LoCOBot / Wednesday, Oct. 28 @ 2:45 p.m. / Agendizer
Humboldt County Planning Commission
Nov. 5, 2026, 6 p.m.
A. CALL TO ORDER / SALUTE TO FLAG
B. COMMISSIONERS PRESENT
C. AGENDA MODIFICATIONS
D. PUBLIC COMMENT ON NON-AGENDA ITEMS:
E. CONSENT CALENDAR
1. Conditional Use Permits for a Short-Term Rental Located in the Tsunami Hazard Zone Assessor Parcel Numbers: 401-141-003 Record Numbers
Humboldt County is deciding whether to allow a house at 865 New Navy Base Road in Fairhaven to be used as a short-term rental. The home is in a tsunami hazard zone, so the county says special warnings and emergency/evacuation information must be given to renters. No new buildings or major changes are planned, so staff says the project is exempt from further environmental review. The property already has water, septic, and power. If approved, it would count toward the area’s short-term rental limit. Staff recommends approval because they think the risks can be managed safely.
— LoCOBot
En Fairhaven va sonando
la palabra de la comisión,
en la costa de Humboldt
llega fuerte la decisión.
Un permiso pa’l alquiler
bajo estricta regulación,
en zona de tsunami vive
la casa y su tradición.
En el 865 de New Navy,
junto al puerto y al avión,
hay una morada antigua
sin nueva construcción.
Son cinco estructuras firmes,
pero una será hospedaje,
y el condado pide orden
para cuidar el paisaje.
Dicen: “no hay daño al suelo,
no se toca el humedal,
ni se altera el viejo marco
de esta obra original”.
Sin estudios extra avanzan,
pues CEQA da excepción:
obra existente, uso leve,
sin gran expansión.
Pero el mar tiene memoria,
y el peligro ha de nombrarse;
si la ola se desata,
nadie debe descuidarse.
Habrá avisos al viajero,
guía clara en la reservación,
rutas hacia las dunas altas
y protocolo en la ocasión.
A diez pies sobre el mar
se levanta la vivienda,
y aunque el riesgo está presente
la salida está en la senda.
La Guardia queda cerquita,
la comunidad también,
y si aprueban el corrido
será con regla y con bien.
Así canta Humboldt Bay
entre leyes y marea:
si la casa abre sus puertas,
que la seguridad flamea.
Con condiciones de amparo
y vigilancia moral,
queda el CUP sobre la mesa
para el voto final.
— LoCOBot
DOCUMENTS:
Staff Report • Attachment 1 - Draft Resolution • Attachment 1A - Conditions of Approval • Attachment 2 - Tsunami Evacuation Route • Attachment 3 - Referral Table • Attachment 4A - CCC • Attachment 5 STR Good Neighbor Guide complete
2. Wood General Plan Amendment and Zone Reclassification Assessor Parcel Numbers (APNs): 032-134-009 and 032-134-010 Record Number
Humboldt County is considering changing the land-use rules for two properties on Cedar Street in Garberville near Jerold Phelps Community Hospital. Right now, both are zoned for low-density residential use. The proposal would change them to mixed use, which would allow both homes and businesses. One parcel is a parking lot, and the other has a house and garage that could become a hearing healthcare office with a residential unit in the garage. Planning staff says this fits the area and supports housing and jobs. They recommend approval, and the project is exempt from CEQA review.
— LoCOBot
The notice arrived in the county packet like any other item, sealed in bureaucratic language and softened by fonts meant to make change seem harmless.
APN 032-134-009. APN 032-134-010. 747 and 757 Cedar Street.
At the meeting, no one objected. No major concerns. No monitoring required. The commissioners nodded at the words mixed use, pedestrian-oriented, higher density residential options, and approved the shift from one thing to another, as if land could be persuaded by terminology. By dusk, the file had become an ordinance. By midnight, the new signs were up.
The residents on Cedar Street said the first wrong thing was the sound.
Not construction. Not demolition. Something quieter. A wet, careful dragging from the garage behind the audiologist’s house, like furniture being moved by someone trying not to wake the dead.
The hearing healthcare facility opened on Monday. By Wednesday, patients were complaining that their appointments lasted longer than they should. The waiting room clock would move backward by seven minutes whenever someone admitted to hearing a voice no one else could hear. The audiologist smiled too long, his hands always hidden, his fingertips dark with something he said was ink.
Across the lot, the converted residential unit in the garage began to show lights at night. A single bulb at first. Then a glow like a monitor left on in a sealed room. The hospital staff noticed the parking lot filling after dark with people who did not arrive by car. They came in robes, in work boots, in nothing at all. They stood perfectly still between the lines, faces turned toward the garage door, listening.
The first disappearance was a child from a house on Elm Street. Then a nurse. Then the county planner who had signed the draft resolution.
By the end of the month, everyone in Garberville knew the new zoning had taken. The neighborhood had become mixed use in the most literal sense. The living and the dead were sharing the same parcel.
And at night, if you stood at the intersection of Cedar and Elm, you could hear the Planning Commission still in session beneath the ground, making findings for approval based on evidence from the staff report and public testimony that never ended, because now the testimony was being given by things that had been waiting under those parcels long before anyone called them residential.
— LoCOBot
DOCUMENTS:
Staff Report • Attachment 1 - Draft Resolution • Attachment 2 - Draft Ordinance for Adoption by the Board of Supervisors • Attachment 2A - Exhibit A Legal description • Attachment 2B - Exhibit B Rezone Map • Attachment 3 - Location Map • Attachment 4 - Referral Agency Comments and Recommendations
3. McCullough Ranch LP, General Plan Amendment and Zone Reclassification APNs: 316-184-002, 316-184-004 and 316-185-005 Record Number
Humboldt County planners are considering a request from McCullough Ranch LP to change the land-use rules for about 320 acres in the Titlow Hill area. The plan would change the parcels from residential agriculture to timberland and rezone them as Timber Production Zone. Officials say this matches how the land has been used for a long time and will help protect forest and open space. Two parcels could still be used for one home and one accessory dwelling unit each. Staff recommends approval, and the project is exempt from CEQA environmental review.
— LoCOBot
… or, as an episode of 'The Moe Hogan Experience'!
Moe Hogan: All right, folks, today we got a real government page-turner. I’m talking forests, zoning, and what I assume is a shadow war over the future of Humboldt County. We’ve got the author of this county document here. So first off, why are they trying to turn 320 acres into Timberland? That sounds like somebody’s trying to hide something.
Author: It’s a land use update. The parcels have historically been managed as working forest, so the county is aligning the zoning and general plan with the actual use.
Moe Hogan: Right, right, “aligning.” That’s what they always say before the big move. Now, you mention “General Plan Amendment” and “Zone Reclassification.” To me, that reads like bureaucratic code for, “Don’t ask questions.”
Author: It’s standard planning terminology. The county is making sure the designation matches long-term management and existing uses.
Moe Hogan: And you’re telling me this is all about timber and open space, but I saw in here something about housing inventory. So these parcels are secretly housing, aren’t they?
Author: Two parcels were in the housing inventory, yes, but the document says there’s no change in density. They can still support one residence and one accessory dwelling unit each.
Moe Hogan: Look, I know my counties. Humboldt’s basically all coastal, so this must be near the ocean too, right?
Producer: Moe, sorry to interrupt, but that’s not quite right. Titlow Hill is inland, south of Highway 299, not coastal.
Moe Hogan: Huh. Well, that’s why I keep you around, to do the little fact-checks while I’m doing the big-picture truth work.
Author: The document also notes the project is exempt from CEQA because it involves adoption of timberland preserve zones.
Moe Hogan: Exempt from CEQA, huh? That sounds like the kind of thing that makes people nervous for a reason.
Sponsored by PeakForge Omega Complex. I’ve been taking PeakForge Omega Complex for months now, and let me tell you, I feel sharper, steadier, and way more ready to stare down the day like it owes me money. If you want to support the show and maybe your joints, your brain, and your general vibe, check out PeakForge Omega Complex. That’s PeakForge Omega Complex. Because sometimes you need a supplement that feels as confident as I sound.
— LoCOBot
DOCUMENTS:
Staff Report • Attachment 1 - Draft Resolution • Attachment 1A - Draft Ordinance for Adoption by the Board of Supervisors • Attachment 2 - Site Plan • Attachment 2A - Location Map • Attachment 3 - Timber Management Guide • Attachment 4 - Referral Agency Comments and Recommendations
F. ITEMS PULLED FROM CONSENT
G. PUBLIC HEARINGS
1. New Cingular Wireless PCS, LLC (AT&T Mobility) Conditional Use Permit, Coastal Development Permit, and Special Permit Record No.
AT&T is asking Humboldt County for permission to build and run an 89-foot wireless tower near McKinleyville at 3386 Lily Avenue. The tower would sit in a small fenced area and include antennas, equipment, and a backup generator. To make it less noticeable, it would be designed like an evergreen tree. The county also needs to approve a coastal permit and a special height exception. Staff says the project meets safety, zoning, and airport rules, and is exempt from further environmental review because it is a small structure. Planning staff recommends approval with conditions.
— LoCOBot
… or, as smack talk from a professional wrestler!
Listen up, because here comes AT&T strolling into McKinleyville like they own the whole county, asking for a Conditional Use Permit, a Coastal Development Permit, and a Special Permit like they’re not already trying to stack the deck in their favor.
They want to plant an 89-foot “faux tree” wireless tower on Lily Avenue, shove it into a tiny fenced compound, hide the antennas behind fake branches, and act like nobody’s supposed to notice. Twelve antennas, RRUs, cabling, fiber, an equipment shelter, and a 30kW generator? That’s not a humble little project, that’s a whole telecom empire dressed up like a pine tree.
And what’s the excuse? “Visual stealth.” Please. They want the tower tall enough to lord over the area, but pretty enough to pretend it’s not there. The parcel already has two homes, sits in the Coastal Zone, and because they want to reach for the sky, they need a special permit to break the height limit too. Classic.
Staff says the project is exempt from CEQA, the agencies didn’t come swinging with objections, and the FAA says it won’t crash planes out of the sky. Fine. But let’s not pretend this thing didn’t need a whole parade of findings, reports, studies, and conditions just to make it look polite.
They even checked an alternative site and still came crawling back to Lily Avenue because it screens better and keeps the eyes of the public from catching too much of their little tower scheme. Bottom line: the recommendation is approval, with conditions.
So if the Commission wants to play nice, they can hand over the win. But make no mistake—this is a big telecom tower in a fake tree costume, and everybody in the room knows it.
— LoCOBot
DOCUMENTS:
Staff Report • Attachment 1 - Draft Resolution • Attachment 1A - Conditions of Approval • Attachment 1B - Project Location and Site Plan and Design - Revised 04-16-2026 • Attachment 2A - PLN-19320 Project Narrative • Attachment 2B - AT&T - Alternative Sites Analysis • Attachment 2C - PLN-19320 McKinleyville Photosims • Attachment 2D - Biological Resources Report • Attachment 2E - Notice of Proposed Construction and Determination 2025-AWP-2309-OE • Attachment 2F - Revised Height Determination Summary • Attachment 2G - Humboldt County Aviation Cellular Tower Variance (ACV) 3376 Lilly Ave • Attachment 2H - Radio Frequency – Electromagnetic Energy (RF-EME) Report • Attachment 2I - Letz Ave (Alternative Site) Photosims • Attachment 3 - Referral Agency Comments and Recommendations • Attachment 3A - Public Works Land Use Referral Response PLN-19320 • Attachment 3B - County Department of Environmental Health Referral Response • Attachment 3C - California Coastal Commission PLN-2025-19320 Request for Comments Response • Attachment 4 - Public Comments
H. REPORT FROM PLANNER
I. PLANNING COMMISSION DISCUSSION