Humboldt County Planning Commission
Thursday, February 6, 2025
The agenda


6:01 p.m.

Thank you. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. All right. Well, this is, I'll warn you, this is my first meeting as chair, so my goal is to run an organized, respectful, and engaging meeting as prior chairs have done. So, with that, Laura, if you could take roll, please. Commissioner Scavdahl? Here. Commissioner Mulder? Here.


6:02 p.m.

Commissioner Levy? Here. Commissioner Curiazzi? Here. Commissioner O'Neill? Here. Commissioner Lorna McFarland? Thank you. Director Ford, are there any agenda modifications this evening? Yes, Chair Scavdahl. There are a few that I would like to bring to your attention. The first one is an item that's on the consent calendar. It's item number E5. It's a coastal development permit and conditional use permit. And this has a new condition of approval. Just to reflect that some of the other things that are on the site plan aren't being approved. Only what's being requested is being approved. Then this is not a supplemental before you, but I just wanted to call it to your attention.


6:03 p.m.

Attention so that there was clarity. Item number E7, Humboldt Heritage Farm. The project description says it's for 20,400 square feet. That is absolutely correct. It's correct in most of the, it's correct in the resolution. There is one place in the staff report that identifies it as 16,660 square feet. That is a typo. That should be 20,400. And then item F2, this is a public hearing item. This is for Evergreen Exotics. There, it's just to correct the name on the applicant. It's Evergreen Exotics. I think it was shown as Humboldt Exotics. Correct. Yeah. Is everything?


6:04 p.m.

That's everything. All right. Thank you. At this time, we'll take public comment on non-agenda items. So if there's anybody in the audience or on Zoom that would like to address the commission on matters pertinent to the commission but that are not on this evening's agenda, now's the time to do so. So just check with the audience in the room. Does anybody wish to speak at this time? See none. And Zoom attendees, has anybody raised their hand? Okay. See none. Yeah, you might. Yeah, you're on. Yeah, I can see it. Okay. Then we'll close public comment on non-agenda items and we'll move to the consent agenda. I think we have seven items on consent. All right.


6:05 p.m.

I'll go through the items if any chair just in fairness I hand did just pop up oh excuse me I can't see who's that attendee 7108 okay so 7108 if you'd like to address the Commission on public comment please do so you have three minutes yes we can yes we can hear you 7108, can you unmute? We can hear you.


6:06 p.m.

Mission. Public comment. Nope. Can you hear me? Yes, we can. Um. Yes, we can hear you. Okay, I just want to say that you're not coming across on the phone. I can hear you on the computer, but the phone... 7-108, can you unmute? We can hear you. Okay, I understand your comment that it's not coming through on the phone. Hello? Yes, we can hear you. Yes, it's not, your audio is not coming through on the phone. Yeah, I think that we understand.


6:07 p.m.

See what we can do to rectify that. Thank you for bringing that to our attention. Okay, thanks. Chair, could I suggest that we take a short break to figure this out? Okay, let's think we need five minutes. Yeah. Okay, we'll be back in five minutes while we sort out some of the IT issues. Thank you.


6:08 p.m.

Thank you. Thank you. So you've got somebody that you're talking to right now? Mm-hmm. So, why don't you bring back up Laura and let's test? Okay.


6:09 p.m.

Thank you. How do we're just trying to see if we've got this matter resolved. Can you hear me clearly now on the telephone? Okay. Sounds like we have that cleared up. Thank you for pointing that out. So we will close public comment on non-agenda items, and we'll go back to the consent agenda. I will go through each item and poll the commission and the public to see if anybody wants to pull any of these items off of consent for discussion. Otherwise, we will take them up as one matter. I have to close the consent agenda. So I'm going to bring the first two together, which is the action item. The action summaries from the December 5th and the December 19th.


6:10 p.m.

meeting. Anybody on the commission want to pull any of the action summaries? And I'll check with the public here and online and seeing none. I'll go to item three, which is a conditional use permit for telecommunications and it's a continuance. So if anybody wants to discuss the continuance of this item, we can pull it. Seeing none on the commission and none in public from the audience. Item four is Laurel Tree Charter School Coastal Development Permit Extension. It's also a continuance to February 20th meeting. So anybody want to discuss that continuance? Seeing none on the commission, none in the audience.


6:11 p.m.

or on Zoom. We'll go to item five, which is the coastal development permit and conditional use permit at 4050 Highway 101. This is the conversion of a short-term vacation rental to traditional apartments. This also has the supplemental item 1A5 that's noting that it's only for this and not for any other building permit issues. Commissioners and checking the audience, nobody in person or on Zoom have raised their hands. Let's stay on. Item six, lockbox storage. This is the storage LLC for a self-storage facility in the Glendale area.


6:12 p.m.

Anybody on the commission? In the public, looking for the audience, and I see no hands raised online, so that will stay on. And item seven, Humboldt Heritage Farm Management, LLC, in the Eddardsburg area, conditional use permit and special permit. Commissioners? In the public, in the audience, or online, I see no hands raised, so all items remain on consent. We'll entertain a motion. Mr. Chairman, I would move approval of items one through seven, all items on the consent agenda. I'd second that. We have a motion from Commissioner Levy and a second from Commissioner Mulder. Any discussion on the motion? No, I think we can just, I'll just call for the motion.


6:13 p.m.

Vote all those in favor signify by aye. Aye. Opposed? Hearing none. We'll move on to item F, public hearings. The first public hearing item is HUMSUN 3 LLC conditional use permit and special permit. We will hear from the staff and then commissioners, if you have any questions of staff, we'll take those and then we'll open a public hearing. Before we get started, I just wanted to note that I see that GHD did some of the studies on this project. And in the past, I have recused myself on projects where GHDs... I've done some of the work, but I'm no longer with GHD and I've had no income from GHD for more than 12 months.


6:14 p.m.

Oh, I believe I do not have a conflict and I've checked with legal and they confirm so that conflict is removed and so I'm going to remain to hear this item. Thank goodness. I just want to pause the computer crashed. Oh, excuse me. We need to take another break. Yes, please. The zoom computer. Okay, so we will we'll break for you need five minutes longer. You don't know. We'll check back at 20 after the hour. Okay.


6:20 p.m.

Thank you. Thank you. Hello. Okay, yeah, I can't tell unless they hear something that's supposed to be...


6:21 p.m.

Go for a test. I don't know how we test it. All right. So we think we have, are we back? Do you have me on Zoom? I'm getting audio from the room, so I can't tell unless it is somebody coming in over Zoom. Oh. So we have people in the audience telling us that they're connecting. Okay. Okay. So are we going to, I'm checking, are we ready to resume? Yes. Okay. So we will open the public hearing on Humsun 3 and turn it over to you, Director Ford.


6:22 p.m.

Thank you. Good evening commissioners. My name is Rodney Andell with Humboldt County Planning and I'll be presenting for Humsun 3 LLC Conditional Use Permit and Special Permit project in the Bloxburg area Okay, I'm in control now. The project is located where that push pin is, off Alder Point Road in the Bloxburg area, a little bit north of Bloxburg, as you can see there in the aerial imagery. The project consists of a conditional use permit for 3.1 acres of new mix-like cannabis cultivation. There will be two ancillary support buildings totaling 7,280 square feet.


6:23 p.m.

feet with wastewater treatment. Water for irrigation and domestic use will be sourced from three permitted groundwater wells. The annual water use is estimated at 1,720,250 gallons with 12.7 gallons per square foot per year for irrigation. Also proposed is 250,000 gallons of hard tank water storage. Thank you. There will be a maximum of 18 employees anticipated for peak operation. Usually there will be 10 on site, but during peak times of the year there will be 18. Renewable power will be supplied by Redwood Coast Energy Authority or the equivalent and by solar. Mixed light cultivation will not occur until the property receives grid power upgrade. The project closes.


6:24 p.m.

Parcel is accessed directly off Alder Point Road, which is a Category 4 road with a centerline stripe. A special permit is required for project-related wetland impacts, creation and enhancement, riparia area creation and enhancement, and the reconnection of a Class 3 ephemeral drainage. This is the project parcel. It's rather large, and I'm attempting to point at some things. I've got control now. Up on the ridge here, there are three wells, one here, one here, one here, that supply water for the project. And this area here will be where 180,000 gallons of water stores will be. I want to point at this area here. Apologize. If I press, it changes it. This area here is what's known as the mid-ridge area, and I'll be referencing it. I'll be referencing that later in the discussion. And this area here is where the water will be.


6:25 p.m.

Here by Alder Point Road is the main project area. This is a close-up of what the main project area looks like now. There's the agricultural field with the residents, and there's a couple barns there. This is the site plan for that main area. And as you can see here, there's the greenhouses here. Up in this area where I'm pointing now is a bioswale. And here's some more tanks here. These are the two ancillary structures, one here, one here, with parking and a septic located at this location here. This project will impact some wetlands on the agricultural field. Wetland mitigation. Wetland mitigation will occur at a three-to-one ratio, resulting in...


6:26 p.m.

Over two acres of new or enhanced wetlands for the 0.87 acres of seasonal wetland impacted by the project. This includes 0.45 acres of riparian enhancement and creation of 1.1 acres of riparian area through the reconnection of a Class III water course. This slide here shows wetland impacts and creation. The pink area are the seasonal wetlands to be impacted by the project. The blue areas are the wetland to be created. The green areas are wetlands to be enhanced. And the yellow areas are wetlands to be, or riparian areas to be enhanced. This area here is showing the reconnection of the Class III stream. Traditionally, there's a culvert there under the road, and the stream, or the water from the culvert, would just go out and flow onto this field.


6:27 p.m.

But now it's going to be reconnected to Cooper Creek. California Oatgrass is going to be impacted by the project. 0.21 of 5.53 acres of California Oatgrass will be impacted. Mitigation for these impacts will occur at a 2 to 1 ratio. The proposed mitigation area is the mid-ridge site that I showed you earlier, with about 7.6 acres of existing California Oatgrass already existing in the area. In the mid-ridge area. The purple here on the slide shows the Oatgrass that will be impacted by the project, and the orange areas show the Oatgrass that will not be impacted and will remain on site in the locations you see there. Environmental review.


6:28 p.m.

For the project, included a lot of different analysis. Of these included air quality analysis, botanical studies, biological studies, aquatic and wetland studies, wetland mitigation summary, well connectivity studies, a noise study, and septic suitability survey. A mitigated negative declaration was prepared for the project. And during the preparation of this document, numerous mitigation measures were proposed in the areas of air quality, biological resources, cultural resources, tribal cultural resources, energy, geology and soils, and hydrology and water quality. Staff supports the project as mitigated, conditioned, and proposed, and recommends that the commission adopt. The initial study and mitigated negative.


6:29 p.m.

negative declaration for the HUM-SUN 3 commercial cannabis cultivation project, make all the required findings for approval of this conditional use permit and special permit, and adopt the resolution approving the HUM-SUN 3 conditional use permit and special permit subject to the recommended conditions of approval. This concludes my presentation. I'm available, other staff is available, and the project agents are available if you guys have any questions. Thank you. Thank you. Commissioner, do you have any questions for staff at this time? Commissioner Curiazzi? Thank you. I just have a question regarding the sedge meadow, and there was a comment regarding the rarity of that sedge meadow, and I was kind of curious if you could elaborate a little bit on that in terms of the mitigation. With the mitigation efforts,


6:30 p.m.

I'm curious what the rarity of looking how rare the the meadow is and what the mitigation would look like. If I recall correctly it was kind of vague on the rarity that's was the there was a question mark and a number but that and I hope I'm saying this right and I know that their agent would probably say this better. But the rarity wasn't really confirmed but I do know that the mitigation will be part of the wetland enhancement and creation if that helps. Any other questions? Okay we'll take public comment now and we'll first the applicant or their agent if you'd like to address the commission. You have up to 10 minutes. Good evening commissioners and staff. My name is Paraj White. I'm with North.


6:31 p.m.

consulting group and me and my team have helped package up this version of the project. I wanted to note that in the staff report you would see that this project originally was submitted over eight years ago as a 1.0 project taking advantage of the more than 300 acres and allowing up to three acres and then I think it was 1100 acres so that or 1200 excuse me the project originally was proposed at 12 acres using that very large project area that you saw and taking advantage of that original ordinance language. The applicants spent tons of money tons of studies looked all over the property and were headed towards EIR for the project and then hence the extensiveness of the studies and the background that you see. There was some frustration on the applicants part with moving this through. We ended up chatting with them finding


6:32 p.m.

that, you know, there were, it was a significant project and reaching up on the ridge and it spread out all over that property. So we worked with the applicant to talk about what's really important. We worked with staff about what the issues are and the areas of impact and we identified that concentrating the project only on this meadow that's right next to Alder Point Road has a history of being an old race, a horse race track and been used for grazing and cattle operations for years and years, made the most sense for the application. The applicant was happy to reduce their application and hence the project fit within this ISMND that you're looking at. It has adopted most of all the fair argument standards that this commission and previous commissions in Humboldt County has adopted. So we're going to talk about that in a little bit. So I'm going to start with the first one. The first one is that the commission has established for a good cannabis project in the region. Our staff who's here this evening worked


6:33 p.m.

with Fish and Wildlife hand in hand through this version of the project and I'm just really proud that we brought it to you guys. I feel that the studies were extensive and staff was very thorough and again working with all the agencies so just wanted to add that light to the project and me and the team are here tonight if there's any questions that come up we're welcome or we'd be happy to answer them and if there is some public comment we would like the opportunity to come back and rebuttal whatever comments are made. Thank you. Yeah and we'll provide that opportunity. All right. Thank you. Thank you. Anybody else that would like to address the commission on this project at this time please come up to the podium. And I don't see anybody coming and I don't if so anybody off online raise your hands. Is it still? There are six.


6:34 p.m.

Star six, okay, to raise your hand. And I don't see any hands raised. Give him a couple minutes. Okay. There's a bit of a delay, isn't there? Yeah. Okay. Okay, seeing none, I'm going to close public comment and bring it back to the Commission. Commissioners, any further questions of staff? If not, I'll entertain a motion. Well, I just thought I would say I don't actually have any questions. The only question I had earlier today, Rodney already answered, just making sure there was no public comment received. But I think the fact that there wasn't speaks to how


6:35 p.m.

Well planned. This project has been. I appreciate Mr. White's explanation of the history of it because this is still a big project. And yet it seems it seems to me that all the impacts have been identified, mitigated or avoided. So I have no concerns about moving forward. Commissioner Curiosi. Along the same lines, I just appreciate the applicant recognizing and taking the time to fully study their environment and the environment that they'll be existing and working in. Okay, I'm looking for a motion. I'll make a motion. I'll make a motion to adopt the resolution 25- which does the following. It adopts the mitigated negative.


6:36 p.m.

Declaration prepared for the HUMF SUN 3 LLC project pursuant to section 15074 of the state CEQA guidelines and finds a proposed project complies with the general plan and zoning ordinance and approves the conditional use permit and special permit subject to the conditions of approval. I'll second that. We have a motion from Commissioner O'Neill and a second from Commissioner Mulder. Any discussion on the motion? Seeing none, I'll call for a roll call. Call vote on public hearing matter. Commissioner O'Neill? Yes. Commissioner Curiazzi? Yes. Commissioner Mulder? Yes. Commissioner Scavdahl? Yes. Commissioner Levy? Yes. Thank you. Motion passes. Thank you. Thank you, staff. I will move to item two, open the public hearing on Evergreen Exotics LLC zone reclassification and and and


6:37 p.m.

I'll turn it over to you, Commissioner Ford, and staff for staff report. Excuse me, Director Ford. Gave you a promotion there. Sorry. Excellent. Chair Skavdal, members of the commission, good evening. My name is Stephen Santos, senior planner, presenting the Evergreen Exotics LLC project. Which is an ordinance amendment and zone reclassification involving seven parcels in the Redway area. The project location is in the Redway Business Park. And as mentioned at the top, involves these seven parcels. The ordinance amendment is to the commercial cannabis.


6:38 p.m.

land use ordinance which would allow indoor cultivation within the inland business park or mb zones that have a q qualified combining zone and so this is in tandem with a zone reclassification to adopt and apply a q qualified combining zone for indoor cultivation to seven parcels in the redway business park with performance standards the amendment to the ccluo is very surgical it inserts the underlying language that's on the screen to this one section which allows would allow indoor cultivation in the mb zone that have the q qualified combining zone you As already mentioned, the acute qualified combining zone is very surgical. It only


6:39 p.m.

applies to seven parcels within the business park and the additional in and in addition to the requirements of the CCLUO permits for indoor cultivation within the queue would be subject to eight performance standards relating to water energy and odor and those specific performance standards are in the staff report as well as the ordinance attachment that's in your packet. So real brief quick history the reason only seven parcels within that park are receiving the queue zone have to do primarily to parcels that already have water meters and were participants or were part of the community service district's most recent water capacity survey. No public comments were received. In fact, there were no public comments received. No public comments were received. In response to the notice for the project. Therefore, staff is recommending that the commission.


6:41 p.m.

32 parcels zoned MB. After receiving public comment on the original reclassification petition, it was determined the most suitable location for this proposal was the Redway Business Park. Was it initially being floated that it would be that this change, this Q zone might extend to other business parks elsewhere in the county? Through the chair, that is correct. The original petition contemplated why not open this up to all MB zones. But as part of the petition process, we received comment from the landowner that owns the majority, if not all of the MB zones in the northern county. And that landowner was not. Thank you.


6:42 p.m.

Thank you. Interested in in having first try out Allитель. So to accommodate that.


6:43 p.m.

Thank you. With that feedback, we made the application. Thank you. and more specific and targeted.


6:44 p.m.

Thank you. I particularly ask it would be a good bonus to have. Thank you. Thank you. Good questions. So we'll open for public comment on the zone reclassification. Anybody in the audience wish to address the commission, please do so. Hello. Good evening, chair and commissioners and staff. My name is Leah Nelson. I work with North Point Consulting. And we're just here to answer any questions. We've been working with the applicant and staff on this project. And we're happy to bring it to you and here to answer any questions. And, Stephen, you did the questions correctly about the water use numbers and things like that. So happy to be here. And let us know if you have any questions for us. All right. Thank you.


6:45 p.m.

Anybody else from the public wish to address the commission? Anybody online as well? Please indicate by pressing star six to raise your hand. It looks like we have one. I don't know how to identify who that is. It is 7108. It's showing up here. Thank you. Yes, we can hear you. Okay. A couple of items on the attachment 5A and PG&E. It says no impact. When I read what they put in that, they were saying a review indicates the proposed.


6:46 p.m.

improvements do not appear to directly interfere with existing higiene facilities or impact our easement rights it's been my understanding that we have a limited amount of power here in southern convo and it's going to be a while before more is happening so i'm just wondering if all these turn into indoor growth where's all that power can come from and also regarding the water i know that redway it seems every summer go through all this stuff because we don't have enough water and um was i hearing correctly that all the parcels up there are using that much water because remember


6:47 p.m.

There's a bunch of them that hardly use any water. So thank you. Thank you. I don't see any other hands. It's this time, just an applicant. We would give the applicant the opportunity for rebuttal. Applicant, if you'd like to come up and address any of the comments that have been made so far. Sure. You're welcome to. Absolutely. So, yes, there is a PG&E, you know, we're all aware of the PG&E crisis, but one of the special restrictions and performance standards that any applicant interested in having intercultivation on one of these seven parcels would have to meet is that they have to demonstrate existing on-site power from PG&E is on-site and adequate. For proposed cultivation. So they would have to already have that power in place. Thank you.


6:48 p.m.

and that could be, I mean, it just depends on the existing parcel as to whether or not they have that PG&E capacity already. And also I want to point out that for the ordinance, they would have to enroll in either carbon credits or enroll in RCEA's 100% renewable power requirement as well. And then for the water, there's a lot of back and forth with RCSD about the water for these parcels, and in the special restrictions and performance standards, that number is the 91,000 gallons per applicant is really the maximum that they would be allowed to take from RCSD, and that was based on RCSD's water capacity study, and we came to that number in collaboration with them. Any water in excess of that amount would need to be supplied from rainwater catchment, and they also need to demonstrate in a, what do we call it in here? In a...


6:49 p.m.

Water use and storage plan which they need to submit with their application to the county they have to describe All on-site activities how much water they use how they're going to comply With that limit of 91,000 if they need extra water where that's going to come from rainwater calculations to address how much storage they would need and Exactly how they're going to meet all these restrictions. So those are good points and they they require some extra detail in the applications Thank you I Want to close public comment and come back to staff to see if there's anything else you want to add to or Clarify with respect to the comments made I think Leah pretty much covered it all. I think the commenters questions and concerns are comprehensively addressed in the additional performance standards that are part of the Q zone standards a through F are all about water having a water plan for


6:50 p.m.

forbearance, acknowledgement that the operator will be subject to curtailment orders if they occur, things of that nature. And then there's another performance standard in there that any applicants will need to demonstrate that they will be able to have adequate energy from PG&E if they're using PG&E power. I just have a PG&E question. It's a business park, so there's already PG&E there. They're just opening up an account. And so when it comes to PG&E, I don't think there's a shortage of power. I think that PG&E is not wanting to extend power too far off the existing grid at this time, like into areas where it isn't already there. But if it's already there, I don't think there's a shortage of power to hook up to it, right? There is a shortage of power. But some parcels do actually have already the power right or the power extended. They just have to open an account. Yeah. And this is one of the things that we're trying to do. We're trying to do a lot of things. We're trying to do a lot of things.


6:51 p.m.

that already has a connection. At least one of them does, definitely. The others, that's why the performance standards exist. CHAIRMAN BRYANT. COMMISSIONERS, ANY OTHER QUESTIONS OF STAFF? SEEING NONE, COMMISSIONER CHIRIASI. I GUESS MORE OF A DISCUSSION WITH COMMISSIONERS. SO I GET, AND THEN WE CAN PUT QUESTIONS TO STAFF AS WELL. BUT I THINK MAYBE JUST, I'M FINDING THE REQUIREMENTS OF THE ZONING ORDINANCE. I'M CONFUSING THAT WITH WHAT MIGHT BE IMPOSED DURING THE PERMIT PROCESS. SO THE, IT SEEMS ODD TO ME THAT WE WOULD IMPOSE A SPECIFIC WATER CONSUMPTION AMOUNT IN THE ORDINANCE INSTEAD OF THAT WATER


6:52 p.m.

Assumption amount being provided as a condition by the services district upon pulling a permit. It seems like that would be a more appropriate place for it. Yeah, I think I would turn to Director Ford. I think that's a fair question. Oftentimes that is evaluated. But in this particular case, it's the best form of planning to look at things comprehensively. And that's what was done with the water. If seven parcels are going to be allowed to develop with all of these uses, and that's the assumption you have to make, then how much water could actually be available? So that's now been established. And that's been allocated to the seven parcels. And so what this really does is give. An applicant some certainty if they're coming in under that. They're not going to come in and have to negotiate, renegotiate the water.


6:53 p.m.

know what's already been negotiated they know what the expectations are and they know what they have to do to demonstrate that they have accounted for all the water so I would submit that it is really good planning to look at that kind of thing up front Commissioner Mulder. I'd just like to piggyback. The way I read that was the reason it was included was because it was part of that study by the community services district so it's good to tie that in. So that way you're tying our environmental document to another community organizations document to piggyback that environmental potential impact. I think it's actually double protecting the county by putting that in there. That's the way I read it and everyone has different interpretations. Thank you and I just want to confirm.


6:54 p.m.

My understanding that by approving this amendment to the, or approving the Q zone, there's no, we're not permitting any specific projects for any of these seven affected parcels. Just wanted to say that out loud. Do you even know, I mean, it lists, the staff report lists the seven owners. Do you even know if they've expressed intentions to move forward with projects under this allowance? If this is through the chair, if this is adopted by the board, we're anticipating at least one. We have high confidence at least one will be coming. Okay, great. Thank you. Yes, Commissioner Kersey. Kind of, thank you. Along the same lines, just kind of thinking this through and what spurred this idea was staff's justification or argument for the benefits. to the public for establishing this.


6:55 p.m.

And going back to my question of whether or not landowners are required to provide consent for this, I'm curious what the drawbacks would be of suggesting that this be considered for all MB areas, even if the areas that are in the northern county, that landowner is not going to consent to it, that landowners can change. And so I'm wondering if there is a benefit for exploring that. If I could, I would say that we would not actually accept an application unless the property owner signs it. Yeah, that's kind of my point. So it is a little bit redundant. And sometimes what we do is we add redundancy just to give assurance to the property owner that they're going to consent to this. To property owners that they've been heard.


6:56 p.m.

I think in this case that's what that redundancy is. It's just to tell the people who have expressed concern, we've heard you and we are putting this in there to make sure that that is memorialized. And that's not to preclude future applicants in other MB zones from coming forward? That's absolutely correct. And if I could, I'm sorry, Commissioner Levy, is that this really has been structured to allow future consideration. So it's applying to this right now, but it doesn't completely close the door. If somebody else, like a property owner, changes and circumstances change, that door is open, but they just need to change the zoning to add the queue. Mm-hmm. Yeah. With perhaps the...


6:57 p.m.

The exception of the water, the gallons per application, which is currently proposed as part of the language in this zone. Correct. I mean, each zoning action would be considered individually. So if somebody came in up in the McKinleyville setting, for instance, the water allotment up there would be far different. And so the queue may look different. And the beauty of what's done here is that the change to CMM or CCLUO, excuse me, is that it just simply refers to the requirement for the queue. And then each queue can be tailored to meet the circumstances in which it's being applied. And so the whole idea with CCLUO is to, oh, okay, I'm going to open this first line, and then I'm going to apply it in correct order so the providers then come and select it. And that same process can be applied. And once these facilities have been designed, we start normally on the next line of applications. Okay. And we're at a poor-value level. And when folks haven't mic's in this matter, if it's a problem that we had in the lower part, then WCH might have to defer this line mitts to type attacks but don't apply this into Track 2019. And a multi��라고 of No. 1, 2 or 3 dining case nearly 40 dozen. Not as many as wanting to eyelashes. WAIT. 3 W Dybel.


6:58 p.m.

Well, and I guess I'll just ask the question I was having, which is prompted by Commissioner Kiryazi. I mean, it's not like I'm eager to encourage or whatever more indoor grows in more business parks or, but I mean, we could consider extending this Q zone to other places in the north, even though currently the owner of those parcels is not interested. So I guess I just wanted to sort of note that you've made, you sort of put that question out there, like, you know, if we decided this was a good thing for MB zoning to allow it, we could extend the Q zone elsewhere. I'm not pushing us to do that right now, but what I guess you're saying, Director Ford, is that if


6:59 p.m.

In future, there are any other parcels so zoned where the owner expresses interest in doing so, we can sort of address it at that time. Thank you, Chair, or I'm going to call you Chair the rest of our time here, Commissioner Levy. The way it's structured, just to kind of confirm what you said, is that a property owner could come in and ask for the queue at any time. Okay. Sounds fine to me. Is that your motion? Well, sure. Then I will make a motion, a multi-pronged motion, that we adopt the resolution which finds that we have considered the final EIR for the CCLUO and the addendum that was prepared for the indoor cultivation queue qualified combining zone and text amendment.


7 p.m.

amendment to the CCLUO and find that this project complies with general plan and zoning ordinance and finds that the proposed project does not reduce the residential density for any parcel below the inventory adopted in the housing element and recommend the board of supervisors approve the rezoning of the seven parcels listed in this agenda item in the redway business park with the indoor cultivation queue qualified combining zone and recommend that the board of supervisors amend the CCLUO to allow indoor cultivation in business park MB zones with the indoor cultivation queue combining zone. I have a motion from Commissioner Levy. Do we have a second? Second. Commissioner O'Neill. Motion and second. Can we have a roll call vote please? Commissioner Scavdahl. Yes. Commissioner Mulder. Yes. Commissioner Curiazzi. Yes. Commissioner O'Neill.


7:01 p.m.

Commissioner Levy? Yes. Thank you. Motion passes. Commissioners, do you want to take a break before we enter the next couple of items, or are we good to keep going? We can get through them super quick, right? Yep. Okay. We'll open the public hearing for Manzanti special permit for short-term rental. And, sorry, turn it over to staff for staff report.


7:02 p.m.

Good evening, Commissioners. My name is Chris Lohhefner. I'm here to talk about the Mazanti Special Permit for a short-term rental. This particular project is located up in the Trinidad area, just east of Highway 101, at the north end of the Trinidad Frontage Road, on what's known as Alder Lane, which is a small road serving four residences. Each of the residences up in that area are residential estates, two and a half to five acres, with single-family residences on each of them. The applicant has submitted a site plan that complies with the checklist that we have for the short-term rentals. They completed their Good Neighbor Guide and affidavit and submitted those to neighbors beyond what they were required to do, actually. They have adequate parking and water and septic provisions. Trash and recycling has been taken care of in their operations plan. Safety components...


7:03 p.m.

Fire, carbon monoxide detectors and fire extinguishers and so forth, everything has been compliant with the standards that we ask of them. And the primary issue or concern with why we've brought this to the Planning Commission is a neighborhood concentration limit that will exceed what is stated in the zoning ordinance as it is stated that the STR should not exceed 20% of the dwellings on the access road. And currently there are two permitted short-term rentals on this access road, which of course takes the percentage to 50%. And this particular application would take it to 75%, which is... well above the threshold, which is why a special permit is needed.


7:04 p.m.

And we did go through all of our findings and found that there is no negative impact on the housing element. It is certainly consistent with the neighborhood dynamics. The owners do plan to occupy the residents full-time in the not-too-distant future. This wasn't necessarily a property they purchased just to have as rental income. It is below the 2% short-term rental cap as that relates to the overall housing inventory. And if we back out a little bit geographically, in the unincorporated areas between Clam Beach and Big Lagoon, there are only nine permitted short-term rentals. There's not a glut of these types of operations in that region. And we do know that short-term rentals offer some benefits to the county in terms of the support for tourist industry, local businesses, transit.


7:05 p.m.

the occupancy tax and so forth. One of the reasons this has come before the commission is because there are very likely to be similar circumstances in terms of neighborhood concentration limit being exceeded. There are a lot of rural roads in this county, even in Trinidad alone, that have only a handful of homes on them, even less. And, you know, the idea of permitting one or two of those homes for short-term rentals is going to take that percentage above what the standard says. So there's a little bit of a gray area there. I mean, there's a black and white application of the ordinance, but then there's also some other considerations that we're kind of hoping for some guidance from you all in terms of how we evaluate some of these as they come in the future. The other piece of the special permit for this particular property is the access road standard. As the ordinance states, the access road shall be built to a Category 3 road, which, of course, is a 16-foot wide.


7:06 p.m.

paved road. Alder Lane is not 16 feet wide in terms of paving. There is that much room in the in the I guess private right-of-way but it does require a special permit based on the language of the ordinance as it stands right now. A couple of notes about the access road. You can see that it is fairly wide actually. We have measurements to it. It's ten and a half feet wide. It is a private road. There is no Road Maintenance Association but one of the parcel owners up there has been the one essentially paving and taking care of the road for for its lifespan. They do a pretty good job taking care of it. There's certainly adequate space for emergency vehicles. There's large wide driveways for all four of the properties. And they can serve as additional


7:07 p.m.

Turnout areas should that be needed if there's oncoming traffic. The north side of the road, pretty much the whole stretch has at least six feet of shoulder that could also operate as a turnout. So, you know, functionally there is at least 16 feet of road, even though it's not all paved. As I said, there's only four residences, so there's very low traffic volume. There's great visibility, all in all. Vegetation debris is cleared regularly, and that's actually part of the condition that we've included with the approval. All in all, this road is a functional equivalent to Category 3 road. And as you'll be taking up later on this evening, I think there is the recommendation from staff to change the ordinance language a little bit to reflect the functional equivalency of a Category 3 road as opposed to requiring an actual control. Category 3 road in terms of pavement.


7:08 p.m.

So in summary, we do find that the proposed project meets all the general plan and zoning regulations with the special permit. The access road and neighborhood concentrations pose little risk to public health or safety nor the properties or anything else in the vicinity. So we do recommend that we make all the required findings and approval of the special permit and adopt the resolution approving the Mazzanti special permit for the short-term rental subject to those recommended conditions of approval. Thank you. That's my question. Thank you. Any questions for staff? I don't have questions. I have comments but I'll wait till the public comments. All right. Thank you. And I'll open public comment then and I see looks like Mr. Mazzanti is on the phone. If you'd like to ask a question, I'll ask you. I'd like to address the commission.


7:09 p.m.

You're here. Okay. Here. Okay. Please, you have 10 minutes if you want. Okay. Awesome. I'm Ashley Mazzanti. I'm the co-owner with my husband, Tim Mazzanti. He's on. So I was going to speak first and then give him an opportunity to share a little bit as well. So thank you, commissioners and chair and staff for hearing this. I know this is a newer process here for you all. So I appreciate you taking the time to consider the special permit. I just would like to reiterate that this is a short-term, short-term rental for us, that we do have hopes and dreams to be here full-time. It's just not able to happen right now, but in the near future, that is our main goal, that we want to be here full-time. We absolutely love and adore Humboldt County. Trinidad is a very special place for us. Going down to the beach, being able to go for hikes, it's just, it's beautiful and magical and amazing. So we are so thankful. To have.


7:10 p.m.

spot for us and we would like to share that with others until we can be here and then hope that by having the house available for a short-term rental that can not only help meet our goals to be here full-time sooner and quicker but then also help and give back to the local community versus just an empty house sitting there um but yeah that's all that i had i just wanted to say thank you for your time and then i'll hand it over to you tim if you'd like to share anything so um mr uh mr mazzani if you're on available you have the floor hello can you hear me yes we can awesome well i'm i'm coming to you from san antonio texas i'm pretty pretty far away um but you know the fact that my wife's there tells you that we're pretty serious about you know the community the humboldt county uh community that is and um it's kind of


7:11 p.m.

Interesting. So we went there in June to celebrate our 15-year anniversary, and then we walked away buying a house. We didn't have a plan to do that. Matter of fact, my wife wanted to go to Hawaii. And I was like, well, I'm trying to find a cheaper way to do this 15-year anniversary. So I was like, yeah, Redwoods. Let's do the Redwoods. But then I bought a house, so that's definitely more expensive. So really, I think she nailed it on the head. I mean, I always had an affinity for the Pacific Northwest. I've been living in San Antonio for about 30 years. And the first time I go to the Pacific Northwest, again, now I bought a house. So we're not trying to go ahead and turn this into a business or anything like that. Just really to subsidize a little bit of a cost while we figure out our next move. We want to go ahead and keep that. Keep the area super nice. We don't want to...


7:12 p.m.

go ahead and have hyper traffic of people renting the house or anything like that we love the neighbors that we live by and we want to respect them too and you know it's it's a really great place so that's the the comment that i want to leave there good all right thank you and i don't know if there's anybody else here that wants to address the commission on this topic i don't see anybody in the room or online so i'll bring it back oh excuse me i do have somebody hi there my name is mike reinman and i would possibly help them manage the property up here myself and the folks that we work together and we've had the pleasure of talking to them through this process and i'm going to hand it over to mike reinman and i'm going to hand it over to mike reinman and i'm going to hand it over to mike reinman and i'm going to hand it over to mike reinman and i'm going to hand it over to mike reinman and i'm going to hand it over to mike


7:13 p.m.

stuff and I think they would be good real good folks for for the community and we've done this before where we've had people come rent it as a short-term mix for a few years and then move to the property and it seems like it's a really it's a it's good for the community and it's good for those folks as they kind of get their feet wet a little bit and find out what it's like literally get their feet wet so thank you very much appreciate it thank you okay bring it back to uh staff or the commission for any additional discussion we just excuse me commissioner I was going this way first Mr. Mulder um I just wanted to comment when we were developing the ordinance we were precluded that this may happen especially in the northern area along the coast so I kind of I don't know if I can answer that question but I think it's a good idea to comment on that and if we saw this coming because of knowing you know there's multiple


7:14 p.m.

Small roads with, you know, two to ten houses and sometimes, you know, we may have challenges and I feel that there's been enough evidence submitted by staff. I didn't read any unless I missed it was a bunch of negative public comments that were hidden somewhere. Okay. So I'm in support of it. And I kind of felt that I appreciate the special permit process to protect people in the community. So that way it's not just, you know, over the counter, but also I did realize this was going to happen. Thank you. Commissioner O'Neill. So we just approved this. And so we're already stepping into waiving some of the rules that we came up with. That area was, you know, from what I remember looking, was, one of the higher revenue generating areas for short-term rentals. So I can understand why someone wouldn't want to have a short-term rental in that area. But we also talked a long time about.


7:15 p.m.

The need to have monthly rentals available and to not take units out of circulation basically for long-term residents and so I would have a tendency to not want to approve this unless there was a time limit put on it because I think anyone could come in here and say oh yeah I want to live here but in the meantime I'm making I think some of the numbers were in the high 60 to 70,000 dollars in revenue in the Trinidad Oreck area for short-term rentals. I'm just not going to take the face value of oh yeah in six months I might want to live there. I think there should be a limit placed on it for short-term rental because one of the main goals was to keep long-term rentals available and I just think we're already making exceptions and we're setting a precedent so that when other people come in I feel like we should approve those always. We shouldn't just say okay this one but the next one no. That's just my own opinion.


7:16 p.m.

opinion. I might be in the minority and it doesn't really matter, but that's how I feel. So I have a little bit different recollection. I thought we set the cap to try to control the number of short-term rentals and that we set these limits in the neighborhood were set, in my view, more on the basis to manage noise and parking complaints and neighborhood complaints that might come from a high-density grouping of short-term rentals in a neighborhood. And when I was thinking of that, I was tending to think more of a typical residential neighborhood with higher density. I understood staff to say these lots are two and a half to five acres. So these are larger parts.


7:17 p.m.

in this particular neighborhood. So in my view, that's why we created the special permit option so that it's difficult to create a one-size-fits-all ordinance, so there are going to be special circumstances that come up. This is a good example of that. And when an applicant is committed and willing to go through the special permit process, we get to hear these individual cases and make decisions on the individual cases like we're doing here tonight. So to me, the process is working. This is a good example of why we would have somebody come forward with a special permit because it doesn't quite fit into the ordinance as we drafted it, but in my view, it seems to fit into the neighborhood okay. Thank you.


7:18 p.m.

Thank you. Commissioner? Thank you for that background. That was going to be one of my first questions was diving into the intent. I didn't really get into any reviewing any of the past hearings on the STR, so I appreciate that background. I think I'm personally leaning towards being totally fine with this project, and I think I'm leaning a bit more towards where Commissioner Skabdahl was discussing or feeling like the process is working. I do feel like the sort of justification of consistent with the neighborhood can start to change as we allow more and more of these special permits. The neighborhood starts to change into an STR neighborhood. And I think that's a good point. And so, but with that, I'm assuming


7:19 p.m.

We have a sufficient process in place for every time a special permit is brought that this gives opportunity for neighbors to voice any concerns. And if there are no voiced concerns, then we should take that as being consistent with what the owners of the properties in that neighborhood see that neighborhood or envision that neighborhood. Good point. I did also want to bring up, I guess through the chair to staff, is it correct that the second STR on Alder Lane did not come for a special permit that was approved? That is correct, yes. So I think maybe my suggestion would be even in this case where you immediately jump in these, you have four or three houses probably still bringing a special permit request to. I suspect those STRs existed.


7:20 p.m.

before this ordinance was adopted so they were kind of grandfathered in if you will um yes well i i think it's great to have this discussion um i want to acknowledge commissioner o'neill's point that um yeah i i i i generally agree with the way chair scavdell remembers it but i think both can be true you know there's there's there there is always a little bit of a trade-off in losing potential housing stock even if they've already bought it they're not going to rent it out for you know short for other purposes and they they that's their right as the owners um um i guess i just wanted to to sort of underscore that i do think that the the the the the the the the the the the the the the the the the the the the the the the the the take okay it's there it's there is there is there there, right?


7:21 p.m.

This one to the Planning Commission. Maybe when we get a little further down the road, there wouldn't be as much to discuss, but I think at this point it is good to see how we're working this process of waiving or whatever it is, the limitations on neighborhood concentration. But in this case, I feel that I'm not concerned with those impacts, and I think the project is fine. Commissioner Roldar. So I want to be careful with our terminology, waiving. I'm a little uncomfortable with that term because we built an ordinance, and we specifically said in these instances you can come forward for a special permit. Just as like the cannabis projects, you know, you meet these certain requirements, but then you have to come forward with a special permit or a conditional use permit. So I feel that we're still. Within the confines.


7:22 p.m.

the ordinance so i just i want to be careful with our terminology because we start here and then all of a sudden it's a trickle down that oh they're bending over backwards like no these people bought a house they followed the ordinance that's in place and we have a decision it would be different if we had a room full of you know five people sitting here you know saying no no no they you know they're doing all these horrible things they've already devalued the neighborhood you know they've burned holes in the asphalt whatever it was so i just i want to be careful with our terminology because i don't want to discourage anyone from coming to humboldt county and spending money in humboldt county and promoting commerce because i don't know if you've paid attention it's a little scary in humboldt county so i'll leave it there no may i respond uh thank you commissioner milder you're you're you're right on actually we didn't waive anything it's just different pathways that were set up and if they were below 20 or 25 they wouldn't even need any


7:23 p.m.

kind of permit but over that limit it means we need to take a look at it staff at least needs to take a look at it that's what a permit a special permit is so we're not waiving it you're right and thank you for pointing that out good discussion yes commissioner curiozzi i just had one other just side comment um with respect to the staff report i noticed in the staff report and justifying the project they also noted the uniqueness of the trinidad area and and i felt like that was in the context of we were making this decision of of removing longer-term rentals off the market and that was there was a lot of consideration around str for that and so i guess i didn't feel like the uniqueness of an area necessarily should come into play regarding addressing the housing stock and sort of that sort of bigger challenge it doesn't impact the resolution or the like that but i did want to voice um good point you


7:24 p.m.

Ready to make a motion? I'd like to adopt the resolution 25- which does the following, finds that the Planning Commission has determined that the project is exempt from further environmental review pursuant to section 15301 of state CEQA guidelines and as a responsible agency agrees with the lead agency's findings and makes all the required findings for approval of the Mazanti special permit for short-term rental and approves the Mazanti special permit for short-term rental as recommended by staff and subject to the conditions of approval. I have a motion. I'll second that. Okay we have a motion for Commissioner Mulder and second by Commissioner Levy. Could we have a roll, any discussion on the motion? Good. Roll call vote please. Commissioner O'Neill? No. Commissioner Mulder? Yes. Commissioner Levy? Yes. Commissioner Curiazzi? Yes.


7:25 p.m.

Mr. Scavdahl. Yes. Motion carries, four to one. Thank you. Okay. If everybody's okay, we'll move on to item four. We'll open a public hearing for the amendment to the short-term rental ordinance. And I'll... Turn it over to you, Director Ford. Thank you, Chair Scavdahl. So we have been in the process of implementing the short-term rental ordinance, obviously, and we've come across a few things that we would like to address. Thanks. And so what we really want to do tonight is talk about the importance of the short-term rental ordinance.


7:26 p.m.

about some of the unexpected consequences that we have encountered as we've implemented the ordinance and then propose really what staff believes to be three very simple changes. One relates to how we refer to Category 3 roads. One is whether or not we should allow short-term rentals on smaller lots within AG zones. And the other relates to the separation of units as part of the neighborhood concentration. So the first thing is, and you just saw this referenced, is that the technical requirement of the ordinance for both home shares and for short-term rentals is that they need to be on a road that is built to a Category 3 standard. There's a fundamental problem with that. Not many roads in Humboldt County are actually built to a Category 3 standard.


7:27 p.m.

So our traditional focus of the county in evaluating roads has been on functional capacity, and you just heard that referenced. And so what we'd really like to do and propose to you is to change that section to simply say that the access road shall operate at a functional equivalent of a Category 3 road. And we believe that was the intent of the ordinance when it was written. I apologize that I did not catch the specificity which we identified built to a Category 3 standard because that really brings in all kinds of engineering dynamics. And quite frankly, we've had one particular home share that we've had to the Category 3 standard. So I'm going to turn it over to you, Dr. McFadden. I think it's a standard that has raised a lot of consternation about the fact that a road is not a functional capacity.


7:28 p.m.

built to a category three standard and and so whether it's a special permit being heard by the planning commission or an administrative permit that staff's approving it it just removes that point of disagreement about whether it technically meets all the engineering standards of the category three road absolutely and it probably didn't come out in my comments earlier but that was the point i was trying to make if we did something in our ordinance that doesn't make sense then we need to change that you know even on the density if it's under a certain number on the road then we can you know i would rather us change the ordinance and make changes like this on the road so that we're being consistent and not just having to wave and wave it because that's so subjective as to who's sitting up here whether or not or how nice the story is or where they live or gee it's a nice couple and you know i mean i don't want to turn down something you know


7:29 p.m.

that makes sense but I think that the ordinance needs to make sense and if you find errors then we should change those errors so that we're not picking and choosing because I would like to have a short-term rental but my house was built after a certain date so I can't do that so do I come in you know so that's what I'm getting at it's really easy to just one at a time pick them off and change the whole thing and then what's the point having ordinance in the first place so I'm all for making changes that make sense and then I get that too that until you're actually in the trenches you don't know if it's gonna work or not so maybe we should make these and maybe there's others that we need to make but I'd rather do that appreciate that well can I just ask I have and they've only gotten through point one of the three just for my own understanding what is the difference between a road being moved


7:30 p.m.

built to category three standard versus operate at the functional equipment? I think that's a great question. I should have gone into that detail. So basically a category three road would be a pavement section that's 16 feet wide, and it's intended to carry a certain volume of traffic. And so as we've seen, and I'm hesitant to bring this up, but we've seen it the most, is with cannabis projects where you've got a road that may not meet the category four standard in that case, but it has maybe some narrow spots where there's turnouts on each side, and so you can see cars coming. The volume of the traffic isn't so great that the road will fail because of the amount of traffic on the road. It's perfectly capable of handling the amount of traffic without creating a safety hazard. So it has less to do with the...


7:31 p.m.

pavement section and more to do with the capacity if that makes sense. That does. Thanks. If I could move into the next one. Ooh, sorry. That was an attempt at having something soothing. So we, as the commission will recall, we really made an effort to identify that in resource protection zones, the AG, AE, TPZ, that short-term rentals could be allowed as a farm stay. And farm stay had to include some kind of activity that related to the resource that was going on on the property. One of the things that we have discovered, and didn't really


7:32 p.m.

anticipate is that the Agriculture General or AG zone in Humboldt County, while it's a resource zone, is also used as a transitional zone. So in many cases there are smaller lots that are approved in the AG that really function more as neighborhoods. And we have discovered that there have been many short-term rentals in those areas. And really the smaller lots don't function as AG land. I mean a three acre parcel, it's a nice piece of property for sure, but it's not AG land. And so we don't really want to do away with the protection that we put on the resource lands in terms of, and also the requirement that if it is resource lands, allowing it with the experiential component of being able to experience the agricultural. use or the timber use or whatever it is.


7:33 p.m.

So we're proposing that an exemption be created within the ordinance, and that would basically keep the same language that's there in 60.05.10.2.4, but then add except as follows. And then basically allow short-term rentals in the AG zones on parcels that are less than five acres. They would go through the same administrative process, be subject to all the other requirements that are components of the short-term rental ordinance. On parcels that are slightly larger that could have some AG usage on them, and obviously we propose between five and ten acres, I question that. That could be far different, but that would then be a special permit. And so that would allow. Some carve out for the AG parcels that are.


7:34 p.m.

smaller to be permitted in short-term rentals and then on the transitional parcels that may be or may not be associated with ag land to give the Commission or the zoning administrator depending on the case discretion whether or not that should be approved and then the next one is neighborhood concentration and the big one here is the ordinance says the near as the crow flies the nearest ten houses so the big purple or big orange line there I can't see colors yeah goes identifies ten houses as the crow flies so you can see that the main street there School Road so for sure the area north of school Road is a different neighborhood than the area south of school but the way the ordinance is currently written


7:35 p.m.

If that blue lot, the lot colored in blue up there, were a short-term rental, all of those lots south of school could not have a short-term rental without a special permit. I don't think that's what we were anticipating when we wrote that. I did, we considered at one point maybe doing the 10 nearest houses, just crossing out as the crow flies. In this particular case, that would be just the houses immediately adjacent to the lot colored in blue. So the proposal is to say within 300 feet of the center of the house. So basically the center of the lot, draw a circle 300 feet, and so there couldn't be another short-term rental within that. And that begins to really address the neighborhood issue. This is really not about the number of short-term rentals. It's really about neighborhood compatibility. And so we're just trying to really...


7:36 p.m.

focused down on the neighborhood. The one previous, does it matter how big or how many square feet it is? Like what if I want to build a 5,000 square foot short-term rental, does it matter on three acres or less than three? Well, if it's a large lot, you know, the 300 feet probably won't go outside. No, I'm talking about the one we were talking about before. Or you said less than three acres of ag land, does it matter how big the unit that they build on it is? No? They could build as big as they wanted. Yes. Could it have multiple rentals on it? No. Just one. Nothing else is changing. So it's just rather than saying you can't have it without a farm stay, and the problem with that is that on small lots in the AG, they have no agriculture. They have no agricultural use. They have no use that really relates to the land.


7:37 p.m.

to farming or ranching or timberland. But they lend to the overall scenic kind of ag area, right? Well, it is a more rural setting. And I think what we're saying is that do you want to treat it as a farm stay or do you want to treat it as something that's just more of a large lot neighborhood? And it really doesn't have the same resource concerns as like land in AE or large lots in AG or TPZ for sure. So we're presenting that some of these neighborhoods that have lots between 3 and 5 acres or 2.5 to 5.5, which is similar to what was approved earlier.


7:38 p.m.

Today it just had different zoning. I mean, it really becomes the same kind of context. And so we're just trying to create some allowance there for those smaller lots because they don't have the same agricultural concerns. So this one would simply say that there shall not be another short-term rental within 300 feet of the proposed short-term rental measured as a 300-foot radius from the center of the dwelling used for the short-term rental. To be clear, so back to your picture that had the purple-orange line. That's a relatively dense neighborhood, small lots. A lot of residential lots are 60 by 100. So if we said 300 feet from the center of the house, that means if your neighbor, you make a smaller liner錯국 and the design is basically done into my line. This front line would suddenlyoires Peace Material Langle Once you've done that it is drop measure. This shows the structure. There are actuallyиф At there was a pocket,


7:39 p.m.

rental you wouldn't be able to have a short-term rental you need to get a special special permit to be able to get a special permit right okay the way it is right now in fact we've got i didn't want to use the actual houses but the the thing that really raised this is this very neighborhood where there is currently a short-term rental on the south side of school road yeah and then somebody's coming in somewhere over on like marty yep and they have to get a special permit and those are so unrelated right no i'm just trying to think ahead it's like yeah how how many people are we forcing into the special permit you know how often does it come up that two short-term rentals are right next door to one another um i don't know i'm just as soon as i find out my neighbor's making seventy thousand dollars a year i'm moving out and yeah yeah yeah all right you answered


7:40 p.m.

My question, I just want to make sure I understood the 300 foot. Thank you. Sure. Okay, well, thank you. I get why the wording as the crow flies could cause some ambiguity about how we're measuring, does it have to be a straight line. So granted, that is problematic language. But I just want to go back to the question of the 10 nearest dwellings shall not be short-term rentals. In another context of slightly less dense neighborhoods, 300 feet radius from a house wouldn't probably capture any neighbors. And so I guess I'm questioning whether this change is... Is consistent with the intention to try to... And again, it's not a prohibition. It's just saying it's not...


7:41 p.m.

You know, you have to get a special permit or some sort of permit if this applies to you. I'm just, I'm wondering if by changing it to simply 300 foot radius is perhaps not tight enough for assessing or capturing the sort of impacts that this provision was intended to capture. In a less dense neighborhood, you know. So, I mean, I hear what you're saying. And we could have something to the effect that there should not be another short-term rental within 300 feet of the proposed short-term rental or within the nearest 10 short, 10 residences. I mean, you could. You could have it basically, and again, I'm not wedded to this, but you could sort of set it up that it's one or the other depending on which applies.


7:42 p.m.

Right. And so part of the thinking with this is that when you get into the larger lots, because the concentration becomes, or the density of the development becomes far less, you have greater separation between units, you don't have the same impact. I'm not discounting what you're saying, but I think that that is a factor to be considered. And if you've got 10 five-acre lots, I mean, that's huge. Yeah, that's a big area. Yep. Right. Sure. Mr. Mulder. So for me, I'm looking at this. I remember when we were making this language, I think we were leaning more towards big partials, like old roads that go far out there and trying to capture neighbors or probably, mile away.


7:43 p.m.

from each other, a quarter mile away from each other. But seeing we made an ordinance and then seeing that we're having some hiccups and then the demonstration there showing like, hey, whoa, we didn't realize the impacts of our ordinance would be pitting neighborhoods against each other that are not really affecting each other as far as impact. I'm okay with this language change. The only thing, if we were trying to also capture those larger partials maybe just put an asterisk that this language applies only to partial sizes less than one acre or something like that if we really wanted to try to split hairs. But personally, I think seeing that we put in language and that language kind of doesn't work, I'm good with the change just because thank you for the picture. That really, really helped. It was like, whoa, I did not realize our ordinance would be that impactful to neighborhoods that probably don't even know each other unless they...


7:44 p.m.

walk around the curbs. So that's where I'm at on that. I agree. Again, I think this neighborhood concentration issue was largely related to noise and parking type issues that we were trying to address here. 300 foot radius, that means they're at the other end of the football field. That does seem to be a reasonable distance to say if somebody's going to be closer than a football field away, they have to come get a special permit. And I'm just trying to, you know, again, assess. These permits were intended initially to, most of them, go across the counter. To be a simple process, somebody comes in and applies, they go across the counter. I really don't want to. Create a situation where every other permit is a special permit.


7:45 p.m.

It doesn't seem like we're getting there because this is the first one and I assume you've processed a lot of permits across the counter. And that's another I would like to see not tonight, but at some point in the future that perhaps you come back to the commission with a report on how it's going, how many permits we've issued, how we're doing with respect to the cap in these different neighborhoods. You know, what challenges, if any, you're having, but it would be interesting to just see how the process is going and actually how the numbers are playing out in these neighborhood concentrations versus what we actually thought they might do. If someone like the last couple, if they move into their house now as their permanent residence, does that permit become available open again in an area where it's impacted by? Do they get to keep it? No. No. In fact, one of the things that.


7:46 p.m.

That, you know, permits expire after two years unless it's renewed. So if they came in and or if they moved into the house, say, in 20 months and decided not to extend the short-term rental administrative permit or now it's a special permit, then that would open up that rental. How much does it cost for them to renew it? Well, how I think is right now I think it's like $160. So it would be in your best interest to just keep renewing it, even if you were living in the house, just to keep that option available. Well, but one of the questions we ask them is are you continuing to rent it? Oh, and if they aren't, then they lose it? Right. They have to demonstrate use. Yeah, they have to use it and rent it a certain number of times. Because you're collecting revenue as a county office. Short-term rental over and above the permit.


7:47 p.m.

Well, there's the TOT tax. And frankly, I don't like to issue land use permits based upon revenue, but we can't be entirely blind to that. It's really about, in this particular case, protecting housing stock, protecting neighborhood character. Well, and I'm thinking about the number of permits, because there were some areas that were more desirable than others. And if someone did move into the house, that that permit could be available to someone else. I don't know if you heard Mr. Lonehofer say, though, that there's only nine that we've issued in the Trinidad area plan. And they had, yeah, but they already had a lot of grandfathered in already, right? Well, they still had to get permits. Oh, I see. But the city issues their own permits. City issues their own permits. This is just the Trinidad.


7:48 p.m.

The area plan, the... Outside the city. Right. Yeah, that was surprising, actually. Because they had a lottery in the city. One of the things that has been a huge disappointment, frankly, is as simple as we tried to make this process, it's still too complicated for us. Yeah. Well, that's kind of what I was thinking, is that if this, there could be more than just this that needs to be changed, and how many times do you want to go back changing, and do you want it to go for a little while and capture more issues before you make a change, or do you want to just change them as we go? Well, I didn't just... These have been building for a while. I didn't just bring this back because somebody complained yesterday. We've got a number of people in the AG zone. We just had somebody... This gets so frustrated with us that...


7:49 p.m.

They withdrew their permit and, you know, wanted, demanded a refund. I mean, some of these are based upon real struggles that are tripping people. And that's... I was just thinking maybe there could be more that we need to really... If there were, I'd be bringing them back. I mean, I don't like to struggle with things. If there's an incongruity within the ordinance, we'll definitely bring it back to you. But these are the ones that are creating constraints right now. Or unintended consequences. I think the separation one is just clearly an unintended consequence. Well, I support all of these. I mean, I'd rather see these changes than us picking and choosing based on how nice somebody was. I mean, one of the other ones that I don't think there's a way to resolve this is that, you know, what's 10%? Or 20% of the unit...


7:50 p.m.

on a street when there's three units. I mean, the first one already exceeds it. Does that mean you can't have it? Sorry, we do have these discussions. I think we're giving you some flexibility on that. Well, that's when you say when there are less than so many units. Well, the first one gets to go, no matter what. Okay, so I assume that concludes your staff report. Yes. And so we have some other questions. Commissioner Chiarazzi? Yeah, I think I have a couple of comments. I'm assuming we're in a comment period. Just discussion. We have to take public comment before we get comments, correct? Oh, we are taking public comment on this. Already kind of gone into discussion, so should we wait and go through that process? Yeah, I don't think it's going to take too long. So why don't we open this for public comment? So we've concluded the staff report. We'll open for public comment. Council could have a vote about the nothing act. There was no motion for initiative. Certainly, steering of policy. Fellows I can recognize your attention. Understandingиласьوف 제� simulation. All right. Let's give it up to Commissioner Farms coefficient preventative committee. Are there any Mayor or city council members we haven't heard about on this?other Some are speaking and we don't.


7:51 p.m.

Thank you. You have three minutes. Hi. Thank you again. I just want to say I think that the planning team has done a great job on this. I've been in this zone for 20 years in terms of short-term rentals, and I've worked with hundreds of people that have them and worked with a lot of different, really all the different cities in some way and stuff, and I think this was done really well. You know, I think these changes that are being discussed today are great. I wonder, the AOB thing, I wonder how that, I know, I've actually had a couple owners go through that, converting an AOB to a traditional permit as well. I know that can be a painful process, but in general I feel like it's really going well, and I really appreciate it and appreciate the healthy discussions you're all having. So thank you very much. Thank you. Anne. Anne, we have... We have somebody still following us online.


7:52 p.m.

Do we have any anybody want to address the commission from Zoom? I'll give that a second. and seeing none I'll close public comment and come back to you Commissioner Curiozzi if you had a discussion item or comment yeah I appreciate the discussion around the intent as well that the backgrounds will be helpful and and I'm curious what the intent was around the crow flies clause or was it entertained of just keeping the access road constraints and leaving it at that why was the additional crow as the crow flies added and it feels like going from the crow flies approach to the 300 feet approach goes to swings the other direction now we're protecting


7:53 p.m.

It's, for lack of a better word, use the word protecting, the higher density areas and now we have a situation where the larger lots can then sort of more easily convert to these STR approaches. So I'm curious, what if we just removed 10.6.2.1.2? If we just remove that whole provision and left it to the other provision, which speaks to the density within a given access route. That's right. I don't remember even the term crow flies. So it was probably just something staff put in there, but I don't remember having a discussion about crow flies. It really was surprising we brought it up. That did not come out at a public hearing.


7:54 p.m.

Thank you. The best way I could explain it is sometimes staff loves to be creative and colorful without recognizing that you can't really do that in ordinance language. And so, you know, we've debated how does a crow fly? I have a lot of them in my yard, I can probably tell you. I don't know. As the Raven flies. If you said Raven, that would be different. But I want to just I see your hand. But if I may just quickly. Yeah. I mean, I leaving the crow flies language out of it, though, I think, you know, Commissioner Curiazzi, that is a valid point. That I do remember having a discussion about not crows, but about the idea that a provision like this should. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.


7:55 p.m.

Because you could have situations where people are not on the same access road, but there are budding parcels or there's a cluster of parcels that are all still forming a neighborhood. And so this would be another, you know, we were trying to have belts and suspenders. You know, if it's like this, it applies that way. If it's the other way, you know, you would apply that term. So I'm kind of like what I said before. I do think 300 might be a little less protective than what was intended by that. But on the other hand, a football field is a pretty good distance between houses. So I'm not overly concerned about it. Commissioner Mulder, waiting patiently. Thank you. So for me, I'm a little like if we go back to intent and purposes, I'm completely removing 10.6. .2. 2.1.2, I think would be a little bit against what all the public comment as far as protect housing. Thank you.


7:56 p.m.

stock and all that kind of stuff so i think it would go against our very beginning intent so i'd have to really like if we're going to course correct that way i'd really have to sit on that one for a while um question for staff i mean i i'm supportive of all these changes but on the smaller partials partials of ag a workaround and i know you hate that term 120 square feet or less chicken coop or greenhouse could justify a farm stay if i was an applicant i would i would try to argue that i i could understand that um but that's where i think that what we're trying to do is just get the clarity um so that people don't have to go to illogical uh things to try to justify something i've seen somebody um people try to argue that they have a farm because they grow chickens in the forest


7:57 p.m.

So making these changes would make staff time more value or more better use because they wouldn't have to be trying to figure out if this is really a farm stay or not. Right. It'd be simple. Check the boxes. No reading a plan of how you incorporate the farm stay. Trying to interpret is this really a farm stay or not? I mean, so in your situation, I don't want to be too facetious here, but, you know, it's like, okay, what's the agricultural activity going on? They're going to go out and look at the chicken coop. Is that kind of really an agricultural use or is that a backyard project? I mean, I could have a farm stay and my neighbor's got a steer in the yard. Makes sense. So this would prevent. That workaround and better utilize staff time. So I'm in support of all the language before us. I guess the other question.


7:58 p.m.

I had for staff was the intention for us to approve tonight or make corrections and come back for a second reading or I'm just clarity on that. I feel that we didn't get a bunch of, you know, usually when we get new language and if there's like, oh, you have to change this word. I haven't heard that. I didn't read it. So I personally feel through the public process. I'm comfortable to move forward on this tonight. It's entirely commissioned discretion. I came prepared to go either way. If you'd like to go forward tonight, I would love that. If you have things that you would like to see addressed differently that we can't address tonight, we can bring it back. OK, thank you. Commissioner. Maybe just to that, maybe clarifying. It sounds like I haven't heard any discussions around the category three change in language. I'm fine with that. And. And then. Oh, right. Change. Basically changing the units from.


7:59 p.m.

You know, acres per unit to units per acre, I think that makes a lot of sense. That brings clarity. And so those were like the three elements before us. So it feels like the change to the crow flies to 300 feet, that makes sense to me. I appreciate that additional background and context. I also feel like the 300 feet is about consistent with the less than one unit per acre constraint. You're about in the same ballpark there. So I think staff came up with a good number there. And I guess lastly, on 10.6, correcting the 1.000 to 1,000 feet. Staff, I'm sure, have noted that. Commissioner Mulder. Just to clarify what I meant, I'm supportive of all the proposed language. So everything that's been stroked, striked out and then


8 p.m.

All the new language that's underlined, I'm supportive of everything that's been presented tonight. So I apologize, I wasn't clear about that. Yes, it was a motion. We have a motion from Commissioner Mulder. I'll second. Second from Commissioner O'Neill. And to Director Ford, I appreciate that, again, these one-size-fits-all ordinances do need a little adjusting, so I appreciate that you're working through the process and bringing back some practical changes that will help streamline the process, make it easier for applicants and easier for staff and more clear for us. And we still have the special permit process for exceptions when they come up. So can we call for a roll call vote, please? Commissioner O'Neill? Yes. Commissioner Mulder? Yes. Commissioner Curiazzi? Yes. Commissioner Levy? Yes.


8:01 p.m.

Yes. Commissioner Scavdahl. Yes. Motion carries 5-0. Thank you. We had no items pulled from consent. Report from planner. Anything to report? Yeah, the main things I just wanted to make you aware of is that there are, well, in a bigger picture, the Board of Supervisors gave cannabis permit holders an opportunity to pay off their measure as tax and to pay any money that they owe the department for processing their permit. And that period is coming up pretty soon here at the end of March. And there are quite a number of permit holders that fall and potentially fall in that category. Beyond that, there are


8:02 p.m.

There are currently about 130 permit holders that never entered into an agreement with the treasurer tax collector and also owe the planning department for processing their permit. We're going to start taking those forward for revocation. They're already suspended. We're going to start taking those forward for revocation to the board in early March. Do they come here first or do they go directly to the board? Directly to the board. Do you know if those are active users or they just never got started? A lot of the initial ones probably are folks that are not active anymore. So it's a difficult time, and I just want the commission to be aware that we are struggling with that right now. You might want to, if they are active...


8:03 p.m.

come up with some sort of plan because there's a lot of other economic issues going on on the federal level that are going to seriously impact this county financially and we don't need to drive anybody away but you know maybe they just need a payment plan out but if they're not using the farm then that's a different matter that that request has been made but if you'll recall back to I think was last September the board offered the payment plan to permit holders I'm having a hard time not sharing personal experience I will say that I am but I do have two farms that you know I'm not sure if I can get them to come in and see if they can get a you know the county tens of thousands of dollars and is on a payment plan but you know if someone doesn't pay you


8:04 p.m.

You can't really pay your bill. I've got a beautiful ADA-compliant break room and parking spot that I paid to finish. So, you know, but I know other farms that don't have that done and are compliant on their measure S tax. So it's like, do you do all your conditions of approval or do you pay your taxes? Right. So, I mean, there's all those stories out there. And there's some people that have, no, I'm not going to say that word. There's a lot of reasons why. But, I mean, I could share personally that I have a piece of paper that someone owes me $327,000 signed by a judge. I don't think I'll ever see a penny. So it is what it is. I appreciate that context. If I may just, under report for planner.


8:05 p.m.

So just echo what Chair Skavdal already said about the short-term rental ordinance. And, yeah, as you get to a point where you have enough data that it makes sense to report back to us, I think we would all be curious to hear how many permits have been sought, in which neighborhoods, where are we with the cap, all that kind of stuff. Okay. We can bring that back. Yeah. Anything else? Nothing else that's really pressing is striking. Yes. We're about to release two EIRs. We'll get to make those available to you. One is for the Regional Climate Action Plan. Oh, that's right. The other is for the McKinleyville Town Center. So boom and bust. We're going to boom here for a little bit. Yeah. Okay. Any planning commission discussion items? I'll just note that I'll be missing the March 7th. 6. Okay.


8:06 p.m.

Commission meeting. Okay. Thanks. Thanks for notice. Hopefully we have our other chair filled by then. Okay. All right. Meeting adjourned. Next meeting February 20th. Thank you.