Thank you. Thank you. I wasn't talking to you, I was talking to Mike. Good morning. Welcome to the meeting of Tuesday, October 21st. We're going to go ahead and start. And we're going to start with roll call, please. Supervisor.
Supervisor Bone? Yep. Sorry, one second. Supervisor Royal? Here. Supervisor Wilson? Present. Chair Bushnell? Good morning again. Supervisor Madrone is absent. Okay, we're going to salute her flag, please. flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. CAO Hayes, are there any modifications this morning? Good morning, Chair Bushnell. There's one modification. Item H3 will be pulled from the agenda. Okay, thank you. So we are going to go right into our consent calendar. Any member of the board wish to have comments on the consent calendar?
Thank you. Yeah, there's recognitions that we probably should mention because they've earned them. This comes from the Henderson Center Kiwanis Women in Business, and they've got this year they're recognizing Carol Crosley as Businesswoman of the Year, Dr. Kathy Thornhill as Woman of Distinction, and Jan Carr as Nonprofit Woman of the Year, so I'd like to recognize those. Okay, and then for the Fortuna Kiwanis, this will be happening tomorrow evening. Genevieve Brown is Woman of Distinction, and Sandra Close is Businesswoman of the Year, so congratulations to them both. And then also today we will be closing.
And a journey in memory of Susan Susie Smith, who was a flight nurse that was killed in a helicopter accident on about three weeks ago. And although I didn't know her personally, she flew into Humboldt County often. And I believe Supervisor Bone had an opportunity to meet her. If you read about her accomplishments that she had in her life, she was a huge humanitarian and did a lot of work overseas with her nursing credential. And her flight crew, definitely, and the people that worked with her just really, you know, just honoring her. And she sounds like an exceptional lady. Yeah, she was. I mean, I think. The sheriff's here. I know a lot of his staff and everything. Knew her real well. Dan Bratton, who runs the reach outfit for this area. Jason Chan said she was an exceptional flight nurse.
But the problem, the issue is she wasn't just an exceptional flight nurse, she was an exceptional person. And she brought calm to the bird when they were on it, but she brought calm to outlying areas. As Supervisor Bushnell said, she did a lot of stuff away from her job that benefited the county. So that was a tragic thing. There were two other people injured in that. It was pretty serious, obviously. But anyway, you've got to understand when those flights go out that there's always that possibility. And she did it with a certain amount of calm. And so she gave her life doing what she loved, but she did it very well. Yes. And so we're sending our love to the Reach family and to her family, her husband and children. And just a lot of reflection about what people do for others. And sometimes they give their life. They give their life in service.
Definitely did. So is there, oh, I'm going to have, CAO Hayes is going to make a clarification. Yeah, my apologies. It's item H2 that was pulled. There was some shifting in the agenda. There is no H3, so if anybody was wondering about that, H2 will be pulled from the agenda. Okay, thank you. Any other comment, Supervisor Bond? Number two, I think, was brought by Supervisor Arroyo, maybe. And since I've known some of the parties for well over 20 years that are involved in that station, and the amount of work that has gone into cleaning that station up and making it an asset to Myrtle, I'd like to see this on the consent, because I don't see where there's any issues. I didn't hear from anybody, but we have some owners in there that have a history of doing a very good job in Humboldt County, so I appreciate it. Okay, if there's no other comments from the board, we'll go out to public comment.
We'll start on the zoom. Thank you chair caller 7718. I will unmute you and you'll have three minutes Well, yes, that was one of my points. There wasn't any H3 there. Appreciate you catching that before I had to make mention. I did notice the item number two, the public convenience related to the type 21 alcohol beverage license brought forward by a supervisor of Royal. The main thing is, if you do have a good reputation, I'll trust Rex to say that they did on this. I'm not serving minors. I'm not allowing that to happen. And it's always a major concern. We do have some other establishments around the county that are busted for that so often. And if they're being responsible, I don't have any problem with that moving forward. The other thing I did want to mention, it appears that you're finally coming to the fruition of the down.
I think the petition game commission that you have there down I think from 15 to 10 that's a great move so those are my main comments I think I have for today as far as your concern I thank you for my opportunity to speak. Thank you chair that's all on zoom. Okay any public comment on the room? Good morning Joanne this is on consent calendar if you wish to speak you can line up to okay go ahead. Hi good morning my name is Joanne McGarry and in your adjournment for Susie Smith I didn't know the woman however one of the things that stands out and it's a really important issue is that she was an organ donor and this is something that is a beautiful beautiful contribution people make and so in addition to all the other things in her lifetime that she was able to do to help people in her death she
also did that. So I just wanted to say that about her. Thank you. I didn't know that and I appreciate you saying that. Any other public comment on the consent calendar? Seeing none, I'll close public comment and bring it back to the board and we're going to welcome Supervisor Madron. And if you have any comments on the consent calendar? No? Okay. So I'll be looking for a motion. I'll move consent. I'll second. Thank you. motion carries 5-0 okay we will go right into public comment on non-agenda items and so if you're listening on the zoom we always start with zoom make sure you're not listening to your compute your phone
computer but listen for the prompt and Kaylee is there any public comment on non-agenda items? There is chair. 7718 I will unmute you and you will have three minutes. Hello, thanks a lot. I have a question for someone who works for CWS. He's an attorney. His name is Doug Tabor, and his job is to represent people during CWS trials. So my question for Doug is, is it common legal practice to provide a client file upon request after legal representation ceases? My opinion is it is, and hopefully Mr. Tabor will comply with that request. Many things that a person who's in these kind of trials have is 30-day timeframes, and if they can't get the paperwork they need, they cannot follow through.
Appeals or have their rights dealt with in many ways. So it's been over three months since that's been requested of Mr. Tabor, a county employee there with CWS attorney. Maybe sometime he would respond or have to follow through and do what's required. The second topic I have here was last meeting. There was a comment, if I recall it, made by Mike Wilson, Supervisor Wilson, under the thing where you have to move forward to do a letter of opposition to offshore mining and oil. And it was alleged that there was going to be a sale or something put forward on October 15th. That didn't transpire. So I don't know where Supervisor and Coastal Commissioner Wilson got that information. I tried to track it way up the ladder to see what happened. And there may have been some comment by somebody on staff or the president sometime about looking at it. That sale didn't happen. Or is there any witness? But in the future, there may be.
It seemed to have raised some interest and that was brought forward. So if we do end up with an offshore sale for mining and oil exploration, and that was an exact footprint of the offshore wind, it's kind of interesting. It's okay for us to go ahead. And I don't support either of those projects offshore. But if you can have one, you can have the other. You're such a golden thing, pretty large structures. So I guess if that does happen, I guess the first derrick will probably be named after Mike Lawson, as far as the derelict derrick there. Anyway, sometimes it's best not to bring things to light. And you may get attention to topics that kind of were not happening or laying there. But now it appears to be on somebody's plate. So it's an opportunity to speak on non-agenda items today. Thank you. That's all on Zoom, Chair. Okay. Okay. Now we go to public comment on non-agenda items in the room. Please come forward. Good morning.
Good morning. Thank you. Thank you. I won't read the part about myself as you can read that and I'm not very, I don't like talking about myself. But anyways, I'll move on. I'm here today to express serious concerns shared by me and many of my neighbors in Jacoby Creek area near Upper Jacoby Creek Garden and Glory Lane. Recently, several of us noticed significant grading and tree removal activity on the watershed directly above the creek at the property located at 6108 Jacoby Creek Road. Large trees have been dropped and heavy equipment was used to build roads without any visible permits or timber harvest plan on record. Ironically, the same property owner previously published an op-ed in the Eco News describing his arrest for blocking a legal timber harvest by the city of Arcata, claiming that trees are sacred to his beliefs, but yet less than a year later, the individual is cutting down large trees on his own land without a permit, including one so large that it shook the ground. Beyond that, he's graded appropriately. Approximately a quarter mile of road.
roadways above Jacoby Creek without an engineer permits or regard for the sensitive spawning habitat below. Although code enforcement issued a stop work order in August of 2025, the property owner continued heavy equipment work, and I got photos of that, and even publicly stated plans to build dams, storage ponds, and an eco-village in Jacoby Creek Forest, an area not suited for that level of development. In the packet, you'll see his plans, which are publicly published about this. Neighbors have endured years of safety and nuisance concerns, including aggressive, unrestrained dogs that were officially deemed potentially dangerous by animal control, free-roaming livestock, damaged yards, and even a bonfire during a county-wide burn suspension. Despite repeated warnings, this individual sows a consistent pattern of disregard for county regulations and community safety. Equally concerning, his previous attempts to move people onto the land led to trespassing, theft my property was broken into, and threats of violence.
toward neighbors, including me. This is not just a code violation, it's a public safety issue and watershed protection. For almost eight years, this person has demonstrated a pattern of lawlessness, intimidation of neighbors, and environmental harm. Our community has lost patience and confidence that voluntary compliance will occur. We are respectfully requesting that the property owner be required to restore the graded areas and cease all unpermitted activity, that the county impose civil administrative penalties for continued violations of the stop work order, which continued even yesterday. Should violations persist, that criminal charges be considered. It's an essential water shed, Jacoby Creek, with a source of drinking water and habitat for salmon. It deserves protection, not exploitation. We cannot allow another yee-haw number two situation to develop while enforcement lags behind. We urge the Board of Supervisors to act. Act swiftly and decisively to protect our community, our creek, and the county's credibility.
in enforcing its own laws. Since this time, my house has been broken into. I provided copies of them cutting the chain. Thank you. Good morning again. Good morning. Joanne McGarry here. The three things I want to talk about. One is the bike cage here at the courthouse. I know that the Board of Supervisors doesn't have control over the building necessarily, but I know winter is coming and maybe fewer people will be motivated to ride a bike here, but I do hope come spring we maybe have more adequate and safe bicycle parking and parking for things other than cars so that those of us who want to take, for example, the Humboldt Bay Trail, we can do so and come here to these meetings to be enlightened and enlighten you and then, you know, safely park. Our bicycle. It would be wonderful for those with e-bikes to have a charging.
station. So I just put that out there knowing that things take time, but it really would be an incentive to get people out of their cars. And so once that regional climate action plan is passed, you know, we're doing something to get people to do something different than drive a car. The second thing is I rode my e-bike out to the Foster solar field, I guess, that's on county property, county territory, not in the city of Arcata. And, you know, I love the fact that we're going with renewables and agricultural land. Apparently there's an apiary component to these solar panels, but when we do these large-scale projects on agricultural land, preserving the agricultural component and having a more agro-solar combination, with livestock and
or crops would be wonderful. You know, bees, I guess, is one thing, but, you know, sheep and crops would be another thing. So those are two things that I'd like to bring up in the one minute I have left. I just want to remind us because everything that happens anywhere in the world affects us. And what has happened in the past two years with the horror show in Gaza has affected us in so many ways, monetarily with tax dollars, you know, emotionally, personally, with the horrors of what's happening to humanity over there and to the climate. And I just want to say that we passed a ceasefire resolution. There was supposed to ceasefire a couple weeks ago. It's not going to happen. We're going to have to wait until the end of the year. So I just want to being upheld by the state of Israel. And we should start considering how to vote.
voice our concern about what is really going on in that part of the world. And it matters to all of us. It affects all of us. So I just want to say that out loud. Thank you. So those of you that came in, this is a public comment on non-agenda items. If you would like to make a public comment on non-agenda items, please come forward. Good morning, Charles. My name is Charles Wilson. Uh, we've been protesting, uh, at the courthouse corner for about five years now. We've never been in the newspaper. The Time Standard had a one-time protest against Trump in their headlines a couple of days ago. Media doesn't like Trump, and their purpose is to control public opinion, not necessarily report it. At the beginning of the government COVID, nonsense times, we would get 15 to...
20 honks. Lots of fingers and screaming, but after the death data started leaking out, we were getting 600 to 700 honks in two hours. Motorists probably can't read our signs because they're driving by so fast, but they like to see a human waving at them. We like to make them happy. 50. Motorists don't honk at a billboard. Here's a sign. This is my current sign. I say, no number 50. Government is our servant, not our master. We don't live in China. We think for ourselves. The politicians in the states of California, and Texas are our nation's leaders.
They both think alike, and they both show the proper concern and way to control us people. California, however, is making a big mistake with this special election that's costing us $290 million. That's a lot of money. That's taxpayer money, not government money. That's almost a third of a billion dollars. It doesn't matter that California has a deficit of $20 billion. We have an innovative group of high-paid legislators, however, and they know how to manipulate us in the direction of their demand. They have lots and lots of tax money, but it shouldn't be wasted, like Democrat governors do. Governor Gusom is a great example of that.
doing. My suggestion is that instead of wasting so much of our tax money on this stupid election, we should have, they should have passed a law giving Texas $290 million so that they can fight their state's politicians' trick to rig their election. California has- Okay, is it three minutes? Yep, that was three minutes. Okay, my, my, anyway. Thank you. No, you can't finish. Our affiliating party is the- Charles, you can't finish. Thank you. Any other public commenter on non-agenda items? Seeing none, I will close public comment, and we're going to go to our first public hearing of the day, and this comes to us from planning and building.
Thank you. Good morning, Chair Bushnell, members of the Board of Supervisors, John Ford, Rodney Yandel, and Augustus Grishow to present this modification to the reasonable accommodation provisions of our zoning ordinance. Okay, I think I need to open the public hearing. You do. Okay, so I'm going to do that and then I'm going to have you continue. Thank you. And before Mr. Grishow begins this, and this isn't very complicated, it's really to comply with state law, I wanted to say that we've been diligently working on getting our housing ordinances updated, and Mr. Grishow, that's his primary responsibility. So you'll see him rolling through here with housing ordinances on a pretty regular cadence. He's doing a fantastic job and he and Rodney, Mr. Yandel, are just doing super. So with that.
All right, so this is the updates to the reasonable accommodation ordinance as John Ford said specifically about residential accessibility. So reasonable accommodations for residential accessibility need to be permitted ministerial per state law and presently our code says they need to be special permits. So we're fixing that and they are still appealable to you guys at the board. A reasonable accommodation is changes, exceptions, or adjustments to rules, policies, or practices for individuals with disabilities such that they have an equal opportunity to use and enjoy the whole of a dwelling and the intent here is to eliminate barriers that prevent individuals with disabilities from fully participating in housing opportunities. For example, if someone needs to have a ramp such that so that they can access their home, a reasonable accommodation is a reasonable accommodation. A reasonable accommodation may be required to reduce the setbacks if it can't be built otherwise.
outside of them. And these are changes in accordance with housing element implementation measure number 67, which promised to amend section 312, excuse me, 312-42 ex sequentes, which is the requests for modifications or exceptions for residential accessibility code section, such that they're consistent with the Americans with Disabilities Act and fair housing standards at both the state and federal level. We've also included other anti-discrimination laws, such as California Government Code section 11135 and the Rehabilitation Act section 504, which is federal. And planning staff recommends that you all adopt this resolution, which does, which, excuse me, which finds that the proposed amendments to the zoning ordinance are exempt from environmental review and makes all required findings. Thank you.
We will adopt the amendments to the zoning regulations as described in the staff report. That ends my presentation, but we're happy to answer any questions y'all may have. That's a very brief summary of everything. Thank you. Are there any questions from the board? No? Seeing none, we're going to go out to a public comment, and we'll start on the Zoom. Thank you, Chair. Caller 7718, I will unmute you, and you will have three minutes. Thank you. I noticed that the CEQA basically is being eliminated throughout all of California because of the desire to have outing when they're willing to throw away the environmental guidelines that protect that. I've never seen this before. It's the first time. I find it interesting that CEQA is exempt from review under the common sense exemption. So I guess that one person's common sense is...
I don't see a problem. You have to comply with state laws. But I did want to point out the fact that the elimination of CEQA in Excel is not a common sense thing. Thank you, Mark. Can you speak on this? Thank you. That's all on Zoom. Okay. Is there any public comment in the room on this item? Seeing none, I will close public comment and bring it back to the board. I'd like to make a motion to adopt the resolution, to adopt the ordinance, and to direct the clerk of the board to publish the post-adoption summary in all parts of the recommended staff actions. I'll second. Okay. We have a first and a second. Thank you.
It disappeared again. Kaylee, can you do a roll call, please? Supervisor Bone? Supervisor Arroyo? Yes. Chair Bushnell? Yes. Supervisor Wilson? Yes. Supervisor Madrone? Yes. Motion carries 5-0. Okay. Thank you. We actually are going to do, you guys are going to have to move and come back. Sorry. So we'll go from there. We're going to go to the next public hearing, which comes to us from Public Works. Let me get back to it. Okay. So we're going to, oh, this is the one you pulled. H2 was pulling. I'm sorry, John. I moved you guys for nothing. Aerobics.
Okay, so the next one was pulled. So we're going to go back to planning and building for a departmental report. And this is adoption of a vehicle miles travel policy by resolution for CEQA threshold and screening criteria. And we're going to go back to Director Ford. My apologies. That is correct. Thank you, Chair, members of the Board of Supervisors, John Ford, and Rodney Yandel, to present the VMT guidelines. And I'm going to pull the item up so we have a presentation. And what this is intended to do was with the change in CEQA to change the review criteria for environmental impacts related to transportation from level of service. To VMT. This provides guidelines for.
whether or not it's subject to additional environmental review or whether it can be exempted. And so I'm going to pull the presentation up here very quickly, or do you already have it up? It's going to take me a second to get set up. Sorry about that. That's fine. Take your time. We're clipping along pretty quick here. Do you want us to take a five-minute break? Please. Okay. We're going to take a five-minute break, and we'll come back. Okay. Thank you.
you Okay. Go ahead and start. All right. Good morning, Board of Supervisors and the public. My name is Megan Acevedo, and I'm here to present the Vehicle Miles Travel Threshold Policy.
SB 743 was signed into law in 2013, which changed how local governments assess transportation impacts under CEQA by switching the primary metric from level of service to vehicle miles traveled. Starting in July of 2020, local governments were required to assess projects' transportation impacts using the VMT metric, either by adopting thresholds of significance or by reviewing project impacts on a case-by-case basis. The department has been assessing projects' transportation impacts with the VMT metric on a case-by-case basis, and we are proposing to set guidelines through the VMT threshold policy. Setting VMT thresholds will provide for better consistency in assessing projects' transportation impacts. To comply with CEQA and enhance the use of vehicle miles, the VMT metric for project review, we have developed the draft. The VMT...
threshold policy that is being presented today. Development of the policy was done using the Office of Planning and Research's technical advisory on evaluating transportation impacts in CEQA by incorporating recommendations from fair and peers traffic consultants and information from the VMT study report and through consultation with other local jurisdictions. The VMT policy establishes a baseline for existing VMT and sets quantitative thresholds to determine a project's level of impact under CEQA. It outlines appropriate screening criteria for projects considered to have a less than significant impact without a detailed VMT analysis and sets guidelines for a detailed analysis when a project cannot be screened out. The overall goal of the policy is to encourage development in appropriate areas that would result in lower VMT.
Analyzing a project under CEQA determines if a project would have a less than significant impact, would have a less than significant impact with mitigation, or would have an impact that is significant and unavoidable. Adopting specific screening criteria in the VMT policy would allow for efficiency when assessing transportation impacts by identifying early on if a project is considered to have a less than significant impact or if further detailed analysis is needed to determine the project's level of impact. Here is a list of the recommended screening criteria, which have been developed using the recommendations of the OPR Technical Advisory. The following criteria would identify projects considered to have a less than significant impact without preparing a detailed VMT analysis.
Projects that would be screened out include small projects that generate less than 110 trips per day, residential and employment projects located within low VMT mapped areas, mixed use projects located within all applicable low VMT mapped areas, projects within a half mile of a major transit stop identified by HCOG's regional transportation plan, 100% affordable housing projects located within urban areas, local serving retail projects that are under 50,000 square feet, and redevelopment projects that would not increase VMT from existing uses. The options for low VMT screening areas will be discussed further in the presentation, and it should be noted that there are currently no major transit stops in unincorporated Humboldt County, but there are plans to increase. The list of major transit stops identified in the regional transportation plan
such as one being proposed on Central Avenue with the approved McKinleyville Town Center. To assess projects against the VMT metric, specific methodology needs to be identified first. The following VMT metrics are established in the proposed policy and were developed using the recommended VMT per capita methodology in the OPR technical advisory. The two established metrics are VMT per resident and VMT per employee. The VMT per resident data would be used to assess residential projects, and the VMT per employee data would be used to assess employment projects or projects that have employees, including retail, commercial, and industrial projects. The VMT policy is a very important part of the OPR technical advisory. The VMT policy also sets thresholds of significance for new development projects.
line with the recommendations in the OPR technical advisory. As there are two baselines established for existing VMT, there are two thresholds to follow. The thresholds being recommended are 15% below the baseline for residential projects and 15% below the baseline for employment projects. Existing baseline VMT for the county was established in the VMT study report from Ferron-Pierce, which utilized 2022 streetlight data to estimate the average trip length per resident and per employee. The study found that for unincorporated Humboldt County, the average VMT per resident was 22.1 miles per day, and the average VMT per employee was 14.1 miles per day. The study also identified countywide VMT averages, which includes data for the incorporated cities.
Averages were found to be 20.1 miles per day for residents and 13.2 miles per day for employees. According to the technical advisory, the county has the option to use the unincorporated county averages, option one identified in the staff report, or the countywide averages, option two identified in the staff report, to set the baseline VMT and thresholds from. On May 1st, 2025, the planning commission was split on whether to use the unincorporated county data or the countywide data to establish the baseline VMT and thresholds from. Option one would establish a higher threshold with lower intensity, and option two would establish a lower threshold with higher intensity. This will also affect the established low VMT screening areas, and staff's recommendation is to utilize the unincorporated, unincorporated county data, option one, because this.
is more reflective of the county's jurisdictional area. Here's a map of the low VMT areas for residential projects using the unincorporated county data for average VMT per resident. This map identifies U.S. census block groups that were found to have an existing VMT that is already 15% or more below the average for the unincorporated county. However, staff recommended removing the outlying block groups from the low VMT mapped areas to encourage development in infill areas. Here is a map of the residential low VMT screening areas that are being recommended for adoption. This map removes the outlying rural block groups from the available mapped screening criteria, which is in line with the intent of encouraging development in infill areas. Going with the countywide average, including the city's data, would further reduce the risk of
the available screening areas from this map. This slide shows the difference in screening areas for residential projects using the unincorporated county average, option one shown in the map on the left, compared to using the county-wide average, option two shown in the map on the right. You can see that there are several block groups in McKinleyville and around Fortuna that would not be included on the county-wide low VMT screening map for residential projects. Here is a map of the low VMT areas for employment projects using the unincorporated county data for average VMT per employee. This map identifies U.S. census block groups that were found to have an existing VMT that is already 15% or more below the average for the unincorporated county. However, staff recommended removing the outline of the
and block groups from the low VMT mapped areas to better encourage VMT reduction. Here is a map of the employment low VMT screening areas that are being recommended for adoption. This map removes the outlying block groups from the available map screening criteria for future employment projects. Going with the countywide average, including the cities, would further reduce the available screening areas from this map. This slide shows the difference in screening areas for employment projects using the unincorporated county average, option 1 shown in the map to the left, compared to using the countywide average, option 2 shown in the map to the right. You can see that there are several block groups that would not be included on the countywide low VMT screening map for employment projects. Okay.
The VMT policy would provide appropriate screening criteria for projects that would automatically be considered to have a less than significant transportation impact and determine that no further VMT analysis is required. Projects that cannot be screened out would require further analysis to determine their level of impact, and projects found to be above the threshold through a detailed analysis would need to apply mitigation strategies to the extent feasible. Mitigation strategies applied may reduce project impacts to a level that would be considered less than significant with mitigation or would be determined to have a significant and unavoidable impact. Here's a flowchart from the draft policy guidelines, which shows the step-by-step process for VMT impact assessment under CEQA. Projects that conduct a VMT analysis would require further analysis to determine their level of impact, and projects found to be less than significant with mitigation or would be determined to have a significant impact.
that are found to be above the established threshold and apply mitigation strategies can potentially reduce their impacts to a level of less than significant. Or if they are still found to be above the threshold with mitigation strategies applied, they would be found to have a significant and unavoidable impact with mitigation. Mitigation strategies can be quantified using the California Air Pollution Control Officers Association's or CAPCOA calculation methodologies for transportation demand management strategies. In the current handbook for analyzing greenhouse gas emission reductions, assessing climate vulnerabilities, and advancing health and equity. Further, if you have any questions, you can contact the California Air Pollution Control Officers Association. This is described as the handbook. Methodology and guidance provided in the handbook from the chapter on transportation.
shall be used to determine the VMT reductions achieved through mitigation strategies that are applied in a detailed VMT analysis. Here's a table showing the potential VMT reductions that could be achieved by mitigation strategies as identified in the CAPCOA handbook for calculating reductions. These strategies can be combined in a project to achieve a less than significant impact with mitigation. We received public comments on the policy, and after review and consideration of these comments, along with requests from the Planning Commission, the following changes were made to the guidelines document. We added language that a reassessment will be done. In 2030, to determine if there is a need to update the baseline VMT for the county,
We added language to specify that employment projects would include projects that have employees, including industrial and commercial projects. We added language to include utilizing the trip generation guide from the Institute of Traffic Engineers in a detailed project VMT analysis. We removed the rural block groups from the low VMT screening maps. We updated major transit station to be major transit stop in line with the regional transportation plan. And we referenced the CAPCOA handbook for calculating VMT reductions from mitigation. And lastly, we removed the use of cleaner fuel vehicles from the mitigation strategies. As well, the policy guidelines will be updated to include the low VMT screening areas that are being decided on by the board. Staffs recommend...
The recommendation is that the Board of Supervisors adopt the resolution finding that the proposed policy for VMT thresholds is not a project pursuant to CEQA guidelines, sections 15060C3 and 15378B5, and adopt the proposed VMT threshold policy guidelines establishing thresholds of significance and screening criteria for the purpose of analyzing VMT transportation impacts under CEQA, utilizing either the unincorporated county data or countywide data to establish the baseline and CEQA thresholds. And that concludes my presentation. Thanks so much. So I'll bring it back to the board for comments. Clarification. I have just a quick question here. Supervisor Wilson. Thanks. In terms of the choices before us, right, in moving this forward.
Am I to understand that we're choosing between like county average or jurisdictional averages? Is that part of this? I mean, there was these. Yes, absolutely. Just clarify, please. Sure. So the baseline data is really important because it does two things. One, it establishes the VMT for a given area. And just as a baseline. And then when you subtract 15% from that, then those areas automatically screen out from having to do additional VMT analysis. If they're already 15% below the baseline. Okay. When you use a lower baseline, obviously, the 15% goes lower. And so you see areas like McKinleyville that then would not screen out.
And so part of the policy decision with this is do you want to have areas in the county that would screen out and as priority areas to allow development? Or do you want to remove those and have a higher, basically, threshold that then would require more projects to do that analysis? And in doing the analysis, they may still have a less than significant impact, but they may not, and then they may have to do mitigation. Okay. When we get to the part about making a motion on this, I may need, or some of us, at least, I don't know who's going to make a motion here, but we're going to probably need a little help in framing that. Yeah. I appreciate that. I'm sorry. It is a little bit complicated.
Because it's like baseline DMT, you know, that just doesn't make sense for most people. But what it really is talking about is that there are areas where, because of the nature of the location, the trips there are not real high. In fact, one of the things that we found absolutely counterintuitive was the fact that there were those huge blobs that are way out in the area. And talking to the traffic engineers about why, it's because those folks don't travel every day. They stay on their land. And so there's not really a commute trip. So for residential purposes, we really don't want to encourage residences there. And that's why we're proposing taking them out. But they would still fall under the exemption of a small project because not many of them would have projects that exceed that threshold. So we're not...
Removing their ability to do anything without a DMT analysis, we're just not encouraging residential development there. Okay, that's helpful. Let's see where it goes from here. Supervisor Arroyo? I mean, I understand that methodology to a point, but can we go back to the countywide versus unincorporated decision? And I know this was like a sticking point for the Planning Commission as well, if I'm not mistaken, or maybe they're hangups or something else. But when we think about projects, it is hard to – I mean, people don't stay within either living or working within the unincorporated part of the county solely. We are sort of married to our incorporated partners in the community. When it comes to –
you know, where people live and work. And I guess I'm having a hard time wrapping my mind around why we would, I understand that we only have jurisdiction over the unincorporated portion of the county, but why would we use that higher threshold? That's a great question. Thank you for that. The struggle is that the cities, as you would expect, have far lower VMT because a lot of people, of residences travel to and from work within the city, or the businesses don't generate a lot of VMT because they attract from the local area, whereas the county is a little bit more broad. So when you add the cities into the countywide average, it lowers the countywide average. The unincorporated number really represents how people in the county travel. Whereas the other is...
with how the city travels. And so in that context, you would expect the county to have a little bit higher VMT because people in the county travel further, things are more spread out, whereas things in the city are far closer together. But you're right. There are people who travel from Arcata to Eureka, and so that's all in that data. Thank you. Supervisor Bone? So, and I really don't understand this. The baseline, is that the average you figure? And so you're talking about taking three miles up, 15%, three miles off the baseline if the baseline is 20.1 or depending, you know, or 20 whatever. The 15% reduction? Yeah. So we're looking at.
You're saying most everybody only travels in their vehicle 7,300 miles annually then? No, we're not saying that. We're saying for the trips that are included, which are typically commute trips, that's what the average is. Okay. And the 15% is not an arbitrary number. That comes from the state guidelines in terms of what it should be. Some jurisdictions go higher, some go lower. So it is arbitrary. If it's not arbitrary, then it's set. But if some go higher, some go lower, it sounds like they're not going with the set rate. So that would make it... Arbitrary. Well, what we are trying to do is go with the established recommendation from the state, which places us in a good position to be able to...
and the policy. If you want to go lower, you've got to really figure out why it should be lower than 15%. If you want to go higher, you've got to have criteria for going higher, and the recommendation that came from us was to stay at 15%. Okay. Thank you. Can I back you up to the comment that you made about not encouraging building in, I'm assuming it's the very rural areas? Right. And what I'm talking about there are large housing developments. Okay. Okay. Not single units? The single units would screen out as a small project. Okay. Single family residential wouldn't be subject to this. It's exempt. Okay. What about housing project in, say, Southern Humboldt, which is very far removed from services? So a housing project.
That is a single-family housing project that's 11 or less units would realistically screen out under the small project exemption. Okay. A multifamily project that was 12 to 13 units, multifamily 12 to 13 units would screen out under the small project criteria. Bigger than, larger than 13? They would need to do a VMT analysis if they're subject to CEQA, yes. And so that could affect larger building units down in that area? It could. If they were doing an affordable project, they wouldn't be subject to this. Right, I understand that. Yeah. Okay. Supervisor Fone? Supervisor Fone. Supervisor Fone. They also would be subject to this. They also would be subject to it if I read it right.
Within a half mile of a transit stop and I'm and I could I see we're changing the name of major transportation stop. What makes a major transportation stop just to cover? I think we are an example that HCOG differed a little bit from where the state went with the major transportation stop or station. I believe it was and adopted the major transportation stop for Humboldt County. What what what would that what would that be? Because it's it's hard for one hundred and thirty thousand people to have anything major up here spread out over forty four hundred square miles. So I know yesterday we tried to make something or we did make something more urban like I can answer that. I was part of the designation of that. So if that's helpful. Yeah. Yeah. Sure. I mean, Stephen. I are both at the HCOG meetings, but since in the transit role, I go in that in that particular.
It is true, and so the HTA board made a recommendation to HCOG around this. So it either needs to meet a certain number of trips per day, which just based on our population we struggle to meet, or be designated in the regional transportation plan. So there are stops in Humboldt County that don't meet that state threshold because that's geared towards the LA metro area. It's hundreds of stuff. Oh, we're getting there. It's hundreds of riders a day, and we generally don't have that at stops. And so the HCOG regional transportation plan has designated those instead. And I thought that we had designated one in McKinleyville, but I could be mistaken that that was. We left the option to expand to that. Thank you. So they're simply designated by the local transportation planning authority. So can I back you up to. So can I ask, 3rd and H would be considered.
Because they have 354 a day? Yeah, 3rd and H is certainly. 354 with 38 buses, I think, or something. Yes, that's one of our major transit stops. What would be another one? But it's not any transit stop. I hope that's helpful. The Arcadia Transit Center and the mall. Thank you. The Bayshore Mall is a big transfer point. So backing up to my question, I don't think Southern Humboldt is one of those. No. And so that would curtail building in that area? Could. It could if people wanted to build a large track of residential. And not low-income but moderate apartments. Correct. Correct. Yep. Through the chair, just clarifying. With.
Supervisor Luchinel was talking about curtailing. We're really talking about exemptions from the existing law is what we're talking about. So is that? We're talking about projects, number one, that are subject to CEQA. Yeah. And one of the things that we try to do is look at our general plan. Yeah. And if it's consistent with the general plan and it's in the area that has a community plan or something like that, we can typically use the provision in CEQA that allows use of that environmental document that was certified for that area. And then we don't have to do additional CEQA analysis, which this wouldn't even come into play. Yeah. So this isn't a prohibition necessarily. Actually, we're just talking about taking layers off of the analysis in some cases. We're not talking about adding analysis. Correct.
Correct. This should streamline analysis where we do actually have to do VMT analysis. So there's nothing that we're doing that's making anything more difficult? That's not a true statement. Well, I'm trying to... Over what we're doing now, if there are projects currently, if there are projects that would be subject to CEQA and we're getting to the VMT analysis, there is no ability currently to exempt them from that analysis. Right. So we're still talking about exemptions. We're not talking about adding things. We're talking about removing things. So what we're really saying is in areas where there are higher intensity of people, they tend to travel less miles, we're not going to require them to do VMT. Great. Thank you. So I'm going to ask a question around that, though. Community plan areas in the southern Humboldt area are very small.
And construction goes outside of those community plan areas very often, including the Shelter Cove area. And so those folks would have to, they would be required to adhere to this. Is that correct or not? That is correct. Okay. Yeah. And I mean, I know it seems we've had that discussion a lot between us is the whole fairness of it. Yeah. But what we're being asked to do by the state, both from a traffic perspective and a greenhouse gas emissions perspective, and they are related, is to reduce the number of miles people drive. No, I understand. But also it hits into the Carlotta and Hydesville area as well. There are many parcels out there that are out of community plan areas designation. Well, and that does. That does hit at one of the things Ms. Osvito.
mentioned was that using the county-wide or the city-wide, I'm sorry, unincorporated area-wide option one would open that area up just, well, quite a bit. Okay. Supervisor Bone, then Supervisor Arroyo. So, and I'm thinking of the areas much like Perndale that doesn't have a major. Is there a way, since if we have a prerogative or we're being arbitrary, of taking in the fact of Southern Humboldt has, let's say, approximately 7,500 people down there in proper Southern Humboldt, and comparatively speaking, Greater Eureka area has probably 35, 40 when you throw in Cutton and everything else that has buses going out to it. Is there a way to arbitrarily adjust for the population in the area? Because they have the same issues. They're on a smaller scale, you know.
You know, we're building quite a few, over 150 units now that are in construction right now in Eureka, but a lot of that's going to be subsidized, a lot of it's going to be, you know, so. That could be done, and I think there are those who would advocate for that. The struggle with that is that we would have to go back and redo all the analysis that we've done, and if that's the direction of the board, you know, we'll look for funding and do that. Well, there's just a certain level of fairness or comparability for people that don't live in our perceived urban areas or what we're trying to make urban areas and don't necessarily want a four-story apartment building, you know, because they want their kids to play outside, but they have, they want a place to live in the city. They want to store their things and stuff, so, you know, in the out...
outlying areas that have bus service maybe it'll increase with that they could they have more room to um i guess sprawl is the famous word but i mean to use up more space because it's available understand i i think that one of the things and and at the end of the day this was was kind of where i landed relative to the rural areas we do not see huge projects come through and and so they would fall under the small project exemption and i mean maybe that's not enough but i i i haven't seen anything over an 11 or 11 parcel subdivision in my time here down south and and so i don't know that we would be affecting anything can i um well supervisor roy is next then i'll go yeah i just wondered if you
I understand this is the reduction that's a little bit different than what the Air Resources Board direction is. The new Air Resources Board state direction was to reduce VMT by 25%. Now we're looking at a minus 15% exemption. I know those aren't perfectly matched criteria, but can you explain how we're getting to that 25% reduction through this? So the 25% reduction is a reduction that includes not only new development but existing development. It includes moving people from driving single occupant vehicles to being on transit to using bicycles to electric bikes and that sort of thing. Whereas this really is focused on new development and reducing the number of miles that people are traveling.
We would expect them to travel for new development. Do you think that this is the right tool to get us closer to that goal? I think this is a step in the right direction, absolutely. And that's part of the reason why I think the Planning Commission wanted to see it reexamined in 2030, that as we're reexamining the Regional Climate Action Plan that will be coming to you before the end of this calendar year, that will need to be reexamined. This will need to be reexamined. And so the lead up to 2030 will reexamine a lot of things to see how effective these are. I'm going to go to Supervisor Madron, but clarification, what was Planning Commission's vote? Well, no. They were two to two. They were split on the option one or option two. But then when they said, board, here, we can't decide. You are going to need to decide. I believe they all. I believe they all voted yes.
Yeah. Okay. Supervisor McGowan. Yeah, so, John, as you know, in the approval of the town center ordinance yesterday for McKinleyville, there is a transit center proposed there. In addition, in recent discussions with Caltrans around the Vista Point Park concept, the development of the airport business park, further development at the airport, there is a new concept that Caltrans had brought it forward about a transit center on Airport Road right at Highway 101 that would serve a commuter route in particular with shuttles up and back, back and forth to the airport. Would either of those things change what we're doing here today? I mean, I don't think they would, but I'm just curious. Well, if they were effective, what would happen is more people would be riding the bus. Yes. And so the VMT for those areas that... It was serving would go down.
That's a positive in both directions, regardless of which one. And it might be two, maybe a downtown center and it may be a highway center for different purposes, frankly. Okay, thank you. So we're going to go out to public comment. I have one last clarifying question. Is there, and I hear what you're saying about you haven't had those developments come from the southern area, but is there a process to mitigate this if there were, because this will also affect Bembo, all of that area. It's basically all of southern Humboldt. And so what would be the process, because there is no, I don't anticipate ever getting those bus stops down there that meet that criteria. Community plan areas are very small down there. So what would be the process? So the process is, keep in mind, they're already in. The CEQA process. They're already doing technical studies on a bunch of things. Okay. One of those would.
and be on VMT. In the like Bembo area, Piercy area? Yep. Okay. And so it's just really determining and doing the VMT study doesn't necessarily mean that, as Ms. Acevedo said, that there's a significant adverse impact. It's just having to do the study. Who does the study? Typically a traffic engineer. Who? A traffic engineer. Who pays for the study? Usually the applicant, the developer. How much do those cost normally? I'd be guessing if I told you right now. We don't see many of them. But does it require it? It requires probably between $5,000 and $10,000. Okay. We're going to go to public comment on Zoom, please. Thank you, Chair. Caller 5603, I will unmute you and you will have three minutes. Does that make sense? I do, Kids. Is there another question or posting from here? No questions, 2010, 2016, 2000, 2012. Can we all go back to page 6 James? And it's like, I'm starting to wonder where are we going with this and all the stuff. This looks kind of awkward but try to do something. Not quite dished out. Not quite it or something. Let's take a look.
Thank you. Good morning. This is Colin Fisk with CRTP. The current California's coping plan for climate, as you heard, calls for a 25 percent reduction in VMT per capita, and we would prefer that the county adopt the threshold that aligns with that goal, but you know we can accept the proposed 15 percent reduction, which has been standard in recent years, as long as there's an appropriate baseline set. Now staff have recommended either using the county-wide average or the unincorporated average, and that would make sense for a city or for a smaller or more homogeneous county, but it doesn't really make sense for Humboldt. The CEQA guidelines provide information on how a baseline should be set. Specifically, the baseline describes either existing conditions or projected future conditions in the absence of the project. In the case of VMT, one way to think of it is how much driving a potential future resident or employee of the project would do in the absence of the project. That can be estimated by looking at the existing VMT in the immediate vicinity, but the logic
down over larger geographical areas. So for example, let's say a project developer wanted to build apartments in Myrtle Town. Potential tenants are presumably people who want to live in a place within a reasonable commute distance, which means they work or go to school somewhere nearby. They probably live or want to live in the Eureka area. They may also look at places like Arcata to live, maybe even McKinleyville or Fortuna, but they're unlikely to consider a place in Orleans or Garberville or Petrolia. So the baseline conditions can be the average VMT in Myrtle Town or in the greater Eureka area or even in the area stretching all the way from Fortuna to McKinleyville, but it can't be the average over the entire county because that's basically a meaningless number that masks large regional variations. The size and diversity of our county demand more than a single county-wide baseline, and the idea of using only the unincorporated county average makes even less sense because city limits have nothing to do with how people travel, and environmental impacts are not as important as the city limits. So the baseline conditions under CEQA are not constrained by jurisdiction.
boundaries. So we ask that you divide the county into smaller sub-regions that reasonably reflect housing and job markets and establish separate baselines and thresholds for each region. The consultant, Taryn Pierce, has actually made VMT estimates by Census Block Group publicly available and have derived those estimates from the same 2022 streetlight data that the county has used for its estimates. So establishing sub-regional thresholds shouldn't be very expensive or arduous, but it must be done. Thank you. Thank you. Caller 7718, I will unmute you and you will have three minutes. I always find it interesting that a seat was supposed to be an environmental assessment as effects on the environment. And yet now it's determined that if you are not a wealthy person, you are living in a certain...
category of financial housing, you have no effect on the environment you're exempt from SEPA. So in other words, someone could go down and build unlimited things down in Garverville or that area, out of the area, as long as they have a certain category of income for the people or things of that nature they're exempt. I have a, you know, we're putting an awful lot of time and effort into a lot of these things, and I look at what I consider experiments in transportation. And the biggest experiment we've had is, I think, $20 million between Arcata and Eureka. And we were told that we were going to have all kinds of people commuting back and forth. And my observation is kind of a little close to what Rex mentioned yesterday, and I think it was 8th Street or Ice-Cree or something like that, 17 Bikes, with the same happening between Arcata and Eureka. They had movies where hundreds of people were going back and forth on this thing. And I think that's a really good example of what we're seeing. And I think that's a really good example of what we're seeing. And I think that's a really good example of what we're seeing. And I didn't see it happening while I was there, and I'm getting since the word.
change more negative for you folks positive for me down here you're having less people commuting on that basis um i strongly suggest that you go ahead and move forward with whatever uh john ford recommends on these particular things don't spend a lot more money doing more studies doing more diversification on this uh follow the minimum that you're required for this case of course nothing gives us nothing but unfounded mandates for that major negative effect on what we want to do in humboldt county so best of luck with this one Thank you. That's all on Zoom. Public comment in the room on this item? Hello again. Hi. My name is Joanne McGarry. I was at the Planning Commission meeting where some of this was discussed. I love how we get down to just calling at VMT, and it really helps me.
my brain to talk about vehicle miles traveled because it was part of the climate action plan discussion and as i spoke about earlier today at this meeting um uh the climate the global climate what happens anywhere in the world affects people elsewhere in the world and uh for humboldt county to really work hard and recognize that we are at a point in our world where we need to take urgent action on these types of issues i just kind of want to say out loud it makes sense to do as best we can to um reduce the use of um individual vehicles for people and improve our collective travel plans whether you live inside a city or in a far off way
In a rural community in Humboldt County, we all collectively as human beings living here need to do what we can to change the way we are doing things now that are horribly impacting the planet and the climate. Thank you. Any other public comment on this item? Seeing none, I'll close public comment. And Director Ford, do you want an option to respond? Thank you very much, Chair. Thanks. I don't know that there is a lot to respond to. You heard the comment about developing sub-regions. That's similar to what Supervisor Bone was bringing up. It can be done. It's more complicated. And what I think what...
The more broad approach does is it really highlights that there are areas that are appropriate to allow the exemption from doing the analysis within certain areas of the county. And the change, the change that that results in is that right now everybody does a BMT analysis. Everybody does one right now. Under this, there would be certain areas that already have very low BMT that would not need to do an analysis. I'll give you an example. The Nordic project. The BMT analysis with that went through and identified the travel lengths associated with that area on the Samoa Peninsula. It was much lower than what the region. The regional travel model right now shows for average.
and it identified there was more than 15% below that. So it found a less insignificant impact related to traffic. In this particular setting, if this were adopted, it wouldn't have had to do that analysis. That's the major change. Can I clarify that single-family residences do this currently? No. I'm sorry. Only if they're subject to CEQA. Okay. Single-family residence is not subject to CEQA. So everyone doesn't do it right currently. Correct. I'm sorry. I misspoke. Everybody that's subject to doing environmental analysis needs to do this currently. Okay. So I'm going to bring it back to the board. We're going to look for a motion. Thanks. My question for the director is, do you feel like there would be a significant, significant impact, significant difference?
In the areas that would be exempted from VMTs, if we were to follow the recommendation of the caller around doing regional analysis, would it be, you know, we would, if we were to go down that path, we would pay to do a study that would take a look at that and more refined thing. But would it, you know, just a gut check here in terms of the change in area, would it be much reduced? Well, I think if you made areas into smaller granular sections that were more homogeneous, there would not be areas then that stand out as having lower VMT than other areas already. Because everything, the areas are homogeneous. You've got small little sections. Right. And so there wouldn't be the ability to identify, well, they're already low, that area.
It doesn't travel as much. And so you wouldn't be able to do things. You're telling me you're you think that there might not be much of a difference is what I'm getting at. It's like I think you would end up doing VMT analysis for everything. OK. All right. OK. I have a question before if you're going to make a motion. Yeah. And so then basically. I mean I'm just really narrowing it down. From a from just an environmental perspective or from a VMT perspective option two is the more conservative option. Is that is correct. Yeah. OK. I'm happy to make a motion that we find that the proposed policy for VMT VMT threshold is not a project pursuant to Section 15 0 6 0 C. 3 and 15 3 7.
8B5 of the state CEQA guidelines and adopt the proposed VMT threshold policy seen in attachment to establishing thresholds of significance and screening criteria for the purpose of analyzing VMT transportation impacts under CEQA utilizing the countywide data including the incorporated city data to establish the baseline VMT and CEQA thresholds. I'll second. Director Ford, tell me how CEQA covers the Bumbo area or the Shelter Cove area or the Sprawl Creek area. Bumbo, I believe, is outside the Garveyville Community Plan area. Yes, it is. So that area could not, it may be able to qualify for the general consistency with the general plan. And. And if it's determined to be completely consistent with the general plan, the general plan.
IR addresses all the environmental effects associated with that. We would use the 15153 provision that allows consistency with the general plan to be used. So it's not a guarantee, though, that if there was a project to come into those areas, which are mostly, there's not a lot of buildable area in Garberville at all. Very little in Redway. And so if there was a project that was to come, it would be outside of those areas. There is not, you can't tell me that it would fall under a criteria that would be allowed. If it was a bigger project than the 11 units and it was a moderate income. So what I'm saying, if it comes in and is consistent with the land use and zoning. Yeah. And we believe that it's covered under the general plan EIR. Right. It wouldn't be subject to CEQA. Right. The things that are largely going to be subject to CEQA are things that are changing the EIR. The general plan changing zoning. Mm-hmm.
Which happens a ton down there. Yeah. Okay. Kaylee, I believe we need to do a roll call, please. Kaylie, can you do roll call? Supervisor Bone. I just hope this is a weapon for development. I will. Vote yes. Supervisor Wilson? Yes. Supervisor Arroyo? Yes. Supervisor Madrone? Yes. Chair Bushnell? No. Motion carries 4-1. I also will clarify for staff that this is very this is my constituent base.
And, you know, it passed anyways, but it's what I'm here for. Thank you. Understand. Okay, we're going to go on to the next item, which is brought to us by Supervisor Bone. You want to introduce? Yeah, I do. Where'd she go? There they come. We haven't heard from the Family Resource Centers lately, and when we talk about things that make a difference in our county as we sit up here and argue all this other stuff, I think things that work towards our youth, creating a common area, the things that First Five does in conjunction and everything else. So I asked them a few months ago if, you know, I know the one out at Petrolia that we helped get going seven or eight years ago is so successful. It's so exciting to see for those out there, and especially in our non-
urban areas that don't have a lot of berries. So with that, it's all yours, Dad. Thank you, Rex. Thanks so much for inviting us today again. Your mic's not on. No, on the neck. Let me try this one again. Okay, thanks again so much for inviting us, Rex. We're really proud of what we do at the Family Resource Centers, but we cannot do it without the many partners, partners, organizations, and friends in this room who support and partner with us on the work. I think we have a really brief slideshow, and then the focus of why we want to be here today is we actually had a video made about Family Resource Centers in Humboldt County. I'm going to ask you to pull that microphone in because you're very quiet. I apologize. I can be when it's necessary, Rex. And I believe, Amy, you have a clicker right there in front of you, and you can advance your slides. So for those of you who are not familiar with Family Resource Centers,
My resource centers. Our goal is family strengthening across the county. There are 16 of us spread throughout the entire county and you can see we are located all over in places as small as Petrolia. We have three centers in Eureka. We have a center on tribal land. We are all over the county and have been since the 90s when the first of our centers opened. As I said, I just wanted to be really brief and make sure we called out some thank yous before we shared our video. But I want to do a really quick call out. We have a bunch of friends and partners in the room as well as a number of family resource center coordinators. So Amy, if you'd introduce yourself and then let's do a call out to everyone in the room. I'm Amy Taranis. I'm the coordinator for the Southern Humboldt Family Resource Center. And then I know we have in the room, I have notes here so I won't forget anybody. Social services. Special call out to Monique. Thank you.
First Five and Mary Ann, Changing Tides and Carrie, Providence, Martha and Joy, and then the many resource centers we have here. So we have today with us in the room Arcata Family Resource Center, Blue Lake Providence Community Resource Center, Jefferson Community Resource Center, the Manila Community Resource Center, the McKinleyville Family Resource Center, the Rio Del Providence Community Resource Center, and the Sohum Family Resource Center. This is not all of us, but we just wanted to show up and say thank you and show off some of our work. So with that, do you mind starting our video? Thank you.
There should be sound with it. Hmm. Technology is not my friend some days. I'm not sure if we get sound through this. Oh. Okay, one moment. Thank you. I was going to say, I think we can maybe stream it through a... No, the... Oh, there you go. Oh. Maybe. It'll be helpful to listen. Perfect, thank you. When someone has experienced four or more adverse childhood experiences before the age of 18, then they are twice as likely to develop diabetes, twice as likely to develop heart disease, 12 times more likely to attempt suicide. 50% of those classic adverse childhood experiences come directly from what's considered child abuse and neglect. If most of our ACEs are related to... Child abuse and neglect, then...
RCS have that critical role of preventing child abuse and neglect so that children can be successful. Family Resource Centers build these relationships with community members that really allows us to provide any type of advocacy and support for them whenever they need it. Summers are expensive for families. If your kid's not in school, are they in child care? Child care is incredibly expensive in Humboldt County. Summer is like a little harder because school-aged kids, you know, we're used to having them in school and so it's really nice that there's all these free produce here. My daughter also just sized up. You know, a lot of her clothes are too small and ready for a whole new size of clothing, so this is a really valuable resource like for my family and definitely for many families as you can see. Jefferson actually has a program, where they make a meal every day that anyone under the age of 18 can access.
Jefferson Center every day, it helps me a great deal. Being a single dad, it's hard for me. You know, they have the clothing closet. My kids need some shoes, you know. So there's a lot of different resources here. I'm just very grateful for it. The period before age five is really critical to children's development. They arrive in this world absolutely able to be shaped by their experiences, whether those experiences are good or bad. And so it's just vitally important that they have the supports and the connections so that they're developing that brain architecture and that body response system that sets them up to be successful for their lives. In our county, all of our resource centers are held independently. We call it community reflected. Thank you.
We want to be able to support families in their own neighborhoods and not have to send people off to all these different places all the time. There's not only one in every major population hub, but in many of the smaller and more rural communities as well. Anyone who's ever tried to access services through the system knows it's a lot of doors and a lot of repeating the same story and a lot of false starts and wrong turns. A lot of times agencies have one very set thing that they're helping the family with. We're going to help you with housing, we're going to help you with food, we're going to get your kid into daycare. If you come into the FRC, we're going to try to help you with all of those things. And so we really get the full picture of a family, where they're at, what they need, and because of that we build really deep relationships. If you had to get court papers done, they would be right there. They can back shoot court papers, they can reach out and help you.
Get your stuff, they can help you fill out papers, like if you were to get on unemployment, Social Security, they're always willing to help you get that started for you, or even food stamps and cowards. They never shut the door on your face, they were always there to help. Everything that they do is really driven by a community process to be responsive. What families told us in every community in Humboldt when they were interviewed was that they needed opportunities to take their children with them, but connect with other families. Playgroups can meet one, two, three times a week. They've got staff there to facilitate the activities, and then First Five also sends out what we call family support navigators. Services like this means a lot to my family because it shows that there's communities out there that care about our kids, that care about what resources we do and don't have, how they can help us.
Hispanic families, they need to have people that speak their language so they feel comfortable in our community. Some people might feel shame or guilt or think that their problems are too big, but if you're experiencing it, it's something that we can help support you through. I was living in the local homeless shelter. I had just left inpatient treatment. My son and I really had nothing. You know, I'm sleeping in technically a stranger's home. And the FRC was absolutely there for me to walk in the door. Fast forward to 12 years later, I have another son, I have a partner. We've been together for 12 years. I have another son, I have a partner. We've been together for 12 years. I have another son, I have a partner. We've been together for 12 years. I have another son, I have a partner. We've been together for 12 years.
Since that time, we now own a home, I own a car, I work a full-time job, I take incredible care of my children and I get to give back. I keep saying, don't tear up. I get to give back to the community. That gave so much to me in the beginning. It really is beautiful to see folks who come in, get a little bit of support and then really start to thrive in their own life. It's beautiful to watch. When you support an FRC, you're really supporting all of the families around it. One spoonful of honey with cinnamon before bed equals zero memory collapse. And only worth a billion dollars. Sorry about that.
I want you to know, if you struggle with memory lapses, confusion, you can stop it. Thank you. I just want to take a second. I do that work every day along with these other folks here, and we're just watching that video. It's just an honor to do the work that we do, and all of us are sitting here with tears in our eyes. So thank you for letting us show that to you and sharing in the joy of the work that we get to do with your families and communities every day. Thank you for that. But Supervisor Brown? Yeah, and that's why I brought this forward, because they kind of do this in the shadows, all of you guys. And you look around, and we're throughout the county. I mean, how far reaching you are, especially our rural areas and our urban areas, it's important you do it. And I know you love this stuff, because you and I have been doing this and looking at it. Longer than I'd like to think about. But the progress.
You young kids, sorry, I'm old, so you guys are young kids. I mean, you guys getting into a job. It's kind of cool to start, you know, to be working somewhere where you love and you see the issue, like the gal right there at the end. You actually see the fruits of your efforts and the rewards of your efforts. So I can't say thank you enough. And the partner agencies, Mary Ann, Carrie, you know, Connie, supporting this. And the reason we're not really, we're all aware. Everybody up here is aware of you. But you don't come here asking for money and stuff every three months. So we're not as aware. Maybe you should come by and ask for more money. I don't know. But thanks for what you do. I really appreciate it. Your pops would be proud. Thank you for that, Rex. Thank you. I also want to thank the communities that support you as well because it's not, yes, you guys do the work, but you also depend on your communities that largely support you and are socializing. So thankful for.
for all of the FRCs in all of the communities. I know Amy is mine from Southern Humboldt, and I'm so appreciative to her and her staff. And I hear all the time how Amy goes and her staff go extra miles, and if they don't have it, they find it. And that is support from her community as well. And so it makes a huge difference in the very rural area of Southern Humboldt, clear to Blacksburg, clear to Shelter Cove, down to Pier C, or, you know, Humboldt. But it is, you guys make difference in kids' lives, in parents' lives, and it's something you can see. It's attainable and see it. And I've seen many tears at the FRC and many happy tears, many sad tears, but it always is, how can we fix this? How can we help you? How can we do this? And so I appreciate that. Also, the partner agencies, Marianne and the FRA, and Changing Towers.
And everybody here, I just can't say enough from my district especially, but we're all of humbles. Anybody else? Supervisor Royal. Thank you so much. It's great to highlight the incredible work you do. I think this is a particular moment where people are really looking to you all as a trusted source of information and resources and ways to connect with what's available and the sharing culture and community care culture that we have in our rural communities and our less rural communities. But people look out for each other here. And you're a point where... We're of contact where people can find that. And we are in some unprecedented times right now. I bet people are expressing a lot of fear and concern to you. And you're having to hold that for them too.
Thank you for that, and I'm sorry that we're here. And I'm grateful that you're, you know, I think that trust is going to be everything in the coming days too. Thanks. Supervisor Bone? And I would be, I've got to say thanks to Providence and the other health care organizations. Providence has stepped up. I know they've been huge in Lolita, but they're huge throughout the county with helping, and outside of their work here or whatever. But they've been a great partner with the FRCs, and I know that they all can reach out to them. I mean, I know Jared Phelps helps you in immense ways. I'm sure it's not mentioned, but I just know that that's part of their caring pledge that they've all done. But Providence, you'll see their name. And they're doing great. Some good stuff there. So I wanted to thank them. Yeah, absolutely.
I echo that. I know that one of your staff members or two are paid by the work at the FRC are from Gerald Phelps, correct? Yeah, so Home Health. Yeah, so Home Health. And then Sarah from Riadel and does so much in the Riadel area. And I'm sorry, I don't know if you're not in my district, I don't know you, but I'm glad you're here. And so it's huge that those partner agencies step up. We're going to go to Supervisor Wilson. Thanks. Yeah, the Family Resource Centers across the county are just extremely important. And we're sure sometimes I think Supervisor Wilson's work can be offline or not in the light, but in many times you're right there. And I would say, especially in places like Blue Lake, for instance, it's just basically, partially kehw shut up because we're going to be saying anything that's going on with people. We're not going to be saying anything that's going on with people. It's just, basically, of City Hall really it's like right in it they couldn't be you couldn't be anymore in in civic life
than that particular branch of this organization. And it was great to see the video because there were so many people in there I've known for many years. There's some in this room I've known for many years. And those folks have, if they weren't in this position, they were doing this kind of work in other ways all the time. So I just want to really, and the partnerships are extremely important. I think it was highlighted in the video in terms of, the only way that you're able to give in the way that you do and to operate the way that you do is through partnerships because you don't, as an organization, provide all the services that you connect people to. But it's extremely important that there's one place that they can come to to do that. And I have to tell you, we are hearing, from families,
is especially these are these are some these are some tough times at the moment and I will say with the shutdown it's gonna get a little rougher it's gonna end you guys know it it's coming and and we really need to be aware of that and and push harder to get those resources back online as soon as possible and it's not just the the resources that you guys are speaking to specifically but we also have housing resources in in in our in our elder communities as well that that we're gonna which impacts everybody they are part of our we are all family and so thanks for being there and we're gonna work hard to have your backs as it come it won't in these times that are coming really appreciate it thank you supervisor Madron what would we do without you guys really thank you every one of you you and all the centers and changing
Tides who had a wonderful 50-year celebration just recently, 50 years, as well as First Five Humboldt. It's along with, as Supervisor Bushnell said, the community. It really is an amazing community effort, and I really don't know what we'd do without you guys because you provide such incredible support to our families, both English-speaking and Spanish-speaking. So muchas gracias for all your efforts. We appreciate you from the heart. Thank you so much. Okay, we're going to go out to public comment, and we're going to start with Zoom. There is none, Chair. Is there anybody online? Yeah, no hands are raised. Okay, so we'll go to public comment in the room on this item. If you wish to make public comment, please come forward to the podium. Hi, welcome. Good morning, everybody.
We came here for a different cause, but this was an eye-opening segment, so we appreciate everything you guys do. We're also part of the sometimes unincorporated area that's underserved, so as a group, we'd like to offer anything we could do. If it's a canned food drive, whatever it may be, because this is quite an eye-opener for all the things you guys do for the county. Like I said, again, we might be a business in some of these areas, but we're also a family that lives in these areas. So eye-opening. We appreciate everything you guys do. And again, reach out. We are also sometimes neighbors of where the centers may be, so just feel free. I'm sure the other gentlemen in the room would love to also help. So again, just reach out. We want to help in any way we can. Thank you, sir. Good morning, Carrie. Carrie. Carrie. Good morning. Carrie Venegas, Changing Tides Family Services. I just wanted to...
I think you all just said it really well, but the work that we do actually happens because of the partnerships we have with the FRCs. Because they are part of the community. They are rooted there. They do amazing work. I want to give particularly special recognition to Sarah and her team in Rio Del. Because when emergency services, as you all know, we're still cleaning up from the earthquake. When emergency services leave, it's actually the FRCs that do the rest of the work and continue to support people. So their role, as Supervisor Wilson was saying, is sometimes kind of hidden. But for those of us who go out and visit or are part of our communities, we see you every day. And we really appreciate you. So I just wanted to make sure you all know how much you're appreciated and loved. So thank you for the work you do. Thank you, Carrie. Good morning, Marianne. Hi. Good morning, Chair Bushnell. Thank you, Supervisor Bone, for bringing... Thank you.
I'm bringing this item forward. I just feel like I talk to folks across the state in different counties all the time, and I know you have this experience as well, that they do not understand the rural nature of our county and how difficult it is to serve families who, you know, from your VMT discussion, we have families living throughout the county. And we are so fortunate to have 16 family resource centers grounded in their community, in their work, in knowing the needs of those communities, and those familiar, trusted faces serving families throughout Humboldt, like our public health home visiting, like WIC, our Changing Tides Family Resource, sorry, Changing Tides Family Services and their child care referral, like our play groups. These are all things that are. They're an essential network with the FRCs for our community that we need to keep.
reporting and talking about. So thanks so much for the opportunity to just honor the FRCs and their just incredible work. So thank you. Thank you. Any other public comment on this item? Yeah, of course. Come forward. Good morning. Good morning. I'm Monique with Social Services and I just want to extend a heartfelt thank you to the FRCs, to Taffy, and the rest of the FRC leadership. We really appreciate the partnership that we have and the collaboration that we have and just a big, big thank you. Thank you. Any other public comment on this item? Seeing none, I will close public comment and I'm going to bring it back to the board for a motion to receive and file. I'll move to receive and file this report. I'm going to second. Second. And then I'm going to second. And also I just want to say, echo, and I know my colleagues up here feel this.
Same. Oftentimes, Amy will reach out to me and say, hey, blah, blah, blah. And she keeps me informed. And I appreciate that so much because I can't know everything. And if there's something going on in our community where she needs help or the FRC needs help, I am so thankful that she's able to reach out and ask for that or ask, how can we? What can we do here? It's so important to me to keep those connections and Sarah as well. I go down to the one in Riadel often. Haven't been there lately, but we'll get there. And I'm just so thankful that I have those connections and that you all have those connections to the communities. So we have a first and a second. And we have our little thingies here. Thank you so much. Thank you. Thank you. Your confidence means a lot to us. We can clap on this one. We're going to do the tip back. Oh, go ahead. Motion carries 5-0. Okay. The next.
Item is a tobacco ordinance. We're going to take a five-minute break, and we'll be right back. If you are here for the tobacco ordinance, staff, you guys are welcome to come forward. Thank you. Thank you.
Thank you. And I'm, if Supervisor Madron can hear me, we're going to start. Okay. So this next item is a status update from the Tobacco Retail Licensing Ordinance Ad Hoc Committee and Department of Health and Human Services Public Health Branch. I'm bringing this item, however, I'm going to pass it off before I go to staff. I'm going to pass it off to one of the ad hoc members to get kind of a statement, and then we'll get some stuff from you guys.
I appreciate when I called and told you I was going to bring this item to get some information. I can't speak with the ad hoc outside of this forum, and so it was important to me and my district to be able to get an update on this. So I'm going to pass it to Supervisor Madrone and I want to recognize that Supervisor Madrone and Supervisor Bone are the ad hoc for this conversation. Supervisor Bone. Well, I started on this voyage and I guess I don't pay enough attention, but I've gone over the meetings repeatedly and the ad hoc we've met twice. I got in trouble once. We're kind of just still separated on what I feel is a, in no better way, a miscarriage of how it was presented and it was presented to the retailers. And since I was raised in a corner grocery store right next to. Sequoia Park, I know how important certain things are to these vendors.
And then some of these vendors are, I've known for when Sonny first came to town, I don't know how many years ago, and I've become friends with most of them. And then I met somebody that bought a market from a friend of over 40 years here just recently, and the whole deal closed, everybody shook hands, everybody was happy. And then he owns two or three other stores in other counties, and that became a problem. But this all triggered for me was when a young man of 89 years old, Peter Vandalia, took on, he has six stores here, he has 30-plus stores in five counties, and the only three stores he couldn't close escrow on were three in unincorporated Humboldt. Now, five counties, and this was the only place he couldn't do. So. I know that vast amounts of research and outreach.
and everything came up, but I don't think anybody understood that they were going to take a viable part of their business, not a business, not a part of the business we all accept, but a legally licensed paying business for years and have it become a non-entity if they changed hands rather than going to, unless it went to a relative. And this has taken quite a bit of financial toll on one individual. It's actually degraded the business values. I've asked some realtors what this does to somebody's profits, and we're okay. We get a check every two weeks. They depend on who they get in the store, how they get them in the store, and everything else. And so I asked about it. I appreciate Supervisor Bushnell taking this on because I was getting nowhere. So I would like a change. And when it comes to.
down to is when somebody owns a grocery store that sells tobacco and i even said i like the sonoma model because i know we did a lot of research we didn't check anybody around us the sonoma models if you were on the state board of equalization nine years ago you could transfer it that means you've made a commitment and and that's most of these people have that commitment a lot of them but i i would like to go to five years or something like that so they're not just flipping them but when i voted on this i thought it was if somebody came in built a new store brand new ground up they weren't going to be able to get a license because we had decided arbitrarily how many there should be i mean we're at 2500 some places i see are 1250 and i appreciate marl's mario's honesty he says we're just trying to get people to stop smoking um and i and i relate to that but i think it's it's a lot like drunk driving we have to educate them unless we're gonna the next thing we decide if this wins
Are we not going to allow any local liquor licenses? And then it goes on and on, fried foods, potato chips. So I would like this re-looked at to keep the viability. We sit up here and talk about that we're for small business. And we're going to see a lot of small business here today. Some are big business also. But I've got one retailer that has estimated he's probably paid over $100 million in taxes since he's owned his stores here in Hubbell County and some of the incorporated areas. That is an investment in our community. And he has asked for this. Others have asked for it. And I know there was great outreach. They said there was great outreach. I'm having a hard time finding a retailer that they said I would never be able to sell my store and they would be able to continue business as is. So that's where I'm coming from. I know it might be unpopular. But it's legal.
It's legal. It's the license. We've initiated a TRL where we can get extra money and do our investigations. I'm even a thing. First violation, second violation, you take a 90. Second violation, you take away the license. I'm fine with that. Education and enforcement, but the idea of taking somebody's, taking money out of somebody's pocket because we feel that's the way we can combat it, there are still a lot of places and it's not going to work. It's just going to hurt some small businessmen. Thank you. Thank you. So I asked for this item because I don't want you all to do the work if the board is not favorable. I feel it's a lot of time and money and energy without getting the full board's thoughts. Also, I would really like for other jurisdictions to incorporate the tobacco ordinance. Okay. Especially now that we have the nitrous ordinance. Thank you so much for all that help.
It really, I have heard from the jurisdictions in my district, which would be Fortuna and Riadale, that there are a few things on there that they're hesitant about, one of them being this. You know, we made some upgrades already to the tobacco ordinance. And so I also, you know, have recently been reached out by some folks in my district that are trying to sell their store, and it was really hinging on not being able to, who they're selling to is saying, if I can't roll that license, I'm not interested. And it is breaking their family. And so it is, you know, I just want to get a thought process from the board so that you guys don't waste your time if we don't have consensus up here, but also to hear your thoughts on, you know, what we can do. So, Sophia, I think I'm going to... Hand it to you, unless Supervisor Madron wants to add from the ad hoc. Go ahead. Thank you, Chair.
Well, yes, Supervisor Bone and myself both sit on the ad hoc, and we have had differences of opinions about this particular ordinance and its implementation. I want to say that at least what my memory is of the presentations that public health gave to us here at the board was a very detailed set of information about the outreach that occurred. It didn't happen in a vacuum. It didn't happen in one month. It happened over a long period of time, along with the tremendous amount of outreach that staff made in regards to looking at other counties, looking at other ordinances, and bringing that forth. And my recollection was that there was pretty strong evidence, and I'm assuming public health might be able to share that with us today, that there was very strong information that was presented to us. It showed that there was a lot of information. It showed that there was a lot of information. There was outreach to almost every single outlet in the county.
either via email or other direct communication that occurred. Sometimes it was with the managers, not necessarily the owners, but again, that's my recollection, that there was extensive outreach that occurred with every single retailer. This board voted 5-0 to support the ordinance, and it may be that some did not understand the implications. I can understand that that may have been the case. As a board, we often have 1,000 pages to review before a meeting in regards to being prepared for whatever issues might be brought forward to us. But we did have a very robust discussion about this, and we voted 5-0. It was always my understanding that what we were trying to do was reduce the number of outlets down to a cap based on our population, and that the way that was going to happen was that as a business sold to the company, we would have to reduce the number of outlets that were going to be pulled to somebody other than an immediate family member that they would...
lose that license. So all of a sudden it sounds like some people feel like they didn't have any communication, but my understanding was that there was every effort made to do that. I realize that can be a hardship, especially for a small mom and pop business. So in our ad hoc discussions, we've talked about a couple of things. One was the hardship that some of these businesses are feeling now that they realize the outcome that if they sell to somebody other than an immediate family member, they could lose that license. In some cases, it's very rural stores, like in Southern Humboldt and Petrolia or Honeydew or other places in Southern Humboldt. Dinsmore, I'm sure Supervisor Bushnell could identify a few others that are in very isolated Alder Point. And others where they're very isolated and there may only be one outlet, if at all, to be able to purchase your
cigarettes there, but given the health risks of tobacco that are well documented, it was our intention to actually try and reduce the number of outlets in the hopes that that might actually ultimately encourage people to stop smoking. It's true that alcohol is also a killer, and you know, there's all those issues around that. There are other things too. We've dealt with vaping, we've dealt with nitrous oxide, and a lot of other issues in our efforts to try and not legislate people's behavior, but to try and make choices about health risks and trying to help our community move in the right direction in that regard. Is it going to be perfect when we do that? No, and there's always going to be some opposition. I think at the ad hoc, there is pretty strong support for potentially modifying the ordinance to allow for a business that maybe the next closest place to go to buy tobacco is 10 miles away or 15 miles away. I forget what the number is. But again,
Public health staff can help share that with us. But I want to be really clear. I really, really very much appreciate the hard work of public health and our staff in really delving into this and trying to figure out what might be a way forward with this, and that's that ordinance. But could we modify it for that issue of very isolated stores? I think there might be support for that at the board. I certainly would support that under those conditions where there's simply no other option. And, you know, if you can't buy it at a particular store and you've got to go 10 or 15 more miles, then the argument could be made, well, that's additional vehicle miles traveled. That's additional safety risks of traveling on the highway, even more and such. But that being said, the issue of getting rid of the loss of a license due to sale to somebody other than a family member is a split. You know, Supervisor Bone would support that change to not lose the license, I believe. He's. Stated that clearly.
And I don't support that. I think it was pretty clear when we passed the ordinance that that was our intention. And I still feel that way. The biggest case that first came to us actually involved the sale of 33 businesses, all in one lump sum. And out of that 33 businesses, three of them are in the county. One Garberville, one Willow Creek, one McKinnaville. And so three out of the 33 licenses would lose their retail outlet tobacco license. But the other 30 would not. And it is true that, you know, the cities aren't necessarily all aligned with this ordinance. This covers the county, covers the unincorporated areas. And we talked a bit about that, I remember, as well, when this came before the board. So I appreciate coming back. I agree with Supervisor Bushnell that it's good to get a pulse of the board and see where we're at on this. But mostly I really want to thank staff for your hard work and dedication to trying to figure out ways to help make our community safer. So thank you.
Thank you. So I want to say, and I'm going to go to Supervisor Bumgarner, I'm going to let you guys talk too. And I've stated to Sophia and to you that I didn't do my due diligence and understand all of what I was voting for when it came through. It was a lot of information. It was a big ordinance. And oftentimes when we get ordinances, we do modify them. We've already modified this one once. It came back. There was things in there that I got calls about that I immediately brought to you guys. We brought back to the board and we modified this ordinances. Brand new ordinances have sometimes five, 10 modifications to as they get working to realize that, oh, this isn't working that great. Let's do a little change here. And I do appreciate the work that you guys have done. I also appreciate. The work that you have done around wrapping the nitrous oxide ordinance around the.
tobacco ordinance. That is one of the reasons I would love for the jurisdictions and incorporated areas to really come forward and want to be part of this ordinance also because they have embraced that nitrous oxide ordinance throughout the county which has been great and you guys did that work. And so you know I will own that that it was my not doing my due diligence enough and digging in and not understanding that you wouldn't be able to sell your business and retain that tobacco license and I've told you that and I've told my constituents that as they've called me. So I want to give you guys an opportunity but I think that we need to do a straw poll on the board to see where we're at. You can say you know you you whatever you would think I think five miles is because we are talking about vehicle miles traveled and you know some some some Five miles is quite a ways in the...
unincorporated areas which is what we're really talking about so I my preference would be if we're going to modify that we put a five mile radius on it but what are your guys's thoughts thank you chair Bushnell and your board just really quick just since we have members of the public here and then those that might be tuning in I'm Sophia Pereira I'm the public health director I have Brianna Sherlock here who oversees our healthy communities and WIC division that includes the nicotine and tobacco prevention program and Mario Kelson our director of environmental health that is responsible for the enforcement aspect of this tobacco retail licensing ordinance you know really appreciate the the conversation starting here and we definitely appreciate the opportunity to get you know clear direction from your board of how you would like for us to proceed we did prepare some slides to just go over a few things and so basically we're going to be talking about the health and environmental health of the state and then we're just I'm gonna probably repeat some things that you all have heard but just for the
public's benefit. You know, we received direction back in August of 2022 to develop a comprehensive tobacco retail licensing ordinance. It was adopted in July of 2023. And like you were mentioning, Chair Bushnell, we've made amendments both in 2024 and then this past June. With that nitrous oxide sales ban, we amended the TRL. I'm going to start using TRL because that's very long to say, tobacco retail licensing ordinance every time. But this last came to your board at the June meeting to amend the TRL to include a provision that would revoke tobacco retailers license if the nitrous oxide sales ban was violated. So I just want to give the context of, you know, some of where we've been. And at the adoption of that particular TRL amendment, your board discussed other potential amendments regarding the TRL's density or transferability clauses. Which we will.
Have some updates on there was the ad hoc committee that was voted for us to work with and Since there have been questions around outreach we have some slides that will go over that so I'm gonna turn over to Brianna to talk About the really extensive outreach that has been done by our team give a bit of an overview about the TRL and give a larger perspective of efforts Elsewhere in the state and then we'll share those potential options for amending the TRL for your consideration Thank you So our team our nicotine and tobacco prevention team has done seven waves of outreach With the tobacco retail licensing ordinance and the stores and unincorporated humble this began in December 2022 which was after your board Directed our team to work on developing a tobacco retail licensing ordinance
And this began with letters which were sent to all of the state tobacco licensed retailers in unincorporated Humboldt County to solicit input from those businesses on the TRL ordinance. Following the first reading and presentation of the ordinance in the summer of 2023, our staff made phone calls to all 60 state tobacco licensed retailers in unincorporated Humboldt to inform them that the TRL would be passing in July and to provide general information and address any questions that businesses had at that time. In fall of 2023, our team went to all... All of the stores in unincorporated Humboldt in person to be able to visit them and provide some education and go over specifically the different provisions that were in the TRL with the stores.
So they informed the retailers of the TRL and they discussed the services that were offered by our branch in terms of being a resource to store owners and to store managers. Should they have any questions, for example, if the people that they purchased the tobacco products from were telling them, oh, you can sell this or you can sell that, they were encouraged to reach out to our staff person so that we could help direct, you know, yes or no, that product would not be allowable under our local TRL. They also educated on the local, state, and federal laws. Outreach continued in spring of 2024 with phone calls, emails, and letters informing retailers about the local license application, providing technical assistance with the application, preparing. Stores for the compliance checks with the Division of Environmental Health and.
Our staff members, Courtney and Chelsea, Courtney is from Healthy Communities and Chelsea is from Environmental Health, also hosted three in-person workshops throughout the county, one in Benbow, one in Willow Creek, and one in Eureka, which were open to all store personnel. Then in summer 2024, when the update to the TRL was made regarding the five-foot provision, our health educator, Courtney, again, went out to all of the stores in unincorporated Humboldt and educated them about the updated five-foot provision. In fall of 2024, when the state passed the flavor ban, Assembly Bill 3218, I'm sorry, not the flavor ban, they passed that the state would be coming up with a list of what flavors were going to be allowable. Our educator went out and informed. Store owners and managers about that. And then most recently this last summer with the nitrous oxide.
ordinance. Courtney again went out to all of the retailers and educated them about the update to the TRL as well as making them aware of the nitrous oxide ordinance. So the print is small on this, but this is an example of the type of educational materials that our staff handed out during fall 2023, which was after the TRL was passed by your board. And so this lists out all of the provisions in the TRL in a very shortened, condensed format because as Chair Bushnell mentioned, the TRL is quite long. So in addition to providing all stores with a printed copy of the TRL for the review, our team also prepared this two-pager about the TRL. And so on the right-hand side there, you can see that we have a lot of information about the TRL. And so we're going to be talking about the TRL in a little bit. And so we're going to be talking about the TRL in a little bit. And so on the One of the things which was listed is that the total number of tobacco retail licenses within the county shall be limited to one for each 2,500 inhabitants of the county.
county. And then in the next section down on the licensing process, the very last bullet there says a tobacco, wow I need my glasses, a tobacco retailer license may not be transferred from one person to another or from one location to another with the exception of a tobacco retailer in good standing that may transfer to a parent, child, spouse, or domestic partner. So this was given to all stores in fall 2023 during their visits. These slides are taken from the May 2023 presentation that we did with your board. It was a much longer presentation. These are just the two slides that went over the proposed ordinance details including the limited transferability to only a parent, child, spouse, or domestic partner. This means that tobacco retailer density will slowly decrease over many years creating a healthier community as Supervisor Madron shared. And so just a little bit of a look at what's happening in the rest of the state. There are over 230
jurisdictions in the state of California that have a local tobacco retail licensing ordinance. Of those more than 230, only one has a transferability exception, as Supervisor Bone has mentioned, in unincorporated Sonoma County. Approximately half of jurisdictions, 126 of them, have a TRL that regulate the density and or proximity of tobacco retailers. And then this is just an example of the types of tobacco products that are available. In the market. Some of the impacts of our local TRL include that in 2022, when this process started, we had 60 state licensed tobacco retailers in unincorporated county. We now have 54, so six less. When our team started doing outreach and education with the stores, over 60 percent of our stores in unincorporated county were out of compliance with one state or federal law. That does not even...
Include what's in our local tobacco retail licensing ordinance that's just state and federal laws, which everybody should be complying with regardless. Now with the waves of outreach and education, less than 5% of our stores in unincorporated county are out of compliance. The primary purpose, as we have talked about many times, of the tobacco retail licensing ordinance is to protect youth and to reduce the accessibility of commercial tobacco and nicotine products, as well as provide a local enforcement structure for local, state, and federal laws. It also provides the opportunity for us to build relationships with the local business community. Our tobacco retail licensing ordinance was based off a model TRL from the Public Health Law Center. And in March 2024, your board received a leadership award for the passing of a comprehensive TRL. Thank you.
Thank you, Brianna. So, you know, with the TRL, you know, I think we've already covered and your board has already discussed a bit about the legislative intent to enforce, you know, state and federal tobacco laws and reduce youth's access to tobacco. And like has been mentioned, there's, you know, definitely several different provisions that focus on reducing access to tobacco from having future retailers, having distance from youth-oriented facilities, to over time reducing the number of retailers selling tobacco. So, I know your board will be, you know, having robust conversation and receiving public input, you know, and considering a variety of different factors in terms of, you know, what makes the most sense going forward. You know, as public health, you know, we feel strongly in maintaining the protections that are in place in this TRL. You know, when we think about the health impacts that are caused and trying to prevent future health impacts.
for our youth. That's something we feel strongly about and we recognize your board is considering a variety of different factors. And so what we've worked on with the ad hoc committee was some different alternatives. So one being for the population intensity clause in the TRL, giving an exemption for rural retailers if they're 10 or more miles away from the next licensed tobacco retailer in the county. And I'm just going to go over these high level and then you all very well may have questions and so then we're happy to answer those questions as well. The other option, and I think we identified I think five or six stores that would meet that particular exemption, also looked at population by census tract. So really looking at unincorporated county. And
Distributing that cap throughout the counties that there's not a concentration of licenses in one community over another to increase the likelihood that there will be in each census tract tobacco retailers that are still existing. That one definitely has required some more follow-up and research from our staff. So the first one is a bit more cut and dry. I just want to recognize just in terms of the timing of this presentation, there's something that if your board would like us to look more into the census tract one, we would definitely need to do some more research on what that would look like. And frankly, we don't have the GIS tools to properly denote unincorporated versus incorporated for all the census tracts, and that was a barrier for us. So I just want to acknowledge that one we're not going to be able to have as robust detail, but if it is something your board is interested in and giving us direction to look into further, we'll need to figure out the best way to get you that accurate information about how that would look. And then we did also look into...
Sonoma County's transferability exemption. It is something that we've, with all of these options, we've been in communication with county council on, and they've been really key in helping us to do this research. And that provision in particular that Sonoma County has does need to be further looked into. And so if there are questions, I would just defer to county council on the questions that arise on that particular one. And so with that, look forward to any questions you may have. I'm batting a fly, not you guys. Okay, okay. There's one fly up here. Thank you. I do want to go to public comment before our board deliberates too much. I think Supervisor Bone has a small comment question, and then we'll go on to public comment. In the Sonoma County clause, I think I gave you a copy of that two months ago. I looked at it.
And we have to look into it some more. But if I look at what you just said, there's only one unincorporated county that has a transferability license because I'm about ready to go get some paperwork because most of them have no issue whatsoever. And the three counties that I found that have something similar to ours are in front of the Board of Supervisors for every transfer. It's become a nightmare. And I understand all the health reasons. I was the most fortunate child in the world. My dad owned a grocery store, so I'd get cigarettes whenever I wanted. But I had asthma, so I couldn't smoke them. So I didn't have that problem as a youth. But as I look at all these other issues, and I did a little, I called the student body presidents and some of the high school kids. High school kids aren't smoking cigarettes anymore. It's down immensely. They're doing the vapes. They're doing everything else. And I'm not going to lie. I'm not going to lie. I'm not going to lie.
And they're easily accessible. We have smoke shops and everything else, and it seems like they're easily accessible and they're getting them. All I'm saying is most of these, you mentioned the gentleman, as Steve mentioned, we're only talking about three out of 30 for this gentleman. This gentleman owns them in five counties, and everything else is transferred seamlessly except here. Except here. And then the company that's buying him has never run into this problem, and it's holding up a very large sale. But the other thing is, he'll do fine. He'll do fine. But we have a lot of small businessmen. I mentioned Sonny earlier. He went from driving cab 15 hours a day, seven days a week, to come to Humboldt County, bought a store, and is, I don't know if we're the promised land or anything else. We're slamming a door on a lot of small business people.
Because we're taking an asset that has always been available to them, and we're deciding that, no, that's no longer available. Just we. We're deciding. And I voted for this, yes, but I have spent six hours going over the old meetings, and then I've talked to numerous retailers and all this outreach, and it was never said to them, or they don't remember, and I never hear it in presentation, you will never be able to sell your store with a cigarette license. I don't think that was portrayed, and I appreciate all the outreach and the inspections and everything else, but I don't know if that factor was portrayed. I noticed it wasn't even highlighted like the other stuff was highlighted that you brought up. So did I miss that? Yeah. How many pages is it? Yeah. I heard the grandfather. And grandfathering, I did hear the grandfather part. It was mentioned. I thought that meant that they would be able to transfer to anybody. But there are some pretty good. So I just.
I'll let it go to public comment, but I'm just frustrated. Thank you. So at this time, unless any other board member would like to add something small, clarifying, we're going to go to public comment and hear from public comment and then come back to the board to ask staff additional questions and make recommendations. Anybody else from the board, or can I go to public comment? So, I mean, I thought we, in those conversations, that it was pretty specific that the transferability was to family members. I think it was said out loud, and I think that was the case. And I even thought that the calculation at the time was that the cap would be somewhere around 22 licenses, but now it's 29. That was my memory anyway, but 29 is more. And that...
There was talk of a cap. I mean, there was a, which would denote that there would be a reduction in licenses, and that was clearly discussed, that that would happen. I'm not sure how the board thought the reduction in licenses would occur if it wasn't at the time of these transfers. So, I don't know. It seemed clear to me at the time. I will say, I'm just going to put it out there, if we're going to keep bringing back this ordinance, and I hear what Supervisor Bushnell says, you do have to do some edits every once in a while on ordinances, but also we have other ordinances that could use updates as well. We have to be, we have to be efficient with our time and our staff's time.
But I will say that there is, I'm going to bring this up for whatever it's worth, it's like there's a movement to remove and seek non-conversion or whatever to non-filtered tobacco products. It's called Ban the Butt. The number one piece of garbage we find on the beaches are cigarette butts. There are jurisdictions that have been moving towards banning cigarette butts or basically filtered tobacco products. And we'll see how that takes effect. It's a fairly new concept, but again, it has impacts on our environment. And so for me, if we're going to keep bringing this ordinance back, I'm going to keep... I'm going to keep asking for analysis on the trajectory or the ability for us...
to consider filterless tobacco products moving forward. That's kind of where I'm at. I'm happy to hear a public comment. Thank you. I want to remind you that this board challenged the ad hoc to discuss this and to suggest some edits. And so while, and that wasn't too long ago, I don't know if you remember, Mike, but I don't want the staff to do the work if this board doesn't agree. That's why we're here today. Also, while you may have understood, as I clearly said, I didn't understand the implications of the entire ordinance. So it wasn't clear to me. And I will restate that again. I'm taking ownership of that. And I have told Sophia and Brianna that. So we're going to go out to public comment. And we're going to start with the Zoom. Thank you, Chair. Caller 7718, I will unmute you. And you will have three minutes. Thank you.
Mr. Waspie calling from Mexico. We haven't had the education down here and smoking is very prevalent. I take my old paint cans and I paint them red and I stick cigarette butts on them with glue and I put the caps on them so people throw them in there. I did have a question, I was speaking with one of the supervisors today regarding can you buy cigarettes online. So I did a little search on it and came up with Tobacco Con online cigarette store. When you buy cigarettes in the US it can be difficult, the convenience factor is not as long as you decide. Cigarette store tobacco products are not readily available if you want to buy cigarettes online. The Tobacco Con is the answer to your problem. You are able to purchase cigarettes on the internet. Some people are not aware of this possibility but your wishes have finally come true. Try it out today. There are every single brand you want on there with discounts and everything on there. So people can, no matter where they are at, I guess if they get any kind of delivery, can buy these things and have them delivered to them. Yes. Thank you.
here that indicates it's not possible to do but there may be other complications with my limited research i think that is one option if people uh say they can't get them uh everything seems to be deliverable online these days i pretty well recall the discussion uh along the lines of what uh supervisor wilson recalled i can understand there's a very lengthy discussion there may be a room person uh possibly not understanding uh i'm not i'm not obviously in favor of smoking the nice thing about this ad and really big things every single pack is smoking kettles um i do believe that's true uh so anyway i guess we're going to re-regulate today or take another vote on what happened before and we'll see what happens thanks for opportunity to comment on this very negative health consequence product out there thank you that's all chair okay we'll go to public comment in the room if you have a comment that you want to make or
or make a statement according to this ordinance. Now is that time to do that, and you'll have three minutes to do so. Hi, welcome. My name is Gurpreet Sol. We have been here from my family and us 30 years. As Rex told us, I was a kid when I met Rex. So, I mean, everything is when the public health reach out to us, all we understood we need to apply for new license, and that's what we did. We did not know that we have to, if we sell the store, the license not going to be transferred. That's what our understanding was. I called a couple of times too. You can see the last couple of years, there might be like five, ten different smoke shops opened up recently. And I called them, like, you know, they can sell everything, even legally or illegally. Hey, what are you guys doing about it?
They don't have fund. They can't do anything about it. Our business is dying because of that. And now we can't even sell it. That's another problem. As the caller mentioned, a cigarette you can buy online. It comes to your door. You don't need to go anywhere. So whoever's going to smoke it, they're going to smoke it. I mean, I'm not favor to selling cigarettes. If we need to stop it, we should stop it everywhere. That's all. Thank you. Sir? So there is a member of the board that's going to ask you a question. We're going to continue forward with public comment, and then he's going to call you back up. Yes. Okay. Any other public comment on this item? Someone needs to come forward. I'll be closing public comment. Thank you. Hi. Welcome. Hello. My name is Dan Noga. I own Country Club Market on Humboldt Hill for 38 years.
In the time I was there, the ordinance came through to have a tobacco license, which we applied for. They came, they inspected, we were under compliance. In no time did they let me know that we could not transfer the license. Also, there's a lot of marijuana shops that have opened in the past that the board has approved of. Ingesting any smoke into your lungs is not good for your health, yet there's tons of marijuana shops that are being approved and there's no restrictions on them when the smoke going into your lungs is bad for your health. Also, liquor licenses. Liquor is bad for your health, just like cigarettes are, yet a liquor license is transferable. So I see don't see the problem with transferring a license from one retailer to the next retailer.
I understand if you don't want a new retailer with a tobacco license. Thank you so much for your comment. Thank you. Anybody else? Okay, we're going to, sir, Tom's going to go and then you can go. Hi, my name is Tom Biro and I own the Redwoods Market in Delhi in Myers Flat. Me and my wife have owned it for five years and we didn't get any information on the new ordinance. Chelsea has been by our market several times and I don't recall her mentioning to me that if you were to sell your business, that the license was not transferable or the person purchasing the business would not be able to apply for a new one. Myers Flat's a real small town and 90% of the people who own it are from the Redwoods Market.
90% of the people that live there can't drive or don't own a vehicle, ride bikes, or walk up to the market, and 90% of them smoke cigarettes. I mean, it's just a fact. I mean, it's kind of a crazy little town. But without—our market's been there for about 50 years, and it's always been able to sell tobacco. Without—and we're in the middle of trying to sell our business, me and my wife, and the person purchasing the business does not want to purchase it unless he can apply for a new license or we can transfer our license. Well, our family relies on the sale of this business because we want to move on. We want to do something else. My wife's a full-time bus driver for the school, and she works at the market. Well, it's getting—
to be too much so we're trying to sell our business and do something else so we're um thinking about opening another business but without the sale of our our current business that's not a possibility so i i don't know if i was sent a letter about the changes and i didn't receive one that i know of and my wife never got one so i know we didn't really know about this until just recently so it's um it's kind of important for us to be able to move on but people are gonna like they said people can buy them online order cigarettes well a lot of the people that live in myers flat now they're going to buy them online but a lot of the people that live in myers flat not that much it's not that much um and that's why we're um that's why it's not that much rattles and rattles and rattles and that's why we're not that much um and that's why we're not don't even have a phone or a computer.
or a place to live for that matter. They just come out of the woodwork or they walk up to the market to purchase cigarettes. And the closest other market that does is I think six, seven miles away. And if we were to sell it. Tom, I'm sorry. That's for three minutes. Thank you so much. Thank you, everybody. Hi, welcome. My name is Amrik Singh. I work at store for six, seven years on Blue Lake. And what is my observation is I'm not smoking, I'm not drinking. But people who are drinking or smoking, they have to buy a cigarette. And all these countryside store dying, they are disappearing every year. And I'm not smoking. I'm not drinking. I'm not drinking. I'm not drinking. I'm not drinking. I'm not drinking. I'm not drinking. I'm not drinking. I'm not drinking. I'm not drinking. I'm not drinking. I'm not drinking. I'm not drinking. I'm not drinking. I'm not drinking. I'm not drinking. I'm not drinking. I'm not drinking. I'm not drinking. I'm not drinking. I'm not drinking. I'm not drinking. I'm not drinking. I'm not drinking. I'm not drinking. I'm not drinking. I'm not drinking. I'm not drinking. I'm not drinking. I'm not drinking. I'm not drinking.
And if anybody buying cigarette, they're buying other stuff from the same store where they're buying cigarette. So all these stores, they will get disappeared because they don't have enough business. And other people will get suffer because they don't get other items because they're going to close those stores. That's all. Thank you so much. Thank you. Hi there, Roland Treeherd. I just want to ask the board to be fair in your thoughts and comments here and apply the same train of thought that maybe has been applied over the years when the board has made decisions along the cannabis industry line as we saw changes going on there and rules and regulations that you put into place. Consider the mom and pop legacy folks that were in that industry. If you took out the label of
cannabis and you called it a and then we got tobacco sellers in these retail markets the small retail markets there be are we applying the same principles and fairness in our decisions supervisor madrone talked about the stuff that you see that's hundreds of pages long sometimes you don't get into the small fine print supervisor bushnell says same thing staff pointed out in their example on the screen one line that applied towards the you can tell i talked for a living but i'm nervous up here in front of you guys the one small line in the outline of everything that the ordinance said but one small line pertained to really the issue that most of the people here with me are addressing i don't smoke i totally go for the premise of what we're trying to do here but again we have to look out to the livelihood of the people that have invested into our community with family with
finances and so forth. As the previous speaker just said, it's not just the tobacco that they come into the store for. They come into the store to get the tobacco, but they buy the carton of milk, they buy the chicken. If they're not going into that store, they have to go somewhere else. They didn't just lose the tobacco sale. They've lost the income to their family of these other products too, and it changes. So that's all I'm asking is, I think staff did a good job in getting the mechanics shared as the ordinance came into place and licenses became required, but maybe failed in notifying that one small line that, by the way, store owner, you've just lost the value of this in your product if you ever want to sell. So I just ask for consideration on those regards, and thank you very much. Thank you. You're never nervous on the court. I know. If I was here without you guys looking at me, it'd be better. Any other any other any other any other public comment on this item? I'm going to
Close public comment. Please come forward if you have some. There you go. It's not nervous. It's not bad up here. I'm not nervous. Some of the other folks may feel a little tough time because of language barriers or other things. And, you know, more about that, just a little bit. We usually don't feel marginalized in this day and age. But the fact that the outreach, we're in the stores all the time. To be here, I had to call my wife to go help out, work the counter. So if we're in the store all the time, how do we miss all the outreach is the question. Secondly, if there was outreach, we would have given input. The two pictures they showed of the sets of tobacco, both were flavorless, yet they pointed out one was a flavor set and one was a post-flavor band flavor set. If we had been around, while we're not smokers, we're not championing smoking or tobacco usage, we do intimately touch the product every day. We may not even know about it. But before I.
I worked at one of my dad's stores. I didn't even realize there was 20 sticks in the box. We just don't know these things, just like a non-smoker. But we do still interact with the product. So we could have actually given input on how to address and accelerate the curve of the usage of product in a different way rather than arbitrarily saying, we're going to set a limit based on a population of a huge geographical area. And the 5-mile, 10-mile radius thing from one spot to another doesn't work out in our geography either because we have a lot of seniors who, again, like Sean was saying, do not drive. And we're the only spot where they come to buy everything for their week or that day, whatever it may be. So there's a lot of information that we may have given to the board and to the health department had there actually been input asked or even, you know, if we'd come to the meetings. You know, now that it's post-vote, post-passing, it's a little bit of a different situation. And I told the gentleman in our...
Our group, even if you can't go up there and speak in English, maybe just go up and say whatever you want to say in our language, that does show there's a lack of outreach, lack of, you know, just involving us in the process. There's other jurisdictions that do have this, but there is more than one county or more than one jurisdiction that has a transfer exception. I have relatives who are in this business. Our community does largely, you know, operate these kind of stores. So we do hear things in the two weeks that this has come up in my life. I've talked to other people. So if we'd given the chance to give input, we would have given more ideas on how to do this. Prices, pack sizes, there's many other things that could have been done rather than we're just going to ask stores based on a store limit or a distance limit. If you're grandfathered and the business has been there for 60 years, I had multiple customers who wanted to come, but it's a working day. Some of those who do work or can drive. But. It was a nine to five.
time. They can't be here all day and we don't blame them. But there has to be some thought and process given to this part of the ordinance. Thank you. Sir, and anybody in the audience, if there is anybody that wants to speak that needs a translator and if someone in the audience is able to do that, you can come forward and someone could translate for you if they're available. Is there anybody that wants to do that? Thank you. So you're also allowed, it's six minutes, it's three minutes and three, yeah. And so, sir, would you be translating? I will try to English. Yeah, yeah, please come forward. Hi. Hello. Yeah, there's no, any information or nobody in person or by email. We don't know about this. Can you let him know if he wants to speak in his? Yeah.
You can say it for him. He can say it in English. So again, the... So no, just that I'm going to be saying this on the air, no, not because I am by, or not because it's a... Sorry, that's the way I'm going to... Okay. So, see, they can, just like a... So again, he wanted to say that the outreach was not there, that he's in the store. His family, other families have worked there for many years, sometimes 20...
30 years, and they built this thing up as their retirement or pension. There is no 401k for a small business. They may have a private thing here and there, but there's no pensions. There's nothing for them. This business is the pension. And by doing this, where it diminishes the value of these businesses, like his and mine, that retirement basically is gone. If somebody loses a lot of portion of their sales, they will not be able to sell the business. And he's saying if there had been some notice, they would have been more aware of the topic that was at hand. Thank you. Anybody else? Okay, we're good? Okay, so I'm going to close public comment. Supervisor Madrone is going to have a question for the first commenter, but I do want to say that I know that
The outreach did go out and part of that responsibility also is to the supervisors in your district to let you know what's happening. I was approached by several in my district that said, hey, what is this? What's going on? And I was negligent, not negligent. I didn't read every bit of it. My fault. And so I just, staff did do outreach. Whether they expressed that to you that the license wasn't transferable, I don't know. But I do know that the outreach happened. And also the supervisors knew and public hearings happened. And so there was a lot of information that happened around this. Once again, I'm going to own my own mistake of not reading every single line. So who was the first commenter? Yes, please come back forward. Thank you for being here today. My question was, which store do you represent?
I have 10 stores all around the blue lake. I just sold it a year ago. Then United Gas on Muddle Avenue. How many stores do you own in the unincorporated area that would be affected by this ordinance? Kask and Flask and probably three. Three stores? Yeah. And you represent all three of those? Yes, sir. Okay, thank you. And then there was one gentleman that identified that he was representing Myers Flat. Tom. Also, thank you for being here. So that would answer that question for you. Thank you. And then there was the last gentleman. Was it the tall gentleman? Is he still here? There he is. Yeah. I was curious. No, the other gentleman. Oh, Roland. Roland. Yeah. Oh, okay. I just was curious what store he represented. He is a, can I, Alan? He's real estate. He sells real estate. Very good. Thank you.
That's all I have. Okay. So we're going to come back to the board. And I, Supervisor Wilson said something to me. It wasn't clear why this was coming back. And so I'm going to reiterate that it is part of the ad hoc. I wanted to get some feel from this board along the lines of what the ad hoc has been working on so that your staff knows which way and direction to go or not to go. So that's why this item came back today. Okay. So who, Supervisor Bone. And I guess it's because I'm old. I don't have the recollection. So like I said, I spent some time on a Sunday going through the meeting. And I do not doubt the effort and the concerns that our health department had. And I've got documentation where they hit one or two. But I hit no less than 20 retailers, and they were never specifically told that their asset was going to be diminished in value. Now, we.
dropped four or five. Some of it is the small grocery stores are going out of business and we're doing a pretty good job up here making sure we can get some more out of business. But I don't think that's how we want to do it. I think the idea of small business, I mean I keep hearing the backbone of the United States is the small business person. And there is no other way to look at this is and like I said I did extensive outreach to other counties and they said we've never had this problem. So I can't believe the stores over there are changing hands and everybody's going okay I'll just not do it. It's a vital source to sell other things and they're you know they're it's perfectly understandable. They're going to go somewhere else. They're not going to stop and get all their shopping that they used to do with you and then get their pack of cigarettes. And again I'm not advocating smoking but we don't have a ban on it. We're talking about maybe cigarette butts. I think the better thing to do for the beach is to smoke. I think the better thing to do for the beach is to smoke.
just to disband smoking out there, but then we're going to have the idea how much do we tax to enforce this. So as we move forward, I can't personally, you know, and like I said, I went through the, and I'm going to spend a whole bunch of time probably tonight watching the tapes again to see if this came up specifically. I heard grandfather, and I said, okay, that's going to mean somebody that's made an investment, and not necessarily less because this is new to us. This is another, you know, way to monitor or source of income or whatever the case may be to put a burden on, because I remember when this passed, everybody was mad about the $365. Is that right? What do we charge annually for a cigarette license? I don't know exactly. There's an application fee. It's right around $365. We do receive a Department of Justice grant to subsidize that application, and renewal fee for a year or so. Retailers haven't paid anything to be licensed at this point.
They did pay to begin with. The application fee. Yes. You're correct. And the first year, right? The retail, because that Department of Justice came second. And thank you for doing that. I was going to say that. So I'm having, and like my friends out here that I remember watching on a trike in front of the store, now managing their own stores and growing to a big part of our economy, which is sales tax driven. You know, and that's as big, you know. But this is a person's choice. So what I would hope, what I used to do, I used to have a sign out at Redwood Fields for 24 years that I never, the county paid me $300 the first year to have it out there 24 years ago that said no smoking, the anti-tobacco thing. I can't remember the gals. Lives in Blue Lake. And I never billed for that because that was the one main sign I had out that everybody saw when they came in. Because I truly believe in it. It's probably not the best thing. It's a person's choice.
choice. And so by actually cutting them off, I just don't think this is right. I think we need to respect our small business community better. They are making a plea. I was going to ask Roland if this doesn't just take 25% off the value of their business. Myers-Flatt, they won't buy it. They're just, the person won't buy it. There's other stores. Paul up on Country Club, and this probably hit closer to this why I go to this. And he was mad originally at Dan because he thought he withheld. Dan's, I've known him 40 years. He's honest as the day is long. He would not withheld if he would have known. He said they used to come in and tell him you can't have this, you can't have flavor, you got to have it set back, you got to put a screen, all the things we did. He complied. He did not know he would be able to transfer. And it really hurt me when Paul says he has numerous, he has other stores in other counties, never had a problem. He said,
I wished I'd never come to Humboldt County. That rings a bell for me. He wishes he'd never come to Humboldt County. And we're trying to get businesses here. And at the same time, let's see how many we can close. I just, I thought we would get to this fabricated, since it's just an arbitrary number anyway, I thought we'd get to this 29, 22, 11 through attrition, stores going out of business. They're not going to rebuild. I know some of the ones that have burnt down are closed up in Eureka or in Eureka, so I guess they don't count against us. But there are stores in southern Humboldt that have closed that have cigarette licenses. I've got some in my district that have closed that don't sell cigarettes any longer. Some have closed because they don't want to pay the $3.65 a year because they used to have, a big one is probably the bars and stuff that used to have cigarettes. And they said, well, they can get them at the store because you can't smoke them. So. I'm. I'm just saying if we're going to.
Turn our backs on these guys that made a commitment to Humboldt County and to the United States to come here for a better life or maybe a different life, I don't know. It is hard for me, and I will apologize all day long because I had no idea, no idea when that came to us. And I've looked through the tapes. I'm going to look again for the robust conversation that we were telling people that they would never be able to sell their stores because I don't remember that part. And I've yet to see it in the videos of the past meetings. So I'm just, I am sorry, gentlemen, if this does not go to. Supervisor Arroyo. Thank you. I'd like to start out by thanking. The public for coming out for this item and thank staff for the work on this. We have had no less than 10 meetings.
about tobacco retail licensing and I remember this transferability conversation very well. So we're not here to re-litigate that. We're here to figure out what we want to do moving forward and I know that staff just want clear direction from us. I do want to address a couple of points. I think this is going to emerge from conversation. The solution will emerge from conversation. I don't have a specific suggestion, but I do want to address a couple of points that were brought up. So I thought it was interesting around DUI reduction being about education and just thinking of that as another public health challenge and one that was very impactful here in Humboldt. Education is actually one of the least effective ways to address DUI. The effective ways to address it are policy changes like reducing the BAC allowed and enforcement. Combined, with prevention approaches.
So a combination of physical things being done and enforcement with education going along with it, but being one of the least impactful strategies. So similarly, with tobacco prevention and cessation and control, the strategies have been physical reduction of licenses and access. And in doing that, we realize there are broad public health benefits, but there are consequences. So we're talking today about those consequences. I appreciate that. But the strategies that staff have proposed have been really well-researched and well-documented. And never were we told that this was without impact to some of the retailers. It was that here are the strategies that work for public health. And we recognize that. And I would actually love to see more restrictions on smoking products. I don't know that.
There's an appetite from this board to do that related to cannabis products, but I recognized, you know, one of the public commenters spoke to that, and there are, you know, differences perhaps in the carcinogen levels between the two products, but both, you know, I will acknowledge that smoking is not good for human health. We have control over the unincorporated part of the county, not the cities, so folks have said, oh, there's, you know, people being able to buy and sell tobacco in cities, and we don't have control over that. We don't have control over tribal lands, and there are pretty significant restrictions on getting them in the mail because of the PACT Act, and, you know, the Postal Service doesn't sell them, so it has to be legal. We have licensed sellers that verify age, and it's somewhat more restricted, and most of the delivery companies do not service this, so I think...
I think we're making a dent in the access to cigarettes, which obviously it doesn't just impact the individual. It impacts young people through secondhand smoke and people who have no control over their exposure. And, you know, we know that the profit margin for these products is relatively low, too, because, you know, there's high taxes. And I get that it brings people in the door to buy other things. But, you know, those are the kind of considerations I'm using as we've approached this. And, again, we do know that there is some impact on businesses. So I'd love to see a way that we can preserve the cap to the extent possible. If this board wants to make recommendations about what that looks like, then great. But I don't want to see the cap just get... just continue to grow because...
defeats the purpose of this whole ordinance. This is an area of public health where it has known benefits and we have a choice to make about, you know, about whether we want to protect people from the harms of not just cigarette smoke for the individual but the other people it impacts. And, you know, I just want to see us preserve the cap to the extent possible. So whatever suggestions you may have about how to do that in a fair and equitable way that also supports small businesses but doesn't grow the cap over time, I'm happy to hear. And I think we just need to give our staff direction. And I'm frankly like a little bit miffed about the way that we're talking about the outreach that has happened and the meeting conversations that we've had. So not very often do I get ruffled by this board. But thank you for just kind of bearing with it to the staff that are working.
on this. Thanks. I too would say that one of my issues is that I want the other jurisdictions to sign on and I think that if we do make some accessibilities or some not accessibility some different language for transferable if you already currently have one that we would get we could get the other jurisdictions to sign on and I am not a cigarette smoker and I do not like it and I do not like to be around it and I've said that many times but I do know I do come from a family of smokers unfortunately and they would drive 500 miles to buy cigarettes when they are out which is a bummer to me you know that that it's that addictive so I get I get that I would love for me I guess what I would like is that if a store currently has a tobacco license and I would like to put a probably a five mile
radius on it. I'll reference to Myers Flat, who the next is the only store in the town. And or we could say if that if there's one store in a town and and they sell cigarettes, something like that. But Myers Flat is the only store there. The next only store is Miranda. And then then it's another seven miles to Garberville. So you see what I'm saying? It's And so something like that would be my preference. I would like to stick with the category that Supervisor Arroyo is talking about and not allow new businesses to, if we're above that cap, new businesses to get a license, but to like Supervisor Bone reference to through attrition, through stores closing and not new ones opening. I think we'll get down to that cap. And then once we're under, then there would be an application for a license. And then once we're under, then there would be an application for an application for a license. And then once we're under, then there would be an application for an application process. Is that correct? Yeah. But to allow the stores that currently Um,
Carry tobacco if they're trying to sell their business, and that is going to hinge on the sell to allow that to happen, and then through attrition or stores closing, whatever, to try to get down under that cap. I also really want, I can't say it enough, really want to encourage the jurisdictions to want to sign on. And so I think a little bit of lighter language around transferring current licenses will help that. So that's my preference, and I'm going to say it 100 times. Thank you for your outreach. Thank you for your education, and thank you for what you do. Supervisor Wilson. Thanks, Samia. I think the main goal of all this is to reduce smoking and the harms of smoking and the harms of tobacco in general and nicotine. And I've heard that it's choice. But I did. Addiction is not a choice. We talked about.
What drives people to want to go great lengths to get cigarettes, and that speaks to the addiction, not the choice. No one's choosing to spend half their day to try and find some cigarettes in some other town or whatever it is. It's not what they want to be doing. We've definitely, through restrictions, reduced smoking through ordinances in California and many other places. And I can remember very clearly when we removed tobacco products and smoking from bars. And I remember very clearly the sort of language around the Armageddon that would occur, these businesses, if that was to happen. And, well, it turned out some months later people still went to bars, and people still went out, and they still did their thing, and they smoked.
Outside for a while, we did have an issue around cigarette butts, again, getting into gutters because people were outside smoking. Again, I'm going to be clear, I think we should get rid of filtered tobacco products in general. So I just want to say that, to address another issue, but I think the way that we deal with these changes over time is through caps and that we do this through attrition. But I think the attrition that we were talking about was the transfer of these licenses. And I think there was specific discussion around, well, that's why we had it. It was for everybody, and then we modified it to not be an issue for family members. I mean, that's why I think the language is actually in the ordinance is because the original language was non-transferable at all, and then it was modified. For family members.
So I think there was some discussion around that. And so I strongly favor and want to see a cap. If there is discussion around some sort of geographical construct around that, if a majority of the board wants to really look at that, I'm personally not, that's not where I want to see this go. But if that happens, I would say that it should be fairly, the distance should be more than five miles from my perspective. Because otherwise we're just making it for, we're making, again, we're doing planning. Planning around specific applications versus what we're trying to get to. So when one person comes in and says,
Well, this doesn't fit what I want to do. Then we're like, then do we come back and reorient our ordinance once more? I think that's, that's, it feels a bit like that. And I want to make sure that our policy is broad and, and, and, and it's fair. It makes sense to everybody. The one thing I would ask for is, I think is, is the application or the, the permit itself, the piece of paper we hand to somebody that says you are an owner of this, of this asset, which is the permit, this entitlement. It, is that, is that a Humboldt County derived piece of paper that, you know what I'm saying? Like a certification? Yeah, that's a DEH developed fillable application. And I would say that if we're going to be retaining the, the cap and the non-transferability of this, that it should, if it doesn't already, because I've not seen it, that that app, that piece of paper should be, should be, should be, should be, should be, should be, should be.
Paper should say very clearly with a box around it, this is non-transferable to any other business unless or something or even like may not be transferable or, you know, because we don't know what the caveats are. But be just really clear, this piece of paper, this license is non-transferable, saying it very, very clearly. You know, we've talked about this at the planning department around the owner-occupied permits. It's like it should say very clearly, non-transferable, so that everybody really understands and there's not this sort of assumption as, oh, I didn't know. It should be, you know, in red letters. I don't know. I'm not telling you what to do. But something that gives you, that gives that assurance to everybody or that understanding to everybody. The other part about this was an expression around saving the mom and pops. And I think we see that in a lot of other, even around. Cannabis. Sort of the.
You know, the multiple ownerships and the limit on sort of the franchising or the franchises to have access to those transferabilities. And so in cannabis, we made some, you know, adjustments around that. I would say that in this case, if that's something that is considered, again, I am trying to, if there's a majority that wants to move forward with some of this stuff, I'm offering some ideas about, you know, trying to get a middle ground to that space. But I am not in favor of necessarily moving these things forward. But in what I'm getting at is like limiting the number of licenses in terms of the transferability. Like if you own so many licenses, sorry, you know, until you get down to a certain number of licenses, it's not transferable. So that you are offering transferability only to people who have no licenses. Or one license or something that's very, that's very.
limiting in that in that regard um and again i'll just you know i want to put it on the table and i don't know where it gets weaved into this the last time i'll mention it is is i i think we need to start looking at um non-filtered tobacco products or banning the filter and tobacco products so that we can limit the amount of pollution that is created from from these products and then so those are my comments um i'm sorry that they're kind of a little bit all over the place and not offering succinct direction but i didn't really actually know what we were going to be talking about today so other than hearing some discussion so thanks thank you i also just um want to in in essence of time remind this board that two board members have to leave and so if we could try to wrap this one up i'm going to go to supervisor arroyo but i do want to say uh the five miles for me is um on the avenue of the giants which is largely in my district district it is like one store
five miles. It really is through the avenue. And similarly, and I don't need you to respond, I'm just making a comment here. And then I'm going to go to Supervisor Arroyo and then you can come back to you. Just similarly in that area down there seems to be the five mile increments and people would drive from Myers Plot to Miranda. I just think it makes sense that we don't have these vehicles going back and forth between communities if we can help it. So that's just my thoughts. Supervisor Arroyo. Thank you. I think this is known and has been emphasized when we talked about this in the past, but I just want to reiterate that commercial tobacco use and that term distinguishes from like ceremonial use of tobacco within specific cultures. But commercial, you know, frequent regular tobacco use is the leading cause of preventable disease, disability, and death in this country. So when I think about what...
have control over is a decision-making body that makes decisions about public health. If we could make any dent at all in any meaningful dent in the leading cause of death that is preventable in our nation, I think I take that responsibility very seriously. And I think it outweighs some of the other impacts in my mind. But I would suggest that the ad hoc take this feedback and come, you know, we're not prepared with an agendized recommendation on a policy change today. This was about providing input and direction to staff, but also, well, okay, then we can have it go just to staff to consider this input if you feel like you have enough information to make. To move forward or if you feel you need more clarity from
this board today to be able to incorporate what we're asking for which does sound like we have diverse perspectives on this um then then that would be helpful to hear um thank you uh let me just share i mean definitely we've been taking lots of notes of just the general conversation and points made and different considerations what i'm hearing is some potential options so there's the you know greater than you know 10 miles that sounds like there was some interest um five miles as another alternative to that i also heard from supervisor wilson um you know perhaps considering a limit of for one business how many licenses they could transfer um and that so that's something that i also heard um oh go ahead what's the question i just an alternative because i i hear the five more than five miles or less than five miles or supervisor madrone said
10, Wilson said a little bit more. What if there's one business, one store in a town? Is there some, and I, if that one store is selling and wants to transfer that license, you know, is there some kind of language we could put in there? Because that would, that would cut down on the traveled miles, the vehicle travel miles. Yeah. So that was sort of that line of thinking was one of the options that we had explored. And the challenge that we ran into was how towns are defined. If it's like a census designated area, or there were a couple other terms that I didn't retain. And so just determining what language would be used to determine what is considered a town. Well, so if you did a 10 mile radius, but you recognize that Myers-Platt is a town and there's one store there, so then nothing else within that 10 mile radius would qualify. Anyways. So it would.
You know, like we ought is another five miles from Myers flat. Miranda is another five miles from Myers flat. Garberville is seven miles from, you know, Miranda. So I don't know, but just the Avenue is a very dangerous area to drive as well. And I, to cut down the travel miles and the back and forth on the Avenue to, you know, that's just my thoughts. I appreciate that. I mean, I think what we would just need to do is consult with County Council of like that, you know, what would be the legal definition of a town so that we could consider that, that input that you're describing. Thank you for considering that. And I interrupted you. Do you want to finish? Was there any other alternative that we just want to, those were kind of adding the non-transferable or the license non-transferable or may not be transferable. Oh yeah. Yeah. And I think that's. Feedback that we could.
taken in terms of how we update the licenses and what's written on them. Regardless of the ordinance. So you get a state license and a county license, correct? So the state will not say that. Yeah, but the county would. Right. Transferability. Subject to whatever ordinance. Right. Then that's a big motivation for the ad hoc to provide clarity. And I'm hearing some other ideas from Supervisor Wilson. And I don't know if the board supports pursuit of those ideas or if there's, if that, how we digest that as staff or take that to, is that direction from the board? Is that direction from one supervisor? And how do we balance that direction? And what do we come back with? What is the expectation for us? Yeah, I think something that would be helpful is, you know, I don't know how, you know, procedurally you all would want to handle it. But I think actually getting. Yeah.
idea of like if any of these ideas have majority support or consensus it would at least help give an idea at least for us as staff to get an idea of like probably because we can look into all of these but that also but if there's a difference yeah that that really defeats what this agenda item is about and because the brown act we cannot talk with the ad hoc and so why don't you uh read your items we can raise our hand we'll just do very simple um and you can see if we have a majority or not and we can is that okay county council here you go that is okay it would be a straw vote however another way to do it too would be to just make a motion with regard to the direction that you would like to provide to staff and then vote on it that way and then that would it's going to be very complicated and i don't want to make five motions so i think we could just drop hole really quick and then you would have direction i don't even know if we need um anyways we'll just do that go go ahead
Okay, I'll just read it in the order that I said them. So a five-mile exemption. So I'm going to read five-mile, ten-mile, and then limited transferability. Those were like the three main ones that I... Part of the problem of the, I'm going to say the politics of this or the process of this that we're talking about right now, is that what I'm clearly saying is that I'm not actually really wanting much changes to occur, but I'm offering suggestions if there's a majority that might want to do that to get to that place. So I guess it's a little awkward in that way. I did have one, before we do that, though, I did one clarifying question from Supervisor Bush. There was a statement that there are two jurisdictions that have maybe issues around this, and are those issues around that they have... Around the cap in the transferability, because it is our transferability.
transferability issues within their jurisdictions is that something that they're concerned about and what's happening with that so rio del and fortuna are the two incorporated and yes i've had conversations with their council and their um city managers that they do not think that their council and their council has said i haven't talked to all the council but with the transferable or the cap they're not sure that they would sign on but i think they would be more likely to sign on if the license were transferable to a new owner not restricting more business in their towns so the cap i think would be okay if the licenses were transferable with current businesses they have currently and so they would not have a tro at all or i they don't have one okay i'm confused don't they take on their own version of a tro so so i think there's kind of two pieces
So one, you know, each city can choose to do their own TRL. If they, however, wanted to align with the county's TRL, that would then open an opportunity if they wanted Division of Environmental Health from the county to do the enforcement, because we already have a staff person dedicated to doing that work. And so there is an incentive for city jurisdiction, if they wanted to have that benefit, to align with what the county's ordinance is. However, they absolutely can do their own. And I will say that as we've been doing the nitrous oxide work with the city managers, you know, recently this summer, Brianna and I, you know, did connect with the city managers just to be like, hey, these are all the different provisions. What feedback do you have? Recognizing, you know, every city is going to, and every council member is going to have their own perspective. And there wasn't any, one thing in that conversation that came up as an issue, but recognizing, of course,
that council members and you know all the councils are going to have their own deliberation on it but just to share like we we did ask the city managers like hey is there anything that immediately like gives you pause and in that conversation nothing rose but obviously there have been other subsequent conversations. City and city managers advise their council and so when I was speaking with them they were like I don't know if my council will go for this and then I spoke with council members their their issue also is adopting their own ordinance and enforcing that they don't have the funds for that Riadel Fortuna and so they would it would be easier to adopt the counties and also because the nitrous ordinance can be backed by that TRL and and you guys have done the work and so it it would be easier if we were all the same if it was all the same it's more equitable for the stores and businesses as well. And just one last clarification for me the transferability on the limit of licenses wasn't the number of licenses that could be transferred. Thank you.
But the number of, if they are to be transferred under a cap, that you could only, the person being the transferee could only own a certain number of licenses, one, two, three, whatever that is, that there would be a limit or a cap on that transferability. That was it. Thanks. So I had initiated a straw poll, and I see that you want to add something else. Is it around that straw poll? I just am concerned that the things mentioned were outside of my, I want to, yeah, I guess I want to add something to the straw poll or say that like my only, I would say most of those things I will not be in support of. But yeah. If the item was just to cap the number of licenses that we currently have and allow...
form of additional transferability. I'm open to that. I just don't want to see the cap go up. So if that could be one of the straw poll items. But that's already on there. I think that it is. Yeah. Okay. I mean, I don't hear anybody on this board saying increase the cap. Great. I've not heard one person say that. Okay. Supervisor Bowne. Well, and I, I guess I, I guess when I walk on this dais, I ruffle people. I remember, um, I'm not questioning what staff did. I'm questioning. The only part is, is we've had a pretty much unanimous and everybody I've talked to, this wasn't explained to them. And you're right. They should have read all the pages. They should have run that one single line where it says, yeah, you can grandfather, but you can't sell it to anybody. But I understand that. But then we go back to the Sonoma and you brought out Sonoma because I handed it to you. I can go get more if you want from other counties, because I've done a lot of calling on this. Nobody has this issue on the transferability. So Sonoma, I think is if you've had your license with state board equals.
for nine years, that is an asset you have paid the state for. You have paid the state for. We are basically, since we have taken money from these retailers, since we have taken, and I know it's not a taking, but a lot of their businesses will be deemed basically negligible. They won't be able to sell them unless they can transfer the license. So, I mean, I'd like to see some sort of, I know we have a cap. We have an arbitrary cap which says, hey, we're throwing a cap out there. And now this is what you're going to live with. And we haven't done this. This is probably what's going to stop the local guys from wanting to get on this because they don't want to deal with this. They don't want to deal with these guys who thought they had a viable business for the rest of their lives, as they said, as they have a makeshift 401K. Now, with that being said, heart disease is the number one thing that kills people. Then cancer.
It goes down. And then heart disease, it goes by age, smoking, obesity. There's a lot to do with this. So I'm really finding that education doesn't work, and that changes a lot of what you guys are doing, because a lot of it's education, outreach, posters, paperwork, and everything else. But education doesn't work. It's enforcement and taking these things away. So if we're going to take everything away one by one, I have a concern as we go down the line, because it's just, well, we'll just take this. This won't be hard. This won't be hard. It is hard on the small businessman. And five miles. Okay, we're going to do five miles. But five miles is a crow flies. Five mile both direction. Five mile radius is Humboldt Hill of town. It's got 2,400 people up there. And the nearest market would be, I guess you go to Fairway, but otherwise it's all the way. I'll probably get it.
that five months so i'm just saying is there a consideration i know it's not going to happen i know there won't be any consideration but out of respect for the gentleman that showed up and all the ones i've talked to they're getting blindsided on this and it's nothing to do on staff i'm not staff they told them a lot of things and they've abided by a lot of things because they have the plastic up they have the setbacks and everything else i don't think they knew they wouldn't be able to transfer their business license and a classic case in point is the transfer of country club market and the transfer of redwood oil only three stations he can't transfer and it's here and i think those people are owed a certain amount 38 years red oil 50 plus years the father of convenience stores they call them so can i ask this board do does this board have a a
store an unincorporated Humboldt that already has it, not exceeding the cap. These are three of us. By raised hands. Sorry, can you tell me what the current cap is? It was 29, 28, whatever the current cap is. Yeah, 29 is the current cap and there are currently 54 licensed retailers. I see. Yeah, so we're well above the cap and we are trying to get to the cap. There are businesses closing. There are, you know, cigarette sales aren't as prominent as they used to be. I'm just asking this board, is there, because we need to get through this and we all have different ideas. And so I think we can agree on we want to keep the cap, correct? Okay, we got that one, keeping the cap. Is there a, does someone want to see a radius? Or is, does this board feel like transfer, transfer?
of any store that currently carries a tobacco license if they sell their store is okay. By hand raise, is there three of us? No, there's two of us. How about by miles? Is there a thought by miles that a store could be transfer their license within a certain mile radius? Do we have, is there three of us? Raise your hand yes or no, please. Rex, just so I can try to get through this. I understand what you're trying to get to, but I'm just saying. You don't have the board, we don't have the boards for the. I'm well aware of that, trust me. So I see three votes for a mile radius. What that mile radius is now we need to get down to. What was the other things? Let's see, Supervisor Wilson's recommendation of, and for the American Council, I don't know if I can say this, but I think it's a good idea to have a recommendation of a mile radius. I don't know if I can say this, but I think it's a good idea to have a
It's like I know what you're talking about, but I'm realizing maybe I'm not saying no around a cap on the number of licenses an individual business could transfer. Is there a three votes for limiting the amount of licenses that are consecutive to one owner? Or just straw poll. I don't understand that. I don't know if you mean transferable to just the owners or transferable. So if someone owns one license and someone wants to purchase the business that owns 15 licenses, it may not be transferable if there is a cap on the amount of licenses you can own. Let me clarify here, because really it's about the mom and pop part of this, which is transferring to somebody who has a limited number of licenses, basically. It's the same, Mike. So it's. If someone out there that has 30 licenses wants to buy a Tom's store that has one.
And we have a cap on that, then those folks are not going to be able to buy his one store, which is a mom and pop. But if someone of a mom and pop has a zero license or one or two licenses wants to buy Tom's one store, they can. You got it. Thank you. So you're saying if somebody comes in here and wants to buy Tom's store that's been in business for 20 years, 10 years, whatever the case may be, and he owns no stores in Humboldt County, we could transfer to him? Yes. That's the concept because it maintains the mom and pop part of that. That's kind of from day one. I'm not looking to sell to change or anything else. We do have the element of the one that's selling to a large chain, but they don't own any here. So if this board wants to have a cap on excessive licenses not being able to buy another license, please raise your hand so we can get down to that. Is there three of us? I'm willing to see that workshopped. Yes. I have a lot of questions. There's going to have to be clarification.
But we need to whittle this down. So there's three of us. Next question, please. There was five of us, actually. I'll have one that I request, which is, sorry, which is transferability only if the license limits to non-filtered products. Does anybody on this board, are there three votes for that? It's about the butts, the waste product. Yeah, I know what it is about. So it would be selling non-filtered tobacco products. Are there three votes for that? No, no three votes for that. Well, I'm just going to say it turns out that it's not less.
Okay. Less healthy. So you have three items that this board feels that you have support for. Does this board then want it to go back to the ad hoc to funnel out those three items? Do you feel like you can get us closer to the goal that you've heard today? I'd rather just see it come back from staff because I think Rex and I are on very different wavelengths on this particular issue. Fair enough. I don't want to hear his comments the 20th and 30th and 50th time on the same stuff over and over again. I've heard you, Rex. You've made your points very well. But frankly, that was the problem that you actually admitted to in the very first meeting where you got in trouble of trying to push stuff. You know, it's like we should just speak our points of view but not feel the need to lobby for it 20, 30 times. I get real tired of that. So no, I think it should just come back from staff, frankly. Okay. So then, Sophia, do you need more? Wow. So on those three items. Thank you.
How can we help you with direction? Let me just summarize how I understand them. And you all let me know if you're like, that is not what I heard. So keeping the cap the same, so that would remain the same, but having some sort of radius exemption. We didn't get specificity on miles, but we can look, given the conversation, I feel like we can look at like five miles versus 10 and kind of get, you know, look at some, give you some ideas of like what the difference would be. And then also looking at, again, we'll workshop how to talk about limiting the transferability based on the number of licenses owned by a business. And so we'll also work with county council will be a really important partner. Thank you so much. But that's what I heard. Is there any clarification you all need? Okay. Okay. Say it back one more time. And then I'm going to make that into a motion. Okay. Okay. Okay.
Pop quiz. So keep the cap the same with a radius exemption and we will look at different options for that and then also coming back with a recommendation for limiting the transferability of licenses based on the number of licenses held by a business. Kaylee did you get that? I did. I'm gonna make that motion. Can I get a second? I'll second. Okay Kaylee can we get the voting taps up? Supervisor Arroyo. Oh, sorry, we're voice voting? Yes. Oh. I said yes. Oh, I'm sorry. Thank you. Supervisor Wilson. Yes. Supervisor Madrone. Yes. Chair Bushnell. Yes. Supervisor Madrone.
Supervisor Bone? Yes. Motion carries 5-0. Thank you to staff. Thank you. Thank you very much. So our next item is going to be closed session and we'll go to County Council. Thank you Chair Bushnell. It is the intention of the board to meet in closed session pursuant to California Government Code Sections 54954.5 and 54957 in order to consider the public employee performance evaluations for the positions of the Clerk of the Board of Supervisors and the Director of Planning and Building. It is also the intention of the board to meet in closed session pursuant to California Government Code Section 54957.6 in order to review the county's position and instruct its designated labor negotiators. Finally, it is the intention of the board to meet in closed session pursuant to California Government Code Section 54957.5 6.9 D1 in order to discuss existing
litigation in the cases of Janet Reed Rogers versus County of Humboldt, Humboldt County Superior Court case number CV 2501810, Yurok Indian Housing Authority versus County of Humboldt, Humboldt County Superior Court case number CV 2401392, and Robin Heather Storm versus County of Humboldt et al., Humboldt County Superior Court case number CV 2500572. Okay, thank you. We're going to go to public comment on closed session items, and we'll start on the Zoom. There is none, Chair. Closing that portion, going into the room, any public comment in the room? Seeing none, closing that. How long do you estimate closed session? I would say about two hours and 15 minutes. Okay, so we're going to do two.
Two hours and 15 minutes. We'll let Eric know if it's sooner. And then also, for the board, 10 minutes, please. We have lunch in there. And then come right into A, please. Thank you.
Thank you. Okay. We're reconvening here and... Oh, yeah. Microphone, right. Here we are. We're reconvening this afternoon after closed session. Do we have a report out? Yes, we do. There is no reportable action taken with regard to items K-1 through K-3 and K-5 through K-6. With regard to item K-4, the board voted unanimously to authorize the Humboldt County Council's Office to defend the County of Humboldt in the...
Case of Janet Reed Rogers versus County of Humboldt. Humboldt County Superior Court case number CV2501810. Thank you. Are there any other comments? Seeing none, we are adjourned. We are adjourned. We're adjourning memory. It's a reminder. It was brought up. OK. They came in here. Yeah. Was she on the highway? Down on I-5. She was the one that got landed on top of. OK. Do you want to talk? Oh, OK. OK.