Rhonda Parker / Wednesday, Nov. 15, 2017 @ 1:57 p.m. / Courts
Judge Orders Embattled Public Defender to Answer For Attorney-Client Chaos in the Courthouse
Embattled Public Defender David Marcus has been summoned to meet privately with Judge Christopher Wilson to discuss the revolving-attorney crisis in the Public Defender’s Office.
This morning Wilson, after hearing from a disgruntled client who’s had six attorneys in under 14 months, ordered that Marcus appear in court tomorrow morning.
“Mr. Marcus needs to address this,” Wilson said, “and we’ll do it in closed session.”
Marcus was not in the courtroom when the judge issued the order.
Out-of-custody defendant Alex Lee Simpson filed a motion this morning to fire the Public Defender’s Office, saying he’s been represented by a half-dozen different lawyers. Another defendant told Wilson she’s had four.
From frequent observation, this has become par for the course in Public Defender cases. It’s common for clients to say they’ve had numerous attorneys and therefore no consistent representation.
Marcus, hired by the Board of Supervisors in February, is already the subject of a civil lawsuit challenging his qualifications. A judge is expected to rule next month on whether he is eligible for the job, which pays more than $150,000 a year.
After Marcus was hired there was a revolt in the office, with all deputy public defenders and most office staff signing letters claiming he was incompetent to handle serious criminal matters. Many of those unhappy lawyers then resigned. Marcus has hired several new attorneys to replace them.
A number of major cases have been delayed because deputy public defenders were either overwhelmed by the caseload or had to take over complex cases they knew nothing about.
Among the high-profile cases are those of murder suspect Jon David Goldberg, murder suspect Maxx Carson Robison and child-molestation suspect Chad Alan Smith. Smith and Robison were both represented by former Deputy Public Defender Jennifer Dixon, the senior attorney in the Public Defender’s Office.
Marcus did not respond to a request for comment.
- Supervisors Appoint New Public Defender After Questionable Hiring Process
- County Government Signals That it Will Stand By Its Recently Hired, Embattled Public Defender
- Humboldt County Board of Supervisors Issues Public Statement Defending Its Embattled Public Defender, Whom It Has Decided to Continue to Defend From the Public
- Defending the Defender: Judge Issues Ruling in Favor of County’s Controversial Public Defender Hire, but Victory Could Be Short-Lived
- Judge Rules Lawsuit Against Hiring of Humboldt Public Defender David Marcus Can Proceed
- Trial Date Set for Shawn Hof, Accused of Shooting at Warden
- Is Humboldt’s Public Defender Qualified for the Job? Visiting Judge Says She Will Issue a Ruling One Month From Today