Humboldt County Board of Supervisors
Tuesday, June 17, 2025
The agenda


9:01 a.m.

Thank you. Thank you. A, B, and everybody's all ready to go? All right. It is 9.01. We are going to begin this meeting of the Board of Supervisors for Humboldt County on this day, June 17, 2025.


9:02 a.m.

Can we get a roll call, please? Yes. Supervisor Madrone? Present. Supervisor Arroyo? Here. Supervisor Bone? Hey, how you doing? Vice Chair Wilson? Here. All are here, except for Supervisor Bushnell, who's absent. All right. All right, please stand for the salute to the flag, and I'm going to ask Director John Ford to lead us in the salute today. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, to the republic for which it stands, with one nation under God, indivisible, with one nation under God. Thank you, Director Ford. Moving on to modifications to the agenda. Good morning, Supervisor Wilson. There are two modifications today. Item D. Item D. 7 is being...


9:03 a.m.

polled for discussion and just for a point of clarification on item k2 the case number is an inaccurate reference there when we read in closed session prior to going into chambers we will read in that modification thank you all right going to move on to the consent calendar we are going to be removing d7 for you know trailing that for discussion is there any any discussion from the board on items on the consent calendar before i go move to public comment we have one resolution here today it's it's in honor of ronique simpaul and it's for retirement um um is anyone here to receive it and if not


9:04 a.m.

We'll send it with a bow. All right, so we're going to move on. And thank you again for her service. It's always amazing when people have these wonderful and fruitful careers in public service. We need it. All right. Yes, sir, do you have something on this one? Well, I'd like to thank Sabelle and everybody that helps with the fire safe councils. It's nice that the fire safe council at Willow Creek, I'm sure Steve was thinking ahead. But, I mean, that's a big deal for our staff to incorporate them because that's not a moneymaker. It's probably because we do that with all our volunteer fire departments. That's something we offer to them and to try to help them to keep our citizens safe. That's a big deal. That's a big deal. So I wanted to recognize, because staff spent quite a bit of time on this. I'm trying to get this through the ringer.


9:05 a.m.

Sure. Good point, Supervisor Bone. If there's anything else on the consent that Board of Supervisors want to comment on, I'll ask that. Do we have anybody online who wants to make a comment? No. All right. We're moving into the room. Please come forward if you have something to say. You have three minutes to say it. I wish to echo what Supervisor Bone said. It's most important to support our fire people out there. I don't know, maybe Blue Lake's already been supported, but we handle the other opposite end of that thing and have a very dedicated thing. It's very hard for us to get people to serve, and so anything the county can do to participate on that. I did also wish to make comment on number 12. It's regarding a professional agreement for basically debt collection services, and I think that's money very well spent. As people go more and more upside down, you're going to have a harder time people paying their bills, and to have a good debt. Debt collection processes.


9:06 a.m.

always imperative thank you my opinion to speak on your consent items today kind of a sparse room today it's kind of interesting all right thank you for your comments i guess we just go to the vote on consent items uh minus d7 i'll move approval of the consent calendar minus item d7 second great are we doing this online or or all right yes give me one second all right and if not we can do it in-house all right Motion carries 4-0. Thank you. Okay. Moving on to items removed from the consent calendar. Let's move to item D7.


9:07 a.m.

Please introduce what's coming up here. Yes, this item was pulled by Supervisor Bone, and Michelle Stevens is here to answer any questions your board may have. I'm not sure if you have a brief presentation or anything. Yep, here for questions. All right, Supervisor Bone, you asked for more discussion. Well, I had some of this explained to me yesterday, but it's up to 450,000. It was 480 last year. I think when reading about it, and then I asked Ms. Stevens for some results, we paid $308,000 last year is what I think was paid of the 460. We did not use all the contract, but that was for 51 contacts, phone calls. Now, with those phone calls, I understand there were 25 mobile calls on that too, but we're... Still looking at better than...


9:08 a.m.

Almost $9,000 per individual call. Most of them are on Saturdays and Sundays. Most of them, I don't know how much staff we have on Saturdays or Sundays. But this is money being paid to an outside firm in Ukiah. And I'm always, things like this, I'm always wondering, I'm always saying outside contracts are great, we don't need a lot of extra. But something like this, it seems like we can almost handle this in-house with the people we have. And if we bill at this rate, there might be profits. But I'm just saying, it just seems like a lot of money to be spending. Now, I know it's a state-mandated program, but the state can't mandate us to throw money away, even if they give it to us and tell us to throw it away. And it just seems like we're spending a lot of money per call. And if we can justify $9,000 a call, then I'll just be quiet. Well, it comes down to less, because it was only $310,000, so it's $7,000 a call or something like that. So. You want to explain it to me? Sure.


9:09 a.m.

Well, you're right. It is a lot of money. So the FERS, the Family Urgent Response System, is part of the continuum of care reform that the state's been doing for a number of years now. And it's been unstable funding from the beginning. It's decreased. So the amount in this contract, we don't have the current amount for the 25-26 fiscal year. So we're using last year's amount. Last year's amount was $30,000, as you pointed out, less than the year before that. There's been a $13 million decrease as well. So we're anticipating the 25-26 allocation that we're going to get is also going to decrease. And so we did actually, CWS did actually kind of evaluate what this would look like in-house. A couple points I think that are really important to say. One is, you know, these are, it is a need. Definitely it is a need. Not just a mandate, but it's a need. We have really high needs.


9:10 a.m.

Youth and families that are in crisis and at any time of day, and they need a mobile response option from CWS. And so that's the intention of this, and it's really great. And the numbers are really low. And I think the state is seeing that across the state, across counties. And so they are evaluating the program. There's been a lot of conversation at CDSS and CWDA around how to change it so that it is more effective for the amount of money that it's costing the state. It is an allocation that we get. We have a mandate. We can't use it for anything else. So when we looked at taking it in-house, because it's unstable funding, the cost to get staff, not every staff person can do that type of work. It takes time. And RCS, the vendor, has clinical staff that are trained in crisis intervention, mobile response.


9:11 a.m.

showing up when a child or youth is talking about killing themselves or their caregiver, for example. Really, really scary behaviors that not just any social worker in child welfare systems are going to be able to manage. So these are their more highly trained folks. We would need to be doing that work as well. So we evaluated the effort of preparing staff, getting staff trained, identifying what the system would look like. It would look much like our on-call system in child welfare. To that point, I do want to say that one of the guidelines around this program and kind of designing something in-house is youth don't want to call CWS. Parents don't want to call CWS when they're in crisis because they're worried, they're scared, understandably, right? That their child's going to get taken away or something like that, right? So best practice would be to have an outside-in-house system that's going to be able to do that work. So we're going to be doing that work.


9:12 a.m.

provide the service. It's a neutral party, basically. And so I completely understand what you're saying, Supervisor Bone. We've been having these conversations ourselves a lot, that it is a lot of money for not very many calls. 26 mobile responses is the number that from last year in terms of how many of the RCS staff actually went out and to the home. That's not nothing. We don't know what would have happened if they hadn't gone out. But I agree. We all agree that the numbers are really low for the amount of money that it is. So we're going to continue to have conversations with the state and CWDA around how do we provide the service for less cost to the state and what that might look like in Humboldt County for us. And that's partially why I brought it forward, is as you said, this has been going. And I just got two years. This year we have 28.


9:13 a.m.

calls year-to-date and 10 of them have mobile responses. Last year we had 51 with 24 mobile responses and I know we need it and I know it's an important service. I'm not denying that and everything else but I'm just saying that it seems like a lot of money per individual and the mobile calls do they you know it just seems you're right and the thing is and then I look at this and I'm going I said this 12-13 years ago I asked do we ever look at any of these programs we have out there and groundproof them to see what we're getting because you know before when Phil was here Phil never found a program he didn't like. He says hey we'll try that program we'll try it. We had a lot of we were very innovative a long time ago and Phil would he raised his hands every time but after we got the program two years in we never looked to see how the program was doing we just kept on going with the program and then we absorbed some of it end up us because the funding was not enough. We had to do a lot of work and we had to do a lot of work and we had to do a lot of work and we had to do a lot of work and we had to do a lot of work and we had to do a lot of work. So that's where we took the pretty good three so that's where we stand settling down. So I I


9:14 a.m.

Because we had the money back then. So I'm just saying, the programs need to be ground truth because something like this can just fall through and 51 calls for $310,000 and half of them are just phone calls. Absolutely. And I know they have to talk to them and I know they have to have a certain amount of knowledge to talk to them and stuff. But it just seemed like a lot of money. So I felt like the, we always talk about this, we give millions away. And the consent calendar, you know, and I heard the word last week, budget dust. And that was just to be one of Amy Nielsen's favorite lines and everybody else. But the problem being is we need to pick up the dust too and make sure, you know, it doesn't pile up. So anyway, I don't have a problem with it as long as we're, you know, as long as we're looking at it. I mean. We are very much. Because right now we're being asked to not give people raises. We're asked.


9:15 a.m.

Not giving anything else. And when you say, well, it doesn't affect our budget, it affects my budget, it affects your budget, because the money's coming from somewhere. And as we go through this, we need to, you know, kind of do our part in this. You know, just make sure we're getting our bang for the buck. And basically that the money's going towards the recipients in foster care. You've just said foster care needs a lot of work, needs a lot of work, needs a lot of work. And I didn't ask how many of these 51 calls were repeat. You know, somebody that took three, four, because I would imagine, I've heard a lot of them are repeat calls. So we're dealing with the same client. So now we're spending $310,000 on maybe 35 clients, 30 clients, and that's a lot of money when that could be going throughout the foster care program somehow, if it's there, to further the benefits of the caregiver and the children. So just thought I'd ask. Because, sorry. It's a fair question. Yeah.


9:16 a.m.

Thank you, Supervisor Bowen. Is there any other comments? Supervisor Arroyo? So I think what I heard you say was that this is state funding that can't be used for another purpose. Correct. So and that I fully understand the idea that we might be able to increase that capacity internally or benefit from this funding, but also the statement you made about it creating a bit of a separation from the CWS system and the fears around that is very real. Have there been any requests for proposals for a new provider of this service, or is this our on-call provider? No, we provide on-call services in-house as a standard, as a requirement. We're a 24-hour mandated program. But no, so RCS also has a STRTP. Don't ask me what that is.


9:17 a.m.

That stands for, I've forgotten over the years, short-term residential treatment facility. And they provide that locally. And so we do have high-needs youth that are placed in that program locally. So they are based in Ukiah, but they are local as well. So this contract is separate from that? This is just on urgent response? Right. Yeah, we have a requirement to provide continuous telephone-based, in-person, in-home mobile response, stabilization, and support services. So that's the service that they are providing. And the numbers are low for the amount of money. And are there other, I'm just not familiar with this particular niche, are there other providers of this type of service that are not county employees but are outside organizations? From my knowledge, we've looked, and RCS is really the only one that.


9:18 a.m.

remotely close to us that could provide services here in Humboldt County. So even having them as an STRTP is kind of a big deal for us. It's really, it's a big deal. So this does take some staff capacity to receive the reports and do the billing or do all of the kind of processing of administration of the contract. But beyond that, are we able to recoup some of those costs through the funding from the state? Where does the leftover, I believe that whatever we don't spend goes back to the state. Yeah, we don't get to keep it for anything else. But do you know if we're able to charge any of our staff time or services to the funding stream? A small amount. Okay. Okay. Okay. So most of the work is contracted out. Okay. All right. Well, I'm ready to vote. Thank you for the explanation of this. Okay. Supervisor Madrone. Supervisor Madrone. Well, thank you for the responses. And the details, I think that.


9:19 a.m.

matters. I appreciate Supervisor Bowen bringing it forward to have that discussion. It's a worthwhile thing. You know, I suspect that if we looked at the data, when children are adopted, I suspect the crises go down to some degree, simply because an adopted home is a more stable home than a foster home, just in very general terms, at least from my experience as an adoptive grandparent of six foster kids. But one of the things that's always been interesting to me, watching my daughters with our foster kids, is that when they were foster kids, they were able to get services easier than once they adopted. And, you know, it's not your fault. It's nobody's fault. But it's an interesting phenomena that occurs. And yet, I suspect that an adoptive home is a stabler home, just simply because it's long-term. You know, from that perspective, I think it's a great thing.


9:20 a.m.

But I wonder, is there any data around that kind of stuff at all that you're aware of? I'm sure there's some data around successful adoptions versus quote-unquote failed adoptions. But, you know, in my experience, it's yes and no. I mean, trauma doesn't stop. The experience of experiencing trauma as a child doesn't stop once you're adopted and the paper's signed, right? And so I've seen many adoptive, adopted children, you know, struggle. So, yeah, I think it's a both and. Yeah, yeah. Okay. Thank you. Supervisor Bell. So does the Red River community, do they have people here? Do they do the mobile response from here? Yes. And we don't send staff out there that are not, right? Not for this. The report gets, they make the initial. Then it goes to you guys, and then you guys follow up, right? Is that? This.


9:21 a.m.

This is separate from, right, if there's a suspected child abuse report to be made, then it comes to us and our on-call or our daytime staff, right, that take those calls. All right. Inquiring minds wanted to know, or minded. Thanks. You're welcome. All right. So we still need to go to public comment. Do we have public comment online? No. All right. In the room, looks like we have someone. Please come to the podium. Well, I appreciate what I refer to as an admission that a fatal flaw of CWS is that parents are afraid to contact them. Legitimately, I've had all kinds of cases where they make a contact, and all of a sudden, they're the ones who are losing their children. And that is a major fear. There's actually people in the room, most likely, that would be speaking, except they're afraid of losing their children. And that needs to stop. It needs to stop right now. That's ridiculous.


9:22 a.m.

Whereas if they were calling CASA or some other thing like that, they would feel confident that their concerns would be probably addressed in a way that they wouldn't be afraid of losing their children unjustifiably. There's just so much taking of children here without relevancy, without justifiable, without facts, and it sure would be nice if we could get it local. I strongly support Supervisor Bone's desire to have it local. I don't see why that couldn't actually be. It sounds to me like the training is just originally initial training, but you basically have staff that could respond through other things to do the follow-up and everything necessary. It should be nice to keep the money local. But again, the biggest thing we have to fix is we have to fix CWS people's perception that they can't call them, can't report things, or they just end up losing their children. So that is a major flaw in our county. Thank you for the opportunity to speak. Thank you. Is there anybody else? Seeing none, I guess we'll go to... Do we have a...


9:23 a.m.

A motion yet? All right, let's take a motion in a second. All right, I'll move approval of the contract. Second. Great. And we'll bring up the votes. Sorry, was that the entirety of the motion that you needed? I just want to make sure. I didn't look at the specific recommended language. It looks like approve the professional services agreement and authorize subsequent amendments and direct the clerk of the board to return one fully executed copy. So I think it's the authorization of subsequent amendments that was probably important. I think that's what I heard you say. Great. Seconder? All right, great. Well, I guess we're moving on from that item. Thank you so much for your presentation today, and thank you so much for bringing it up. Motion carries 4-0. All right.


9:24 a.m.

Thank you. All right, so here we are. We're taking public comment on non-agenda items. So do we have anything online? Anyone online who wants to make comment on non-agenda items? No, we don't. All right. Anyone in the room? Please come forward. Three minutes. Good morning, Supervisors. My name's Joanne McGarry. I decided to ride the bus in here this morning for this meeting to make a public comment. I like to talk in threes. The first thing I want to talk about is the Golden Rule. Then I want to talk about collective travel in county. And finally, I want to talk about peace and nonviolence and compassion. So first of all, I want to thank the Supervisors. I wasn't here last week, but I understand. A proclamation for the Golden Rule peace boat was made.


9:25 a.m.

And I was able to participate last Saturday in an event at the Eureka Theater and see a film that has yet to be released to the public about the Golden Rule. And I just want the County of Humboldt to know we are really fortunate to have this boat here, this historic peace boat here, that was set sail, as I mentioned before, in 1958 by a Quaker crew to sail to the Marshall Islands to stop nuclear testing. And the whole nuclear deterrent, nuclear disarmament issue is what the Golden Rule is primarily about, but peace is also what it's about. And both those issues are in our reality right now that we must think about in a global sense and how it's affecting us locally. So just thank you for recognizing our historic peace boat, the Golden Rule. Secondly. I took the bus in here and I'm discovering.


9:26 a.m.

There's a lot of wonderful events that happen in our communities, in our county, in the cities. One is coming up on the solstice out somewhere on the beach, which is probably not accessible by public transit. It's a solstice celebration that people have, and it's primarily peace-loving people just going to the beach and honoring the solstice. But people get there in a huge amount of vehicles. And we really need to start looking at ways to accommodate people to participate in these wonderful events, but do something to prevent the literal traffic hazard that it creates, because there's no other way for people to get to the locations that these events are held. So I just wanted to bring that up, and it's something that you, Supervisor Madrone, might be interested in looking at this week, seeing if there's something we can do last minute. So finally, on 34. I've been working with Arcata and Eureka, or at least Tocqueville.


9:27 a.m.

talking to them about becoming international cities of peace, a nonviolent city project out of the Pache Ibeni organization, and finally signing on to the Charter for Compassion so that our communities can declare that they aspire to be peaceful, nonviolent, compassionate places. So I'm just letting you know, and I'll probably follow up with an email with information about these international organizations that maybe this county wants to consider as well. Thank you. Thank you for that. We have another speaker. Ken Sawatsky, I always get things to remember people by, and this was Joel who passed on a little while ago. And $5, beautiful briefcase. I talked to Lauren. She said he didn't like it. So anyway, but it reminds me of people that are important that have passed on. I did want to bring this to your attention here. I found this. Side of the road in front of my Glendale Road.


9:28 a.m.

No reason that this would be being used in this area. And it's basically a Great Whip cream charger nitric oxide container. I know you've had regulations on this, but there's no skull and crossbones on this. There's no really warning on this. And yet apparently, I don't know, maybe you did make some warnings on these things. But if this is even to be sold for this particular purpose, Great Whip, you know, for chefs and things, it should have a warning because it's a disastrous, terrible thing to be used improperly. So that's a suggestion. I can leave this with you if you would like to see it. We also have a 4th of July coming up. And we're really going forward for safe and sane fireworks. No illegal fireworks, please. People like my good friend Erin Beth McClure and a lot of us are really making a big thing to try and get people to quit doing the illegal fireworks. It disturbs animals, our dogs, our horses, all of the things out there. The critters in the world do not react well to it. So for those of you who are watching this, I want to thank you. And for those of you who are totally inconsiderate and feel like you're going to get a lot of money,


9:29 a.m.

You have to bust off fireworks for six or seven hours over that time period, make a lot of noise. I really wish you would cease to do so. It's not considerate. We have humans also who have PTSD, and this has a major effect on them. And my third topic today was I put some information out to you, public comment in your written packet. And this was from somebody I met by the name of Jasper. And this is a major concern to a lot of us here. If you had time to read that, I highly recommend you do read her comments. This is what she felt happened to her regarding the weed business that happened in Humboldt County and what's happened to a lot of women. This is a very important thing. And in her process, her son was taken from her. Same old CWS process, same player. I mentioned a certain, she mentioned a certain attorney, and I've observed. So when you have somebody who's upper shelf CWS, who was in here last meeting, and I said, I'm going to take you to the CWS, and I said, I'm going to take you to the CWS. And she said, I'm going to take you to the CWS. And I said, I was going to relay this to you, a little more information.


9:30 a.m.

because I did remember the name there, who basically is able to have a working relationship and monetize corruption, in my opinion, through the court system, because if you really want favoritism and you want to have your children put in your care rather than your spouse's, you go to an attorney like this. And I have a great lack of respect for attorneys who engage in this process and use their prior connections with the district attorney, judges, and other things. These are the kind of people who work very well with Judge Creases of the world. And I think we all know who he is and his amount of moral compass. Thank you for my opportunity to speak. Thank you for that. All right. There's no more public comment. I just wanted to remind folks that this week is the week of Juneteenth, and we have a bunch of really wonderful events happening. So please look it up and please attend. And please help celebrate.


9:31 a.m.

I know there's someone planning to give some public comment on that today, and so I'm just standing in for a minute here. All right, so next is our public hearings. And this is the time when I'm going to open the public hearing. I'm going to open it in relation to the revocation of nine permits due to unpaid measure S taxes. The permit numbers are listed in the item. And take it away. Chair Wilson, thank you. John Ford and Michael Kine to present the revocation of nine cannabis permits. And I'm just going to turn it over to Mr. Kine to make this presentation. Good morning, supervisors. My name is Michael Kine, planner with the Humboldt County Planning and Building Department. I am presenting a short presentation regarding the nine permits up for revocation.


9:32 a.m.

A quick background. Back in 2023, the Humboldt County Board of Supervisors decided to decree that all permits that had outstanding processing costs and outstanding measure S taxes were to pay in full to remain in good standing. On March 31st, 2024, a deadline was set for payment for measure S taxes. On May 3rd, 2024, a letter was sent out to all the permit holders that are up for revocation today regarding their suspension of those permits. At that point, these permit holders had not entered a payment plan for measure S taxes and all have been suspended since May of 2020. At this point, all nine permits have ceased operations. Only one still exists.


9:33 a.m.

has a unexpired state license and at this point there is a total of $222,155.02 that remains outstanding. Prior to this revocation there was a request by a current permit holder to take over another permit that is under revocation. That permit is number 10424 out of the Holmes Flat area and currently that permit hold owes $35,870.50 in Measure S tax. The current policy states that a new permit holder would need to pay all Measure S taxes that are owed or pay by the end of the year.


9:34 a.m.

year December 31st. At this point that would be the waiving of those taxes would be unprecedented under the current policy. A couple of examples that I wanted to point out all the farms listed in this slide have taken over other permits and have either paid the Measure S taxes in full or are working on it through a payment plan, one of which was Ancient Truth out of Bridgeville. This operator has paid in full as of this past few weeks. The next example is Rainmaker Properties out of Petrolia. The operator took on a Measure S tax of $52,000. That's currently in a payment plan. Lastly, the last example is Manna Farms which you may recall from a couple of weeks ago or a couple of


9:35 a.m.

Months ago, they took on a debt from a farm of $9,830, and as of April, they have paid that in full as well. The Planning and Billing Department makes the recommendation to adopt the nine resolutions as follows, and to find that the permits have been exercised contrary to the terms of the conditions of approval and request that you revoke the nine permits per Section 312-14 of the Humboldt County Code. Great. Let's first start with the board and if they have any comments or questions in relation to this. I'll wait for Supervisor Bowman. All right. Anybody else? So I'm sorry, we're not including those properties that you showed. Is that correct? Correct.


9:36 a.m.

were just examples of the people who had taken over prior to revocation. Great, thank you very much. I do want to point out that the first one, which was Ancient Truth, that one was up for revocation. That was on their original plan to go to the board, but we were contacted by a person, and they have, like I said, it paid up in full. So we're in good shape with them. Great. I don't have any other questions then. Is there a, I mean, we're kind of doing these in batches, it feels like. Is that true? That is true. All right. Do we have more batches coming? Yes. Okay. Okay. Have we heard anything from the folks that have requested this exemption? Would a delay in maybe putting that one into the next batch be of any value to anybody to? Is there any negotiation that's occurring or any outreach on that?


9:37 a.m.

We have tried to work with them to find a way for them to either be able to pay it off or to enter a payment plan. None of that seems to have been successful at this point. Okay. When do you expect the next batch, I guess, of these to come forward? We don't have a date right now. Okay, but probably before the end of the year? Yes. Would it be very outside the purview of this board or Preston if we were to just request that one go to the next batch and give them time to figure it out? We don't, we're not, I can't, I think you guys are correct. It's like us waiving the taxes is just something we can't do. Otherwise, it just creates a flood of other issues. So I think we're, I think the board understands that. That being said, Well, we.


9:38 a.m.

We also saw was an example of some successful transfers that did occur, and we were able to actually collect, and it was to have some benefit to the county. So maybe I'm just off just as a concept that we delay this one until the next group that comes in, and if there's nothing more that can be done at that point, then we just move it on through. But it would be nice if they could figure out a way to do that. And it's just a concept. I don't want to belabor this too much, but I just want to get your thoughts on that. So as a general principle, no problem with continuing to a date uncertain to allow the applicant to try to work on it. Right. As a practical matter, it's just in all likelihood that's more unreimbursed work for the department. I see. Right, trying to negotiate, trying to get there. And so it's like how much? How much are we going to spend to get this $30 million?


9:39 a.m.

$5,000, but ultimately, if you can get somebody operating and running, that would be good, too. Right. Hmm. I'll see if the rest of the board has any comments or questions about those concepts, and we'll kind of go from there. And I know Supervisor Bone was trying to speak earlier. Cough dropped down the wrong side of my throat. Okay, so I'll let you jump in first. And I understand the part about if we kick it down the road, does that give them an opportunity to operate this summer without paying any fees? So there's that issue. They would still be suspended. They would still be suspended. Yes. So we know that if they're suspended, they would never grow on their property. That is the idea. Anyway, is there a way we can look at this? Because there's quite a... There's quite a few properties out there like this. Now, the three examples that we put up are kind of like the...


9:40 a.m.

Oddballs, because we're not getting a lot of those coming in and paid in full and everything else, unless they're neighboring properties or have great infrastructure and everything else. But I got calls from three realtors yesterday wanting to know, they have properties they could sell. These are former cultivation properties, the majority of them, and they either have unpaid taxes or the biggest thing is they have abatement liens. And the abatement liens have to be released before these people can buy the property. These people would buy the properties with the contention to clean them up, and I don't know how we do this, but the whole idea is trying to turn this property over and get it back on the tax rolls with somebody that's going to pay their taxes. You want to ask me a question, don't you? No, we do that successfully all the time. Okay. That's not even unique. Okay. We often work with realtors and buyers. Okay. To come to an agreement without them having to pay any...


9:41 a.m.

penalties or anything like that just if they're going to get to buy the property clean it up that's what we all want okay because even if you're borrowing hard money they want it to be a clean property in case they get it back they don't want to clean them so if if that's if that's an option that's available then you know on a regular and i know i know it's happened in the past but i don't know if it's always going to happen and everything else because the main thing is we want to get this property if it's laying fallow now they've as you said we've got eight of these licenses that you can't get a hold of the people at all uh we actually recently heard from one of them they wanted to withdraw it but at this point it would have been more work one one out of one out of eight so we had seven so big percentage the property is just it's not going to fix itself but if somebody wants to go in there and turn over and a lot of times some people some of these people aren't doing it to grow you they just want to get out in the hills or get out somewhere else so with that being said um


9:42 a.m.

If they can make that work, maybe we should have a meeting with the Realtors Association, letting them know what's available, or the next time you talk to them, so these people know that, you know, they put it on the counter, that there is an avenue to buy these properties and have these things released. So... I don't mean to interrupt Supervisor Bona, and I appreciate that topic, but I think what we're talking about is licenses. And I think what you're talking about is the transfer of property sans license, without license. Kind of accumulative is what I'm saying. License doesn't do you any good unless you have property to use it on. Okay. I mean, you could have a lot, it goes hand in hand. A lot of these properties have liens against them that are abatement liens, right? Well, they do. And that's through the code enforcement process. We often see those cleaned up. This, and these properties where people may have abandoned, lol...


9:43 a.m.

that were permitted sites. We're currently looking at options to see how to get those cleaned up. One of them is for somebody to come in and buy it. They will often, the realtor, the more sophisticated realtors, will come in and talk to us up front for their client to find out exactly what needs to be done for this site to be cleared. And we work with people to get them there. Okay. Because we want to back on the rolls no matter what we want in providing people places to have a tap. Thank you, Supervisor Brown. Supervisor Madrone. So, John, all of these that are up today have suspended licenses. Correct. And yet one of the three examples that I think you showed in terms of precedence wasn't paid off. It was just a payment plan was developed. Correct. This board set a deadline of December 31st.


9:44 a.m.

of this year, I believe, for all measure has to be paid in full. And there was a lot of comments made by the board about how we're not kicking this can down the road any further. We've kicked it year after year, and that's that. This is it. We're not going to extend any more. Is that correct, your memory of? That's absolutely correct, and there's an important piece in there. The board actually, back in March, reopened the ability to enter into payment plans. Yes. So any of these, if they wanted to keep their permit, could have just simply entered into a payment plan. That's where I was going, Nick. So if you did enter into a payment plan, does that renew your license for growing this summer? No, it's still suspended. Until you pay off the measure? Right, but it keeps the permit active. Okay, yeah, yeah, absolutely. So, I mean, I just wanted to mention that, Supervisor Wilson, that there is an out here. That is develop a payment plan, right? That's kicking it down the road, so to speak. And that it gives time.


9:45 a.m.

to try and hold on to that permit and make payments and finish that off by the end of the year. So that's the pathway forward for those folks, frankly. And we've deliberated over this over and over and over again to try and, I mean, we've given a lot of leeway over and over. And should we have ever had a measure S? I don't believe so, but it is in place and it is there. So I just wanted to mention that because it is an out for people to at least preserve that permit. Okay. I'm going to take public comment and then we'll see what we can do to wrap up something here. So is there any public comment on line? Yes. Caller 2223, I will unmute you and you will have three minutes. Good morning, can you hear me?


9:46 a.m.

Yes. Good morning, Craig Johnson here and I'm calling in one of the permits on here took my attention and that was my Cality Medicinal APN 521-091-043. I see it's probably one of the smallest permits in the county, 3,260 feet. They owe back $4,000, 4,260. This is clearly, I know the owners, this is clearly a family operation out in Redwood Valley. That community suffered a degrading road for access to get to their properties. Their school is even closed because the... The entire community has pretty much moved out because of cannabis legalization.


9:47 a.m.

and over taxation. We were coming to the board from the very beginning saying this isn't working, we need help. And this particular property is in Supervisor Madrone's area. And Supervisor Madrone, I just, I really got to make this point. You just said you didn't think we should have a measure S, but yet you were the hardest one to pull into a reduction when it was time. And I just really want to connect with all of you because we've been coming to the board and now I'm seeing some of these permits and these are pretty personal. These families have been trying hard. And I know it's too late now, but please, when your constituents are coming to you saying it's not working, please listen with both ears and ask more questions if you don't know. Thank you.


9:48 a.m.

Measure S is just another way that it didn't work for the community. And it was just too much. And we did come to you all saying we needed the help for this. Thank you so much. Thank you. And now, is there any more online? That's all. All right. Great. We're taking it into the room. Please come to the podium and say what you need to say. Hi, this is Sunshine Sarasata from Red Crest. Do you have any questions about the letter that I put into the agenda? No. We don't have that kind of just for whatever formality. This is your three minutes. Okay. That's great. Yeah. I would really, I'm just asking you to waive those taxes. My father bought that parcel there in Red Crest last year. And it was in foreclosure at the time. I really need this just to get stable. I have been floating for the past few years. Really? Really? I have.


9:49 a.m.

I had two leases going in 2020 and I lost those just due to straight up greed. One of the people I was leasing from, they didn't want to renew because they wanted to redo the whole permit and do debts and not do dry farm and thinking they could get more money that way. The other landowner, unfortunately, thought he was signing a lot laying adjustment with the neighbor and he lost his property, which therefore I lost the lease I had there. It's been difficult. So what this does is this means I don't have to lease something. This is in the family and this allows me to carry on with my brand, with my genetics program. But to have the burden of those taxes would be really hard for me today, right now. It's treacherous out there. And sitting and holding on a permit would be better than right now in the short term just due to how things are and not trying to rush into things. I'm here to just ask you if you've thought about this. Or if you... Who can... Yeah, I tried...


9:50 a.m.

signed last year to transfer the permit with the with the holders now and it didn't really work out last year and now this year i recently had a meeting with them on monday and it's like yeah let's let's we will we'll sign the permit over to you but carrying the liability of those back taxes would be very burdensome starting out right now a minute if you need it um i don't know i was just hoping you maybe had some questions for me about this and and uh you could you know talk to me about this is there a possibility can we talk we negotiate what's what's happening here like we don't do that here so if you want to sit down and we have questions we'll call you okay okay sorry i'm just like i understand i know it's a hearing and i'm like i'm ready to talk like i want to work something out today this is one of the most awkward ways to communicate so okay yeah all right thank you yeah just you it's not you next


9:51 a.m.

Ken Sawatsky, I wrote the opposition to Measure S for a reason. Some people say it's a psychic ability, but at the time it was brought forward, all the growers were in favor of it. I mean, they wanted, they said, we want to do our share, we want to be taxed. I like Sunshine, I like her business model, I like what she does, but I think you have to have consistency in the project. I hate to have to be in the position where I should say that I think today, if she wants to make out a payment plan in some way to make it work, I can't see you waiving this for one person and not waiving it for them all. And that's not in the county's best interest. There's a lot of money at stake here. The people who were able to raise the money had the business to do it. It sounded to me as if John Ford's done his due diligence and tried to work out a deal with people, but they were unable or unwilling to. I don't have a problem with you. Extend. I mean, if that's something you feel is necessary. The indication I got from his communication.


9:52 a.m.

It didn't sound like that was something that was worthwhile. Maybe this particular thing will put enough pressure on that person to actually realize that they do have to come and make a payment plan and have it paid off. And I would assume all payment plans include, and this would be a question you may wish to ask, by December 31st of this year, they all have to be paid in full. That was the payment plan. I don't think we're going beyond that. I hope not. You do have leeway, but you have to be consistent with everybody. It's consistency. It's something that's imperative. Can't pick favorites just because I happen to like Sunshine and her business model, but I think as far as equity goes, everybody needs to be treated the same. They have the opportunity to speak today. Great. Is there any other comment on this item before we take it back to the board? All right. So I'll start this conversation. So I think, I mean, Yeah, I'll go. John, I think.


9:53 a.m.

Let's take it to staff and have some discussion. Thanks. I just wanted to really emphasize that the board, even if you were inclined to consider waiving taxes, the measure S does not grant the board that ability. You can modify things generally, but on a case-by-case basis, you do not have that authority. Yeah, thank you for that clarification. I think that's true. It's that we don't have the authority. So that's why I brought up at the beginning of this discussion the issue or the, you know, what do we have in terms of our – and it's not even if we did have the authority, the question then becomes the issue around a gift of public funds because it's one specific parcel versus every other parcel that would be coming to ask for the waiving of these fees or these taxes. And so that's – It's just really out of our hands.


9:54 a.m.

from that perspective. And that's why I was asking to see if there is a way to give some more time for this particular case. But for me, I think it's limited. From a policy perspective, I mean, we individually can talk to you about policies internally and trying to bring something back to the board. There might be some creativity in that. But in what we have in front of us today, it seems like the best I feel like we can do is to put this one onto the next docket and really only limit it to the, I don't even need to call it an applicant, but the interested party to bring back a payment plan. That's it. And then there isn't really a, I don't see another path for us in the current context under our current policy format. I would agree. Thank you.


9:55 a.m.

The one thing I want to make clear is that when the board granted the ability to enter into new payment plans, it did set a sunset for entering into those, which is now passed. Yeah, I get it. So you need to reopen that. That's not really on today's agenda. I see. So you can't just unilaterally make that decision. You'd really need to re-agendize the measure as payment plans. Okay. Say we're going to reopen that. Let me ask you this question. Do we have any other similar requests when we're bringing up these sunsets on these revocations? So, Ms. Karnes said we do not. Okay. But one of the things that often happens is people do watch the board meetings. Right. And so your decisions often trigger lots of problems.


9:56 a.m.

Some responses. Right. And how many more revocations do we think we're going to be getting to by the end of this year? Just mas o menos. 20 or 30. 20 or 30. Okay. Right. So we could be inviting a flood of requests for, or not. I mean, it really is, you're not going to come in, I think, with a payment plan once there's some, you have something to back that up. Yeah. You know, this is painful. Yeah. This is painful to say. Yeah. But part of the struggle is that these folks are suspended. Right. Which has taken away their primary source of income. Right. So it's like, it's a double hit. Right. I feel that. If anyone else on the board has something to say about this before we kind of hone in, Supervisor Bone? Yeah.


9:57 a.m.

Sometimes kicking the can down the road is what we do best. At the end of the day, I know when Measure S passed in 2016, the public made a decision. And then what we did after that is we actually instilled the lowest tax rate in the state for any county. Some people were getting $25 a square foot. But some people balanced their budget, Calaveras, in two weeks because they didn't have any review or anything else. I mean, there was a lot of things going on back then. Monterey took all their flower beds and had moved south of the border, and we're turning those over. Oaksterdam, everybody else had things down there. So we had the lowest rate. We expected the first year to bring in $2.2 million. We far exceeded that. And then we actually suspended it.


9:58 a.m.

like we do with a lot of things, or like help businesses that are having troubles, you know, and a big part of our business. And I guess, like somebody said, if you don't think it's a big part of our business, take a look around town some nights and some days and everything. So, whatever we can do, I don't think, I don't know if it's calling a failure upon ourselves as we kind of do this, there seems to be a little bit of renaissance going on right now, people wanting to pick up parcels and do it on a smaller scale, but do it. I don't, you know, I don't know if there's still a market out there. So, and especially for people that are in the market. So, any way we can help keep that segment of the business, I would kind of like what we try to do with logging and fishing and all the other ones, even though we try to stop them, but, I mean, we need those. We're resource-based. County, there's no way around it. We're, you know.


9:59 a.m.

Most of our people work for the government, but somebody has to pay them. So as we move forward, anything we can do within legal realm, we can't give taxes away. We can work with people. We can do things. The measure S tax, isn't there a little bit of we can drop it to zero, but we can't make it go away or forgive it, if I remember right, if I remember how it was written back then. So it's been 10 years, darn year. So anyway, I kind of think the board agrees that anything we can do to help. I mean, I remember nine years ago, Sunshine came in and wanted to shed a smaller parcel than would allow her to have a permit, and we made that arrangement. And we worked with the growers even back then. So if we can still allow this, I know we can't give away taxes. I mean, the buyer beware. If it's got taxes on it, you're going to probably have to pay them. No way around it. So as we move forward, I'd be all.


10 a.m.

in favor of revamping some more or doing whatever the case may be but you have done a very good job at the county pivoting with what leeway we give you you know what what you can do legally without county council getting all upset um but i mean as you move forward you've been able to make a lot of deals with a lot of people to keep properties on the tax rolls and not becoming a burn dust i remember three years ago it was set up here that we were going to have so many pieces of property in a couple years we wouldn't know what to do with because we're going to forfeit them all and i don't know how many we forfeited but i don't think we have a big list because we've been able to do these kind of things so i appreciate that is there anything as we move forward okay um i'm willing to take a chance on holding holding this one off


10:01 a.m.

until the next batch personally and I do have to disclose because I didn't realize that my Cality Farms was on this list that I did speak to the owner of as in a casual basis and he let me know that he was going to you know let this one go so what what permit number is that that we're talking about you


10:02 a.m.

That is item number nine. It's PLN 10424. 10, excuse me, 10124? 10424. 424. Yep. PLN 10124. Okay. Great. So just for clarification, this is a hearing specifically on permits and the revocation of permits. It is not a hearing where we're making policy in relation to measure S taxes or anything else, so land use policy or any of those things. It's not on the agenda. So we really can't offer any changes, correct? That is correct. Okay. I want to smell your ear. As much as that may have come up as a subject today, we're not making any discussion. We're not. We're not having any.


10:03 a.m.

Any changes about that? So, yes, Supervisor Madron. Thank you. I see two different issues here. One is this particular permit and where you're going with that in terms of putting it into the next batch. The other one is to come back with an agenda item as soon as possible to revisit the payment plan option and open that back up to allow for payments to be made, but still maintaining the end of the year all payments have to be made in full. That's an item that would at least give this operator as well as others the option to enter into a payment plan to try and preserve that permit. I know that's not a solution that is. That's desirable. But as you mentioned, John, we don't have the authority to waive these payments on one operator.


10:04 a.m.

We just simply don't. And we have dropped it to zero, we dropped it to five, we dropped it to ten percent. We've done a lot to try and reduce the burden of those taxes over the years. So you know I see two different items and if I might I would make a motion to bring back the an agenda item to revisit the payment plan option. Is that in conjunction with with the revocation of the... I'm separating the two just trying to take them one bite at a time. I'll just my prerogative as chairs I'd like to just combine these if we can. Go ahead make a motion then. Yeah that's fine and I appreciate the language and I support it so I just want to be there. So Supervisor Arroyo anything to say? Yeah thank you. I mean this is a tough one because I know there are a number of different circumstances in the state that I'm in right now and I'm not sure if I'm going to be able to accommodate for anything in those circumstances. We would like to walk away. If we have any later suggestions, if meant a Taste test. Thanks so much


10:05 a.m.

has passed. I'm open to whatever the will of the board is to discuss that further at another date, but I am wanting to clarify, so when you're recommending that we defer the revocation for these, all of these, or it doesn't sound like we can do some of them, we have to do all of them or proceed according to what Director Ford said, right? No, no, I'm sorry if I misspoke. Okay. I understood the desire is to set aside fourth generation family farms, continue that to a date uncertain. I see. There'll be no action on that. Okay. But then the other eight permits would be a recommendation for revocation. Okay, because we have not heard from them. Right. Okay. I mean, I understand also that, you know, there were, there was at least one permit holder on the list that worked with the department to address their issues and then was taken off the list based on the presentation. Um, so I guess my question is,


10:06 a.m.

I mean, by offering that option to work with the permit holders, which I think is a reasonable choice, we are still past the point where we told people that was an option. So it is, in essence, us saying that we are, on a case-by-case basis, working with folks who are communicative. I don't think that's a bad idea, but it is, maybe this is unimportant, but it is sort of making exception to what we had already said about the time period to come into compliance. So, in essence, we are talking about that today by allowing that to happen. I think we're opening that door. We're all ready to changing the policy that we already set. Again, I'm okay with it. I just want to recognize that that's the case.


10:07 a.m.

Yeah. I think the discussion is basically to have a more formal discussion that results in an action. Okay. And so you are beginning the discussion today, but you're not taking action on that today so that you don't violate the requirement to have something agendized. Sure. Yeah. Sounds good. All right. Well, I'm okay with the proposal that I hear kind of taking shape over here. I just wanted to be sure I was clear on what we were talking about. And what I think is another detail in this particular case that we're talking about, and it's my understanding that even if you're to revocate this permit for this particular parcel that we're talking about, that it doesn't qualify for version two. And I think...


10:08 a.m.

That's part of the issue. I mean, because I think some places have been like, okay, that's someone else's permit. Let it go. I'll do my own permit. Get in there and do that. So I would want to, in that discussion, look at is that a practical limitation or is it one that's just outdated or whatever? I don't really know because I don't know the details of that, but I want to make sure that as we move forward, we think about that a little bit in those discussions. And I just don't want to exclude that analysis is all I'm saying. So, all right. So I think, yes, yes, Supervisor Bowen. Is there an option in there where they could just re-permit the property in their own name? That's what Supervisor Wilson just mentioned. This is too small of a piece of property to be permitted under.


10:09 a.m.

2.0. Because it's it's the parcel size is too small. Because we made the concession last time. Yep. But a lot of these other people could that are switching. A lot of the parcels where they're the permits are being revoked could be re-permitted. And uh the because I've already gone through the hard part. Right. Now the other thing is is there a way we as we move forward with this we seem to get really going and wow wow wow. Is there a way fish and wildlife can be in the room so they are more of a partner in this than maybe a roadblock on some of them? Whenever we do anything relative to an ordinance or to a permit we consult with CDFW. I don't want to go too far down that road today. No I know. But I appreciate it. I understand. Supervisor Madron. So you mentioned so you mentioned it's not eligible for 2.0 because of the parcel size.


10:10 a.m.

What about the 2,000 square foot ordinance that we created? The streamlined permit process. How big is this current square footage? Is this the 3,300 one? No, this is a 10,000 square foot next light. Okay. So what about the 2,000 square foot approach? I don't think that waived the parcel size requirements. Oh, okay. Okay. All right. Just wondering. Okay. Okay. So maybe what I'll do is I'll try and formulate a motion here and see where we go, just because I'm trying to gather everybody's thoughts as best as I can. So I'm just going to state the motion. I'm not going to make the motion. I'll ask that my board members do that just for protocol reasons. So this would be to adopt the attached resolutions.


10:11 a.m.

It's not 1 through 9, it's now 1 through 8. 1 through 8. Okay, so that happened to be the last one. Well, that's very helpful. Which do the following. Finds the permits have been exercised contrary to the terms and conditions of approval and revoke the 9, excuse me, 8 permits per section 312-14 of the Humboldt County Code and direct the clerk of the board to provide a certified board order to the planning and building staff to be included in the notification. Of decision to appropriate parties and to direct staff to come back to the board with suggestions for modifications, I guess. Help me out here because I want to make it broad enough to have that discussion and come back with some solutions.


10:12 a.m.

So it could be modifications to payment plans. It could, that's the big issue right now. It's really the major S issue. How about just modifications to payment plans and other ideas? Okay. Okay. Okay. To, you know, assist in license transfers. That's it. I think that's the issue, right? Right. One more, if I could offer it. Yes, please. Is to continue PLN 10424 to a date uncertain. And please continue PLN 10424 to a date uncertain. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. So will a board member own that motion, please? All right. I'll own the motion. I tried my best. Is there a second? I'll second. Great. Thank you.


10:13 a.m.

Thank you. Okay, is there any more discussion from the board? Seeing none, I just wanted to say it. Is there objection to unanimous consent? Motion carries 4-0. All right. Yes, I always wanted to say that. Now that we have this computer, I can't say it. Seeing no objection to unanimous consent, the motion is passed. Thank you. All right. I think that is it. We don't have any departmental reports. There's no matters initiated by the board. We'll be moving to closed session. Do we have a report on that? Thank you, Vice Chair Wilson. It is the intention of the board to meet in closed session, pursuant to California Government Code Section 54956.8, to grant authority to its negotiators, regarding the price and terms of payment for the purchase of real


10:14 a.m.

property located at 515 J Street, Eureka, California 95501, assessor parcel number 001-193-007. The county's negotiators are identified as the Humboldt County Public Works Director and or designees thereof. And the parties with whom the county may negotiate are identified as John Stone and Larry O'Doss and any duly authorized agents thereof. It is also the intention of the board to meet in closed session pursuant to California Government Code section 54956.9D1 in order to discuss existing litigation in the case of Bear River Band of Roanerville Rancheria Tribe at all versus California Department of Social Services at all. Case number 4-23-CV-01803. 809-HSG.


10:15 a.m.

Thank you. Great. Do we have an estimated time when we will return? I would estimate about 30 minutes. Awesome. Okay. So, we're closing for closed session. Or we're adjourning. We need to do public comment. Oh, I'm sorry. Let's do public comment. Do we have public comment online? No. All right. Do we have somebody in the room who wants to speak to these items? Of course. Mike, you were doing so good on public comment, and then you made that Coastal Commission move as far as unanimous consent, and it all got distracted. So, there you go. It's legal protocol. I do wish to make comment on a potential acquisition of property. I've been guessing this is pretty close to where we're at here. In your prior decisions, you are taking away quite a bit of parking. I'm parking further and further away from this thing every single time. Now, I'm up past over by the paint store up there. It was the closest parking place I could find. I remember the white paper we made over there that came dry. You crisp things. I said everything is about parking was fine. Let them leave a little bit. It just escalated. So, you kind of said, no, okay. When I say we'd like to take a look at that Yuvalu, that means they like Haida ateler, at flavor. Let's emotion. At least that would be a Android partnership for them in the first place. Maeve재�uties.com glitter. We don't really have any, let's look, let's look before going, here. Okay. You say...


10:16 a.m.

You may consider, if you're going to do development of these properties or things that you do allow for parking, either a parking storage or garage underneath. Parking problem's not going to go away or some other solution when you're doing acquisitions in this area, rather than taking away other parcels that may have potential parking on that's being used in the area already. I did find this interesting, the one with the Bear River Casino, California Department of Social Services. I don't know, maybe this is an ICWA-related thing, but these are all things that happen, and it'll be interesting to see how that's going. So happy Fourth of July. You may get a little more fireworks and litigation than you might anticipate on a major matter here, so that's my prediction. All right, we have received public comment, and we're ready to move to closed session. So we'll see you all back in half an hour, hopefully. Thank you.


11:12 a.m.

Thank you. all right great so we're gonna yeah we've got we have a quorum please thank you before we get online there please straighten that out thank you all right council please report out from closed session thank you vice chair Wilson there was no reportable action taken with regard to items k1 and k2 with that this meeting is adjourned Happy Juneteenth, everybody.