm Jessica Maciel, Deputy County Administrative Officer. I am before your board to present the first quarter budget report which covers as CAO Hayes said FY fiscal year 23-24 estimated ending fund balances. We'll give a brief update on first quarter of fiscal year 24-25 including a number of budget adjustments and recommendations for your board's consideration as well as a quick initial projection of the budget outlook for fiscal year 25-26. To start with fiscal year... 23-24 review of the general fund.


2:28 p.m.

I want to start off by saying thank you to the Auditor-Controller's Office. They've made great progress in catching up the county financials. That said, they are still in the process of the fiscal year 22-23 audit and closing fiscal year 23-24. We believe these numbers are reliable. However, there are still transactions that may be posted that will impact fund balance. At the time of the fiscal year 24-25 proposed budget, the year-end fund balance for 23-24 was projected to be $38.6 million. The fiscal year 22-23 fund balance had since been updated and ended at $38.3 million, which was $3. $305,964 less than anticipated. In addition, the general...


2:29 p.m.

Fund was anticipated to use 9.1 million in fund balance in fiscal year 23-24 at the time of the proposed budget. It is now estimated that the general fund will increase fund balance rather than use fund balance by $4.5 million, which is a $13.2 million increase in fund balance from what was anticipated at the proposed budget. Given this, the estimated ending fund balance for 23-24 for the general fund is $42.8 million. The positive financial performance can be attributed to a number of increases, which are detailed on the table on the slide and include one-time revenues such as the cost plan, interest, prior year revenue, a one-time backlog of canceled checks, that the auditor's office caught up on, cannabis excise taxes, and capital projects.


2:30 p.m.

prior year revenue as the capital projects budget used to exist in the general fund. Additionally, it includes expenditure savings in Measure Z and contingencies and significant efforts by departments to contain spending. The balance includes, the balance of $42.8 million includes $6.8 million in Measure Z funds. In more detail, the estimated ending fund balance of $42.8 million includes $129,641 being carried forward to 24-25 in regular general fund expenditures. And of the $6.8 million in Measure Z funds, nearly $1 million of the Measure Z funds are carried forward for projects in 22-23 and 23-24, including a public works chip seal and a public works chip seal.


2:31 p.m.

Road repairs project carry forward for the Humboldt Fire Chiefs and $200,000 for the public defender. The remaining Measure Z balance of $5.8 million is as a result of $600,000 in county expenditure savings in fiscal year 23-24 and $233,000 in unspent outside agency funds. The remaining funds are from prior years and were allocated in the fiscal year 2024-25 Measure Z process to one-time applications. As you recall, there was around $4 million available to the committee to allocate in the 2024-25 process. With these considerations, this leaves $35.9 million of general fund balance to fund fiscal year 2024-25 and $3.9 million of general fund balance to fund fiscal year 2024-25. and future fiscal years.


2:32 p.m.

I'm going to touch quickly on some of the other funds of note. Recently, I've been trying to focus a little bit more on our other funds than just focusing on the general fund, and that's because we have some negative fund balances in other funds. Health and Human Services funds ended 23-24 with a combined total of negative $16.3 million, which is an increase in the negative balance of $10 million. This negative balance impacts the general fund through interest, losing $664,863 in interest for the general fund. DHHS has been working to implement cost reductions through the hiring freeze that your board implemented, the Voluntary Separation Incentive Program, expenditure cuts, and changes to the department's interdepartmental cost. DHHS has been working to implement cost reductions through the hiring freeze that your board implemented,


2:33 p.m.

anticipates through these strategies, they will be able to return their funds to the positive by fiscal year 28-29. The Economic Development Fund, as noted in previous staff reports, we anticipate a future negative fund balance in the Economic Development Fund. That has not happened yet. It ended with a balance of $1.1 million, an increase of $354,138 over the prior year. This increase was due to receiving Project Trellis funds in the prior year that needed to be distributed to applicants in fiscal year 24-25. That has since been done. Additionally, staff found that the general fund contributions approved by the board in 2013 were not in the fiscal year 24-25. For the redevelopment dissolution, we're being under-calculated.


2:34 p.m.

The lack of administration funding for Headwaters. We recommend your board consider making a correction for those allocations since that time in the amount of $571,714 to resolve a Headwaters admin negative fund balance issue. The next fund is the Road Fund, which ended with negative $7.4 million, a very slight increase in the negative fund balance of $36,156. Long-term receivables in the amount of $3 million for fiscal year 23-24 were reported, which will reduce the negative fund balance. Additionally, as you all know, disaster safety. Headwaters have decimated roads ability to maintain roads in the county and the passage of Measure O will allow them to begin to complete a backlog of road maintenance. The North Coast.


2:35 p.m.

Resource Partnership Fund, I have not touched on much in the past. However, it did end with a negative fund balance of $584,024, an increase in the negative fund balance of $335,491 from the prior year. This is all accounted for in long-term receivables, and once those are received, it should be back in the positive. The library I'll just quickly touch on, they ended with $1.1 million, a decrease of $47,895. This is notable because this was better than their budget picture, which anticipated utilizing nearly $800,000 in fund balance. The Aviation Fund, I also have not touched on the Capital Projects Aviation Fund in working with the Auditor-Controller. We've been bringing this one forward. The Capital Projects Aviation Fund.


2:36 p.m.

fund is negative 4.9 million. When you net that with the aviation operating fund, it's an overall negative 3.9 million. This is as a result of delayed reimbursements and project closeout timelines with the FAA. Aviation's operating fund has been on the decline since COVID-19 and aviation is exploring opportunities for revenue generation. And finally, the internal service funds ended with a total 22 million, an increase of 2.8 million over the prior year. There's one negative fund, that is the purchasing fund, and that was due to increases in cost plan charges that will be corrected by the end of fiscal year 24-25. On to a brief update on fiscal year 25 and a review of the fiscal year. So, we're going to go ahead and get started with the fiscal year 25 and a review of the fiscal year 25. So, we're going to go ahead and get started with the fiscal year 25 and a review of the recommendations in your staff report.


2:37 p.m.

We adopted the county's fiscal year 24-25 budget on June 25th with a $15.1 million structural budget deficit. Your board directed cost-saving measures including a VSIP program, voluntary furloughs, and a hiring freeze for the general fund, and in funds with negative fund balances. The fiscal year 24-25 VSIP program has had four county employees receive a total of $72,000, and the only department that ended up participating was DHHS. The estimated savings for fiscal year 24-25 is $243,869, and overall through fiscal year 26-27, it's estimated the savings will be more than $1,000. The voluntary furlough program has had 27 participants submit their paperwork.


2:38 p.m.

to the CAO's office. While this is a helpful saving mechanism, the savings are really minimal and don't make a material impact on fund balance. The hiring freeze has been helpful to DHHS, which estimates as much as $6.6 million in savings by holding positions vacant after staff vacate them. All requests for exception to the hiring freeze have been approved, and so it is unlikely that there will be significant savings in the general fund. Staff discovered two, moving on to what is recommendations three and four, staff discovered two departments with errors in their position allocations, the library and the public defender. The library's position was an administrative error. In the adoption of the budget, the public defender reallocated filled budget. The public defender reallocated filled positions, which does not comply with county policy, and this corrects that action.


2:39 p.m.

And the next recommendation is to approve a general fund contribution to the deferred maintenance fund in the amount of just under $1.4 million. Due to the one-time nature of the additional fund balance in the general fund, staff recommend your board consider making up for two years of lack of contributions to the deferred maintenance fund. So that amount would be the just under $1.4 million. Additionally, this is the next recommendation, which is recommendation six. Staff recommend that your board consider a contribution to the general reserve. The general reserve policy sets a target funding level of 10%, a minimum target funding level of 10% of general fund expenditures. A contribution of $3 million will make progress towards that funding target, bringing the balance to $13.6 million or 8.1%.


2:40 p.m.

of general fund expenditures while maintaining some fund balance in the general fund to fund future years. This is the estimated general fund projection. This assumes that your board would approve the recommendations in the staff report. Additionally, it assumes that the entire adopted budget structural deficit would be used. I will say that is unlikely. There will probably be savings in the structural deficit just from vacancies that weren't anticipated and all of that. So if that all came to fruition, we would be looking at just under $16 million in available general fund balance to fund fiscal year 25-26. Thank you.


2:41 p.m.

The next steps looking forward, as we move forward into the mid-year process, which we kicked off last week, I want to remind departments again that it's very important that they are realistic when submitting their projected year-end estimates to our office. We will be carefully reviewing submissions to ensure we receive representative data in order to provide recommendations to your board in February for the fiscal year 25-26 budget development. Further, while these fund balances are an improvement from what was anticipated at the proposed budget, it's critical that we proceed with caution as one-time funds, such as fund balance, do not resolve the structural budget deficit. It's important that we work to develop a budget that balances ongoing expenditures with ongoing revenues. With that, I'm available for questions. Thank you. Nice job. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.


2:42 p.m.

Supervisor Rowe? You read my mind, Supervisor Bowen. Well, sure, I would like to say something. I'm pleased, of course, that the outlook is better than we initially projected, and I think you already indicated that, in part, that's the hard work of folks to bring down expenses. And unsurprisingly, I think there's some interest in us funding other things. Or potentially reallocating funds. And I just want to note that this still means that we have a structural deficit that remains due to the great number of additional general fund requests that we receive each budget cycle. And so while that reduction in fund balance wasn't as severe as anticipated, we still do project that, right? That in the coming years, we will run out of fund balance.


2:43 p.m.

Should we not? Could you elaborate a little bit about what that picture looks like? I know you talked about it, but just to put a finer point on it. Yeah, for sure. So on the projection that I showed, it estimates approximately $15.9 million to fund fiscal year 25-26. To put that in perspective, we would need nearly all of that if the deficit stayed at the level of fiscal year 24-25. Additionally, a consideration is that from an audit perspective and from the auditor's perspective, all general funds are lumped together. So if our other general funds continue to maintain negative fund balances, that could eventually impact our ability to use the general funds fund balance. And as we saw, several of those were one-time funds, essentially. Like they canceled checks. That's not something that's going to be reflected.


2:44 p.m.

occurring. Correct. All of the of the 13.2 million only 2 million of it is anticipated to be ongoing. Okay. Thank you. Supervisor McJone. Thanks for all your hard work and the good news and we just got to keep our belts tight and keep forging forward and doing the best we can but thank you. Supervisor Bushnell. Thank you. Thank you for the report. I was hoping you could email that to me and maybe the board wants it as well. The presentation. Yep. Yeah I would like that and I echo what Supervisor Arroyo says that you know although it looks healthy it's it's really not and if so we use 15 point something million this year and so that would leave less than a million dollars in that in that pot and that's pretty scary. You're next. Thanks. Mine's the same. Thanks.


2:45 p.m.

sort of a granular question it's around the the housing trust fund so i just there's two points on this i guess one is um there was money from from arpa and then but that's not in existence anymore so that's is that what that reduction in the housing trust fund is that what that's about oh the budget adjustment for the housing trust fund yeah yeah we had the um 1.5 million allocated to the housing trust fund by your board originally we had anticipated needing to move that to the general fund and then use it out of the general fund okay um that's no longer necessary so this is just a budget adjustment so that we can spend those funds directly out of the arpa fund okay great yeah sorry because it was in two sort of bullet points here yeah it's because um we have to make the adjustment in the general fund and also in the arpa fund all right well this is why i'm not an accountant you


2:46 p.m.

Thank you. I just wanted to see who was going to read it. I really want to thank all you and the staff because I know it's been, I know you can't pay for things when you don't have the money. And I know you guys have been doing everything possible and screaming hit the brakes all the way through the whole organization. I think the whole organization is hearing that. We don't like to hear it. There's going to be answers to questions and requests that people aren't going to like for a little bit. This happens every 12 to 16 years. We get a couple years like this. But the thing is we're resilient. We come out of it and we do it because of you people, you folks putting these numbers together that allow us to do that. So looking for brighter days down the road, but thank you guys for all you do. So what is your Bushnell? Thanks. Soon to be chair. Not that that's any.


2:47 p.m.

I do want to recognize that the departments really got on board, and we have a better look right now because departments did take it serious and really worked with the CAO's office to come, like with DHHS, not hiring and with the hiring freeze. And I know our board initiated that, and that came through the message from the CAO's office. And I think the message is to the whole organization, as Supervisor Bowen just said, it's going to be rocky for a few years, but hopefully down the road we can get back to some normalcy. And I just really want to say to the employees, I know they're working extra hard and understaffed, all of them, and taking the Fridays to try to catch up on their work and not having the public come in. And then the public yelling at you, too, because you're not there on Fridays, you don't answer your phone, and social media is not anybody's friend. I see those comments, but it is necessary, I think, for...


2:48 p.m.

Staff to just really have a breather from answering the front door if I may say and allowing you know them to catch up on their work and so I really appreciate all of the employees and the department heads that have taken it serious and the CAO who you know we came in over budget over budget and to her saying no we can't do this and did it anyways and so it doesn't look that rosy going into the next fiscal year and hopefully you know hopefully we'll be able to reduce again and not have to use that fund balance so and thanks for the presentation it was very clear is there any public comment on this item you guys just came in to see if we're gonna do mass layoffs didn't you again a big thank you goes to everybody out in the audience that works for the county too I know you've all had to make a difference I know you've all had to make a difference


2:49 p.m.

sacrifices and that's a big deal with that i would entertain a motion i'll make a motion to accept the presentation there's more to it i guess staff recommendations second yeah there's a bunch of them it's been moved and seconded Supervisor Bushnell? Yes. Supervisor Madrone? Yes. Supervisor Arroyo? Yes. Chair Bone? Yep. Supervisor Wilson? Yes. Motion carries 5-0. Thank you all. Chair Bone, would you like me to kick off the last item? Sure. Okay.


2:50 p.m.

Your board has received the resignation of auditor-controller Cheryl Dillingham, effective January 31st. And so before your board today is consideration to accept that resignation. I'm not sure you have an option. It would be funny if you said no. We've tried that before. It doesn't work. But I was just wondering why it had to be so long. The resignation letter had to be so long. And also to consider an interim appointment. And Ms. Dillingham has also included her recommendation to your board to appoint deputy auditor-controller Michael Evenson. And while I have the microphone, I just want to take an opportunity to continue to show gratitude to Cheryl. Who came out of retirement to serve.


2:51 p.m.

of our community and our organization, and she has really done a phenomenal job getting us caught back up. This is why Jessica can present to you the budget presentation that she just did. And Cheryl and Michael together have developed a very competent and capable team in the Auditor-Controller's office. So while we're very, very sad to see Cheryl go, I think we can speak on behalf of the whole CAO's office that we have no concerns in their ability to continue in Cheryl's stead in holding us up and keeping us chugging right along in the same speed that they have been. Cheryl, I think we're going to have you up here because you love this. I know. No, I mean, I think you stepped up at a time, and I think exactly what we need to do.


2:52 p.m.

would have uh i i think i think what everybody realizes and i think um what we went through in the time you've taken to fully aware that we're not out of the situation that was created for us but you've got us on a path that the state isn't mad as mad at us anymore and we can actually make decipherable financial decisions and reports so i i can't say thank you enough um i have a lot better relationship with our current auditor controller than i had with the last one i appreciated that too thank you so i also would like to say thank you i know this is not something you really wanted to do and um really uh uh valued the county and really came forward and um the i know the um election process and


2:53 p.m.

Campaigning is difficult and not any fun, but I appreciate all that you've done since you've been here and really helped navigate that team into a better place and really straightened our books out if I could say books and I hope retirement second time around is what you want it to be and I think your team is going to miss you and and the county organization as a whole is really going to miss you And so thank you for being willing when you were and good luck in your next adventure To Vajra Thank You Cheryl I echo all that and it's been very helpful to work with you and your team and I appreciate the recommendation you've put forward and one thing I happen to know about your recommendee is He has the voice of an angel He can sing some fantastic light opera


2:54 p.m.

addition to other talents so um very cool uh i i look forward to to perhaps hearing you sing again yes uh feel free to come up in and uh and do an acapella performance for us if you like supervisor wilson yeah big thanks for uh stepping up and bringing it home really appreciate it um i'm looking forward to you introducing your recommendation for your replacement here in a minute so there you go thank you cheryl and welcome michael oh i want to hear the pitch give me the pitch you can wait to vote but well i think balance the budget that's sweet music and and michael got two years of tutorship that


2:55 p.m.

I think is invaluable and how to run an office and he'll put his own spin on it. But I think what he learned and what I've heard, what he's learned from Cheryl is invaluable. That is just amazing what we were able to do with that department. So I'll send it over to you. Well, as you all know, I don't like to do public speaking and it hasn't gotten easier. I'd like to thank all the departments, the county administrative office and Michael, because we wouldn't have been able to do what we've done without the assistance of all of those folks. Michael came in and one of the things I did was say, well, we have this financial transactions report. It needs to be done next week or we're going to have like a problem with the state. Please do it. And he just did it. He never asked me for any assistance. It was kind of a test to see if he could figure out how to do stuff on his own. And he passed with flying colors. And.


2:56 p.m.

He's done the financial transactions report every year since and assisted new staff in learning how to do it. That was one of the items on the settlement agreement that we had with the state. So the office is set up, ready to go. I believe that everybody has been trained. I am going to be available to work part-time extra help for maybe even some other places in the county. I just don't want to work full-time. So I think Michael has done a great job. I think he's got great relationships with the staff and the office. I think he's worked well with the departments. And I feel that the county's changed a lot in the 30-plus years that I've worked for it. And it's time for a younger, newer generation to take it forward from here. So that's why I'm recommending him. Thank you. 25.


2:57 p.m.

words was the length of her resignation letter too which i was pretty sure it was going to be two i quit i have to say i believe is almost exactly verbatim what the um joe mellitz was i got a feeling there might be some public comment on this i know regina's house happy no not that she's resigning no not that she's resigning that we had her in the first place yes my name is regina fuller i am the deputy director of financial support services for the sheriff's office and truly echo what you have all said cheryl has been so amazing i honestly do not believe i'd still be at the county had she not come on board to really help turn things around so just a huge thanks to her and truly like she said you know it has taken a team she's done a great job bringing michael on board and her entire team the transparency the transparency and the transparency of the work that she's done and i think that's what i'm the transparency of the work that she's done and i think that's what i'm


2:58 p.m.

the collaboration. Also, Michael has a very unique ability to understand technology and communicate the technology needs with operational needs. You don't find that very often. I think I know one other person that I've worked with that has been really good at that. So I'm looking forward to what Michael will be able to do from a technology perspective to make things even more efficient as we move forward. And truly the whole staff there, I am just very grateful for them. We love working with them and we're looking forward to the future. So again, Cheryl, if you're serious about extra help, my office needs it. We need help. So we'll hire you if the AC doesn't. Corrections? Yeah. What's that? Corrections? No, I'm not going to put on corrections. I'm talking the business office. We need her accounting expertise. So we're just really short-staffed right now. So I'll pitch that right now. Recruitment happening in the sheriff's office. So truly, thank you. Thank you, Cheryl, Michael, team. And we're very excited.


2:59 p.m.

for our future. So thank you. Tom Mattson, Director of Public Works. I too am here to thank Cheryl. I think one of my worst days was when I forwarded you all the note from Caltrans that said we could no longer get grants because our audits were behind. I'm thankful for Cheryl for stepping in, for coming back, for giving back to the county. We didn't give to her, she gave back to us. I want to thank her for that. Since you haven't voted yet and using airplane technology, I want to pre-board Michael to the department head airplane. I thought we took aviation away from you. Sean Quincy, Deputy CAO. This is, I've worked with Cheryl my entire career here at the county, so almost 13 years. I've had to say goodbye to her once for her leaving our office.


3 p.m.

office. I'm having to say goodbye to her again, partially. I'm thankful that she's going to be coming back as extra help, but in this latest round that she came and served for the community, you know, she really put on her cape and came back and helped us out. She was uniquely qualified for the position. We needed it, and she just provided a desperately needed public service to the community, to the organization. So I can't thank you enough, Cheryl, for all the years of service, even though I wasn't here for even half of it, but you've been an institution for the County of Humboldt. Thank you very much, and looking forward to working with Michael as he steps, hopefully, into this new role. Thank you. Step up, Luciano. I don't have any music prepared. I'm sorry. Hang on. What do you want? End of God of DeVita?


3:01 p.m.

I also want to echo everybody in thanking Cheryl for coming back. She really shouldered a major burden, did something she didn't have to do for the entire community, and it benefited the community. I think we all, everybody in Humboldt County owes Cheryl a huge debt of gratitude. I'm also very proud of what we have accomplished as a team in the Auditor-Controller's Office. It's not just me and Cheryl. It's everybody in that team, all, I think we're up to 18 staff now, all 18 of us working diligently every single day to get the county's financial record keeping up to date, to processing payroll timely. There hasn't been any major payroll debacles in a few years. Everything has been smooth sailing to getting things caught up. Yeah, yeah, yeah, I know. Everything's smoother sailing than it was. There's still some things we're working on. You don't catch everything up overnight. But the...


3:02 p.m.

The impacts of the things that we're behind on are getting smaller and smaller by the day and I am nothing but proud of the staff in the office, the team in the office for accomplishing that. The thing I'm probably most proud of, Regina touched on it, Cheryl touched on it, is how well we communicate with departments, with the other community partners such as special districts. People reach out to us now. They communicate with us. They ask us questions. We answer them. Everything is collaborative. We work toward solving problems, not just decreeing what to do and it has been my pleasure to help build that environment and I would love to continue doing it moving forward. Thank you. You've done a great job, Michael. I appreciate it and I know you've worked with Cheryl and the staff. Thank you. I'm glad to make this happen too and it has made a difference.


3:03 p.m.

In the great words of Ryan Sundberg, if I don't hear any complaints, then you're doing a good job. And I have not had a vendor call me in over two years asking for payment. And that's my biggest thing, is I started to get numerous vendor calls. And one that had done business with us for over 100 years, and he says, I don't remember. Nobody here ever remembers that. And we don't hear it anymore, so thank you very much. So, that's awesome. I'm happy to make a motion if we're done with public comment. I have someone, too. All right. Okay. Caller 9651, I'm going to unmute you, and you have three minutes. It said I'm unmuted. That's probably a bad idea. This is Greg Foster over at Revit Region Economic Development Commission.


3:04 p.m.

And I just want to say thank you, Cheryl. I remember talking to you as you were getting ready to do your announcement downstairs and you did not want to run for anything, but you were absolutely committed to fixing the audit controller's office and you did that without ego. You did that with a clear goal in mind. And for us at REDEC, it's been a pleasure to work with you and your staff and we can get our money out right away. We get our reports. We no longer have to footnote our audits. So I just want to say good job. Enjoy your retirement, at least partial retirement, because I hope that people will be able to rely on you to keep helping out. That's all I have to say. Thank you. Thanks, Greg. And I think we have a whole time. Oh, special guest old timer from Kansas on the phone. Yes, indeed, Mr. Chair.


3:05 p.m.

Good afternoon to the commission. I am not Sean Quincy as it says on the screen. My name is Philip Smith-Haines and I am a former co-worker of Cheryl's and Sean conspired to get me on today to congratulate her on her re-retirement and let her know that if she can't find extra help work in Humboldt County, we have to get her back. We have plenty of it in the Midwest. I'm just happy to note that Cheryl and I coordinated our outfits today. Blue is the color of the day. She couldn't quite be a snowflake though. Is that what you're trying to say to me, Phil? Philip Smith-Haines, always great to see you. Please. I'm sorry. I missed the in-person people comment. On behalf of Connie Beck, Director Beck, I wanted to


3:06 p.m.

I do thank Cheryl and Michael and all of the auditor controller staff for their wonderful partnership with our finance services staff and the massive amount of work that it's taken over the last couple years. So thank you, Cheryl. Connie wanted me to publicly say it for you, even though she knows you hate public speaking. Thank you so, so much. So, the motion. I'm happy to do this and say that I think that the auditor controller's office is like the heart. I've kind of viewed as really pumps the blood, right, to and fro, you know, and manages it in that way for this institution. And I want to associate myself again with everything that was said here today in thanks and anticipation of what's to come.


3:07 p.m.

So with that, I move that we accept the resignation of the current elected auditor-controller, Cheryl Dillingham, effective Friday, January 31st, 2025, and not consider, but appoint an interim auditor-controller effective Saturday, February 1st, 2025, and until a newly elected auditor-controller officially takes the oath of office. I'd like to second that with a question of county council. Can we put off, can we wait until the next election to have dropped the interim, or to elect an auditor-controller and not have a special election? Is that too long or not? It will be until the next general election. Perfect. I wanted that clarified. Thank you. Chair Bonal, did you second it? Yeah, I seconded on that. I just wanted a clarification so we didn't have a special election. It might be. It might be overly persnickety, but would we like.


3:08 p.m.

I'd like to not just consider appointment of an interim auditor, or not just appoint an auditor controller, would we like to specify who it is? Oh. I apologize. It's an interim auditor controller. I'm assuming you mean Michael Evanson. Not Karen Clower, please. Karen, you could do four jobs, right? No, not Karen Clower. Sorry. Michael Evanson is, I think, what he's trying to get. I was looking for the last name. He was trying to think of the name. All I could think of was singing at this moment, so I apologize for that. We now have Luciano Pavarotti. Thank you, Michael. It's been moved and seconded. Supervisor Madrone? Yes. Supervisor Bushnell? Yes. Supervisor Arroyo? Yes. Chair Boehm? Small Christmas present, yes. Supervisor Wilson? Yes.


3:09 p.m.

Yep, yep, yep. Motion carries 5-0. And with that? No. So we're going to get ready to adjourn, but I really would like to say that thank Chair Bone. It's hard to, I haven't done it yet. I'm going to find out next year, but I don't think it's an easy job. And we all have a lot of attitudes up here at times and like to be in control and be the boss. None bigger than mine. So as we end this year and come back in January, I just really want to say thank you to Chair Bone and thanks for the last year of running our meetings and dealing with our attitudes. It's the third time I've done it, and I still haven't got it right. Anyway, it's been a hoot. Thank you, Father Christmas. Yes, we go. All right, you guys. And I speak for the whole board. Merry Christmas to everybody. Enjoy yourselves. Merry Christmas.