So Supervisor Rex Bohn has now abandoned his momentary effort to get the words “In God We Trust” emblazoned onto the walls of the chambers of the Humboldt County Board of Supervisors.
What was that all about? As has been widely reported, Bohn’s effort was part of nationwide movement spearheaded by a nonprofit group called “In God We Trust – America Inc.,” which was founded by a God-fearing former councilmember from the city of Bakersfield. The group’s mission statement reads, “[t]he goal of this mission is to keep God’s name in America, and acknowledge and affirm the role that faith in God plays in the public lives of the citizens in this country, and in the core values of our nation.”
According to the group’s literature, 396 local and state governments have gotten on board with this, and have festooned their meeting rooms with the holy slogan.
The first message such actions send is that the public body in question views the establishment clause of the First Amendment to the United States Constitution with disdain. But what other messages do they send? What kind of county adopts such a resolution, thereby forevermore signaling that The Almighty guides the proceedings … and also, by implication, signs off on the decisions made by the board?
An answer is available to us. The kind of county that adopts this resolution is poor, uneducated and overwhelmingly white.
In God We Trust – America, Inc. helpfully posts a document listing the 396 jurisdictions who have passed the resolution. Of these, 77 are county governments. What would we find if we considered these 77 counties as a nation of their own? What would such a nation look like?
Let’s call it God Country. As of 2012, it had an estimated population of 9,448,350 – just over 3 percent of the United States as a whole. What is God Country like?
|
United States |
God Country |
Population (2012) |
313,873,685 |
9,448,350 |
Source: USDA Population estimates for the U.S., states and counties, 2010-2013.
I. Education
The United States as a whole has nearly twice as many college graduates as high school dropouts. Grads still outnumber dropouts in the counties that have signed on to the “In God We Trust” mission, but it’s a much closer proposition.
God Country residents fail to complete both high school and college at dramatically higher rates than the country at large.
|
USA |
God Country |
Difference |
High school dropouts |
29,179,819 |
1,035,647 |
|
% dropouts |
9.3% |
11.0% |
+17.9% |
|
USA |
God Country |
Difference |
College grads |
58,205,022 |
1,241,778 |
|
% College grads |
18.5% |
13.1% |
-29.1% |
Source: USDA educational attainment for the U.S., States, and counties, 1970-2012
II. Economy
The counties that have adopted “In God We Trust” have lower median incomes, higher rates of unemployment and higher poverty rates than the country as a whole. Perhaps that’s why people tend to move away from them. God Country had a net loss of 3,774 citizens to internal (U.S.) migration between July 2011 and July 2012.
|
USA |
God Country |
Difference |
Mean household income |
$51,318 |
$45,717 |
-10.9% |
|
USA |
God Country |
Difference |
# in poverty |
48,760,123 |
646,149 |
|
Poverty rate |
15.5% |
17.4% |
+12.2% |
|
USA |
God Country |
Difference |
Labor Force |
142,469,000 |
4,342,956 |
|
Unemployed |
12,506,000 |
409,419 |
|
Unemployed/Labor Force |
8.8% |
9.4% |
+7.4% |
Sources: USDA poverty estimates for the U.S., States, and counties, 2012, Unemployment and median household income for the U.S., States, and counties, 2000-13
III. Race
Finally, it should go without saying that “In God We Trust” counties are massively less diverse than the United States of America.
|
USA |
God Country |
Difference |
White not hispanic |
195,483,640 |
7,325,021 |
|
% of total |
62.3% |
77.5% |
+24.5% |
###
If you’d like to check my work, here’s a JSON file containing the data compiled from the various sources above.