Thank you. Here we are, starting the meeting. Welcome to the Board of Supervisors, Humboldt County. This is Tuesday, February 3rd, 2026, and we're going to do a roll call here. Thank you, Chair, Supervisor Arroyo. Here. Supervisor Madrone. Here. Supervisor Bone. Here. Supervisor Bushnell. Good morning. Chair Wilson. I am present. All are here. All right. Great. And if we're going to do the...
Salute to the flag. We're going to have Supervisor Bone lead us in the charge. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. This is the part where I ask if there's any modifications to this overwhelming agenda. Thank you, Chair Wilson. There's no modifications today. Moving on, we're going to go straight into the consent calendar. A couple of items here that maybe a supervisor or two want to talk about, but the first thing I have on here is the Greater Euclid Chamber of Commerce Award Recognition Certificates brought to us by Supervisor Arroyo. Thank you, Chair Wilson. These certificates were presented already, so we're ratifying this today.
and the Eureka Chamber Gala was this last Friday, and I know that a couple of us got a chance to attend. It's a really nice opportunity for the chamber nominates and then votes on the recipients themselves. So these are not accolades that we selected, but ones that we're lifting up on behalf of the Eureka business community. And I will admit I'm stalling a little bit while they load. One second. All right. So I do just want to say who they were. It was very exciting. There were a couple of big surprises in the mix, which was really fun. People did not know that they were going to receive these awards. So small business of the year was Ashley's Seafood. Large business of the year was Advanced Security. Positive Community Impact Award was Eureka Books. Positive Community Impact Award for Nonprofit or Government was Food for People. These dealsы did not stop more than half a billion dollars because the largest Intell contenido de ouvertura del mundo Greater Bermudez of the black community, forcesommen menos los colores a misgiv王 Anybody got to know this friend me or a child. I'm curious.
Hospitality and Customer Service Award was Casaro's Catering. Extraordinary Business of the Year was North Coast Co-op. Business Leadership Award went to Dale Maples of Maples Service and Plumbing. And the Chamber Ambassador of the Year was Sophia Santana-White. So congratulations to all the recipients. Great. It was a fun event. I really had a great time. It's definitely different than it was 20 years ago. And I'd say in a positive way. So the next one is the Proclamation Recognizing Children's Dental Health Awareness Month. And this is again brought to us by Supervisor Arroyo. Thank you. So good to see you. Good to see you. We're here again. Yay. Yeah, so important. All right. This is the Proclamation and Recognition of National Children's Dental Health Awareness Month. Whereas February is National Children's Dental Health Month, which is a time to acknowledge and support efforts to improve the oral health, social care, healthcare, and health for dear and mother. Again, I am happy to go with everyone, this year and our state is extremely grateful and grateful to the broader community that we have gathered here with us. So thank you for joining us and we look forward to the next generation where we can luxurious podcasts that you'll enjoy. We're really happy to support you forever. Thank you,, everyone for joining us. And we will see you all soon in our next episode. Take care. Just do that. Peace out. Bye bye. Bye bye. Peace out. Bye bye.
our youngest and most vulnerable population in Humboldt County, and whereas tooth decay is the most common disease found in children and is completely preventable through twice daily brushing with fluoridated toothpaste, daily flossing, and twice a year dental checkups, and whereas parents and caregivers can help reduce the odds of dental disease by reducing access to sugary food and drinks and by not sharing utensils, cups, and toothbrushes, which can spread cavity-causing bacteria, and whereas one in four children in Humboldt County will start kindergarten with untreated dental decay and fewer than 50 percent of children ages five and under with Medi-Cal will visit a dentist in the next year, and whereas the Humboldt County Department of Health and Human Services Public Health Branch acknowledges the efforts made by local dentists and OB providers in prioritizing dental care during pregnancy, which has resulted in a higher percent of patients attending a dental visit during pregnancy in Humboldt County than the average statewide. That's exciting. And whereas... There is Humboldt Health.
Excuse me, Public Health commends the health professionals who provide dental education, treatment, and care coordination while simultaneously acknowledging the dental workforce shortage that has created limited dental access for many residents in our county. And whereas Humboldt County supports systems changes that create better access to preventative interventions such as fluoride varnish, dental sealants, and fluoridated water within Humboldt. Excuse me. A brief intermission. Now, therefore, let it be resolved that the Humboldt County Board of Supervisors hereby calls on residents of Humboldt County to work together to address oral health disparities beginning with our most vulnerable populations, including children, pregnant individuals, historically marginalized communities of color, and immigrant families. Thank you so much. I'm Sarah Vogel, Oral Health Program Coordinator. Thank you for taking the time to acknowledge this important issue. I know you have a full agenda. We've shared a lot of information through the proclamation. Thank you so much. All right.
Nice to see you. 3, 2, 1. 3, 2, 1. Thank you so much. I didn't get to brush my teeth for breakfast. I was thinking about it the whole time. It happens. You have the whole day. All right. Do we have any comments from the board on either one of these consent calendar items? I have one more that I've been asked to bring up, and this is just asking. It's about the resolution to auction tax defaulted properties. Requires a four-fifths vote.
And is there any comments on that item before I entertain a motion? There's a resolution to auction tax defaulted properties. Yes. It was advised to me to bring that up, so I did it. All right. Let's see. Is there any comment on line? Yes. All right. Caller 7718, I will unmute you, and you will have three minutes. Good morning, Ken Sawatsky calling from Mexico. I see the crowd in the room is kind of sparked today. We do have a very quick agenda going here. You know, it's something I did wish to make comment on, on the dental cost that the US government or everybody, I mean everybody in the United States has to pay. I come down here and it's very common in Mexico
We need to adapt a third world country solution to dentistry and our other medical profession services that we need to live on back home there. I think it's probably 10 cents on the dollar down here instead of taking six weeks to get an appointment. Frequently I can have that within three days. Top quality dentists take care of our needs down here. I do not understand why we can't get the same kind of services back in the United States. Something is seriously wrong with this. It's so important that teeth are taken care of from a young age especially, but it's so expensive. Very few people can afford to really do it in a regular, good, preventive basis. I did wish to make comment on that. I also did wish to make comment on the public defender's office. The public defender's office has a grant that they're receiving. It's for, I believe, one investigator.
When social worker and the total grant for this, of course, only this year is $143,365. The total amount you're receiving for the three-year time period is $748,000 and change. And my question was, you know, a lot of the DA's positions were frozen, and yet the public defender benefited from that. The question was, well, maybe now it's time for them to benefit. And I can understand a potential conflict of interest, as mentioned by your staff, regarding the one position as a investigator, but I can't see it as far as a social worker. A social worker could be able to be beneficial for both departments. Hopefully in the future, the public defender's office will repay the benefits they received when the positions were frozen by the district attorney's office. So thank you for my opportunity to speak on these particular consent items today. Thank you. That's all on Zoom, Chair. Great. Is there anyone in the room that wants to speak on consent items?
Seeing none, I'll entertain a motion. I'll make a motion to approve the consent calendar. I'll second. Great. Is there any objection to unanimous consent? Seeing none, we're moving on to public comment on non-agenda items. You have three minutes, and we'll start with online. Chair, my screen is frozen. We are going to take a break. Well, no, we're going to. Huh? Is that the only thing that's not working? Are you on, Mr. Black? Then I think we'll just go to the room and this is how it goes. If we can't get, can we get on Zoom or no? Okay. Okay. Well, as it says in all our packets and everything else.
If Zoom breaks down, that's just how it goes. And do I have that right? All right. For those on Zoom, I apologize, but we have a frozen screen, so we're just going to go to comments in the room. Good morning. My name is Joanne McGarry, and the sun rose, so I still froze, but I rode my e-bike across the Hamble Bay Trail this morning to get here, and I know it's a short agenda, and I just want to speak up about a few things. Again, we're celebrating, apparently, the 250th year of the United States of America, and it's kind of interesting. I haven't seen a lot of information about what's being planned nationally or internationally. or locally or whatever, but that comes to...
The idea of the 4th of July and fireworks, and I really do hope that you will consider some sort of policy about that one way or the other, just so it's something that people are talking about casually in my circles of the community. So I just really think we really need to have an understanding of why we want to keep it or why we want to phase out of it or stop it completely. So that's one issue. As I was riding my bicycle across the bay, beautiful day, beautiful morning. I wasn't with a lot of people this morning, but the cold temperatures probably necessitated a lot of people choosing a different way to get there. But. I was thinking about earthquakes and tsunamis and sea level rise as I was riding across, and I do carry my go bag.
with me on many occasions. But the one thing I was concerned about is if there was something while I was on the Bay Trail, how would I get to higher ground midway through that trail where there's fencing and all sorts of things. So it was sort of an interesting thought I had as I was writing, what's my escape route on the Bay Trail if I'm right in the middle there? And need to get to higher ground. So that's that. When I arrived here at the courthouse, I sort of asked if I could bring my bike in to charge it because it does need some charging before I can take it back. And I'll have to figure that out. So a future concept of how we can support e-bike riders to get what they need to ride their bikes instead of driving a car or whatever, that would be something interesting, including...
Safer parking. I'm parked down on 4th Street. Another bike was parked there. There wasn't a lot of room for me to park safely onto the actual bike rack, so I'm just, you know, right next to it. And again, it's not ideal. And there's the bike cage on 5th Street, but with the climate action plan and getting everybody to move differently, oh, I'm sorry, you know, doing something for bike bicyclists, okay? Thank you. Climate action plan. Thank you. How are we online? Are we back online yet? Zoom is working. I don't have access to Live Manager. Okay. I'll just, just for informational sake, I'm going to read part of our instructions here. So please note this meeting is being conducted in accordance with Assembly Bill 707, which I might add, doesn't actually take effect until July 1st. So we are
Bill in compliance with this bill, meaning that everything we're doing doesn't have to be in effect until July 1st. But those not able to attend the Board of Supervisors meeting in person will have the opportunity to provide public comment via Zoom. The County of Humboldt will comply with Assembly Bill 707 in the event that technological problems are encountered with Zoom, which may involve a recess where a good faith effort will be made to remedy any technical issues. However, the Humboldt County cannot guarantee that the Zoom system will be available for the entirety of every meeting. The only way... Excuse me. The only way is to guarantee that your comment is received and considered by the Board...
Supervisors is to attend the meeting in person or submit comment in written, excuse me, in writing in advance of the meeting. And I might add that you can also call us as well in advance of the meeting. So seeing that we don't, are you hooked up now? I can take them. All right. I have stalled long enough. And we can take the online comment. Thank you, Chair. Caller 7718, I will unmute you and you'll have three minutes. Thank you. I appreciate you taking the time and having the people in the room speak first. Again, I would, I would, last meeting it was brought to your attention it might be better to have the room in first, otherwise the time I had to hit star 9 was just about non-existent for today and I'm pretty good at that stuff. So I recommend maybe you, at the discretion of the chair, make that particular policy change in the room first as was requested by Joanna.
We support many of the things she speaks on there. Fireworks down here for New Year's was next to nothing, and it was within probably a 15-minute time period right at New Year's. We're back home. We had people shooting off stuff from what I heard days in advance and after, and we're actually still having some people harass other people with fireworks as of last night. So that's something that hopefully we can change. I did wish to make comments. I'm having some angst. I'm dealing with the Great Redwood Trail Agency, and apparently Mikey McGuire, when I've had magically passed a bill or some kind of thing, but they don't have to go through the normal sequel process. So one of the largest projects we're going to have in Humboldt County with the most potential negative effects on the environment that appears to be exempt and won't happen. No EIR would be required.
I hope House of Honor Mikey Maguire gets the message that maybe the environment, if he wants to claim to have anything to do with the environment, he will go ahead and request that the DRTA actually does a full CEQA environmental effect and does an EIR regarding the trail. So, yes, sir, because it's not motorized, but they're going to use motorized vehicles in the process. So, that's one of my things I'll be dealing with. And I guess there's going to be a court ruling maybe today on Prop 50, and we'll see what happens with that. Thank you for my opportunity to speak on non-concept items today. All right. Thank you. We're going to move on to, it looks like we're just going straight to departmental reports. And I think we have someone from the sheriff's office to give us a report. A drought resilience plan and SB 552 compliance. Anyone? Because yours is your big chance.
Don't wait. Patrick Esch, I'm the hazard mitigation program coordinator for the Office of Emergency Services. Mario, you want to introduce yourself? Good morning, folks. Mario Kelson, Director of Environmental Health. So first I'm going to be talking about the provide a drought report, and then Mario will continue with the presentation. Based on current federal and state monitoring data, Humboldt County is not experiencing drought conditions at this time. According to the U.S. Drought Monitor and the National Integrated Drought Information System, 100% of Humboldt County is classified as no drought. No recorded impacts to population.
cultural ecosystems. Recent precipitation has been above historical averages, contributing to improved soil moisture, stream flow, and overall hydrological stability. State water supply indicators further support this assessment. Daily reserve storage data from the California Data Exchange Center show that major California reservoirs are generally at or above their long-term historical averages for this time of year. While some reservoirs show low percentages of total capacity due to operational flood control constraints, overall storage levels indicate strong statewide water supply conditions and an adequate buffer against near-term drought risks. However, California snowpack conditions introduce an important forward-looking concern. Snowpacks function as a natural reservoir that supplies spring and summer runoff. Although snowpacks do not directly affect the water supply, they are important for the water supply of California. Most of Humboldt County's current statewide snowpack levels are below long-term average of the
for this point in the water year, despite recent storms and improved reservoir storage. Below average snowpacks may reduce spring and summer runoff if dry conditions persist, potentially limiting reservoir inflows later in the year, even when current storage conditions appear favorable. So what does this mean for Humboldt County? Nothing directly, as we primarily rely on local surface water systems, small water systems, and domestic wells rather than large state reservoirs or Sierra Nevada snow melt. However, statewide hydrological conditions, which include snowpack, remain a critical contextual indicator for regional water security and drought resiliency planning. Current conditions reflect recovery from recent drought cycles, but snowpack trends underscore the limits of that recovery, increase pressures on local systems, fire risk, and drought preparation. Furthermore, the absence of current drought conditions, does not eliminate drought risk. California's climate is highly variable.
and historical patterns show that severe droughts often follow wet or average years with literal warning. Variable conditions can mask underlying vulnerabilities, particularly for rural areas and communities served by small water systems and domestic wells, which are often the first experience impacts when conditions shift. Planning during non-drought periods is both more cost-effective and operationally practical. It allows the county to strengthen monitoring, improve coordination, address infrastructure and data gaps, and implement mitigation actions without the pressure and expense of emergency response. Proactive planning also positions Humboldt County to meet state requirements, remain eligible for funding opportunities, and respond more quickly if drought conditions reemerge. Thank you. Thanks, Patrick. I'm going to introduce myself. I'm Mario Kallsen, Director of Environmental Health. A division under the...
Public Health Branch and co-chair of the Drought Steering Committee with Patrick Esch and it's been a collaboration between us and staff of the OES Planning and Building and Environmental Health and other collaborators to that make up the Drought Task Force to get this work done. Also here with us and I want to confirm that she was able to join online is Bridget Lowry of Stantec. Stantec, let's make sure that this is working. Can we show the slides? Yeah, so Stantec is a contracted consultant with Department of Water Resources and Bridget Lowry was working with us to write the plan so I want to be sure that she's online and able to answer questions. If specific questions come up regarding some of the analysis.
Do we see her online? Can you hear me? We can. Thank you. Fabulous. Thank you. So today I'm going to talk and present a summary of the plan in completion of requirements for counties that stand mandated by Senate Bill 552. I'm going to change the slide up here too. So passed in 2021, the state legislature required a number of resiliencies focused resilience focused mandates for a variety of jurisdictions and agencies and including counties and for counties. The mandate was to establish a standing drought and water shortage task force to facilitate preparedness for state small water systems and domestic wells within. The county's jurisdiction and to develop a county drought resilience plan.
That includes potential drought and water shortage risks and proposed interim and long-term solutions. So your board, having established the local drought task force in May of 2021, had already completed the requirement when the bill was passed in September of 2021, which is good news and shows we're looking forward and anticipating these problems. The bill provides some flexibility in the organization of the plan and mandates certain concerns are addressed. And we're not going to read this whole slide, but focusing on items one through five, there are specific, those are the mandates. And thankfully, the state provided assistance through the Department of Water Resources for either direct funding or technical assistance. And staff, with support of the CAO, applied for direct assistance on behalf of the county and connected with staff.
consulting to organize the strategy and draft our plan. Senate Bill 552 requires county plans focus on domestic wells and state small water systems, which are water systems with 5 to 14 service connections in recognition of the variability of impacts for those systems during droughts and water shortage situations. Our plan satisfies the requirement, identifies resources necessary for implementation, and provides a template for future expansion to increase our resilience planning for drought and water shortage events. As the Drought Task Force has provided an update on this plan in October of 2025 to your board, I'm not going to unpack the entire plan, but briefly review the risk assessment process and results.
results, describe mitigation strategies, and touch on implementation considerations. So the risk assessment involved evaluating the physical vulnerability through a tool developed by Department of Water Resources called the Water Shortage Vulnerability Explorer tool. The data comes from a variety of sources. Department of Water Resources incorporated data from the State Water Board, U.S. Forest Service, CAL FIRE, universities like Berkeley and Oregon State to evaluate counties across the state, and Stantec was able to access that data locally and with the reflection by staff, customize it for Humboldt use.
After physical vulnerability, considering physical vulnerability, we also evaluated the density of state small water systems and domestic wells. And then went to social vulnerability. So combining physical vulnerability, the density of water wells, and then overlaying social vulnerabilities using methodologies used by CDC with indicators like social and economic status, language and education, housing and transportation, and demographics. We were able to develop a social vulnerability. And the data is... The data is primarily sourced upon census data from 2020. Some of the major drivers for the
Physical vulnerability, our wildfire risk with variability reflected across the county, more intense along the eastern border of the county and less intense along the coast. Our geology is a factor that drives much of our physical vulnerability. The yellow portion in this slide indicates alluvial unconfined aquifers with more reliable water sources as compared to the darker purple, which is fractured rock and that dominates most of our county and has variable capacity to provide groundwater. And that adds vulnerability to those reliant upon these sources. Along the coast, sea level rise and saltwater intrusion can impact the depth. And quality of groundwater and threatened water supplies for folks relying on.
on water wells. We're not going to unpack all of the physical vulnerabilities, but this is a summary of what the results were from that evaluation. And you can see the trends here in this slide echo the fractured rock areas. The darker colors are showing higher vulnerabilities compared to the lighter yellow, so saying that there are some regions in the yellow areas that staff believes maybe the tool has kind of missed some of the nuance. And from our experience in talking with local industry and just permitting wells, we see some other vulnerabilities that may not be captured by the state tool. Cigarizer Bone has a question. So,
Looking at all the colors and then you say the state, which is imposing this on us, their data is inaccurate? I think we have unique experience as the permitting agency for water wells. I'm aware. And some of the data that's represented in this tool didn't highlight some vulnerabilities that we think are important. For example, West Haven in Trinidad has a lot of shallow wells and some families there struggle with supply and marginally productive wells. And that's not reflected in the state tool. Those are extremely shallow wells, though, right? According to the well drillers. Right. So anything less than 20 feet, the minimum seal size is 20 feet. So when we don't have... Groundwater below 20 feet, that's...
minimum seal to the surface, we can't meet that. So then we're having to explore what are the alternatives to that. Families still need water. We've got to come up with those scenarios. But those kind of nuances are not captured in the STEEK tool, I think. And maybe it's an opportunity for expansion on their part. And reflection on ours. Thank you. Yep. So this slide is showing the density of domestic wells and state smalls. The blue dots, very few. I think there are 16 state smalls. And the orange dots are domestic wells. This is data from the Department of Water Resources. So every one of the orange dots, there is a representative. We have a well completion report. And we can see the importance of.
water wells across the county and see areas of higher density which may heighten vulnerabilities So this is the combining of the physical vulnerability with the density. And we're starting to see, again, regional trends, the darker colors. Dark orange is showing high domestic well counts. Dark blue are higher vulnerabilities. And overlaying those in brown and darker brown, we'll see the areas of more intense vulnerabilities. And, of course, we've got to factor in the social vulnerabilities. And it's variable across the county. It's important to remember that the areas with high social vulnerability may be less.
able to respond effectively to water shortage events. And understanding what's driving the vulnerability in these areas can help create customized strategies to support communities of need. A lot of the drivers for this are high rates of poverty, higher rates of unemployment. There are a substantial number of seniors living and people with disabilities in some of these areas, and that needs to be considered. Also, households without access to a vehicle, specifically in rural communities, can make transportation and access to services extremely difficult. So the results of the assessment highlighted different communities.
That really need focus, especially in water shortage events. They're reflected here. It's important to note that the drought resilience plan is not focusing on the Eel River Valley, although it does show some vulnerability. But in that region, the groundwater sustainability plan is the local tool and the state-mandated tool to organize and manage water resources in that area. So resilience requires consideration of vulnerability, as we've discussed, and also planning to address those concerns. So mitigation strategies are divided into response actions implemented when water shortage criteria thresholds are exceeded, and long-term solutions are needed.
term strategies that increase the resilience within our community. Our plan articulates an emergency response plan to identify when those occurrences of an emergency are happening. We use a three-tier system to rank local intensity and make recommendations to your board for emergency declarations and when staff would be implementing short-term response actions. Referencing monitored resources, state and federal recommendations, and local pre-articulated thresholds, we can rank. The events to organize response actions, including the local emergency as a.
described. So this slide's a little bit busy, but represents the short-term response actions that staff would like to take, has taken, but also needs funding in some situations. Departments have resources and procedures for implementing some of these actions, but like I said, we'll need funding to complete others. A few of these, specifically six and seven, we probably need to amend for this slide because the development phase of agreements needs to happen before we get into an emergency scenario. So this is an amendment that I need to make within the plan such that we're planning for the short-term events events. And we developed.
these agreements before the emergency happens so that we can activate these agreements in the moment and have plans pre-articulated and basically turn key ready to go. Long-term mitigation strategies, again, these are strategies that the steering committee believes will add resilience and increase our ability to respond in emergency events. So we aim to secure funding through state, federal, and or private sources to coordinate with local water providers, community partners to develop emergency supplies for hauling water to communities of need, and in making improvements to our well permitting program. So some of those things, like the well permitting program, we don't need more funding. We have just to identify.
improvements necessary and make those changes. So in doing this, of course, implementation of the plan requires monitoring and connection. One, drought task force members will need to connect and reflect and consider current and forecasted conditions on an annual basis or more frequently. With improvements in technology, data management, relationships, and an intention to make improvements, the plan will evolve. We'll need to continue to pursue exchange of information to learn from local professionals in water management. And emergency preparedness and to share lessons learned and best practices with owners and operators of state small and domestic wells.
Thank you. So we learn from our outreach efforts and see benefits to the DRIP when we complete those outreach efforts and hope messaging will improve resilience for our community in water shortage events. This slide, the steering committee has made efforts to engage the public and professionals in the water industry. We've received valuable feedback from from LAFCO staff, managers of local public water systems, local tribes and state agencies and public comment period is still underway. The draft plan is available on the OES website. There's a link at the top of the slide here and we hope that people will provide feedback for making improvements. So in our Mediterranean climate we
know that it's only a matter of time for water shortage pressures to return and the drought resilience plan provides a framework for us to reflect on vulnerabilities and opportunities to improve our resilience and with that happy to take questions or and comments thank you great we're going to start with public comment and then we'll go to uh supervisors is there any public comment online yes thank you chair caller 7718 i will unmute you and you'll have three minutes Of course, one of the most important things in our world is water. We're blessed by it. I understand we have some small drought effects, but right now they're minimized. And the biggest thing that's helping Mother Nature deal with our water situation is we no longer have all the...
evil and illegal straws in all of the smaller watershed creeks where the fish need to survive um the drought will come and go as we know it always has always will i can't see us being affected much more maybe they're going to say our highs and lows will exacerbate what we're looking at right now is the uh the concern being whether our sponge gets replanted sometime by uh by late in the season rains we don't get those then we do have potential problems of course we have two years in ruth lake which could actually be made into three as far as water for municipalities one of our biggest problems is a continuing threat that i feel we will have to endure will be the large water districts wanting to go ahead and take the water from the mad river continue taking the rare water from the eel river and not leaving it in mother nature's place where it belongs please work as hard as you can to keep the water where it falls that's in our best interest and uh the study's nice and all this
We have to do it. It's required. I don't know. An unfunded mandate, which most of these things are. But I think we're in good shape. Always have felt we have been in good shape. Mother Nature treats us really well in Humboldt County. And thank you, Ma, for you to speak on this drought report. That's all, Chair. Is there any comment in the chambers? This is an issue that I think is important since we aren't apparently in a drought situation. But I was talking to people who were concerned about January's rainfall levels and such. And so preparedness for our community. And hopefully this is all stuff that will be communicated and talked about in the various communities, even in the community. Even if we're not in an urgent situation. I think preparedness.
For the layperson, it's really important to emphasize because we don't want situations to arise where it becomes urgent. So we really need as community to be holistic and, you know, broader reaching on a daily basis about what may be to come and to be prepared. And again, this is just a symbol of how individuals and families and communities, whether they're in very rural areas of our county or downtown Eureka or Arcata, we all need to be much more aware of what's to come in a climate changing world. So I appreciate this presentation, although it was hard to read some of the small print, but keep that communication and outreach going. For people.
like me so that I too can share it with others that water is life and we need to do what we can to have a good system in place so that we're not without water. Great. Thank you for your comments. Do we have any from the supervisors? Supervisor Madrone? Thank you guys for the presentation. Appreciate it. There's a lot of work that goes into these kinds of plans working across many departments and things, so I appreciate that coordination. I have provided information in the past. I still don't see it reflected here in this plan. That concerns me because I've tried hard to offer you guys various more specific input. I want to start out by saying thank you. I appreciate the customized strategy approach because every committee is different, as you pointed out.
You know, geology, fire, there's so many different factors that vary a lot. But you pointed out the Trinidad community several times in regards to shallow wells. Yeah, there are many wells that are like 10 to 15 feet deep because of that perched groundwater table. It sits on clay hard pans, which is also problematic for septic systems, right? So in the community of Trinidad and West Haven, our approach has been to, one, fix the leaks, because Trinidad was actually up at 40% of its water supply was being lost from leaks. They're now down to about 15. They've been doing a very aggressive effort to locate, identify, and replace leaky pipes. And, of course, I think we all heard about the disaster that happened in December where they had a massive line break on scenic drive due to unstable geology, earthquakes, breaking pipes. In the middle of the night. And it's a big deal.
They do have a backup detection system for a very rapid line pressure loss, but there was a comedy of errors that occurred that they didn't get to the plant in time and didn't deal with certain things, so they lost their entire storage, which is quite a few hundred thousand gallons of water, which then required them to pay massive amounts of money out of their water fund to have that water hauled and to refill their storage. Once we implement a program I brought you before called distributed water storage, then that wouldn't be a problem. They wouldn't have to spend all that money to refill their storage. Line breaks are going to happen in this kind of geology, not just in Trinidad area, but it can happen anywhere, frankly. And there are a lot of line breaks that have already happened from earthquakes that we may or may not even know about. They're just part of the loss in the system. So in the West Haven...
Trinidad area, like I said, we fixed leaks, we've added storage to the system, but also the city of Trinidad and West Haven have done an intertie. So when you talk about consolidated systems, there's a scale issue there. So at the smallest scale, two communities next to each other, they've just now in the last month completed an intertie with valves on either end so that if one loses all their water, then the other can back them up, or if a fire is happening, they've got more storage between the two to fight fires, stuff like that. So that's a really great example, I think, of localized or customized strategy of consolidating versus something like bringing a pipeline from the Mad River up to the community for unlimited water supply, but that would also trigger, because of the Senate bill that makes ADUs and other things now ministerial, it could easily lead to a lot of water loss. It could lead to increased growth and urban sprawl. So at LAFCO, which you mentioned, they had provided you some input.
We have these competing directives. One is consolidate systems and the other is avoid urban sprawl and induced growth. And in particular, if that induced growth is going to lead to more septic pollution on these clay hard pans, like I said, you can force a system in with a mound and other things, but you still get groundwater pollution if you don't get that 100-foot separation of soil treatment, things like that. And I know you know this stuff really well, Mario. It's what you do a lot. So in that case, bringing a pipeline might solve one problem, but it actually creates another. So looking at this consolidation of systems has to be done really site-specifically and looking at all of the impacts, pros and cons in all directions. Whereas in the Trinidad-West Haven area and all over the county, once we implement distributed storage, then you've got backup. And what I mean by that is people having a 5,000-gallon. tank in their backyard, it takes up.
10 foot by 10 foot. Even in an urban area, you can have one of these, literally. 10 by 10 is not much room. And a 5,000 gallon tank or less is actually ministerially permitted. It doesn't require any special permits, and it's not subject to the building code, although you want to do it right regardless. And there are grant monies out there to actually apply for by these communities. We're working on that in the Trinidad area to get grants to actually cost share with the landowners to put in these systems, which cost, if you add a little small pump to them, it costs about $10,000 to do a 5,000 gallon tank with a small pump. 5,000 gallons sitting there right at your house when the city of Trinidad lost its entire water supply is 50 days of supply at 100 gallons a day. That's for two people. They say, I think they recommend 50 gallons a day per person in a normal situation. So a lot of the average home size in the Trinidad-West Haven area is like three. Three and a half or something like that.
5,000 gallons, especially if you're being careful with it, could last you two to three months. While the city naturally fills its system from the creek, rather than having to pay to haul all this water, putting your water fund in great debt, right? So distributed storage is a part of the solution, and it's not in there, and it really ought to be in this plan. Because it is one of the solutions that would work in many communities, and like I said, there's grant monies to help people do this, so it doesn't cost 10 grand. It could be two grand or something like that. So I want to make sure we get that into the plan, because I think this kind of distributed storage solves a whole lot of problems, including fire. When you have a fire, you could get a line break from an earthquake. You know, in a disaster like an earthquake, fires happen. And so you could easily lose your supply. Even if you think you've got unlimited water from the Mad River, it's that pipe of water that you're going to have to pay for. If that pipe breaks, you're in a world of hurt. That's why the McKinneyville CSD is actually building a second...
redundant line over the Mad River so that if one line breaks, hopefully the other one doesn't. That's water supply for an entire community. So, you know, having this distributed storage with the three or four inch valves on them, you have a fire, there's water right there, right at the home, you know, that the tender can tap into and provide x number of minutes of supply for fighting that fire. So it has multiple benefits in a lot of directions. So I just want to make sure that we consider those things. And lastly, you know, the Mad River supply may be unlimited water, but it's threatened by a dioxin plume in the Glendale area that was once underneath a concrete cap. But now because the mill went away that was using all that water and lowering the water table is now gone. So that water table has come up and that dioxin plume is moving out from underneath that concrete cap. So that's an issue for the Department of Toxic Substance Control and for our community because 80% of the Humboldt County gets its water from the
Mad River and upstream from there is this dioxin plume that they are monitoring for, but there was a point when this actually got into Hall Mill Creek and into the river, killed fish and all kinds of things, which is when they reacted and put in the concrete slab to try and not have rainwater coming on it and distributing it, but that's not the case anymore. So this is a really big issue. So it may be a lot of water, but it's threatened by a pretty big deal, you know, that is going to take some really serious money to resolve, and I have not seen a plan for that yet. So those are my comments. I appreciate, you know, I'd love to see this distributed storage in particular get into the plan and comments about the customized strategies needing to be the right fit for each community. Thank you for your work on this. I appreciate it. Sure. Before you respond, I'm going to let, you might want to write down your notes. We're going to let the Board of Supervisors. Do their comments, and then we'll get to you guys.
Well, I appreciate, Steve, you've been talking about this distributed water storage concept, you know, when water issues come up. And I am interested to hear, I guess, a question that you can come back to is what barriers exist to that model being enacted now, whether it's just fundering or there's permitting barriers or other, you know, barriers in statute, anything like that. So maybe we can all come back to that in a minute. We'd love to hear, you know, what's standing in the way of that, because it does sound like a good idea for communities that have water security and, you know, quantity issues and are small, you know, small systems or individual households or neighborhoods, but just not understanding why that can't be enacted now. Okay. Before we get into a discussion about distributed water storage, I just want to make sure. Thank you.
Sure. Is there a surprise about? Nope. All right. Let's have a, sounds like that's the crux of your comments. Yeah, and it's funding. To answer your question in one word, it's funding. Okay. That's all. There's no permit barriers. And there seems to be some interest in having that be part of a future discussion within this annual update. I would add that although it's a bit of a tangent, the distributed power is also important to our resilience of our community. And there's a lot of movement in that direction. And we're going to need certain investments and those sorts of things. And I get it's different than this. But frankly, also a lot of these water systems are reliant on power. So distributed power is also something we should be considering. With that, I'll take it. Let staff respond to. Comments from the board. If I could just make one last little quick comment, please. Thank you. Also, there has to be check valves between these distributed storage.
systems and the municipal system so you can't backflow that water into the system but that's a simple plumbing that's always used in these kinds of systems so that's a technical aspect to it check valves right so mario take it away great comments um check valves backflow prevention really important connection and and notice to the csds that are providing water if we're putting storage or water wells within a service district the the service provider needs to know and so that's part of the conversation and treatment is also anytime you're storing water there's a treatment issue and water can degrade over time and so there is a public health issue there and folks should have the awareness about if it's a private water system well there are risks when you store water you're going to have to do a lot of investigation and a lot of clean water maintenance and if you and with potability and controlling pathogenic.
bacteria and other unsavories that can cause illness. And it makes a lot of sense to have resilience with stored water. I did want to highlight in the plan one of the long-term mitigation strategies, number five, is reducing barriers to on-site water storage. It may not read exactly as distributed water storage, but that's the goal. And there's a little bit of jurisdictional confusion about the role of the county, especially when it comes to enter ties and consolidation. We don't have authority to mandate consolidation. I think what our role is to provide a venue for discussion and to provide a way for people to come together and to come together. And I think that's what we're trying to do. And to start asking those questions. How can we...
assemble folks, how can we assemble community and the professionals into one room and to explore how we can provide resilience for each other and explore these topics without a mandate. Because there's a lot of different perspectives. It's not one, it's not, everyone doesn't all agree on the best strategy for providing water across the county or up the coast or into different areas. And so discussion is always part of it. And through this, this is a great example. So all fantastic feedback. And I wanted to say also that today is just really a new beginning. It's the closing of this draft. Yes, we're compliant with 552. And it's the beginning of expansion of this plan. We have a new tool, which is this drought resilience plan. We don't need to, there's no, nothing that says we need to constrain it to.
Smalls and domestic wells. Resilience will mandate. If we want to be prepared, we have to look at expanding this plan and through participation from everyone who has a perspective weighing in. And so we can put that in the record and evaluate it and fund it. And that's really what we struggle with is finding the time in between our mandated programs to make improvements to elective programs. And these are elective, for sure, very important. But when we're trying to also complete other mandates, we struggle with resources. And there's action with respect to that. There's folks getting together, county leaders that are exploring ideas, trying to see where they're going. The overlap is trying to see where we can harmonize funding sources.
to check multiple priorities. But really great feedback, and I think that's food for thought, and we can incorporate those ideas into the plan over time. Yeah, that's it. That's all I have. Thank you. That's super. I suppose you're now? Thank you. Thank you for this work. I have two questions. I want to know, like, where does this report go, and how are you utilizing it with well applications? And then secondly, I also want to know about... Thank you.
And so that's, we won't have the detail about the driver behind why it's gone dry, but only that it has gone dry. Saying that, your other question related to SGMA and the test wells within the Eel River Valley, and that's one of the implementation processes. One of the slides articulates annual evaluation and connection of the drought task force. During that connection, we also need to connect with Hank as the drought coordinator. Thank you. The drought resilience plan, or not the drought resilience plan, but the SGMA dude, for lack of...
nuance here. He's going to have, he's required in his plan to evaluate what is going on seasonally and we connect with him to have another data point to evaluate what is going on regionally. With those 100 plus wells he's going to really have a quantified assessment of what's happening in the Eel River Valley which is a benchmark for what's happening in other regions and not one-to-one and that's another gap that is identified within the drought resilience plan is that we don't have a comprehensive evaluation of capacity in other watersheds and if we're exploring development what capacity does, do those other watersheds have for further development in the headwaters, in the lower reaches? These are part of CEQA requirements and if we were able to do
A comprehensive evaluation, complicated, expensive, and it would help development because then we have one less issue that developers would have to overcome to understand impacts to the watershed. So thank you for that. However, you know, I'm looking through the report and I'm specifically asking about whether the test wells and the monitoring of the SGMA test wells is going to be included. I see, and I've seen, you know, there's reference to here in this report to, you know, groundwater basins and SGMA, but there's not a reference to the data that we already have collected for the last four years. And so... I think it would be, you know, instrumental that we include, and maybe that's something you can talk with Hank about, that we do include some of that information since we have those...
Westwells and the state this is a state requirement for Sigma right and so it seems like it would be pertinent to include some of that stuff that makes a lot of sense yes okay I absolutely agree and I appreciate the thought and an idea again this is a template that needs to evolve over time and improve over time and I understand and I do want to say that you guys are working with a template that's given to you and I understand that but it one thing that happened with the Sigma is that we you know we're rated you know we're half a point below what they needed to not put us in a Sigma you know required area and that we get compared with different areas that are not similar to our climate or not similar to our area and that can be frustrating at times for people and so I think that
Where I would like to go and see this report be very accurate for our area, not just something that we, you know, stamp and send off. And I understand that it needs to be done because of the requirements, but there is data out there that we have that's very accurate. And so if we can kind of include that and make it more specific to our area, I think that's really important for reporting. Okay, Supervisor Boe. And I hope you're listening to Supervisor Bushnell because in 2013, Dr. Nelson and I, Denver Nelson and I, went to Glynn County for the first SGMA pre-SGMA meeting. And we were under the impression that we were not going to be, and then we hit 16.5. But the evaporation levels they used were Central Valley, basically Kern County. And, you know, when we did have our, quote, unquote, the state had their drought, we were the only county that was actually. Thank you.
Still able to do grass-fed beef because Marin County had to back feed because they didn't have what we had. Basically fog and a water level. And as we know, the Eel River runs six miles wide underground. So I just, and we've met, we met with Wade Crowfoot twice, Natural Resources, and said, why are we in this? And it's just the encompassing finger of, well, we've got to do this, and it's government and everything else. But it did not take into consideration our fog levels, our ambient temperature. Down there is 80. I think their ambient's in the 70s, and ours is in the 50s. Big, big point of evaporation. And saltwater intrusion. I know we say that, and I don't know if we've had any wells of saltwater intrusion. We haven't in a lot of the ones out in Centerville and everything else. But they've, there hasn't been a water shortage. Even during the drought, we were able to, you know. Maintain what we had.
So a lot of this is, we shouldn't even be there. And I hope that shows in the report. So I, you know, as we go forward, because I see a lot of funding, funding, funding, and at the end of the day, we still have water. So I understand, you know, we're taking the state levels and doing the state thing, but, you know, as you said, the state doesn't take a lot of things into consideration. You're right, Sigma, they didn't take a lot of things into consideration, but that's not it. We're talking fracturing lands and things like that. We don't really have, you know, a grasp of that. We speculate and we throw things against the wind, as we've seen. And like you said, a lot of the well guys, they've had issues getting wells, getting replacement wells, and, you know. So it's either going to say they ran dry or they didn't run dry. Most of the time it's failures. And, I mean.
50 years later, now that we're permitting wells and everything else, some of these wells are 60, 80, 100 years old. And we really want them to change them because now they're going to encapsulate. They're going to sleeve. They're going to be up to health standards. So there's a lot we need to put in there. I do like the 5,000-gallon tanks, but if you've seen a 5,000-gallon tank, I really don't want one in my yard. Sorry, but the other thing is I don't know if we put 60 of them in Trinidad. I don't know how the Coastal Commission is going to accept 5,000-gallon tanks in every yard when view sheds and the height of a fence has to be five feet and things like that. So, I mean, there's particulars. It sounds good, but can we deliver on the areas that we're talking about? There's just things I hear. Things are going to look really good.
It said they can't look so good All right any other comments yes supervisor Madrone Thank You mr. Chair So the city mayor of Trinidad actually Chiwi Lin about ten years ago put a five thousand gallon tank in his backyard in the city Of Trinidad again, it doesn't require any permits Even in the coastal zone, I mean views are important and heights are important But you put it right next to your house in a spot that it doesn't create any view blocking for anybody You can put up some nice lattice fence around it do a little landscaping. There's ways to make it less Obtrusive and things like that and you're right that stored water does deteriorate Absolutely can appreciate that and that's why they make these really simple little chlorination systems for small private Systems like that and or you could have a UV system as well filters UVs you can have rainwater collection with filters on the Inlet system so you reduce the amount
of roughage that comes into it and all that from rain off a roof or whatever. At any rate, there are solutions to that that add a little bit of money to the overall cost from $10,000, it might be $12,000 if you plan to store it for a period of time where it really needs to be treated and all that. And you know, the 50 gallons a day, I mean, most of that is not drinking water. Most of that is flushing toilets and taking showers and things like that. And a very, very small amount is actually for drinking water where that treatment of the water is critical. So I just wanted to mention that. And then the last thing is one of the other reasons why Trinidad was in a real bind when they lost their entire storage is it happened during stormy December, right, with high turbidities in the creek. And while they've made vast improvements on their water quality through the implementation of a watershed improvement plan working with Green Diamond. To do a lot of road work and reduce turbidity in the system dramatically.
There's still a lot of stored sediment in the system along the creek. The creek has a channel, next to it are terraces. On those terraces there's a lot of stored sediment from the logging from the 70s and 80s. So whenever we get a high intensity event or high rainfall amounts, it comes out of that channel and it mobilizes those sediments off the terraces, which creates really high turbidity and difficult to treat. So they were up against, they could only pull so much water at a time and actually still be able to treat it through their filter system and the rest of it, because of the high turbidity. So I'm actually in conversations as we speak with the State Water Board, looking for funding for local assistance that seems to be available. I'm supposed to be getting some calls back in the next day or two, to help the city tap springs up higher in the watershed that come out. You know, we have these uplifted marine terraces that have 50 to 100 foot thick sand layer, which is what, the best sand filter in the world? And then that sits on the Franciscan blue clay, and so the water infiltrates on these flat...
Terraces, hits the clay, runs out in springs at an elevation that allows for gravity flow to the city during high turbidity events with really clean water. So you know in Trinidad-West Avon area we are looking at all the various aspects on a very site-specific level of what it would take to make the overall community system more resilient as well as cleaner you know and it could have a redundant line producing small hydro with the electricity to run the plant. So there's these incredible opportunities there as a pilot to really show how a small community can actually figure out its localized problems and find localized solutions that doesn't create growth inducement and more septic pollution and other kinds of you know negative impacts. So just wanted to share those pieces to it. So you know as like you said this plan is really this is a certain milestone but it's a living document. There's going to be a changes you're going to be developing more solutions like looking at the water quality and the water quality of the water. So you know looking at the Sigma issues and other things in the
river. These are all localized specific issues. And yes, there has been some issues of saltwater intrusion up at Patrick's Point and Big Lagoon, where they have wells that go down 100 feet, 80 feet, 50 feet, and they do intersect that saltwater plume. And if they pull too much of the freshwater on the backside, they can absolutely pull saltwater into those wells there. And interestingly, upslope from them are these Franciscan springs that also could be providing water to those small communities that would be clean and pure and solve their problems. So localized solutions for localized problems. Thank you. All right. There's a lot of information there. The only thing I... Supervisor Bushnell, are you... Okay. Why don't you do that? Make a motion. I'm going to make a motion to accept the presentation, and thanks to both of you. And... And I... Now, secondly, I just wanted to say...
To address a comment from Supervisor Bushnell, she had a question around your applications for new wells when they're replacing old wells. And what I heard you say was that there's nothing on the form that would log in that information as to the reason why the new well is needed. And so maybe, I don't know how customizable our forms are, but maybe there's a space for at least speculation on the part of either the well driller or the county employee so that at least we can collect that data for the future and sort of moving forward. Sure. It's just something small. With that, there was a motion and a second. Is there any objection? There is one more question. Mario, I know that for a bit.
We were having some time with getting the well applications. You know, you needed information and data and all this stuff. Is this being utilized at all to help move those along or to slow down those applications at all, this report? No, this report is not regulatory in any way. The impact to well permitting is improvement only. And because the goal is to identify the gaps when there's a dry well so we can start to understand if there's regional impacts, are there communities that are suffering. But as far as permitting, there's no influence on our permitting. Okay. We still have. I mean, I understand that and thank you for that. With self-reporting, though, in one well dry in the last five years, that's not a great, you know, way to be able to monitor what's happening out there. And I do know that you. Planning and building, you guys are doing like a.
well applications for for non-domestic like agricultural uses they come to you for you know like cannabis permits or whatever but so thank you for that update i appreciate that sure all right well always better to have a plan than not have a plan especially when we're talking about situations of drought or any other community emergency if there is no objection to unanimous consent seeing none we will move on to the next item which i think is going into closed session yes guys Take it away, Mr. Miles. Thank you, Chair Wilson. It is the intention of the board to meet in closed session pursuant to California Government Code section 54956.9 in order to discuss the initiation of litigation in one potential case. Do we have a
Estimated time when we might be returning? I would say closed session should take around an hour to two hours. An hour to two hours. Do we have anyone online that wants to speak to this? All right, please bring them in. Yes, Chair. Caller 7718, I will unmute you and you'll have three minutes. Thank you. You can try to press star six to unmute. Looks like we might be
Having some technical difficulties. I will try to remember when we come back to ask if that person is still wanting to comment, but that's going to be in a while. With that, we're going to move into closed session. Oh, no, there you go. Jump in. You're on. Thank you. Just a second. Let me get rid of the screen thing that I was using as an alternate. Yeah, that's a rather long time, I guess, for initiating lawsuits. This has been interesting. There's so many things that I guess could be litigated in Humboldt County. Of course, the public is not aware of what we're spending a couple hours on, an hour and a half on for closed session to initiate litigation. That's something we're not privy to. That's unfortunate in some ways. The public's been blocked from receiving the report out from the public. What's being sent to the grand jury, we can't be aware of that, but I guess that's just a ballgame.
I'm considering maybe the county would be also. GRTA has $50 million they just got. They have all kinds of hazards in the Blue Lake Glendale area. I think, provided the drone's aware of one, that should be fixed there. Maybe the county could go ahead and either threaten litigation or have them fix that. There's another one on Warren Creek Road and a rather large bridge that they have responsibility for that could dam the whole Mad River. So we don't know what you're doing, but I would consider some of these other things you might find. We were talking about water. Is that the city of Blue Lake has a large quantity of chlorinated water leaking into Dave Howard Creek. That's within the jurisdiction of the county. So maybe sometime we'll have to litigate that. This time of year, it's not a major concern. But later on, it could be a major fish kill in that particular area. Wanted to bring those potential concerns that you may potentially litigate at some time. So thank you for my opportunity. Look forward to a report out and hopefully we will find out what you are intending to litigate. Thank you.
Thank you. That's all, Chair. Thank you for that comment. We're going to go into closed session now. Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. By all means. Thank you.
Thank you. Does that mean we're on? Okay. We're on. Let's close this out. Thank you, Chair Wilson. With regard to item K-1, the board voted 3-2, with Supervisors Wilson, Arroyo, and Madrone voting yes, and Supervisors Bone and Bushnell voting no, to approve the initiation of litigation in one case. The specific action defendants and other particulars shall once formally commence be disclosed upon inquiry, unless the do so would jeopardize the county's ability to effectuate service of process.
on one or more unserved parties, or that to do so would jeopardize the county's ability to conclude existing settlement negotiations to its advantage, as set forth in California Government Code Section 54957.1A2. Great. And with that, we're closing out. We'll see everybody next week. Yeah, next week. Thank you.