Humboldt County Planning Commission
Thursday, October 15, 2026
The agenda


6:01 p.m.

It's a meeting of the Planning Commission to order and start with a salute to the flag. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you. Commissioner Kuriase? Here. Commissioner Curiazzi? Here. Commissioner McFarland is absent. Commissioner Fulton? Here.


6:02 p.m.

We have a quorum. Thank you. All right, that brings us to item C, agenda modifications. Director Ford, do we have any modifications this evening? Thank you, Chair. We have no modifications to the agenda. I just do want to call out that we do have two supplementals related. Two of them are related to the Humboldt Bay Area plan. Two of them are for public comment. Thank you. And I think we received an additional new one from a member of the audience as well. That is both available to us and available on the dais. It's a map. It's this one. Okay. Well, that brings us to item D, public comment on non-agenda items. At this time, persons may appear before the commission on any matter relevant to the commission's jurisdiction that is not on the agenda tonight. So if you're here to comment on an item that is on our agenda, we will have a public comment period for each of those items as we take them.


6:03 p.m.

So this is a time where you can comment on items that are not on the agenda. So I will start with folks in the room, if you could please approach the podium, and then I will go to anybody online who would like to make a comment. If you would like to make a comment on an item that's not on the agenda tonight, please raise your hand now online so that I can call on you when we are ready to move to the online section. There can be a little bit of a lag in the video, so it's best to raise your hand now so that you are prepared when we go to online comment. So with that, please, if you are in the room, approach the podium to make a comment. You have three minutes. Hi, my name is Jennifer Raymond, and I am here to speak about the conditional use permit for Miranda's Rescue, and I am imploring the Planning Commission to consider agendizing this item so it can be used. It can be discussed. I believe that you should...


6:04 p.m.

should agendize a recommendation to revoke this conditional use permit to the Board of Supervisors. This conditional use permit has been a mess since it began. It was originally approved by the Planning Commission in 2003. The conditions were never met. The county didn't ever notice that until it was brought to their attention this past April. At which point, rather than saying that the permit had expired, they gave a compliance agreement to Mr. Miranda. He has now failed to meet the first set of deadlines. The conditional use permit, in addition to never having met the conditions, there are a number of conditions that were on the process.


6:05 p.m.

... property or in the site plan that have never been met. To begin with, there are a number of kennels and I've given you, I've provided you with a handout and there is a site map on the second page and it shows where the kennels were allowed. And they were allowed on the parcel that is 004. They were not allowed on the merged parcel that is now 013, which I've outlined in red. And yet when you look at the aerial photograph, you can see that there are kennels all along the property line of that 013 parcel. Those kennels are on my property line and over my property line and on a regular basis, all the feces and urine is hoarded on the property line. I've imposed right onto my property. I've complained about...


6:06 p.m.

I submitted a code enforcement complaint and was informed by Mr. Ford that it was not sustained. I am also concerned about this permit because it was given to Shannon Miranda. One of these properties is not owned by him. It is owned by Edgar Cornell. I have asked for a letter or an application showing that Mr. Cornell said it was okay to have a rescue on this property. The county has been unable to provide me with anything. The final item is the fact that Mr. Miranda is not being charged property taxes. I'm sorry. Thank you. Okay. Anybody else in person who would like to comment? Good afternoon, everybody. My name is Angel Martinez. I am also here to ask that the board...


6:07 p.m.

Agenda is revoking Miranda's rescues permit and they should reapply them have them reapply throughout the process I want to re-elevate some of the comments that were about on the attachment added to this agenda Miranda has not removed any of the structures on unpermitted parcels And he's still in the process of doing so from the ones he's been ordered to Additionally to echo what was mentioned about unpermitted Kennels that includes parcel 201-191-002-00 On top of that there are he has not agreed to stop euthanizing any animals on property or in general None of the animal enclosures have been risen above flood elevation include and he hasn't Gone out of the way to obtain any plans to do so no work has been started on that and the work has been completed on that as well On top of that he has not submitted an emergency plan To require California law Top that I just want


6:08 p.m.

I want to reiterate that this is a local issue and I implore this Board of Supervisors to keep any related events to this transparent for the victims of these crimes and just for the community in general. Thank you. Would anybody else in the audience like to make a comment? Okay, I'm not seeing anybody, so I'm going to go ahead and move to online and phone calls. I see a couple hands raised. Just as a reminder, please raise your hand now to be called on. I'm going to start moving through folks. Okay, Lori Mansell, you have the floor for three minutes. Yes, I've not seen any evidence that Miranda has complied with the conditions of the original conditional use permit. He also hasn't complied with the requirements of the subsequent compliance agreements. He's basically not complied with anything.


6:09 p.m.

It's shocking to me to hear John Ford say that he has, and the evidence is right before our eyes. We can literally see it. And recently, I obtained documents subsequent to a public records request, which clearly indicate and document that Shannon Miranda violated the conditions of his permit suspension. If the board didn't already have ample reason to recommend that the Board of Supervisors revoke his permit, the county itself recorded in its own records that Miranda continued to take in new dogs and adopt dogs out while his permit was suspended. And from my information and understanding, that in itself is an ample reason to revoke his permits. Because he doesn't honor or respect or comply with anything the county has required of him. Thank you. Thank you. Okay, next I see a phone number ending in 6556. Thank you.


6:10 p.m.

It is star six to unmute yourself. Hello, good evening, Commissioners. My name is Nancy Klein, for the record that is Klein, K-L-E-I-N. I'm here to address the systematic operational and financial collapse surrounding the Planning Department's 23-year failure to regulate Miranda's Rescue. Public records have revealed a shocking truth. This department has completely lost the wheel. You have debated and issued conditional use permits for over two decades on parcels where this county cannot even verify legal ownership. Planning staff admitted on record that the original application signatures were never authenticated or notarized. Shannon Miranda does not own all of these parcels. Some belong to outside individuals who were never contacted, while others have recently been


6:11 p.m.

sold and remaining flux. Worse, this is a massive fiscal failure. By allowing an unpermitted operation to masquerade under a blanket charitable welfare exemption on unpermitted land, including private residential property, this county has failed to collect 20 years of required property taxes. Let's look at the real world cost. Humboldt County is one of the poorest counties in California with a medium household income 38% lower than the state average and an 18% poverty rate. The community desperately needs every dollar for public service. Yet, because of California's strict statute of limitations on escape assessments, this department's multi-debt paid negligence means the county has permanently lost up to 15 years of back taxes revenue that can never be legally recovered. That is a problem. Permanent irreversible theft.


6:12 p.m.

from Humboldt County taxpayers. If this commission continues to coddle noncompliance instead of enforcing the law, you will leave the public with no choice but to bypass local government entirely and force external accountability. The evidence belongs in the hands of agencies that actually enforce the law. Locally, a demand to the Humboldt County assessor for a retroactive tax audit and a formal referral to the district attorney's public integrity unit. At the state level, an escalation to the California State Auditor's whistleblower hotline and California Department of Justice white-collar investigation team. At the federal level, a report to the FBI's Public Corruption and Complex Financial Crimes Unit to investigate how a county department can look the other way for 23 years. The planning department's... And...


6:13 p.m.

This off-approach needs to end now, and we are collectively demanding a full independent audit of this department's land use and tax verification practices before external regulators are- I'm sorry, your time is up. Thank you. Okay, I'm not seeing any other hands raised. I'm going to give it one more moment to make sure that everybody who's had a chance, who would like to comment has had a chance. I'm not seeing any other hands raised online, so I'm going to go ahead and close our public comment on non-agenda items. Can I ask a question? Yes. Does he or does he not have a permit? Because I'm confused. And we have to be very careful with respect to topics that are not on the agenda, but the Brown Act does allow staff to respond briefly to questions like the one that the commissioner asked. Well, I'm just following up on- The last meeting we had. His permit remains in the same-


6:14 p.m.

Status as the last time I presented to you, which is it is suspended I don't know what the audience understands Okay, we are gonna take up item II the consent agenda These public hearing matters are routine in nature and are usually approved by a single vote And the chair will I will pull the audience tonight And members of the Commission to see if anybody would like this item pulled from consent. There's only one tonight So with that I'm going to go ahead and read the item and if you would like this item pulled for consent meaning that We will have a staff report and have a public comment period for it. Please raise your hand Otherwise, we'll just take a vote and and move on to the other items on our agenda So we have the review and approval of the October 1st 2026 action summary would anybody on the Commission like to pull this item?


6:15 p.m.

Would anybody in the audience or online like to pull this item? I see one hand raised. I'm going to... Thank you. Oh, and they pulled their hand down. Okay. I was going to confirm with them whether or not they intended to pull this item, but it seems like they have removed their hand. Okay. Seeing no members of the audience with their hand raised, I'm going to go ahead and leave this item on consent. I'll move to adopt the consent agenda. Okay. I'll second. Okay. I have a motion and a second. Let's go ahead and just have a voice vote for this one. All those in favor, please say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Any abstained? Okay. Motion passes. Item F is item pulled from consent. We only had one item. It stayed on consent. So that brings us to our public hearing item for tonight. We are on G1, a public hearing of the Humboldt Bay Area,


6:16 p.m.

plan and local coastal plan amendment and zone reclassification of parcels within the Humboldt Bay Area Plan. So tonight if you're not familiar with our process we're I'm going to go ahead and open the public hearing now request that staff present the staff report we will then open up a public comment period where we'll take comment from the audience and from folks online regarding this item and then we will bring it back to the commission for deliberation and potentially a decision. So with that oh commissioner oh um okay do any commissioners have a ex parte um for this item? Um yeah thank you I do have some ex parte um so just uh uh some of my engagement with the public over this agenda item over the last few months I did attend I listened to a public


6:17 p.m.

Meeting that county staff held on this plan back in June 16th. I also attended a site visit that was extended by county staff to primarily the Samoa, the town of Samoa, on August 3rd. And we really primarily focused on the town of Samoa, but also gained some perspective on the Harbor District's property and that location next to Samoa. I then had a meeting with two Samoa residents on August 7th through their invitation and primarily listened and also a lot of the discussion helped clarify the boundary or the distinction between the Humboldt Bay Area plan and some of their comments around the Danco permitted project. And lastly, I did have a brief call with Humboldt Area Foundation on September 3rd as well about their plan. And I think that's where I'm going to end my comments and just.


6:18 p.m.

clarifications there. And lastly, I don't think it matters, but I do own a home in Burlentown, but I don't think that really matters in this case. Thank you. I, at the last meeting, was struggling with the sea level rise recommendations and understanding the science behind them and reached out to someone I know, Bonnie Ludka, who had worked on some of the science and some of the recommendations to Caltrans and received a little bit more information on their process and talked me through some of the science behind it. And I think what's relevant to this commission is simply it was a lot of what was presented here already. I think just thinking about it again was helpful for me. So I don't know that there was new information that I had necessarily beyond what was presented to us. I just understanding that in a different way, how engineering decisions are made. And thinking about the sea level rise data.


6:19 p.m.

There's so much uncertainty with the ice sheets melting, which was presented to us already in the staff reports. Any other commissioners need to do ex parte? Okay, wonderful. Well, then, staff, whenever you are ready. Good evening, commissioners. My name is Rianne Meagan. I am with the Planning and Building Department, and I'll be presenting on the Humboldt Bay Area Plan. I apologize, this is a hearing, not the workshop. The agenda for tonight, I will provide a brief overview of the changes made since the last workshop. We will respond to comments received from both the Coastal Commission and the public, related to land use zoning and also document changes. Afterwards, we will open the document. Once we go through the document, open.


6:20 p.m.

for public comment and end with a deliberation with the Planning Commission. The changes from the previous workshop on September 3rd, where we included comments from Planning Commission, Public, and Coastal Commission, we did receive a draft from the Coastal Commission with comments, and that was received on September 21st. We did add the completion date for any Samoa Town Master Plan policy that has been determined to be completed or there was an identifiable date relevant to the policy. Addition of maps within the document, and we are going with, from the last workshop, we determined intermediate high scenario for sea level rise and have come back with scenarios for intermediate versus intermediate. Immediate high to discuss with the Planning Commission tonight.


6:21 p.m.

One policy addition to environmental justice was the concerns of existing residential areas and tribal concerns shall be addressed as part of a discretionary project analysis. This was in response to comments from the Planning Commission and the public. This was added to the coastal dependent industrial background and was received from the public. We combined public access into recreation and that was based on Coastal Commission recommendation and Coastal Commission recommended to include a section on lower cost overnight accommodations as well. And then I will go into sea level rise scenarios, intermediate versus intermediate high. Currently, the document is with the intermediate high.


6:22 p.m.

scenario. However, there was discussion at the last workshop and previous workshops about going to the intermediate scenario. And we were looking at the numbers for 2100. And this is from the adopted Ocean Protection Council sea level rise document that was completed in 2024. So the numbers would be round up to four feet for intermediate and intermediate high would be five and a half feet by 2100. This is a brief scenario from NOAA showing what could be inundated by the intermediate scenario of four feet by 2100 and five and a half feet by 2100. And I can also open a number of different scenarios. So this is a brief scenario from NOAA showing what could be at that time of not seeing that they can set videos. So there's a lot more data Ting,


6:23 p.m.

is low line areas, so those may be subject to flooding if there's increased rainfall or a keen tide. And then the various shades of blue show possible forecasted water depth of areas that might be inundated by sea level rise. And this is just a brief overview of the Humble Bay proper. Quick question. That's okay. The NOAA maps do not include subsidence. Is that correct? I believe it is a bathtub model. It's a bathtub model, but I do believe, as I read it, it did include subsidence. Thank you. This would focus on the communities of King Salmon, Fields Land,


6:24 p.m.

being in part of Humboldt Hill, and there's a more detailed change between the four feet scenario and the five and a half feet. Once again, this green is a low line area, so heavy rains, king tides, it may receive some flooding from that. However, with the intermediate high scenario, it would most likely be essentially permanently flooded in part of the bay. Thank you. I can go back to the previous slide, stay on this slide, or open the web browser if the commission would like, or we could bring this up once we get to that section. So the recommendation is we can continue to use the intermediate high as is already in the document.


6:25 p.m.

or change to the intermediate scenario and we would like to discuss that with the commission tonight. Going on to Coastal Commission comments, this is in response to the document that was received as an attachment. Thanks. I get to go through some of these. So the number on the upper right is the number where they identified where the page was. So this is following the exact order within the document that they provided this week. So the first change, or the first requested change, was to add policies for tribal engagement in Chapter 2. That's the chapter that includes the information on the history of the tribes and the importance of the tribes in this area. One of the things we did is that we took all the tribal engagement general plan policies and we put them all together and we put them all together. Out of the general plan and put them in chapter three


6:26 p.m.

And normally when a planner at least goes to look for what is applicable and what should apply, we go to the policies, not the background. So we feel that we've addressed that. We would not make any changes. We would not make that change that's been requested. Staying within Chapter 2 there, this is to modify the environmental justice background. What they wanted to do was modify really the description of environmental justice. We agree with that. We would make the change that's shown there on the screen. And I apologize that we didn't get copies of that out to you sooner, but that basically is the change they asked for without any deviations. So we would recommend that change. Really quick, I apologize. I'm asking you. I'm asking you to repeat yourself, but can you repeat the last slide again?


6:27 p.m.

Go back up to, yep. Yeah, thank you. Which change you did not do. We would not recommend this because all the tribal engagement policies from the Humboldt County General Plan have been included in Chapter 3 already. And for those who are interested in following along, there's a supplemental on this front counter. And Director Ford is going page by page addressing the comments that the Coastal Commission has put into it. So we addressed this one. This was on environmental justice. I think now we're going to – there was another comment. There is a number five in there that we included within environmental justice, identifying that. That indigenous populations essentially are part of the community that should be considered environmental justice. The Coastal Commission recommends that we remove that because that's redundant.


6:28 p.m.

to the environmental justice and the cultural discussions that are there, we would recommend retaining that because that is by definition an environmental justice community. They have been historically depressed with land use decisions and so we think that the duplication of that is appropriate and is good and emphasizes the county's commitment to paying attention to the concerns of the tribes. Go to the next slide. We're moving down now to chapter four or five. This is chapter five. And the first one is that we capitalized tsunami hazard area throughout. We didn't in... That was in section 5.3 policy.


6:29 p.m.

to and so that that should be or policy 1A that should be capitalized. And then there was a comment made that the definition of who can prepare a tsunami plan would be hard for anybody to meet. That's a California licensed professional civil engineer with substantial coastal hazard analysis experience, specifically including evaluating tsunami hazards. And looking at that again, that probably is a little bit or a lot of overkill in terms of what the requirements are. So we would recommend making a change to that. And if you go to the next slide, it would just be a California licensed professional or civil engineer, and that's who would be qualified to prepare the tsunami plan. And then there was also a request. On the next slide.


6:30 p.m.

We refer to the building code ASC 7, and that actually is thoroughly addressed in policy number 8 below. We don't think we need to keep repeating it everywhere, so we would not recommend making that change. Then in policy 2 of the tsunami hazard, there was concern that if, for whatever reason, the California Geological Society started making the tsunami maps differently for whatever reason, that we just wouldn't want to, we wanted some clarification that it was really to show that it is a tsunami hazard area. And so they asked for that language, and we agreed. We would include that language within policy 2.


6:31 p.m.

In Section 5.3, Policy 6, we had a typo there. We used the word change. So we would agree that change needs to be changed to chance. And then, again, another reference to the building code. And, again, we don't believe this needs to be modified because that is clearly identified in Policy 8. And then in Policy 7, this is the requirement for recordation of a development plan when a property is within a tsunami hazard area. And the requirement is to include that development plan recorded on the property, identifying it's in the tsunami hazard area, and include the tsunami safety plan that was prepared for the project. That would include a map of where the tsunami happened.


6:32 p.m.

refuge points are we we believe that's a good change and then here's policy eight and all they asked for is the removal of the specific reference to the policies down there because those change over time and i believe they even have been changed in the 2025 code so we would just recommend removing those that's an appropriate change and then we're moving into now the sea level rise policies and in this policy 2d the last sentence of that policy of the hazard analysis is a little bit is a lot redundant to what's above and it makes sense to just remove that the first part of that policy is perfectly self-explanatory so we would recommend deleting that language and then


6:33 p.m.

Unfortunately, in policy number eight, under transportation, we somehow, the computer left, I'm going to blame it on the computer, left a random word in there. And so we would agree that that should be removed. And here we have, they want to include the reference to the fire safe regulations that are included within the California Code of Regulations. We're fine with doing that within the background. And so we propose to just include all of that chapter and verse within the background. And that's how it would look. And then they want to add that the following policies are intended to help minimize fire risk in the coastal zone, ensure that any applicable fire safety requirements are not incorporated into this coastal area plan, and related. And that's related to coastal zoning regulations.


6:34 p.m.

are carried out in conformity with the LCP. We're fine with including that language. We agree with that and recommend that the commission should include that. And then the first one up there is a little bit bewildering, and I don't want to be negative, but they suggested because they put the reference to the California Code of Regulations in the background that it should be removed from the policies. And, you know, from a planner standpoint, when you go to find out what applies, you go to the policies, not the background. And so we believe that language should absolutely be retained in the policies. And then in Policy 9, and you can see it, it's written right down below, it says the county shall encourage all new development within state-responsible areas blah, blah, blah. We believe that should be a shall.


6:35 p.m.

about it. We want that to be enforced. If you put should there, my experience as a planner is that if a developer does want to do it, we'll have a three-month discussion about should versus shall. And so the shall is the appropriate language there. And so we disagree with the recommendation to change it from shall to should. And then they want to include the use of fire-resistant material in construction. We're good with that. We agree that that should be added. And that would modify Policy 9 under the wildfire provisions. Then moving to Policy 10, just adding at the end of it a statement while minimizing coastal resource impacts. That's always the objective, but it's not bad to say it. So we agree that should just be added. And then coordinating. Thank you.


6:36 p.m.

language, we would agree that changing it to local, state, tribal, and federal fire protection agencies, that's an appropriate change as well, and we would recommend making that change. And then this, I'm sorry this is so hard to read, but here they just recommend basically replacing the language that was there with this language. It's very similar, a little more thorough, a little more detailed here. We're fine with that. We agree with that language change. And then in the Policy 15, this relates to the fire hazard zone safety maps. We keep those and have adopted those and show those on our website, and that should be sufficient. We don't need to refer to the CAL FIRE homepage. Because if there's a slight difference or something, then we're going to be in a weird place. So one place to look for it, and that's the...


6:37 p.m.

adopted local map and we keep them up to date. So we're fine with that change. We agree with that change. And this is one that I kind of cringe at saying this, is that the Samoa Town Master Plan Policy 1 makes a reference to ensuring that buildings are not damaged by a tsunami. And that's not where the policy, overall policy guidance is going in this. And so we would recommend to ensure consistency between all development within the Humboldt Barrier Plan just to remove Policy 1. Chapter 5 still addresses what can and must be done with respect to a tsunami and the dangers of a tsunami. Within the


6:38 p.m.

entirety of the Humboldt area plan and that would include the Samoa Town Master Plan and so then they also wanted us to replace the definition of communities to have it be an environmental justice community and that being the same as a marginalized community or an underserved community we're fine with that we thought we used the the state definition when we did it the first time but if they've modified it we're good with using the updated definition and then there's a concern that we didn't include and this is I feel really kind of bad about this but didn't address water quality and so what we would propose to do is add a new subsection 19 in section 4-1


6:39 p.m.

One of the Humboldt Barrier Plan specifically addressing water quality. And so what this would do is require that projects be designed with either BMPs or other project design elements that would protect water quality before it's released from the sites. And it can be done through mechanical means or non-mechanical means, low-impact development kind of things, or by collecting it in water or oil and grit separators or something like that and screening it before it's released. So these, I think there's A, B, and C on three different slides that go through and basically explain that. And, you know, all development shall be designed to minimize infrastructure. There's an introduction of pollutants that may result in water quality impacts. And also...


6:40 p.m.

Control peak runoff rates and so basically keep a storm runoff basically at the same level as a normal storm so that there would be on-site retention or detention. And then this just goes on and adds to some of that. Maintain existing drainage. Conserve the natural resources by clustering away from it. And so that's something we did want to add. Apologize for that not being in the draft we put out but that water quality obviously is important. And that's more of the BMPs. Thank you. Moving on to Coastal Commission comments on public access.


6:41 p.m.

Thank you. Similar format, page 185 of the same document. This is comment number one. They suggested that a public access site would be around Lamphere Road on the Mad River Slough. Based on aerial photos and street view, there was no evidence of a pullout or boating access at that site. So we do not recommend adding that site to public access because there is no identifiable access in that area. Moving on to comment two. There was a suggestion to provide multiple maps of the public access sites.


6:42 p.m.

More detail so it's easier to identify where the access point is. The GIS will be updated once the Humboldt Bay Area Plan is approved and certified. And we can create zoomed in areas to correspond with the public access inventory as well to show, you know, Manila area, Samoa area, and provide those as more zoomed in maps so the access points are more identifiable. There was recommendation to include the California Department of Fish and Wildlife Mad River Wildlife Area. We do not recommend adding the site because there is no identifiable access point. Based on aerial imagery and street view, it is fenced off. There's no pullout areas that I was able to see that someone could even access with a bike. So it's not.


6:43 p.m.

That we're just looking at car access. We are also looking, you know, for pedestrian, horse, bicycle. There just does not seem to be any identifiable access point to these sites. Comment number four was asking why these listed sites were removed. This is the old public access inventory map, and I will go site by site. The first one is Walker Point Road. There is no identifiable public access for this subdivision. The second one, Jacoby Creek Mouth, and this section of the PowerPoint is the current adopted certified language from the Humboldt Bay Area Plan.


6:44 p.m.

there's no direct point of access for this site. This is an aerial imagery. It's off of 101. It is accessible by the Humboldt Bay Trail. However, you can't pull off to the side of 101 and access that bridge. So that is why we are not recommending adding it to the public access inventory. Similarly, for Braycut, there is no, this is owned by the California Coastal Conservancy. I believe it is a mitigation site. It is not developed for trails or pedestrian bicycles, any of that. But you can ride along the Humboldt Bay Trail. So you can view it, but there's no identifiable public access spot within that parcel. Old Arcata Road, this was included in the original Humboldt Bay Area Plan. And there's no established trail.


6:45 p.m.

or sidewalk, we would recommend that the Humboldt Bay Trail could be used for pedestrians, bicyclists to go between Arcata and Eureka. However, we do not feel it's appropriate to identify a road with no sidewalks to be public access if there's no safe way for them to go from point A to point B. Deadmau5 Marsh, I believe this is also a mitigation area. There is no identifiable public access. You cannot pull off to the side of the road and walk around that area. It is just a marsh with no access. So that is why we are not recommending including it in the public access inventory. For the Faisaloo, the actual public access inventory is not included in the public access inventory. Access to this wildlife area is within the city of Eureka.


6:46 p.m.

jurisdiction. The access is right here off of 101 by the car dealerships and that was the only identifiable access point that we were able to observe to enter this wildlife area so it would be within the city of Eureka's jurisdiction which is why we are not including it within the public access inventory for the Humboldt Bay Area Plan. Finally comment number five is Coastal Commission said there is access to the Bay and Fields Landing at the end of South Bay Depot Road and this is the end of South Bay Depot Road. There are some gates and it is an industrial site. This was previously a site 103 in the public access inventory of the current adopted certified Humboldt Bay Area Plan and it was really a site that was not in the public access inventory of the current adopted certified Humboldt Bay Area Plan and it was really a site that was not in the public access inventory of the to be deleted previously because of the physical hazards and there is


6:47 p.m.

access there is a boat ramp and launch point within fields landing so due to it is now owned by the Humboldt Bay Conservation District however it is still an industrial site so we do not recommend including it as a public access site because there it could still be gated off and there is still remaining industrial and that would conclude the public access and we are going to move on to comments on the land use and zone change proposals hi I'm gonna I'm gonna present um well I'm Rodney I'm sure you guys know me um um we got some comments uh specifically on some of the proposed land use and zone change proposals and we're going to move on to comments on the land use and zone changes within this uh project the comments came from the Humboldt Bay Waterkeeper


6:48 p.m.

Epic and CRTP and I'm just going to kind of go through their concerns. There's a response from the county at the bottom and I'm going to start. The first parcel that was commented on is at the base of Humboldt Hill. It's a large parcel that was previously an urban reserve, but this plan will change that because their service is there now. But the concern from the commenter was that the ownership has changed since the original proposal, which is true, and that the parcel is now owned by the Weop tribe, which is also true. We have reached out to the tribe multiple times on this matter amongst others, and we have not received a response. And this proposal was removed from this project in very early September. So it's not even in. Any of the documents.


6:49 p.m.

that are part of this hearing. So there's that one. The next one is at the top of Humboldt Hill. There's a rather large parcel at the terminus of Humboldt Hill Road that was proposing to change from AE land use and zoning to residential land use and zoning. The concern was regarding future subdivision of the parcel, the parcel needing secondary access if there was a subdivision based on the state responsibility area requirements, and then the parcel has a lot of earthquake faults on it. As described in the staff report, we believe it would be acceptable to modify the land use at this time. However, the zoning should be modified at a time a future project is proposed. There's a lot of constraints up there and we feel a planned development zone developed with a complete set of technical studies would be most appropriate.


6:50 p.m.

It's actually in the documents that we've brought forward tonight, the proposal that I just read. The next one here is a... Can we interrupt really quick? I guess I'm not, for the last two parcels, I'm not clear whether or not you were agreeing or not agreeing with their changes. The first one is we removed this from the discussion in September. This isn't even a thing anymore. We did not get in touch with the tribe, and we don't feel they want to develop that parcel with high density. The second one, we removed the proposal to rezone it. We don't want to rezone it until more studies are done. We feel that the land use could be changed, but we'd like the zoning to remain the same at this point. The third one is we removed the proposal to rezone it. We don't want to rezone it until more studies are done. We feel that the land use could be changed, but we'd like the zoning to remain the same at this point.


6:51 p.m.

This next parcel is in the Braycut area, a little east of Highway 101, and this proposal was to change from a natural resource land use and zoning to an agriculture-exclusive land use and zoning. The concern from the commenter is that the land use and zone change would promote future development in wetlands, and that the parcel was part of a study called the Lower Rocky Gulch Salmonid Access and Habitat Restoration Project that was done in 2006, and also that the parcel sits within Humboldt Bay's salt marsh extent. Now, I had not heard of this Rocky Gulch Habitat Restoration Project, so I did some digging. I had to go downstairs, actually, to find some files. But I reviewed it, and I've determined that the site is indeed classified as a salt marsh. It's a salt marsh based on the biological documentation and is not considered a salt marsh.


6:52 p.m.

Considered a farm wetland and staff is removing, recommending to remove this proposal from the list entirely. Okay, so remove it entirely. Yes. This one is a parcel that's near Indianola and 101. It's kind of northeast right there. And they're proposing to change a portion of the parcel from ag zoning to residential zoning. The concern from the commenter was that the parcel contains wetlands, it's in the flood zone, and it's subject to sea level rise inundation. I just want to point out that this is a 58-acre parcel, and this proposal only replants and rezones 0.6 acres, which is 1% of the parcel. And that area is an upland portion of the parcel at approximately 40-foot elevation that's outside of wetlands.


6:53 p.m.

flood zone and future inundation from sea level rise and this proposal is recommended to stay we support the proposal next one please okay this one is the fields landing it's kind of dead center there in the middle if they wanted to change and from a low residential to a high residential parcel 30 units per acre the concern from the commenters that the parcel is subject to sea level rise inundation and the density shouldn't be increased it certainly is subject to inundation from sea level rise kind of overlooked this one a little bit because it's got an apartment complex on it but it it's only a 10 unit apartment complex on a half acre parcel so i did some i did some homework in and found that up zoning to 30 units


6:54 p.m.

per acre would allow for an additional 11 units to be developed and that's counting maximum density calculations. I went a little further and found that upzoning to 15 units per acre would align with the existing density on site which could be acceptable and then a little bit further on that I found that not allowing the change would ensure that any redevelopment say the parcel was swiped clean and redeveloped it would only allow for a density to three to seven units per acre which we feel would be more appropriate considering it's subject to sea level rise so we recommend this be removed from the list. Okay, this one here.


6:55 p.m.

with me here for a second. Okay, I just wanted to get my bearings on where it is. This parcel here is the, it's part of that industrial complex. It's on 255 where, right south of where it crosses the Mad River Slough. There's a big old mill site there. There's a parcel in the top right-hand corner that has a different zoning than the rest. The landowner want to rezone that from natural resources to industrial land use and zoning. The concern from the commenter is that the parcel may contain legacy contamination beneath the asphalt, that the change would encourage industrial use that could expose contaminated soils, that it's adjacent to sensitive biological resources, it's actually close to tribal resources, and has habitat restoration potential. The only thing we could really say is the parcel is part of an existing industrial site,


6:56 p.m.

Under one ownership, it's paved. It's been historically used for industrial purposes. And this proposal continues to be supported by the planning division. I have a question on that one. It's paved. Are you able to find any, if it's zoned natural resources, why is it paved? I don't know. That is the big question, right? It's like, why would they put a natural resource zone on a paved parcel? Or was it paved? Yeah, I guess that's the question in my head is, was it paved inappropriately? Or was it zoned after the fact and not necessarily paying attention? There's been a lot of work done on that property over a long, long period of time. We don't know. And. I think that.


6:57 p.m.

You know, that is something for the commission to weigh. It's like if you have a tendency to think that somebody went and paved something that they shouldn't have paved, then maybe you want to keep the land use and zoning where it is. If you believe or think or are even inclined to think that all that paving was done at once and, you know, sometimes the parcel lines are not easily determined when you're out in the field and that they weren't trying to do anything wrong and it's been part of an industrial site for at least 70 years. I mean, and that's kind of where we fell. That's helpful. Thank you. Okay. The next parcel is...


6:58 p.m.

Just south of the boundary of the city of Arcata, just north of Samoa Boulevard, the proposal was to change the land use and zoning of a third of the parcel from industrial to residential. The concern is that, from the commenters, that the parcel contains wetlands and is a former mill site with potential contamination that's not been assessed. And that potential impact should be assessed prior to residential zoning. So I took a look at it, and yes, the entire parcel is mapped wetlands, and it does appear to be the site of a historic industrial operation. We do have notes on file that the parcel is in the Arcata City Sphere and is planned as residential and urban service area by the city. If the city annexes the parcel in the future, we feel that the land use...


6:59 p.m.

Zoning changes can be addressed by the city at that time. We propose to remove this proposal from the list. That would conclude the presentation unless the commission would like us to go back to any slides before we open the document. Commissioner Fulton. I would, and I apologize for not interrupting Director Ford when he was speaking, but if we can go back to policy B, your definition change in regards to the civil engineer. Yeah. I think just my opinion, I think we, for lack of a better word, dummied it down too far as far as just any old civil engineer when it comes to tsunami hazard and seaside hazards and what have you. I think some wordage could be changed in there in regards to with a background.


7 p.m.

of coastal hazard analysis with experience in that. So we have, I mean, just not any old civil engineer is going to be able to make the decisions I think you're looking for. So that's just my thought. Somebody with at least a little bit of background in that world would be good. Wouldn't that be a geologist? It could be. It could be an engineering geologist, professional or civil engineer. And then I think what you're asking for is with a background in coastal hazards. Correct. Just something to say that he has some experience in that world as opposed to just being a civil engineer. Yeah, that makes sense. If the commission is okay with that. I saw Commissioner Scaptol and then Commissioner O'Neill. Yeah, I did.


7:01 p.m.

I don't think a coastal engineer is that difficult to find. They're not rare. It's a whole specialty, especially along the west coast. And with sea level rise and tsunami hazards, I just disagree that it's difficult to find one. So you would be okay with just leaving it as it was? Yes. Yes. Commissioner O'Neill? My comment on the intermediate versus the intermediate high, I didn't see a whole lot of difference in the maps. Can we just, I'm sorry. Okay. Could we finish one discussion at a time? Okay. I didn't know we weren't finished. Well, I think the commission needs to come to consensus on what you want to do with that. On the item regarding the experience for the engineer. Oh, I thought you were done. Well, I've got two different, actually four different. Ideas here. Three different ideas.


7:02 p.m.

We'll come right back to yours after this one. I think a licensed professional engineer, you don't have to use the word civil, licensed professional engineer with a specialty in coastal engineering and experience in tsunami hazards is not that. Okay. So just slightly different than what was there. But keeping the expertise specific to coastal and tsunami hazards. Civil engineer is a broad, broad discipline. I think you want to narrow it a bit to get that coastal expertise that Commissioner Fulton was referring to. As someone who has worked in that field for quite a long time, I'm deferring to you. I'm going to ask you to give us your expertise on this one and how easy or hard it is to find an engineer like that.


7:03 p.m.

So I'm amenable to that. Every project that's done along the coast, I mean, they exist. It's not a unicorn. It's a tricky one. I think whenever we consider qualifications of someone who's giving professional advice for consideration, we end up in a pickle when we have somebody who's not giving us enough information and may not have all the qualifications that we think we need if it's a controversial project. But also we don't want to provide an undue burden to the applicant to find somebody who's either very expensive or very hard to find. But it sounds like in this case that's likely not to be the case, so I'm in support. So I want to make sure I captured what you said. A licensed engineer with experience in coastal hazards. Yes. Okay. Is that okay?


7:04 p.m.

Consensus? I would agree with that. And just to throw it out there to Commissioner Scavdahl, would you be amicable to engineer slash geologist? Yes, different applications. Those are two different things. Two different things. Could you tell us specifically which section this is referring to? This is preparing the tsunami safety plan and the qualified individual to prepare that.


7:05 p.m.

For residential development. Yeah. I think it would be the engineer, personally. Okay. Okay, so I'm seeing a couple head nods. Are we generally in agreement on this? Okay, I'm seeing head nods and thumbs up for this one. Thank you. I'm sorry to interrupt. Okay. Okay, so then I think that brings us to Commissioner O'Neill's question. I just, this is my opinion. They might have different opinions, but I didn't see a whole lot of difference between the mapping on the intermediate and the intermediate high, and so I think going with the intermediate could be appropriate. There was only a few areas that seemed to change that much, but maybe somebody else had different observations.


7:06 p.m.

I would agree with Commissioner O'Neill. Okay. Commissioner Kariasi? I would point out I double-checked the NOAA maps you're referring to do not include vertical changes in vertical elevation per the storyboard that was developed by Northern Hydrology Engineering that Director Colt from Humboldt Baykeeper referenced. So it's the Northern Hydrology maps that include or account for vertical changes. The OPC does. It's just not the NOAA maps. Okay. So I bring that up just because Commissioner O'Neill, I think we're not necessarily seeing these maps aren't accounting for how the bay is subsiding. And so I think we'd want to reference different maps. Well, I'm only going by what I'm seeing. So, I mean, if there's something else, then that needs to be presented.


7:07 p.m.

Thank you. And this is 2100? It's 2100. So I mean a lot can happen between then that could change things, right? So one of the struggles here is that we're a little bit early into this whole process of sea level rise to know how it's going to turn out. So like when you look at the intermediate high, or look at the high, you know, the scientists think there's really no chance that that's going to be exceeded. And so that's why that's so conservative. Intermediate high, there is an 80% chance that won't be exceeded. And that percentage has to do with how well. We as a global community.


7:08 p.m.

address climate change. If we're good about that and slow down the path, then the intermediate could be more appropriate. But if we're not real good about it, then intermediate high is perhaps more appropriate. And so that's what we're struggling with here is there's a degree of uncertainty. And so we are admittedly leaning towards the intermediate high because that is conservative. We were a little bit encouraged looking at the maps, although they're the NOAA maps without some guidance. But there's not a huge difference in what happens between the 3.9 and the intermediate high. And so we're not really sure. And so we're not really sure. We used 4 and 5.5.


7:09 p.m.

We could pull up that model and choose to compare five and six to be more representative of what's going on with subsidence, although that would be an overestimation as well. But they're both, because of the configuration, the shoreline, the things that are going on there, they're pretty similar except for those low areas that we all know are low. And one of them is the green up there that we just know that if sea level rise happens at any rate, those are going to start getting affected. We know that King Salmon up there already experienced what, it was really more than nuisance flooding. They had a pretty catastrophic event that left them.


7:10 p.m.

wet. And so we're looking at real conditions that are starting to occur. And so what we're doing now is deciding on a policy document that helps us to think about how do we think and address sea level rise as we go forward. I mean some people would want to go to low and and say no you know that's way too conservative. But others would want to say you know what if we have to start relocating people in like 2080 then we should we should be prepared to start thinking about that. That needs to be in our policy document. Don't you also have to start thinking about raising in the highway? Caltrans is is a working on that. If Lorna was here she would talk at length about what they're doing right now in terms of planning.


7:11 p.m.

and how they're working with the Coastal Commission. Because, I mean, that pretty much is the first thing you need to worry about. That's the backbone of this community for at least around the Bay, of course, and so is 255, frankly. But look how long it took them just to raise a little bit. I mean, just one little overpass was a huge project, and I enjoy going over it because you have a nice view of the Bay. It would be nice if the whole thing was that high, but I can't imagine what that would cost. It's going to be really hard to adapt to sea level rise at some point. And so as planner, you want to start to put things on a map that remind you that you've got something to pay attention to there. Because one day, one day...


7:12 p.m.

It's happening in Southern California right now in all the beach communities, and it's not even a storm. It's 102 degrees down there, and they're losing the whole shoreline. Well, but there's El Nino-driven waves that are happening there that are highly unusual. Highly unusual is the... Is the new norm. Yeah. Right. And so I guess we have to get used to highly unusual, too? Well, and that's the struggle here. I'm glad you're struggling with it. Because that's what we're... I'm sorry, I'm not speaking into the mic. That's what we really have to struggle with. And I don't like to put colors on a map that show that people's property is going to flood. We don't like that. But if we don't start to think about that, we can't plan for it. This is... I think one of our most... I think one of our most... I think one of our most...


7:13 p.m.

Important discussions for this document and I don't want to curtail it but I think I we do have I think a more staff report. We were going to open up the document and walk through it if you want or if there's specific things that you really want to discuss rather than just walking through it we can do that. Prior to public comment or post public comment. Your discretion. Sure. Okay. I think typically where I'm inclined to have public comment before we truly get into the weeds on everything and so people can say what they need to say before it gets too late in the evening. But also if there are things that you think it would be helpful for the public to hear before public comment. I don't want to stop that. I don't know that wandering through the. I don't mean to. Wandering strong term. I don't know that. I don't know that.


7:14 p.m.

Going through the actual document is going to help the public that much at this point. I think that, you know, we've introduced some of the bigger issues that need to be addressed. Certainly, sea level rise is, like you said, it's probably the one, if not the most important, one of the most important things that need to be addressed in this plan. And it needs some thought. Okay. Okay. If the commission is amenable to it, I think what we'll do is we'll do public comment, and then we'll do a break, and then we'll come back, and we'll move through the document. Does that sound good to everybody? Okay. So with that, we're going to move to the public comment portion of this item. What I'm going to do is similar to the other items on the agenda, I'm going to start with folks in the room. Please approach the podium and line up if you'd like to comment on this item. And then if you are online or calling in, please raise your hand now so that when I move to online.


7:15 p.m.

And phone call comments after in-person comments. I know who to call on. There can be a little bit of a lag, and I don't want to miss your hand. So please raise your hand now if you are calling in or online and you would like to comment on this item. And then we'll move to the room and see if there's anybody in the room who would like to comment. If you would like to comment on this item, please approach the podium. All right. I'm Jane Madsen. I'm from Samoa and I was very impressed with the amount of attention paid to Little Samoa in our Humboldt area plan. So I would like to first request that public comment perhaps be allowed after the entire document's been...


7:16 p.m.

gone through, but I will respect your opinion. And I just wanted to echo John Ford's comment about the difference between shall and should. Having been a lawyer for, I don't want to say how many years, that is a very crucial point. Shall is easy and should is just litigation waiting to happen. So that's my primary comment. Thank you. Thank you. Tonight, we addressed most everything in the Samoa Master Town Plan previously when we had two public comments. So I think tonight, barring extraneous circumstances, we will have one public comment for this item. Hello, good evening commissioners and staff. I'm Amy Jester. I'm a resident of Eureka and I work


7:17 p.m.

with the Redwood Region Climate and Community Resilience Hub based at Humboldt Area Foundation. I just wanted to appreciate the work that you all have done on the update to the Bay Area plan and the thoughtful discussion about all of the items including the port overlay element and environmental justice. I appreciate the staff's consideration of our comments and finding ways to address those in the document so thank you for that. As you consider the plan tonight and your future roles as decision makers I just wanted to highlight that the Humboldt Bay Harbor District has already begun environmental review for their heavy lift offshore wind heavy lift multi-purpose marine terminal project and that environmental review will support the future port overlay application that will come before this commission. So while I recognize you're not dissatisfied with the plan I just wanted to highlight that the Humboldt Bay Harbor District has already begun environmental review for their heavy lift offshore wind heavy lift multi-purpose marine terminal project and that environmental review will support the future port overlay application


7:18 p.m.

play zone is as part of the Bay Area plan update. I do think that attention to that plan moving forward being an active environmental review with the notice of preparation being released last week that it's important to acknowledge that as part of this the hearing this evening. There are a number of community interests that and concerns that Core Hub has learned about over the last couple of years regarding the project that you'll be considering as part of the overlay and for which you'll be setting precedents for a new industry on the west coast and in the United States and that includes how we design expanded industrial standards for lighting, noise, vibration, air quality and emission, cumulative impacts on disadvantaged communities, compatibility with nearby neighborhoods and affordable housing and protection of tribal cultural resources and culturally significant areas. As the process moves forward your decisions will help


7:19 p.m.

define what responsible offshore wind development looks like on the west coast the port overlay will be an opportunity to show the economic opportunity renewable energy environmental stewardship cultural resource protection and community well-being can move forward together thank you for your consideration and your service to the community have a good night thank you you You guys can ignore most of that because you guys, yeah, there's two, yeah. You guys addressed most of that stuff that's in there. Hi, Sylvia Van Ryan with Humboldt Waterkeeper. Since the planners addressed the large majority of our land use and zoning change recommendations, I'm just going to touch on one or two. The parcel off of Indianola cutoff of 501.


7:20 p.m.

1-261-039, of which I've included a map for the things you're being handed right now. The parcel does consist mostly of wetlands, and I recognize that the proposal is for the upland portion of that parcel. If you take a look at it on Google Earth, the upland part of it is not that elevated, and the parcel itself is also going to be almost completely surrounded by sea level rise, as well as if you turn on the FEMA flood zone layer on the county web GIS, you can also see it's almost surrounding that parcel. I don't think it would be appropriate to encourage housing development on any portion of this parcel. I do think it would be appropriate to encourage future restoration and public recreation by changing the parcel's designation to natural resources, and this would actually also support some of the sea level rise adaptations that Caltrans has proposed in the community. The CAPE that they published this past year, because that segment of the one...


7:21 p.m.

is one of the segments that they're proposing for various adaptation projects. So I think that would be a really great opportunity for some restoration. In one of our previous comment letters on the Humboldt Bay Area Plan update, we requested some clear policies within the port overlay zone requiring avoidance, minimization, and mitigation of impacts. The only direct mention of impacts within the port overlay zone descriptions is talking about allowing impacts to ESHA given certain mitigations. And I just wanted to get a clearer picture of why avoidance and minimization weren't uplifted as a top priority. We're really hoping that the county can establish clear environmental performance standards at the planning level, which would provide greater regulatory certainty for applicants and ensure that future offshore wind infrastructure proceeds in a manner that is already consistent with the coastal act without having to go back. And...


7:22 p.m.

do any tweaks on the policy. I'm hoping that we can get a clear outline of the environmental review processes that the county will be involved with in regards to the port overlay zone. Whether or not the county is the lead agency on that environmental review, the public deserves a clear answer on the collaboration with the harbor district on the overlay zone. And lastly, we still haven't seen an incorporation of a discussion on contamination outside of the Samoa Town Master Plan. Humboldt Bay is listed as impaired on the 303D Clean Water Act list for dioxins and furans, and that is still not mentioned in the HBAP, and we would love to see that incorporated. We also recommended incorporating a contaminated sites overlay zone, and we'd love to see that potentially incorporated as well. Thank you. Anybody else present in the audience who would like to give public comment? Okay.


7:23 p.m.

Seeing anybody, so I'm going to go ahead and move to online and phone calls. One more reminder, please raise your hand now if you would like to comment, if you are online or calling in. And I'm going to start calling on folks. So we have Aaron or Eron, E-R-O-N, you have the floor for three minutes. Thank you. Hey, Laura, can you let him in? I've completely lost internet. We are working to unmute you currently. There you are, you are unmuted.


7:24 p.m.

Thank you. Erin or Eron, we aren't able to hear you if you are speaking, but it is your turn. You have three minutes. Can you hear me now? I can hear you now, yes. Hi, my name is Erin Gonzalez. I live in the old town of Samoa, close to the proposed heavy lift terminal. Before approving the port overlay language on page 61, please explain what rules currently protect our homes from noise, vibration, lighting, pollution, and truck traffic. Which Samoa Town Master Plan protections apply to the terminal property? Would the overlay weaken or override any existing rules, and what protections would it add? If the proposed overlay allows industrial impacts that cannot be adequately controlled in our home, please include a volunteer buyout relocation program. Samoa Town Master Plan


7:25 p.m.

Please put these answers and comments in your writing before approving changes. Our health, safety, and homes deserve protection. Thank you, Aaron. Okay, I'm not seeing anybody else with their hand raised. So we're going to go ahead and close public comment. And bring it back to the commission. It is 7.24, so I do believe we are going to go ahead and take a 10-minute break and return at 7.34. Thank you.


7:35 p.m.

Thank you. We are going to continue on with our item that we are currently considering, which is item G1, the public hearing on the Humboldt Bay Area Plan and local coastal plan amendment and zone reclassification of parcels within the Humboldt Bay Area Plan. If you would give us the privilege of responding to a public comment, we'd appreciate that. Yeah, absolutely. So I did want to go, the waterkeeper did in the first comment here tonight, was discussing this parcel in Indianola ending in 039. And I just wanted to go through the evidence that I looked at to make our determination to support the change. So if you can bear with me, I'm going to share my screen here and try to walk through.


7:36 p.m.

This on zoom. Oh boy. Not that one. Aha. Share. I'm sharing this. I can... Okay. So I'm going to go through a few layers here. This is the parcel that's ending in 039. You can't see the whole border because of the pop-up, but it's a very large parcel. Let's see here. Let's go to some of these constraint layers. This would be the sea level rise layer right here.


7:37 p.m.

We'll dump the tsunami layer right on top of it here. Get this out of here. And I could put the flood layer on, but I don't really know if that's necessary. It's not as extensive as this layer. So I'm going to take down to the portion of the parcel that's proposed for the change. It's this chunk right here. So I did look at this in detail. I even did go to Google Earth, which I will bring up now. And just for reference, remember these trees and the structure here? If you go to Google Earth, what we're looking at is this area right here. Oh, I have to stop share. Can't I minimize this?


7:38 p.m.

This or something? Try that. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Let's see here. Is it coming up? Okay, so if you remember we're talking about this section right here. And Google Earth will show us the elevation. So down in the area where all the constraint layers were lit up. We're about two, three feet down here. And up here where the proposed change is is on this, up on this knoll here. And the elevation is 50 feet here. 45 here.


7:39 p.m.

42 here. So I did look at all this, and I was unable to make findings to deny this request. So I just wanted to share that for the commission to see. To deny the property owner's request. Yeah. Yeah. This was proposed, and I looked at it, and I looked at the comments from the waterkeeper, and I'm like, okay, I'm going to look at this again, and then I'm going to look at it again. And at the end, I just didn't find, I couldn't make the findings to go along with the recommendation. So I just wanted to share that to show that, you know, we did do our homework. Then I'm not biased about the change at all. So if the commission doesn't want the change. Any commission questions or comment on this item? We're going to need someplace to put the houses that are going to need to be moved because of sea level. See, saying the house was hard tieneed at this time. And by the time we moved theffuc Nuti right there, we could take theaiougihekn what ever that is right there. That was near This is actually<|nn|> one of our main responsibility decides anything. So we think. Okay.


7:40 p.m.

I think that keeping as much of it as residential as we can is the right answer. Commissioner Chiarozzzi. Can you clarify or I guess repeat, it's just that portion of the entire parcel that is the zone, rezoning. Okay. Were there any other items from public comment that staff wanted to address? So, when the EIR, it's important to understand that EIR being prepared by the Harbor District. Harbor District will be the lead agency. We will be making comments on how things may or may not align with the current zoning. And our concern is that we will be making comments on how things may or may not align


7:41 p.m.

with compatibility and the need to address those. The zoning, assuming the EIR adequately addresses those items, the county can use that EIR to either modify the zoning standards or adopt a port overlay zone. The county can choose to say that this EIR doesn't adequately address that and require preparation of a subsequent environmental document. We hope that what the Harbor District does is prepare an environmental document that does adequately address all the issues. And so anything the county needs to be involved in, the county will be involved in. The county is the only one that can do that. The county is the only one that can do that. The county is not, just to repeat, is not the lead agency in this. The county will not...


7:42 p.m.

not process the coastal development permit even for the upland portion of it there was a law passed by the state requiring the coastal commission to be the approving authority for anything port or offshore wind related so the county's been carved out of that for we have another public comment that um they were asking for us to do some things but i'd also i think it sounded like they were asking for some clarification on how the um how this document and like setting up a port overlay zone interplays with the environmental document and the permitting process can you discuss that a little bit so the way i i yeah i just tried to explain it obviously it wasn't clear so the way i anticipate that it will play out


7:43 p.m.

is that the Harvard District will prepare an environmental document that addresses their needs which we don't know what they are yet in terms of what that heavy lift terminal will look like and the environmental effects of that and also the land use compatibility effects associated with that and then they will or should be identifying what they intend to do to address some of those zoning issues the place that the county does have discretion is in the zoning because the zoning is a different issue than development under the coastal act so if it's not compatible with zoning then the county has discretion there so there probably will need to be I do anticipate there will be a change in the zoning process but I don't think it's going to be a change in the zoning process but I do anticipate there will need to be amendments to the zone


7:44 p.m.

to make this work. So what will happen is that the EIR should evaluate what it would, what the environmental effects would be of changing the zone to allow the heavy lift marine terminal to move forward. I think you're being very clear about that. I think where I'm hearing confusion, and honestly could use it, but making sure I'm still understanding, is how the decisions we make in this port overlay and in this document impact that process. Sure. So part of what this document will do is establish policies and guidance for future considerations. Part of what then the Harbor District would do, is either find that they can follow that policy guidance.


7:45 p.m.

or not. And if they can't, they may be in a place where they're asking for relief or modifications to that policy guidance. I don't know. I'm speculating. I'm giving you the worst case. Okay. And so the way ideally that it works is that the things that the commission puts in place and the board adopts guides how any future port overlay zone or future consideration of the heavy lift marine terminal by the coastal commission are considered, processed, and looked at. And evaluated. I mean, I think that some of the discussion around the environmental justice associated with what's in the bay.


7:46 p.m.

Has been helpful. So that begins to set some sideboards. Does it set absolute prohibitions right now? No, it doesn't But does it say this really needs to be considered? Yeah, I think it does and the arenas that it'll be considered in are at the port overlay zone Could be considered in the port overlays on considerations. That's on the part of the county The Coastal Commission can choose to use the Humboldt area plan for guidance They don't have to And then the Sequel document does not necessarily reference this document. It has its own state guidance that it know it the EIR will have to look at Consistency with this document Okay and so If there are things there that are inconsistent with this document, it will be required to disclose


7:47 p.m.

So the steps are this document and concurrently the Harbor District is starting to do their environmental document. Yes. And then once they complete their environmental document, then potentially a port overlay zone would be considered by this commission. I would say that would be the likely scenario, yes. And then depending on how that all shakes out within, either they would need to do more environmental review or they would move towards other steps. Am I understanding correctly? Yes. Okay. Thank you. That was very helpful to understand exactly how everything interplays. Commissioner Curiazzi. Yeah, thank you for doing that discussion. And to clarify, so if a port overlay zone came to us through that EIR program, would that potentially add to the cost of the EIR process?


7:48 p.m.

Additional conditions to the EI, I guess what what comes out of that port overlay zone process? So they could apply for the port overlay zone first. But the environmental work needs to be done before that can be adopted. ____________ Normally, if the county were the lead agency in processing that, we would do the environmental document as part of the review of the zoning change. And then there would be communication between the environmental work and the zoning work. In this particular case, the Harbor District is the lead agency. They're focusing on...


7:49 p.m.

what they need to do to implement a project. And the county functions as a responsible agency because we have to issue zoning. So the normal way that that works is that the lead agency will finish the environmental document, will finish their work, and then begin to do the subsequent permitting, which in this case involves a zone change. And then the county will be in the place of looking at that environmental document to determine whether or not it's adequate for the zoning action. Commissioner Scapto.


7:50 p.m.

And depending, again, on the circumstances, so then they could at some point be required to do a supplemental EIR to address things that haven't been covered that come up during the zoning change. That would be correct, yes. Okay. And it sounds like they don't necessarily, did I hear you right earlier on that they don't necessarily need to come to us for a port overlay zone? If they can comply with the current zoning standards and the current policies within the Humboldt Bay Area Plan, no, they don't. But it's my understanding the buildings, the light standards. The cranes are all going to exceed heights that are allowed by the current zoning.


7:51 p.m.

Thank you. So we're laying the groundwork of the port overlay zone that it will be then the framework by which the future zoning changes are going to be made within that framework. It's like we're laying the groundwork of the port overlay zone in this document. Right. And so the questions that you're raising is, are you putting enough sideboards into that port overlay zone to feel comfortable that a future application can live within those sideboards and those adequately reflect the concerns of the community? Correct. Yes. Thank you. Okay. So it sounds like I think we've covered most everything that came up.


7:52 p.m.

A comment. And staff wants to now move to the document, correct? Well, we can. I mean, but if there's specific things that you'd prefer to focus your time on, we've got, you know, time's precious. Yeah. Commissioner Kiryasi? Yeah, I do have a couple more questions in terms of what, from the staff report, if I could address those. So the, you had, for the Coastal Commission's comments, I think it was the page 18, number one, alternate language for the environmental justice community section. I've missed if you were agreeing to accept their change or not. Yes. Yes, we were. Okay. Thank you. And then in terms of.


7:53 p.m.

We walked through the different recommended access, coastal access points from the Coastal Commission. And that was really helpful to see your thought process on whether or not there is an existing access. And to clarify, it looks like it's related to the language in the Humboldt Area Plan where the county would, for new development, would grant an easement for any particular property where an existing access exists. Yeah, you know, and it's a little bit unusual right now. I don't want to confuse this. But in 1982, there wasn't nearly... There wasn't nearly as much development around Humboldt Bay. There's a lot. But there's been development since then. And, you know, some of the places where access was anticipated didn't end up being there.


7:54 p.m.

And so then the, the, the, and, and Miss Meehan and the previous manager that was working on this actually went out and looked at these sites. I mean, did a visual survey of them. It's not just looking at aerial images to determine whether or not they're appropriate or not. It's, it's like you saw in the one picture of, of, I think that was Fields Landing. It's like, that goes right into an industrial site. And so in that one, I'm forgetting the name of it, but it's along the safety corridor and it's associated with a bridge that is part of the Humboldt Bay Trail. And there is pedestrian access, but you had noted that because there's no vehicular access, you wouldn't want people stopping on the highway, for example, to access that point. Correct. And one of the other things that we did, and you've probably seen this, is that we.


7:55 p.m.

included all the trails as part of that access and recreation so the trails clearly identified there as as as being an amenity yeah so i was just curious if um because there's access uh by foot but not by car but that's your thinking is that if you're you're looking at all modes of access essentially is that right yes um for that specific site there is no direct access to that point you have to go on the humble bay trail in order to get to that so that's why it's not identified as a site because you'd have to be walking the humble bay trail in order to access it or get out of your car or walk along 101 to access it so that's why we aren't recommending keeping that site in because it is no


7:56 p.m.

longer a direct point or there's no direct point of access it would just be part of the Humboldt Bay Trail which is included in public access under trails so it's not just an area of interest anymore it'd just be part of the Humboldt Bay Trail. So meaning it doesn't necessarily need a special easement you already have access to it from the trail that's am I capturing that correctly? So at that point is there some place for people to go does that provide access to out into the bay onto the it would be more of a viewpoint you know standing on a bridge at the mouth of the Jacoby Creek I would assume you know probably some good bird watching other than that it's not like you could access Jacoby Creek or the Bay Trail.


7:57 p.m.

directly from that site. I mean you could but it's not identified as a site where you can get into the water. Is that the site that has the benches there? I can check. I don't believe so at least anymore since they have updated that in the recent years. That was one of the replacement bridges. Okay. Commissioner Scafdal? Yeah while we're on public access if you don't mind. Walker Point, Walker Point Road was one of the ones that you I think recommended removing but in the document when we talk about Walker Point Road and rural development and 3.5 there's actually a discussion about there being a dedicated easement and it so even though it may


7:58 p.m.

not be developed today if there's a dedicated easement for a trail that accesses the coastal air shouldn't we leave that in the public access regarding the easement it was recorded in a track map and i believe it was 93 and then the next recorded map it said it was rejected in 2000 so we are not sure what the current status of that easement is that easement exists it does exist still um and i could pull up those track maps if we need to to pull up the shown easement so one of the confusing things here and commissioner scavall you know this is an engineer is that there's the offer of the easement and sometimes it's not accepted okay but the easement is not accepted okay but the easement is not accepted but the easement still is there as an offer


7:59 p.m.

It's required to be offered. I don't think any... Okay. Well, let me change that. I think that a citizen did accept that easement. It's an easement right now to a person. It was an easement to Mrs. Cockcroft, and then it was offered to the county, and from what I saw, it was rejected by the county. But there's no identified public access. There's no kiosk. There's no bench. There's no parking. It's confusing, and I'm not sure if it's usable or used. I just don't know. Is there going to be other access granted there as a condition of mitigation of the construction that was going on there? Well, you may recall that there's two parcels there that were engaged in... It's been a rather unfortunate debacle.


8 p.m.

and I believe those two parcels are actually being dedicated to the primary recipient would be the tribes okay okay and that easement goes to those two properties but does not go beyond that so it goes down around and goes along the bluff overlooking this loo wasn't there a lady that came and talked to us about that easement and said she had given that easement when all that was going on I remember a woman that came in and talked about that I guess the point of my question is it's a little bit confusing than one part of the document it reads about a dedicated easement for a trail and then earlier this evening in response to Coastal Commission comments we're saying we're gonna remove that area as a public access area so I just looking


8:01 p.m.

for us to be somewhat consistent there. So if we're going to remove it, maybe we remove that part about a dedicated easement too. I mean, the dedicated easement could be separate from the public access site in the sense of currently there isn't a developed public access point. It would be... I think we should put it back in. If I read this document, I'm going to go walk on a trail there because that's what this document says. And there is, there are, at the end of the cul-de-sac, there are two bollards there that prevent vehicles from going in there, but pedestrians can. What's that? We could add that back to the public access. Okay. Okay. Thank you. Thank you.


8:02 p.m.

To the question about whether or not we go through the document or whether or not we just talk about the issues on our minds, we have about an hour and 15 minutes left for this meeting, and I wanted to see where the interest was with our commission in terms of how we wanted to use our time. I have a number of comments that at least I structured in a way anticipating we would go through the document. I think also I'm feeling a bit like I came into this meeting feeling a bit hesitant that I felt like I could approve this at this point. I know that's not what we're hoping, but feeling like I would need one more session as well. I don't need the staff to go through the document for us, but I would like perhaps the chair to take it.


8:03 p.m.

I think it chapter by chapter and ask commissioners if we have any questions and go through it that way. Is that, if that would work? I don't know if that works for Commissioner Chiriazzi. Yeah, I'll just have a partial delay as I make sure I don't have any comments for each chapter. Yeah, I think that works well. I always appreciate the notes that you have and how you're meticulous. And that's very much appreciated. And I want to make sure we have time for that. And I think that's a good compromise of cutting through some of the scrolling time between comments and moving through the different pieces that we need to talk about. Would you mind bringing up our first chapter? Thank you.


8:04 p.m.

Thank you. So this would be Chapter 1, Overview on the Coastal Act, unless we do need to start before Chapter 1. On 1.9 exemptions, these are exemptions that came through a 1986 order, page 16, yeah. I'm curious if, so we list single-family dwellings. I was curious about ADUs. Are the ADUs, is it appropriate to address ADUs here? So this is something we need to go back to the commission to address, because the commission has written our ADU ordinance or modified our ADU ordinance to require a coastal development permit for an ADU. So we are proposing to edit this at a future date. It's not.


8:05 p.m.

Not this, the zoning ordinance. Okay, so it doesn't make sense to mention it? No, it doesn't make sense to change anything here right now because technically, under California law, an ADU is part of a single-family dwelling. That's all I have for chapter one. Did you say it is a single family or it's part of the single family? It's part of a single family dwelling. That's already there. By definition, an ADU, accessory dwelling unit, is part of the use of the property as a single family dwelling. Chapter 2 You mentioned...


8:06 p.m.

I heard earlier that one of the comments was engagement policies, particularly tribal engagement policies, and those policies are in Chapter 3, and I understand that, and that's where the planners will go. But the public, some of the public members might not get beyond Chapter 1 or 2 of this document, so could we, at least in Chapter 2, just make a note that those engagement policies are covered in Chapter 3? Absolutely. Thank you. Commissioner Kiryasi? Yeah, can you repeat again whether or not you were agreeing with the Coastal Commission's suggestion to expand the policy under Part B around basically engagement? The tribal, no, we didn't. We didn't.


8:07 p.m.

want to expand that. We don't think that that's where you would go to look to see the policy direction. But I think that, you know, an appropriate compromise is what Commissioner Scavenall just brought up, is to refer to the fact that there are very specific engagement policies within Chapter 3. That makes sense. Yep. Thank you. Thank you. I want to just express I agree with staff's recommendation to keep background a characteristic five and agree with staff's agreement with the Coastal Commission on revising that first paragraph.


8:08 p.m.

The last sentence of Part A I found a little bit awkward. I was proposing just striking it. I wasn't really clear what that brought. I think in the Coastal Commission's proposal that is struck. Let me see if I can pull that document up. I don't know. Yes, if I can. You got it? Okay. Yeah, I missed that. Okay. I did also want to make a suggestion for Policy 1B. I think...


8:09 p.m.

Inclusive and meaningful engagement can, I think the examples are a little bit, sort of very bare minimum at this point in terms of hybrid meetings or accessible public materials. I would suggest including some sort of language using the term collaborative governance. I think that's a pretty well established term at this point and I think sets some good examples for what I think staff is intending around the term inclusive and meaningful public engagement. Thank you. That's all I have for chapter 2.


8:10 p.m.

I do have an overall comment. Putting the particular section and subsection in the footer would be really helpful for navigating the document as a whole, if that's possible. If it's a ton of manual work, then I'd understand not doing it. There were some issues with Microsoft Word. We were proposing to add the chapter, but we can add also the subsection to make it clearer when possible. The chapter would be great, too. Thank you. Okay. I don't see any more comments for this chapter, so we'll move on to the next one. I'll go ahead and jump in. Please do. So it appears to me that...


8:11 p.m.

The earlier comments around eliminating new natural gas infrastructure development wasn't incorporated. And I'm noting in 3.3.1, so I'm on page 25, it is stating that natural gas pipelines are allowed in all land use designations. But I'm not seeing reference to existing versus new development. Are we just assuming that the Coastal Act language, which I think forbids natural gas development, applies? Well, it doesn't forbid. It says that onshore support facilities are not...


8:12 p.m.

A coastal dependent industry. Right. So, I mean, there may be needs for gas pipelines, and I know all the climate arguments about that, and I know the bear trap I'm stepping into by saying that. But then there's also the matter of electrical transmission lines. I'm fairly certain we don't want to completely preclude those, because those are going to be needing to serve the offshore wind industry. Natural gas pipelines may need to be replaced at some point. So what criteria is going to be used to do that? Whether we want them or not is a different issue. Yeah, I agree. But I think what got lost in this version is the distinction.


8:13 p.m.

between new developments and existing natural gas infrastructure. Help me understand. Is the intention to say that no new natural gas pipelines are being allowed? Yeah, that's right. And I think that was staff's response to RCEA's comment back in the September workshop was that they agreed with that. But I don't recall saying that we'd prohibit that. I mean, I understand not allowing them by right. Yeah, if you give me a moment, I can try to pull up a comment.


8:14 p.m.

Thank you. Thank you. The RCA comment was similar to oil, can natural gas be eliminated or limited to only replacement of existing infrastructure? And staff's response was yes, this will be added to the public hearing draft. So there's a difference between facilities and conveyance. So...


8:15 p.m.

That's talking about pipelines, which is conveyance. In my mind, before, we were talking about facilities that processed that. So I'm trying to understand the section that this is in. So this is 3.3, plan designations, standards, and area plan maps. And it says natural gas pipelines are allowed in all land use designations. And it says in accordance with section 373. There's a section on pipelines. There's a section on electrical transmission lines.


8:16 p.m.

But yeah, 373 is just electrical transmission lines. So where are you going with this? Well, I'm advocating for not, I guess, to Director Ford's point of conveyance versus end use. Am I rephrasing that correctly? Conveyance versus processing or production. Production, right. I'm definitely advocating for not allowing production or processing. So it would be new development that ties into existing natural gas pipelines that makes sense, I guess, in alignment with.


8:17 p.m.

Regional climate action plan, et cetera. But I guess I still find this phrase confusing. Natural gas pipelines are allowed in all land use designations. So does natural gas pipelines not mean processing? No, it's conveyance. That specifically means conveyance. Yeah. Okay. Okay. So I guess does it, so RCEA's comment was addressed then? So I think RCEA's comments would be addressed within the, you know, the uses that are allowed. And within the MC, we took out anything related to either oil and gas production. If there's any of those issues that I heard or that I have my gerne, but I do wonder what dilutive it would mean to talk about and what RCEAs typically meant. The duplicated bomber would be used as the portal. Basically if you had regarding the efficiency, you know, the level of our beekeeping activity within that value чув of, if you done a set of now, it would be a multilateral deployment kind of thing. So. So. So. Most important. Yeah.


8:18 p.m.

In fact, you know, the on-site or onshore support facilities are no longer even identified as a conditionally permitted use. Under the zoning, they can fall under. There's a section at the end of every conditionally permitted use section in the zoning ordinance, things that are not addressed. That is clearly going to be a conditional use permit and a coastal development permit to bring those in. Okay, I think that clarifies it for me. Thank you. I think one of the...


8:19 p.m.

with that the reason we left that in there is that you know a conveyance may be allowed by right but that doesn't mean it doesn't require a coastal development permit it still does so you still look at the coastal resource impact of putting in something that you know in this particular case the way it's structured should be to serve existing development to replace something that needs to be replaced electrical is going to be different That makes sense and I'm glad that that's stated here in this meeting. I wonder if it might, it's not clear to me if that where it's mentioned in 331 would benefit from some clarity there or not, but maybe just to staff's discretion to consider if.


8:20 p.m.

I would return that back to the commission if you want to create a prohibition on something. I mean, we clearly took out the permissive language, but we did not add prohibitions. Right. I think clarification in terms of what you stated as it would be serving existing development. Okay. Let me take a quick look at that. We could simply also


8:21 p.m.

That was on page 25. Is Nick covered on the policy on page 37? The new development policy? Yeah, no, even the gas pipeline requires a conditional use permit. So that's something that no matter what happens, it's coming back to the commission.


8:22 p.m.

Thank you. Yep, that makes sense. And again, this is conveyance, not production. Okay, thank you. That was a helpful discussion. So I guess I don't... I guess I'll just put it back to the staff again, whether or not it's worth clarifying that 331 intends to mean conveyance and not production, but maybe that's just too repetitive. Thank you.


8:23 p.m.

I don't mind adding conveyance into that sentence if it's the desire of the commission to to me reading something that is a pipeline or a transmission line is it's just clearly conveyance okay It's fine. Thank you. Is there more in this chapter we would like to go over? Yeah, I'm going to go into the policy that Commissioner Scavdahl referenced. So this would be B1 on page 37. This, uh, I think...


8:24 p.m.

I was thinking it would be useful to reference this in sections 3.6 and 3.7, so that has to do with coastal dependent and industrial development. It would seem prudent to also make this policy recommendation for that development. I think we know that heavy industrial development can dramatically increase greenhouse gas emissions, and so I think it would be useful to reiterate that we encourage similar languages as this policy. Thank you. Isn't that length?


8:25 p.m.

Which included both the urban and rural. I believe it is I was referring to 3 6 & 3 7 I would you know one of the difficulties of this the bottom line is I would just move that same policy down into B for for rural development I'm not seeing it that policy is


8:26 p.m.

in uh real development it's four yeah okay but there's requests to put it in coastal dependent or yes coastal dependent but coastal dependent is in rural yeah it's no matter where you go it's there it's a more of a general policy that everybody gets to to comply with i understand okay i see yeah so coastal dependent and industrial will occur in either right rural or urban right i see that makes sense okay you I've taken up all the air time here.


8:27 p.m.

I'm now to urban limit lines, page 42 in the policy section. I was thinking this would benefit from adding a little bit more guardrails around adjustments to urban limit lines. I know that adjusting those would have to come back as an amendment to this Humboldt Bay Area plan, but I think it might be useful to add language that those adjustments should be consistent with the regional climate action plan. I think it would also benefit to highlight that those adjustments should consider access to buy pedestrian and bike infrastructure. Since the intent of urban within the Palermo City those difficulties do not fall into the plans, but they seem like they have to be cauced into the plan nevertheless.


8:28 p.m.

development is higher density. The intent of the urban limit line was to focus development where there's access to utilities and I mean we certainly could but I would submit to you that by nature of the fact that there is the climate action plan already in place that a modification to that would need to be evaluated in the light of the climate action plan anyway. I guess why? Why? Because the climate action plan applies to everything. And so every land use decision that gets made needs to be found to be in compliance with the regional climate action plan. And so...


8:29 p.m.

If a land use decision is being made that completely increases vehicle miles traveled requires excess amounts of energy to be used you know does those kinds of things. How do you find that to be consistent with the regional climate action plan. Thank you. I guess I wasn't quite aware that the RCAP carried that amount of weight, that it would be automatically reviewed against every project. We're beginning to review projects in relationship to, or we're not beginning to, we are.


8:30 p.m.

Thinking about how it fits into the R-CAP or the R-CAP fits into it. And so when you see projects start to come forward, you will see that analysis. Okay. I mean, it's one of the interesting things. And, you know, some people like a lot of redundancy where you put in everything that applies over and over in every place so that you can never miss anything. But on the other hand, if you've got requirements that exist unto themselves, you know, the art of being staff is to recognize what those are and make sure that you're doing the right thing. And so I think that's one of the things that I would like to see. I think that you're paying attention to that and to bring to the Planning Commission, to the Board of Supervisors, an understanding of how those fit together and the findings that you need to make.


8:31 p.m.

Thank you. So it sounds like in those resolutions we'll start to see findings related to the RCAP. Correct. And so if an adjustment to urban limit lines and a change to the Humboldt Bay Area plan in those findings would start to address the RCAP is what you're saying? Yes. And I find it hard to envision that the urban limit lines will be changed very much in the Humboldt Bay Area plan. Yeah. But they might. They may be. There may be requests for that. But the issue is going to be is there sewer and water? You know, I could envision a scenario where from a transportation perspective certain sites.


8:32 p.m.

It's worked better, but getting sewer and water to it don't work. Yep, and the vice versa as well, which is why I'm bringing up the transportation piece and the RCAP. But it sounds like your recommendation is it will already be treated, we'll already be seeing the RCAP referenced in the findings associated with those changes. Correct. Okay. Yeah. Thank you. I'm losing my audience here. The... So for...


8:33 p.m.

Residential high density, I appreciate staff including that section in here. Do you think that's important? I did note that it doesn't seem to exist in current county code, and I didn't see an RH definition. There's not in the zoning ordinance. That was why we took it out originally. So would this result in staff considering? Well, I think, of course, yes. But I think the first step really is to see is there any place where that's an appropriate land use to apply within the Humboldt area plan. And at that time, that's going to require a rezone too. So part of the zoning act. Action will be to create that zoning district. And then to assign that zoning district to a piece.


8:34 p.m.

property I felt like, so in conditional uses you included mobile home development. That didn't quite seem appropriate. I know it's a conditional use, but we cover that in medium density. So I felt like that was a little bit awkward to include mobile home. You just wouldn't see densities anywhere near the 30 to 50. That was part of the, from the existing adopted certified plan. The RH was already existing. All we did was put it back in and we didn't change it. I see. Okay. Not a big, not a sticking point for me, but still.


8:35 p.m.

A suggestion. Also, minor tweak of putting gross density at 31 to 50 because medium density goes to 30. So if you hit 30 units per acre, are you high density or medium density? So suggesting 31 to 50. If the commission is fine with that, we're fine making that change. Right now, residential high density is defined as 30 to 50 units per acre. Medium density residential is defined as 80 to 30, and so they both state that 30 units is. That makes sense to me. It did be clear. Thank you.


8:36 p.m.

In other parts of the county code, RM is defined as residential multifamily. Here it says residential medium density. I'm assuming you'd want those to be titled the same. Not necessarily, because there is a range of density there. And so you could do something like a tiny home development where you don't have attached units. Okay, so I guess it's fine to have different definitions for RM across. I think in the general plan and the LCP, the definitions are the same. When you get into the zoning ordinance, they may differ. Got it, okay. And last question under medium density, you've listed transient occupancy.


8:37 p.m.

Does that include short-term rentals? Is that sort of like a catch-all term? It could, yes, subject to the limitations that are in that ordinance. But that term captures SDRs? Yeah. Okay. That's just a point of clarification, if that makes sense. Thank you. Are there more questions?


8:38 p.m.

Questions in Chapter 3 or would we like to move on to Chapter 4? I'm still trying to figure that out, sorry. I think I do. I was curious if on page 48, defining MC, Industrial Coastal Dependent, if it would make sense to mention the port overlay in that section regarding principal use. No, that doesn't. I guess with a port overlay, that doesn't relate to a principal or conditional use. That's a different concept. It's a different concept. That's really a development concept that has to do with needing to do something that's... More intensive than has been considered before. That makes sense. Thank you.


8:39 p.m.

But it's the same uses. I had a question on page 53 at the top. We're talking about a policy related to the Fairhaven area. We say creation of new parcels shall not be permitted. And that was just a clarification if ADUs are allowed. Within that Q zone. Top of my head, I don't think they were. It seems appropriate that they would not be given the intent of the Q zone, I think. Yeah, the intent of the Q zone was not to...


8:40 p.m.

It was to allow the sewer to go in without allowing any additional development. Yeah. Okay. So, yeah. So, ADUs are also restricted for that area. Before I say something incorrect, let me look at the cue zone. Just to clarify, it's creation of new parcels, not creation of new development within this specific paragraph. Yeah, which I think the intent is that we're saying we don't want to see new development. And I was just curious if we are allowing ADU development on existing parcels. Thank you.


8:41 p.m.

To minimize risk from tsunami inundation and sea level rise hazards, no permit should be granted for an ADU on any lot for any of the following conditional uses normally allowed in the RS. So no guest house, no manufactured home park, no bed and breakfast establishment, no community assembly, no neighborhood commercial, no private institution, and no private recreation. That's what's in the CUSO. Great. Thank you.


8:42 p.m.

I so I'm now in 3.6 I really appreciated staff's additional work in in 3.6 and appreciated the addition of the third and fourth paragraphs I think those were those were well written I just wanted to acknowledge that you I appreciated attaching the industrial lands inventory, well the appendices in general, so we could review them.


8:43 p.m.

The inventory report recommends reviewing that or revisiting that report every 10 years. I thought that might be useful to capture in this section or capture somewhere where it might seem appropriate. Um... Again, I'm not exactly sure if this is the appropriate place for it in 3.6, but also just noting that some joint review with the City of Eureka, if that's possible, might be beneficial since they also have industrial zones.


8:44 p.m.

And they talk about changes to that would want to make sure that there's sufficient CDI in the bay in general. So I don't know if that would make sense to encourage collaboration with the city of Eureka on that review process. That's the wish of the commission. We can include a policy on that. You would like an additional policy that asks that the county collaborate with the city on changes to CDI? Yeah, the industrial inventory, the Eureka, the coastal LUP talks about reclassifying and reclassifying only if there's sufficient CDI in the Bay Area in general. Who's determining whether or not CDI is a good idea?


8:45 p.m.

there's sufficient CDI. Hence the joint review collaboration. I guess... I appreciate the intent. Our CDI lands are complex and there's a lot of different opinions about them and it's a moving target on what they should be used for and whether or not there's enough of them or there's too much of them. And I worry about adding another thing to both staff's plates that may not... That would be hard to navigate clearly. Is it just they need to consult and tell each other what they're doing? Is it they need to have official processes that move through their official bodies? I'm wary of...


8:46 p.m.

Of adding in something that requires them to do some, requires staff to take an additional step without providing clear direction on what that means. That makes sense. Commissioner Fulton? Yeah, I would agree with you, Commissioner West. I don't know that it's necessary to add an additional policy on something that probably would happen anyway when it comes to coastal-dependent industrial-related work where the city of Eureka and the county of Humboldt collide. I would imagine there would be some sort of conversations that happen, and I don't believe that it needs to be a policy to outline that. That works for me. I appreciate the discussion. Yeah, thank you.


8:47 p.m.

Hello, I'm going to show you how to make a beautiful, beautiful, beautiful, beautiful, beautiful, beautiful, beautiful, beautiful, beautiful, beautiful, beautiful, beautiful, beautiful, beautiful, beautiful, beautiful, beautiful, beautiful, beautiful, beautiful, I guess in, we're in, I'm in F, so B1F, so this is where establishing the port overlay zone. Page number? Yeah, page 61. Thank you. We say port overlay zone may be established. I think our earlier conversation maybe helps answer this because I was curious why we didn't say will. So I think that makes sense that port overlay zone may be established.


8:48 p.m.

Yeah, this you don't want to tell the county what it has to do Especially when it gets in a dialogue with an applicant. It's like you will give me the port overlay zone because it says shall there It's like no we didn't say that We said you could apply for it. We said we'd evaluate it We didn't say we'd approve it That makes sense We give example, later in that paragraph it gives examples of what that port overlay zone may address. I was considering adding as an example impacts to cultural and tribal resources. I know it's not intended to be a catch-all, but I thought it might be useful to re-acknowledge or strengthen.


8:49 p.m.

So commission's call on that. Yeah, exactly. So that says the port overlay zone may be used to address zoning regulations for, and I think we've had a lot of public comment about how this should be expanded. And I think staff's response has been that it's the intent of the EIR to capture all of the things, so this is not intended to be an inclusive list. No, it's not. And frankly, relative to tribal stuff, when we get down to the discussion on the policies, that's got to be addressed. Whether it says address...


8:50 p.m.

here or not down further it's got to be addressed yeah so just kind of it goes back to what do you choose to include in this list and what do you don't what you don't and i think we had a fair amount of public comment about what to include and whatnot and so i think like just as what you had said height lighting and noise have to be addressed well and those are basically things that are contained within the zoning regulations tribal cultural resources are typically not addressed in zoning regulations i mean we did include the health-based concerns based on public comment but i don't mind it i don't i mean if it helps everybody get past this we can add


8:51 p.m.

That's no problem. I think that, you know, the other sections down below really require a full analysis of the potential tribal and cultural impacts. I'm a little hesitant. Well, we put health-based concerns in there. That's not typically a zoning issue. So it's whatever the commission wants to do. I'm really only just coming at it from further showing the importance of that. So if you say cultural resources, that works. Would that include tribal resources without saying tribal resources? You could say that, yeah. Just cultural resources, and then it's more comprehensive.


8:52 p.m.

Includes a lot of things besides just tribal. But tribes would recognize cultural resources as a tribal concern, but you could have other cultural resources that wouldn't be tribal. Yeah, I was proposing cultural and tribal resources, but cultural resources would work as well. I'm kind of ambivalent on the point. The Harvard is, if we get to a port overlay zone, it's going to be because the applicant is trying to permit a heavy lift terminal that they've completed a CEQA document for that's going to have covered a lot of this ground. To your statement earlier about, you know, we have these policies, it's really important, I think, that the policy stays in their lanes. We start getting multiple policies.


8:53 p.m.

And they each one overlaps the other a little bit and then one policy changes and you've got another policy that Didn't change, you know, it just gets confusing. So I would keep this language as generic as possible At this time and not get specifically detailed to keep it broad and generic so that we have room to maneuver And again understanding that When or if this gets to us it's going to be on a project that's already Going or gone through a secret process It's going to have addressed a lot of the issues Maybe in advance and that's why I like the word may in here We don't know how deep they're going to get into the secret process, but I suspect the community is going to be quite engaged and A lot of this ground is going to be covered before it gets there


8:54 p.m.

Yeah, I agree. I think I just kind of struggled with what was omitted. And it sounds like staff's intent was to just simply state that zoning regulations will be addressed. And I would be happy with going simplifying. I think what strikes me is we don't want to go too far down the path of listing everything. That's not the intent. But why did we choose to omit, add some things and omit other things? So either make it more generic or more comprehensive. We simply started with zoning. The public comment that the commission, I believe, gave us direction on was to include the health-based concerns. That's why that was added. So. Thank you.


8:55 p.m.

Thank you. Yeah, it's not a make or break. It just, but it does strike. But that's fine, I can move on. I think just noting that the appendices that were included don't have appendix labels. We recognize that, and we will absolutely definitely fix that. Sorry. I did feel that so I'm not


8:56 p.m.

3.7, the very beginning where you're quoting Coastal Act policies, I do think it's prudent to repeat 30250B, which is discussed above, I think in 3.4, but it's about addressing the location of hazardous development away from existing developed areas. It could be useful to repeat that here, because this section covers hazardous industrial development. So just to clarify, it's just repeating the Coastal Act language. We can do that. I still got more.


8:57 p.m.

In 371, so I'm on page 64. I just wanted to note that the original, the current version of the Humboldt Bay Area Plan, so the one that we're currently amending, has an alternative siting priority ranking process. And that process is actually referenced in the CDI lands inventory. But quite a while back, staff removed that priority ranking language. And I was curious what the motivation was for that. So it doesn't work. We struggled with that trying to get through Nordic. And it's like, if you would have taken that absolutely literally.


8:58 p.m.

It couldn't have been approved. Okay. Yeah, thanks for that context. And it was a reuse of an existing site. It was tearing down existing destroyed buildings. But that wouldn't necessarily allow that. Okay. But that's exactly what I think we want to see, is we've got a bunch of, you know, our decaying buildings out there. It would be great if somebody came in and removed them and redeveloped that area. Great. Thanks for the context. Thank you. The last sentence in that 3.7.1a, it refers...


8:59 p.m.

To a 40 megawatt wood waste power plant planned. I'm assuming that is old. Can be removed. Yeah, I think that's existing. Yep. Oh, it says planned MG. It's not that the plant is planned? Okay. Did you catch that? So... A way of articulating the land use is to say it's planned for a land use. So it's planned MG. That doesn't mean that something's planned there. It means it's on land that's planned to be heavy industrial. Another way of saying it is...


9 p.m.

This is on land that's heavy industrial. It's consistent with that. So because it's, okay, that makes sense. So it makes sense to leave it in because that infrastructure is still there. Yeah. That is just a term that goes back a ways. And if you're not familiar with planter jargon, it can be a little bit weird. That makes sense. Thank you. I'm now on page 74.


9:01 p.m.

Still in chapter 3, this is trails. Would it make sense to include an adaptation policy associated with trails here? Or does the seal or rise section sufficiently capture adaptation for trails? I think all we're trying to do here is to identify that trails exist and the adaptation sections above and sea level rise really is what would be used to determine whether or not any adaptation measures are consistent with that.


9:02 p.m.

Since this is under the policies section, maybe it makes more sense to put it in the background. It's a separate section, but we can move trails to be above policies if the commission would like. I see. I think I'm just used to seeing policies being the last section. Got it. Okay. No, that's fine.


9:03 p.m.

I'm in the... I'm in page 76. So this would be policies associated with housing. It's the density ranges. My understanding is that the Samoa Town Master Plan and hazard requirements override density bonus? I don't think so, no. Would we not want them to? Not sure under state law we could.


9:04 p.m.

So in a tsunami hazard zone or in a Samoa Town master plan, density bonuses would still be allowed because of state law? Well, I mean, it's a little hard. There's only a couple of residential parcels that are – there's a couple – it's a commercial parcel. I don't think there's any residential parcels left in Samoa. Okay. Yeah. So I guess to clarify, so the zoning in that Samoa Town Master Plan has no residential parcels?


9:05 p.m.

No, it does, but they've already been approved for development. I mean, most of the stuff that's left has already been mapped. Okay, so what you're saying is there isn't a future scenario where we would be considering density bonus law. The only place that there could be conceivably density bonus is on the commercial, on the Samoa block. And I guess where I'm coming from is do we want increased density in these areas? And I was just curious if they do allow density bonuses or they don't. And it seems like we would not want to encourage higher density development in these areas, these hazard areas.


9:06 p.m.

That's a different question. Because, I mean, some of what should have been done is that that's truly the case. We should not have allocated land use there in the first place. But that decision was already made. Okay. And because that decision was made and state law says, gives guidance for density bonuses, then we have to follow that. Yep. Okay, I am now in Aquaculture 312. I didn't see...


9:07 p.m.

Thank you. I'm on page 85 of policies. It seemed like not having a policy around water quality that protects aquaculture, that seemed like an omission, or it seems like. We presented adding a fairly elaborate set of water quality measures to be included in 4.3, which would apply to everything terrestrially developed. Yep, that makes sense. Thank you. So also compatibility of aquaculture with other coastal dependent developments, I think.


9:08 p.m.

My understanding is the intent that aquaculture, particularly existing aquaculture, is protected. But then I think there's also language saying that coastal dependent development comes before... I think aquaculture is coastal dependent development. It's treated as coastal dependent industrial development. And we've expanded it to also be more consistent with where the Coastal Act comes from. It's also agriculture. So we've come at it from both ends. We've protected it in CDI. We've protected it in areas that are out in the bay, although we're taking the zoning land use off the bay because it's not ours to regulate. And then in areas that are like NR.


9:09 p.m.

the MR areas that could be transitional ag lands that could support aquaculture, it's addressed there. Okay. So for new coastal dependent development, compatibility with existing aquaculture has to be addressed. We all, well, we always look at compatibility. And particularly that's part of the public process. And particularly for the existing operators to say, hey, we're concerned about that. And so we look at that. You know, you know the public process, what comes out in the wash. It can be variable. But the intent is to look at it. I mean.


9:10 p.m.

Thank you. I mean the policy number one well says oceanfront maybe we should change that to bayfront land that is suitable for coastal dependent aquaculture shall be protected for that use and proposals for aquaculture facilities located on those sites shall be given priority Okay. Yeah, I think I just wanted to make sure that was the case or that was... It was clearly done here and it sounds like it is. That was a new section we added. That wasn't previously in the plan.


9:11 p.m.

Thank you. I'm trying to find my bearings here. I'm not quite sure what section I'm in. But I don't know which section it is, but it is page 97. 97? 97, yeah. 97. This will be in chapter 4. This would be wetland and transitional ag-related policies.


9:12 p.m.

On page 97, so this is allowable uses in transitional ag lands. So B, diking and filling for new development. I guess I was curious how that relates to, are we allowing, I guess we are allowing for dyking and filling for new development, but in other areas we say we encourage not hardened armoring, but more living protection. And so I was curious how. Well, I think this has to be read in context because it doesn't say shall be allowed. It says shall be consistent with coastal access.


9:13 p.m.

Section 30233. See section 3.30 of this plan, including but not limited to modification or repair of existing diets threatened by erosion, oil or gas wells, and incidental public service purposes. So, you know, this is saying that if you're going to do that, you've got to take all these things into consideration. It's not allowing it. It's saying if you're going to climb this steep hill, you've got to deal with this stuff. And I don't think that's new. Okay. I think also the reference to section 3.8.


9:14 p.m.

There doesn't quite make sense for oil and gas wells. Yeah, we need, we'll fix that because we took that out. So, well, I guess if this is approved tonight, which I think I'm making that very difficult, the language that you're proposing for a new Section 19 here for water quality, 4.1.19, that language, the public would have sufficient time to review that when it goes to the Board of Supervisors. Is that kind of the thinking here? If you end up recommending the Board approve it, yes, that will absolutely be in the draft that's presented to the Board.


9:15 p.m.

Yeah, because I think it'd be important for the public to have time to review that language. I think we're finally in section five, which I think you opened this with this is the most important discussion with sea level rise, and we have 15 minutes left. Okay, so we are, Commissioner Neal, we're now in section five, which is talking about sea level rise and where we left off the conversation that you were at. And I wanted to make sure before I open it up to the rest of the group that I wanted to make sure that you had your comment that you could finish.


9:16 p.m.

Your thought on that one, because I know we moved on pretty quickly from your discussion with Director Ford. Yeah, I mean we've gone back and forth on this I think two or three times now. And I know Commissioner McFarland was pretty adamant on the intermediate at our last meeting. She couldn't be here. But these projections are, how do I say that? The science is clearly not able to accurately predict sea level rise over the extended period of time. You can look at these numbers and see.


9:17 p.m.

Well, we kind of know what sea level rise is going to do next year. Five years from now, the range is not too broad. 70 years from now, so we picked 2100, 70 years from now, the range from low to high is from 1.8 feet to 7.3 feet. It starts to get just really broad. And that's where I start having a problem with this. I'm not ready to make a decision to advocate where we should be. But my concern is that we're picking a horizon that's out there quite a ways. Why 70 years? Why don't we pick 50 years from now? And then... Regardless of...


9:18 p.m.

What we, whether we select immediate, intermediate, or intermediate high, the science is going to change, and presumably we're going to get better at this over time. So should we include some language in here that mandates that we revisit this within five years, or every five years, or would we revisit it as needed, as better science, better data comes to us? So that's, my concern is just that, picking, going 70 years out. On something that's, and maybe picking a foot and a half higher.


9:19 p.m.

Thank you. Today, we have no real idea if that's going to be a foot and a half lower or three feet higher. So I guess my question is how important is this data? What are we going to do with this? What's the impact to future development or current development by this decision? Those are all key questions in this. And part of going out to 2100 is that's approximating the life cycle of the building. Obviously buildings can last much longer. But you can at least get returns. You can turn on investment there. And so if you're going to


9:20 p.m.

Put a building in a location, you know, that's going to be inundated with four feet of water within its useful life, that may be something that's a really not a good idea. And so that's what we're trying to grapple with here is to, and it is an estimate, and the thing that has to do with the low, intermediate low, intermediate, intermediate high, and high has to do with several factors. The modeling looks at, you know, what at the current rate, how does sea level rise continue to go up, and in the case of Humboldt Bay, how does land subsidence, combined with that, affect that? It could be.


9:21 p.m.

that some of the things that are being done around the world change the way that the climate is being modified, or is changing, or is warming. And so these numbers may not be reflective of what actually happens. And there are some policies in there. They don't get as specific as what you just said, but using the best available information to regularly look at these maps. And when there's new information, and if they're adjusted up or down, that needs to be done. We need to pay attention to it. We can't just say, okay, we did it in 2026, and we're good for 50 years, because it may be too conservative. It may not be conservative enough. And so obviously this is something that requires monitoring and requires... giving it attention.


9:22 p.m.

Thank you. Obviously the concern is that if we're too conservative, we could preclude people from being able to do things on their property. I think there's another thing, something that I noticed when I first moved here, and I moved here in 1972 or 3, something like that. And the first thing I thought was, why isn't Samoa and Fairhaven, why isn't it like Balboa? Because I grew up in Southern California, Orange County. And I think people coming up here see this land, they say, oh my God, I could never have purchased this if I lived in Southern California or the Bay Area. And they need to have a heads up. They need to see in a document that if they do think that they're going to buy this property and build out there, like some of the people that I've seen come in here and buy this as their beach summer home or whatever, they're not seeing that it could be inundated in the future. And so they need to.


9:23 p.m.

know that there's a document that says there could be a problem here and we're looking at it you know if you're not looking at it we're looking at it as planners that it could be a problem and so i i think that it's good to have in a document that they they don't get fooled into thinking oh yeah i'm buying this property because i'm going to be able to develop it it's going to be you know my retirement i'll you know it's going to be an investment because it's really going to you know go up in value and i think it's important that they know there's constraints you know so it's i don't know if that fits in the conversation or not but it's something that's been on my mind well you probably just said what i was trying to say better than i did so um i think that's getting to the heart of it is that it really is about giving people people people information giving decision makers you


9:24 p.m.

Planning Commission Board of Supervisors information giving staff information to help everybody make the best possible decisions but it's a it's a reasonable legitimate struggle in terms of where to place that line because while intermediate high at 5.5 and 2100 that is a conservative number it's like that people who study this a lot feel like there's an 80% likelihood that that will never be exceeded so for some people that's too conservative you know what if we were to scale it down a little bit and look at something that is more towards the you know 40 to 60 percent likelihood and just monitor that then that would be I think represented by the intermediate you know 40 to 60 percent likelihood and just monitor that then that would be I think represented by the intermediate you know 40 to 60 percent likelihood and just monitor that then that would be I think represented by the intermediate


9:25 p.m.

That's still putting people on notice. That's still identifying that there's sea level rise going on. But it's not taking some of the properties that would be on the fringe of the sea level rise impact from having to do things to their property that will cost additional money to develop. There's another factor that I've been faced with is you can't get insurance. If you're in an area that's going to be inundated at all, you're not going to get insurance. And so if you're trying to take out a loan to build something, you're not going to get insurance. And so that's another heads up you're giving them. You better think twice because it's like if you build your house in a wildland fire zone or in a flood zone or a tsunami zone, you're not getting insurance. And so unless you have cash that you're willing to risk a loss, you might as well.


9:26 p.m.

not think about building there. I think I'm struggling with the other side of that coin. I generally lean towards intermediate high and being more conservative and I absolutely agree with you that people need to be aware of the concerns but also there's a question mark with this data and we just don't know what's going to happen and I'm really wary and worried about assigning a hazard to an area and hurting somebody's property value and making it more expensive for them to build. I'd hate to get 30 deer eggs down the road and look back and be like oh no like the science wasn't good enough yet and we precluded these uses on the property and we like people whether or not an insurance company uses what we what this document says it's possible it will impact somebody's property value. There's just a lot there that you could the other side of that coin is looking at that and we didn't make this chart up did we? This chart is not. This chart says it.


9:27 p.m.

I'm excited already that someone else made it up. This chart comes from the Ocean Protection Council. It's not our chart. It's not our chart. And it's been vetted pretty well. And it gives the rationale and the risks associated with that. And that's what I'm trying to say is, like, there is no certainty in this chart. And I think that's what you're all struggling with. So how do you make a decision without certain information? No information. No decisions are ever certain. But, you know, it really comes down to, I think, what Commissioner West just started to struggle with. It's like, yeah, if I were just doing things, I'm kind of more conservative, putting words in your mouth, I apologize. But. I recognize that making that decision through that paradigm.


9:28 p.m.

I may be adversely affecting people unnecessarily. But I think it's already there. You don't, it's, they, I buy a flat piece of property in McKinleyville and I think great, you know. And then I go to try to get insurance and I can't get it. You know, like I can't get flood insurance, I can't get wildland insurance. If I had a document that would have given me a heads up, I might not have bought that property or might not have thought that I could, you know, build anything else on it. So that's where I'm saying this is helping people to make decisions so they don't make poor decisions because their property is already impacted. And nothing that we say here is going to make it any worse. It's our, I mean, they've already got all these areas mapped already, the insurance companies. They rely on FEMA and flood maps and all of that already to keep you from being able to insure your property. So if you don't care about insurance. Then you'll build it wherever you think you want to build it.


9:29 p.m.

can but I don't think we're hurting anybody's property or causing them to to spend more money the county already requires you to build high enough out of the flood zone that when I built the ADU I had to build it up really high so I think you're giving people information that they need to make decisions and to not go gee I just bought this property not knowing that I was in a flood zone or a tsunami zone or you know it was going to get flooded in 10 years you see these people down south that are right on the beach and they're losing their houses now because you know things have changed you're in support of intermediate high right where is that what I'm understanding you're saying I didn't see a whole lot of difference between the two maps there's a few parcels maybe in there that are going to change but I'm like with him I mean this is all just guesstimate somebody smarter than us


9:30 p.m.

up with this chart but who knows where it's going to be in in next year it could be worse than what we thought you know so we're just going with somebody else's science and saying here's some science that's been vetted and perhaps you know an approach could be you could choose between a more conservative number or maybe going to intermediate but then using the idea that commissioner scavall mentioned and requiring it to be readdressed every five years because next year could be the year that was like we weren't even expecting i'm sure those people that in long beach and laguna beach i just came back from laguna beach a couple weeks ago who would have thought that the water would have been all over the road you know or that houses you know that have been there for a while are now gone so you just don't know yeah that's i mean that's what i'm struggling with is you just don't know


9:31 p.m.

Commissioner Kiryazi. Yeah I think I keep thinking of your well the example you provided where we had water on the road or Director Ford brought up King Salmon. We're already seeing impacts. One thing that really stuck with me this last weekend when we had a high tide not an extremely high tide but we had significant wind and those wind driven surge completely flooded land along the safety corridor that isn't typically flooded and we were getting ocean spray onto the bay trail and that that is the bay trail is underwater at 3.2 feet of sea level rise. The heavy lift marine terminal that the harbor district is proposing is underwater at 3.2 feet of sea level rise.


9:32 p.m.

I think what we're trying to do is create a safe, guidelines for safe development. So I think, I agree, we don't want to increase costs for development. That's a big concern. But I still feel like intermediate high is probably appropriate for the timeline of this document. I do like the suggestion of revisiting every five years. And I think that also says in here, I think the Coastal Commission also revisits this every five years. I see Commissioner Fulton and then Commissioner Scaptal. Yeah, I would just, Commissioner Chiarazzi, I'd like to address your comments about the sea spray on that thing. I have lived here my entire life, and that has sea sprayed across the railroad tracks my entire life. Stinky Beach along where the PG&E plant is north along through there. As a kid, I used to remember going through, going in.


9:33 p.m.

The town seeing those waves crash over those rocks and onto the railroad track. So I have yet to see anything of any substantial that isn't anything different than what I have seen since I was a child growing up in this county. I'm not discounting sea level rise or the ground sinking out from underneath us. But I am not seeing anything that would lead me to believe that going into an area of 85 percent tile that it would not happen is suggestive of a, I just don't think it's a good idea. I'm more inclined to the intermediate with the checking on the science every five years. Commissioner Scafdal? If we're going to stay out to year 2100, I'm more than happy to say that I'm not seeing any significant change in the climate change. I'm not seeing any significant change in the climate change. I'm not seeing any significant change in the climate change. I'm more inclined to go intermediate because


9:34 p.m.

I just, I don't think the science is really able to tell us where we're going to be 2100. If we're going to go to intermediate high, I would say reduce the high horizon back to 50 years, which is still a long time in the residential construction world. Longer than most people's mortgages, not going to be an insurance issue or that type of thing. So I'd pull back and say, well, let's go to 50 years out. I don't know how that ties to other planning documents, though. If everybody's looking at the year 2100, that's what we're planning towards, and I think we should be consistent with that. I think one of our concerns, just to respond to you a little bit if I can, I'm sorry, I'm getting a little bit. I'm getting slack here late at night.


9:35 p.m.

Commission typically looks at a longer planning horizon. Then I'm leaning to the intermediate with a five-year. We have to revisit this every five years at least, I think. Maybe earlier, you know, somebody comes out with a new science, better document, then I think this policy needs to be amended. So I'm hearing consensus on the five-year review piece. I think everybody seems to be in support of that. And then I'm hearing mixed bag of intermediate versus intermediate high. We could keep going with this, but I think we're at a point where we need to make some decisions about what we're doing next with this document. It's 935. Director Ford, can you talk a little bit about where we might go? So I would offer just, and this is easy, we can just add a sentence to, to 1B that says the...


9:36 p.m.

A rate of sea level rise and the appropriateness of the projections will be reviewed at least every five years. And then the thing that I would recommend to you about at least getting to maybe a direction point, if not a decision point, on this is see if you can get a consensus and see where people are at. Consensus on this particular item or the whole document? No, just an intermediate high. So does that mean you have to update this plan every five years or you just substitute the data? We look at the data. We look at the rate of sea level rise. We consult with Cal Poly Humboldt and the Coastal Commission and the Ocean Protection Council and see what they are seeing in terms of the rate of sea level rise and see if there's something that we need to amend. Okay. So then what? Then what happens? Let's say.


9:37 p.m.

You notice there's something different. Then we bring back a modification to this. And it just comes to this board, gets modified, then it goes to the supervisors? Yes. Okay. So can we do a quick straw poll on where folks are at? If they had to choose their intermediate, intermediate high, or one other option on the chart, which one they would be supportive of? Okay, here, intermediate. I still lean towards intermediate high because infrastructure that's built in the next five years, that elevation difference is what they're going to build to. That's where they're putting their floor elevation. I'm assuming that's one of the outcomes of this number. That's likely, yes. I think, though, it's too bad that Commissioner McFarlane is not here, but Caltrans, for the 101, is the one that's going to be here.


9:38 p.m.

for the Cape is intermediate. What did you just say? Caltrans. I believe that's correct. Caltrans is designing their infrastructure on the intermediate scenario, out to 2100. Not high, but on intermediate? Correct. Yeah, and I think part of it is because the cost difference to go to intermediate high is so astronomical. And that's one of the struggles we have here is the floor elevation that we would be providing guidance to for new development, it would add cost. Personally, I'm leaning intermediate high, although I am on the fence. So I think if we go intermediate, it's not going to be a deal breaker for me. Commissioner Skadal. I'm going to stand on intermediate with the caveat that we're going to look at this in the future. Data every, at least every five years.


9:39 p.m.

which could drive this up or down in the future. But with that provision, I'd stay with intermediate. Okay. Thank you, Commissioner O'Neill. I said intermediate before because it didn't look like there was that many parcels that were impacted by the difference. Okay. Thank you. Okay, so we have three intermediates and then two intermediate high. Thank you. So we're coming up on 940, which I think we need to wrap up our meeting, unfortunately. I think our options before us are to make a motion that moves this to the supervisors or a motion to continue this. If we were to continue this, would there be a date certain or a date uncertain? Date certain.


9:40 p.m.

Thank you. We do have a list of all the changes that we've proposed. If you were willing to make a motion, we could put that on the screen and show you all the changes that we came in proposing and then the changes that you just proposed we can add to that list. Commissioner Skaftel? Did you have something that you wanted to say? We've heard this at least three times, four times now. I think staff's done a great job on this document, and I like the way you've consolidated it, accepted all the comments, engaged with the Coastal Commission on their comments. I think it's a great update, and I think it's time to move it forward to the Board of Supervisors.


9:41 p.m.

And I'd say that understanding there are also other projects underway that are going to need this document. So I don't see us getting anywhere different by bringing it back one more time. So I'm ready to move forward. Commissioner Carozzi? Yeah, I think I'm not quite there yet. I think I still need some clarification. I think I'm still... Yeah, I don't think I'm quite ready to go ahead and approve this. I completely agree with Commissioner Skavdal's statement around staff's work. I think they've done a fantastic job. I just personally need a little bit more time. But a no vote can be out. Voted.


9:42 p.m.

I think at this point we're just waiting for somebody to make a motion one way or another. I would so move that we move this forward to the Board of Supervisors. Would you consider your motion to include all the changes that we've discussed tonight, all the staff's recommended changes, and the intermediate position on sea level rise with the five-year, with at least checking into that five years? I'll second that. Okay. I have a motion by Commissioner Fulton and a second by Commissioner O'Neill. Laura, may we please have a roll call vote? Commissioner? Commissioner Scavdahl? Yes. Commissioner O'Neill? Yes. Commissioner West? Yes. Commissioner Curiazzi?


9:43 p.m.

No. Commissioner Fulton. Yes. Motion passes. Okay. That brings us to... Normally we have a couple... Am I missing the report from Planner? Okay. Well, we have... Is there anything quickly that Planner needs to say? I don't think so. I think... In the interest of time, we will just go ahead to item H and go to adjournment. Our next meeting is November 5th, 2026 at 6 p.m. Thank you.