you you okay i'm going to welcome us all to home county board of supervisors meeting of tuesday november 3rd 2026
It is about 9.02. Getting started. Could we have a roll call, please? Yes, Chair. Supervisor Bushnell. Good morning. Supervisor Bone. Supervisor Arroyo. Good morning. Supervisor Madrone. Present. Chair Wilson. I'm here. All are here. Great. All right, next we're going to do a salute to the flag. Looks like Supervisor Bone is raring to go, so I'll have him lead, please. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. All right, this is the time we ask Kaylee to read some instructions on how to give your comment online.
Thank you. This meeting is being conducted in accordance with Brown Act and applicable state and local requirements. Members of the public may participate in person and or remotely as noticed on the agenda. For those participating remotely, public comment is welcomed and encouraged. To help ensure your voice is heard, it is recommended that you raise your hand at the start of the item you wish to comment on. If you are joining by computer or mobile device, please use the raise hand feature to indicate your desire to speak. When it is your turn, you will be unmuted by staff. If you are joining by telephone, please press star nine to raise your hand. When recognized, you may press star six to unmute yourself and begin speaking. Please state your name for the record before making your comment. The board asks that all participants conduct themselves with respect and courtesy. Comments should be directed to the board as a whole and limited to the time allowed. Thank you. Thank you.
Are there any modifications to the agenda, CAO? Good morning, Chair Wilson. There are no modifications this morning. Okay. Great. I think then the first thing we're going to go into is the consent calendar. And I'll just ask maybe are there any supervisors that have anything that they want to read or have comment on on the consent calendar? I'll start with you, Supervisor Bowman. Nope. Supervisor Jones. All right. Supervisor Arroyo. Thank you. We have a Veterans Day proclamation. Would you like me to read it now or wait for a moment? Go for it. Go for it. All right. Well, I see our VSO is here. Welcome. Good to see you. Thank you for coming. All right. This proclamation is in honor of Veterans Day. Whereas the people of Humboldt County and the state of California appreciate and admire the thousands of individuals who serve and have served in the armed forces to protect and protect their loved ones, to protect and preserve.
their country and the freedoms enjoyed by all Americans. And whereas in war, international conflicts, and peacekeeping missions, surface members have been wounded, taken prisoner, and died in the line of duty. And whereas due to their military experience, veterans possess a wide variety of valuable qualities, including experience, maturity, leadership, and loyalty. And whereas the County of Humboldt is committed to ensuring that veterans receive the respect and honor they have earned. And whereas as part of Operation Green Light for Veterans, Humboldt County is illuminating the Eureka Veterans Hall Green and other veterans halls, as well as the county courthouse, beginning on November 4th. And we encourage individuals and businesses to join us by changing one light bulb in the entryway of your house or business to a green bulb. And whereas Humboldt County Department of Health and Human Services Veterans Service Office has provided veteran services to more than 8,500 veterans, including connecting our veterans and their families to federal and state benefits, helping them manage employment needs and doctor's appointments, as well as helping them find veteran peers.
Can assist with the transition back to civilian life. Now therefore the Humboldt County Board of Supervisors hereby proclaims that the County of Humboldt honors all veterans for their extraordinary service to their country and thanks them for protecting the freedoms we all enjoy. And let's take a quick photo and then we'll hear some remarks from you. Thank you. Thank you. Good to see you.
Well, good morning and thank you for this proclamation on behalf of Humboldt County Veterans Service Office under the Department of Health and Human Services. This is an honor and it is wonderful to know that the board respects our veterans and supports the office and its program. We strive to help everybody we can as often as we can and we're just excited to continue to be able to do our services. So unless there's any questions. Bringing it back, any Supervisor Bushnell? I'll just say thank you for everything that your department does for the veterans but I also I'm gonna put a plug in for the Veterans Hall that is gonna do a grand opening this Friday at 1230 thanks to this board. Southern Humboldt veterans have waited a long time for this so I just want to. Garberville? Correct. In Garberville, yeah. It'll be exciting to have them have that opportunity.
Hey you. Hello. Yeah, I want to say thanks for everything you do, the efforts you put in to Stand Down. And I think Stand Down is one of the 20th anniversary this year, and I think it's one of the best events. It actually touches a lot of veterans, and it still seems to get great numbers. DHHS, I think, tables like four different tables for so many different things. I know the Barber College or the Beauty College, whatever you want to call it at the time, does over 150, 160 haircuts. There's veterinary service. So all the efforts, and the effort you put forward for veterans is sometimes not as recognized as it should be. And as we celebrate this Veterans Day, I wanted to thank you for that. Well, this year I was only able to attend as a veteran myself. I had just had surgery, so I wasn't able to have a table this year. I know. I didn't know you had that. So it was the first time in 20 years I didn't have a table.
But I mean the dental van, the open door, Providence, I mean it's, there's 60, I don't want to call you vendors, but 60 different types of caregiving for veterans. And it always amazes me, I always run into one or two that just found out they could get a service they didn't know they could get, which means a big deal. Correct. So DHHS goes out and all the departments go out with the ones that are, so it's pretty cool. So it's amazing to see change one life one little bit and have them help others. Yeah. Spread in the word is how you make change. Well, from the first year, 20 years ago, I saw guys out there, now they're out there working it. So Sons of Italy does a big meal there, which is great, and other people do. So anyway, that's, it's passed, but we've got another one coming up this September. So I see you in the planning. So anyway, thanks for all you do. Thank you guys, and thank you for all. I hope to see some of you out at Garberville, if you can. Thank you. I just want to.
I wanted to comment on the fact that we're kind of at this interesting watershed moment with service members. I know as our resident veteran and current service member, I have a lot of people that I have worked with and who have come to me for advice along the way in their careers who are retiring or who are eligible to end their enlistment. And there's a big shift of a lot of people getting out or going into the ready reserve. And then a huge amount of recruitment, you know, sort of unprecedented level of recruitment for most of the branches of the service. And we're seeing a lot of turnover in veterans. And I can't help but think, you know, we're going to have a lot of need to support people as they leave the service, many of whom have served for 20 plus years. Who I know and are finally, you know, entering the civilian sector. And, of course, that's always.
It's happening, but right now it's happening at a greater pace, and I wondered if that is something you've been seeing, is more demand for services. Well, right now, and I'm very proud to say, Sector Humble Bay is having me on site doing their transitions assistance program, so they're programming, helping everybody to get out. And I recommend everybody start working on their discharge, their actual plan, two years out. So we're working with a lot of people that are looking to getting out, and we're getting a lot of support from the command. Captain Barrett is amazing with helping everybody know what's available. He even uses himself as an example, so amazing. Plus the VA clinic gives me hours there so I can go and find the people that just haven't known anything other than health care. So we're getting the community resources and support, plus all the Medi-Cal referrals that helps us find the people that didn't even know anything was available to them. So. So we've got a lot of legwork to try to get things done. So I. So.
Much appreciate you guys support for us and that we just closed the position for applications over the weekend for our veterans service rep. So future is getting brighter with getting someone on board. Thank you guys. Thank you. I want to associate myself with all the comments from other board members but also highlight the services that vets provide post service and the volunteerism not just around the vets halls and all that but within the community and all our organizations and as individuals the continuation of service is always it's it's great to see and it's and I'm thankful for that very much. OK. It's almost like every house if you look at it has a connection to veterans and their family. So helping spread the word so they can know what's even available they could choose not to use it but to know what's available is huge opportunity to go to for their kids to go to college is amazing and that's a program. Yeah. Thank you.
County I'm allowed to process those fee waivers for them. So there's so much out there. It is a full time job trying to keep up on all the changes. So. Well thank you guys. Thank you. OK. I think unless there's any more from the board I'm going to take this to public comment. Is there any public comment on line for consent items. There is. All right. Caller 7 7 1 8 I will unmute you and you will have three minutes. Thank you. Hello, Kent Sawatsky calling from Mexico. I hope you can hear me. Wonderful thing that we are finally getting the Garberville facility for the veterans done. Kudos to everybody who got that done finally. I also wanted to make a comment regarding our interim auditor controller is getting an award, I see there. And I always find out...
It's quite interesting, we've got an interim audit controller, and I'm glad that PF is getting this award. We also have an interim county council, and when you look up the definition of interim, it sets things as temporary and things of that nature. So I'm just curious, maybe someday I'll get an answer from somebody why long-term employees have a title of interim rather than being actually in that position. Those are my only comments today on your consent items. Thank you very much for my ability to comment. Okay, anyone else? That's all. All right, bringing it to the room. Is there anyone who wants to comment on things on the consent calendar? Yes. Hello, my name is Joanne McGarry. And first of all, I appreciate recognizing veterans this month on Veterans Day. I have the opportunity in Arcata to attend the monthly brunch. The veterans. The veterans put on, or the American Legion puts on at the.
The Arcata Veterans Hall, and I'm impressed that hall has gone through a bit of turmoil in the last decade or so, but I think there's some steady leadership there now, and I'm impressed with some of the activities that they're doing, including this Wednesday a dinner and discussion about what veterans go through and military people go through, and they're going to have some excellent panel people speaking. And so in addition to other Veterans Day activities, I encourage people to look into that, including a man coming up from Berkeley who does ceramics as kind of a therapy for his military service. And I finally want to say that I've been affiliated both in Santa Barbara and here, and in San Francisco actually, with Veterans for Peace, and they are very interested in reminding people that November 11th was initially, Armistice Day.
And they're trying to bring back that concept of not, you know, negating veterans, but also recognizing that Armistice Day was an important day in the war to end all wars. And as we all hopefully want to move toward a peaceful world, recognizing Armistice Day as well as Veterans Day, I think, would be wonderful. And I finally want to say that I really appreciate the Veterans Service Office that helped a friend of mine who was having a difficult time in getting his paperwork for his military service that was able to open a door for him to get a whole lot of other services in his time of need. So it's great that we have this very capable service provided by the county. All right. Bring it back to the board. Is there any more comments? I just want to.
I recognize on the consent calendar the item from Public Works doing about $300,000 in deferred maintenance. It's really important. We've talked about that a lot and how deferred maintenance is not a great way for our facilities. So just a plug for them that we're getting some of that work done. Great. And we also have a certificate of recognition from Michael Evanson for all his great work. He's not here. But there was a press release and all kinds of stuff. So we'll just say yay, Michael. And moving along, do I have a motion to approve the consent calendar? I'll make a motion to approve the consent calendar. A second. There's a motion and a second. Is there any objection to unanimous consent? Seeing none, the motion passes. All right. We are now on to public comment on non-agenda items. So this is the time. We're going to have a motion for people to talk about things that we don't have on the agenda.
And we're going to go to online folks first. Do we see anyone there. Yes. Caller seven seven one eight. I will unmute you and you will have three minutes. OK. Thank you. Ken Sawatsky again from Mexico, 83, 63 high and low, wind 6 miles per hour with a 93% humidity. I did wish to make a comment I saw on Aaron McClure's Facebook thing, their Blue Lake Real Truth. And I found some things there I found humor a little bit and some good things. One read, to everyone I offended this year, work on yourself so I don't have to do it again next year. And then the other one on there that I enjoyed, being hated by idiots is a price you pay for not being one of them. I did wish to also make a comment regarding some things.
...transpiring. I've had a lot of angst before with some of the staff that's hired, not direct staff, but experts who do diagnosis for CWS and things. And I just wanted to let people know as far as I can tell, one of those people involved in that is in a lot of trouble. He's lawyered up, and I think there may be some other repercussions that will come when these false diagnoses have been paid for by DHHS. I also still have angst because a lawyer who does work in this capacity to represent people in CWS cases still does not provide a file to the person who's, I think it's been well over a year, probably 14 months now, still has no file. So. I think some things are going to come down the pipe. You're going to probably see some litigation, and I guess we get to talk about that a little bit later in the meeting.
Thank you for my opportunity to speak. Looks like a short day, and so on we go. That's all, Chair. All right, we're bringing it to the room. This is a time for folks here that want to talk on things that are not on the agenda. Good morning, Mr. Chair, distinguished members of the board. My name is Vernon Price. I just want to say thank you for all of your support. If given the opportunity, I'd like to have just a little bit of latitude to thank some county staff that has been very supportive in my recovery from being unhoused at this point. I am now accepting my application is being accepted in Lolita with an apartment. I definitely want to thank Connie Beck for directing Jack Brazil.
to give a phone call into me being repositioned here in Eureka. I want to thank this entire board and Madam CAO's office for all the prayers, the support, and the thoughts that you have been putting in to my recovery from being unhoused again. Thank you so much for your time, your concern, and your consideration. And keep me in your thoughts and prayers as this transition moves forward to fruition. Thank you. Thank you. Good morning members of the board. For the record, my name is Michael Orcutt. I've been the fisheries director for the Hoopa Valley Tribe for a long time, probably close to 40 years now, and I just wanted...
to provide a statement to the board today and leave some documents with you as well. Chairman Wilson, members of the board of supervisors, my name is Michael Orkett, Fisheries Department Director. My current address is 2084 Fern Street, Eureka, California. Today I'm here to speak to you about the Trinity River Division water supply promised to the county and downstream water users in federal law enacted more than 70 years ago. Despite the promises, the Bureau of Reclamation has refused to deliver even one bucket full of water to any of us. For the last 25 years, the Hoopa Valley Tribe has led an effort on behalf of the tribe and the county to get the intended benefits of this water, which amounts to 50,000 acre feet annually. The economic value of this water supply is enormously important to the future of the region. Instead, it is being diverted to the Central Valley Industrial Agriculture Interest. I'm Michael Orkett, Chairman of the Board of Supervisors, and I'm here to speak to you about the Trinity River Division water supply.
Billions of dollars from it. In a June 17th, 2026 letter to the Hooper Valley Tribal Chairman Joe Davis, Supervisor Wilson stated his personal view that neither the Trinity River Division Act, the 1959 contract, nor any subsequent legal documents specified that downstream water use, whether there are individuals, private companies, public agencies or tribal governments are entitled to be allocated a portion of the quantity of water specified in the 1959 contract. He stated further that neither Supervisor Madrone nor I support allocating a portion of the county's water contract to the Hooper, Yurok or any other downstream water users. Chairman Davis replied to that letter on October 8, 2026. He encouraged Supervisor Wilson to reconsider his position for several reasons. First, in our view, it violates the mandates of the 1955 Trinity River Division Act.
At not less than 50,000, the AQA3 be released annually from Trinity Reservoir and made available to Humboldt County and downstream water users. Supervisor Wilson's statement contradicts the statutory mandate that the water supply is for the benefit of downstream water users in addition to and other than Humboldt County. Second, it contradicts the 2013 sworn declaration by Supervisor Wilson's predecessor, Ryan Sundberg, on behalf of the county that stated, Humboldt County deems the Hoopa Valley Tribe, whose reservation within Humboldt County, to be a downstream user within the meaning of the 1955 Act, the 1959 contract between the United States and the county, and the 1959 state permits for the Trinity River Division. Third, the water supply. It is for economic development and is independent. Should I pay attention to that? Well, I mean, how much more do you have? You have to be fair to everybody. So if you have just a little bit more.
I can just leave a statement if you don't mind. If you have a finishing remark, it's fine. Okay, I'm going to leave a copy of two letters with you, and if I could make one last parting statement, I will say that. It is my understanding that the ad hoc committee has made a recommendation that there will be an action taken on the water allocation agreement that Hoopa Valley and Yurok Tribe, over 10,000 people, within this county and other parts of this northern part of the state, have already signed and have encouraged for over two years now the county to engage in a discussion about how the county can get in agreement with that allocation agreement. Thank you, and I'll provide the documents. Thank you, Mr. Orcutt. Thank you. Hello again. My name is Joanne McGarry. I took the
Again today I was hoping to ride my bike but looked out and thought the weather was not conducive to that. But again in part of my three things that you get from me usually, bicycles and advocacy for their increased use and incentivizing more and more people to use them. I just want to say I did come in on the 4th Street side of this building and once again looked at the pathetic bike parking that is available for the public for this building. And hopefully during this winter months when fewer people will be riding their bikes probably because of the weather, we can come spring have something more significant for people to feel better about leaving their bike here at the courthouse when they're coming here to speak and such. And I know you don't have control over the building per se. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. That's what the courts do. But working together maybe you can come up with something that would be beneficial for us all.
So that is one thing I wanted to say. Then climate change, I went to an Ollie Brown Bag lunch online yesterday and heard the new Regional Climate Action Plan group from RCEA talk to us about what's being planned for climate action. And just to remind you that it's first and foremost in anything we do in this county, we must take into consideration that climate action plan and our what we contribute or don't contribute to the harm we're doing to the planet in our actions here in our county. But that also extends to my third thing which is war and peace. And there's major concerns that things will be not very pleasant after today should things not go certain people's ways. And I just really want to say that what happened there and there is support for a saw over there from various territories, sorry for the deployments here at the gas station and they did pick one but when I Facetimed in during the prison period and I called to and I said we're here upend engaging communication because I understand things are goingense constantly but honestly there's no way we would talk about anything else because I've판 talking about it and I say no no, this isn't the case. This is a det pact.
in other parts of the world impacts us, including the climate. And that those of us who approach you for resolutions on war and peace issues, it's not because we think it's outside your jurisdiction. We think it's because there are many people here who pay our taxes, who do not want our tax dollars going towards violent wars in other places in the world. So come this winter season, I just want us to all reflect, hopefully, that what Humboldt County can do is really important in the grand global scheme of things. So we really need to keep that in mind in terms of climate and peace. So thanks for listening. All right. Thank you. Is there anyone else in the room that wants to speak on things that are not, on the agenda? Through the chair, we do have a hand.
Raised on to. We'll let him in. We have a short meeting today, so I think we have some time. Thank you. Caller 3053, I will unmute you, and you will have three minutes. Good morning, thank you for allowing me to speak. I couldn't raise my hand earlier. Thomas Mulder here. I want to confirm you can hear me there in the chambers? Yes. Thank you. I say this again and again and again. It'd be great to see a letter of support towards farmers in regards to the state, no-notice inspections, and the cop-like mentality. I've talked to multiple farmers as well as people in the community that are distressed, they're trying to scrape through. They don't know how they're going to make it. And, you know, when they run into those kind of situations, it's enough to put them over their heads. So if we're in a county that we want to support...
It created tens of millions of dollars in tax dollars into our county. It would be great to see an agenda item, a nice strongly worded letter, some support. I believe the county isn't doing no notice inspections. As far as I know, I think there was a couple that had that in their thing, but it would just be nice. You know, treat people like human beings. You say you want respect towards you as individuals. Respect towards other community members would be great. And on that line of respect, it would be great for responses from heads of departments. Including public works to address situations where there's, you know, contamination in a class two water course. That's been known about for over six months. So it's unfortunate that, you know, us people that are held to have our category road four standards from the county road on. The county isn't held to the same standards. So it's really, really unfortunate. Thank you for the opportunity to speak and have a good day. That's all.
All right. I think we're going to close out comment from non agenda items and we're going to now go into departmental reports and the first thing we have on our agenda is consider at large appointments to the Humboldt County Resource Conservation District Board. Take it away. Good morning. I'm Tracy D'Amico clerk of the board. This item is spot you today with four recommendations. One is to reappoint directors at Cahill and Cody director Cody Reed who both in their term at the end of November. There was a third member whose term is ending and that would be Daniel Cahoon and he is resigning from the commission after 20 long years. So the second recommendation is to sign the chair have the chair sign an appreciation letter for that long and dedicated service. There was already an existing vacancy. And Jill Deamer the director who is here today if anyone has any questions is recommending
that applicant Allison Hunter fill that vacancy and lastly there will be a new vacancy for the resignation from Daniel Cajun that is all the information before you because this is at large and we're asking for multiple decisions we went ahead and went departmental all right first bring you to the board and then we'll do public comment. Allison Hunter is wonderful and what a great addition she's gonna be a to your board so and of course I appreciate greatly Daniel Cajun and happy that we have some reappointments it's always nice to have a bit of consistency but also someone new in the mix but who knows Humboldt County very well. Supervisor Madrone. Thank you chair yes I agree Allison Hunter will be great
And I really appreciate Zach and Cody's continued service and thank you to long-term director Daniel Cahoon. Really quite amazing commitment there for sure. The RCD is just an amazing organization. Thank you Jill for what you and all of your staff do there. Also in partnership with the Fire Safe Council. And slightly off topic but because we're up here with the RCD. Is it true that the Trinity County RCD sponsors the Firewise communities in Trinity County? Is it okay if you Mr. Chair if she comes up? Sure if there's a question. Hello Board of Supervisors. My understanding is the Trinity County RCD administers the Fire Safe Council and the Firewise communities. Oh that's wonderful. And I know you're in partnership with our Fire Safe Council and help run a lot of those things with you. With Sabelle Emmett and others that keep that alive in this board.
has been helping support that for a long time. You know, fire insurance keeps going up for everybody, but one of the things I've heard is that if you have a FireWise community, it actually can provide people with a discount on their insurance. So are we thinking about maybe doing a FireWise community countywide or working with our FireSafe Council collaborators? Yeah, the FireWise community initiative is part of the Humboldt County FireSafe Council, and so the RCD does help as part of the county coordinating team, and we have seen a growth in the number of communities that have been enrolling in the FireWise community, and several of our staff have been working on that as well. I don't know that we've discussed it countywide. Honestly, I've been stepping back from that role a little bit, but it's something I can bring back to the group at our next meeting and ask them a little bit more about a countywide status. I'm not sure I'm familiar with that. That would be great because there are very few things that give you some discounts, and that would be... Yeah.
To me a small lift to make that happen, but again, thank you for all that you do. Appreciate it. Thank you. Okay. Thank you I know there's a little off topic but I thought well, you know opportunity right? So, thank you Jill All right, Mr. Rezabon Ditto as a board member that Attends meetings on a somewhat regular basis because I'm always trying to figure out what is gonna happen in the river valley completely But you do a great job It's a it's it's a tedious job. I know the biggest contract you ever had by a Lot is still an ongoing Procedure and funding is getting tougher and everything else and before we take on too much other stuff because there's that out there We probably we need to make sure that everybody's focused on finishing this stuff over here I hope because there's a lot of unfinished stuff that needs to be done according to some of the people out there And you're you're aware of all that. Yes
Referring to the Salt River ecosystem restoration project and Williams Creek. Yes, we are still in Williams Creek, everything else. We have major flooding. We have everything else and it's becoming the cost that we actually give reduced property taxes to the people that live on Frog Alley or, you know, and stuff like that because of the constant flooding. So if we can move up that channel, that would probably be a great thing. So and we need to before we take on too much more and forget about it. But anyway, I appreciate what you're doing. Thanks. All right. Do we have any comment online? Yes. Caller 0150. I will unmute you and you will have three minutes. All right.
Hello this is Dottie Russell and you'll be hearing from me later on in the meeting I was trying to get on public comment but the star 9 was not working and so I will expect that you cannot give me some time now so that'll be that okay and just you can also write and email us and call us individually if you want to tell us anything you want to tell us okay with that is there anyone in the room that wants to speak to this item seeing none can we get of a motion I'll move approval of all of the recommendations I don't think I need to enumerate them one at a time all right all right the motion in a second for staff recommendations is there any objection to unanimous consent seeing none motion passes I would just like to add something to that I think it's a good point I think it's a good point I think you're doing great at providing to me and most importantly you're doing great in the meeting is there any compelling message I think I'll get it in the next meeting if that's what you think well you can do from whatever you may caption and both also to like.
Executive Director Deamer and I spoke and we're really looking forward and we're really gonna try to make an effort not just with this commission and committee but to have that have them start coming to a regular meeting presenting information that they're working on to keep you all and the public informed about what these hard-working boards and commissions are doing for volunteer work and it's impressive and I just wanted to point that out. And as always as a reminder if you're just hearing about this Commission for the first time you think this is something I really want to do but oh well it's been filled put in your application now doesn't matter we'd never know when openings come up and even when they do if your applications in there someone will give you a call and and let's ask you if you're still interested which is always good so by all means please do that. And we're noticing a vacancy today. Okay we have a vacancy. We have a vacancy. Yeah. All right there you go. Talk it up to everyone you know. Thank you. Thank you.
It is not the only vacancy we have, but just on this particular board. All right. So, next we're going to go matters initiated by the board. This is consideration. Oh, we didn't vote. We didn't vote. I'm sorry. Did we vote? Yeah, we did. All right. Is there a motion? I made a motion to be seconded and re-invited. I said, is there any objection to unanimous consent? Did I say it? Yeah, you did. Okay. Okay. So, you guys are really messing with me up here. I know. I don't know. All right. Here we go. We're going to go on to matters initiated by board. And this is consideration of funding to expand access to low-cost spay and neuter services in Humboldt County. I think this is brought to us by Supervisor Bushnell. Please take it away. Thank you. So, we, as a board, had talked about this during budget times. And this is the return. So, we are very happy to correct your Jeffrey Cohen-Ann Jones. I will re-invite Jeffrey Cohen. similarities? That's okay. Um-uh. Great.
of what we talked about that day and to figure out a funding strategy around spay and neuter neutering in Humboldt County there there's a lot of you know there's been a lot of stuff in the news about you know animals and treatment of animals and spay and neuter and one thing that we all should recognize is that the problem is overpopulation of animals in Humboldt County and beyond Humboldt County I continue to hear in my district how it's especially with dogs how hard it is financially to get them to you know spayed or neutered and also for to travel sometimes and so I'd really like this board to discuss how we can do possibly you know an idea would be ten thousand dollars annually to help spay and neuter there are some funding streams and we can talk to the to the CAO about where that money can come from.
I also want to recognize that you know department heads are probably maybe cringing a little bit because we talked about our budgets and we don't have any money to spare and how do you know we asked department heads to continually cut and so I recognize that although this is a small amount which can make a huge difference it probably you know might not settle well with some department heads and I do feel that this is really necessary in Humboldt County as as you know as I hope other counties in the state of California will follow and I also want to recognize that Rio del does a small amount in their little jurisdiction there for spay and neuter to help and just would like to have a good discussion at supervisor though most anything we do up here is gonna upset some department head yeah read deals program successful um I mean a lot of the issues we have up here has been overcrowding it
out of area facilities dumping dogs on us and I think that needs to be addressed also but my biggest thing about this is I don't know the way it's set up here we need like three different people to make a plan and everything else where it seems to me we should be able to just go to four locations say we will pay this minimum find out what to make because I know they do free spay and neuter some weekends and everything else but at least address the situation because I'd hate to see the admin and admin is expensive I mean we've got three different groups I think you're needing to put something together and that's gonna eat up our 10,000 or is that besides so that's the part no this is a great program Michelle I'm not saying about this is great I wanted to hit the ground running rather than government it to death is what I'm trying to say so if we if we if we if we if we if we if we if we if we if we if we if we if we if we if we We sat there and we've got McKinleyville, the veterinarian.
McKinnonville, I think that takes care of our shelter. We have a spay and neuter clinic in Fernbridge. We have one out here on Myrtle Avenue. And I think if we got one down, I don't think we have a vet down in Sohum, but maybe we could, if they want to get a spay and neuter, they could take their animal with them on that trip to Costco that we know they do every two weeks or to town to further their shopping. But if we could just go to them and make a contract or make a deal with them and allow so much, I don't want it to, if we set it up through financial, people financial need, people won't do it. And I think it just needs to be open first come, first serve, first 30 at each place. I don't know how it would work. I just know I don't want to government the hell out of it and have all these people come back to us with something six months from now. May I respond, sir? Sure, but then let's bring this back to...
Well, let me get other board members first and then. Well, I'd like to add that there were three meetings that happened around this item prior to bringing it to the board. And the reason was to figure out the funding mechanism and not have the county involved. And I would love for the CAO to talk about that because what Supervisor Bones said, yes, we don't need to be handing out vouchers. That's not what we need to do. Also, I see the undersheriff is here and probably has something to add as they were involved in the meeting as well. And so once your board talks, if we could have those folks come up, that'd be great. Yeah. So I'm going to bring it back to the board again for this is like questions and clarifications. You have any questions, clarifications, and then we'll kind of stack them up there and we'll let staff and undersheriff address them as best they can. Yeah, I had similar questions about how. How the conversation had evolved. That's very helpful to know.
And so I'd love to hear those clarifications and just similarly, you know, wondering how we can administer this as effectively as possible. So it sounds like we have some experts in addition to you who've been in the meetings here to to share those thoughts with us. You know, similarly, I feel like we can it's a time when we can get some feedback about, you know, funding decisions from from the, you know, within the organization. But I also think this is obviously responding to a very high priority need. And I just wanted to add, you know, that we are really. Be working with our state legislators on some other legislative fixes that are much more broad and get at other aspects of animal control and and well-being needs. So those those irons are in the fire as well. But I really.
that we get a chance to talk about this today. Supervisor Madrone, questions? My biggest question would be how many spay and neuters do you get for $10,000? And what does that actually mean? And what I mean is a differential, not how many do you get, but how many do you actually increase? Because as Supervisor Rabone had mentioned, some people would just take advantage of getting the free service that might be paying anyway. So it's like what is that differential? And that would be interesting to me. Is there opportunities for matching? Because I know there's a lot of folks that are very interested in donating their services and time and money for these sorts of things. And so those are some of my questions about this. And I am pretty sensitive about starting paying for something that will become an expense. And that is on theuffices that I was
thing and then what we've seen in the past is oftentimes then the the program that we're creating then reduces sort of the the community's efforts into that we've seen it for and I and and I would wouldn't want that to be us doing that again it's so we've seen that so those are some questions I have about that I'm gonna ask the CAO to unless there's questions from the rest of the board you have more questions I'm I think it's a great program I think it's way and I'm glad you mentioned the Freeman trust because Humboldt Area Foundation has a lot of money just for animals just for animals and it and it's pale to our 10,000 year and I agree putting something out there like $10,000 a year we have to do it every year I'm and I'm trying to say this is delicate I'm trying to say this is delicate we treat $10,000 around here
Like it's nothing. Look at how much sometimes comes through this consent calendar. And when you think about, and I'm hoping the undersheriff comes up, I don't see animal control. How much time we spend on animal control. How much time that we spend, I see those trucks everywhere, dealing with an abandoned cat, dog, even had goats the other day in my neighborhood. But anyway, how much money we spend, it's risk versus reward. Can we save money doing this? And I truly believe in the way it's brought forward. I just don't want to, department heads, if they're involved with it, are going to complain if their people are working on something to work it out. Where there are people that already do this. I mean, there's numerous clinics that do it, like I said. And can we just go to them and say, what will you do? I'm just saying, if we can get it done, that's fine. And I would be all for it. Just the way it's written.
I'm just saying we have to be careful as we move forward. And I appreciate again going after the Humboldt Erie Foundation because that's a big a big big part of it because there's a lot of money sitting out there. Again I want to get back to at some point staff but go ahead please. So I think that there were a lot of talks previous to this item coming and it doesn't have to be. I think that the board should consider whether it's a one time donation. I think Humboldt Erie Foundation is a funding source. We also as a group met with some of that like Critters for litters and the people that already do this work. And we also have had folks say that if the county puts in some money then we'll put in some money as well. And so it's just an item for consideration. I hope that this board will put some funding towards it but it doesn't have to be annually was a suggestion but it could be a one time fund. And I think that's a consideration. Consideration of the board.
I you know we talked about getting the money out the door so that the county doesn't have to deal with it as supervisor phone said and then it can go to the right areas of need Humble Area Foundation already gives money for spay and neuter and so it would just increase the amounts that they are able to get out the door and then like the southern Humble area the critters for litters they do Mary Ellen down in southern Humble is very active and brings will bring cats especially up to this critters for litters and really works diligently in that southern Humble area but it there always seems to be a shortage of funding for cats and dogs and it's around my understanding it's around $300 for dogs and about $100 for cats is my understanding and I am seeing an odd out there so that's just the information I have and then I would like the undersheriff to come up and talk about the McKinleyville shelter and what they do around spay and neuter
and how they get those funds back and the cost, which is in the staff report, if you all read it. And then also the CAO can add about how we talked about the funding source and possibly where those monies could come from. Okay. Through the chair. CAO, can you? Thank you. So to the question of how many animals this could potentially accommodate at $300 a dog and $100 for a cat, that's roughly maybe 20 dogs, 40 cats. Obviously, it depends on which are in high demand at that point in time. If more dogs, it's going to be less overall animals that could be attended to. For the funding, it would come from the general fund. In the current year, we would transfer it from contingencies. In future years, if it were an ongoing allocation, it would likely be an allocation.
that would be provided to the sheriff through animal control. I would certainly defer to their finance director, who's also here in the office, in terms of what the most expeditious way to get the dollars out the door might be from their perspective. But if we send the dollars out to a new entity, there is a contracting process. So sometimes for $10,000, that can be a little bit of an administrative lease, sometimes it ends up being more difficult than it can be in reward. And also, just to be clear for whatever agency that would go to, there would be insurance requirements, and that tends to be the harder part for nonprofits to meet our expectations there. But if the sheriff already has a contractual relationship with an agency or can work it into their own spay and neutering program, then that's a good thing. Thank you.
There may be some ways that we can streamline that a little bit more. Okay, and bringing it to the under sheriff. And the finance. I think you guys can hear what the questions are, so address them in whatever order you feel is appropriate. Good morning. Good morning. It may have been overstated my expertise on it, so I have her chief financial officer here to give the number stuff, and I'll try to answer any questions you may have after that. Yes, good morning. So we do contract with McKinleyville Animal Center, and I have statistics on last year. So last year we did 376 spay and neuters of dogs and cats. We spent $75,000.
dollars for that. That averages about $200 per procedure. So, you know, based on what we're paying, that would be about 50 procedures on average that $10,000 would cover. The way that we recover our funding, so right now the idea is that when an animal is adopted, they have to be spare neutered before we release them. And we pass through the full cost to the person that's adopting them. So, theoretically, we're getting back 100% of what we are spending. Of course, you know, with the board report, there was about $14,000 that we hadn't recovered yet, but that's because those animals will potentially be adopted out the following fiscal year, and we would be recovering it in that fiscal year. So, right now, we're theoretically not putting any money towards spay and neuter. It's a complete pass-through to the people that are adopting the animals. I do agree, the sheriff and I spoke just yesterday, about this. I wasn't part of any of the original.
meetings, but we spoke yesterday and we agree that we don't have the bandwidth in our office to handle any kind of program that's around financial, you know, somebody's income, because that would be a lot more work for us to validate and have to fill out more paperwork. The idea that I threw out to him yesterday, what we could administratively do if you did decide that you wanted to do this through our animal shelter is, you know, maybe when the shelter is at maximum capacity and we're trying to really encourage adoptions, you know, we could subsidize maybe half the cost of that spay or neuter for them and not charge the full cost. That would be one way, you know, that wouldn't be income-based. That would just be based on the shelter being at capacity and trying to move animals. Another idea is that it is true that the most expensive animals are spay of the larger dogs. So, you know, maybe it's something where we are re-examining. We're reducing that cost that we're passing through to try to help adopt.
out those animals. They're usually the ones that are a little bit more difficult to adopt out, and they have the higher cost. So that would be another way. Again, it wouldn't be income-based, but it would be these are ways that we could manage it if you wanted to do it just through the shelter. OK, that's clear. So basically running a special. Yes. OK. Yeah, certain times that we're running that special or throughout the year. Yes, just these animals would be the ones that we're running it on. That's how we could administer it until the funding ran out. Or the need has been reduced. Correct. OK. I also, I mean, I just want to, for the board, I have some concern around this in a precedent setting way. I just don't, some boards, boards that's super-virtual. Okay. Yeah. I'm pretty sure that one is for yourselves. I believe that's their provisional plan. And for me, it's like this one, just like some board members have, this one summer, whatever, and it's 2020, and we don't, nobody who's had experience using a similar program that we require in a ceremony, because I can apply to a conference all at once, it's actually the same federation. They actually will know more about the prominence of some certain of those relationships a lot more fast than the��asters. If you do more presentation dives into their sure
Where they have like these every board of supervisor gets some certain amount of money that they are give out to various organizations within their district or whatever that is every year within the budget we don't do that. And so I guess I'm what I don't what I don't want to have happen is that every time we you know one of us or two of us feels that there's an you know a small need for some organization that we're bringing it back to the board for doing these sorts of things because this could this is not something that I think is fiscally responsible in terms of a format of how we do this sort of work. I think we have to be really careful and cautious of that because we could all think of very deserving organizations that we would want to give money to. I think it's important for us to really think about that and so I'm cautious around that. This concept and I will say $10,000 as supervisor
Bone says in some ways is what some people might refer to as budget dust. It happens, right? And when you have a $600 million budget, and certainly there are many things even on consent calendar that far outweigh this, but nonetheless, even in this, what we've done, we've spent $1,000 in staff time easily, probably just sitting here up here at this meeting, and then also putting the report together and everything else. Some thousands of dollars have already been spent to just bring this forward. And so it speaks to the administrative burdens that we have. And so when we're asking for these smaller amounts of money, for me, the only way I kind of feel like even remotely comfortable moving something like this forward is if it's basically a matching fund. If there was a commitment from another organization for some amount of money, then I would say it would be a matching fund. If it's just a small amount for the equal or more.
amount of money to to make that happen because I think it's an it's important and we have abilities to fundraise for our favorite organizations and causes as well and I know Supervisor Bohn's very good at this and and and others and so I just like I said it makes me a little uncomfortable nonetheless I'm gonna take this to public comment starting with folks online and we will see where we go from there Thank You chair caller zero one five zero I will unmute you and you will have three minutes Good morning, it's Dottie Russell calling from Southern Humboldt. First of all, I'd like to say that if you have a first-time, first-serve person going to some location to have an animal spayed or neutered,
And I'll be respectful to say I'm not supportive of that. I could say more, but getting a dog that is a big dog that has already attacked people on a bus to go up to see if they're in a line to get something done is absolutely absurd. So a first come first serve to an area that is already suffering from a lot of dogs, a lot of attacks, a lot of problems, and then to see if somebody manages to get there up on time is a terrible idea. We definitely need something done down in Southern Humboldt about animals being spayed and neutered. We need more than we have. We have participated in having somebody arrested for having a dog that was attacked by a dog. And I think that's a great idea. And I think that's a great idea. And I think that's a great idea. And I think that's a great idea. So something like this is just gonna espouse the ownership of dogs. Thank you so much for your time, Thank you.pper, questions before the end of the session? Hi, we're so happy to see that you potermee
So what's happened with the dogs, because apparently it's not public comment, I mean public information what happens to dogs that attack people, but we do have a set of dogs that are attacking people in Southern Humboldt currently, and I don't know there was supposed to be a hearing on one dog specifically that had attacked people, and there's even filmage of film coverage on one of the attacks. So we need help, we need a lot of help, and at the very minimum to have something done today that's a temporary fix, maybe just a temporary to be discussed, I mean to approve the money, but know that there's going to be community involvement in making the decision how the $10,000 for spaying and neutering can happen. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Alright members so protect that argument that theazing. Okay. Alright. Alright.
part of this county and a lot of things don't get done down here and there's a lot of things dangerous that are not being addressed by anybody responsibly or enough so the animal control has tried really hard to take care of some things took one dog away um there was a public meeting about one but it wasn't a public i'm sorry it wasn't a public meeting it was a hearing about one of the dogs but anybody listening to southern humble might know who this person is that has had three dogs that are dangerous he uses them as weapons because he's not allowed to have a weapon like a gun because he's already a felon so whoever wants to help whoever wants to get involved we're not safe down here as long as this is not addressed you have used all of your time allotted thank you caller 771
I will unmute you and you will have three minutes. I could give a correctional thought about department heads who would object to this. I strongly suggest you use your skill set, which should cost nothing. At one time you were kind of sponsoring the dog every month, and I haven't seen that lately. The pressure that you can put on Humboldt Area Foundation to release a very large amount of money that could be being used for this and some leeway they have, I think would be of great benefit. That's where the money frequently has been donated. Down in Mexico, where I am at, I just purchased a property for $75,000, and of course I'm donating that plus another $25,000 to get it ready. I have eight facilities there where I can handle pregnant dogs and their puppies and things. The vets down here are...
are extremely smart and I think pressure should be put on your local vets. Down here they understand if they spare or neuter your pet for free for you that you're probably going to use them as a vet and then they get their money. Of course down here they make 10 cents on the dollar for procedures that you make up there. One of the few things down here that isn't the same price gas, groceries and those are all the same as up there even more in some circumstances. But the labor of these people who come and do this because they love it. And I have people who are willing to come down here they say and I'll put them up for a week. They can spend a few days doing spay and neuter. I think you can get this done just by reaching out to the people you know, putting pressure on those who have the money and get people to do the right thing. Miranda's Rescue was getting sometimes $100,000 worth of property and other donations. I think hopefully if you have something like in my circumstance there will be no administration fee. So what we're doing down here and the people are lining up to be
part of the program to donate time effort money dog food toys and participate so uh hopefully you'll have the same luck up there that uh good karma seems to be down here the problem's way worse but we are working at it and we will conquer it in the next few years as far as dealing with the problem so uh i recommend that you uh try some things don't feel you're within the box ten thousand dollars is interesting but i think your political pressure is worth way more and you can accomplish way more with that thank you for now thank you caller 4176 i will unmute you and you will have three minutes to
Thank you. I can't hear you. Can you hear me now? Yes. Hello. Okay, sorry. Thank you for taking my call. And I really appreciate this. You guys are discussing the same neuter that needs to be done. I think there obviously has been a big problem with overpopulation. I also think it should include licensing, registration, affordable state of neuter because I think if people can afford it, they're more likely to bring it in. But knowing how many animals you have within your community and making sure that there isn't any backyard breeding going on would be a huge help to reduce the population as well. I know some vets will probably maybe give a discount and make it affordable for you know,
people that live in the area and as the gentleman before me has said Randers Rescues managed to get a lot of money from people that really do care about animals so if we could get that help with somebody that's maybe trustworthy more could be done I noticed that where I'm from a spay is like almost $700 for a medium-sized dog and that's basically because the veterinarian offices in our area have all become more of a corporate versus a personal vet and I think that when the volume of money of being transpired is made affordable to normal working people I'm sure that they would do more to protect their animals than just let everything fall to pieces I guess I'm sure I have a lot more to say but I'm sure I have a lot more to say but I'm sure I have a lot more to say this is all I can say for the moment
Thank you. Thank you. Caller 7108, I will unmute you and you will have three minutes. Good morning. This is Bonnie Blackberry from Southern Humboldt. We lost our vet down here and to take an animal to Fortuna or Eureka, just going up there and back cost a bunch of money. And the amount that it costs to get a dog made is very expensive. I'm really glad you brought this to the board. And, I mean, you could make a deal with the Critters Without Lizards, people that are doing that, to be able to have little...
Who caused pay in New Jersey. So when we had Art at here, he was really good about how much he charged. But he's gone, and that would cost a lot more. Plus just the transportation cost. And I don't know, places like Willow Creek, people live out there, how far they have to go to see a vet. So thanks, and I hope the board can push this forward. Thank you. Thank you. That's all on Zoom, Chair. All right, bringing it to the room. This is your time to speak on the side. Wow, I am so glad this day is here. I want to thank you, Board of Supervisors, for talking about this. And I especially want to thank you, Michelle, for developing this microphone today. Thank you. Yep. And thank you everyone. Yes, come on up. . Yeah! Congratulations, Jennifer. You are the Crime Surveyist these days. We all know . My fellow at the students call me. Thank you so much for joining us. My name is Jennifer L mattabarro. below. .
You are my hero today. Let's all turn on the faucets in this entire building. And instead of turning them off, let's grab mops. And let's see how quickly those mops fill up. Let's don't turn off the faucets. Animals have suffered far too long. This is when I was 18, I got my first kitten. I lived in inner city Cleveland, and I went down to this shelter and adopted my first kitten when I moved out on my own. And at the time, they euthanized by air evacuation, so collapsing their lungs, or by gassing them, throwing cats in with dogs into these ice-solid chamber. Now we humanely euthanize them by a needle in the heart or an injection in the vein. Every animal fixed, what you have to understand, I've done this work for 39 years. Every animal fixed is saving your county money. I am
Saving your county money every single day. Every animal I take in, I took in seven on Saturday. Two weeks ago, I took in 20 cats in four days. I am saving you money. They're not going to the shelter. We want your support. We want your acknowledgement. We want your ear. We appreciate it more than I can stand up here and say. Okay. Humboldt Area Foundation does release their money. They've been doing it for years. The Freeman Fund had $4 million, and that translates to about $185,000 a year. That money is used up by the groups that are getting it, and there are more amazing new groups on board by about August of every year. And that is with primarily fixing females, dogs, cats, and feral cats. Okay. So, I believe this county will look highly upon each.
Every one of you, just for this discussion today, do you know how precious animals are to us? To almost every single human, animals are quite precious to us. And seeing them suffer and knowing they are suffering is very difficult for all of us that do this work. How do we make animals more valuable? We make less of them. I believe that everybody wants to do what's true and good, don't you think? It's tough times now. And I think that if you take and not pay for all of a spay and neuter, maybe that money covers 30% or 50% of a spay or neuter. I don't believe in doing everything for somebody. I do believe that can create a really weak community. I believe to ask people to do their very best and I think that you will see a lot of support for this. Thank you. Subtitles by the Amara.org community Okay.
Good morning. Before I read my notes, I just want to say thank you so much, Supervisor Bushnell. And I would like to say this is not a pet project, no pun intended by Ms. Bushnell. This is something that benefits the entire community, just like garbage collection, recycling, lots of things that we do that we know benefits the whole community. And spaying and neutering does benefit everyone. Now I read from my notes. Good morning, Chair Wilson and members of the board. My name is Janice Haschak. I am a resident of Arcata, and I'm here today as an animal lover and also someone who understands the fiscal demands of our county. I strongly support Agenda Item Number 1, sponsored by Supervisor Michelle Bushnell. Her proposal to allocate a baseline of $10,000 annually from the general fund to explore a partnership with a qualified nonprofit, and to help the community to achieve their goals, and to help the community to achieve their goals, is something that I would like to see in the future. I would like to thank the committee for their support. I would like to thank the committee for their support. I would like to thank the committee for their support. I would like to thank the committee for their support. I would like to thank the committee for their support. I would like to thank the committee for their support. I would like to thank the committee for their support. I would like to thank the committee for their support. I would like to thank the committee for their support. I would like to thank the committee for their support. I would like to thank the committee for their support. I would like to thank the committee for their support. I would like to thank the committee for their support. I would like to thank the committee for their support.
The profit for Spea and Nooter Services is a practical and fiscally responsible investment for Humboldt County. According to public records, our regional animal shelter has a total operating budget of $1.5 million. Although cities contribute a share through service contracts, the county still bears a net cost of hundreds of thousands of dollars every year out of our local general fund. This trial run targets the root cause of that financial burden by preventing unwanted litters before they happen. As the staff report notes, the initial $10,000 allocation will directly fund approximately 20 dog and 40 cats, Spea and Nooters, which will help us gauge public demand. Because a single unspayed cat and her offspring can produce well over 100 kittens in just a few short years, every single procedure, prevents dozens of future shelter intakes. Furthermore, because staff is directed to seek matching dollars, this initial...
county investment has the potential to double its impact through private donations. A significant portion of the shelter's daily operational strain stands directly from the sheer volume of cats and dogs entering the facility. Beyond the dollars and cents, this volume places immense burden on our shelter staff and volunteers who face the emotional impact of shelter space constraints every single day. By reducing the number of cats and dogs arriving at the shelter in the first place, we reduce our county's remaining budget gap and protect staff well-being. For many working families and rural residents across our county, the barrier to spaying or neutering isn't a lack of care, it's accessibility and cost. Partnering with a qualified nonprofit opens doors for targeted community outreach where help is needed most. Spaying and neutering supports the community's need for health and well-being. It suppresses the biological urge for animals to roam, which drags
cuts down on loose packs, spread of disease, territorial behavior, dog bites, and traffic hazards on our county roads. Can you finish up? Also, when these programs are coordinated through qualified nonprofits, they are frequently paired the surgeries with essential vaccinations helping to actively control disease risks like rabies. Okay. Thank you so much and thank you Supervisor Bushnell. You're kind and compassionate. Thank you. Hello, this is Joanne McGarry. I just want to remind you that I've shared with you in the past that I have a 16-year background working at the San Francisco SPCA in the 80s and 90s. I was an executive secretary to a very visionary executive director, Rich Avanzino, and I was also for a few years a California state humane officer and had to do some investigation in cruelty issues in San Francisco.
It is, to its benefit, a county and city all in one in a very confined 49 square mile place in an urban environment. So it's quite different here than Humboldt. And I've been out of animal welfare directly for this whole century. And I really appreciate the desire to help animals. And I think I want to remind you that when I spoke earlier this year in regards to the Miranda situation, I suggested a few things. And one was potentially looking at animal control as something outside of the Sheriff's Department. And, you know, I'll give that one up for the time being. But I also want to say that an animal control and welfare commission, you just spoke about some of these other commissions and vacancies on it. Humboldt County. It could really benefit by a commission or a council of this sort.
Because there's a lot of interested people and you wouldn't have to worry about vacancies because the minute somebody stepped down, somebody else would fill it in. So I think they could handle a lot of these issues. And I totally appreciate the concern about county monies and where they're spent. You know, I have this issue with the homeless. You know, I think it's sometimes just pocket, you know, putting out pocket fires, what we do in certain situations. Um, the grand jury has said that the animal control center needs a lot of work, you know, and so here we're talking about $10,000 for spay neuter, but what are we doing about a roof or whatever other needs there are that the grand jury put forward for animal control? So I, um, really think that maybe go ahead and do this, make it sure it's maybe a one-time thing, but we need to be much more comprehensive. And that's what a commission could.
really present. I mean I applaud you Supervisor Bushnell for bringing this forward but this is a drop in the bucket and it's a much bigger issue than what ten thousand dollars will do. So think bigger and maybe again like I said this winter let's put our hats together so that come the new year we can figure out a better way to treat our animals in Humboldt County. All right thank you. I'm bringing it back to the board. I'm going to let Supervisor Bushnell start us off in this discussion. Oh wait all right you got it you got to step up if you're going to talk. Sleeping with y'all. My name is Paula Ray. I'm with Karuna Rescue here in Humboldt County and firstly I'd like to thank you for putting this forward. I did actually have a speech that I was going to read but after listening to some of your comments I was like oh my gosh comments. I think I'd like to look at those. So Mr. Bowen you had said about
The cost may be not going very far with having to set up administration, who works the money, who deals with it, insurance. We already have some amazing clinics here. We have Critters Without Litters, we have Humboldt Spay-Neuter. Would it not be the best reason, would it not be best to allocate the money to them? We know that they give great care, they have insurance, they have great surgeons, and the local animal community trusts them with our animals. The idea of it going through the Humboldt County Shelter, yes, you could do half-price adoption days, sounds great, but it wouldn't touch the problem. The dogs and cats, animals in need, are already out in our community. We as a rescue are overrun with dozens of calls every week asking us to...
help them get their pets spayed or neutered, take their unwanted litters, and it truly is overwhelming for every small rescue here in Humboldt County. And I think somebody also said it's not a county problem, but it is a county problem. It's a community problem, a county problem, and we're all watching animals in our community suffer. I mean, yes, 10,000 drop in the bucket, but it's a start. Humboldt Area Foundation donate millions, but if you're a small rescue or a homeowner or somebody on a limited budget, Humboldt Area Foundation is not helping you spay or neuter your pet. It's an overwhelming problem. It's a start, and if you could see your way clear to make this happen, I mean, any difference, is a difference.
Okay, thank you for the time and thanks again, Michelle. My name is Jennifer Raymond and first I want to thank Michelle Bushnell for bringing this forward and for the board considering it. I believe yes it's a drop in the bucket but it's a start and I would love to see Humboldt County leading the way in beginning to focus on prevention because prevention is the solution to pet overpopulation. Yes ten thousand dollars according to the staff report would do 40 cats and 20 dogs. If all those animals were allowed to breed for just one year normal birth rates we'd be looking at 720 kittens and puppies. That's how many we can prevent. The other thing though about the staff report is they were assuming that we would be paying the full
amount for each of these animals. The fact is that we will be asking for each pet owner to contribute and if each pet owner could just contribute 50 percent of the cost we'd be looking at 120 animals not 60 animals. I founded both of the spay and neuter clinics. Our costs have gone up tremendously. We base our prices strictly on our costs. We figure out what it costs us for everything that we do and that's what our prices are. Unfortunately the smallest dog now is $300 and that's significantly more than a lot of people can afford especially for a large dog and if that large dog breeds she's going to produce 12 to 15 puppies and those puppies eventually will very likely you know they're going to be able to live with their dogs. So we're going to be asking for a lot of money and we're going to be asking for a lot of money. We're going to be asking for a lot of money and we're going to end up being
Dealt with by animal control. We're already spending over a million dollars a year on animal control. So we're asking for a very, very small amount to go toward prevention. It's a first step. I am also working on statewide to get legislation to begin in California looking at prevention rather than simply dealing with the symptoms of the problem. And the other thing I want to say is that I am prepared to match this amount. If the county will allocate this, I'm prepared to double it as a spay and neuter fund for this year. So I hope you will consider it. I would like to see Humboldt County be the leader in the state in saying we're recognizing that prevention is the solution. Thank you. Okay.
Is there anyone left? No one's jumping up. I am closing public comment. I'm going to bring it back to Supervisor Bush now, sort of lead off the conversation. And hopefully also, well, actually, if it's all right, can I have staff respond? If there's anything that staff wants to respond to, what was said by public, and then we'll bring it back to the board. No, I just wanted to point out that our office isn't advocating that the funding coming to us. I'm just letting you know that should that be your board's direction, this is how we could do it. So I just wanted to make sure that that was clear. And Jennifer's correct. The costs are definitely going up. We're seeing a pretty significant increase with our new contract next year. You know, the smallest dog, you know, zero to 25 pounds is going to be $290 for us. So the costs are escalating. Yeah, so just wanted to make sure that that was clear to everybody. Okay. And bring up if the CAO has anything to.
Add in terms of these. I don't have anything to add. OK. Bringing it back to Supervisor Bushnell and that there's more questions from the board and discussion. This is the time. Thank you. I first want to thank all the commenters and I also want to thank the Sheriff's Department. We when we had I think there was two meetings around this item with outside folks the Sheriff's Department and the CIO to try to figure out and you know be able to have a thorough discussion today. The Sheriff's Department has a lot of numbers and data because of the animal shelter. And so I really appreciate their work around that. I personally wouldn't I would want this to go to spade and neuter for the community. That is where people are struggling. And I see in the rural areas and you all probably see the same thing I see that I have folks ask me I want to spay or neuter my animal but I can't afford it or I can't get my animal up there. And I think. With. You know building on.
$10,000 I think community I know community members will put money in and towards and I would really love to see I know it's a drop in the bucket it's not much money and I know like some of the board members said earlier it's not our problem but that's to me it's not the right attitude it is our problem I see abandoned animals everywhere you did yeah anyways I just would appreciate if this board would consider us funding one of the spay and neuter programs so that the outside areas folks just community members could utilize it I think it's a great idea to say if you can put 50 percent towards the spay and neuter then we can help you with 50 percent that's a really good pathway because some most people can afford something they just can't afford all of it and so I would appreciate the discussion from this board you yeah hold on I just have to respond because I was just
Someone just put words into my mouth. No, so I'm going to clarify that you said financially, you don't think it's the county's responsibility to fund things like this. That's what you said. So not that you didn't support spay and neuter from spay and neuter programs. Okay, so speaking out of context, great. Please don't put words into my mouth because it's not what I said. And it's, and that is, yeah. We do have a problem with animal control and we have a problem with overpopulation and it does lead to issues around, and significant issues around animals being mistreated and abandoned and all of those things. And we don't want any of those things to happen. And we just, as a county, absolutely don't want any of those things to happen. We, as was mentioned, put in over a million dollars a year towards this.
towards this issue. So there's not, and $78,000 specifically around in, you know, it seems like in a recirculating fund in terms of what we do and what we manage for spay and neutering. So it's not like there's nothing being done and it's not like this county doesn't do those things. What I was getting at specifically is that we have many issues in our community that are important. And my concern is that we don't generally bring special issues to this board, you know, at $10,000 chunks to have long conversations about that and then talk about whether or not that's going to, it was interesting because I heard several times, this is a start. Well, that is kind of a concern that this is a start because I'm not really, I'm not really sure. I'm not really sure. I'm not really clear where the end is on that. There's been questions about whether we should have a
A license fee. Many counties and jurisdictions have fees, a license fee for animals, and it helps subsidize and... Well, I mean, okay. Well, it's not on the collar though, right? It's not on my cat anyway, I don't know. Anyways, I'm not, maybe I am out of compliance, but I take my cat to the vet. Thank you very much for the conversation from everybody. Let's try and hold it down, you guys. Jeez, one person at a time, please. I get all my cats from our shelter at the county, just want to say. Love that space, and I think they do a wonderful job. And I get them spayed, and neutered, or whichever they are. Anyways, what I'm getting at is maybe we need to increase, if we have a fee for that, then we need to increase it. I just feel like there's... There's got to be ways that we can do this so that it's programmatically happening without just...
of like pulling off little bits and pieces and then starting this whole thing about is it a start where does it go we don't really know it's a concern and we have all kinds of organizations that have all kinds of needs in our community so what i'm asking here a little want some clarification on if if we can is there was one idea about giving money to the sheriff's department and in in subsidizing the efforts that they do there and i see that really services kind of one space and and you guys go through basically the place in mckinleyville and it's kind of and i can see how that doesn't really provide necessarily access to folks farther away or it's just not as accessible necessarily and and i think there's an expectation or a question about whether money would go to a non-profit and we have to administer that to a certain degree has to meet all of our qualifications and requirements both insurance
and the administration of all that, and I would expect that we would get some reporting back about what happened with that. We heard a donation offer of $10,000. I assume that's from a private fund and not necessarily from another nonprofit, because, again, someone's offering someone else's money if it's from an organization versus their own, and so my expectation is that's a personal offer. And so, again, I don't dismiss that this isn't a problem that affects the entire community. My point is that we have to understand where this is going to go every time we bring this up. And I guess I have a question. You keep talking about these meetings. Do we have these meetings here, or who was having the meetings at the time? I had the meetings. Okay, because when you said we, I was like, we who? And I asked staff to attend. This is something that bothers me a lot, the Spanish.
neuter availability in Humboldt County and the folks that can't afford the sheriff's department they recoup their spay and neuter the seventy eight thousand dollars that you're talking about when you adopt an animal so you probably adopt if you adopted a cat my question was who was at the meetings that you're talking about so when you're talking about uh you know the sheriff's department they recoup their spay and neuter neutering so I said earlier the sheriff was there the CAO was there Jennifer was there I was there and I asked for a meeting with those people in the room so that I could thoughtfully put something together to bring it to this board we also discussed this at budgetary time on the dais about spay and neuter I don't know if you remember but we talked about it then and I had said that I would bring an item back which I'm doing now okay great um thanks for answering this question supervisor Arroyo and then supervisor Bo okay okay okay okay see yo okay so you you too you you so so so so so see so see see so see going but yeah yeah
Thanks. This is an important conversation, obviously. I think there's no question that we all love and care about animals. We are all animal lovers, and these have been some difficult months for sure. And as has been mentioned, we've had findings relating to needs at the animal shelter for a long time, and we all are aware of that and appreciate that the grand jury has brought it up and appreciate that staff themselves have brought it up. And one of our public commenters mentioned the promotion of adoptable animals, and that was something I tried on, tried out, was a couple different ways of promoting some of the animals by featuring an adoptable animal of the month. This is something I saw other supervisors throughout the state doing. And so we had... The
One of the folks from the shelter bring in a dog to the chambers, which was fun, to promote that, you know, adoptable animal. And then I went up to the shelter a few times and took photos with animals and really just trying to highlight some of the adoptable pets and quickly realized that our shelter staff were really at capacity and really checked in with myself about whether it was about the animals or about me or us or trying to, you know, look good or something. And so instead of that, I've just been highlighting and sharing a lot of the posts from the volunteers. So that's something we could explore again is whether our board wants to kind of have a more comprehensive program where we highlight adoptable pets. But I stepped away from making that a big feature and instead have just been really trying to amplify the work that our shelter staff and volunteers are already doing. Just incidentally.
So I really appreciate the idea of having, I know that when we do have adoptable pet free day, free events where someone is sponsoring the pet adoption fees, the line is like around the block. It's out the door. So that's a big incentive for people to adopt adoptable pets, which is wonderful. And I hear loud and clear that what we're asking, what folks are asking for in the community is something different to add to the pot of funds available to ensure that people have some kind of spay neuter voucher. And I've heard a couple different ideas. So I appreciate that there's potentially matching funds out there. I love that. What I'm thinking about is. The boring but important stuff, which is the contracting requirements and some of the insurance requirements and what steps we have to go through to get this money.
out the door. If we are to go through with this, which is a beautiful idea, we want to make sure that it goes as far as possible. And so that's what I'm hearing reflected up here. It's not a lack of caring about animals or caring about this issue. It's that it needs to happen in an as effective and streamlined a way as possible if we are to embark on this and try to address this problem. And I also don't want to really open the door to the ongoing needs of the community sort of coming in in small amounts and us feeling like that's something that we can take on. That to me needs to be more strategic. But this is a one-off in response to a big community concern that has come to the fore. And so I sort of in the position where it's pretty hard to say no.
So I am curious if we could, if we have explored, and I apologize because I wasn't at the meeting so I don't know and it's not in the staff report, whether we've explored the county shelter increasing our, and whether there's the capacity to increase the contract with the existing provider and whether we can route funds for some kind of voucher program for pets that are not affiliated with the shelter but are not fixed through what we already do, thinking that that might reduce administrative burden. Has that, was that explored in your meeting and could you speak to that? Yes, we talked to the sheriff about that and I'm gonna let their fiscal person talk about that. We don't have the administrative staff to do something like that. So I mean I, it really, anything that comes through the shelter, animals that you know are abandoned, or that have been found.
And so, you know, what I'm hearing too is that there's, you know, they want to do something different where it's not any animals that are actually touching the shelter. And I really do not see how we could administer something like that. You know, we do have a really maxed out staff, you know, that is already running that shelter, both administratively and, you know, operationally handling the kennels. So I don't see how we could do that. That's helpful to know. Yeah, I talked with some other county supes around the state who do have, like, voucher programs that they administer with all the different local law enforcement agencies who come into contact with animals in the course of their work and organizations. And they, you know, kind of have a voucher program. That sounds like more to set up than we have the bandwidth for right now. But it is something that I, you know, I'm aware that other people do. So I wanted to ask about it. And then I also, since it sounds like Humboldt Area Foundation has an existing. Fund that already sends funds out the door.
It's already set up to do this. And it's not like they have money. They're given money by donors, right, to get out to the community under certain criteria. It sounded like that is utilized fully every year, the amount available. So my other question was whether we had explored routing the funds through them because we have existing relationships with the Humboldt Area Foundation over, you know, giving funding. So I think this is a question for staff. Sure. Or Supervisor Richelieu, whether that has been, was... Yeah, and I think it's a good question. There seems to be a sidebar. So the question is, is the potential to asking, Supervisor Roy is asking if there's a potential for routing monies potentially coming from our general fund through HAF. And would that just add to the existing fund, which is now, I think, at $4 million, but I guess it seems like, that it is...
What's coming off that fund annually is $180,000. Is that what I heard? I just wanted to, when we had the discussion with the meeting that I was in and talked about Humboldt Area Foundation receiving the funds, I think that if that was the route we were to go, if the county decides to do that, if the board decides to do this, and I want to recognize that, you know, this is obviously a sensitive subject, and there's a lot around, a lot of passion around the issue, so I want to recognize that. But we, I think, could be specific that we could route the money through Humboldt Area Foundation to go and then for them to give it out to SPAY, the Humane Society SPAY neuter clinic, and that was something we talked about in our meeting. CAO? We, again, to my comments earlier, that it would require an agreement, would essentially be like a grant to them, so there would be some expectations on reporting out, and they would probably be, probably be better equipped to meet our insurance requirements.
My suggestion to your board would be if you are interested in using County General Fund for this purpose to give us that direction whether it's one-time or ongoing and then we can work with the Sheriff's Office to determine the best vehicle to effectuate your board's will. I hear you Supervisor Bowen I just have a quick question sorry I'm take the chair's prerogative here the the question I have is about that is there's kind of like two zones of discussion one is through the Sheriff's Office which is kind of effectuate really supporting their their program which is really I'm going to say is McKinleyville centered and then there's the question about the outer lying areas and how to how to and it's not just folks in those areas but there's also stray animals that people capture and neuter and spay that happens also out there and I think that's important. Thank you. So there's
There's that one direction, and then there's like, I don't even know how we effectuate what we've been talking, you know, this other method to that. I'm just going to leave that, sit there, and take this to Supervisor Bones and give him some time because he's been waiting patiently. Yeah, I, again, I want to thank Supervisor Bushnell just like everybody else, and in no way was I questioning the organizations. You guys run on a shoestring when I said administration. I'm just saying for us, last week, in a very short amount of time, we gave $2.4 million of tax dollars out for different programs on our consent calendar. We're going on over an hour on $10,000, and as Supervisor Wilson said, we're eating that money up with all the staffing and everything else that's like this. I will tell you, give me a day, and I will get you guys $10,000. I'll make some phone calls. I'll get you $10,000. And then... And then this county can work out amongst themselves how they're going to...
I'll just make some phone calls to people who love dogs. I'm just saying, I'm going to get them $10,000 whether we do it or not. I say we give them $10,000 and streamline it and we kill two birds with one stone. And I think if we do that, I'm just saying we're talking this to death and I think this is such a great idea that Michelle has brought forward and she's spent meetings and how much time have we got with that? We're talking $10,000, guys, and I'm not saying, somebody said budget dust or anything else. I'm really cognizant of $10,000. That's everything else. But last week we brought back illegal dumping and we all said illegal dumping is terrible and everything else. I got nothing but phone calls this week that says why don't we pay and Steve's a proponent of this, why don't we pay for garbage? Do you know how much that would cost us? And we're talking, Michelle's asking for $10,000 to help these organizations without all the BS. Now, the problem being...
is you hit the nail on the head. We have our insurance requirements. You guys don't want to come anywhere near those. We have a $2 million rider that you're going to have to carry. I don't imagine you're doing a $2 million. I imagine you've got a million, because I deal with that at the ball fields. So if we could find a way that our CAO could come back very quickly and say, we can do it this way. I can't believe it can't be done, or else we can talk another half hour for it. But I'll go find you some money, and if this board can find it in themselves to give the money that Supervisor Bushnell has asked for and has met on without eating it up with everybody sitting around, I think that would be a win-win. That's just what I would hope for. I've just heard that $10,000 turned into $30,000. I'm going to make a motion that we direct the CAO to come back with an item to annually fund $10,000 a year. For spay and neuter.
Second. Yeah, we're talking annually. We're not talking... All right, all right. I just think this is... I'm much more comfortable for a one-time, I will say, so we can get a report back on how this actually works. Because I don't know how it's going to... We haven't determined how it's going to work yet. Chair, I think that the COO will bring all that information back. So could you call for the vote, please? Hold on one second. Yeah, I'm the chair. I don't know if you've forgotten, but maybe. All right, so is there any more discussion from the board on this? And CAO, how do you... When, what kind of timing... Yeah, there's a second on that, yeah. What kind of timing do you think we have for that? Like before the next fiscal year? Yeah, yeah. Okay. So before the next fiscal year, we'll be talking about this again, but we'll have a proposal on the table for $10,000. Okay.
Here which I'm now expecting to be 30,000 not from us but in commitments from the community and Supervisor Bone. So with that do we have a do we have any objection to unanimous consent seeing none motion passes and we are moving on to closed session items. Thanks, Jenny. Kaylee it's so warm in here. Yeah, we're going into closed session. So we'll take a 10 minute break before we go, right? We're at closed session? There's four of us here right now.
Go ahead, council. Thank you, Chair Wilson. It is the intention of the board to meet in closed session pursuant to California government code section 54957.6 in order to review the county's position and instruct its designated labor negotiators. It is also the intention of the board to meet in closed session pursuant to California government code section 54956.9 D2 and E1 in order to discuss exposure to litigation in one potential case. Finally, it is the intention of the board to meet in closed session pursuant to California government code section 54956.9 D4 in order to discuss the initiation of litigation in one potential case. Okay, do we have any online comments? Yes, we do.
Caller 7718, I will unmute you and you will have three minutes. The first question is anticipated time for closed session and report out. My comment is, again, they're still playing games with the employees there. I've seen this going on for many years and I don't think it's great for the morale of your employees, but play the games. Regarding potential litigation, you're going to initiate one. Again, I've always cautioned on that one. You can be counter sued. And then, of course, there's the blank check, which is who do you think, who do you anticipate suing you? And I personally feel that you're one of your biggest potential lawsuits has to do with DHHS, CWF, the misuse of diagnosis, fraudulently, the misuse of all kinds of things while you're dealing with the children's welfare there.
Good luck and thank you for my opportunity to participate for Mexico today. Things seem to be a lot less complicated and people go on and on and on about small amounts of money. It should be a no brainer to just go ahead and take things and do things such as pay for staying neutral or partial. Thank you for having me here to speak. That is all online, Chair. Anyone in the house that wants to speak to things that are on our closed session? Seeing none, we're going to go into closed session. Let's see, it is 1051 if we could meet in closed session at 1105. That would be great. How long? I would estimate an hour and a half to two hours. Great. Mr. Black, are you hearing that? Enjoy your lunch. Enjoy your lunch. Exactly. Thank you, Mr. Black. Thank you, everybody. All right. Thank you, everybody. Thanks, everybody. Thank you. Thank you, sir. I appreciate it. It was an honor being here. Thank you very much. Thank you. Thank you. Good night. Good night.
you all right And we are back. Council, will you please report out from closed session? Thank you, Vice Chair Arroyo. There was no reportable action taken with regard to items J1 and J2. With regard to item J3, the board voted unanimously to approve the initiation of litigation.
one case the specific action defendants and other particulars shall once formally commenced be disclosed upon inquiry unless to do so would jeopardize the county's ability to effectuate service of process on one or more unserved parties or that to do so would jeopardize the county's ability to conclude existing settlement negotiation to its advantage asset fourth in california government code section 54957.1a2 all right and with that we are adjourned and we will see folks next week