I last wrote about guns and gun control 30 years ago, in an op-ed for the Bellingham Herald. As I recall, I tried to cover all the bases, naively appealing to reason and the wise judgment of my fellow Washington State citizens. This column is not about gun control. It’s about the myth that falsely claims gun ownership increases your personal safety.
By far the most common reason cited for gun ownership is personal safety (60%), followed by hunting (36% and recreation/sport (13%)., according to this 2013 Gallup poll.
In 1993, physician-epidemiologist Arthur Kellerman et al. published a study in the New England Journal of Medicine in which they examined 388 cases of in-home homicide, concluding that households in which there was a gun were 2.7 times as likely to experience a homicide (and three-quarters of the victims knew their murderers). Because Kellerman had been largely funded by the Centers for Disease Control, the ironic result of this study was that the NRA pressured Congress into forbidding federal funds to be allocated for the study of gun violence (the 1996 Dickey amendment).
Which means there’s very little research on just how dangerous gun ownership is. What we do know, from non-CDC figures, is that:
- The odds of being murdered are between 1.6 and 3.0 times higher when the victim has access to a firearm. (2014 UCSF meta-analysis published in the Annals of Internal Medicine.) Suicides outnumber homicides about twice in the U.S. (CDC reports 2013: firearm homicides = 11,208; firearm suicides = 21,175). Many suicides are impulsive acts, and suicide odds increase 3.3 times if the individual has ready access to a firearm. (Same UCSF study as above.)
- A study published last year in Preventive Medicine (using data from the National Crime Victimization Survey, 2007-2011) found that guns almost never deter crime. In 14,000 episodes of “contact crime,” the victim of the crime threatened or attacked the perpetrator with a firearm in less than 1% of the cases; in 300 cases of sexual assault, a gun was used for self-defense not even once.
If you’ve been taken in by the NRA and/or the $50 billion/year gun industry and you own a gun for self-protection, please consider the above. The most loving thing you can do for yourself and your family is to get rid of the damn thing.