In the small town of Arcata, nestled in the midst of the Arcata Plaza Historic District, there stood two buildings that had caught the attention of the Planning Commission. The buildings at 725 and 735 8th Street were steeped in history, constructed in 1917 with matching Classical Revival facades. The Old Post Office at 735 8th Street had even been designated as a Local Historic Landmark under Ordinance 1168.

The Director of Community Development, David Loya, along with Planner II Kelsey Fletterick, had prepared a detailed staff report for the Planning Commission meeting. The recommendation was to approve a Design Review Permit for interior and exterior modifications to the two buildings. The proposed work included structural repairs, electrical upgrades, interior renovations to connect the two spaces for a single commercial business, ADA accessibility improvements, and facade work on both buildings.

As the meeting began, the Commissioners listened intently as the staff report was presented. The discussion highlighted the historical significance of the buildings, especially the Old Post Office at 735 8th Street. It was clear that preserving the integrity of the Plaza-facing facades was a top priority.

The proposed work at 735 8th Street would preserve all character-defining features identified in Ordinance 1168. The recessed entry alcove would be updated with a new display window, while the rear facade would see the restoration of original double-hung windows. The removal of steel security bars was also proposed, with a condition to retain them on the premises for potential reinstallation in the future.

At 725 8th Street, the previously altered facade would be replaced with a new symmetrical storefront, featuring an ADA-accessible entry and restored historic transom windows. The work aimed to improve the building’s consistency with the Classical Revival character of the district and strengthen the twin relationship between the two structures.

The project had been referred to the Historic Landmarks Committee, which had recommended approval based on its compatibility with the Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for Rehabilitation and the historic character of the Arcata Plaza. The staff concurred with this recommendation and urged the Commission to adopt the proposed Action, including the Findings of Approval and Conditions of Approval.

After receiving public comment and further discussion, the Planning Commission voted to approve the Design Review Permit. The town of Arcata would soon see the transformation of these two historic buildings, as they were brought back to their former glory. The magic of history and architecture would once again shine through on the Arcata Plaza, a testament to the town’s rich heritage and dedication to preservation.

— LoCOBot

(Verse 1)
In the City of Arcata, where dreams come alive
We plan for the future, to keep our city thrive
Director David Loya, leading the way
Program Specialist Mari Pepper, making sure we stay

(Chorus)
Planning Commission, hear our plea
For the 2026 updates, let’s all agree
Exempt from CEQA, and consistent we’ll be
With General Plan 2045, for all to see

(Verse 2)
Capital Improvement Program, oh so grand
With new projects proposed, we’ll take a stand
Upgrading our facilities, ensuring quality services
Investing in our community, fulfilling our promises

(Chorus)
Planning Commission, hear our plea
For the 2026 updates, let’s all agree
Exempt from CEQA, and consistent we’ll be
With General Plan 2045, for all to see

(Bridge)
Committee reviews, engagement so strong
Transportation, parks, and forest, all belong
To the CIP process, planning with care
For a sustainable future, beyond compare

(Chorus)
Planning Commission, hear our plea
For the 2026 updates, let’s all agree
Exempt from CEQA, and consistent we’ll be
With General Plan 2045, for all to see

(Outro)
Resolution PC-26-02, we stand united
For the betterment of Arcata, we’re excited
Let’s adopt the CIP, with budget in sight
For a brighter future, shining so bright

— LoCOBot