Humboldt County Board of Supervisors
Monday, May 11, 2026
The agenda


1:38 p.m.

With our local youth, we have some of our staff go to the police academy and they teach classes. So that's a really great thing. We have a district attorney investigator who helps run the parent project along with probation. Another very positive thing for the community. We go and speak to classrooms. Sometimes we have classes come visit us in the courts and get to see what we're doing here. And hopefully.


1:39 p.m.

educate folks on, you know, not only what the criminal justice system does, maybe future litigators, who knows, it would be nice, and also hopefully deter folks from becoming engaged, you know, in the criminal justice system. So we also have a really robust internship program at the district attorney's office. I'm really excited about that. So we get lots of applicants and they're amazing young people that are, you know, get the opportunity to, you know, work hands on with the attorneys, investigators, the support staff, and oftentimes they get to help prepare presentations that, you know, will be provided during the course of the jury trial. So that's pretty exciting stuff too. And we certainly do go out to other community events and try to educate what we do, what services are available, in particular with our victim witness program. So we have


1:40 p.m.

A lot of programs where we talk about the victim services, what we can do in terms of theft and the prosecution of theft and reporting of theft and combating human trafficking. So those are some of our focus areas. So turning a little bit to specific accomplishments of our victim witness program so 44 years which that's an awfully long time for the program to be running so it's a great team of professionals that have been here serving Humboldt County since 1982. Our district attorney victim witness program has helped and served so many individuals within the community and when I saw the numbers for you know 2025 I was just like wow we just added another 2,000 victims that were served so that's that's pretty pretty impressive.


1:41 p.m.

And really just goes to speak to these folks despite the fact that they've had a decrease in staffing numbers. They've had this tremendous increase of people within our community that they're helping. So things that they do, they'll help with courtroom orientation. They'll guide them through forensic interviews. They attend meetings where victims are there with prosecutors and investigators and other scary people. And they will also make referrals to counseling and other services. And a big one, of course, is helping victims with victim compensation, preparing the applications to ensure that they're able to be made whole, perhaps get assistance if they need some sort of transitional housing. Maybe they're getting out of a domestic violence situation and they need a new place to live. So these are all the types of. Services that our advocates are providing to members of the community that have been.


1:42 p.m.

victimized. One of my favorite things every year as well is just getting to hear all the thank yous that are provided to our advocates and investigators and prosecutors for the work that they do. So this slide is typically really hard to read, but thank you for the advocate and investigator for your time today. I really appreciate all the guidance and I will stay in contact. That's from a domestic violence and attempted murder victim. Thank you for everything you and the program has done for us, for keeping us updated on the court progress. We really appreciate it. That was from a victim of assault with great bodily injury. Thanks ladies for always being there. That's from a mother of a child sexual assault victim. Thank you for helping me. I appreciate the support and updates. That's from a human trafficking and domestic violence victim. Thank you.


1:43 p.m.

And then finally a victim of a DUI incident indicated a victim witness helped pay my medical bills and helped me understand the system. Without their help, I would not have survived financially or emotionally. So these are some of the folks that do the hard work. And they are advocates who absolutely go above and beyond. They're positive. They're active listeners who really empathize with their clients. And as they put it themselves, we help give a voice to the once voiceless. Turning now to our CAST team. And as this board is aware, that's a multidisciplinary team that works to serve children and families for children who have been abused. And this last year. I think.


1:44 p.m.

Just kind of our ongoing work in serving the families and victims and conducting the forensic interviews and taking the cases to trial. We also, in order to continue doing that work, it's really important for us to have an accredited child advocacy center. So we worked through that process, and we were reaccredited. So that was actually, it sounds like not that big of a deal, but frankly, it really is a big deal because all of the different agencies that we work with and all of the requirements, and there's always a lot of new stuff that the National Child Advocacy Center wants their advocacy centers to be doing. And so we worked, you know, to ensure that we were in full compliance and checking off all the boxes. And I just have to really give a shout out to Chief Investigator. Chief Investigator Kyla Baxley, as well as our CAS coordinator, Katrina Horton, because together they did a lot of outreach.


1:45 p.m.

and ensured that everything was taken care of, worked with our individual advocates, law enforcement agencies, child welfare services, behavioral health, St. Joseph's Hospital, the SART nurses. And so anyhow, a huge thank you to all of those folks to helping make it happen so we can continue to do the good work there with CAST. And EVAST is our elder and vulnerable adults. And so there again, we work closely with the Department of Health and Human Services, Adult Protective Services, as well as the Sheriff's Department, Public Guardian. This is through Measure Z funding, so that was really key for us to be able to sort of create this collaborative team to help address elder and vulnerable adult abuse that was happening within the community. And as you can see, like the number of cases and filings has increased. I don't know that that's necessarily reflective of, you know, the number of cases that we've had in the past.


1:46 p.m.

that there's more incidences of abuse, but I think perhaps it's more awareness and communication between the different agencies and just having those conversations about the potential victims and potential offenders and who really needed to have the attention of my office. So that's a great success as well. We also have an organized retail theft vertical prosecution team. So that particular team has really worked hard to focus on retail theft within our community. And we've seen some great trends. We've seen a lot of successful prosecutions. We've also developed our own in-house diversion program to help divert low-level, more first-time type offenders. away from the criminal justice system, and then focus our efforts and our monies on the more serious...


1:47 p.m.

repeat offenders. So we've seen that initially most of the reports were coming out of you know kind of the big box stores kind of those stores that you would expect expect but other smaller stores local businesses they had kind of stopped reporting but as we're getting out there in the community we're seeing a definite increase and the more you know the businesses in rural locations smaller businesses and making those reports and just knowing that if there is a theft that we will prosecute it's very helpful. We also have a vertical prosecution team that's dedicated to crimes involving violence against women and this particular caseload has a dedicated prosecutor and a district attorney investigator and advocate that also is a or assigned to the particular team. It's really important for this particular


1:48 p.m.

particular team to have a reduced caseload. So those cases that are funneled into the Violence Against Women prosecution team are those where there's a higher risk of lethality that's presented. And so cases that involve offenders that might use weapons or have a conduct that could result in death. So strangulation, for example, severe injuries that are inflicted upon the victims. All of these factors are kind of taken into consideration as well as specific threats of violence or death upon the victim. And so then the team has the opportunity to have additional time to provide those direct victim services and work closely with the victim and the victim's family. Thank you.


1:49 p.m.

and have additional meetings and interviews and orient them to the court and provide them with additional supports that might not be something we can do otherwise for other types of cases. So our future goals continue to be really to enhance community safety by prosecution of crime and affair in timely manner and we're always going to prioritize violent crimes and those perpetrated against the most vulnerable victims in our community. We will continue and we will engage in community outreach and education efforts that are designed to prevent and to reduce crimes so focusing on the organized retail theft, the elder abuse, and then also focusing on fentanyl and opioid substance use reduction. We will continue to produce and protect our local businesses and


1:50 p.m.

and have consistent accountability measures for repeat offenders, in particular as it relates to theft. We'll enhance our data collection capabilities through interface with the court system and heighten efficiencies through continued case management and tech improvements. With our law enforcement partners and county IT, we want to establish an electronic report submission. Hopefully that would enhance and expedite the referral process. And so all of that we can also do with our case management system. And then we want to maintain and expand a highly competent team that's committed to professionally serving with integrity, compassion, and respect. And as alluded to earlier, we're always looking for qualified candidates. And it's, you know...


1:51 p.m.

It's really difficult to bring in, in particular, deputy, you know, district attorneys, people that are looking to go into that line of work. You know, sort of the public sentiment has changed over the years in terms of what it means to be a deputy district attorney. I, of course, you know, think that it's one of the best jobs that you could ever have. Extremely rewarding and you get to really have a sense of seeking justice. But, you know, here in our rural community, these historically low deputy DA applications across the nation are really impacting us and so it's just, it's just a different climate and, but, you know, I think as folks get the word out and as they get to meet our team that we will, you know, maintain and add to our really good hard work. working team. So, and I think, you know, with


1:52 p.m.

perseverance we will we will absolutely get there so thank you so much it's really an honor and happy to answer any questions thank you for that review um supervisor bush no uh thanks very detailed and um i i wanted to ask if there was one area that you think is suffering because of the budget issues in your department what would it be so it's it's it's staffing i mean we just need more people to do the work that needs to be done yeah i mean it's clear when you look at how many cases you have compared to how many staff you have that it's a huge workload and um and the amount of interaction you have with in and outs of courts and all the things i want to thank you and your department for all that you do for the residents of humboldt county it's super important and the advocacy around


1:53 p.m.

Keeping people safe in Humboldt County and keeping criminals off the streets it's really important and the work is tireless and sometimes it doesn't always go your way and it's hard it's a hard job I can't imagine the frustrations that happen within your department and I hope that our budget improves so that we can help you with that dedication that you have to Humboldt County families. Thank you. I think the outreach on the retail side the retail theft and everything else because I can tell you a lot of your retailers are just on their hands in the air because they'll get the problem being is they don't get a you know the response time sometimes is slow and they're expected to hold that person that person knows full well they can walk out and nothing's gonna happen to them. Literally they'll be back in that day even if they get


1:54 p.m.

arrested they'll be back that afternoon stealing again so the as you said the the hardcore you know this idea of everybody you know i saw it the other night a guy walked out of there with a a shopping full of at safeway in the on harris street walked out of there with a shopping cart full of groceries they tried to stop me wouldn't stop and they let him go knowing that i feel well i'm paying for his groceries when i pay for my stuff so i mean if we can you know and i know there's a lot more important things on the on the plate but both for the preservation of our tax dollars and the preservation of of at least the the semblance that we're you know providing some sort of avenue of defense for the retailer who's who thinks he's paying for it and you know because that's we saw that in 800 you know we saw that in 800 you know we saw that in 800 900 almost a 35 drop in misdemeanor because they've just


1:55 p.m.

Quit calling. Right, right. And I mean, you're exactly right. But I have to say. I don't want to be right. I want to be exactly wrong. No, but I mean, I think another thing that is really helpful is Prop 36, which the voters brought. And so we do have now Penal Code Section 666.1 for the repeat offenders. And that has been a helpful tool that we want to use appropriately, though, of course. And then the other thing is that if the retailer has the video evidence, and a lot of them do have that, we can proceed on prosecution, even if the offender walks out with the item so long as we can prove it. And there is another frustration. A lot of them have video and don't see anything happen. And that's a frustration. And I know this is never ending, and there's no shortage now that everybody has a ring phone. Everybody gets caught, hopefully. Well, I think.


1:56 p.m.

I encourage those retailers, though, to reach out to our office if they're not getting a response, and that's why we have an investigator assigned to retail theft. I mean, that's quite a dedication of resources, right? And because I do appreciate the significance and the impact that it has, you know, when folks are committing thefts, not only on the direct victim, that particular retailer and their business, but the community as a whole. It not only becomes part of the climate and culture, but it also impacts the services that you all can provide to other parts of the community. So it's like when you're talking about housing and shelter and basic needs, you know, that really has quite the ripple effect. So it's a big deal. No, and, like, I appreciate that you're doing that, but if you could get the reach out out there a little bit more, and I know you're limited, but so people know things have changed. We are going to do something. 36 made a difference. 47 killed this. But, you know, some of those things that pass when nobody reads. It's what is actually written in the ballot. But I appreciate it. Thanks. Thank you.


1:57 p.m.

Thank you. Okay. Thank you again. We are going to take a 10 minute break. We'll be back at 10 after two, so that folks can do the things we do during breaks. Thank you.


2:12 p.m.

Thank you. Thank you. I'm running.


2:13 p.m.

We are back from our break. Take it away. All right. Thank you, Chair. And with that, the next department is the Department of Health and Human Services, and we have DHHS Director Connie Beck here. And joining me today is Travis Green, the Finance Director for Health and Human Services. Or I should say Deputy Director. Sorry, Travis. So good afternoon chair and board members. I want to thank you for allowing us to present today on our proposed budget for fiscal year 26-27. After looking at all of...


2:14 p.m.

The beautiful photos in the last two presentations, I am feeling bad that I focused so much on just the budget and not so much on our accomplishments because I could go on all day and all night on the accomplishments for DHHS and the staff that work for us. So in addition to that, I do want to take a moment to thank staff. I want to thank the CAO and Jessica, Human Resources, Risk Management, and the Auditor-Controller's Office for working with us through some pretty difficult budget times and decisions that have been needed to be made. So I want to thank them and then also thank the DHH staff that are here in the room. A lot of those staff have participated in the budget process this year and are also available for education.


2:15 p.m.

To answer any questions that you might have. We were able to submit a very tight, balanced budget on time, working with what we are currently aware of. There are still many unknowns. As you are aware, the states may revise as being released soon. We may know a little more then. And of course, when the state budget is passed, we'll know more. So I'm going to turn it over to Travis now to go over some of the high-level budget information. Good afternoon, Chair Wilson and distinguished board members. It's a pleasure to be here. Again, my name is Travis Green. I'm the Deputy Director of Financial Services for DHHS. What we see before us in this slide is the total budget for fiscal year 26-27, broken down by branches and by budget. You can see the total there is $315 million. We are also asking for two additional general.


2:16 p.m.

Fund requests, one for $250,000 to replace the carpet in our 445 West Washington campus, and another for $250,000 for IS switches and server equipment that will be costed across the entire department. Next slide. In the previous slide, General Relief is, oh I'm sorry, can we go back one? Can't reverse? Nope, I don't know how. There you go. Oh, Kaylee's doing it for me. Thank you. There we go. Thank you. General relief is not in the pie chart, but it is listed up there as a separate item.


2:17 p.m.

General relief is a general fund budget, however it's administered by social services. GR being administered this way is how it is done in other counties because the systems and benefits are connected with social services and so that's why we house it that way and administer it. It is important to have some history of the integration of DHHS. DHHS was created with public health, behavioral health, and social services in August of 2000. Public guardian and veterans service offices came to DHHS beginning in 2004-2005 during budget challenges. When DHHS received veteran services office and public guardian, the county general fund was less than $100,000. Now the budgets are $618,000 and $1.3 million recently. N emprexit was lost on the east side of,, it is then repaid with payments from county service offices, rate Grandpa Calif to $10 a month and an individual and Africa inflammation客 most low off the Gulf Huh videos podcast I you. Up מע


2:18 p.m.

The programs have grown in caseload and costs have increased requiring additional funds to support them. As a result, more and more of Social Services County General Fund has been carved out to support these two county programs. Since the Department of Health and Human Services, the Department of Health and Human Services inception, the Department has held to a minimum or no impact to the County General Fund beyond what the Board of Supervisors agreed to with the administration at the time of its formation. At that time, the County General Fund represented 4.8% of the total DHHS budget and now is less than 2%. This slide represents the total budget amounts year over year. For three years, the increase for 26-27 is coming from behavioral health solely.


2:19 p.m.

Well, it is an overall increase for 2627. Public health had a decrease of 1.3 million, and social services had a reduction of 12.2 million for 2627. The increase for behavioral health is largely attributed to a $10 million investment in the new Sempervirens crisis stabilization unit building, a $4.43 million grant for diversion, and $10.8 million in placement costs. The placement costs are anticipated to be offset by increased revenues from billable bed days, Medi-Cal, and the addition of a new patch rate for claimable costs. We have been decreasing the number of allocated positions since fiscal year 23-24. Earlier on...


2:20 p.m.

Allocating positions was easier because they were often positions that were vacant and or hard to fill. In the previous budget year, we held all admin positions vacant. And in the current year, we have had a hard hiring freeze in social services, only filling three total FTEs. We are down to minimum staffing levels in many areas. To balance the budget, we are decreasing another 55 positions in the proposed budget. There have been a number of positions identified that have been held vacant in the current year that will need to be filled going forward and have been budgeted in the new fiscal year cycle. This chart illustrates that the majority of our funding for DHHS comes from federal, state, and realignment sources.


2:21 p.m.

Number of health and human services programs were realigned to counties and that's what came up out from realignment in 91 in 2010 2011 not mentioned in the earlier slides. The home program, which stands for housing outreach and mobile engagement, became a cal aim provider this year, enabling it to bill for community supports. Claiming will be more robust for fiscal year 26-27. While the claiming makes a significant difference, it does not fully fund staff so other sources of revenue are still needed. The home program has gone from two outreach crews to now just one. Medi-Cal administrative activities known as MA is a source of revenue. The public health branch and public guard Aztecan community, which provides error-free focuses for staff, has mostly funded from home for Section".


2:22 p.m.

years ago. It allows for federal claiming for medical administrative work already being done. Other divisions and programs plan to leverage that structure and expertise in order to begin claiming mod dollars for program activities. The upside is the strong existing structure. Public Guardian has been reimbursed for $334,000 out of its $1.2 million budget in fiscal year 24-25. The downside is that it will take 20 months for the funds to start coming in. The next slide. When we talk about realignment, it is really the effort, two efforts. One in 1991 focused on health and human service programs and 2011 realignment focused on.


2:23 p.m.

Adult services and law enforcement. This diagram shows what realignment funds can be used for. There is some flexibility. However, it is designed, designated funding that must be used for one of the covered programs. It also cannot be used for funding outside programs like veterans or public guardian. In this slide we see a breakout of the County General Fund and realignment across public health, behavioral health, and social services. So up there where it says three that would be behavioral health, public health would be number one and two would be social services on the realignment chart and it follows the same for County General Fund. And with that I will turn it over to Director Beck for the rest of the presentation.


2:24 p.m.

So in order for changes to be included in the proposed budget, we met with the CAO and HR Director to discuss possible scenarios to be included. IS and IT security was a pilot in the current year, so we are moving positions and costs to IT to formalize implementation. Employee services and HR consolidation consists of two analysts and the Deputy Director. With the reduced number of staff in DHHS employee services, it is no longer necessary to have the same level of support. Staff continue to meet regularly to plan a good transition of work.


2:25 p.m.

Something that could assist in this transition is for your board to support implementation of the employee online software. Also, during the Attorney General judgment against child welfare, we moved the social services director position to child welfare to provide direct level of support to make all the necessary changes from that judgment. I took on other supervision responsibility of benefit programs during that time. Those changes have been accomplished, so we are transitioning back to the previous structure. Programmatically, Public Guardian has been under the behavioral health program oversight for several years, but the budget has been in social services. So in this budget cycle, we are proposing to move this budget under behavioral health. For complete oversight and to strengthen other claiming mechanisms.


2:26 p.m.

These changes total $752,000 for 26-27. Also in discussions with the CAO in February, we also proposed moving Veterans Service Office back to the county since it is not a social services mandate. Since then, we've come up with a couple of other possible funding solutions for the Veterans Service Office. During that discussion, Jessica provided information around the general relief budget, having additional funding available. And so we are able to use that County General Fund portion for Veterans Service Office. And then we're also going to start claiming MAW where it's possible. We also reduced a number of contracts.


2:27 p.m.

$1.9 million just in social services for fiscal year 26-27. As your board knows, there's impacts of HR1 pretty extensive to Health and Human Services. The state has yet to put the significant additional funds in the budget. Counties will incur additional workforce costs to implement the eligibility requirements of HR1, including Medi-Cal and CalFresh. And California counties are responsible for verifying initial and continued eligibility, processing applications, and working with individuals and families to ensure they can access the safety net programs that they are eligible for, including Medi-Cal and CalFresh.


2:28 p.m.

Cal and CalFresh. HR1 requires CalFresh recipients who are subject to able-bodied adults without dependents, we call it ABOD, rules to be subject to expanded work and documentation requirements. Effective June 2026, the county eligibility workforce will be responsible for screening, verification, and engagement that is needed to comply with the HR1 CalFresh rules. Over 3,500 Humboldt County CalFresh recipients will be impacted by this change. On January 1st, 2027, HR1 requires Medi-Cal expansion enrollees and applicants to re-verify every six months instead of annually and verify exemption from the work requirements to continue receiving Medi-Cal and to re-verify eligibility every six months instead of annually. Thank you.


2:29 p.m.

The county eligibility workforce will be responsible for supporting clients in navigating these complicated new requirements. Of the more than 55,000 Humboldt County residents enrolled in Medi-Cal, over 20,000 Humboldt County residents will be impacted by the new HR1 requirements. Expanded work requirements for CalFresh, new work requirements for Medi-Cal, and increased frequency and complexity for Medi-Cal eligibility determinations, verifications, and ongoing case management will increase county eligibility workforce costs. Counties will also incur new costs to provide indigent health care to individuals who lose Medi-Cal coverage due to HR1. Counties are required by state law, welfare institution code section 17,000, to provide basic medically necessary services. Care to medically indigent lawful residents.


2:30 p.m.

Humboldt County is one of 35 rural and small counties that participate in the County Medical Services Program, or CMSP, to collectively contract with clinics and hospitals to provide this state-mandated care. County costs to provide indigent care were formally paid for with 1991 realignment funding. Under AB 85, a budget trailer bill from 2013, that funding was redirected by the state for other purposes, and the growth of those funds was significantly slowed, leaving counties without resources to serve the individuals who come to counties for services. Humboldt County will incur at least $430,851. In addition, CMSP... CMSP costs in fiscal year 27-28, likely growing in 28-29 and beyond.


2:31 p.m.

Counties assume that 33% of those who lose Medi-Cal coverage will seek care and be eligible for services from the county indigent care program. Public health has lost more than $4 million under this federal administration. First, when the Department of Government Efficiency, known as DOGE, rescinded nearly $3 million in epidemiology and laboratory funding. More than a million of which was intended to help build the new public health laboratory. Then HR1 eliminated the SNAP-Ed program, known as CalFresh Healthy Living, which took more than $250,000 in annual funding that supported the community partners, such as schools and clinics. Public health has also lost more than $180,000 in emergency and hospital preparedness funds due to the changes at the federal level. Your board has supported...


2:32 p.m.

CSAC efforts to secure additional funding for county health and human services impacts resulting from HR1. These items are included in the board's 2026 legislative platform, and we thank you for that support. We look forward to seeing the governor's May budget revision proposal and then the budget being passed. For behavioral health, behavioral health is starting to recognize increased revenue from payment reform, including increased revenue from reimbursable bed days and bedside visits at Sempervirens. We continue to have increased expenditures for mandated placement costs as the need within the community increases at approximately 1 million year over year. We continue to see ongoing staffing challenges with...


2:33 p.m.

A three-year average of 26% vacancy rate overall in behavioral health. We struggle to hire qualified and licensed staff to do some of this work. Behavioral health's mandate requires that we have a minimum level of services that meet the needs of the community. We continue to struggle with this given our staffing levels. Due to hard-to-fill positions, behavioral health is no longer providing services in the jail. WellPath has taken over the behavioral health services, so staff have been working on that transition. New initiatives continue in behavioral health. Mental Health Services Act changes to Behavioral Health Services Act has been a huge lift as the funding buckets are changing with new requirements. Changes coming to mobile crisis benefit make this benefit an optional benefit.


2:34 p.m.

benefit instead of a mandate which will reduce the funding currently available and increase behavioral health costs limiting our ability to provide those services and those are those those services that that we provide with our missed staff and and with law enforcement with the Sheriff's Department and as care court is another mandate that comes without funding and requirements we struggle with due to our staffing shortages although our care court has been implemented it seems better than most in in other counties sp43 is another change we are working through with limited staffing as this has expanded the criteria for grave disability to include those with serious substance use disorders and impacts the number of clients requiring services and and and there are no facilities


2:35 p.m.

currently to place those individuals with substance use disorder only criteria, and this will continue to be impactful to our systems. Prop 36 is also another mandate that came with no funding. Behavioral health did apply for a grant to assist in getting these services lifted, but that's not sustainable long term, and it is not an ongoing funding source and could prove challenging over time. With the impacts of HR1, behavioral health is projecting less individuals eligible for Medi-Cal, but still needing services, which will be another impact on decreased revenue in the coming years. Behavioral health does continue to look for ways to reduce expenditures and maximize billing when possible. We continue to follow required changes and seek resources with other counties facing similar challenges. We will continue to work with the state to address the challenges that we face. We will continue to work with the state to address the challenges that we face. We will continue to work with the state to address the challenges that we face. We will continue to work with the state to address the challenges that we face. We will continue to work with the state to address the challenges that we face. We will continue to work with the state to address the challenges that we face. We will continue to work with the state to address the challenges that we face. We will continue to work with the state to address the challenges that we face. We will continue to work with the state to address the challenges that we face. We will continue to work with the state to address the challenges that we face. We will continue to work with the state to address the challenges that we face. We will continue to work with the state to address the challenges that we face.


2:36 p.m.

In public health over the last few years has reduced their expenditures through program restructuring and deallocation of positions. The clinic and communicable disease programs are merging under one supervisor, now called the Communicable Disease Prevention and Response Unit budget. Several funding sources for public health ended in fiscal year 25-26. Including CalFresh Healthy Living, Mental Health Services Act, which for years funded suicide prevention education and training in the community. A smaller amount of funding from CDPH through the new Behavioral Health Services Act rules will replace the allocation public health received previously under Mental Health Services Act. And then the Advanced Molecular Detection.


2:37 p.m.

action grant that funded the design and construction plans for the new public health lab. Along with preparing their budgets for costs for of staff and program delivery, public health has been preparing for major facility improvements. This next fiscal year will include a new roof for public health main building, which is estimated to cost a million dollars, and staff will be preparing for future construction of the new public health lab. Thank you. As noted here, we're looking at double the renewals for 40% of the caseload from HR1 to our self-sufficiency programs. Currently, there are 21,374 individuals on CalFresh and 53,902 individuals on Medi-Cal. We anticipate a large...


2:38 p.m.

Expansion of CMSP. Currently our caseload for CMSP is at seven. In IHSS there's not enough funding to do the work. There are penalties for not processing timely. There are 3,114 authorized cases and 3,228 providers. The average social worker ratio for IHSS is 1 to 314. In child welfare we are continuing to hold vacant positions in child welfare except for promotional opportunities. Child welfare is currently meeting all of their mandates. We've always focused on maximizing use of federal and state funds. Per your request, we looked at mandated and non-mandated services.


2:39 p.m.

and social services. The programs listed here are the major program mandates. Our programs go through audits often, both scheduled and unscheduled. There were 30 audits in 2025 for these programs. If an audit identifies we are not meeting a mandate, for example, authorizing CalFresh cases timely per regulation, then the county receives corrective action plan. These plans require additional dedicated staff time as well as potential fines. In IHSS, counties became liable for penalties for late reassessments in specific types of IHSS cases that require a lot of caregiving hours. Beginning July 1, 2026, counties will be liable for IHSS, which is a program that is used to provide caregiving hours for IHSS. An additional penalty if the state of California loses federal Medicare.


2:40 p.m.

paid funds because of late reassessments. Corrective action plans require additional administrative time to come into compliance at the time is, oh, staffing is least available. This is a list of the non-mandated services provided. These are services that are provided to enhance services and are connected to our mandated programs. Most of these programs are claimable for reimbursement. We could choose not to do them, but based on the needs of our community, we choose to. We have always gone after every funding opportunity to better serve the community. There are some counties that choose not to do these non-mandated services and not receive the funding that's available.


2:41 p.m.

and to just do the bare minimum for health and human services. It is an administrative workload to build a program and then scale down if the funding is lost. We experienced this last year with bringing families home. Funding ended, we wound down the program, and then we had to begin again when the associations that work with us helped secure funding again. And if your board is interested in reducing these programs because they are not mandated, we should have conversations around this. I do want to say I do not recommend this based on the needs of our community. CalFresh outreach is not mandated and is claimed through our administrative allocation. And due to the lack of match funding, we have scaled back outreach services. By over 1.2 million in the proposed.


2:42 p.m.

budget in this proposed budget. CalFresh is a great example of where the lack of County General Fund and realignment is reducing DHHS's ability to claim available funding. Even before the Big Beautiful Bill increased the state portion of the match, Humboldt DHHS was underspending and underclaiming approximately $5 million due to the lack of match. If there are additional budget actions that are taken by your board this year that impact DHHS's budgets, like increased wages for staff or IHSS, this would be a good opportunity to draw down additional funds to help with that funding gap.


2:43 p.m.

Thank you. Here are our big projects that we're working on. We do need funding still for the public health lab. We also are looking at our ongoing services and how the Mad River Crisis Triage Center will help meet the needs of the community. The Navigation Center should be breaking ground this year. We've really done some really good work with Public Works and the architect for the project, so I'm feeling pretty good about that. And Sempervirens, the budgeting for the architect and other Public Works costs are included in the proposed budget for fiscal year 26-27. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. You're welcome, Eliza. And that is all we have in this holidays episode. So thank you to Lisa again for thinking about more detail and where to continue to move forward in this diabetes 빼liny campaign. And being very grateful that you've kind of prepared an opportunity for people who are up to speed and really exists in seven and eight weeks. Yeah! And it's very much a result of who you are and who you are, and able to actually make decisions about these Lauren Caldwell walking, just like that, sowe can't give a EPA lag, but we're keeping it low and sound, but we'll see how we can pull you through the campaign and how we can succeed. So that that comes along every day. So two people'd be in the first meeting. Hey, knows how to cast a etti and boost you by asking someone for help. And what they were asking, was very Ibama. If you have


2:44 p.m.

Any questions? And I apologize for the lack of pictures because I noticed that I didn't include goals and accomplishments because we, yeah, we're so focused on this darn budget. Okay, bringing it back to the board. Is there any comments? Supervisor Arroyo. Is there, I mean, the indigent care expenses going up proportionate to other programs going down is, it's sort of keeping me up. How, what are other counties, how are folks looking at that issue? Other counties with clinics and other services are probably in worse. Need than we are. There is funding available for one.


2:45 p.m.

One year is what I understand. So I'm not sure if we will see funding for CMSP in this current budget. It may be in the next budget. Jessica, do you have other information? I just wanted to clarify that currently and prior to the Affordable Care Act, we have funded the CMSP participation fees through the County General Fund, not through the Public Health Fund. Which is the $430,000, but we also need funding for the workers to do the work and to pay for services to clinics and hospitals. Supervisor Bushnell. Thank you for the updates.


2:46 p.m.

offended that there weren't pictures i know that you guys have been um i know for your staff though you wanted to highlight you know what your staff's been doing i know this budget cycle has been difficult for you and you and i've talked about that and how you've been working with the cao and jessica and really um you know coming up with ideas around what that looks like and i appreciate some of the collaborations that you've talked about that your department's doing to try to reduce costs and i think finally i just want to say that you know it's been a difficult couple years with uh change in administration and how things look for your department and having sudden funding streams cut and then having to pivot to try to figure that out it's affected a lot of people and that's difficult on everybody's fronts and i just want to say thank you to your staff and you for your continued thoughtfulness around


2:47 p.m.

all that happens with DHHS in our county. Supervisor Madrone. Well, I would say that there are pictures all around us in the community. I mean, your staff, the breadth of your department, and the programs and projects you do, we encounter every day in our communities, you know, with the help you provide in public health and behavioral health and social services, family resource centers support. I mean, on and on and on. So I see the pictures every day. So don't worry about that. I think we all are very, very aware of the incredible work that your staff do every day. And to do that work and to not bring it home and to carry that load every day for not very much pay, to be frank, is just, frankly, amazing to me. So we see you. Thank you. Thank you. All right. All right. All right. All right. All right. All right. All right. All right. All right. All right. All right. All right. All right. All right.


2:48 p.m.

I didn't miss the pictures. I actually like the numbers. So it's relevant and it has its own picture, obviously not the one we want to see. And so much of this is external to what we're doing and it's being felt by counties across the nation. It's not just California for sure. We are going to see the fallout from this very soon. And hopefully people will understand where that came from and vote accordingly. So thank you for this. And I'm not proposing to cut back on any of those programs that you were talking about there. So, yeah. I think we're ready for the next report. Thank you. Yeah, thank you. Thank your staff as well.


2:49 p.m.

Thank you. all right thank you chair and the next department we will have up as the assessor's office and assessor howard leahy is here to present all right Well, thanks for having me here today. This is my last budget I'm going through, so as most of you probably know, I will be retiring at the end of the year. But I do want to start off with thanks to Jessica over the years who have guided me through this budget process many times, same with this.


2:50 p.m.

CAO and then with the board with their support and I really appreciate it but thank you. So the assessor's office is mandated by the state of California. We are required to assess all taxable property in the county which is real property, business property, personal property such as tractors, boats, aircraft and we're also required to do a minimum of 24 audits of businesses per year. We apply the property tax exemptions where appropriate to non-profits, homeowners exemptions, disabled veterans are a few. We are the oversight of the assessor's office is the California constitution and the California revenue and taxation code and essentially the board of equalization. This requires us to to reapply


2:51 p.m.

raise when we're required to using fair and impartial reassessment per the tax laws in the state of California the board of the board of equalization they make sure that we are doing our appraisals fair and equitable and they do provide direction when we come to areas that are fuzzy and if you read tax laws a lot of it is fuzzy sometimes and so we do rely on them to for guidance many at times they do do surveys of all the counties it rotates every five years and Humboldt's been selected this year to be surveyed which is basically an audit to make sure that we're our assessment practices are within line of the state laws workload so we


2:52 p.m.

Average about between 5,000 to 6,000 recorded documents annually that we process each year. This year, this last year was about a little over 6,000. We're looking, we're seeing that trend to probably start to decline somewhat, but we're still in the 6,000 document range. For appraisals, we average about, excuse me, about 4,000 appraisals a year, basically for change of ownership, new construction, and possessory interest. And so if you're not aware what possessory interest is, it's when a private individual or company is using government-owned property. That, obviously, the government agency is not aware of that.


2:53 p.m.

taxable but the person using that property is taxable and so they we do provide assessments on those properties for personal property assessments we do about 10,000 per year right now for business properties we're doing close to that that 10,000 then about a hundred hundred and fifteen or so aircraft and about 2,400 boats that we assess annually For exemptions, right now we have a little over 21,000 homeowners exemptions that are applied to the property taxes. Other exemptions such as welfare, church, religious exemptions, there's almost 800. And for disabled veterans, right now we have about 570 of those.


2:54 p.m.

Disabled veterans exemptions have increased over the last few years. I think about five years ago we had in a neighborhood of 400 now we're up to about 571 which I think is a great program. There is some state legislation right now trying to increase that exemption for veterans so we'll see where that goes. It's come around a couple of times and trying to increase the exemption amount right now for someone who's considered low income it's right around 270,000 per year in exemption and so there there's legislation trying to do 100% for disabled veterans so we'll see where that goes. So currently with our assessed values so we're right now we're almost 18 billion in our net um um um assessed value which this year this last year was about a three and three and a half percent increase over the pricecoff Tool of Occupational Training and Social Entrepreneurs wear Designita over to millions and millions Hunting presented dois is the future um open web online and online uh google


2:55 p.m.

Our year for 26, we're looking, my projections are going to be right in that same neighborhood at about three and a half percent increase. We are starting to see some flatlining in the real estate market right now, which will have an effect on that. Current staffing, we have 27 staff, which has been reduced since 2019. We used to have about 31, 32 staff. We're down to 27. Right now, I think that's probably the minimum that we can really function to continue doing our mandated job and to keep the assessments and going through timely. Our other appraisers are required to do annually continuing education trainings every year. And so they're up to...


2:56 p.m.

They're kept up to date on current laws, assessment practices, and so on. So they're required to do that annually. Investing in the assessor's office. If you're not aware, the property taxes are the biggest revenue for the county general fund. And especially when there's sales tax decline, the property tax revenue is critical to keep the general fund afloat. The tax dollars fund public safety, schools, fire districts, county roads, library, the cities and all the special districts, and, of course, the general fund. There was a study done several years ago by the state auditor's office, and they said there was a loan grant program that included a loan grant program for the state auditor's office. Every dollar invested in the assessor's staff created about $11 revenue.


2:57 p.m.

and the general fund Talk about some of our accomplishments. Last year, like I said earlier, we completed the tax roll with about a 3.5 percent increase. We reduced our deed processing backlog. At one point, we're almost a year behind. We're down to a couple of weeks. Part of that is due that we implemented a few years ago some AI technology that helps us process the deeds. Thanks for this board approved some one-time funding for us to do that. We appreciate that it's helped not only our office, but the public as well to keep our records up to date. We've increased our e-filing, the business property statements. Right now, we're in neighborhood about 1,700 pre-filings per year. We're hoping that increases which helps efficiency for our office. I think that some of the large .


2:58 p.m.

filers, tax reps and stuff that helps them be able to do that online versus to handwrite everything like they used to in the old days. We've increased our review of Proposition 8 assessments, decline in market value, that is. A big one recently is we were able to reduce our business property statement mailings, which we do in our exemptions annually. Before, it was taking us about a month to go through that whole cycle. We've got that down to about a week and a half to two weeks, which is a huge time saving not only for our staff, but it helps the public get their documents in a more timely manner. We've also, our website was one of the first in the county of some of the other departments to be ADA compliant way before the deadline in April this year. So that was a big accomplishment for us as well. Some of the challenges. We've had some problems. We've had some staffing issues.


2:59 p.m.

used in the last couple of years. We've had about a 25% turnover rate. Many of the folks that had left was due to salary issues. They took jobs, whether within the county with higher paying positions or left the county altogether. We've lost several of the Caltrans, right away agents and other agencies and stuff. And it really makes it difficult to for productivity. When you're constantly in a training mode, so when you're constantly getting new employees, your productivity is just not there. Not that they're not good employees, they just haven't had the training to fully accept to be able to do the job on their own. Our workload, especially with staffing shortages, Prop 19 has really increased our workload. When that was passed a few years ago, when there was a parent-child transfer, we didn't have to.


3 p.m.

We didn't have to reappraise it. We just marked it on the records, and we moved on. Now we have to track all that, and we have to appraise it, even though they may qualify for that. So it's increased our workload. And, of course, just like all the other departments with the current budget issues and stuff, working as doing business is getting more expensive. And so trying to find creative ways to save money internally but still be efficient and get our job done. It's been quite a challenge. Thank you. Our the current assessor's budget about 80% of our our budget is our salaries and benefits Again, like I said earlier our staffing level we're at now Hopefully we can maintain that moving forward is I think that any reduction would be severe hardship Not only for our office, but for the county as well We are requesting a one-time additional funding from


3:01 p.m.

69,000. What we plan to do is digitize all of our property records. Right now we're old school. We have everything is hard copy and this will create more efficiency in our office. If those records are ever lost in an actual disaster, not only our office but the county would be in deep trouble because it has the records going back to the 40s and 50s and from valuation to ownership and so on. So it's critical that these are maintained and that we don't lose those. Right now, you know, just from human error sometimes they get misfiled. We go through our vast records. There's, you know, 76,000 records. We go through them every couple years to look for misfilings and we average probably about 100 misfilings. If not more every time we do that. And so this will eliminate that and you figure


3:02 p.m.

For every misfiling and if every person spent 15 minutes searching for a record add that up it adds up pretty quickly How much time and staff is his time is used on that? So that's a one-time request to do that And that's all I have any questions Right it's a good update any questions from the board Seeing none you I was just gonna comment that I appreciate that you're digitizing those records and I think that you know Sounds like a time saver in the future. So thank you. Yes No, you know what that means You're doing a great job. Yeah We really appreciate it and I appreciate the you letting us know The staffing level and and You know, I think that's a good thing to do I think that's a good thing to do Where that is relative


3:03 p.m.

what you think is needed or minimally required to get the job done. I appreciate that. We have eliminated an appraisal tech position to add another appraiser this year. We did that through the budget processes last year. So we're hoping that any backlogs we have in our current appraisal process, once they get up to speed, will be reduced dramatically as well. And it sounds like Supervisor Bushnell has something. Yeah, go ahead. Thank you. You can't. You can't. On would be good. You kind of answered my question because I have gotten some phone calls about backlogs and appraisals and how long it's taking. Yeah. And the other question was, is your short staff, is it from budget constraints or because you don't have enough qualified people applying? All of the above. Okay. We've, with the appraiser position that Paul.


3:04 p.m.

They basically have to have a bachelor's degree and they can qualify. What's really challenging is our audit appraisers. They have to have an accounting background and to find those individuals can be really challenging. And then the pay is another big piece of it. Especially someone coming out of college with an accounting degree, they can work for a CPA, for instance, and make almost twice as what the county is offering. So it's been really challenging to recruit. Today we actually have an audit appraiser who started today. This is the first time we've been fully staffed for over a year and a half. And so to answer your question about some of the appraisals, we had an appraiser just started, a real property appraiser just started a couple weeks ago. And I think she's working in some of the southern Humboldt areas. And so those unfortunately have been...


3:05 p.m.

you know, not done timely because we just didn't have the staffing to do it. Can I ask a question around how it can impact our budget with back appraisals and say a decreased amount of, um, you know, property values in Southern Humboldt are falling drastically and they were inflated because of the cannabis, um, world down there. And so how could that say, if you had an appraisal, I understand you have like a year to do, there's some mandate around that, right? Yeah. Technically, legally we have four years to, we can go back four years to, to assess something. Um, so for instance, if something was to change ownership four years ago and for, if we're just getting to it, hopefully we haven't gone that long. Um, but if we had, uh, we can, we call it escape assessments for those four years. So around that question then, because you, I anticipate that in Southern Humboldt, especially the values are.


3:06 p.m.

quite a bit lower and so then if they apply if they are due like the appraisals are lower than they get a credit or they get uh you know what could that do to our general fund budget um yes it could have a negative effect on it um if the taxes are paid in current um then any anything that was paid on a higher amount there would be a refund for the difference so yes you're correct yeah um sometimes um if we we are trying to um get to decline property decline market value for a lot of those properties and we've done we've we've addressed a lot of them i'm sure there's others we haven't gotten to yet or we don't know about yet i mean we don't have the staffing to go through 76 000 properties in the county and so if people are having they believe that they're they're being over assessed they need to go through the staffing to go through the staffing to go through the please have them contact our office right and i've been telling them that i just uh i'm glad that you haven't


3:07 p.m.

new person I would it would be could be detrimental to the budget if we get in a position where we're four years backlogged and then you know you see a lot of declining values especially in those rural properties down there and then lastly yeah congratulations on your upcoming retirement and thank you for the service that you've done for the thank you appreciate it any other questions supervisor my drums bonus before me supervisor bone well we're doing a full round she got up when you had the chance okay and just for my own knowledge when you do an assessment are they all done physically or nowadays with all the technology we have and then you have the support of what the two neighbors sold for and then you know you can get within a one-foot range of the neighborhood and you know it's really a lot of fun and you know you can if you want to go by satellite.


3:08 p.m.

whatever we um to answer your question depends um if we hadn't been out to the property in numerous years um and depending on the satellite imagery that we're we have access to um if we feel that we need to get out there to verify the the structures are on the bill on the property especially in the rural areas then we do go out there but if it's something we maybe we're out there last year and we look at the aerial hey you know everything looks nothing's really changed and it's just not really a necessity to go out there and so as long as we have sales data to support it then we can avoid having to actually go out there i'm just thinking off the top of my head if you went to 25 less places using the technology at hand it would save the mileage the the time and probably get a lot more because i know if you're going out to the rural areas and and if you're only doing one or two right thirdiling survey camera voit camera video audio certified advertisement visualization now sound sound sound sound sound sound loud background


3:09 p.m.

it gets pretty high in costs up there. We have people buying property online just because from out of state, they're just looking at it. Right. Yeah, we do do that. I mean, like I said, if we hadn't been out there for numerous years and we're not sure exactly what's there, then we would definitely need to go out there and verify it. But there's a lot of times we don't have access. We can't get on the property. We try to communicate with the property owner, and they don't respond. And so we do the best we can. And we take the information that we have, and we do the best assessment we can on it at that time. Try to be fair and as accurate as we can be with the information that we have. All right. I know this is budget hearings. Yeah, yeah. Come back to me. That's fine. Go ahead. See you, Professor.


3:10 p.m.

Madrone. Sometimes being too quiet is, although I never get in trouble when I'm quiet at any rate. Thank you. I mean, your staff and you have always been very responsive to my constituents when they've had questions or concerns or confusion over Prop 8 versus, you know, Prop 13, you know, and all the differences there. So I want to really thank you for that very responsive effort by your department. And I look forward to buying you a 7-Up to toast our achievements when we both retire at the same time. Right on. All right. Next, Supervisor Bushnell. I'm going to ask you offline. Yeah. Well, I wanted to ask about with the, you know, you guys assess cannabis cultivation sites and a lot of those sites have gone away. And so you're having to reassess, I guess. Is that the same? We don't assess cannabis in.


3:11 p.m.

directly we do not build structures but you need the structures and and tanks greenhouses water tanks and stuff like that yes we do assess that and so is that a backlog also of three to four years to get that reassessment done as the cannabis cannabis um is going away not necessarily it just depends on the area where it's located okay and if we've been there you know it's last time we've been there and so on but okay yeah thank you for that update yeah no problem all right i don't think there's any more okay i'm just gonna say that likewise uh supervisor with super madrone every time i've had a constituent that hasn't had an issue i've been really impressed with the quick response that we've received that they receive from your office and follow-up i just want to say in thorough so thank you so much all right thank you thanks positive feedback yes you you


3:12 p.m.

All right. Thank you, Howard. And the next department, as I mentioned, a slight switch up in the order here. So the next department will be the library. And we have Interim Library Director Sean Hinman here to present. Thank you. Thank you all for having me here today to speak about the library. Is this better? Thank you so much for having me here to speak about the library. I'm the interim director of library services, Sean Hinman. Just jump right in. Humboldt County Library


3:13 p.m.

Library connects communities by offering free services that strengthen our community by educating, inspiring, and connecting people. We do this through our 11 locations. These locations serve patrons as far south as Garberville, as far east as Willow Creek, and to our northern Trinidad branch. Each of these communities with its own needs, interests, and expectations regarding library services. We provide resources for lifelong learning, research, entertainment, and socialization. The library provides outreach to those who can't make it to any of its locations. And the library provides programming that serves the many different interests of all the ages and patrons all around the county. Acting as two more service points to various locations in the county, we provide mobile outreach through our bookmobile. And our library... ...at your door programs. As a small branch on wheels, the bookmobile makes...


3:14 p.m.

14 different stops in the seven days in the month that it's on the road. It travels to five geographic locations, Orleans, Van Dusen, Mato Valley, Avenue of the Giants, and Oreck. We're pretty widespread around the county with our mobile outreach and our locations. The bookmobile consistently outperforms three of our small brick-and-mortar branches, highlighting the importance of connecting with these communities further out. Our Library at Your Door service serves communities in Arcata, Fortuna, and Eureka by providing library materials to people who cannot make it out of their homes to one of our locations for whatever reason. What we do, we provide print and digital material, things like books, audio books, magazines, AV materials, internet and computer access, and access to historical and research.


3:15 p.m.

documents. We provide access to digital databases for research and learning and non-traditional items also for available for use like our library of things at the Kim Hurton Memorial Library in Hoopa. A place where you can check out tools or various cooking supplies or our telescope checkout program where you can get a little closer with the stars in our Arcadia branch. We also have an ability to provide experiences through our state parks pass program and also our partnership with the zoo to provide patrons with access to their facility. We provide outreach to community organizations, we table at events and markets, we create connections with schools through field trips and site visits and even parade attendance with our mobile outreach vehicles. Especially through the library, especially through the bookmobile, the library is able to provide outreach to schools that have no library or resources.


3:16 p.m.

that meet their needs. Some metrics we use to gauge our growth in these areas are through program attendance, checkouts, and patron registration. For this fiscal year, we're anticipating over 350,000 physical items and over 160,000 digital items available to check out to Humboldt County residents. Our program attendance, we plan to see over 21,000 individuals at our ongoing programming at all of our locations throughout the year. And at this time, we anticipate seeing about 4,400 new patrons welcomed to the library for this fiscal year. For some current accomplishments, we really want to emphasize our work with the California State Library Building Forward grant, where we were able to make some of our improvements to facilities.


3:17 p.m.

Pictured here we have our Fortuna branch where we were able to make ADA renovations in partnership with the City of Fortuna. And at our main library in Eureka, we saw some major infrastructure improvements. We replaced two failing boilers with two new efficient ones in partnership with Public Works and also a new HVAC system was installed in the library server room also in partnership with Public Works. Our Humboldt room hosted weddings for the first time in partnership with the clerk's office and some of the programs that we offer countywide. Our summer reading program, our tiny art show and story walks for exploration of spaces, literacy and engaging imagination.


3:18 p.m.

The accomplishments that we look forward to this year, we're proud to start work on our replacement of our bookmobile. This project is largely funded by the Humboldt Library Foundation and through community support. This is an example of what our vehicle will look like in the end, once fabrication is finished. As you can see, it's much more nibbler to get up through those areas like Panther Gap than our giant bus is. This vehicle, we are excited to announce this vehicle has moved into production. They are waiting on the chassis, and they'll move into fabrication right after. We're able to find some cost savings through reduction of some supply and energy use, and we'll continue to audit areas where we can find savings. For the upcoming 26-27 fiscal year, the library has submitted a balanced budget. In order to do this, the library used $350,000 to fund the library's budget.


3:19 p.m.

thousand dollars in one-time reserve funds. We are very thankful to our library foundation to increase their contributions this year by ninety five thousand five hundred and we also deallocated one FTE, a library division manager of over a hundred thirty thousand in savings. At this time, the library is exploring reduction in service hours as another cost-saving measure. We have already reduced shipping runs and streamlined our courier services to our locations, reducing the amount of times we go out to the more further outreaches, the times that we can reduce smaller drops to smaller branches that don't necessarily need them. We've reduced those from the shipping routes.


3:20 p.m.

Thank you. We are having current discussions with municipalities to evaluate dated MOUs and their support for the library and all locations are now split into individual budget units providing more transparency and a better understanding for the needs at each location. Time studies will also be conducted this year to better evaluate staffing needs at all of our locations and the major concern the library is facing is going to be a potential deficit of $350,000 in the following year. And lastly we did make an ask of $106,000 to replace our failing integrated library system. This is our system that manages all of the ingoing outgoing materials. It audits our


3:21 p.m.

thing that we have in our possession, inventories, it's the heartbeat of the library outside of the people. And with that, that is my presentation. All right. Thank you for giving that to us. Any questions? Supervisor Bushnell. Well, first of all, thank you. I know that you really did this on the fly, so I appreciate that. And, you know, there are some, you know, questions that have gone around the library's budget. And I know you've been working hard with Jessica and CAO staff to kind of see what that looks like in the future. And, you know, I hope as you settle in as interim for, you know, a while that there can, you know, that path can work well. And when we come back for budget. I was curious about the.


3:22 p.m.

So the 106,000 that you're asking for, is that system not working currently? Or you don't have that system? So currently we have a system in place. There's essentially two systems that are offered to public libraries to provide those services. And the system that we're on is what's called a self-hosted environment. We provide our servers on-site. We maintain everything. IT helps us maintain those services as well. As far as the physical equipment goes. At this time, our physical infrastructure is not capable of moving forward with this software. And so we'd like to move to a cloud-based system that would reduce the need for staff to be involved. It would also provide incredible efficiencies for training going forward. It would create more accuracy and less manual processes for library staff. Okay. And it would also be further supported by our IT department.


3:23 p.m.

Currently, they do not support any sort of Linux environment programming, so this would move it to a more Microsoft-based program that would allow them to support us further. Okay. And then I also wanted to say, you know, the library in Rio Del and Garberville and Fortuna, which are my districts, and the Bookmobile are real lifelines for those communities, and especially in Southern Humboldt where the community down there, it's very small, and there's, you know, good. I go to the library often there, and, you know, it's very well utilized by the constituents, and the people really enjoy it, and it is kind of a lifeline for folks down there. And just want to, you know, the update, and thanks to the ADA team and Fortuna, is really beautiful, and Fortuna is really loving that. So I just want to thank you for all the support that you've given us. Thank you. Thank you.


3:24 p.m.

Anybody else? Yeah. Thank you. I receive compliments often from constituents. Some of them are my family members who use the library in Southern Humboldt and in Arcata. Thank you so much. All right. We're good to go. Yeah. Thank you so much. Yeah. There you are. Thank you, Sean, and thank you, Chair. Our next department will be the Planning and Building Department, and we have Director John Ford here to present. Okay. It's a little off from the list I have here. The public defender has just moved to the end. Okay. I did. Thank you, Jessica. Good afternoon, Chair and members of the board. John Ford with the Planning and Building Department to present the budget for the Planning and Building Department. Thank you.


3:25 p.m.

I would like to thank the CAO's office, not only for their continual help, including this year, but in past years when the budget has been far more tenuous and difficult. I really appreciate the fact that they've stood by us to help us get through that. So moving directly into our budget, we do have four budget units, and I'm going to go through each one of them today. But one of the things I hope that you see is that we're really kind of trying to break down the silos, maybe not because it's the best thing to do, but it is the best thing to do from an organizational and a budget standpoint. So I'll present that. So currently we have 54 positions that are proposed. There is one. There's a new position, and that's for a code.


3:26 p.m.

enforcement manager. So overall this is really a kind of a status quo from last year. We have 46 filled which means there are eight vacant and I'll explain those momentarily. One of the things that we are doing as I mentioned is that we are moving this people around a little bit and putting them in different budget units to provide support where there is a demand and remove them from jobs where there's not as much work. So the kind of the I guess it's a periwinkle color the kind of blue is a budget unit two six two and that's the building inspection budget unit. The kind of salmon color is the code enforcement. The green is the budget unit and the blue is the budget unit. So we are moving this people around a little bit is 277 which is current planning that also currently is cannabis planning.


3:27 p.m.

and also the post-approval monitoring. The gray is long-range planning. And over to the right, we have the kind of the support team and then also the business team. But they're funded out of 277. So one of the things, and my pointer can be seen, so I'm going to kind of point this out, is up here we have a senior planner. And this is in 262. It's funded out of 277. But at the counter, we have a senior and an associate planner there. And the reason we do that is so things that come in that don't really need to go into the back and sit there for a while can be acted on right at the counter. That gives them that opportunity to do that. The yellow colors are currently vacant positions. One of the things that we currently have going on, we're not proposing it in this budget unit, but it's being...


3:28 p.m.

done right now is that we've got a planner out of 277 working with the permit team to help answer questions to actual building permit questions and that may seem a little out of place but it does give good cross training and so there's not that hard silo between a planner and the building team we also have a planner stationed in code enforcement that's the green there they're functioning as a code compliance officer and so you can see there's three vacant code compliance officers but we've moved a planner there and we're going to refill one of the other code compliance officers in the near future but that gives us the ability to take the pressure off of 277 and give aid and help


3:29 p.m.

to another budget unit. And then we've also moved two planners out of 277 and into long-range planning. One of those is a senior planner. The other is an associate planner who's actually functioning as the program coordinator, which is the yellow down at the bottom. And what that gives us the ability to do is fill those positions with existing staff while the number of current planning permits is drastically dropping. So the trends that we're facing are kind of interesting. I'll point out the building permit trends in a minute, but the building revenue is actually going up, and it's going up by a lot. And it's just an interesting dichotomy of what's going on there. Planning permit revenue is down over the last couple of years. It's gone a little bit. It's only down by 3% this year. Some of that is because there are still cannabis people who...


3:30 p.m.

who are paying their bills to keep their permits active. And so we've got that going on, but the number of permits are going down. So it's kind of difficult to predict the future with the external factors, economy, interest rates, the Canada's market. So we're being pretty conservative and using this opportunity to cross-train people. So this is the overall department budget. You can see that our revenues come in at just under $3.4 million. The budget would spend about $9.5 million, and the general fund contribution is about $6.1 million. The way budgeting is done is that our grant revenue that does pay for some of our planners, pays for some of the work that's done, doesn't show up in our budget. It shows up in the grant's budgets. And so that's what the little star is. So here's... So I'm just...


3:31 p.m.

Some things from the building division. They did almost 7,400 inspections this year. They plan checked 890 permit applications. They issued 1,783 applications. And they issued 258 stop work orders and substandard housing inspections. And then correlating that with the types of permits, 69 of those were new single family dwellings. 18 were for manufactured homes. Many of those were replacements of existing manufactured homes. And then there was 35 accessory dwelling units and junior accessory dwelling units. It says 12 new commercial. That's a little bit misplaced. That's misleading because those are not 12 new commercial buildings. Those are largely things like charging stations, telecoms.


3:32 p.m.

communication facilities, other things that are done that are stand-alone but are not new commercial buildings. There was 83 modifications to commercial buildings. The big addition is people are remodeling their existing homes. We had 600 of those permits, and you'll see on the next slide that is a substantial increase, and that number has been going up each year. We also had 247 photovoltaic applications. That won't add up to the number I presented previously because we also have reroof permits and solar permits, and those are actually done by the computer. Those are just issued online. Nobody even touches those. So here's some of the trends, and you can see new single-family residences are going down. The ADU, JEDUs have been...


3:33 p.m.

Somewhat constant, but the residential additions have gone up dramatically in the last five years. The new commercial has gone down from 2021 dramatically. The commercial remodels has been fairly constant. Manufactured homes, fairly constant. Then photovoltaic is somewhat constant, although it's gone down a little bit in the last couple of years. So one of the things or the accomplishments from 262 from building is that they did implement and maintain a digital referral process. And this made the whole referral process and permit process more efficient. The counter team processed 95 short-term rental applications. That would be to approval. And then the Xcel system is now automated and issuing communications. Right when something's done.


3:34 p.m.

The system immediately sends out an email. The goals for this coming year are to transition into the 2025 California Building Code. We're also looking to enable people to, rather than having to call in to schedule inspections, that they can get right online, choose the time that they want the inspection done, and do that online. And then the building inspectors are being equipped with tablets. So when they're out in the field, they can make real-time updates to permits and things that will feed right back into Acela. And they also see what's going on there. So this is the budget for the building division. The projected revenue is $1,700,000. The expenditures are a little under $2.8 million. And the general fund contribution is just a little bit. And that's it over.


3:35 p.m.

million dollars. The personnel are 14 within this this budget unit. So moving on to code enforcement, the code enforcement unit this year closed 108 cases, 215 new cases came in. We did perform two abatements. By the end of the year, we will have taken four properties into receivership. One of the strategies that we're currently pursuing is that we're looking at receiverships first as a first alternative to clean up the site rather than trying to pay for an abatement. And with the receivership, the thing that happens is when the property sold the county, we get our costs back immediately. So it's not taking it out and putting a lien on the property. That's a almost a real-time reimbursement. There's over a thousand active cases. And then one of the things that we're looking at is the cost of the property. We're recommending individuals live in a paid living with a way to make a return. But as a edge service is saying, if anyone on the list reported a clean over and descried theThanks.


3:36 p.m.

that has been done that is becoming helpful is that investigators, the way that cases are assigned and pursued, they've been assigned by district. So the county's been broken down into four districts and so each investigator has a district to work within. And then this is the budget. The revenue is pretty small for code enforcement. A lot of that is because with liens and things like that, you can't tell when the money's going to come back for staff expenses. The projected expenditure is about $1.6 million and the general fund contribution is just a little bit less than $1.6 million. There's eight full-time positions budgeted here. We are looking at adding a code enforcement. We are looking at adding a code enforcement. We are looking at adding a code enforcement. We are looking at adding a code enforcement. We are looking at adding a code enforcement manager. Then the objectives for this year is that as the board is aware, we are going to be able to do that. So we are going to be able to do that. So we are going to be


3:37 p.m.

We've been undertaking an organizational analysis of code enforcement. That should be done within the next budget year. And so we'll want to implement those recommendations, hire a new code enforcement manager, and allow the code enforcement unit to just become more efficient and more effective. Under current planning, the current planning has approved 170 permits. They did 820 compliance inspections. Those are largely for cannabis permits. 300 of those were not completely in compliance. One of the things that we've done is we've written letters to those folks, letting them know that they have until October of this year to come into compliance. And then at that point, we're going to start suspensions. And if that doesn't work, we'll begin revocations. We've also done 61 revocations. We've also done mining inspections.


3:38 p.m.

So the accomplishments is that we processed 213 permits to action. You'll notice that that is different than the 170 I just mentioned above. The other numbers were related to permits that were denied, largely cannabis permits. I didn't really want to say denial of a bunch of permits is an accomplishment because it doesn't feel good, but it did represent a substantial amount of work. And we've been working to reconcile the permits that are out of sync with their major S taxes. And so we're moving forward with that, as you will see tomorrow. So the objectives for current planning is to continue to prioritize housing projects. We are actively reassigning planners to other units to address workload, not only the workload in other projects, but also the workload in other projects.


3:39 p.m.

units but also the fact that there's a declining workload in current planning and it's good to have that kind of cross training. We're also going to have planners rather than having a separate permit approval team or permit monitoring team is to have them do both the compliance inspections and work on staff reports and work on administrative permits. And then we continue to become more effective using technology to do remote inspections. I think our goal this year is to do at least 50% of all permits remotely and then it's just time to clean up the legacy 2016 cannabis applications. So the current planning budget we are projecting we are projecting just a little bit over 1 million dollars as revenue.


3:40 p.m.

And then expect to spend about $3.3 million to address the things that we've got to address, which requires a general fund contribution of $2.2 million. And this is the biggest unit of the budget of the department. It's got 27 filled positions. Which brings us to long-range planning. In the last year, we were able to see the Regional Climate Action Plan adopted. We were able to see the policy for vehicle miles traveled adopted. We were able to complete the General Plan Housing Report. We were able to see the McKinley-Biltown Center zoning amendment adopted. And then we were actually able to have seven ordinances certified by the Coastal Commission. And so going into the next... Next year, we're going to continue to work...


3:41 p.m.

on coordination on a regional basis and that includes working on the King Salmon Fields Landing resiliency planning project to do a feasibility analysis to determine if there's anything that can be done to address the sea level rise there. We're also working primarily with HCOG and other entities within HCOG to do a comprehensive transit analysis of the entire county and then we also are working on a natural and working lands carbon stock inventory and feasibility study that will involve a lot of different people and professions on that. We're also working through the Humboldt Bay Area plan update that needs to be adopted this year and we've got to complete the seventh cycle of the housing element and that one of our ARPFA requests is related to doing that. We plan on doing that in-house and what we're going to accomplish that is we're moving a planner up into long range.


3:42 p.m.

planning to do that. And then we've also included within our budget funding the Regional Climate Committee Manager. That is a position that will be within the Regional Climate Committee, which may be in HCOG, it may be in RCEA, but there is an obligation from each of the jurisdictions to fund that. So we've included that money for that to county share within our budget. So this is the long-range planning budget. You can see that a lot of the money comes in from grant revenue. And then there's just work that's done within the department itself. We have five field positions. Two are related to housing and grants. Three are related to planning. We're moving one up to work on the housing element.


3:43 p.m.

And then our ARCFA is to fundamentally work on the housing element, but we're also bringing up the idea of sharing some of the work with the aviation department to do a planning study for a land use plan and economic development plan related to the airport. And so that's what that request is about. So I just kind of wanted to show we've got four basic planners. There's also a manager in here, but the first FTE is working on the housing element. The Glendale Field or Glendale, that's not Fields Landing, it's Field Brook, sorry. Glendale Field Brook plan and scenic highway designation as to kind of second and third work in the airport. In their work program, those aren't nearly going to.


3:44 p.m.

consume as much time as the housing element, but so that people stay busy. There's a primary and a secondary and a tertiary assignment so that they keep working on stuff. And then FTE2 is going to be working on implementing the Cycle 6 housing element. We've still got a number, I think about six or seven ordinances and action items that we need to do to finish off the 2019 housing element. That position is also going to be working on the rezonings associated with the general plan to implement the general plan. And then there's another change to state law that has changed to the ADE regulations that we need to update our ordinance to reflect. And then FTE3 is largely engaged with the Humboldt-Berry plan. That is a very compressed schedule at this point. And then FTE4 is working on King Salmon, Fields Landing, carbon sequestration. That's a very compressed schedule at this point.


3:45 p.m.

They're currently actively writing the low-impact camping ordinance and then a noise ordinance. And then we also want to come out with kind of an ordinance to address recreational facilities within our natural and working lands. I just probably shouldn't do this, but I thought I would, just because it's likely that these are going to be in front of the board at some level in the near future. I'm hearing a lot about addressing these issues. One is detention facilities. People are scared to death that, you know, if we approve a new warehouse, it's going to become a detention facility. And then there's a lot of talk about onshore support facilities for offshore oil and then onshore support facility for deep sea mining and then also concerned about data centers. So those are things that are floating out there. They're not on our work program. Currently, but they're likely.


3:46 p.m.

to be brought forward to see if the board wants to take a look at those. So just our path forward, really we are being budget conscious. We're working at not hiring new people. We're working at filling gaps with existing staff, even if it's cross-training from another department. Primarily the current planning and code enforcement efforts are going to be to address the backlogs that exist there to clean those things up. We continue to place a high emphasis on finding grants, and particularly grants to fund planning work, but also other work that's needed within the county. And then really the big emphasis is long-range planning to fulfill the board's strategic initiative. With that, I'd be happy to answer any questions. Sorry I went so fast. No, it's great. It was great. It was a...


3:47 p.m.

Good. All right. Supervisor Madrone. Start with you. Well, I said it earlier today with another division, another department, but wow. I mean, you know, the breadth of work in your department is just amazing. I really appreciate the reorganization work you're doing and trying to look at ways to be more efficient and always have that filler work in their box. So, yeah, maybe they're done on their primary assignment, but what's next, right? So thank you for all that, John, and I think we're very lucky to have you moving all these things forward. And, yeah, your last list, I know you said probably shouldn't do this, but it was good to do it because, yeah, the community is talking about all those things. So I don't know how we get it all done, but I appreciate all the hard work in your department. Thank you. Supervisor Bushnell. Thank you. I want to also thank you for the reorganization that's happened within the department. I know that that came out of budget. I know that that came out of budget crisis a few years ago, and you continue to look forward to it.


3:48 p.m.

ways to manage your budget within your budget appreciate that um it's for my district and for Humboldt um broadly um your staff has been very responsive I know that there's been you know uh submittal of permits are online now reduced hours closed on Friday all of those things have been in response to the budget crisis and has made it more difficult for constituents to access but I um I continue to hear how your department is responding well to um to those restricted hours and restricted times and still trying to serve the communities I encourage constituents to continually reach out email do those things which seem to be working and um lastly you know with the cannabis especially in my district it's been a lot for your department it's been a lot for the community and um


3:49 p.m.

continues forward and I think that there's a better process that has come out of that and I hear really good things about inspection processes, interaction with staff, and just really want to thank your department and know that we're always moving, trying to move forward and to better processes. Thanks. Supervisor Wright. Thank you. I know Public Works also mentioned surface or mining operations. Could you, I didn't, I realized I don't know how the work is divided. Could you speak to that briefly? We, Public Works does the mining. We do the regulatory part. So they have permits that to do the surface mining and we administer those permits and Public Works has some of those permits. Okay and then so some are held by Public Works but some are held by Public Works. Yes. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Other entities? Yes. And you, we do? Okay.


3:50 p.m.

Thank you. That's good to know. All right, on this side over here. I have just a couple of questions, and it has to do with, and again, thanks to everybody who does the everyday of what you do. Unsung heroes on helping us maintain civil society. And function, you know, and get along. And these are the, you know, you're part of that construct of how we do that and live on the land, and so I appreciate that very much. You brought up the offshore oil measure, which we took a position here on the board on that. But also, in 1988, there was Measure B that the county passed. And subs.


3:51 p.m.

there's been no action from the from the Board of Supervisors to codify measure B as was I think was directed by the vote of the people in 1988 so how hard do you think that would be to sort of get that over the over the you know the finish line to actually do what was asked of us of this in this board in 1988 I don't think the work itself is all that hard I think that you know it really just needs to I was planning on bringing that in okay and and allowing the board to say yes go and do that okay and then given a give a priority to it because really the department shouldn't just pick something up and run with it without the board saying yes go and do it okay and do you anticipate that because you're right I'm I think we are hearing at least I am hearing from folks and in really


3:52 p.m.

to the things you just mentioned which is now we're just seeing it in news feeds all over the place that in that local jurisdictions all over the country are having land use ordinances around data centers which is huge exploding all over the place and detention centers like you mentioned and so have you been looking at some of those and i'm just kind of wondering how if that comes to if that if that gets prioritized to from this board's perspective what do you think is that is that would that be a heavy lift for those i don't think those are a heavy lift it's you know the best ordinances are really clear the hardest or not hardest but critical part will just be the findings upon which it's based to take that action right okay yeah because i mean those seem fairly finite they're not broad land use issues around accessory dwelling units or noise ordinances or sign


3:53 p.m.

You know, that can just be, there's not a lot of detail that goes into defining what is a detention center and what is a data center. Right. Okay. I was just wondering about that, and I appreciate it. And I wanted to also thank you for, you know, working with the Aviation Department, but I also assume the Economic Development Department as well in terms of getting it together for doing some land use planning around our, well, specifically around the airport in McKinleyville. But I assume we could have opportunities for development, ancillary development on our other airports as well, and we should be thinking about that too. So I appreciate that. Thanks for being here. Thanks for running through this. Thanks for letting us know what's going on at this report, but also the community at large. Really appreciate it. And with that. We're going to, I think, move to the next. All right. Thank you.


3:54 p.m.

Thank you, John, and thank you, Chair. Our final presentation is from the Public Defender's Office, and we have Public Defender Luke Brownfield here to present. Thank you. Luke Brownfield, Public Defender, here to present both our Public Defender's Budget, Conflict Council's Budget, and Alternate Council Budget. I'm going to focus on Alternate Council Budget mostly because we've never done that before, or we haven't done it in 15, 20 years. The budget for the Maine Public Defender's Office and Conflict Council are pretty much staying the same. They are increased a little bit, and that's from the raises that you gave to the attorneys, and I wanted to thank you again for that. Alternate Conflict Council is something that we've been working on, working on with the CAO's office, trying to come up with.


3:55 p.m.

A plan on how to deal with the increasing costs and difficulties of finding private attorneys to take criminal cases. Right now, I think we only have two private attorneys that are willing to take criminal cases, and it's been increasing in price. So the thought is, by creating alternate counsel, we can get better representation, more consistent representation, but also save the county money in the long run. It may not save the county a lot of money right away, because they will still have quite a few cases that have already gone to private attorneys. I'm sorry, can you do a little reminder on... I understand. Conflict counsel, but can you remind me about alternate counsel? Okay. Is it like a secondary conflict counsel? It's a secondary office. So when both offices...


3:56 p.m.

have conflicts it would now go to a third office but why do conflict councils and not those offices even exist well when individuals are charged with crimes there we are constitutionally entitled to have them get legal representation ethical conflicts prevent one office from representing co-defendants in a case as well as related parties so victims witnesses adverse witnesses things like that separate defense offices are required to maintain the independent representation and confidentiality of clients and the increasing conflict cases in Humboldt County have exceeded the capacity of the two offices that we currently have like I said the increased complexity of criminal cases with body body worn camera all the video evidence as getting more difficult taking more time for each case there's also just a higher


3:57 p.m.

Volume of conflict related appointments, more co-defendant cases being charged. Once we've, you know, some of the higher profile cases that we've had lately, multiple co-defendants in that case, and then lots of witnesses that both offices have already represented. We have a limited capacity to absorb these additional conflict cases internally because we can't just put up ethical walls and still have the same staff working on these cases. That has created the heavy reliance on the private attorneys taking appointments. These private attorneys, over time, are more expensive. Oftentimes those cases go to trial, sometimes needlessly, and they oftentimes, cases last a lot longer. They're with a private attorney rather than a public attorney.


3:58 p.m.

It's also difficult to find attorneys right now for appointments, so people are sitting in jail having never seen their attorney and not knowing when an attorney will be appointed to them or come to see them and even talk about their case. Also, private attorneys are often withdrawing from cases even after they've been appointed, especially when it's a difficult client or a very complex case. So the creation of alternate counsel. This would be a third-tier indigent defense office, structurally independent from the public defender and conflict counsel office. We would change our design on how we took cases to hopefully maximize the amount of cases we can take and limit the amount of cases that would go to private attorneys. Hopefully, we're not going to be able to completely eliminate it because that just doesn't exist. But hopefully make it so that it's extremely few cases that are getting private attorneys.


3:59 p.m.

This will create a better defense system for those that are accused with crimes. It'll be more coherent, cohesive. I would still oversee the third office as well. However, maintaining the ethical walls, I couldn't get involved with the specific cases, mostly for management and things like that, not with specific case questions or motions or anything like that. So, yeah, separate case management and independent ethical structure, but still with me overseeing it. What would be the benefits of an alternate counsel? It obviously reduces the reliance on private appointed counsel, and that's probably the main benefit that the county would see. I would estimate that it's going to be a year or two until we really see the benefits of this because it's going to take time. A lot of these cases. As most everybody knows, drag on for a year more.


4 p.m.

before they see trial. So we'll still have a lot of cases that we're still paying private attorneys for. Also would expand the internal representation capacity. Now we can take more cases as a whole. Between the three cases, we'd be adding five more attorneys. We can take on all these other cases. Would improve the continuity and consistency of the representation. We would have more oversight, as right now we're just hiring private attorneys that don't really have any oversight at all, except from sometimes with the courts. It would enhance the long-term budget predictability. As we're seeing now with one particular case that's going to be very expensive that we had to hire private attorneys on, having this third office would hopefully eliminate that and we wouldn't have, if there were other high-profile cases that are going to be expensive, we should be able to handle it internally instead of hiring now. It would also support sufficient case management. And strengthens...


4:01 p.m.

The overall indigent defense infrastructure. The long term goal is to improve the county's ability to manage increasing conflict caseloads, maintain ethical and constitutional compliance, use our public resources more efficiently over time and create a more stable and sustainable indigent defense system for Humboldt County. That's a lot going on. It's a lot, yeah. I feel for you. I should add, this is a great plan. We're going to implement it. It's going to probably take a little while to implement this. Hiring five attorneys is going to be very difficult. I had a misdemeanor attorney position open for the last two and a half years. That is just getting filled on June 1st. With the turn, I think we're getting more applicants now.


4:02 p.m.

The pay raises really helped with that. So we are seeing more applicants. I think I will be able to fill it, but it's going to take some time. Also, logistically, we're going to have to find an office that's big enough to fit a whole other, you know, 12 employees. Right. Okay. Supervisors. All right. Supervisor Arroyo. I'm sorry. Did you say what the cost relationship to current expenditures was? I don't know exactly what the current expenditures. Yeah. So a couple of things there. We're estimating the alternate council budget based on the budget for conflict council. So just under $2 million. As Luke mentioned, we're not expecting that we'll get even close to that $2 million in the coming year. Well, we're. We're not expecting that.


4:03 p.m.

you know, hiring and finding a place and all of that. Our current indigent defense costs are, that range between one and a half million to two million a year as is. But as Luke mentioned, for the coming year, we will be recommending a contingency for one particular high profile case that is likely to be very expensive. And so all it takes is one case like that and it blows that budget out of the water. Yeah. Supervisor Madron. Thank you, Chair. Well, Luke, thank you for the hard work you're doing there. I appreciate trying to come up with a plan to try and long-term reduce costs because that's unattainable, you know, to keep doing what we're doing. So thank you for that. I also wanted to thank DA Eads for her cooperation in defunding three positions.


4:04 p.m.

letting those go and sharing that change not only with the DA lawyers attorneys but also yours so thank you Stacy for that incredible team effort there I know that was not easy but without it we wouldn't have had it and my sense is I mean the hope was that that would improve retention are you seeing that that's yes it definitely is well again thank you because that was a big part of it appreciate that so thanks I know you appreciate it all right well I'm just glad to see there's a plan and I know it's taken a while to sort of get there but it takes a while to make a good plan so I just want to appreciate that and I know I know there's been that transition in in relation to that so unless there's anything else


4:05 p.m.

Who wants to say to close this out? Yes. I was just going to clarify for your board that adding the alternate council office in the long term is not likely to reduce costs regularly, but make them more predictable and contain them. Right. That has value. Supervisor? Madrone. So we didn't do everything. We did a lot of departments today. Nine of them. But we have, what, four or five others still to go or more? This was optional again this year, and this is all of the departments that elected to participate. Okay. Well, I guess that's good news. I was looking at my calendar going, where is the other? And they're not there. So, hey, that's great. Certainly we'll fill that time with other important things. So thank you. Admittedly, we struggled to find a date in the month of May. It was very – it's a tight month this month. Thank you. Thank you.


4:06 p.m.

I think that's it. We are closing out for the day. It is public. Oh no. Okay. Whoa. We are not closing public motion as well. All right. All right. Right. Right. Sorry. You're right. It wasn't being was I thought it was being continued as well. So do we have public comment online? We did two seconds ago. Okay. Come on back. Come on back. If you're there. Okay. At this moment, we do not have any public comment. Oh, yeah, okay. He's gone. Well, I haven't closed the meeting yet, so there you go. Are you closing public comment? Well, I guess I will close public comment.


4:07 p.m.

Online anyone else in the room seeing none no public comment. I'll make a motion to accept the reports staff recommendations. I'll second. All right. Any objection to unanimous consent seeing none. It has been moved seconded and unanimously voted on. Thank you.