Thank you. Okay, let's go ahead and call this meeting to order. Please salute the flag. The United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Welcome everybody. If you're not familiar with our processes agendas are in the corner by the door and supplemental materials that have come in are on this lower table right here. If you would like to grab them to follow along. We are going to move to item B. Commissioners present may I please have a roll call. Commissioner Fulton is absent.
Commissioner McFarland is absent. Commissioner Curiazzi? Here. Commissioner Sarah West? Here. Commissioner Peggy O'Neill? Here. Commissioner Noah Levy? Here. Commissioner Ivor Skabdahl? Here. We do have a quorum. Excellent. Thank you. Okay. Well, that brings us to Item C, Agenda Modifications. Director Ford, do we have any modifications tonight? We have no modifications to the agenda tonight. There are some new attachments or supplemental information. Two of them are related. Actually, all three are related to the item on the public hearing for the AT&T Tower. Thank you. We have those on our table up here, and then, as I said earlier, they're available for the public on the table down there if anyone would like them. Okay. So this brings us to Item D, Public Comment on Non-Agenda Items. This is the time in the evening. Where people...
may appear before the commission on any matter that is relevant to our jurisdiction but is not on the agenda tonight. So if you're here for an item that's on the agenda tonight you'll speak when we hear that item we'll open up a particular comment period for that item but if you want to talk to us about something that's not on the agenda tonight tonight now is your time. So I'm going to ask folks in the audience to approach the podium and they'll have three minutes to speak and then I'll check with anybody calling in or online to see if they would like to speak at this time on a non-agenda item but if you are calling in or online please raise your hand now so that I can see you when we are ready to move to online comment. There's a little bit of a lag in the video so make sure you raise your hand now so that I don't miss you when it is time to move to the online and telephone portion. So with that anybody in the room who would like to comment on the non-agenda item? Please approach the podium and you have three minutes. My name is Jennifer Raymond.
And I'm here to speak about Miranda's rescue. When Shannon Miranda applied for the conditional use permit in 2003, he stated that he would build an approximately 7,000 square foot kennel building to house the dogs. That description is included in the executive summary, the project description, the plan of operations, and it's shown on the site plan. The planning commission approved his conditional use permit with conditions, including a grading permit will be required for Phil to raise the kennel and other structures a minimum of one foot above the mean flood elevation. It also went on to state that the companion animal rescue and adoption facility shall be operated in accordance with the project. Description site plan and plan of operations that kennel building.
It was never built. The dogs are housed in open chain-link kennels subject to all the weather. Other conditions were also never met. This was brought to the attention of the planning department and in June they issued a letter of compliance to Mr. Miranda, which he signed. And in that compliance agreement, he was required to meet those original conditions, that is a grading permit to raise the kennel and structures one foot above mean flood elevation. Mr. Miranda's attorney objected. He wrote letters to the planning department and on September 25th, Mr. Ford responded to her and said it is the intent of the permit for the animal rescue enclosures to be raised above the flood elevation and it's not plausible that in reviewing a conditional use permit, the county would have to raise the kennel and structures one foot above mean flood elevation. He wrote that the county has felt it appropriate to allow the animals to be intentionally
contained in enclosures in the flood zone that would be subjected to flood waters with the potential to trap and harm the animals. She objected again and on October 22nd, Mr. Ford responded and said, we concur there is no specific requirement that the existing kennels, which do not meet the definition of a structure under Humboldt County Code, be raised above the flood elevation. The failure to submit a grading permit to raise the kennels will no longer be a reason for suspension. In other words, it's fine to trap the dogs in the water. 60 dogs could go underwater and Shannon Miranda will not be there to rescue them. This permit is so terribly flawed, it needs to be reviewed. He has not met the original conditions, which said he'd build an indoor kennel and now the dogs will be trapped in kennels.
underwater. I'm asking the Commission to consider this. Thank you. Thank you. Anybody else in the room who would like to make a comment on a non-agenda item? Okay, I'm not seeing anyone so we'll go ahead and move to online and calling in. This is, please raise your hand now if you would like to make a comment on a non-agenda item, otherwise we're going to move on. Okay, I'm not seeing anybody with their hands raised so we are going to go ahead and move to our next item on the agenda. This is the item E, the consent agenda. Items under the consent agenda are public hearing matters that are routine in nature so they are usually approved by a single vote but before we do our single vote I will poll the Commission and the audience to see if anybody would like to pull an item off of this, off of the consent agenda so that it can have a staff report and public comment. So I'm going to go ahead and pull the comment section with it.
So I'm going to read through each item and if you would like this item if you would like an item pulled when I read it out please raise your hand and I will pull it from or we will pull it from the consent agenda and we'll hear it separately with a public comment period. So with that let's go through our list. So E1 conditional use permits for a short-term rental located in the tsunami hazard zone. Would anybody on the commission like to pull this item? Would anybody in the audience or online like to pull this item? Please raise your hand. Okay not seeing any hands raised. Item E2 would general plan amendment and zone reclassification. Would anybody on the commission like to pull this item? Would anybody in the audience or online like to pull this item? Not seeing any hands raised. Item E3.
Branch LP general plan amendment and zone reclassification. Would anybody on the commission like to pull this item. Would anybody in the audience or online like to pull this item. OK. I'm not seeing any hands raised. So we will go ahead and entertain comments questions or motions. I would move approval of the staff recommendation for each of the three items on the consent calendar. Okay, we have a motion and a second. Let's go ahead and do a voice vote. All those in favor, please say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Any abstain? Okay. Motion passes. Item F, items pulled from consent. We didn't have any items pulled from consent. So that brings us to item G, our public hearing item. And tonight we.
I have one item under public hearings, the G1, new singular wireless PCS LLC AT&T mobility conditional use permit, coastal development permit, and special permit. Chair West, can I make a quick statement? Sure. I just want to acknowledge that this item was heard on September 3rd. I was not present for that meeting, but I have reviewed all of the letters and staff report and watched the video from your discussion of that meeting, so I am prepared. Thank you for doing your homework. Yeah. Commissioner Scaptal. Yeah, and I just want to disclose I did do a drive-by site visit of the site and of one of the alternative sites. Which alternative site? The one by Hammond Trail. Okay. Well, staff, whenever you are ready. All right. Thank you.
Good evening commissioners Michael Kine with Humboldt County Planning Department here to present the project PLN2025-19320. Alright, sorry about that. So this was originally heard back on September 3rd. The project is at 3386 Lilly Avenue in McKinleyville, California. Here is a site map of the location. You can see that it is just south of the regional airport. Here is another view of the location of the proposed tower. A quick rundown of the proposed project approximately. The tower would be approximately 89 feet tall. Originally it was planned to be 105. It would have stealth design sheeting which would cover the entire area. And, uh, resemble an industrial nonexistence. Cap is outside when the building college. The building will open for business as of April 1st. Future project as seen here.
A conifer tree. It would also have a 30 kilowatt generator used as backup as well. This next slide is the original search ring for the proposed site. The original tower used to be on the 76 gas station on Murray Avenue. It is currently still there. The gas station has been raised but the sign is still there pending the possible moving forward of this project. This next site shows the location of the preferred site and then this next one is the alternative site that we'll be discussing today. The applicant had looked at approximately 10 different locations as you can see based on the criteria that they needed and also based on county code.
The next few slides will be a simulation of what the proposed tower would look like. This was shown at the last meeting as well. So here is a view from Lily Ave looking south. You can see the tree right there. Sorry, the cell phone tower. This next one is looking north from Meyer Ave. And there would be the tower blocked by those Monterey pine trees. This next one is from the neighborhood to the east on Yamaha Avenue. And that is where the tower would be. And then here is a view from the southbound lanes of 101 looking north. That would be where the tower would look. And then here is a view from the southbound lanes of 101 looking north. And then from the southbound lanes of 101 looking north.
Looking northbound, the tower would be right there. Here is a map of the different locations where those photos were taken from, and I do want to point out that the Yamaha Place neighborhood has filled in quite a lot since this photo was taken. You can see there's a lot of vacant properties now that is completely filled with homes. This next slide reviews the consultation with the FAA that allows to determine that there is no hazard to aviation. The tower would not require lighting, nor is it proposed, and the top of the tower would have a clearance of approximately six feet from the ceiling protection space. This project, like I said, was originally 105 feet. It was proposed to be a tower that would be at the top of the tower, and it was proposed to be a tower that would be at the top of the tower. Due to issues with the airport, they had lowered it down to 87 feet, and the proposal was to have it be at the top of the tower.
Rose project has received approval of application for variance pursuant to county codes by the Humboldt County Aviation Director. So here's the tower location and you can kind of you can see in there that it would be slightly in the flight path of the runway. Which is that is that last slide that arrow pointing at the Lily Avenue site. Correct. OK. You'll see another one. Got it. So this is the proposed site that the applicant has preferred. This is the alternative site that was studied on September 3rd at the last hearing. The Planning Commission requested that the planning department review this alternative site, which is on APN 511-011025 at 3248 Letts Avenue. This site does match. And here's what it organised. It wants theanden and IT in a list because these guys are back in the service space. I had an outstanding fly in 1968. And I think that glove and bed in wet t-shirts are lashes. I'm not beat and out there, HD and Who es tirar una bar positioned itself antioxidants leisten aydet role on transport please ask on the We'd be the law or he knows there are doctors,Please install this. Do you know was a trauma doctor again with a t-shirt seating officer. This is the question. Has anyone done?
All required objectives for the applicant for their coverage. And the property owner is willing to lease part of the property as well. This property is zoned commercial recreation and is in the appeal jurisdiction of the coastal zone. Staff has reached out to the Coastal Commission for comments, and they did respond, which you can find in attachment 3C of your packet. The zoning of this parcel, like I said, is commercial recreation, the Hammond Trail area. It is outside of the flood zone. There's no potential liquefaction, and it's outside the hazard fault zones as well. Like the other parcel, it is within a moderate fire hazard severity zone and is in the... Arcata Fire Protection District.
Um Based on review of the California Natural Diversity Database, there was no flora or fauna that was protected on this location. However, a full bio review has not been completed. This site also has not received any FAA clearance for hazards to navigation, nor has an aeronautical study been performed, and a height analysis has also not been performed. So again, this is a view of the tower location as proposed. Here is the secondary location. They are both in the same zone. However, this one is more central to the landing zone, yet is further away from the end of the runway. So the height would probably not affect the zone. These next slides are...
of the alternative site and photo simulations of the proposed potential tower. This is at the end of Letts Avenue, and this is Howard looking south. Here is a view from the Hammond Trail just north of Norton Creek, and that would be what the view would look like from there. This next slide is looking on the 101 northbound, looking north, and that would be what the tower would resemble. And then finally, looking due west from the 101 north, it would look like this. One of the concerns that the applicant had for this location was the lack of other trees or shading that could prevent that tree from being seen, hence why they preferred the other location. So, this is the first time that we've seen this. And then finally, looking north, this is the second time that we've seen this. And this is the second time that we've seen this. And this is the third time that we've seen this. And this is the third time that we've seen this. And this is the fourth time that we've seen this. And this is the fifth time that we've seen this. And this is the sixth time that we've seen this. And this is the seventh time that we've seen this. And this is the seventh time that we've seen this. And this is the eighth time that we've seen this. And this is the seventh time that we've seen this. And this is the eighth time that we've seen this.
location being with the Monterey Pines. This next slide is a representation of the zoning area for the locations. You can see that the alternative site would have single residential families to the north and also to the south, where the proposed location has the same to the east and to the south, as well as the business park to the direct east and northeast. Apologies. This project is exempt from CEQA based on Class 3 exemptions for new construction or conversion of small structures. This project was noticed for a hearing on the 22nd of October. And notices were sent to all neighbors within 300 feet of the property line.
For this hearing, there were three comments received for this project, all mimicking what was the same concerns from the previous hearing. Only one of the comments received was from a person who had commented in the past. And during the last hearing, we had a petition that was signed as well by the neighbors of Yamaha Place, and it had approximately 21 signatures. During that last hearing, there was a recommendation requested to change the broadleaf shape of the proposed tower to a faux pine to resemble the Monterey. The proposed tower was a faux pine, however that condition was removed due to the fact that the samples previewed by the planning department
We're not up to the standards or unification of the project. It is still recommended that staff or staff still recommends that this project be approved at its original site. The tower proposal complies with the wireless telecommunications regulations. The lease area is within a is not within an area of sensitive habitat. And the project conditions address local concerns and required findings. If you have any questions, please let me know. Commissioner Scaptol. Yeah, I have a couple questions. First, on the alternative site, you noted what some of the surrounding properties were. To be clear, those properties haven't been noted.
Correct, because this hearing would not be able to vote on the alternative site. It's only for the approval or denial of the proposed site. So if this site wasn't approved and we were to move to the alternative site, there would have to be another hearing and those neighbors would be notified? Yes, a new application would have to be filed. Okay. Yes. Next question. The property between the cell tower site and the residential area is the business park property? Correct. It's zoned business park. It's zoned business park. It's not currently developed. It's not currently developed. What can be developed there and what's the building height limit in that business park? Do you recall? It is a Q zone. So I believe it would still be. It would be only three stories.
Well, commercial and industrial uses would be permitted. I don't know off the top of my head what the building height is. I'm thinking it's probably about 45 feet. We'll get back to you on that. Okay, but it is commercial space could be developed with a structure up to 45 feet high between the cell tower and those residential properties. Yes. Okay. All right, that's all I have. Thank you. Commissioner Levy. I guess I just want to be clear about what the staff recommendation does mean and doesn't mean. You're recommending that we approve this project in the original location. But that, as I hear you, but let me confirm if I'm understanding correctly, that does not amount to a recommendation that, given all that we presently know about the two locations, that the Lilly Avenue location is superior to the one across the highway. Correct?
It is superior in the eyes of the applicant. Otherwise, they would have chosen to move it, have it in the secondary site. As I had mentioned that they had preferred the Lilly site due to the camouflaging effects as well as it. I read their letter. I saw their testimony. But I mean, it's not the staff's recommendation that the Lilly site is superior in light of what we presently know about the Letts Avenue site, is it? No, it is. It is. Right, I'll just clarify that it is our recommendation that the Lilly Avenue site is superior primarily due to the potential aesthetic impacts. They would be less at this site than they would be at the other alternative location. So that's forming the basis for the recommendation. Because what it sounds like I'm also hearing is that we don't have, well, we'll get into more questions. I just wanted to clarify that right now. Thank you. Thank you.
Commissioner Chiarazzi. Thank you. I was just curious if and maybe this is a better question for discussion later but I was curious if real estate values come into play at all during the decision process here. No. I had a question to make sure I'm not sure I'm following along with the the camouflaging of the tower as a tree so you said that the planning department decided to to not have the requirement that it looked like a pine tree correct to resemble a Monterey pine but a broadleaf conifer as originally suggested would still be in place okay it's just during the last hearing they said maybe we can do a pine tree to mimic and all the examples they gave us were not
Um... As attractive at all. Thank you. Director Ford. The height limit in the coastal zone for a business park is 50 feet. Thank you. Any other commissioner questions or shall we move into public comment? Okay. I'm not seeing any other commissioner questions. So we'll go ahead and open up our public comment portion of this item. So we're going to start with folks in here in the chamber in the audience. If you could please approach the podium, each person will have three minutes to speak and then we'll move to online and calling in who will also have three minutes to speak. But if you were calling in or are on zoom, please raise your hand now so that we can be sure to see you when it comes time to move to your comments. Okay. You have three minutes. Hi, my name's. Christine.
And I live in on Yamaha Place near where the tower is proposably going to go. I wanted to speak because I'm really concerned about the impact this tower could have on our neighborhood and our homes. I want to say it's really emotional to see that photo literally outside my house and then I would have to walk out every day and see that. That's really, and sit on my porch and watch my kids play and see that. I mean it's it's not aesthetically pleasing to anybody that lives on that street at all. Maybe it is to AT&T but they don't have to live on that street and watch our kids grow up on that street. So we've worked hard for our homes and it's really upsetting to think that something like this could affect our property values and the views we enjoy every day. I understand there's a need for cell service but I really hope you consider the location that does not have such a direct impact on families and their families. Thank you.
And I respectfully ask for you to reconsider the location. Thank you. You can go ahead and we will reset your time for three minutes. Good evening. My name is Lindsay and I'm a resident and homeowner on Yamaha Place. First, I'd like to thank the board for allowing me the opportunity to speak and taking the time to listen to the concerns of the residents who will directly be affected by this decision. One of the things that makes our neighborhood special is a strong sense of community we have built here. We have a close-knit neighborhood where families know one another, neighbors look out for each other, and people take pride in their homes and surroundings. It's not just a collection of houses, it's a community that many of us have invested years in building, which is why this issue is so important to many of us. I appreciate the need for reliable cell phone service and understand that as technology continues to advance, our infrastructure must evolve with it. We rely on connectivity for work.
education, public safety, and everyday communication, and I am not opposed to progress or improve cellular coverage. However, I am opposed to the specific location. The proposed tower would have a significant visual impact on our neighborhood. A large telecommunication structure would become a dominant feature in an otherwise residential area, changing the character of the community. Many residents chose this neighborhood because of its active surroundings, and this tower would be a permanent eyesore. There is also concern about the impact on property values. Whether it is because of the appearance of the tower or simply because buyers do not want to live near it, homes located near visible cell towers can become less desirable. Homeowners have invested significant time and resources into their properties, and this project has the potential to negatively affect those investments. One concern raised at the last hearing regarding the alternative location was that people using the Hammond Trail may see the tower. While that may be true, there is an important difference between its actual location and these high-temperature buildings, which can・・ be located in sites along 89, Jewish sono-Siumabекс, and both are located at 9 Diallo ltd., in areas more Ukras keywords in the Nadine default 24ただ It makes no dissent. But there has been a limit to future power recognition,
Seeing a tower during an occasional walk and living with it every day. Residents near the proposed site would see this structure from their homes, yards, and neighborhoods streets year-round. Those impacts are permanent and affect far more people than occasional trail users. If this project is going to move forward it should be located where it provides the needed services while having the least impact on residents. Choosing the site that minimizes impacts to homeowners and families is the most responsible planning decision. I respectfully ask that you reject the proposal, propose location on Yamaha Place, and pursue the alternative site. We support progress and understand that the need for improved cellular service. We're simply asking that it be placed in the location that has the least impact on residents and our community. Thank you for your time. Good evening chair and commissioners. My name is Isla Gilbine.
I'm Jared Reed and I live and own my house at 1090 Yamaha Place near the proposed Lily Avenue Tower site. I'm here to respectfully ask that you deny the Lily Avenue site. I understand that the alternative site on Letts Road has been raised as a visual concern because it lies in a coastal zone or adjacent to the Hammond Trail. I ask the commission to weigh the concern against the impact on the people who live and would see that tower every day versus those walking by. The impact on property value is a real concern. There's more than 40 homes that sit within the 600 feet of the Lily Avenue site. And based on peer-reviewed studies, homes stand to lose as much as 20% of their value. That means more than 40 families would take a major financial hit to their biggest investment. By comparison, there are just maybe three homes in the Letts Road site. So the financial impact to those families... The... What?!стрay.co Demol diverse
The total financial impact would be far less. I hope the commission will take into account the additional potential negative effect on property values that this neighborhood is facing due to the proposed Amazon site. That was a totally separate issue. The visual impact as well. The Lily Avenue Tower is only partially shielded by the trees to the south. It would be fully visible from the north, east, and west. And although the reports discuss it being shielded within those trees, it still sticks out and is weird and it seems to make really no difference. So we would just ask that the experience of the visual disturbance be an impact more on folks that are just walking by and are not living there every day. So for these reasons. I I I respectfully urge the commission to reject the proposed Lily Avenue site. Thank you for your time. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
Thank you. Before we move to online and calling in comment, I need to apologize. It's typically our practice to invite the applicant up first to make comment. And I'm sorry that I skipped that step. If the applicant would like to come up and address the commission, you're very welcome to. You have ten minutes and then I can invite you up again at the end as is our practice. Thank you, commissioners. Good to see you all again. So one thing I wanted to address is some things that I've seen in the letters and discussed here is the site location and how it was chosen. This was the job that I did. I was first issued this search ring from AT&T in July of 2023. So this is a long process and it's not an easy one. I think I may have mentioned last time I was here that
I got into wireless from real estate. I was selling homes in Sacramento. 2007 came around and I wasn't gonna make it through that downturn so I got into wireless. So that's almost 20 years I've been doing this. I've gotten pretty good at finding the least obtrusive place. The first candidate that we had was at McKinleyville High School to replace one of the light standards and put the antennas up there. It's something we do all the time. I feel good about it being an old guy. I like to see that money go into the community, to a school district, you know, that type of thing. And it was going well and then suddenly they pulled out. And so I looked for other places, talked to a lot of other landlords. A lot of them weren't interested. Some weren't zoned properly and we had to expand the ring wider. Again, more candidates. These two were about the only ones that were really willing, had available utilities. You don't have to talk about the other thing.
and fit the needs of the network. I chose the one on Lilly Avenue because I could put it up against some trees and at least get some visual screening or backdrop from it. Because the one over there across the freeway on Letts Avenue, there's nothing really tall around there. There's just some 20 foot high brushes that wouldn't really hide the tree. And my feeling is that if I had chosen that one and come to planning in this commission with those photo sims that you just saw, probably wouldn't have gone very well. So I understand the objections of the neighbors and I'm not gonna try and discredit that in any way. You have their letters, you have AT&T's letters. I just wanted to speak on the site acquisition process. And if you have any questions.
Thank you. At the end, I want to make sure we get to online and calling in comments. And then at the end, if we have questions or if you would like to rebut what you've heard, I will call you back up. Very good. Thank you. Okay. So as a reminder, if you're calling in or you're Zooming in, please raise your hand now so that I can be sure to call on you during this comment period. And we're going to start moving into comments. So Stephanie Israel DeSouza, you have three minutes. Good evening. I'm Stephanie Israel DeSouza, a resident of Yamaha Place. I know that you have heard from me a lot already. But if it seems like I'm fighting like my life depends on this, it's because it does. I know that you are not legally allowed to consider health or disability-related concerns like I expressed in my written public comment before the first hearing. But you can take into consideration the fact that this cell tower placement, which is a framed light ourinformant of 78 years ago, and today I have the space to present it to both of you. Thanks so much, therapies. And that's why I'm here today. I am a起來box and it's my pleasure to say thank you very much to all of you SEA program practitioners you which I'm very grateful for sparing time I am a law сор. And thank you very much to my present speaker, Dr. Juan Carlos Gomez with any chance to speak with one of my colleagues online. But anyOTS. Thank you all. Right now.
financially impossible for me to sell my home at any point in the near future, thus trapping me in a location I cannot escape regardless of how much of my mental factors in that location caused me to suffer. The peer-reviewed real estate literature consistently shows that residences within a 200 meter radius of a cell tower face a significant reduction in property value. There appear to be, based on my use of your GIS tools on the county website, about 45 homes within this radius of the proposed Lilly Tower. Although the extent of property devaluation depends on various factors like distance from the tower, the degree of visibility of the tower, as well as unrelated market factors that fluctuate over time, some studies show devaluations between 8 and 20 percent within this radius. Even a 2 to 3 percent devaluation would be crushing to my family, but at 8 to 20 percent I would not be able to afford to sell my home at any point in the foreseeable future. I represent one of roughly 45,000 people in the United States, and I am within this 200 meter radius of the tower.
One of 45 families that can't stands to take a significant financial hit to our greatest investment, our home. Furthermore, the cell tower would be visible from our cul-de-sac, from our homes and our yards, every minute of every day that we are home. It is only partially shielded by trees to the south, but unshielded in other directions. I understand that there are visibility concerns related to the alternative Letts Avenue site, but I ask the commission consider visibility as an interaction rather than a fixed physical property. How often is the tower being viewed and by whom? To what extent does it negatively impact their quality of life? Someone viewing a tower as they briefly drive past on a highway or walk past on the Hammond Trail is not the same as someone viewing it all day, every day from their yards and windows. I stand with the 21 residents of Yamaha Place opposing the cell tower location at Lilly Avenue. Cell towers break. They belong in commercial, industrial and unoccupied areas, not in residential neighborhoods.
Thank you. Okay, next up I see Amy Bland. You have three minutes. This is also the last hand I see raised, so please raise your hand now if you would like to speak. Hi there, this is Amy Bland. I live right next door to Stephanie. I'm a little concerned, of course, about the value of our homes going down by 20%, but I'm also concerned because I have not gotten any notification or any letters about this cell tower going up. I wouldn't even have known about this if Stephanie didn't mention it to me, and to possibly take the chance of losing 20% of a cell tower is absolutely absurd, just because somebody doesn't want to look at it that is possibly driving by or walking on a hidden trail. That's crazy. Buying a home is your biggest investment, and having a cell phone tower put in is crazy. It's just ridiculous. I am just... I am...
I'm upset about this. Again, we have to look at this every single day and I'm not even being notified about this. Again, my house was the one with the trailer in front of it for the people that were at the last meeting. And I just I'm baffled. Our families live here. It's something that we will have to deal with again every day. You all have heard people can walk by the Hammond Trail and look at it for, you know, five minutes or whatever it takes to walk by it. But I just I do not want please consider this. It is crucial to us. Everyone on Yamaha, we do not want to lose values of our home. Please consider this. And I appreciate your time. Thank you so much. OK, thank you to everyone who has taken the time to come out tonight and make comment to us. Public comment is really important and we value it. So I don't see any other hands raised. So I'm going to. Thank you.
Close comment and go back to our applicant and see if we have any questions for him or if he has any additional comments after hearing public comment. So, oh, I do see one more hand raised. Okay. The iPhone calling in on Zoom, you have three minutes. Hello, can I be heard? Yes. Yes. Okay. Okay. So, my name is Chris Hudson. I live at 1093 Yamaha. And my main concern with the cell tower, I take a lot of pride in my home, a lot of pride in my yard. It's one of my pride and joys. And to have something like this stuck in the middle of our neighborhood to affect us with both the visual beauty of our surroundings and also our home values just seems completely unnecessary. So, I don't have a whole lot to say beyond that. But I just wanted to share that. And that's where I stand with this whole thing. I think there's. Thank you.
There are options that are probably completely viable, but to kind of stick us with this thing just seems really unnecessary. That is all. Okay. I don't see any other hands raised. Okay. Would you like to come back up and say anything else? Yeah. One thing that I forgot to mention was the request to go from a pine tree to what we call a broadleaf. I'm not a tree person, so I'm not sure what type of species it's actually supposed to be, but the broadleaf trees have broader leaves than pine needles. And so they just hide things better. And so when you look at a... A faux tree that's a broadleaf, they hide the antennas better. They look better over time. And since this...
Our is Is going to be visible especially from the freeway and from this neighborhood, I thought it was the better choice for camouflaging Another thing I might mention is that if the tower was placed on Letts Avenue, it would also be visible from Yamaha place That's all I have to say and answer any questions, yeah I Yeah, I'll just ask you um, I Appreciate the the letter that you submitted the new letter with simulations of both photo simulations, but just going back to the the The other variables involved with these two options and I know only one option is before us tonight, but apart from what you've already said and what staff Represented that you felt it was better to choose the site east of the high I I I I I I I I I I I I I
way because it had some trees nearby that could help visually mask it yes and that wasn't true on the let's property is there any other reason why the let's property is a less desirable location from the standpoint of coverage um you know it is as i see it closer to the location of the the one that's being replaced um it's closer to most of mckinleyville in that sense it's it's no further really from the highway but it is a little bit further south uh from a practical perspective of filling the needs of the network no they're both they would both provide coverage um ease of construction was probably about the same on both um cost of construction that those type of considerations um when i'm looking to when i'm looking in that first run through of an area i'm looking at you know where
And I put it that it's going to be the most screened because they can stick out like a sore thumb. And that grove of trees was one that looked like a place where I could tuck it up there as close as I could. And, yeah, it's going to be visible. I understand that. And I understand the views of property values. Like I said, I used to be a realtor. But, you know, at the same time, right now, I'm paying $212 for Comcast cable and Internet. And I'm swapping it out for an AT&T Air thing that runs off of a cell tower. And I'm going to get that, and that's going to be my Internet and YouTube TV, and I'm done, and I'm saving $85. So it's worth it to me. It's all subjective is all I'm saying about that. And I understand what they're saying. Like I said, I don't want to discredit their feelings at all. But, you know, these are the criteria that I've chosen. And if I could have found a better place.
I would certainly go for it. And I thought I had that with McKinleyville High School because that's a prime coverage objective to any carrier is a school. And, you know, I'm working on 30, 35 sites at any one time, and usually two of them are going to be schools because they go well. But unfortunately they pulled out. Right. And I believe you said in your comments in the September 3rd meeting that it had been a while since you'd actually gotten the permission or from the landowner of the alternative site. I know it's only been two months since then, but did you in fact revisit that landowner and confirm that they would still be willing to move forward if it was moved to the alternative site? Yes, I did. And they were still willing to lease. Okay. Thank you for affirming that. Yeah. Very nice people.
Any other questions for our applicant? Okay, thank you. Okay, so at this point, we're bringing it back to the commission for discussion and potentially an action. Commissioner Curiazzi? I'm curious, can you provide a general sense of which zones, in general, cell towers are conditionally permitted in? Can we generally consider them in most places, including residential? Yes, in most zones they are allowed. Usually, if they're tall towers like this, it would be a conditional use permit. Right, okay. So most... Most places that are residentially zoned, where all of us are living, could potentially face this same thing. Correct. Okay.
Tim Sprigg's Perforated Wrist Juth Part rolled Okay I guess I'll speak up again. I think I'm probably already indicating that I'm having a hard time understanding why the Lily Avenue site would be considered superior to the one across the highway. I understand that the nature of this permit was that they had to pick one and come forward with one instead of being able to come forward with two that could be chosen, and that's unfortunate. And I understand that the company, they've invested several years in this, and they would rather move forward with the one that was teed up and ready to go. But when I look at what I think is the most current aerial images of where residences are in proximity to those two sites, when I look at
which one is actually closer to the one that's being vacated, which one is further from the airport, which one is in an area that seems to be more appropriately zoned. And when we take into account what many people have said, which is that there's a difference between affecting the viewshed of somebody who walks by occasionally on the Hammond Trail, looking towards the highway, I might add, not looking out on the bluffs, versus people who are looking out their front door, out their yard, or out their window. I mean, to me, I don't see an argument for why the one on Lilly Avenue has fewer visual impacts than the one across the street, across the highway. So, I mean, it's unfortunate that apparently the only option for us tonight is to say yes or no to the one on Lilly. But based on everything that I've heard, including from the applicant, I don't see why the other one wouldn't be a superior location.
If I could. So context is everything, particularly when placing cell sites. So a couple things that you've got going here, and this is a rule of thumb for most planners, most people who work as applicants, is that if you can find a site where you can put it in the context of trees, that fits much better into the context of where it's going to be than a cell site that just sits out in the middle by itself and sticks out. The goal, particularly with a faux tree, is to have it not be invisible, but be less attractive to the eye, and that's the goal. Because it fits into that context of those existing trees. Now the secondary...
early you know some comments were made and I do not want to discredit anything the the community members have said because this is their neighborhood obviously but another thing about context to consider is that the area between where the proposed cell site is located and that neighborhood is a business park parcel that is likely to be developed with a business park warehouse distribution kind of use and so that is the context of where this is being proposed it's not being proposed in the middle of a existing and future residential neighborhood is being proposed in the context of what will one day be a business park parcel neighborhood but it's it's not being built in the middle of a residential neighborhood but it's pretty close to a residential neighborhood
And I guess I would just say that I think the matter of camouflage is a really subjective argument. You know, is it better to see a fake-looking plastic tree with some near trees that are not as tall as it nearby? I mean, I'm not sure I consider that a superior aesthetic outcome either, if that's what this all hinges on. Just saying. I saw Commissioner Scavda and then Commissioner O'Neill. This is an interesting discussion. And at the last meeting, I was kind of right where you are. In fact, I think it was I that suggested that we get more information on the alternative site. But I'm going to try to answer your question. And I did go out there and spend some time. And it is a nice neighborhood. It's a nice residential neighborhood. It's a nice neighborhood. It's a nice neighborhood.
... homes and the people do take really good care of them and you can see that. And you know visual impacts are always kind of the toughest because they're totally subjective, eye of the beholder I suppose. The site, when you look at the actual site where this is where it's proposed, you can see why that was selected. It makes sense. It is in a grove of trees. When you stand at that site and look back towards the subdivision, you see the backyard fence, you see trees that are growing along that fence. It's hard to actually see the houses. I think I could see two windows. They were small windows like most likely in a bathroom above a shower or something. So I couldn't see that there was actually going to be a lot of
Be a lot of view from inside homes of the tower. It'd be kind of difficult to see from inside the home. You might see it from the backyard. You can certainly see it from the street when you're out front, like driving through the neighborhood, you would be able to see it. And it's quite a ways away, like a football field and a half or so, 150 yards. It's out there. And there's a business park. The subdivision backs onto a business park that's going to be developed with structures up to 50 feet tall. So it's hard for me to understand a property value impact or something like that. When you drive down the freeway, when you drive down one of the streets, you'll see a lot of buildings. You want to be at the street when a car starts to pass you are going to say, hey, a building would be agreed to by the wayside which is what I wanted to say. So now, and our real estate agent is, a little trees work in that creative work style and then he's putting down, and then he's letting you turn you spectacularly where you wanted to place your, i.e. put that across your plan. If you were today, and you used that to pave the road around a health center, You don't want to go back into it, or you don't want to keep wanting to go back and looking for that green field right now. Theseprot.ai and this DefinitePlace. So if you are, you might want to be there. And you might want to build a boutique home or a怎么样 low to your house or and you want a flatbed tree, which is great.
It's not going to be as obvious because it's in a grove of trees. The one on the west side of 101 will be to everybody that drives by. The trail is actually, the Hammond Trail there is next to the highway. So the cell tower off the trail would actually be on the ocean side of the trail. There are homes there. It's not as densely developed on the west side of the freeway, but there are still homes on the east side of the freeway that would still be, that would have the view of that basically was going to be a monopole because it was just going to be one of these fake trees standing up by itself with nothing else around it. So I kind of went back and forth when I looked at the two sites. I get it.
Thank you. So I actually think they selected probably the best alternative of those sites that are available. I appreciate that. Commissioner O'Neill? For me, it's an easy decision. I'm a McKinleyville resident, and I own my home, and I pay my fair share of taxes to this county. And if the homeowners who live there who've invested in living in McKinleyville say they don't want it, then I'm supportive of that. Because even though it might be the best site and we all can sit here and figure out how it's the best site, they're saying they don't want it. And so I don't want it because I want to support homeowners. McKinleyville had got decimated back in the day when all the homes got taken away and turned into rents. And it was a big single-family home community.
And we deal with a lot. We deal with whatever the county needs to accommodate for the state. You know, it goes to McKinleyville, and we don't always get back as much as we give. So if the homeowners of McKinleyville who live near there say they don't want it, then I'm going to say I don't want it. And it's a really simple decision. And I get there's – we can sit here and say, yeah, it's better for this reason or that reason, but I support local homeowners over an out-of-town interest. And, you know, if it was life and death and if we didn't have the cell tower, you know, we wouldn't have 911 or, you know, then I might reconsider. But if they say they don't want it, then I don't want it. And it's that simple. Commissioner Scafda. And I appreciate that. I just don't know what to do when we notice the next site and the homeowners come and say they don't want it. Are we just, we just keep moving around until...
We find a place. Similar to Commissioner Scavdahl, I think that's where I'm struggling. This is not a popular use with communities ever. Most people enjoy having cell service, but I've never met a person who enjoys looking at these cell towers. It's completely understandable that folks don't want them in their neighborhood. I don't enjoy them in my neighborhood either. But to Commissioner Scavdahl's point, if we say no to this and then open the door up and the applicant considers, and the next logical step would be the applicant to consider their alternative site, then we have a new community of people who are hand and trail users and are neighbors and are
general community residents and whoever else who comes out and says that they don't want to look at it there either. And then we've asked the applicant to spend more money and time, and that site is more obvious. And so if we are then choosing a site based off of neighborhood concern about property values, we end up in the same situation, but it sticks out even more than it does at this current tree site. That being said, we don't know without going down that path whether folks will come out. But I just have a really hard time. I think that these are unpopular no matter what, and I'm leaning towards approving it at the site that it's at. Thank you. Commissioner Kenyazi. Thank you. Yeah, I'm
I think I'm leaning as well towards, I don't know, I was going back and forth. I was definitely agreeing with Commissioner Levy around just it really is hinging down on a subjective aesthetics impact, which is an impact to welfare. And I started going down the road of similar to comments where do you just kind of scale it to it's this many homes being impacted versus a higher number of homes being impacted and just kind of go about it more of an equation type approach as a justification. I think if we did go down that road, I think it's clear the applicant would need to get a biological assessment report, I believe, for that particular site. They would need to get an FAA. They would need to get an aerial analysis. And I think that's fine, just noting that there's a number of additional reports and analyses that would need to be done.
I think for me the neighboring commercial zoning does add a lot to the context. And then I also agree with Commissioner West, this is just not popular wherever you go. Hence sort of my considering making it more of a formulaic decision. I still probably would entertain or vote for considering the alternate site just from that perspective of impacting relatively fewer people, but agreeing that we will likely get a turnout of a whole other group of people that would be opposing this. However, I think I also... I would lean towards approving this as well.
Yeah. Well, I think I'm not seeing anybody wants to comment, but we do have to move forward in some fashion. So does anybody want to entertain a motion? I'll make a motion that we accept staff recommendation and adopt the resolution that finds a plan and commission to determine the project exempt from environmental review, makes required findings to approve the conditional use permit, coastal development special permit, and approves the new singular wireless conditional use.
permit, coastal development permit and special permit, subject to the conditions of approval. I'll second for discussion. I do just want to mention if this does get approved if staff could clarify the decibel rating for the generator. I think there's some that reference 60 decibels and other areas reference 50 and just sort of clarifying in the conditions of approval and the draft resolution. To staff is the intention 50 or is the intention 60? 50. It would be just like most of our cannabis regulations things of that nature. Okay. Does the motion and second still stand with that?
Yes. Okay. And Commissioner Schaafvillig, do you have an additional comment? Yeah. I just want to add that this isn't an easy decision for us, as you can tell, and I do appreciate the neighbor's concerns. I did ask that we get more information at the last meeting on the alternative site, and I appreciate the applicant brought that and staff brought that additional information. I did go out and look at the sites personally, and I just, you know, I did consider your comments, but I think this is the best choice that we have before us right now. Commissioner Kerri-Hausley? I did, in following up on my comment in the last meeting regarding the RF exposure analysis as well, I did go back and compare with the report provided for the Beaupre site. The cell tower we considered back in last year.
I did find this report pretty bare bones, but the report that T-Mobile provided I thought was, I felt, did a much better job. However, I did note that the percent general public exposure was quite a bit lower, roughly one-third of the T-Mobile. And so no additional mitigation requirements were needed. And I just wanted to follow up and confirm that it looked to me that the proposed design looks appropriate. Any other discussion before I call a vote? Okay. May we please have a roll call vote? Commissioner Scavdahl? Yes. Commissioner Levy? No. Commissioner O'Neill? No. Commissioner West? Yes. Commissioner Curiazzi? Yes. Motion passes. Thank you.
Three to two. Okay. I want to echo the other Commissioner's comments. Thank you for everyone who came tonight. We truly do appreciate hearing your input. So that brings us to Item H, Report from Planner. Director Ford. Thanks. I think the one thing I would bring up is the Humboldt Barrier Plan is going to the Board of Supervisors on November 17th. So we're moving that forward. And then the Miranda's Rescue is still suspended. Thank you. How much longer is left on the suspension clock?
They were, yeah, they were required to have everything done, I believe, by around the first of the year. Okay. What does suspended mean? Does that mean they can't take dogs, they can't keep dogs? They can't take in dogs. They can't give dogs away as an organization, as Miranda's Rescue. So if they already have animals on the property, they can maintain those? That is correct. They essentially become private animals at that point. Okay, if there's not, oh. Is there laws about how many private animals you can have? In the agricultural exclusive zone, no, there's not. In residential zones, yes, there is. I might be pushing the limit. We're. We're getting into the discussion on the item, yep.
Commissioner Kerialli. I just had a question about a non-agenda item public comment received about a permit for a redwood in the outer redway area. I just wanted to check if there is a permit or I was just curious if that was something that was happening. Not currently, no. That seems to be something that is more historical that goes way, way back. Okay, thank you. Okay. So that brings us to item I, planning commission discussion. Not seeing any discussion. So we'll go ahead and go. Oh, I do have a question for staff while we're on this item. Do we think that we will, it looks like we will have a meeting on November 19th. We are having a second meeting this month? No, we are not having a second meeting this month. Okay. I would like to do a couple questions on that. So I read the question. So the first question is fine. I used my memory board. I'm going to ignore it. I'm going to here you the question second. What do you hear? I'm a deaf person. Right? Any issue with this meeting? No, I understand. But I do know you for o offer your name, the cert, because that is what it is.
So the 19th meeting, I'm sorry, the 19th meeting is canceled. Okay. Okay. November. So then we will reconvene in our first meeting in December. Correct. Okay. And we will let you know if there's sufficient items for that. We apologize tonight. I mean, the cell tower was a media discussion, obviously, but we're a little concerned about the volume of items on this agenda. It's not so bad to get out of here early once in a while. Okay. Well, with that, we will go ahead and adjourn. Thank you.