Humboldt County Board of Supervisors
Tuesday, January 6, 2026
The agenda


9:01 a.m.

Thank you. And by out of town, I mean out of state. Thank you.


9:02 a.m.

Thank you. Thank you. Start this meeting Tuesday, January 6th. We're going to start with a roll call.


9:03 a.m.

That's where we're going to go from there. Thank you, Chair. Supervisor Bone? Yep. Supervisor Bushnell? Good morning. Supervisor Wilson? Present. Supervisor Madrone? Present. Supervisor Arroyo? Here. All are here. All right. You can stay standing. We're going to do the... All right. And Supervisor Bushnell is going to lead us in the pledge. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you. Great. And we'll start the new year with some minor changes to how we're going to kind of introduce the meeting. And so the next part, this is where...


9:04 a.m.

Staff, Kaylee in particular here, is going to kind of give some information as we move forward. Take it away. Thank you, Chair. Good morning and welcome to the meeting of January 6, 2026. This meeting is being conducted in accordance with the Brown Act applicable state and local requirements. Members of the public may participate in person and or remotely as noticed on the agenda. For those participating remotely, public comment is welcome and encouraged. To ensure your voice is heard, it is recommended that you raise your hand at the start of the item you wish to comment on. If you are joining by computer or mobile device, please use the raise hand feature to indicate your desire to speak. When it is your turn, you will be unmuted by staff. If you are joining by telephone, please press star 9 to raise your hand. When recognized, you may press star 6 to unmute yourself and begin speaking. Please state your name for the record before making your comment. The board asks that all participants... ...conduct themselves with respect...


9:05 a.m.

and courtesy. Comments should be directed to the board as a whole and limited to the time allowed. Thank you, Chair. All right, thank you. And the next thing we're going to do is modifications to the agenda. Good morning, Chair Wilson. There will be two modifications. Item D5 and D12 will be pulled from consent for discussion just to make some very quick updates to the attachments. Okay, D5 and D12. Great. And I just wanted to notice that we have three time sets today, two at noon for employee performance valuations for the Director of Health and Human Services and Public Works. And also at noon, we have a time set for closed session as well. Okay, moving on. So we're going to just go into items that are on the consent calendar. We have a few things here. I'm going to start with a recognition of Tom Mattson. And that's brought to us by Supervisor...


9:06 a.m.

Thank you. I just wanted to, this was a CSAC award that I wanted to, and he probably doesn't like that I'm doing this, but I wanted to recognize that our public works director, Tom Mattson, received the Ed Hanna Memorial Award for the County Engineer of the Year. So we would just like to congratulate him. And I'm going to walk out and give him a certificate. Thank you. I'll do a picture first. Okay, I'm going to stand over here. Maybe you can hold this. All right, Tom, you got anything to say? Yes. Thank you, Supervisor Bushnell, for bringing this forward, members of the board, for the recognition. This award is really, in my opinion,


9:07 a.m.

I have a lifetime award. I really don't do a lot of engineering, but I've dedicated my life to making things better for county and city engineers, especially as it goes to trying to get federal funds. Many small agencies have a real hard time trying to leverage federal funds, and so I started with the county engineers in 2003. I worked on their transportation committee as the chair, the transportation co-op committee, which is a committee that met monthly at the Sacramento airport with federal, state, and local representatives to try to ease the burden on delivering federal projects. And then I worked as co-chair of the highway safety improvement program committee, again, to try to bring more money to local agencies. The highway safety improvement program at that time had... $200 million in unobligated funds, and the problem with that is if you have...


9:08 a.m.

The feds take them back at the end of the year and redistribute them to other agencies. So we were able to turn that around so that every year since 2017, California has gotten more out of the Highway Safety Improvement Program than we were originally allocated because on the August redistribution, we had all of our money spent and we had projects ready and we moved more money into California. So this is, like I say, more of a, there are stupid people in life like me that just don't know really how to say no. And every time somebody asked, I said, well, I'll do that. I'll do that. And the next thing you know, they give me an award for saying I'll do that. So I'm starting to learn to say I'm not going to do that. Thank you. Thank you. Through the chair, if I could ask Bob to say a couple words. He also sent me the. Pictures and was, I think Natalie and I both attended the award ceremony at CSAC and Bob.


9:09 a.m.

Senate there, if that would be okay. By all means, Bob, take it away. Thank you for allowing me a moment to go ahead and speak. It was certainly a pleasure to have been asked to go ahead and present the award to Director Mattson. I have worked with Director Mattson since I started with the county back in 2000, so a 25-year working career and growing, and it's been a great honor working with him and collaborating and producing the great department that we have today. That's what I'd like to conclude with. Thank you. Great. Supervisor Bushnell, do you have anything else? Anything from the rest of the board? Supervisor Madrone? Well, thank you for that. And, you know, Tom always is. He's in the background lifting his own folks up, and that is quite an admirable approach to life.


9:10 a.m.

to recognize the team effort. And so thank you, Tom, for all your decades of commitment to our community. Appreciate it. Nope, nope. OK, we're all good. Thanks, Tom. I'm going to honor you by not giving you a lot of words right now. As I know, that's probably the best reward you would want. So moving on to the next thing, but a huge thanks, 100%. And you know, you get it from us all the time. Certificate of recognition for Gail Gibson-Stillwell for her 2025 national finals. Let's call her Haley. Actually, did I do it wrong? Well, you called her Gail. Haley. Haley. Oh, sorry. That's all right, Bob. I got the last name correct anyway. It's all right, Bob. All right. And it was interrupted. So for the 2025. National finals.


9:11 a.m.

Rodeo debut and so I brought it away. Well I brought this forward because any time that Redcrest, Holmes, but Redcrest and Humboldt County can get mentioned 10 times on national television is kind of a big deal. And so Haley's got a couple of representatives because believe it or not she's rodeoing in Arizona. She's on the way to San Diego. Yeah anyway she's rodeoing somewhere but she's a Redcrest gal now, followed love and didn't grow up here but her husband did and she calls herself a resident of Redcrest, California. And so they call her the Humboldt County cowgirl or the Redcrest cowgirl but Lori Cook has got a few things to say. And so does Meredith but Lori did a big fundraiser back in April I believe and to help them fund her road to the NFR.


9:12 a.m.

You McCorder who happens to be out of Petrolia and we're going to do another one because it's expensive to do what she's doing. But she ended up fourth in the world and I'll let Lori kind of tell her. And I think Haley's watching. Yeah, she should be watching. So, hey Haley. This is a letter that Haley wrote for me to express her congratulations. She goes, Dear Humboldt County Board of Supervisors and County of Humboldt, I would like to extend my sincere gratitude to the County of Humboldt and the Humboldt County Board of Supervisors for the recognition of Achievement Proclamation, honoring my accomplishments during this past year and my performances at the National Finals Rodeo. It is truly an honor to be recognized by the community. I am proud to call home representing Humboldt County on a professional rodeo trail that has meant more to me than words can express. Throughout the year, my horses Piper, Fancy, and Sharky and I have traveled thousands of miles and competed in 82 rodeos across the country. Carrying Humboldt with me every step of the way. From small town arenas to


9:13 a.m.

the bright lights of the National Finals Rodeo. I worked hard to represent our county with integrity, grit, and determination. A point of pride for me is that I bred, trained, and ride my own horses. The success I achieved this season is a direct result of the years of dedication, long days, and countless hours spent building those partnerships and bonds with my equine dancing partners. Being able to take courses I raised and develop at home in Humboldt County and compete in the highest level of professional rodeo is something I am incredibly proud of. This season accumulated with qualifying for and competing in the National Finals Rodeo, where I finished fourth in the world. Reaching that level is no small feat, and it would not have been possible without the unwavering support of my family, friends, community, and sponsors. I am deeply grateful to my sponsors who believe in me and continued support, make it possible to pursue this dream. I am grateful to my sponsors who believe in me and continued support, make it possible to pursue this dream. I am deeply grateful to my sponsors who believe in me and continued support, make it possible to pursue this demanding career. I am also thankful for the Humboldt County community for the support I have received.


9:14 a.m.

their encouragements, messages, and hometown pride, and following me down the road all year long. If it wasn't for the community fundraising this year, it may not have been made possible. Thank you again to the County of Humboldt and the Board of Supervisors for this meaningful recognition. It is a privilege to represent Humboldt County on the national stage, and I look forward to continuing to work hard and give back and carry on the county's name with pride in everything I do. With sincere appreciation, Haley Gibson Stilwell. She went into the NFR in 12th position, and she ended up in 4th. So at the end of the year, she ended up with $328,640 and some change. She went in with only $140,000. So she was one of the top barrel racers that finished there. We are doing another fundraiser this year for her on May 2nd at the Veterans Building in Fortuna for her and Quentin. And then she just won at Red Bluff last weekend. The Cavaliers. California National Circuit Rodeo. So she was the top.


9:15 a.m.

racer so and she also won best dressed cowgirl which i thought yeah she won best dressed and her horse piper won um piper won horse of the year for state of california so so i think on the nfr she only rode piper is that correct yeah she only rode piper she had three horses with her but she only rode piper and if you watch if you watched uh she battled from day one to the end oh yeah she did and i mean her husband was in the in the alleyway with her and he was bit he was kicked he was everything trying to get i mean she her horses are something else yeah so well i like the story says it's kind of amazing because she was riding that horse bareback through red crest oh yeah she was trained and i mean that's these people go out and buy horses and stuff and she's raising her own and and i it's just to hear humboldt county like i said on the national stage 10 nights in a row yeah i mean for something like that it's it's it's it's it's it's it's it's it's it's it's it's it's it's it's it's it's something positive that it was you know didn't have anything to do with just a


9:16 a.m.

one of our residents, you know, and we've embraced her pretty strongly. She uses Piper as a ranch horse on the off-seasons. I mean, that horse does everything. So one of the things that's really funny is, well, not funny, but it's kind of cool, is her sister looked back and found her vision book when she was 10 years old. And when she was 10 years old, she wrote in her book she was going to be, in 2025, she was going to be a national finalist at the rodeo. Wow. I mean, so she knew from young age that she was so small that she was just on a flatback saddle riding when she was little. So thank you so much. Lori, thank you. Pretty cool. Thank you for organizing the fundraiser. It was fun last year. I'm looking forward to next year. Okay. Thank you. Meredith, did you want to? I've never seen you not talk, so. I've got nothing really official to say other than Haley. Like you said, watching her come down that alley for 10 nights.


9:17 a.m.

It's in a row with that mare, and you could just see Piper. The minute she hit that alley, she knew. And it was like she'd look at John and go, let me go. I want to go do my job, and she did. And Haley, on those 10 nights, I'm 68. I've bred and raised horses all my life. I have dreamed of going to a world stage like that with a horse that I bred and raised. Not going to happen. I'm done breeding. I'm done raising horses. I'm too old. I have a nice horse. We play. Haley has made all the young girls in Humboldt County and probably the nation over, their dreams come true. She raises her own. She breeds her own. She trains her own. Like Lori said, she uses them on the ranch during the off season. And then goes to the... least. And she's theatching, always. She's the best. And now 15 horses were to have it for her again. And she'll keep breeding them beyond the sunset, because I'm like a rock from the big nudeíchote казares


9:18 a.m.

finals for 10 nights and smokes them just does good and i just want to thank her and i want to thank you guys for recognizing that and i want to thank her for making old people's little girl dreams come true i think people need to understand there are thousands of barrel racers oh yeah in the state thousands and she was number four in the world in her first time at the nfr yeah so we expect bigger things from her next year no pressure yeah no no pressure no none all right is there a okay a photo well hayley might want a photo i'll take all right someone get a photo quick you


9:19 a.m.

Thank you. All right, thank you. I just want to say this is pretty amazing. Barrel racing is my favorite part of rodeo. It is kind of the most exciting part. And as you can tell, it takes local sponsors to help people do these really wonderful things. So if you're a local business and this is something you're interested in, by all means, jump in and help Haley. Exactly. I mean, you understand, she's towing. She's towing horses and a trailer and everything else. She has a truck broke down somewhere in, I don't know if it's North Dakota, but still broke down from earlier in the year. It's not a cheap sport by any means and everything else, but she had great sponsorship. The fundraiser that we had for her was a good start for her and Quentin McCorder. And Quentin is... Yeah.


9:20 a.m.

He'll be there next year, hopefully. One last thing. Thank you. I just want to congratulate Haley and also just say she had a huge team of folks from Humboldt following her all the way to Las Vegas, going to many of her rodeos. It really does take a team for her, which she is very humble about and recognizes often. Her husband has been just there almost, and her mom has been there continuously supporting her. It's tireless what she was doing. Some of those rodeos, when you compete, you try to get points. There's nobody in the stands, so you're just doing it for, you know, you're going your horse, and you're just competing, getting those points. And so really great recognition for Humboldt County and the support that she got from her family and friends and Humboldt County. And we look forward to NFR 2026. All right. Thank you for bringing that forward. Supervisor?


9:21 a.m.

There are a few letters of appreciation here. I just want to note there's one for Erin Kelly for her service on the Humboldt County Forestry Review Committee. There's some reappointments to the Humboldt Law Library, and there's a letter of appreciation to Larry Miller for his service on the Humboldt County Human Rights Commission. Any comments on those? I would just like to add through the chair, if I could, the Workforce Board added three folks, and they're always looking. A supervisor of Madrone is going to be taking that position this year. I'm going to be alternate. I do plan on attending. It's a very great committee and really hones in on Humboldt County and workforce. And so I just really want to thank those folks, three of them, Jada, Jared, and Justin, for being willing. Great. And with that, we're going to open this up to public. Oh, you have to go ahead, Supervisor Madrone. Yeah.


9:22 a.m.

And I too want to thank Erin Kelly for her service on the Forestry Review Committee and that creates an opening. So if there are any registered professional foresters out there that would like to serve on this committee, you can be from anywhere in Hobo County. It doesn't have to be in my district. But please let us know and get an application in to serve on that committee. They only meet about three or four times a year, so it's not a huge responsibility, but it's an important one. And then also thank you to Larry Miller, who also served on the Human Rights Commission for years. So thank you, Larry, very much for your service. All right. With that, we're going to open up to public comment, starting on Zoom. Thank you, Chair. Caller 7718, I will unmute you and you'll have three minutes. Thank you. Hello, Kemp Swarovski calling.


9:23 a.m.

From Mexico. Yeah, let's start with D1, Tom Mattson. He's one person when he says, I'll do that, he does it. There's a bunch of people who say, I'll do that, but he does it. I strongly support Tom. Kind of interesting that later, coincidentally later in the day, the employee evaluation is when you're getting an award for the Engineer of the Year. I started watching barrel racing here recently. I have a friend, Erin McClure, and she does it, so I always go to her. And this is what I hope Humboldt County will be known for, is barrel racing and things like that coming out of Humboldt County. So I really applaud that people are doing that. I learned by talking to Erin that the relationship that the person has with that horse. That's why when you train the horse from the get-go and you have it and you ride it every single day, the horse works with the person very well under the circumstances. I like the name Adios Bantamonis. That's another horse that races.


9:24 a.m.

But I really applaud our local people for getting involved and doing well on the national level. Law Library, we have Cindy Day Wilson and Dustin Owens, I don't know the other person, but both good attorneys through IU from the Law Library. I know this item D1, we have a $2 million project approximately for ad building going up to bid February 3rd. Hopefully we'll get some local contractors on that one. D13, we have an after the fact notification, I guess, it's December 26th with a holiday, but it's a one-time thing. And so it's a reward justifiably for our great employees to have that extra day off. And of course, hopefully everybody will do good and next year have it off also. So I really appreciate what's going on there and I wish to make those comments on your consent items today. Thank you for an opportunity to speak. Thank you. Anyone else on Zoom? That is all, Chair. Anyone in the room that wants to speak to anything that's on consent?


9:25 a.m.

This is your time to do it. I probably need to say that folks, when you're hearing public comment happening, if you want to do public comment, get in line. Come on up. Let's do it. Good morning, Mr. Chairman, ladies and gentlemen of the board, ladies and gentlemen of Humboldt County. My name is Vernon Price. I'm here to speak about item number D14. I'm reading off page number two of three of the staff report. That residential assistance, housing relocation, and stabilization. I have some questions on the housing relocation part of the stabilization. There are some subjects that are in programs of Humboldt County Home Program that are looking to relocate from their apartment complex due to, for lack of better interest or better words, slumlords. They relocate.


9:26 a.m.

They're needing to get out of the apartments because of the non-fixed, the things that need to be fixed around the apartment complexes are not being fixed and they definitely need a safe place to call home. So my question is on the housing relocation, if the county staff can give me a call or an email explaining what that relocation is, I would be able to get back to some of the formerly unhoused homeless and be able to give an explanation of what that is. Thank you so much for your time, your concern, any consideration on this matter. And if there's any questions, comments, or concerns, I'll be glad to address those at any given time. Thank you. Thank you. Next. Good morning, supervisors. Happy New Year 2026. Great to be in Humboldt County. My name is Lewis. I live here and


9:27 a.m.

Yeah, it's very interesting that a woman basically doing the laps around barrels would require over a quarter million dollars in funding and resources in 2025 to do what she does. That is an astronomical amount of money. Way beyond anything a normal middle class female equine enthusiast would ever dream of investing in getting somewhere. It just puts it in a different level, that type of money. And here in Humboldt County when gas is probably more expensive than anywhere else in the United States, it's a lot cheaper to invest in gas than it is to invest in gas.


9:28 a.m.

Hundreds of equestrians have just gotten out of even thinking about hauling horses, feeding horses, the cost of hay, and the whole equestrian... I'm going to ask you to keep it on the consent calendar item, please. Yeah, and the whole fact of getting involved with horses has become so out of the reach of most people that it makes what she's done even more special. But the fact of the matter is that is it possible to keep that going without huge amounts of sponsorship, investment, and coming together? Is it becoming a completely specialized and sponsorship type thing, or is it something that anybody can have?


9:29 a.m.

access to because here we are january 6th after what happened in the capitol it's all about access and what access do most people in humboldt county have to go barrel racing unless they have extreme amounts of sponsorship thank you all right thank you is there anyone else in the chambers that wants to speak on the consent calendar looks like there's one more is there anyone if there's anyone else please this is your time to get in line all right go ahead yeah good morning i think this is the time i'm supposed to address the board um it's on the item for the sheriff's request to cease the no no this is on consent items that has its own it has its own item on that we'll be talking about later okay but we're getting close i didn't want to blow my chance okay we'll let you know for sure


9:30 a.m.

Thank you. Yeah, yeah. All right. I'm looking for a motion to approve consent calendar minus D5 and D12. I make a motion to approve the consent calendar minus D5 and D12. Is there a second? I'll second, hopefully. Great. Is there any more discussion? Seeing none, is there any objection to unanimous consent? Seeing no objection, the vote passes 5-0. Okay. Moving on to items pulled from consent, and we're going to go to D5, I believe. Through the chair, we do have a 9.30 time set, and it is 9.30. Oh, you are right. We have a 9.30 time set. That's what we're going to do. Thank you for keeping us in line and with the time. So with that, we're going to go to the 9.30 time set, which is a letter of support. For Senate Bill SB 684.


9:31 a.m.

It's called the Polluters Pay Climate Superfund Act. And Supervisor Arroyo is bringing this to us, so I'm going to let her kick this off and give us some explanation. Thank you very much. So this Senate bill, there was an assembly bill that preceded it. It's had kind of a, in both houses of the legislature, it's had people advancing similar bills, sort of consolidated it into SB 684. But our assembly members also helped to sponsor it and co-support it because it was consolidated with that assembly bill. So this was a community request that we consider a letter of support from some constituents and especially...


9:32 a.m.

because, excuse me, our Assemblymember Chris Rogers, but also Assemblymember Damon Connolly, who represents a district just to the south and has been very active in Humboldt County as well, we're both supporters of it. So I did just learn that this one is also not moving forward in its current form. It's sort of that time of year when bills get reconstituted and brought forward again in a slightly modified form. So the request is still to consider passing this because the support for it will help shape the next iteration. And emphasizing the matters brought up in the bill is still of value. So I think that's all I have to say about it unless there are questions. Okay. I'm looking for comment and questions from board members. Before we go to public comment.


9:33 a.m.

And Supervisor Bushnell. Thanks. I'm just curious, with it changing forms, would we be supporting the thought or what? Because I'm not really wanting to vote on something that I don't know what we're voting on. Sure. This one hasn't technically died yet, so it would be voting to support the way that it's currently written, which I personally do support, which is why I didn't pull it. And I did just learn that it's unlikely to move forward in its current form this year. But I think the idea is to express the support for how it's currently worded, so that that can inform the next steps. Okay. And then my next question, through the chair, if that's okay, is it's supposed to make major fossil fuel companies fund climate disaster costs, shifting the burden from taxpayers to polluters. And I'm wondering, you know, that will be passed on to taxpayers through gas prices. I'm assuming. Or could you...


9:34 a.m.

you know, in your research, should you find different? So there are ways that, for example, oil spills is one of the biggest ones where companies are responsible to comply with the cleanup costs and if they're the responsible party. This is extending that and working with, you know, the airport and other regulatory agencies to kind of expand on that framework. And, you know, I don't doubt that it'll have some market impact, but, you know, currently there are already requirements for some forms of pollution for companies that are responsible to be accountable for that. So this is expanding on that. I don't know if it's possible to exactly project what the costs and impacts will be, but


9:35 a.m.

that are part of the Code of Federal Regulations on the federal level, but expanding that in California at the state level. Okay. Thank you. I would, of course, want to hold oil spillers accountable to their cleanups, but I would like language that says that those costs won't be passed on to my constituents who already are bearing the burden of high gas rates. And I also would love for there to be language in here that is, you know, holding the person more responsible as well, saying, you know, do a hybrid vehicle if you can, ride more buses if you can, maybe do an electrical vehicle if you can, not always making it the responsibility of that organization of, say, a gas or oil producer, saying it's your responsibility to cut back. And so I'm not going to be supporting this, but I do support, you know, holding polluters responsible, absolutely, but without the language saying that this won't be passed on to my constituents.


9:36 a.m.

be passed on to consumers and with this document possibly changing in the future i'm not going to be supporting it today all right any more comment from the board supervisor and it's and i don't know the california center for jobs and economy has has done the projections the estimated projections that's all we can do um you know understanding that there's only two other states that have done this and that's vermont and new york and neither one has implemented it because it is basically this is turning into the lawyers full employment act um we're looking at an 18 billion dollar deficit in the state they expect and now we've you know marathon pulled out their refinery closed down at the end of last year valero is closing down so we're now going to be producing about 71 percent of our gasoline that we use in the state fuel that we use in the state of california


9:37 a.m.

All our neighboring states, all our neighboring states are averaging about $1.80 a gallon cheaper than California. They expect energy and gas prices, this is just California Center for Jobs and Economy, and this may be a right-wing, left-wing, I don't even know what this is, but this is what they projected, is they expect fuel could go, energy prices could go up 43%. Gasoline by 2027 potentially pushing prices as high as $8.43 a gallon. Job losses, critics estimate, and these are critics, so we understand, they're going to go on the other side. The other side will price $8.00, it will create 1,000 jobs, but there will be government jobs in the California EPA, which if you've dealt with the California EPA, we're going to provide a lot of jobs, and they're using all the buzzwords, disadvantaged communities, all the same thing they do with a lot of the law enforcement. Laws that's going to help schools, but it hasn't.


9:38 a.m.

estimate 205,000 jobs due to reduced consumer spending. GDP and tax revenue could result in a $30.5 billion annual reduction and a $4.5 billion loss in state and local taxes. And the retroactive liability back to 1990 creates significant regulatory uncertainty. I mean, it sounds great. Let's go after the big bad. But the problem being is this is also going to go after construction companies. This could go after farms because they're polluters because they use tractors. They don't limit in this. This is so broad, and I appreciate this discussion. But this thing died in our Senate and Assembly. And Assembly, that has a super majority of people that should be backing this, but they realize cost-effectiveness in the industry is going to be a big problem.


9:39 a.m.

In this way and times, I cannot look my, as Supervisor Bushnell said, I don't know if I can answer to a $2 increase, $3 increase in fuel prices when we're already paying the highest in the nation. And so I can't be supporting this because this is so open-ended. It's just like throw it against the wall and see what will stick. Well, I don't want to be part of that that makes it stick, so I won't be voting for this just because there's so many unknowns. I mean, it seems all warm and fuzzy for certain people. And I understand that Supervisor Arroyo maybe, it probably has had people say, hey, you got to do this, you got to do this. Just so you know, I have not had one person call me and said, hey, you got to do this. And I didn't even get the email chain that usually everybody puts out where I get 100 emails with the same thing. So I won't be supporting this. I just don't think it's, I don't think it's good. Somewhere in there, our bucket's running dry, you guys. And until we figure out how we can balance this economy, I don't think we should.


9:40 a.m.

taking more money out and especially going after our businesses. I mean, I just saw people are moving out of California and taking their businesses with them. And we're going to see that. We're going to see the results of that in a couple of years. And then you're going to really see the bucket run dry. Thank you. May I comment, Chair? Yes, by all means. Thank you. I do just want to draw some attention to a few of the aspects that made me want to support this. You know, there is already a framework for identifying the responsible party. And there's definitions here that are consistent with what's already in place at the federal level and in other state environmental, you know, the state EPA and other state agencies already have a definition of who's a responsible party. And this expands impacts to include disaster preparedness, response, and recovery. And, you know, having


9:41 a.m.

You know, seeing firsthand, for example, the impacts of the LA wildfires, you know, completely unprecedented, out of season, out of control fire and all its impacts. You know, part of why this was modified several times this last year is in response to that. So it includes some robust language around that. I do think it's a very robust bill, and it's probably a long shot, but I support the intent of it. And I would support it if it were able to be carried out, because I've seen an entire industry emerge around providing forms of insurance, for example, for companies whose business is to transport oil or oil products. For example, where if they're required to...


9:42 a.m.

address the impacts of that should they have a spill or you know not be able to mitigate what they're doing they have a form of insurance already purchased to do that so I don't think it's it's not new and I don't think it's rocket science to figure out how how they will fund it and how they will cover their their liabilities but anyway I think I'll leave it there I think you know it's this is one where we're likely to just have a difference of opinion all right I'm gonna put this out to public comment we have public comment thank you chair caller 7718 I'll unmute you and you'll have three minutes you


9:43 a.m.

Uh, Ken Soloski there, hope you can hear me. Um, the serious concerns I see about this is, again, anything to do with insurance, in my opinion, is necessitated and functionally done by proper regulation, and it is nothing but to enrich basically the attorneys. And this is an attorney tax that we have. It's any of these things. I look at anything that's going to raise the cost of living, potentially for gas or things. These are all regressive items. I mean, someone who's well off, fortunately I feel I am myself, can afford to take expensive gas and just go ahead and do what I do, you know. But the poor people are barely making ends meet, really can't afford to have these kind of increases. To line the pockets of the insurance agents, I all, insurance agents and the lawyers, we are creating another layer of things. The protections are already... They're already there.


9:44 a.m.

It really is disturbing that we as representatives, we as representatives can't see the unintended consequences that are going to hit the people who can afford just the least. People are leaving California in flocks. And a lot of good people, they're taking the business, they're moving on, they're moving out. And this doesn't bode well for California in so many different ways. And all these new regulations and rules and things and add-ons and stuff, are compounding the reason why everybody's leaving the United States. Probably a reason why you're going to see California, and specifically areas like Humboldt County and rural areas, really take more and more of a financial beating. So I don't know whether it's in your best interest to do on some of these things, because it's going to have a direct effect on the budget and your amount of money to do what you feel is necessary for your constituents. I would say caution on these kind of things. I really appreciate.


9:45 a.m.

the discussion and I appreciate Michelle Bushnell bringing this forward and I strongly think you may wish to reflect on this a little more before making a decision. Doesn't sound like it's necessary at this time. Thank you for the opportunity to speak. Great. I think we have a few more online. Yes, thank you. Caller 0920, I will unmute you and you'll have three minutes. Thank you. This is Marcia Walden. I'm a member of 350 Humboldt and we appreciate you putting this bill on the agenda. Humboldt County would be in good company if you endorsed it. We've got at least 11 cities and counties in California have already done so. And that includes L.A., San Diego, San Francisco, and New York.


9:46 a.m.

So this is not a wild-eyed, unreasonable proposal. Simply put, we need a climate superfund. And who better to pay into it than fossil fuel giants, the biggest polluters? These are defined by SB 684 as entities that emitted more than a billion metric tons between 1990 and 2024 by extracting, combusting, and selling fossil fuels. And that would presumably include ExxonMobil, whose own scientists warned them more than 40 years ago about the damage their product was causing. ExxonMobil can't deny their own memos, but they won't admit any responsibility for the ensuing global disasters. This bill, if passed, establishes a chain of responsibility. And those at the top should pay significant...


9:47 a.m.

for the damage. The consequences have been astronomic already and there is every reason to believe that the financial impacts are only going to get worse and worse and that's just the financial impacts. SB 684 will require the Cal EPA to do a comprehensive study in order to quantify damage and assess the amount owed and this process is bound to come up with a conservative estimate. A modest portion of the vast wealth that was extracted from the earth and we're all going to pay for climate change and our descendants even more so. So please add Humboldt County to the list of jurisdictions in California endorsing it. Vermont and New York have already passed one and we think every state in the country should pass one. We think it's the right thing to do. Thank you. Thank you.


9:48 a.m.

And we have one more online. Yes. Caller 3053, I will unmute you and you'll have three minutes. Good morning Thomas Walder here I just want to confirm you can hear me? Yes. First off I would say I wouldn't ever support whatever the bill was even if it was the best thing since sliced bread as some would say. I wouldn't ever support endorsing a bill that is going to be changed at some point in time because I personally feel that those words or support could be misconstrued and then they could add something in there like you know let all the criminals out even earlier than they have since prop 47 just something like that or ab 1950. You know so I wouldn't want


9:49 a.m.

to support a bill that wasn't going to go forward unless it was in final language. That's a big, big caution. And then, you know, call me perceived bias, you know, anything that's going to go after and attack taxpayers and normal people that work, get their hands dirty in the dirt, construction, outdoorsmen, all that kind of stuff. I wouldn't support it because, you know, those are the type of people, men and women, that built the backbone of America. So I don't support this as it is. It's really unfortunate. I remember when you guys were going after the people that worked like that curtain or something like that. You had a room full of angry people. Just remember that when you try to bring forward stuff like this. I feel this does nothing but takes away from those industries and continues to attack them, just like CARB did, which is a big, big, big problem. So I don't support it. I don't support it. I don't support it. There's false claims and false information. In fact, when all the construction...


9:50 a.m.

companies first started taking the hit with their decimal point that was off base, as people say. So please don't support this. Thank you, Bo. Thank you, Michelle Bushnell there, for what you said, your questions. Thank you for the opportunity to speak. Thank you. That's all on Zoom, Chair. All right. Anyone in the room? Okay. As I mentioned before, if you want to talk about something that we're talking about, please line up so we can. Thanks. Thank you for giving me this opportunity to speak on January 6th, 2026. Yeah, I feel like it's another bill that really lacks integrity because if you look at the biggest gross polluters in this day and age, it's going to be


9:51 a.m.

The far left, Gavin Newsom, allowing L.A. to burn and all the pollution and toxic residue down there. We're living in a time where these disasters are not climate or anything to do other than policy and elected officials failing to legitimately hire the right people and all this other woke agenda stuff that keeps fire trucks from operating, firemen from going into buildings. I've lost good friends in Eureka, been burned to a crisp right off 101 here simply because other people were allowed to. Burn it up with their power. Can you keep this on SB 684, please? So, yeah, SB 684, then.


9:52 a.m.

should first go after Gavin Newsom. He's caused more pollution in this state and ruined this state and has the highest gas prices and highest cost of living that anybody capable of fighting a fire can't afford to live here. And these are issues that you keep sweeping under the table and are manifesting. Putting a bill out like this would just allow more Americans that are trying to survive in this economy to be penalized financially for ridiculous pollution that has a net zero effect on clean air or the big picture of pollution. You can look at Arcata. You had a whole square block burned down. And the pollution and toxic waste...


9:53 a.m.

that came out of that has completely obliterated any pollution-saving attempts that Arcata has tried to put in effect for the past five years. So, who are you going to go after there? The homeless people that were living there illegally and causing that fire? Do you think they have the pockets to offset that pollution? What a ridiculous, absolute asinine bill. Thank you. Okay. Is there anyone else who wants to speak on this letter of support for SB 684? Seeing none, I'm going to bring it back to the board. Supervisor Bushnell? Thank you. I look forward to hopefully in its new iteration that it holds people responsible for the damage they do and not allowing that to be passed on to the consumer. I would love to see that in a new iteration of the bill. I'll just.


9:54 a.m.

I'll throw out a few points on my behalf, so since I'm the last to speak on this. Let's see, I will support this. Just from the principle of how the polluter pays principle, fossil fuel companies profited from these products, and they knew they would cause climate change damage. Taxpayers currently bear the cost of climate adaptation and disaster response. And so this type of legislation is seeking to shift the financial responsibility to the companies that created the problem rather than working families. So revenue from this type of legislation strengthens flood defenses and extreme weather preparation without raising taxes and creates thousands of jobs in that infrastructure investments. So I'll stop there. Thank you. So, again,


9:55 a.m.

And the most vulnerable neighborhoods facing the worst climate impacts would be prioritized, and I think that's important. The current system that we have socializes the costs, as we know, and privatizes the profits. And so while these companies profit, we pay the costs in terms of response and in terms of the climate change. So already the working people are bearing the costs of property damage and health impacts, and higher living expenses from climate change. And so this is a change in trying to get the corporations to internalize those costs and help our communities respond. So that's my perspective on this bill. I think it's important that we have a difference of perspectives. I think in the end, again, we are all trying to make a better, healthier community.


9:56 a.m.

What we are disagreeing on here is strategy. And so with that, I think we're ready to vote, unless Supervisor Madrone has something to say. Thank you, Chair. Well, I understand the intent of the bill. And while I might support the intent, I have no doubt that the cost of this will not be borne by these large corporations. It will be borne by the consumers. It gets passed on. That's how it works. I would much rather see a bill that would be focused on incentives for people to use less gas. You know, what does that look like? I don't know. I don't have all the magic bullets there to figure that out. But, you know, if you drive half as much as you used to because you care about these things, then how do we incentivize that? Mass transit is certainly one of those ways, supporting mass transit. Bicycle trails like the Bay Trail that allow more people to get around on bicycles, things like that. So I guess my answer. My concern is.


9:57 a.m.

is that we figure out how to not just pass on the cost to consumers, but in fact reward consumers for behavioral changes where they reduce their use of gasoline and things like that. So that's just my thoughts on that. Thank you. This is Professor Arroyo. Thank you. I just want to, before I make a motion, I just want to express a couple of thoughts about what's in the bill. So it's only like five pages long. The responsible party is an entity that extracts or refines fossil fuels. So it's not more expansive than that, although it can include partnerships and associations that are doing that as their majority business, as their primary business. And I will just, I would say we already require those businesses that extract or refine fossil fuels to be responsible.


9:58 a.m.

...financially for spills of fossil fuels into the water or on land, this is essentially holding them responsible for the impacts to the air, which is the greenhouse gas emissions. And they already do two-thirds of the... They already are accountable for any impacts that are from other forms of pollution. So this isn't reinventing the wheel. This isn't... It's forming a fund that we as impact... I mean, just looking at the flooding and the fires that we've had in California this year and the flooding that has impacted us locally, that we haven't seen in many, many decades, I suppose you could consider...


9:59 a.m.

anomalous or you could look at the mountain of research that shows that it's not anomalous. So I think this is a logical thing for the state to pursue as a very large state with a lot of industries interested in providing these products. I do believe that this same framework, a very similar framework, will be applied in this next session. They just need to kind of merge all of the ideas together. But I will continue to say that I support the framework laid out here in SB 684. And saying that we do support that, to me, sends a message to our legislators to keep trying. So I will move that we, even though I think it may, it sounds like it may not pass, I still want to get on the record saying, I will move that we do send the letter as written. Okay.


10 a.m.

I was hoping that there would be some language changes that might accommodate, but I actually want to speak to one point that was made by- Is there a second for discussion? Sure. Does there need to be a second for discussion? All right, second. Jesus. All right. Moving forward. Please don't interrupt. It'd be great. Okay, moving forward, I want to comment on this idea that we keep putting it on the individual for everything. We live in a society that has huge corporate control and manipulation of our everyday life. And to just say that the individual has- The total control of these situations, I think, is-


10:01 a.m.

not realistic. I do think we need legislation that does push back on and make the larger, especially polluting companies, have some or definitely more responsibility and accountability for their actions in how things have been created, and especially the situation around climate change, is really important. And it is also the messaging from those polluting companies that they also want to push it onto the individual as if the individual has all the control in the situation, and that is just not the case. And so I think it is important to have legislation that reaches back to...


10:02 a.m.

The responsible parties in relation to these polluting corporations, if we have to figure out ways to adapt that so that we can make sure that we feel more comfortable, that it doesn't get put onto working people in terms of payment of that, I think is something we need to have more discussion about. But more than that, we first of all need to define these major fossil fuel companies as responsible parties in this climate change world that we find ourselves in and all its impacts and the cost of all the mitigations and responses to that. So with that, I think we should probably take a roll call vote. Not roll call, but... Was there more discussion that needs to be had?


10:03 a.m.

Okay, great. Supervisor Bone. Well, I think this goes back to that, you know, this has been suspended in the legislature, and we're going to vote on something that might come forward in the next thing, and it's going to be changed. So let's vote for it, and then we're going to support the changes and what's going to happen later down the road, when the opportunity, since we meet every Tuesday, to bring back the version that we're actually going to vote for and actually have some reasonable, I mean, the state or the proponents of this says it's going to bring in $100 billion a year for disadvantaged communities, fighting wildfires and everything along the wayside. It's going to make all our problems go away, basically, but it's going to cost the consumer in excess of $30 billion, and then CalEPA staff, everybody's going to have to. The person who's going to rewrite this is going to eat up another $65 billion.


10:04 a.m.

70 percent. So we'll have about 10 billion dollars and it's going to cost us two, three dollars more per fuel. Maybe. We don't have the answers because we don't have the bill in front of us. We have the bill that might be in front of us. We could vote on the version that is stalled that is being rewritten. But the thing is, as I know, politically, this is going to, you know, some people are going to be really, really happy we passed this. I mean, all these environmental groups that have started because, man, we're going to. But I'm sitting up here going, OK, I'm going to get my paycheck every two weeks from the government. But the people that are going to be affected by this that aren't in a position to pay seven, eight, maybe even take it down back to six dollars a gallon. And we're actually getting back into we're not Oklahoma at a buck ninety nine, mind you. But I just don't feel that we have all the answers and we kind of laugh about, well, we don't. No. And everything else. But the problem is.


10:05 a.m.

We've got to have some direct answers before you vote on something. We're voting on something that might happen, that's going to happen, sounds really good, feels good, but it ain't there yet. So I can't vote for a wish and a hope. I need to see something more direct. And I apologize. I appreciate you bringing this forward. I know how this feels because I've had it brought stuff forward going, oh, that's a dumb idea. Of course it is. So I don't think it's a dumb idea, but we don't have a finished product in front of us. We have a product that might come in the next legislature. I feel it's going to come in the next legislature. So I don't know. Am I done, Mike? Well, I feel your point has been made very clearly. And Supervisor Bushnell has something to say. We have a pretty robust agenda, and I just want to make sure we get through it. Thank you. So I do appreciate Supervisor Royo bringing this forward. Mike, Supervisor Wilson, what you said, is...


10:06 a.m.

What I agree with, not passing that on to the consumer, and like I said earlier, and then we're going to go for a vote, is that just some guarantee that that wouldn't happen and hold people responsible that do the damage. I think we're saying the same thing. The application is what we're not agreeing on. And nobody wants to see oil spills in the ocean and not have the responsible party clean that up. So thank you for what you said and what Supervisor Bone said. We just are not agreeing on the way to get there. Supervisor Bone. Yes, Supervisor Bone. And this doesn't happen very often, but I find myself agreeing with Supervisor Madrone. All the fuel they made and all the profits they made came out of my tailpipe, your tailpipe, and unless everybody's riding and bicycling and everything else, then I understand we've got to pay. But the problem is we're going to pay. At the end of it, we're going to pay. It's not going to be the, and I know we use the buzzwords, corporate polluters.


10:07 a.m.

and fossil fuels and everything else. I was in that business for 25 years. It's what makes the world turn right now until we find something else. But as Supervisor Madrone said, educate the people to use all these bicycle lanes we're building that they're not using. Thank you, Supervisor Bone. Speaking to the question, for me, whether we move forward with this or not, the language of the bill does inform our legislative agenda. And so if there is an intent in that, it doesn't necessarily have to be exacted in this language. What I'm saying is that the legislation, that if we were to pass it today in terms of we're not passing legislation but support of it, would mean that it would be in our legislation, legislative agenda, and that we would be in support of those ideas moving forward. So if other bills...


10:08 a.m.

or other things that align with this legislative legislation come up, we wouldn't have to have this discussion again. But that's where we're at, and I'm going to let Supervisor Arroyo take the last word on this and lead us out. I mean, I think our legislative platform has spoken to the concerns around climate change in the past, and so it has and likely will for our 2026 legislative platform that we'll be working on very soon, it seems like, or seeing come back to us very soon. So I don't think funding to address the impacts of climate change is a big departure from our legislative agenda. And perhaps the language of this is just written away that is difficult. It's different, but I think we can incorporate it into there. It is already in the...


10:09 a.m.

there and um i we can also send around individual letters about whatever legislative items we'd like so um i appreciate the discussion today um doesn't seem like we'll um get to a yes vote on this one um but was that what you were you just wanted to wrap this up yeah well also like giving the courtesy if you want to pull this item knowing that it probably will not get a yes vote give me that just a discussion well we have a motion on the floor i don't know um procedurally um we we need we need either to uh pull the item uh or to take a vote and then decide whether to proceed or get an affirmative vote i'm looking to our um county council um i know we we want an affirmative vote on things that are on the agenda right correct all right um well we can proceed through it let's proceed through the vote and then move on to the next item great discussion good um you


10:10 a.m.

You know, it's a good process. All right, moving forward. Motion does not carry 3-2. Okay. Moving on. Let's see here. So we need an affirmative vote, though. Oh, we need an affirmative vote. Okay. How about this for a motion? A motion to reconsider this legislation that addresses the same issue in the future. When the revised bill comes before the next legislative session, I'm looking at. Through the chair, can I ask, do we need? Council prefers to have an affirmative vote for the minutes that will transpire after the meeting. So.


10:11 a.m.

Possibly a vote to accept the report and elect to not send a letter of support. That would work. You could also direct staff to come back with something to reconsider the new language once it has been drafted. I like the middle ground of that, which is to receive the report and select not to send a letter. And I'll make that motion. There's a second. I'll second. Sure. Yeah. And in that way, if a member of this body wants to bring something back when new legislation is done, they can do that and we can discuss it again. Okay. Great. Does everybody understand the motion? Okay. Well, we can vote on this. We don't need to reopen this discussion again, do we? No. Okay.


10:12 a.m.

Thank you. This is my first meeting of the year as chair, so allow me a little grace here. I'm working these things out. You get to all see the sausage being made here. All right. With that, please vote, and we can move on to the next item. Restate the motion, please. The motion is we're going to, oh, I can restate it very clearly as the motion maker. Yeah, which is to receive and file this report and elect not to send a letter. That's it. Motion carries 4-1. Great. Okay, moving back to items pulled from consent, we're going to go to D5. Okay, thank you. Chair Wilson.


10:13 a.m.

35 is concerning appointments to board members to various boards, commissions, and committees. As discussed at a previous meeting, this effectuates your board's direction. And just a small note of clarification on the appointment list attachment, page 2, 9th row down, is the appointment to the GRTA where Supervisor Madrone will serve as one year and then Supervisor Bushnell will step in for the following year. It just doesn't indicate that formatting got wonky on this. So it just doesn't say GRTA on that. So I just want to make it clear that that line is in reference to GRTA, and that is the only correction needed. And with that, a board motion to accept the modifications and approve the item would be wonderful. That wasn't my intention in voting for that item because the item, I'm just saying, in terms of the GRTA...


10:14 a.m.

seats are not germane to whether we sit in those seats or not. And so I voted on a term for Supervisor Madrone to sit in that seat for the full term. That was my intention. So my intention was not to have that split up. It's a two-year term, and Supervisor Madrone will not be running again, so he will only be available for one year. Hence your board's direction to keep Supervisor Madrone in that seat for the remainder of his term, and then when Supervisor Madrone retires from the board, Supervisor Bushnell will step into that role. I was under the impression that we would be voting again for that seat. Why would... Okay, I'm losing track of the thread here. So go ahead. My understanding of that was that we were...


10:15 a.m.

One option would be to vote for the entire two-year term, and regardless of whether Supervisor Madrona is still on the board, if he wishes to fulfill the rest of that term, it's at the discretion of this board if he is continuing to fill that. We have a person who's not a board member serving on the GRTA board, and other communities have that option as well. So I remember that conversation was a little complicated. But I wasn't intending, my vote was not to try to bifurcate the term. I was just thinking that we were reappointing Supervisor Madrona to the full two-year term. Now, should he choose to step down at the end of his time on this board, that's a different matter. So maybe we all had a slightly different understanding of what this was. Through the chair. Supervisor Bushnell. So I remember... Remembering the conversation, Supervisor Madrona...


10:16 a.m.

did state that this would be for a one year and that because knowing that he's not going to be in the seat any longer so maybe we should ask him. Supervisor Madron would you like to chime in? Yeah it was a complicated decision I will admit to that but yeah it was my understanding that I was simply being appointed for one year of the two-year term. Now I'm going to simplify this even further because I think it would be good to bring it back to the board in the near future because the second person representing this board is a citizen representative. It doesn't have to be but that's traditionally what we've done and that term ends I believe in May of this year. The person has moved out of the county but according to our policy and background with GRTA there's no requirement for the person to actually live in the city. We live within the county it doesn't state that anywhere.


10:17 a.m.

It may have been the board's intent ultimately, but it doesn't actually state that. So regardless, there's going to be an item coming back to this board in April or May or June, depending on how that works, because that seat will be up, that second seat, the citizen representative seat. It is my intention to actually resign from this position at that same time and to open up both positions for this board to consider as a majority who they would like to have representing the board, both in the board position and or if they continue as citizen representative. I just think that given that I am going to term out in a year, that might be the best way to proceed. But, of course, we can't take an action on that because that's not agendized. But when you ask me what my understanding was of what we voted for as far as a one-year term and because it just simply gives me an opportunity to say I've really enjoyed my service on this board and I think it was a great opportunity to do that. Thank you. It would be great for this board to be able to have the...


10:18 a.m.

leeway to really decide about both these positions at the appropriate time that it's agendized which will be probably in may or or june i'm guessing i don't know but that's what i'm thinking so thank you for asking thank you supervisor um chair yeah hold on i want to just do a clarification with staff before we move forward um on this item what are you trying to get what what what was the the recommendation from staff we're just trying to confirm the list of appointments but clarifying that this ninth row on the second page is in fact referencing the grta appointment it doesn't say grta in this final document that your board is going to be approving today so we're just providing okay clarification on that you're just providing clarification so could we give direction then to bring back um um in


10:19 a.m.

sometime in the near future, both the seats for discussion and then moving forward, now that we know that Supervisor Madrone has plans for stepping down from that position at some point before his term is up. We can address any appointments at any point in time. So, yes, that could be agendized at a future date should Madrone resign from his position prior to the end of the year. Okay, great. Thank you. Supervisor Bushnell. I was just going to say that that will automatically come back when he resigns, and then we'll have that discussion. I'm ready to make a motion unless you want to go to public comment first. Let's go to public comment first since that is our tradition. Thank you, Chair. Caller 7. Caller 7, 7, 1, 8. I will unmute you, and you'll have three minutes.


10:20 a.m.

Thank you. I am so confused about this. Having attended this topic prior, I was very pleased to see that you would be actually giving certainty to the position, the two-year position, support the fact that Steven Jones served in there for his one-year term and Michelle Bushnell served the second part. I think in the wisdom, Member Arroyo stated that we do need some diversity on this. This is a sign that diversity will happen. It gives a surety of that, which I think is going to be beneficial to the basic overall effort of the Great Redwood Trail. It also leaves the thing open when it comes to take place for his thing. Which, which could happen at any time.


10:21 a.m.

I would assume you can get a hold of him and doesn't need to wait and if if some other juggling around wants to happen but uh there seems to be all kinds of uh I think you've come game playing here or something but the public would like to be sure of you and I strongly support moving forward with Stephen Dillon the first half of the year Michelle Bush in the second half and then uh otherwise you would have the potential uh if Supervisor McGlone was to be in the position and I know it's not mandated but it's kind of been like you're going to have one supervisor and one not you potentially could have two people with no supervisors in there I guess I don't recommend that so I I would like to see you move forward with with the uh the split term uh divided that way and then of course you guys will make that quick future decision regarding replacing uh uh Jeff's position there thank you for my opportunity to speak today thank you is there anyone else no


10:22 a.m.

We're still on public comment. There is not. Okay. Is there anyone in the room that wants to speak on this item? Seeing none. Supervisor Bone? Well, and if you look at the board, and I haven't followed up all the way, but it would be nice to have someone on that board that the Great Redwood Trail actually affects. Basically, we have a large swath of people in the southern end, both in my district and Supervisor Bushnell's district. We might even have about the same amount of miles of the Great Redwood Trail. But it doesn't affect a lot of people. But, I mean, we do have one ranch. It goes 17 miles through one ranch. They've kind of just said, yeah, that's fine. But I think to have someone in the area that actually represents where the trail is going rather than, you know, I know we want to be 100% behind the trail, and I understand that. But, again, it's $2 billion. $2 billion. $2 billion.


10:23 a.m.

...or venture, and we should have somebody in that area. I think actually we all feel it there, Kaylee. You just said it. But anyway, I support, and I remember the conversation pretty direct. In fact, actually, I think I heard a discussion today between Supervisor Bushnell and Supervisor Madrone that he has to cover, she has to cover a meeting for him. So there is input, there is buy-in, and I know this is a political thing. We want to put somebody on there that's going to, you know, but I mean, it's not. It's about the people of Humboldt County that are going to be affected. Again, in the South, it's not a whole bunch, but it does affect them directly, and I think they should have, I don't know, a louder say, but they should have a say.


10:24 a.m.

representative that could say it for him. Through the chair. Supervisor Bushnell. I'll make a motion for staff's recommendation on D5. Okay does that reflect the discussion? With the proposed modifications which is staff's recommendation. Okay second. Great we have a motion and a second. Do we need any clarification? Just to clarify that that was to reconsider the appointment at a later date but to appoint for the first year. Yes sorry for my confusion on that. Can I clarify it's not for what I didn't add to the motion that Supervisor Madrone said he's going to resign in June and then we would have to bring it back anyways because it'll be a resignation. That's not in the motion. Do I need to clarify that? I'm sorry say that one more time. Yeah so it's not to bring to bring it back at the end but it.


10:25 a.m.

Would come anyways if Supervisor Madrone resigns. Would you like me to change? So we'll reconsider the appointment at that time, right? That's what he said. Okay, great. It's not part of the motion, however, because he hasn't resigned. Okay. Thank you very much. Does staff feel the motion is reflective of the discussion they heard here today? Yes. Okay, great. That's what I want to hear. All right, with that, please vote. Thank you. Motion carries 5-0. All right, so we have one more item on items pulled from consent, that's D-12. Thank you, Chair Wilson. This item repeals and replaces a resolution from 1982 establishing county office hours, and I just have a couple small clarifications to the resolution for the Assessor's Office.


10:26 a.m.

They close at lunchtime, as does the Board of Supervisors and the Clerk of the Board. So we'll modify the schedule to reflect those closures for the public's information. And while we're making a modification, we will also change purchasing to a 9 a.m. open time as opposed to an 8 a.m. open time to align with the remainder of my other offices in the courthouse. Great. Thank you for those clarifications. Any comments? Supervisor Arroyo? I'm wondering if there is any bearing that the conversation that we have next around security has on open hours. For example, if offices want to be consistent about being closed for lunch due to modifications that we might be making, anything like that, if we should, for any reason, hold off on this. Or whether, you know, I think... I think it's a good question. I think it's a good question.


10:27 a.m.

I suppose we can just make additional modifications. Yeah, what we typically do is come to your board and amend the resolution. We're sort of doing a fresh start on this one because we've been consistently amending an 82 resolution. So this will sort of solidify that and give us a starting point. And then from here, any future modifications that are permanent will come to your board to amend this resolution. And that is potentially something that could transpire off of those operational changes. Okay. All right. Thank you. Great. Supervisor Bushnell? Oh, Supervisor Bone. Sorry about that. Yeah, and I'm wondering, looking at the CAO and stuff, a lot of these – and some of this is technical, like when it says Friday closed. I had a couple people call and say, so are you guys going to a four-day work week? And I know that's our day to work from home. For a lot of them, but a lot of people are working home Monday. Yeah. All right.


10:28 a.m.

through Thursday also. Is this a clarification that the people that are working from home now now come into the office? And the other thing is is having HR closed down on Friday when all the other departments are closed and HR is the central point that everybody has to take their insurance and everything else to, shouldn't they be the one that is most available to the to to to the employees especially if Friday is a closed day when they're working in their office and don't have to have counter duty. But I think we need a clarification that the office isn't closed. They're working in-house or supposed to be working in-house. I just, are we going to a four-day work week by doing this? This represents the availability of offices to the public. Does not dictate management decisions around staffing. So offices will be open as described in this resolution and leadership. This invokes a lot of topography right with an intervention somewhere in advance and it's difficult to whether the employees right now have of an option is that you're doing abbng in the 밑 you two there in this moment tr nieprgg has. If their<|pt|> set there steps. You know, a media analytics the data off to get an honest given and that just make them feel comfortable with a press


10:29 a.m.

make management decisions around who is present to adequately staff their offices. So staff, the Friday closure of offices was to allow staff ample time to catch up on other work without the distraction of the public interactions on those days. So staff are still working, sometimes in the office, sometimes at home. That is a management decision. No, I understand. It's just the clarification here just says closed. For the public, it is in fact closed. Yes. But people are still working a 40-hour work week as dictated by our memorandums of understandings with our labor unions. Moving on to Supervisor Bushnell. Thank you. I raised these questions with CAO, and thank you for clarifying and getting back with me yesterday. About more than just this, I...


10:30 a.m.

I just wanted to comment to Supervisor Bones' statement. I have contacted these offices on Fridays, and they have our, you know, respond to me. And so I think that staff can, you know, contact, like, HR. I'm not done. And they will respond. That's been my, you know, what I've seen. I think as it states in this resolution for the public, like it's very helpful to know that someone from Southern Humboldt cannot drive up on a Friday and access HR or access the taxpayer. They don't know the hours. They get confused at times because it hasn't been updated. And so for my constituent basis, it's helpful to know that those offices are not public-facing on Fridays, and you cannot drive here and go into them. Clarification. I fully understand. I'm here every Friday. So I contact all these people, and I actually knock on the door. I knock on the doors and make them open the doors. So I know they're here. I'm just saying for the...


10:31 a.m.

Public when it says closed it makes it sound closed. I want people to understand they're not closed There are people in the office doing work. So Okay, I think that message has been delivered. Do we have public comment on this item? Yes chair caller 7718. I will unmute you and you'll have three minutes I definitely can see a major amount of confusion. I appreciate Supervisor Bone bringing this forward. Closed is closed. If you Google a business and it says closed, it doesn't mean some people can call. The public has a need to know that's closed means we cannot call in there. Obviously, physically, if it's closed, but if people are working in there, can we email people in that office during business time, during that time? Or is it closed to the public? You're lacking the sensitivity that's required for normal.


10:32 a.m.

communication by just saying closed and i think you you should have the arts to that or some clarification to that uh otherwise it's very very misleading to people in this world it's so hard to figure out anyway we don't need anything more misleading that's ambiguous and leads up to interpretation so please go ahead and make that clear as far as what closed means uh and who's closed too and uh and that's all i'm asking is just clarity whatever decision you make is fine regarding that i can understand budgetary reason to think to be closed but you need to define it and have people understand thank you for having me speak thank you um we have someone from the audience who wants to speak this evening or this morning pardon me i really was not wanting to speak before public comment on non-agenda items but i agree actually with the um um vagueness or misinterpretation


10:33 a.m.

of signage on doors of public offices that say closed because I'm a person who likes to go in person face to face and if I especially like housing which is way out on Everdeen really difficult place to get to and it's sign says closed and you're not expecting that and you've taken a lot of time to get to that location I think it really needs to be understood that it's not closed for working inside offices wherever those offices are at someone's home or in the actual office they're still working on a Friday or a Monday in this instance as well so I just think that clarity needs to be made to the public so they they know that they could call in still on a Friday and get an answer but they just can't get that's not true so I I I I really do


10:34 a.m.

I think for service provision, it really is important for the people who need those services to understand better what that means. And I understand challenges, especially with budget and things like that, to have some things that's normal nine to five, five days a week. You know, it's no longer that reality. We need better communication about that. So I agree that there needs to be better clarity and communication for people like me who need to know. Okay. Yeah, point of order, Chair. Howard just let me know that he is not electing to close during the lunch hour. So we will keep that modification the same. Just for clarification. It's a good last minute time to tell. The Board of Supervisors. The Board of Supervisors and the Clerk of the Board.


10:35 a.m.

will be closed at lunch. Purchasing will be open at 9 a.m. Okay. Howard's office will stay the same and he appears to have a comment. Yeah, I just wanted to just clarify that we had that discussion potentially of closing the assessor's office during the lunch hour. We chose not to because we do get a lot of folks come in on their lunch hour that work in other areas or outside of the county that want to need to deal with our office, you know, for their assessment purposes or whatever. So we found as a service to the public that we should stay open during that lunch hour. And we are closed on Fridays to the public for foot traffic, but we are open. We answer our phones, emails obviously. And if people need to make an appointment with us, then we're open to special appointments if that's the only time they can meet with us in our office. So I just want to clarify that. Appreciate that. Is there any more comments from the public before we bring it back? We're going to go back to the board and let's see.


10:36 a.m.

I was just going to add that taking in the public comment today and there does appear to be some confusion around office hours and the closures on Friday, we'll work on a press release to get that information out. In response, I appreciate that and I think that it appears that all the different departments have their own culture around how this works and their customer base. It would be great if their messages on their phones reflect that as clearly as possible or whatever else is needed. So we're hearing you and I think that's something we're going to work on. Supervisor Bushnell. Okay. I'll just make a motion for the recommendation of the modifications. I'll second and may I make a comment, Chair? Yep.


10:37 a.m.

I do just want to clarify, this is something that we initiated in 2022. As a result, in part of our meetings with Supervisor Bushnell and I, we're on an ad hoc to meet with all departments to talk about our budget and our very tight budget and look for opportunities to address the needs that departments had in creative ways. And so one of the things that has happened is we haven't been able to grow the budgets. Everyone's had a status quo budget, essentially, for the last few years. And we had this discussion that some departments would like to be closed to the public on Fridays so that they can get caught up in work because they're not able to grow their staff. The morale has been a challenge and getting work done has been a challenge. And so we wanted to provide the holistic support for our entire county. Should offices be.


10:38 a.m.

able to close to the general public on Fridays or on a day of their choosing to, but it was generally encouraged to be Fridays, so that there was some consistency. And so that was well received by some of the departments, and that's where this was coming from, was an offer to, you know, we know you're stretched thin, so offering that as an option. And much of the time, some of our staff do work from home on Fridays, but much of the time people are in their offices doing work. They're just not engaging with folks at that front counter, whatever the case may be on that day as a way to kind of get some additional things done behind the scenes. So people are still working for the good of the general public on those days. So I just want to make that clear. Okay. Supervisor Bone? And I just, and I've never denied that they're working on Friday. I'm just trying to clarify. I had people calling.


10:39 a.m.

saying are we closing on Friday because it says closed and nowhere in the resolution does it say to the public or we're just going to work behind you know get caught up we're going to do everything you know that we've all talked about that but this is just one of those things that people were confused and I just you know and I appreciate um CAO Hayes clarifying that she can get this fixed so people will know we're not closed we're still working for the public just like everybody else five days a week but we are just but we are doing it behind doors so we can get back to people quicker than we're getting to them now so I appreciate the the adjustment okay one last thing before we go to vote just want to remind folks that most this is our adjustments over decades to some policies that were originated in 1982 what I've heard from the CAO is they're going to go back and at some point straighten this


10:40 a.m.

all out so that's clearer and you've heard the discussion here today so any modifications moving forward will reflect this discussion in terms of how we project both the hours that people can access the county and the different departments but also the understanding of what that means in terms of the reflection of what our business hours internally are so with that unless the CAO has any more clarifications we're probably ready to vote now we have a motion in a second please vote motion carries 5-0 excellent okay so we've moved through items pulled from consent we only have our time certain so we're moving into public hearings we haven't done public comment on non-agenda thank you Wow okay here we are at 1040 doing public comment on non-agenda items this is the time when you can speak on


10:41 a.m.

Anything that is not on the agenda, if it is on the agenda, please don't talk now. So, yes, Supervisor Bush, no. Point of order. No, I have a public comment on non-agenda items. Oh, okay. Well, can we get to you kind of in the last? Okay, that's great. Okay, we're going to move to Zoom first. Do we have any hands up on Zoom? Yes, Chair, thank you. Caller 7718, I will unmute you and you'll have three minutes. Thank you. I believe if I'm correct today is a election in the city of Blue Lake, a small little burb of Blue Lake. There's been a very contentious recall effort. I wanted to thank Juan Pablo for conducting this to the city and hopefully minimizing our costs. We have an estimate up to fifteen thousand dollars for this.


10:42 a.m.

And politics goes on. So I don't know if we've had recalls in Humboldt County, but the politics in Blue Lake are very complicated and interesting. We've had multiple city managers coming and going, interim ones and temporary ones. And one of the biggest consistent things we've had with all of them, none of them are able to get one of the most important things for Blue Lake done, and that's to get an agreement to keep our water system functioning. We have a failing tank that needs to be replaced, and yet with all these different people involved in it, and in my opinion, no fault was from the city attorney, but we've had all kinds of pushback as far as doing a relevant deal on this. Possibly it will head toward eminent domain, which could be quite expensive and disastrous. Instead of accepting multiple reasonable options, we've had a lot of pushback on the water system. And that's to get an agreement to keep our water system functioning. We have a failing tank that needs to be replaced, and yet with all these different people involved in it, and my opinion, no fault was from the city attorney, but we've had all kinds of pushback on the water system that needs to be replaced, and yet with all these different people involved in it, and we've had all of these different people involved in it, and we've had all these different offers that Aaron McClure has offered that Aaron McClure has made to enable the city to continue to have it.


10:43 a.m.

water tank there there's a lot of uh comments out there and things on facebook well i've been connected with this thing and you know we've had a current city manager an airman here who appears to think he can control everything going on but nothing's happened um just so you know should this fail the city of blue lake may be without access to safe uh fire suppression water storage and other topics the cost for this particular tank has gone up from 2.2 million estimates to 5.3 million dollars money is not there for two tanks so maybe the city is going to try and do just one tank uh now we're going to see whether they replace the tank that leaks like us is or the one that appears to have more functional life so we have a major problem in lake and it's an engineer uh shm and in my opinion these projects are completely unprofitable and we're not going to be able to do anything about it we're not going to be able to do anything about it we're not going to be able to do anything about it going awry because of a lot of a lack of ability to do their


10:44 a.m.

job and it's kind of like a perfect storm where someone has to fear for eminent domain when they've made major efforts to do a reasonable deal and i've spoken with cal fire cal oes uh funding agencies and everything trying to get a handle on the why and it all all comes down to a reluctance to do what's right and fair for the public so hopefully we will get someone or have someone in there now who can complete this deal because it's considered a blue lake interest to have a water supply that's sufficient to fight a fire or provide the needs of the community so uh thank you for my opportunity to speak thank you and now we're back in the room where do we uh no i have one more all right one more caller 3053 i will unmute you and you'll have three minutes you Good morning, Thomas Mulder here. I just want to confirm you can hear me in the chambers there.


10:45 a.m.

Yes. Thank you for still allowing us the opportunity to call in via zoom. I do appreciate that I'd be taking care of my cannabis plants and prepping for my next season and still participate in what seems to be a little bit of politics. I guess I thought it was more you know about constituents but still a little bit of politics there. I just want to remind everyone this is a county where we penalize law-abiding citizens. We don't protect them. Assembly bill spark of memory AV 1950 look it up if you want. That was one where they said they said you know what it's cruel and unusual punishment if you embezzled more than $25,000 to have more than three years felony probation. So needless to say right now because AV 1950.


10:46 a.m.

I don't have my 300 grand. And in essence of that, the guy isn't paying restitution by sitting in prison. That was the agreement. That was the deal made. Whenever I said, okay, I trust the judge. So I had little to zero faith in Humboldt County's probation department. They don't follow through. No wonder there's so many people kicking in glasses and breaking businesses. And then, meanwhile, you do policy that drives more businesses out of Humboldt County, like that thing you had earlier about assembly bills. Think about assembly bills. You know, that could have been tweaked and been something great. But they let what they quote nonviolent offenders in. Supervisor Bone, thank you for, well, you didn't say point of order earlier, but I appreciate you interrupting the chair when he was trying to have a discussion and violate the Brown Act. So I just, I really, really do appreciate it. I appreciate people that do follow the laws.


10:47 a.m.

Did you follow the Brown Act? That was a nice little intro at the beginning there. But you know, we're here for paying attention. It's unfortunate that climate action plan you guys passed last, but hopefully that doesn't drive the rest of the hard-working Americans out of Humboldt County. But we'll see. You know, maybe there'll be government jobs coming in from nowhere. I don't know. But thank you for the opportunity to speak. All right, thank you. That's all, Chair. All right, we're in the room. And please line up if you're wanting to speak on non-agenda items. Hi, my name's Joanne McGarry. As usual, I took the bus here from Arcata, and I'm probably going to be late for an appointment because I'm missing the bus I'm supposed to catch because things got delayed before I could get up and speak. I just want to share with you that I wasn't able to stay for the regional climate action plan final vote. I'm appreciative of the approval of the plan, finally.


10:48 a.m.

I had shared with you earlier, you know, and I was quoted, I guess, in the Time Standard, my comment about this generation's selfishness, and I reiterate that, especially after some of the discussion earlier today. I'm going to read a quote from a book that was written in 2019 by a climate journalist. The book's called Inconspicuous Consumption, the Environmental Impact We Didn't Know We Have. And here's the quote. The author is, at the time, a 29-year-old climate journalist named Tatiana Schlossberg. It's up to us to create a country that takes seriously its obligations to the planet, to each other, and to the people who will be born into a world that looks different than ours has for the last 10,000 years or so. Essentially, what I'm describing is hard work with possibly limited resources.


10:49 a.m.

success for the rest of your life. But we have to do it. And at least we will have the satisfaction of knowing we made things better. Come on, it'll be fun. Question mark. I just, in 2026, need to say that dilly-dallying in our county on really important serious matters that we have witnessed in the last week with the flooding and the storms and our need to, and the fire in Arcata, you know, really seriously, seriously look. Oh, yes. And the war in Venezuela and the oil and the gas. And we really need to sacrifice and work harder and more urgently than we have been.


10:50 a.m.

And again, let's not be selfish for our generation, and let's sacrifice for the next generation to come. All right, thank you. Any more from the audience? Good morning, Board. I'm Jesse Jeffries. I'm a Humboldt County resident. I'm just sitting here watching these, I guess, proceedings this morning. And why is it that the callers get to speak first when people like me spend an hour driving up here and they somehow get to skip the line by being on Zoom? I just want to make a comment that I thought would be more fair. Well, I do respect the people calling in as their public members, that I feel like the people that made the effort to drive all the way up here and sit in the chambers should have the opportunity to be first in line to speak to the Board. Thank you.


10:51 a.m.

Okay. Supervisor Bushnell has a comment. Thank you. This is non-political, but I do want to recognize that Congressman Doug Malafa, sorry, Malafa, passed away this morning after 25 years of public service. And, excuse me? What? Last night. Early this morning. Boy, you're really fouling this up for me. I want to send prayers to his family and friends and his constituents that have depended on him for 25 years. Public service is not an easy one, and it is often at personal public cost. And I just am really saddened to hear of his sudden passing this morning. And wish him well. And wish him well.


10:52 a.m.

Public comment on non-agenda items and moving into departmental reports. I think the first one is to the recommendation to cease courthouse security screening services following reduction in court funding. Is that what you perceive as next? Yes. It looks like certainly the sheriff does. Yes. So let's move on to that one. Thank you, Chair Wilson. In July of last year, the courts approached us indicating that they had an intention to cease funding their portion of the courthouse weapons screening process that takes place at the 5th and 4th Streets entrance. Over the second half of last year, we've been in negotiations and communications with the courts attempting to come to. Some mutually agreeable path forward.


10:53 a.m.

and have found ourselves at a bit of a stalemate when it comes to the funding and what level of security services would be provided. There is a proposal that has been made to reduce security screening down to just one entrance. However, that doesn't necessarily cut the cost of security screening in half as we still need to have somebody posted up at the other entrances managing the folks coming in and out. So the sheriff and I have collectively agreed that our recommendation to your board moving forward, given the court's intent to completely cease funding at the end of this fiscal year, is to cease all entrance security screening services once the sheriff and I can work with the courts to make sure that we have the right to do that. to mitigate any operational impacts, particularly around trial court securities.


10:54 a.m.

services. With that, the sheriff is here and also the courts are in the audience to have a discussion with your board. Okay, great. Thank you very much. I'm going to let the sheriff take a shot. Great. Thank you, Supervisor. Take the first run at this? For sure. Thank you, CAO. I appreciate you surmising this. This is a contract at MOU that's been in place for the past 13 years between the courts and the sheriff's office. Some realignments, so to speak, happened in 2011-2012. Direct funding from the courts ceased and then now we just receive certain funding from the courts for trial security, including court security. The county currently provides essentially 12 deputies to run security for the second floor, for the judges. Also to manage the prisoners.


10:55 a.m.

They're coming in and out of the jail to manage security in the courtrooms itself. And so what we've found in the last 13 years is that the state has not really increased their funding. And now the general fund also is contributing to trial court security. The sheriff's office and the CAO have agreed that it's important that we continue the level of service that the courts initially asked for. And so we're dipping into the general fund now to pay for certain costs that the state should be direct cost, should be reimbursing us for. And now we get to the courthouse security, which is also an agreement that we've had for the past 13 years. The original agreement in place by the courts was for them to fund 83 percent, 83 percent of the entrance costs. Now, because we have board of supervisors. Because we have planning commission meetings, those kind of things. The.


10:56 a.m.

They did agree to also pay for roughly 17% of that court security cost. Also part of the agreement was for the courts to fully pay for all the equipment, screening equipment. The metal detectors as well as the baggage screening will all be paid for by the courts. And that's been in place again for the last 13 years. We were notified, like the CAO said, in July, after the contract renewed July 1st, that they no longer wanted to seek funding that. And they believe that under the law, it's not their, I guess, obligation to pay for that. And, of course, we have this MOU that's in place that says otherwise. And so we're at this point now where the courts will have reduced costs as of January 1st. They only want to pay about $7,000 a month, which is roughly. Half of what it takes for them to.


10:57 a.m.

obligation for court security. I currently do not have the budget to continue court security at the current staffing levels. And so without direction from the board or a general fund allocation, I can't afford to pay for that court security cost. And so that's why we're here today seeking clarification of what the board wants to do. But our recommendation would be since courts no longer paying for courthouse security, we will cease funding at the end of this fiscal year. We will come up with a court security plan with the courts to do court security on the second floor. We will have a reduction of courthouse security, but still maintain a level of security on the second floor for the judges for the court process. And we'll figure it out. So that's where we are right now. Okay. Just, I'm going to go through process here. I'm going to have the supervisors.


10:58 a.m.

ask clarifying questions. Then we have some representatives from the court here today, I think, and I want to ask them to speak to their concerns and issues. And then we'll do public comment in the room and then to Zoom, and then we'll come back for discussion. So that's how we're going to roll this, if that's all right. So questions from the board. I'll start with Supervisor Bone. Could we hear from the court so we have a full idea of what's going on? Because we've heard from the sheriff, who I have full faith in, but I'm sure there's a different angle from the court. So for us to discuss something, we've only got half the... Okay, thank you. So I'll modify that then. Let's hear from the courts right now, or the representatives thereof, and then we'll move into comments and questions from the board. Good morning. My name is Kelly Nealon, the presiding judge of the Superior Court. I think it's important for the board to first have some context about... How the API even comes in. Oh. Forgive me. I have my phone right there, so... Thank you. I think it's...


10:59 a.m.

It's important for you to have some context about how this has come about and why the court has taken the position it took. The sheriff needed to engage in contract negotiations to continue with their providers for the screening. The sheriff can and does farm that out. They have a right to do that. It's worked great. Here's the problem. When the MOU was drafted, it did not, and I can tell you I could not find any historic document, but what I can tell you is that the MOU does not in any way address realignment, which wasn't just a little thing. Realignment was a sweeping and broad... Hold on one second. I really appreciate your animated approach to... Forgive me. Can you focus on the moment? I'm going to move the microphone a little bit. That would be great so we can get a new record. Oh, hold on. And did you...


11 a.m.

Did you state who you were? I did. My name is Kelly Neal. I'm the presiding judge of the Superior Court of this county. I apologize for the interruption. No, no, I appreciate that. So the MOU does not account for realignment. Realignment was not just a little thing. Realignment completely across the state restructured how things were going to happen. And not to be flippant, but essentially the message was, hey, county, you're a felon, you're a problem. So we're going to transfer all of the duties for folks that were going to go to prison. Now the county, you're going to have to hold on to them. So this required a number of things. Part of what was encapsulated in those changes is that a trial court security funding stream went straight to the county, not to the court. What the MOU actually says is that the, the court will commit all.


11:01 a.m.

funds from the entrance screening fund i may have the name wrong but it's in there to reimburse the county the problem is that doesn't exist so we have zero funds from an entrance screening fund because it does not exist so i'm looking at that i didn't know that um and when you when you don't know something when you know you take action on it i have an obligation just as everyone else does to make sure that we're doing everything that we can do to support our organization in the most appropriate way so i reached out to our financial people and like what how much money do we have in this fund and they're like that's not a fund that doesn't exist all of that money starting in 2012 went to the county in a trial court security fund which encompasses entrance screening bailiff if


11:02 a.m.

trial judge protection amongst those things. So it's not an unfunded mandate. You shouldn't, I think that's misleading. It's not an unfunded mandate. What you should be asking is how much exactly does the county have, do you get from the trial court security fund? Have efforts been made to seek additional funding through those avenues? And any short come out of that, there should be a proposal to the board, in my opinion, to seek additional funding to provide for weapons screening. I cannot imagine how anyone could take seriously the notion that it would be appropriate in this multi-use building where we have victims of crime, we have children, we have people who are, what,


11:03 a.m.

so vulnerable, access this building, not just for the courts, but for everyone, and say, we're just going to get rid of weapon screening. But, oh, by the way, we'll provide a deputy for the Board of Supervisors meetings. And I can't even fathom the amount of time it would take someone to walk through those front doors with a firearm. The deputy in here doesn't have time to react before the damage is done. And that has nothing to do with the, I have tremendous respect for Sheriff Hansel and the deputies and what they do. But the fact of the matter is, it is misleading to say that the court is just going to stop funding court security, when in fact we know that it's not something the court should have been funding for the last 13 years. We aren't asking for compensation. We're asking for compensation for all those people who have been in this situation.


11:04 a.m.

funds back because what was happening is not only is the county getting money from the court to pay 83 percent based on what the MOU has, they're also getting trial court funding that's supposed to fund all of that. And if it's not funding all of that, there are paths to take that don't include shutting down security on the 4th and 5th Street side. The MOU also encompasses that should the court, in accordance with the MOU, notify the board of supervisors and the sheriff, we don't have the funds to pay you out of this fund, which is exactly what I did. And then I learned because this fund doesn't exist anymore, we get zero funds, I can give you 83 percent of zero. I suspect that the 83 percent must have come from looking at how much that fund had been.


11:05 a.m.

And that seemed to, I'm just guessing, 83% of the total cost. I don't know that. I've looked. I can't find any historical data. But what I don't know is how much the county receives because those funds must be exclusive for use for trial court security. And it's just baffling to me why we would even be having a conversation about ceasing courthouse security in that fashion. The conversation about having deputies and bailiffs in the courtroom, that's a separate conversation. And I know Chair Ponson will have to have that conversation because I think we're all in agreement. This MOU and our current security plan, it's far outdated. It doesn't. It does not account for changes in the law. And, in fact, the MOU itself references a specific.


11:06 a.m.

I'm sorry, my mouth's all dry, references a specific code section that was repealed in 2003. So we know it does not account for the law as it was. So I don't quibble with the sheriff coming to the board to say this is untenable. I agree it's untenable. We're all on the same page there. I don't think the solution, however, asking the board to vote today to get rid of intern screening is the solution. I think the solution is to look at that specific funding source, see how it is being used, and see how we can work together. And I'm not opposed to the court contributing, quite honestly. Not at 83%. That's absurd. We can't do it. We were looking at having. We're furloughed.


11:07 a.m.

employees. So I don't want you to be misunderstanding the court's position. I think that's all I'll say at this point. Okay. Is there anyone else who is representing the court's position today that will be speaking? I don't. Our CEO is present if you have questions. Okay. Great. First, I want staff and the sheriff to respond, and then we'll get to the supervisors. Sure. Thank you. This is no way. I respect Presiding Judge O'Neill and their position. I understand it completely. I would not want to contribute something that I wasn't being reimbursed for. But I think what's important to note is that this courthouse has been standing here with courts for 70 years. And we only, for the last, what is it?


11:08 a.m.

That 20 plus years have had courthouse security screening. And so screening hasn't always been here. And these are unarmed security officers that we are paying to do this. I wasn't here in 2012. This is actually post realignment. The reason why we are here is because of realignment. And so realignment of funds. So this is totally taking realignment into consideration. And so at that time, I think the court recognizes that there is going to be a need for screening services. And that's why they agreed to compensate and be the lead on screening for the courthouse. Because we do not get reimbursed at the current rate from the state for just managing our bailiffs. And so we are going to have to reimbursed for the court. And so we are going to have to reimbursed for the court.


11:09 a.m.

Under the funds that we currently receive, take on the additional $300,000 it takes to run the security screening for the courthouse. And so that's, again, why we are here. And then it's important to note that on the MOU it talks about level of service. The sheriff agrees to provide service under this agreement at the level that is reimbursed by the state of California. The sheriff reserves the right to reduce the level of service to the level supported by the state court security budget. The caveat to this whole thing, and this is something that all 58 counties are dealing with right now, is the courts, the state of California, has no obligation, zero, to renegotiate any of these contracts. Zero. The only time that they actually will renegotiate is when they expand the courts. When they expand the courts, then there's a legal obligation that they have to renegotiate and they have to, you know, get more funding. This is something. If you want to tap into CSAC or.


11:10 a.m.

You know, RCRC, this is something that is dealt with all around the state. And this is no fault to our bench and our current staff. This is something that Sacramento deals with. And so we would love for us to actually just get reimbursed for real costs. And if we could do that, we would love to tap into that. But that's not happening. We have a finite budget that we're provided by the state, and we are utilizing that and more. You, the community, the citizens, are paying additional costs to run courthouse security right now for the bailiffs. General fund money. I don't have deputies on the street because I'm funding them in the court. So that's our current status. Okay, CAO, do you have anything to follow up with that? I do not. Okay. Supervisor Bushnell and then Supervisor Bone. Thank you. I just want to recognize. I just want to recognize that negotiation.


11:11 a.m.

have been going on for quite some time. I think our board was BCC'd on letters and so I appreciate that this is not something that has just happened today or yesterday. Also I would ask the courts just as Sheriff Hansel stated has there been you know while we can ask for money from the state I believe you can as well and so that's an effort I think that the counties should do together saying that we cannot do these mandates or we cannot provide entrance security at the cost of what I'm hearing is probably deputies on the on the ground which also affects our communities and then I was curious 13 years ago when there was no courthouse security what did we do prior to then and I believe that's a question for the sheriff. So we did have courthouse screening prior to that I think it's since 2005 I think ish somewhere around there. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. It was established and again that was I believe at


11:12 a.m.

At the time, I'm not sure who paid for that. And I'm just assuming that the courts had certain, you know, that they had responsibility or they were paying for that screening services. But I'm not sure because at that point in time, they were paying and reimbursing the sheriffs. You know, it was a pass-through. The money went through the courts. The courts went from the courts to the sheriff's office that time. Realignment, we got directly funded from the state after that. And so there's no more pass-throughs. And I think at that point in time, they decided that we would come and do an agreement and share that cost together. Okay. I appreciate that. My last question would be in absence of having courthouse screening, I would imagine that you would ramp up, you know, what your response would be to courthouse if an incident were to happen and your folks are trained for that. But what would it look like differently? Or what would your – Yeah. What would you be anticipating or how would you –


11:13 a.m.

do things differently if courthouse screening were to cease? Sure. What people don't realize is that we do have 12 deputies that are working in the courthouse, right upstairs on the second floor. And whenever any of our departments, we have emergency buttons, alert buttons that are pushed, we have our bailiffs coming down from one of the courtrooms and responding as the first responders inside the courthouse. And so that's something that's currently already in place. So we would have to reimagine what screening would look like on the second floor. And so we are coming up with a plan based upon what is discussed here today. But it is possible. We can do screening. There are other counties that do it completely this way, that don't have screenings for everyone that comes into their courthouse, and they do individualized screenings based upon the circumstances of the court case, depending on the judge's recommendations. And so there's a lot of work to be done. There's a lot of things that we can work out with the courts.


11:14 a.m.

But it's going to be something that we're going to have to come up with this court security plan together with the CAO, the sheriff's office, and the courts to decide how that looks. May I address Supervisor Bushnell's question? Yes. You asked why we can't just go to debt. I can tell you why. The government code says the court shall not reimburse the sheriff. Get back to the microphone. The government code says the court shall not reimburse the sheriff for costs of court security. I appreciate that. However, I think that our organization can lobby together and can get letters from you. I completely agree with that. I completely agree with that. Thank you. And we're happy to do that. In fact, when I learned that this was coming before the board, I was trying to find on the Judicial Council site, who is the person... The person I talked to about this. And that's quite frankly still a mystery to me because I haven't had time to...


11:15 a.m.

understand that. But I, and this is where I have some trouble understanding if the code says the court shall not reimburse the sheriff, which that doesn't mean we can't come into some agreements. And I'm open to doing that, but not at 83% of the cost of screening. And what came, what triggered all this is because the cost that the sheriff is going to have to incur or somebody's going to have to incur to keep the levels that we have is, we were dumbfounded or just gobsmacked by the increased amount that we simply can't afford. We can't absorb it. I know that they can't absorb it either So that's how we got here but to answer your questions because there's a specific


11:16 a.m.

specific government code that says that. And I am happy to lobby. I am happy to write whatever letters you think will be helpful. I'm more than willing to do any of that. Okay. Thank you. I'm going to bring this back to the board. That's all right. If I could just make a small response back to her, would that be okay? Thank you. I appreciate that. And I know I can feel your passion. And in today's world, things are so different. And it can be scary at times. And so I understand not having that security of someone's gone through a screening down here and you feeling safer sitting in your seat. And I think that goes for us as well. It goes for most people in public service or some kind of form of what we do that it can be scary at times. We've had it happen in here. We also have a panic button here. And it's difficult. So I can feel your passion. And I definitely can feel your anxiety around this issue as well. Thank you.


11:17 a.m.

Okay. I'm going to bring it to Supervisor Bone and then Supervisor Royal. Kelly, I thank you for reaching out yesterday. I wasn't available. But you talked earlier about a fund and then there was no fund. Was there ever a fund? I can only assume so. Because we don't know if there was a fund and I just, okay, and that's fine. I was just wondering if there was ever a fund. I believe, yes, there was a fund. I believe it predates realignment. But again, I can only speculate based on the language of the contract. Realignment. So people understand. Realignment was because we had a court ruling against the state that we had overcrowding in the prisons. And they thought we could handle it a lot better like SB 50, 117, 109. All these. All these things that said, okay, we can put it on the county because they'll handle it better. And then what they did is they funded it.


11:18 a.m.

About 50% and figured we could do it better for half the money and that's how they got out of their budget woes. And like earlier I said the bucket's running dry. This is a prime example of the bucket running dry. Now I know some counties and I have not been into some of them, but some counties you walk right into their county offices and you walk right in and then say, okay, where can I go and everything else. No screening because they have a separate courthouse. Yes. 100% of all screening is done for the courthouse, not for the, you know. And I agree with somebody that mentioned about, or I guess you mentioned, why would we have an officer here, even though I like Comer back there and stuff like that. But I mean, why would we have an officer in here but not in the assessors, not in HR, not in everywhere else? I don't know. We've had some incidents here. We've always had a pretty good idea if we're going to have an incident to push the button or make a call. We've done that a lot. We've done that over the last 14 years. I have. And we've also.


11:19 a.m.

So because there are some sketchy people, we're always going to have that ability to call the sheriff. So if we went to a second floor screening and then it would be on on the courts, you would get what you wanted because you would control it. Not 83 percent, not 80 percent. All of it. We wouldn't control any of it. It's still the sheriff. You would pay for it, though, because it would be all benefiting you. No, we would not. OK, so that's a decision. No, I agree. That's a decision you'll make. But I understand. It's not a decision I would make. It is a function exclusively of the sheriff to provide trial court security, period. If they're reimbursed, according to the MOU, if they're reimbursed by the not. Hold on. Hold on. We just for clarification, I want to just bring this back to the CEO for just a minute. Because I think you both are talking about something that she knows quite a bit about. And I want to let her.


11:20 a.m.

clarify this question of who is responsible to pay for security at the courts. So there's two components here. There's trial court security, which is what the bailiffs provide through funding from the state to the second floor where, just one moment please, Supervisor Bone, where the courts take place. Those funds are provided by the state to the sheriff, but they don't cover the full cost of that. So the sheriff covers, through the general fund allocations, the difference. In addition to that, and that's a mandated service that the sheriff must provide. In addition to that, there is entrance screening at the 4th and 5th Street entrance of the courthouses. That is the component that is up for discussion today, the entrance screening. The trial court security will still continue. It will look different if we don't do entrance screening services anymore, but it is simply the entrance. So we will continue to look at the entrance screening services. Thank you.


11:21 a.m.

today that we are proposing that we cease if the funding no longer follows for that service. In addition, I do just want to point out to Judge Neal's comment about the exorbitant amount of these services. Ceasing to pay the 83% as is, is just over $200,000 a year. We'll need to go out to RFP. We already did one RFP and the judge is correct. Those costs almost doubled. So this $200,000 that we're talking about right now potentially being shifted over to the county has the potential in the future to reach upwards of $400,000. So I just want to be clear as we talk about the financial impact around this to the county, it's not an insignificant amount. Okay. I just want to get that clarification out there. And also, I was kind of feeling the conversation was talking past each other a little bit. So I just want to bring that back. And Supervisor, excuse me,


11:22 a.m.

The council has something he wants to add. Yes, I just want to clarify, too. The government code does say that the courts shall not reimburse the sheriff, but also it further says that the courts can enter into an MOU, and it is government code section 69920, and that's the section that we use to create the MOU. There are courts throughout the state that also have entered into such MOUs. There's courts that actually pay for private security for certain courtrooms to enhance their courts. And so this is not uncommon. Not every county is the same, and there are certain counties that pay for direct costs for court screening, but they've had bigger budgets, too, initially by the state. But we cannot afford that, and we cannot absorb that cost. And, again, that's why we're here. I have Regina, my CFO here. She's able to talk about real costs and what happens, and just to echo off what Judge Neal said, we did go out to an RFP.


11:23 a.m.

And because of increased costs, minimum wages and those kind of things, that has increased. And that was the sticker shock that basically got the courts, you know, to make this action here because they could not afford the increase to the 83 percent. So, again, that's why we're here. If you have any questions regarding the costs, I have Regina here. She can answer those questions. I'm going to see if anyone else just – I want to give some other people a turn here. So, Supervisor Roy, do you have any clarifying questions about this? Well, I understand. I appreciate the clarification about the trial court security role in bailiffs and how that might look different and that that's not what we're talking about here. But I see in the staff report there's a long list of back-and-forth kind of possibilities that were floated. But none of that makes it clear to me what the trial court security would look like if, in turn, superiors were able to get the money to pay for the bailiffs. Could you say just a little bit more about that?


11:24 a.m.

Our edification, I realize, again, that's not, we're trying to kind of bifurcate those, but they're not, they would have to look different. So that would be helpful to understand. So screening would occur on the second floor. Essentially, our bailiffs would have to take on more responsibility to screen. And it's something that, you know, we would have to reimagine, so to speak, because we don't have something in place right now. But it could be, it could look like, you know, a modification of the structure. It could look like screening equipment on the second floor. It could be modified to just certain courtrooms based upon the need. It's something that we're going to have to work out between the sheriff's office, the CAO, and the courts. But there's no hard and fast answer. We do not have to screen everyone through a metal detector that goes into court. That's not laid out in the law. Thank you. That's helpful. Yeah. It does seem like there's some. Thank you.


11:25 a.m.

I'm just not seeing the same facts in the same light going on here, which, you know, it happens. Well, I mean, the fact is, I mean, it's like we are in charge of courthouse security. And so there is, again, there's no mandate of what that actually looks like. The level of comfort, oh, yeah, we would all love to see everyone screened coming in the courthouse. But not every county building has that luxury. And so we have to deal with what we can actually provide. And the courts, you know, again, want the county to take this on solely as our burden to do so. But actually the only reason why we would even consider it is because of the second floor courts. I see. Thank you. Okay. I have a couple clarifying questions, and I'll kind of do another round. One has to do, I mean, and comments. One is I do think that if we're going to, that there is a need to team up in terms of asking the state and specifically. Specifically through McGuire and Rogers.


11:26 a.m.

office for long-term funding to do security in this building. Related to that, I mean, it's not every county that has these administrative functions in the courthouse that we have in like this. In many places, they have worked hard to separate those things. So that doesn't, and we have had a dream of doing that as well. You know, that the courts could assume more, a bigger role in this space as well in the future if we were to actually create a separate administrative campus in order to get out of this very old building, which has its problems, its challenges in its age and function. That being said, so if we had been able to separate our generalities, we would have a completely different elected environment. And so we're here because the chief executive officer has the right to support those people, but also it serves a general campaign because we signed an oath last month. Several years ago, a number of deputies came to deliver a letter like these to the SENA that they're going to leave whether or not this city's going to be supported. Now, what I'm saying, and this is kind of people talking about what Esta Talk is because these things,


11:27 a.m.

general county functions outside this building into a separate building and this was the courts by themselves what is the statutorily mandated service that you would have to provide specifically for the courts without assuming that the the county was completely uh separate from this in a geographic space we would have to provide security for the courtrooms themselves and the judges that's that's what is mandated under the law again what that looks like oftentimes is a bailiff in the courtroom to provide that direct security for that of course there's always increased security that can be provided you know based upon the circumstances or the recommendation from the the judge that more security needs to be there whether that's more bailiffs or entrance through screening devices based upon the severity of the case or the people involved and so


11:28 a.m.

That's a level, it is something, that's why we have a court security agreement that's in place that was supposed to be reviewed every year. We're waiting for this to occur here before we start with that current agreement to try and figure out what court security looks like in this next year. Okay, I'm going to now take this to public comment and then ask that when we bring this back to the board that we circle around or get to a place where we can make a recommendation for how to move forward. As quickly as possible because we have a whole other item coming up and we have a time set at 12 and so we're really pushing our time boundaries here. Supervisor Bushnell? Can you clarify for, there are quite a few folks that have came up for this next item and I see the Ag Commissioner is here as well probably for that item. And so do we, I know that you had scheduled a lunch in there but are we able to possibly start that item or is it going to come after just for audience? Can you? As the chair.


11:29 a.m.

Can you clarify, please? Well, through council, we had discussed this in terms of the timing of this. We had a time-sensitive item in terms of outside council, but there was some leeway in that. Is that what I'm understanding? So if we go over past 12, I think that's what we'll try and do. And also, I'm going to ask that I feel like we're going to try and get through the cannabis item in a good, in a speedy way. I think we can do that. And so with that, I'm going to go to public comment on this item, and then we'll. Real quick. Yeah. Go ahead. Thank you, Chair. I think ultimately we need to get the state involved here and cover their costs. Because, you know, when we talk about responsibility, it's really response. Ability. Right. In all these arenas. So I'm just.


11:30 a.m.

to make that comment. Great. Moving to public comment online. Oh, excuse me. I said it was going to go in the room first, so let's do that. Anyone in the room that wants to speak on this item, please do so. And please line up so that we don't have a lot of lag time between folks. Good morning. I'm here to speak on this recommendation to cease the courthouse security screening. Please do not cease the courthouse security screening. Times have changed. This screening is for the safety of everyone in the courthouse. No one knows when someone would enter the courthouse with a weapon of any kind and not be going to the second floor. Security for the entire building needs to remain in place. As the victim of a violent crime, I know how quickly a life-changing incident can happen. I'm here to speak on this item. Can occur. Find the phone.


11:31 a.m.

in the budget to retain these positions, even if you find it necessary to sell some of the property which the county has purchased recently. I do not have my comments typed to hand to you, but I will type them later today and bring back to your office. Thank you for your time, Phyllis Coy. Thank you for those comments, and it is a good reminder that people can call in comments and write in comments. This isn't the only format for making comments. Do we have anyone online? Yes, Chair. Caller 7718, I will unmute you and you'll have three minutes. Well, I've spent a lot of time watching the people go through the screening, waiting for meetings when I'm there.


11:32 a.m.

It never made any sense to me that we didn't bill for Kate the courthouse properly so we were only screening the people that were going up to the second floor. And so I kind of sat there and I thought well you know how could we do that? And the easiest, maybe it's not viable or not but should be considered, is all courthouse participants, anybody going to the second floor would enter the courthouse in the lower entry down there. Wouldn't go through screening at that time necessarily. But then there's one elevator, just take one elevator specifically dedicated to go strictly to the second floor. Other than emergencies, they're entering right down in front of the chair of the office which is a good thing. They have cameras out there and things for what's going on. They would go upstairs in that single use elevator which of course in emergencies would be used for all things. And the screening would have to be done in the second floor.


11:33 a.m.

I don't think there's so many other places, you don't have a courthouse, you don't need this green, Amanda. Although we do get once in a while some crazy person coming in to the supervisor's chamber, some people say it's me. But on the other hand, the ones we usually have are still over the people coming in that are headed up in that direction or have other functional problems. So I strongly support you going with the deputy in the chamber or something during your meeting and rerouting the security up to the top. Whatever the state provides or is mandated that we have to have to provide at that level, it will obviously be required to be provided. And I strongly support you lobbying to go to the state to get everybody to do as they play for that security for the court system. That's the way I look at that one. I appreciate the opportunity to speak today. Thank you. We're going to bring it back to the board. I have one more. We do have one more. Sorry about that.


11:34 a.m.

No worries. Thank you, Chair. Caller 3053, I will unmute you and you'll have three minutes. uh not afternoon yet still almost back in thomas moulder here i just want to confirm you can hear me there in the chambers yes we can hear you hear me there in the chambers okay uh well thank you for allowing me and speak and not skipping over uh first off i would say you know there's many decisions made at that diet not just board of supervisors but also planning commission and other meetings so if you were thinking about having security for yourself as the board sure should pass that gratitude on to any other people that sit there and make decisions that really honestly affect people's livelihood um i think it'd be quite interesting if we didn't have security there you know um wow


11:35 a.m.

What would that do if there was board meetings and planning commission meetings with no security? And if that open carry comes through, would you be allowed to carry a weapon? I don't know. Just interesting food for thought. What sparked my mind is protection of victims. You know, being a victim of a crime. Different things out there. Where is that protection passing through the hallway, throughout the building? I don't know. It'd be quite interesting what would happen. I mean, in Humboldt County, we let criminals out. You know, people continue to break the laws. I think it'd be pretty scary. So, you know, if deputies have an officer involved shooting, maybe we don't spend so much taxpayer dollars confirming that, hey, that was justified. You know? More of that, I don't know. So just think about that. Think about if you're going to provide protection to yourself, you better give it to everyone else. And if you're just going to do the court, just do the court. Thank you for the opportunity. Thank you.


11:36 a.m.

Thank you. All right. I think that it is all chair. All right. So bringing it back to the board, I'd like to kind of hone in on a motion if that's possible and have a little bit more conversation if that's needed. So anybody supervisor Bushnell supervisor Bone. I think, did Regina, did you have something else you wanted to say? I did, thank you. Could I, through the courtesy of the chair, have the CFO? Because we're talking about our money here. All right. Yes, I think this is important information for you to have. So the second floor trial court security that the sheriff mentioned with the 12 deputies that are securing that floor, and that trial court security revenue through realignment that comes directly to us, that alone, so we receive approximately $1.4 million from the state, and our payroll for those 12 deputies to secure that second floor.


11:37 a.m.

on average is $1.8 million. So our general fund is already kicking in $400,000 approximately per year just to maintain the security on the second floor. In addition to that, through the way that the code is written from realignment, we are not able to pass through any of our cost plan charges, our ISF charges. So that's another $100,000. So we are already half a million dollars coming out of our general fund to be able to fund this. Due to the budget was this year and last year, the CAO's office did find approximately $400,000 to help us with that. But that goes away next year. So we're already going to be asking you for half a million dollars next year to help cover just the bare minimum that's required on that second floor. So the security screening is over and above that. So I just want to make sure you're aware of that information. And also we're talking about equipment. So then if you decide to take on the court screening costs, it's also you're agreeing to take on the equipment.


11:38 a.m.

equipment for that screening, the baggage on both sides, as well as the metal detectors. And that has to be replaced every couple of years. And follow up, or follow up and follow up. And the question I have is, is any of this now I understand where the county and I've been and I think publicly to this, these are costs that are born from us by being the county. But a lot of our cases based on actually probably a majority are Eureka, Fortuna, Arcata, you know, actual acts that take place in the incorporated areas that we go that end up coming through our court system. Now, I know we get some money or do we still get some money from booking fees? We don't get any booking fees monies anymore. So the jail, the courts, everything, what we're talking about is all on us. And so we become the Eureka. Yeah. They bring them to the jail. Civil court, family court. I mean, all of it. Yeah. There's about 300.


11:39 a.m.

$184,000 that comes through the state for booking that goes directly to the jail, but we're not able to charge any of the other cities. So we're doing our fair share already. I believe the equipment is owned by the state and maintained by the state. Correct. Is that? No, that's correct. But that's, again, a cost that the state, you know. The other thing is the state going to sell us the equipment if we decide to do this? That's, yeah. We don't know. Yeah. All right. Supervisor Bushnell, and then let's see what we can do to get to a recommendation. I'm happy to make a motion for staff recommendations that includes direct the sheriff. Items one, two, three, and four. And then I want to clarify that those items, once we do that, will it come back to this board once we've decided what we're doing for authorization or what does that look like? If we're making that. Motion for staff.


11:40 a.m.

recommendations so that we can move these talks further along. If that's what you would like, we can make that happen. So I think I would make a recommendation for staff recommendations and then to report back to this board what the new security plan looks like and will happen in the future before, you know, obviously probably around October. I think this would cease to happen in the end of the year. So I think that would give you enough time to get it together. I would love to second that if we could drop number two. Authorizes you to sign one deputy sheriff to the board of supervisors. We have 20 some odd departments and all of a sudden it becomes our Tuesdays. We're going to have to have somebody here and I haven't. Okay. I'm fine. I'll second it. So staff recommendations, excluding number two, and that the, the security plan comes back to this board by October. I'll second that. I have a clarifying question.


11:41 a.m.

Please bow over. So just a point of clarification to Supervisor Bushnell's motion. The courts are ceasing all funding July 1. So our plan is to have that operational plan in place by then. So I would say May. I'll amend that motion to have you guys come back by May. Kaylee, do you have that? I'm sorry. I want to make sure you got that. Yes, I do. Do you want me to repeat it back to you? Please. So to accept staff recommendations with the removal of two and to report back to the board with the new security plan by May. Thank you. You're welcome. Is the seconder okay with that? Five. Okay. We have a motion and a second. I'm going to ask for a potential modification, which is to direct staff to work with our county staff to work, the CAO's office to work with the sheriff to also work with the courts to come up with some, advocacy at the state level. We can't talk until July 10. Are you important to state to recipes. Our I just, I can't collect our I it was an, thank you.


11:42 a.m.

level for funding for these services, both at McGuire's and Roger's office? Does that seem reasonable? So I'm fine with that, and that's what I had alluded to earlier, that we need to engage the state to get it done. Yeah, I just wanted to give specific direction. So, Kaylee, that would be to have someone, CAO, sheriffs, courts, do advocacy around more funding to try to accomplish this. And to the chair, this is CSAC, I know, is already working on this. RCRC is working on this because this, as we're seeing right now, this affects the rural counties a little bit more because you – how many deputies do we have, Sheriff Hansel? A total? Yeah. A hundred? So we're looking at 12% are to the courts. That's a pretty big number when we're 4,700 square miles. So this is something that RCRC is looking at for the rural areas.


11:43 a.m.

CSAC is looking for everybody overall. I appreciate that. I do have a question about the, we have, I see the emergency button. It's right here in front of me. And I have not yet had to press that button. And I don't know what the response time is necessarily. But if we are going to be moving in that direction, then I'm going to ask that we do some training and some updating in terms of how we will respond if there is an incident of some kind. And so we'll put that into the future. It doesn't need to be in this motion. But I want to put out the intent that we're going to have to modernize how we interact in those situations here. So with that, we have a motion and a second. Is everybody ready to vote? I'm sorry, a clarification here. Yes. So if we're going to continue. You know, with this, are we going to get a supplemental budget as well?


11:44 a.m.

Because if the court's only paying $7,000 or agreeing to in the next couple months, then it's going to dip into our fund to continue at the current level until we come up with a plan. So, which is another additional $7,000 a month the sheriff's office has to take on. So, if I could clarify as the motion maker, are you asking to cease courthouse immediately? Yes, I am, unless we get fully reimbursed. Unless we have some other funding source, because I do not have the funds. And again, when I say set, it's going to be more like $8,000, $9,000, because we have to negotiate a new contract. And we can make that out 30 days, 40 days, 45 days, something like that to do a transition. But I just need a timeline to know. So, as the motion maker, I'm going to ask CAO what that looks like and if an item would need to come back to supplement. Like to say if we were going to keep that open for... Two months to make that.


11:45 a.m.

transition yes and uh the jessica and i were completely prepared for a supplemental budget request to come from this but we need to sort of iron out the logistics around what it's going to look like when the the termination date is going to be um what levels of service will be provided in the interim um to fully flush that out so we i don't think it's necessarily needed in the motion we anticipate returning with a budget adjustment okay future date so i'm not going to update my motion then and then we'll be coming back great and one more question or comment from supervisor royal yeah i just uh i haven't said a lot in this item but i wanted to um thank judge neil for reaching out um i did have a chance to talk with her when i was laid over in an airport yesterday so uh thank you for for that time and clarification and um you know i appreciate everyone working on this i know that um it seems like there's a


11:46 a.m.

Some challenging things about this, no doubt. I did want to ask in this interim period, you know, it sounds like there's still some details to work out. In the staff report, there are a number of other options to modify or wind down from what we currently have that include things like closing the Fifth Street public entrance, you know, going, having court employees go through the clerk's office. I appreciate the idea of emphasizing and encouraging use of remote appearances. And I know, you know, I've had concerns just about the cost of bailiffs overall, and that's certainly not going to, that cost doesn't seem like it's going to decrease. So I don't know if there are opportunities to, I'm sure you all already do try to increase remote appearances, but if there's any way that we can up that and decrease those costs. And then you know, I'm sure there's a lot of work to be done to make sure that we're able to do that. You know, I appreciate that.


11:47 a.m.

spirit of not always having a deputy in the chambers, but I'd like to, you know, keep it optional with the, in conjunction with the CAO, the chair, and the sheriff to kind of decide based on what's going on, if we might need that from time to time. So I want the general public to know that could happen when you come in. There could be a deputy here providing, you know, additional security on site. So I realize there's some pros and cons with that for folks. But the, yeah, I just want to, you know, thank those involved and also say, you know, having been in Eureka City Hall for some very spicy meetings, I really appreciated sometimes having an EPD officer. There's always someone in the room and it was, it sometimes did improve the tenor of the conversation. I saw people make threatening gestures and then kind of glance over.


11:48 a.m.

and wind it back. So there were some benefits to that, but I appreciate what we've come up with here, even though it's not a perfect solution. Thank you, everyone. Okay, good questions and comments, but there's no modification to the request? No, but I just wanted to express openness to whatever options need to be incorporated in the meantime while we're winding down, given that the costs are too high for everyone. So it sounds like there were some options in here that we didn't get into the nitty-gritty of, and I think we're sort of delegating the decision-making around that. Supervisor Bushnell. I think that given an item is going to come back for a budgetary item that we can add that to the discussion, because that will ultimately wind down and give us a time frame on how much money, say if we have two months of a budget request coming, then we can talk about these options of what that looks like. For Fifth Street, we have to have Fourth Street. It's the ADA compliance.


11:49 a.m.

and entrance so I think that those items can come and more discussion I imagine that budgetary item will come soon we don't want to dip into the sheriff's budget we don't want the courts to feel like in limbo also and thanks to judge Neal for your advocacy this is a changing time for everyone great and and supervisor Arroyo and I as chair and vice-chair will look more deeply into the evolution of security in this space for these meetings and other meetings as well with that is there did you have one more thing yes yeah just and I think I think the sheriff and the protect and serve and everything else I've been involved over the years with some very contentious meetings and we've always had an officer when it's deemed necessary and it's actually been called upon saying hey you may want to be here today we have an issue and they're here so that's what I'm saying and I think that's what I'm saying and I think that's I think we have to understand that we don't have to have a


11:50 a.m.

And I think we had six deputies at the Terrigen meetings. I mean, you know, for two days. I mean, it was very well represented. And then we've had issues where we've had contentious here, timber war, timber stuff, general plan stuff over the years. And we've had a deputy in place. So I think the idea of having a deputy, I think, is he has a wonderful grasp for the obvious. And I think he reads an agenda and knows where there's going to be a problem. And they're available. And if you've never had to push the button, and I'd say three out of the four times the button has been pushed has been a mistake because you're trying to call everybody back in. But we get a lot of response. And it's quick response. And I don't think when we've had problems with people lighting a cigar inside the chambers, we've had deputies here. So I think the obvious, I don't know if we need that written into it. But if you feel it's a responsible thing, do. But I do have pretty good faith in public service. Nothing to be written in. I just think.


11:51 a.m.

Just emoted an intent. So with that, is there any objection to unanimous consent to the motion that's been made? We've got to get it in one time. Seeing none, unanimous consent has been achieved. We are moving forward 5-0. OK. Can we have a five-minute break while planning a building comes up? We're going to have a five-minute break. I'm going to check in with staff on this to see how we're going to move through this next item as quickly as possible, but also as transparently and as robustly as possible. Thank you. Thank you.


11:58 a.m.

Thank you. Thank you. We have our board members.


11:59 a.m.

Everybody in the room, we're going to start this up. If there are folks online, I'm asking, just like we did at the beginning of the meeting, that if you want to speak on this item, please raise your hand now. That would be great, just so we can have a good idea of managing this meeting. And we're going to try and move through this as quickly as possible, and so we'll see how that goes. I hope everyone can be as concise as possible in this item. Thank you. Moving on. Excuse me. Director Ford, please start up this conversation. I think, do we have to open a public hearing? We do not. This is a petition. Okay. Good afternoon, Chair Wilson, members of the Board of Supervisors, John Ford with Planning and Building, with Waylon Shaw, the Ag Commissioner. So this is a request to modify the commercial canvas land use ordinance. And I do have a presentation, I think.


noon

And so there's basically three requests to modify the ordinance. One is to allow hemp cultivation within cannabis permits. The second is to allow indoor cultivation in buildings that were constructed after 2016. And the third is to allow monofilament netting. And so the first area is hemp, and the Humboldt County Growers Association has presented a request to allow a pilot program that would allow up to 5,000 square feet of hemp either within the existing permit or in addition to the existing permit, of the existing cannabis permit, to really determine whether or not the hemp cultivation would be workable. At first thought, it seems like anything that can be done to help the cannabis community...


12:01 p.m.

Particularly the small farmers, sounds like a good idea. Want to support the industry and it seems innocuous. But getting back to the concerns that were in 2019, they were basically two-fold. Concern number one was about pollination on large-scale growths. And that's really not an issue with the pilot program that's requested. It really comes down to a matter of enforcement. Because what would essentially happen is that right now it's the DCC that does the legal enforcement about where, how, when cannabis is sold. That would essentially be shifted to the Ag Commissioner's Office and also to the Sheriff's Department. The concern here is that there would be a cost of implementing such a program. We would need to backfill the Ag Commissioner's Office to be able to accommodate that. And also equip them with the ability to test hemp.


12:02 p.m.

truly determined that it's hemp and not high THC cannabis. There's also an issue with law enforcement, as was seen in the Oregon hemp grows, that a lot of the hemp that was produced in some of those cycles was actually high THC cannabis. So we're recommending not that the board not direct staff to modify the CCLUO to allow the cultivation of hemp and undo the moratorium that currently exists on hemp. The next item is the idea of allowing monofilament netting. This is not addressed in either 1.0 or 2.0. This is really something that is being brought forward to address the fact that a lot of projects have conditions on them restricting the use of monofilament netting. Monofilament netting is properly used, as shown, in the left picture. You can see the netting that's there that's supporting the plant.


12:03 p.m.

There's really not a good solution for, or a good alternative for it. People have experimented with different products, but none of them really are as effective. The problem, the issue with monofilament netting is, as you can see over on the right photo, the first white blob there is actually plastic, but the second blob is netting that often gets wadded up and left on the ground. That becomes a danger and a hazard to wildlife, and so it's really about how the monofilament netting is handled, transported, disposed of, and we believe that can be addressed with performance standards, and we recommend that the board direct staff to proceed with modifying the CCLU-O to create performance standards and then find a way to address how permits have been conditioned. Because one of the things, Frank, that Electrically, we're struggling with,


12:04 p.m.

with is that we go out to many farms. There I've seen most farms. The only violation is that they're using monofilament netting. So do we suspend them and bring them forward for a revocation for something that is the industry standard and it's a difficult place to be right now. The third item is indoor cultivation. This was added into CCLUO or the CCLUO or 2.0 to not allow indoor cultivations in buildings constructed after or it had to be in buildings constructed before 2016. The reason for this is at the time we'd just gone through the onslaught of applications receiving 2,375 applications in 2016 and being worried that we were going to have to have to do that again. So we're going to have to do that again. So we're going to have to do that again. So we're going to have to do that again. So we're going to have to do that again. And we're worried about, okay, what would this mean for people building new buildings, being incentivized to build new buildings, put new buildings on.


12:05 p.m.

on prime ag land or in other places that really aren't good for buildings to be placed. And so that was adopted as part of the 2.0 ordinance. The industry is really in a different place right now. We believe that with performance standards similar to how agricultural buildings are currently required to be within the curlage and perhaps some other standards relative to size and other things, that this can be adequately addressed and the ordinance can be modified to allow indoor cultivation as a way of strengthening the ability of the community to find alternative ways to succeed. So it's a recommendation of staff to take no action to allow hemp cultivation, and then the Board of Supervisors direct staff. to allow the use of or modify the ordinance.


12:06 p.m.

to allow new permitted buildings for indoor cannabis and allow the use of monofilament netting. That concludes the presentation. I'm happy to answer any questions. Great. We're going to start with quick questions from the board. If they have any clarifying questions for staff, this is the time to do it. Supervisor Bushnell. Thank you. I would like staff to consider opening up cultivation in impacted watersheds with, I'm not saying this right, but currently with farms failing, we have a, you know, an un, it's not, we don't know how many square footage of cultivation can happen, but some farms want to expand in impacted watersheds, and currently it's not being allowed because of, you know, people don't want the growth there, but with the amount of farms that are failing, I think that we should look at whether that could be acceptable to allow.


12:07 p.m.

farms to expand if they want to with the decline in cultivation in those impacted watersheds. And John, I kind of fumbled through that, but you know what I'm talking about. I do, Supervisor Bushnell. And I think that that's something that would probably be good at this point to take a look at to see what the original number of cultivation sites were that were to be permitted within the permitting process and what the actual number is now, and then calculate how many of the sites that were never in the permitting process but had been abated and what the actual reduction has been, and then to coordinate with our state partners to see what their thoughts are on that. Also, sorry to interrupt you. Complete your sentence. No, I'm good. Okay. Well, also, you know, there are like the Matoa Restoration and folks that work on those impacted watersheds, not only down in Miami,


12:08 p.m.

district but in others that we could coordinate with that have information and then i would just like to add about the uh the um netting that i think this is a really good solution because it is happening in almost every farm um they are anticipating a inspection and they're deciding when to put that netting on anyways um because they are using it and i know that you have not seen wads of that netting um because people are disposing of it correctly i think that it's uh really in the benefit of the farmers the other option is a twine that encourages mold that does not work very well and so i really appreciate the department coming forward with that and recognizing that it's getting used anyways and and you know people don't want to hide stuff and so this is a good way to do that um also the cultivation allowed in buildings after 2016 which is a good way to do that um and i think that's a good way to do that um and i think that's a good way to do that um and i think that's a good way to do that um so you know with the market declining as it is uh a lot of folks are just doing smaller


12:09 p.m.

We're trying to do possibly indoor, which is something think is a more sustainable market. And this allows options for Humboldt for cultivation to continue forward if they have a building that was built or constructed and permitted after 2016. Thank you for those updates. Okay. Anybody else? I have a couple questions before we move into public comment. One is in relation to the indoor cultivation element of this. And so would this would be under 2.0 conditions so there wouldn't be generators or anything like that associated with this or under that expansion? That is correct. It would have to be on a renewable source of power. Okay. And I think there is, well, I assume that most of the netting is in relation to deer. No, it's in something else. It's birds or other animals. What is this? Probably a lot.


12:10 p.m.

Of the smaller critters. Okay. No? Okay. No. It has nothing to do with animals, actually. The plants don't stay up if you don't net them. And when they get their end-of-cycle buds on them, they fall over and break. And the netting holds the product up. Is that what you were asking? Oh, what were you asking? I thought he was asking what's the problem. Oh, disposal. Oh, yeah. Well, also even in their use. I mean, I have used this netting before myself. But it was for deer issues, and it wasn't just like putting it over a plant. It was actually put just on the grounds because when they step on it, they don't like that. So I was just wondering. And when we saw this photograph of it over the hoops, what was the purpose of that? The purpose of that was to hold the plants up so that the stems weren't. Got it. Great. Good to know. And let's see. That's okay. I'm a little concerned about.


12:11 p.m.

I hear the impacted watershed question about that. It sounds like there's almost like a request for sort of a cap and trade approach to that, although I'm using that term very loosely. But what we're saying is that there was analysis done for a certain amount of impact within an impacted watershed due to this thing when we did our environmental review. And I think what you might have been saying is like, well, now that the market's different, that analysis may allow for expansion of some because there's not others. Is that what I'm getting at? So I wish it was that sophisticated. Okay. What it really was was identifying that there were critical watersheds, that some of them were maybe beyond the point of continuing to support fisheries. Others were pristine and were refuge watersheds and were important for fisheries. There's two of those. There's ten of the impacted. And so. Thank you.


12:12 p.m.

Those were identified as just no additional cultivation within those beyond what the current application load is. I see. So you can't expand your existing nursery or your existing garden, and you can't apply for a new cultivation site there. So those are closed. And one of the things that we often see right now is when the permit is lost in those watersheds, it's lost. There's no going back. And so one of the things that was intended is that we would work with the state water board, work with CDFW, that there would be more monitoring that I'm aware of in terms of how much water is in the creeks and the rivers, and that that would be the study, the determining factor of when it would be appropriate to look at reopening those. I mean,


12:13 p.m.

Interrupt you just for a second. So what you're saying is you would have to go back to Fish and Wildlife to discuss this. If they brought up a bunch of red flags that this isn't going to work for us, would we spend a lot of time doing this? No. Okay. We bring that back to you as a report saying here's what we think the pitfalls are. We would probably bring back a report to you showing how much cultivation has been reduced in those watersheds because that should be something reported to the public. Okay. And so my question would just be the balance of the amount of work being done versus is the juice worth the squeeze? And I'm just kind of wondering how you feel about that. Usually when we undertake a public process, if the public or the agencies are just like, what are you thinking? Mm-hmm. You know, we tend to redirect because at that point it's, you know,


12:14 p.m.

You don't want to have a fight all the way through a process. But also, on the other side of that, how much growth in the arena could actually, are you going to get out of this versus not doing it? Quite frankly, we're probably not going to see a lot of new farms. And maybe this would be a compromise. It's like you allow certain farms to expand at a certain percentage or something like that. And if they're a certain dimension from a waterway or something like that. I think that there's probably ways to allow, if we find that the numbers have really gone way, way down, to allow this to occur without creating new impacts to a watershed and protecting the gains that have been made. And what I mean by that is, by juice worth squeeze, I mean like our, this institution's administrative enforcement.


12:15 p.m.

capacity that would have to change in order to make a change within the within the industry because you did that analysis for this hemp right i mean that the hemp part of this you did some analysis in terms of like the question of is the pilot project being proposed you guys are saying there's an administrative and enforcement burden that would come with that and from your analysis you're like maybe it's not worth it for us um that's what i'm hearing and so what i'm saying is we would probably do something similar if we were to do an analysis around the watersheds right okay that was all i just wanted to to ask that simple question and then um supervisor bushnell has an has another comment and then we'll take it out to public comment and i think i'm going to ask uh that um it seems like there's now sort of four things on this list uh if people could be very concise about their their concerns and our comments and our suggestions


12:16 p.m.

on those four items that we're discussing in this moment. That would be great. If there's a fifth thing you want to propose, this is also a time to do that, and then we'll bring it back and we'll have some discussion. So I'm going to open this up to, oh, Supervisor Bushnell had another comment before, and then Supervisor Madrone as well. Thank you. I just wanted to ask Director Ford, was there a requirement that we do some kind of monitoring in those impacted watersheds that we haven't been able to accomplish? Yeah, we were supposed to do, yeah. So this needs to be done regardless? Correct. Okay. So on the monofilament issue, obviously it's something, as Supervisor Wilson mentioned, that it's not just cannabis people who use monofilament fencing. I think you were talking about something that was non-cannabis related, just protecting rose bushes or any number of things. And, you know, the issue with wildlife, is entanglement. And it's not...


12:17 p.m.

Not just if it's laying on the ground in a pile, it can actually just be up as fencing and it creates an issue. So I really like the idea of if it's being used in a greenhouse, the likelihood of any wildlife entanglement is almost nil. And even if it's in an outdoor garden, the real solution there is to have an eight-foot fence around your garden outdoors. The deer aren't going to jump to eight feet, but they'll jump a six-foot field fence. And so it's a matter of the type of fencing you use to keep them out of entanglement in the garden. We don't regulate like home garden use of this stuff. It's a whole other level of stuff. And I would just say to people, it's really probably inappropriate to use it for deer protection in your garden because the entanglement issue is still very real there. Better to use metal field fencing eight-foot high if you're bringing a rose bush or you're doing your backyard. But I just wanted to make sure. I want to make those comments that this really just deals with cannabis issues.


12:18 p.m.

with monofilament and there's always all these other potential uses outside of the industry that are important to consider but we're not here regulating that today. Okay great I'm going to open this up to public comment unless there was another oh Supervisor Bone I didn't see. And to that to the monofilament thing because it just I mean do you know how many vineyards use monofilament for the birds? The birds are the biggest culprit for wine grapes and they use a lot of monofilament. I can name three locally that use monofilament to cover their whole vineyard which is quite a bit. So it's not just a singular use so I think you know when you start doing this it needs to be fully evaluated. All right was there did you guys have any responses to any of these questions? Okay great we're taking it in the room here. So there you go. Jesse Jeffries here.


12:19 p.m.

Humboldt County resident and indoor cultivator. It's always hard to follow up after John Ford's speech. He knows this inside and out pretty well. Basically, I built a large building on my ag land several years ago. It was after 2016 and I wanted to expand my indoor cultivation and I was told that because the building wasn't built and permitted before 2016, that that was not an option. I sit here and look at this building that I spent a significant amount of money on to build and basically being told that I can't expand. I wanted to touch on that. I also wanted to touch on impacted watersheds and that I feel like the ordinance has a blanket approach and I believe that every site out there in these impacted watersheds are different. As far as slope goes,


12:20 p.m.

as far as point of diversion, how the water is collected. I mean, my personal farm, I have no point of diversion. It's 100% rain catchment water. I have millions of gallons of water. So the impact from a water standpoint is zero. And so, yeah, I wanted to touch on that for impacted watersheds and then talk about the baseline in these watersheds. I believe there was a baseline. I don't know this too well, but there was a baseline in every watershed that was established. Was that in 2016 or 18? But anyways, a lot of farms have dropped off, as you know, and once those permits go away, they're gone. And if we're still below the baseline for the water usage, if it's a point of diversion, it would make sense that that could still be utilized. Thank you.


12:21 p.m.

Instead of just disappearing off into thin air and not giving anybody new that comes along the same opportunity. And so I would like to see a little bit more, what's the word, maybe diversity because not every site's the same. Some of these sites are cliffs covered in trees. Some of them are flat prime ag soil. Some of them are not an impacted watershed. Their water storage situations are different. So I wanted to speak to that. And then what else was there? Oh, the monofilo netting, however you say that. Yeah, I don't think it's an issue of, it is the industry standard. The issue is that there is or was a lot of bad actors in the marijuana industry. And a lot of those people have packed camp that came here for the green rush and left town. And I personally, as a Humboldt County resident.


12:22 p.m.

I'd love to see him leave, but I hate to watch the economy crash here. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Hello, Craig Johnson. My wife and I own a cannabis farm in Southern Humboldt, about 10,000 square feet. I'll touch on the netting briefly. I think there's a lot of confusion around the netting. This is not fencing. This has six-inch grid. It's strictly for supporting plants. And we personally have been using our netting for over eight years. We could throw those pictures out with, you know, tires or garden hoses or whatever else you want to have. If you're not responsible with your trash, you're not responsible with your trash. And I think we keep the netting in there because it's definitely industry standard. I do want to touch on the hemp. I think we do need to open this up for a pilot program. And we've worked on this for about two years to come up with mindful program that could really help.


12:23 p.m.

really open some doors. And when I say open some doors, you know, number one, it's going to be for cultivators that are already good actors in the system. And those of us that have been paying our taxes on time, if you're part of a pilot program, you're not going to be, I mean, part of a payment program, even with your taxes, you're not going to be involved in this. This is for people that are 100% in good standing in every department. And I look at it that if I was to add 10,000 or 5,000 square feet of cultivation for hemp outside of my space, and Director Ford has been already paid a year ahead to be satellite enforcing me, they're going to see that there's more cultivation space. So they already know who's part of the program and who's not part of the program right there without any extra fees. DCC is already. We're already doing what they call compliance inspections. We can call those enforcement inspections at this point. They're not coming out just to take a look.


12:24 p.m.

They're looking at what they can see wrong with a farm, and they're going to see that's wrong. We have to acknowledge with new site maps. So for me to participate in this program, I'm looking at about $3,000. New site map with the county, new site map with the DCC. We have to declare this space. And then for me personally, I look at it as this to get going on a breeding program for hemp. That's where I'm looking at this to help me out. We don't know where that industry is going. There's a lot of nuances. There's a loophole that has been 1 million percent acknowledged and is wide open. So it's not a loophole at this point. It is law that you can participate at this current way of doing business that has been status quo since 2018. So there's that. And that has been acknowledged that it will be changed within the next year. So all these changes that are happening. Let's keep more opportunities open to the farmers.


12:25 p.m.

And with a quick straw poll, there's maybe 10 of us that might engage in this program. It's not going to be overwhelming, and it's with the people that already are here speaking and trying to engage in good business. Thank you. Thank you. Next. And if there's anyone else in the room that wants to speak, please line up. Good afternoon, and thank you for having me. My name is Oliver Kanner. I'm here representing myself and my partner, Jason Gelman, in our business, HEB Management. We're located in White Thorn. I'm the father of two. I'm a local business owner, homeowner, got a degree in environmental science from UC Santa Cruz, focusing on freshwater ecology. And I really appreciate Ms. Bushnell bringing up the impacted waterways. And also what you said, Mr. Ford. Our farm is located in impacted waterways.


12:26 p.m.

watershed. We currently have 10,000 square feet of mix light and because of the resolution, which was number 18-43 adopted May 8, 2018, we aren't able to expand. I also appreciate what Jesse jumped in and said, but you know this resolution was created almost seven years ago and that was like a much different time in this industry when you know obviously cultivation was rapidly expanding, but the number of cultivation sites has shrunk to a fraction of what they once were. Focusing on our operation specifically, we're 20 acres flat prime ag. We're like Jesse, all rain catchment, over a million gallons of storage, extensive ag infrastructure, buildings, power, and we're like a prime candidate for an expansion.


12:27 p.m.

I wrote a pretty extensive proposal for an expansion that detailed our plan, which is basically a low-impact outdoor cultivation, but the planning department basically, because of this resolution, won't look at it. So thank you again for bringing it up and talking about it, but we're just trying to continue to exist in the industry. It's obviously challenging out there. We have families to support. We're active community members, and, yeah, we're trying to just bring business and keep our economy in Southern Humboldt especially alive. So I think the ordinance needs to be amended just considering the changing times. We need to bolster the economy and create cultivation methods that are not detrimental to the environment. Again, we're one of a handful of cannabis businesses, and we're trying to do that. We're trying to do that. We're trying to do that.


12:28 p.m.

operational in Southern Humboldt, and we pride ourselves on being stewards of the environment and the community and the industry as a whole. Yeah, we look forward to working with you guys and figuring out a path forward. Thank you. All right. Thank you. And we have one more in the room and then we'll move to two more. All right. Again, please line up. Thanks. Uh, good morning supervisors. Appreciate discussion on these items. Uh, Ross Gordon with HCGA. Um, briefly, we support the proposed law on monofilament netting, uh, for the reasons that have been discussed so long as it's consistent with, uh, best management practices and performance standards. Um, as far as, uh, hemp goes, um, I just want to be clear about what I think the opportunity is, as we've discussed this with our members over the past year and a half, two years, is really the opportunity to participate in a federally legal market. Um, where there's commerce, which can legally happen across state lines and where there's not.


12:29 p.m.

the impediments that cannabis farmers face operating under federal prohibition. So I think that's the opportunity. And I think, you know, the staff report in general, it seems like there's acknowledgement that there could be opportunity here along those lines. Acknowledge the concerns that have been expressed around enforcement and want to make a couple of points about why I think those can be mitigated. First, as I think you know, we've proposed a really limited program with a limitation of 5,000 square feet, very small scale, only for permitted cannabis farmers. So this is a known set of permitted individuals who also have accountability by virtue of the fact that they are cannabis farmers in good standing with the county. And I think this is pretty distinct from what the staff report talks about in Sutter County or in Oregon, which are real concerns. I'm not saying those things aren't real. They absolutely are. But those are programs that really operated on an unlimited scale cultivation of hemp without any tie to cannabis permitting.


12:30 p.m.

Sutter County's case, no cannabis program at all. In Oregon's case, this kind of like entirely parallel industry operating separate from their permitted cannabis cultivation. I think the second really important thing I'd want to mention is that I think a lot of the context for hemp over the past eight years has been under a state and federal legal environment that was really a vacuum. And a lot of the reason you saw people pushing the boundaries of high THC hemp, for example, is because they had an argument that was legal under state and federal law. That's something which is now changing. We have new state law. We have DPH regulations in California prohibiting the sale of hemp with any THC within California. We also have AB8 in California, which now codifies that as of October. And there's also these changes in federal law that we're seeing that really, I think, signify that the federal government understands what's been going on with hemp and wants a more rational legal scheme. So those are slated to go into effect in November 2021. In November 2026, President Trump's executive order on


12:31 p.m.

scheduling also addresses this and says that he is going to be pushing for certain changes to that as well but i think the outcome of that is very likely to be a much more specified legal environment around hemp so i think looking backwards to what has been is not necessarily what's going to be in the future and i think there is opportunity to exploring this if it's small scale and if it's something you know that we all agree can be administered thank you all right next please good morning supervisors hannah white here also with the humboldt county growers alliance and also a small cultivator out in willow creek uh speaking on monofilament netting we support the adoption of best management practices and getting farmers into compliance and good standing especially if that's the only thing that is standing in the way of people having an a-plus report card from their inspections


12:32 p.m.

Let's get industry standard approved. Also support the county looking into and just doing what is in regulation and checking in on the watershed situation. How many cultivation sites we still have, how many are impacting, and what the space is an opportunity to support the farmers that we still have existing in our county. On the hemp note, hemp can do things that cannabis can't do. So hemp can move over state lines. Hemp products are being falsely marketed as Humboldt County products. Humboldt County farmers are not currently able to sell our Humboldt County cannabis, and we're not looking to sell cannabis as hemp. That's not the option here. We are looking to capitalize on the opportunity to remind consumers about what Humboldt County produces that is cannabis. That's hemp. That is also the flower that is regulated. If the county...


12:33 p.m.

was able to create a pilot program that allows existing farmers in good standing. You know, how many farmers might participate, we don't know, right? If it's within the existing footprint, you know, this is a gamble of opportunity, but we're in a state of limited opportunities. We are looking at a hemp market that's far surpassed the national cannabis market. The state cannabis market has pretty much failed and is particularly failing the small and existing farmers, patients, small manufacturers, and supporting a state marketplace that's fostering consolidation, which has a proportionally negative impact on our cultivators, on our products. Hemp isn't what our county is known for, but we are known for producing high-quality craft, full-spectrum products, right? And that's what Under the Sun, so being able to cultivate...


12:34 p.m.

Full-spectrum hemp gives us opportunities to enter into interstate medical markets, do marketing for our space when we can actually export cannabis, THC-rich cannabis, across state lines. We're trying to maintain relevance, also trying to create opportunities. Being a federally legal crop, there's opportunities as a small farmer growing weed. I can't access the small business resource development because that's federally legal. If I was growing hemp, I could do that. Thanks. Thank you. We're going to move to online comments. We have a few, and I like the conciseness of everybody so far, so if we can keep on that mode, that would be great. Thank you, Chair. Caller 0493, I will unmute you, and you'll have three minutes. Thank you.


12:35 p.m.

Thank you. Good afternoon. Can you hear me? Yes. Hi, this is Nathan Woodington. Sorry I couldn't be there in person today, but I do have a couple of brief comments. First, on the monofilament netting, to help understand and frame the scope of where this came from, the entanglement with wildlife issue is mostly around bile swells that we use to mitigate runoff, and most of those are wrapped in a very small monofilament netting, and that's where these concerns really started. Now, the cannabis industry, we routinely now use biodegradable wrapped bile swells. You don't have that buildup of netting at the edges of your property. On the second issue around hemp, the discussions and work we've been doing with the proposal for a pilot program, I think it's a good idea to have a pilot program. I think it's a good idea to have a pilot program. The first issue is really about .


12:36 p.m.

opportunity and the ability to start looking at this from a federally legal standpoint. And this does create opportunities to engage more with studies, resources, and especially looking at the changes to potentially Schedule 3 and what those provide. I do think that the narrow scope of candidates who are currently permitted into outstanding, this does create potential value add. I can start marketing my small farm just period as a farm and also would have the opportunity to study the concept. The idea here is not to open this up and to create a whole new industry. It's really a narrow, limited scope, maybe two-year pilot program so we can look at the metrics. Based on our engagement with different actors who would potentially be viable, we're seeing less than 10. Living in Thus


12:37 p.m.

I do see opportunity here as far as breeding and genetics go in relation to Humboldt's legacy value and retaining that and reinforcing that and I would like to find some kind of path forward with a narrow scope while addressing the concerns raised by the agricultural Commissioner and the Sheriff's Department. Thank you for your time. Thank you caller 0746 I will unmute you and you'll have three minutes. Hey, how's it going everybody? I'm Indy Riggs, a local cannabis farmer. I own Galactic Farms and I also sit on the board for the Humboldt County Growers Alliance. First off, Happy New Year everybody. I've been listening all day and it looks like you guys got a lot on your plate and I definitely...


12:38 p.m.

I want to acknowledge that. I'll keep my comments short and really want to voice my support and the comments made by Ross Gordon in the letter he submitted on behalf of our organization, HCGA. And really just want to address the hemp issue and point out and reiterate some things that have already been said. This is really for us about providing economic opportunity for our farmers and for the county itself. I think we all, you know, are seeing our pocketbook serving as individuals and as the county as a whole. This is one way that we can participate in what is federally legal through the 2018 Farm Bill. Although it is being amended. We're not going to be able to do that. We will see those amendments take effect here November of 2026. And we believe that it would be.


12:39 p.m.

prudent for us to be in a position to take advantage of those amendments and this opportunity. Cannabis is federally illegal. Hemp is federally legal. That being said, we are provided much greater opportunity through programs, through the U.S. Department of Agriculture, grants, small business development, the ability to do banking, and a number of things. Also, through the California Department of Food and Agriculture. All those things are not available for cannabis farmers. So there's a lot of advantages in hemp. And again, we are not looking to do this to exploit any loopholes, which are being closed here come November. This is simply for CBD and the ability to participate in something that is nationally, nationally available to so many people.


12:40 p.m.

the others like the state of Kentucky which is really taking advantage of this and again we've mitigated many of the concerns if not all of the concerns addressed by the Department of County Department of Agriculture and Sheriff Hounsell by crafting a plan for a small pilot program this is not something I personally would be participating in because I'm too small and I just don't have room for that sort of activity but I see the economic opportunity that could be provided through a responsible pilot program and yeah there's there's a great future in it and that's why we we can just test the water so I just ask you guys do not close the door on this let's keep the conversation going I apologize you've ran out of time caller three zero five three I will unmute you and you'll have three minutes


12:41 p.m.

good afternoon i just want to confirm you can hear me there in the chambers yes thank you my name is thomas molder uh speaking this is actually the main reason i followed you guys today um i support the monofilament netting allowance um it's quite interesting two projects one right next to the other one is actually in compliance with monofilament netting and the other one gets a violation because it's using monofilament netting in the exact same way as the project right next to it um the indoor use i i would really really you know maybe i'm biased because i'm on tbg property but being as i have a category 4 road all the way to my place i got an ada parking spot even ada bathroom they can get out and you know have less than 200 feet path to travel to use that restroom it's ppz it's where i grew up


12:42 p.m.

Why am I discriminated against? Why couldn't I have the ability to do indoor cultivation with the energy standards that you have about? Just food for thought. I mean, obviously not asking to do it off of a generator, but it would be something you got to think about. Why should someone be discriminated against? Because they're growing up somewhere in a certain region, and I just happen to live one mile away from where I lived as a kid when I was born. So just food for thought when you're developing this policy. I don't know what the environmental impact would be just because it says TBG versus ag. You know, that's just something I feel is really discriminatory. Same thing impacted watershed. I mean, you guys are so far under the cap. The greatest thing you ever did was regulate cannabis because it just completely obliterated everything and almost completely obliterated the economy. So, I mean, if you think about it, you might want to be open up for business. Maybe even


12:43 p.m.

Let new conversions happen to allow so you can still do that for grapes. And I was confused, though, the last little bit, because I thought I heard the supervisor saying they used it for a plant. So I was confused. Maybe it was a cannabis plant, maybe it was a rose plant, but I took it as a cannabis plant. So maybe one day sit down and smoke a joint together. All right. Thank you for the opportunity to speak. Thank you. Thank you. Caller 7718, I will unmute you and you'll have three minutes. Interesting times. We didn't have 40 speakers in the room and probably 20 online. I noticed in the description staff report the area of focus was this diverse, equitable, and robust economy. Strategy plan category promotes strong economic resiliency and growth. I think...


12:44 p.m.

way past that one i don't have any problem with you having people if they want to expand an impacted watershed of course use uh you use rain catchment strictly for that that should minimize the impact there uh the netting stuff you know it's always going to be a problem it's a it's something that has to be disposed of uh it's not biodegradable uh it's just one of those things even for vineyards i tried that once and it was a total disaster and a mess um so i i'm so happy to hear that yep it no longer it's been bred to the point where no longer cross pollinates because you weren't willing to have hemp before because it cross pollinates but i guess that's no longer a problem i guess maybe mother nature changed that one um the changes you're making here you know as far as allowing indoor and things of that nature you i guess but


12:45 p.m.

The greed that's happened around the nation and everything on this has basically put this thing as headed toward a thing of the past in Humboldt County. For the few, I guess, I have no problem giving a few confessions to the people who wish to try to continue to survive on it. Best of luck to them. They're going to need it. So anyway, I guess that's my input on this ever-shrinking... And hopefully our time will be ever-shrinking as far as we spend on this topic in the future. Thank you. I appreciate your speak. Thank you. Caller 9402, I will unmute you and you'll have three minutes. Yeah, hi, thanks for the opportunity to speak. My name is Jesse Hill, a legal, small-scale...


12:46 p.m.

cannabis farmer in southern Humboldt and mostly I'd like to comment on the um on the issue of allow but I feel like the other um monofilament indoor and potential for impacted watershed uh everyone has been supportive and I would just echo those sentiments. I also want to encourage the continued conversation towards allowing for hemp cultivation in Humboldt County. Times have changed a lot as has been stated by several of the commenters and Director Ford since the 2019 hemp moratorium. Now we're looking at cannabis through a different lens and basically any opportunity allowed towards small responsible permitted cannabis farmers should be encouraged and so I want to really encourage the board of supervisors as well as everyone else.


12:47 p.m.

concerned to take a good, careful read of the letter drafted by Humboldt County Growers Alliance. I had a chance to read it, and I believe it explains in really good detail why such an opportunity could potentially benefit Humboldt County farmers and not be detrimental to communities, the environment, and mitigate the reality that, yes, this program would require administrative effort and poses some, you know, work by the agencies, including law enforcement. But everyone interested in this program, from what I hear, is highly willing to, make it as easy as possible, even go above and beyond in order to get a chance to open a door, create an opportunity.


12:48 p.m.

And as we all know, you know, Humboldt, the name Humboldt County was made famous long before legalization for cannabis, world famous. And so at this stage of the game, it's time to just be open minded and encouraging to any project, any opportunities and any proposals put forward by the really well educated, well spoken, articulate cannabis community that you've heard from already today. So thanks so much for hearing my comments. Thank you. That's all on Zoom chair. Great. We're going to bring it back to staff for a minute. I just want to say we're going to try and move through this as quickly as possible. We have a time set that was supposed to start 48 minutes ago. And so and we have an attorney that's online that's going to be waiting for us. So we don't have anything we need to say. OK, so I'm going to bring it back to the board. We have a recommendation from staff. We have some folks that have put out some ideas.


12:49 p.m.

and those sorts of things and have, it seems to me, the biggest conflict that we see right now in terms of what we've heard from the public and what was recommended by staff has to do with the HEMP pilot project proposal. I just want to comment myself. I feel like, just from my perspective, I'm willing to go with staff's recommendation on this. Currently, only to hold off to see what's coming from the federal government in terms of the changes after this administration's recommendations on cannabis moving forward. I feel like I don't want to, I just want to be cautious about that in that what we're concerned about isn't necessarily the impacts of HEMP per se. It's just that we are still... statutorily required to do certain...


12:50 p.m.

administrative and enforcement items around this if we move forward with that. So it's not something that we necessarily have a great desire to want to do, to administer to the level that's required of us to do, but that's what would happen. And so I want to be cognizant of that in how we move forward. The other item that I think was not in the staff report was a consideration of the discussion in terms of bringing back some reporting about the idea of expanding allowances for cultivation in impacted watersheds. I'm willing to have that conversation. I'm willing to allow you guys to do that, and we could put that into motion, I think. I mean, it depends on what the rest of the board is. And the overarching thing here today is these are just recommendations to staff on bringing back these items to us. Thank you.


12:51 p.m.

Again, so we're not actually making a decision to do something on monofilament other than to ask staff to bring something back to address it. Likewise, on the indoor stuff and the other two items as well. So, Supervisor Bush, I know you're probably anxious to want to make a motion here. So I'm going to let you do that and then we'll see where we go from there. Thank you. I would make a motion for staff's recommendations and additionally adding investigations into the impacted watersheds to allow, not investigations aren't the right word, but monitoring. What would be the right word? Could I offer that we will investigate the ability to reopen the watersheds? And if not, we will bring a report back. And if so, we will bring back a modification to the resolution. Kayleigh, did you? Did you get that? I did. Okay. So that would be my motion. Great. I'm happy to second that for the purposes of.


12:52 p.m.

Any more discussion that we see here today? And if there isn't any, then I'm going to go to Supervisor Arroyo. Thank you. I think everything that I am concerned about has been emphasized, but especially appropriate disposal of model filament. I get that people are going to be responsible about waste disposal, or they're not. The other recommendations, I concur with Supervisor Wilson about seeing what federal policies change. I also hear the request to get the ball rolling by having a pilot program, but reading the staff report and hearing from our Ag Commissioner, it sounds like right now that's something that we're not resourced for, but it has some promising potential. So, John, if circumstances change on the federal level, and it seems much more... promising to explore, that's something we can...


12:53 p.m.

revisit, right? Absolutely. This is not a no for all time. In fact, I hear the board pretty clearly saying that you would like to hear back once the federal government takes action, and we can certainly do that. I know that wasn't part of the motion, but it could be, or we could just do it. Okay. I think let's follow up if and when that happens. It does seem like it's created a political schism, but we'll see what happens with that. Okay. We have a motion and a second. Supervisor Bone has something to say. Well, I think the biggest issue on the federal level is banking. The biggest problem we have is the finances. Nobody's ripping off marijuana. They're ripping off cash. I'd like to make sure that staff works with the HCGA. I think it's really great to have input from the people that it asks.


12:54 p.m.

actually affects. We can make up here and make all the rules we want, but it doesn't affect us. But anything, and my concerns are so limited lately on this because 10 years ago we had 15,000 grows. Now we don't even have 1,500, both legal and illegal. So I think that's something that we always need to be aware of, or the estimate of the sheriff and stuff. So we have 10% of what we had. So when you talk about impacted anything, roads, watersheds, and everything else, you don't see it. And you can tell that by going a little bit outside your comfort zone and going out in the country and look at the businesses that are closing in Southern Humboldt, grocery stores, and everything else. So I just, as long as we work with all the parties involved, and especially the ones that are most affected, I can support this. But the hemp, right now there's no hemp market to speak of. And we've kind of cut down on that. The CBD influenced hemp.


12:55 p.m.

As we move forward, I think it's something we can readdress. All right. Supervisor Bushnell, close us out. Thank you. And I know we're pressed for time, but Director Ford, you won't be surprised to hear me say that there's been some issues with ranchers on public and state and federal lands with Humboldt County is a no open range property. And I know that Waylon is going to know what I'm talking about as well. So folks lease those properties to run their cattle. There are cultivation sites that have been directly adjacent. They're not allowed to fence those cultivation sites. And so I want us to continue, if we can, trying to find a solution to those issues. The board. So there's public and state lands that ranchers lease and run their cows on. And because they're not the ranchers. Ranchers are not allowed to fence those lands.


12:56 p.m.

cultivation sites the cows have gotten into those cultivation sites there's lawsuits that are going on it's been an issue throughout Humboldt it's a large issue and we're not required farmers are not required to fence their cultivation sites I don't think that is a solution because it will be expensive however the ranchers are not allowed to fence public and state lands either and so what they've had to do is fence out those cultivation sites at their own cost I've been talking with the AG Department and direct report about this to find a solution that doesn't harm both financially so I just want to keep that on the radar and hopefully we can try to find a solution Mendocino has also been dealing with this issue and just putting it out there interesting subject all right I think we have a motion in a second is there any objection to unanimous consent seeing none we are gonna be moving into closed session please read us in the question closed session


12:57 p.m.

Thank you to staff. Council. Thank you Chair Wilson. It is the intention of the board to meet in closed session pursuant to California Government Code sections 54954.5 and 54957 in order to consider the public employee performance evaluations for the positions of the Department of Health and Human Services Director and the Public Works Director. It is also the intention of the board to meet in closed session pursuant to California Government Code section 54956.9 in order to discuss existing litigation in the case of S.N. et al. versus State of California et al. Humboldt County Superior Court case number CV2401970. Thank you. I want to acknowledge this board has not taken a break since 9 a.m. so soldiers I'll all of you.


12:58 p.m.

Do we have a comment from the public on this item? We do not. Okay. Seeing none, we are going to move into closed session. We have an item with an outside attorney. And what I'm saying is that's going to be a very short item, and then we're going to take a lunch break, and we'll do it then. Okay? If that's all right. And if you need to run to the, you know, do your bio on the way there, please do. Yes. Yes. Say it, Mike. Thank you.


3:54 p.m.

Thank you. Thank you. There's three of us here. We're going to close this meeting out so that we can report out. Okay, go for it. There is no reportable action taken with regard to items G2 through G4.


3:55 p.m.

Okay, we have closed. Thank you.