RCEA’s office in Old Town Eureka. File photo.
A few months ago, an opaque PG&E fee forced Humboldt’s local energy purchaser, the Redwood Coast Energy Authority, to increase the amount it charges for electricity to its customers — and it’s set to do it again today.
The way the RCEA prices its electricity depends heavily on what PG&E charges organizations like it — “community choice aggregators” — something called a Power Charge Indifference Adjustment. Although RCEA purchases its power from elsewhere, it still delivers it with PG&E’s infrastructure, and PG&E gets to charge the alternatives a fee for using it. How it decides how much the fee will be is unknown, and how much it will increase is hard to guess. Its calculations aren’t public, and Governor Gavin Newsom vetoed a bill in September that would have forced PG&E to make them transparent, though it passed both legislative chambers with large bipartisan support.
Executive Director Beth Burks told the Outpost she was “frustrated” that Newsom had vetoed the bill. She’s hopeful a refreshed round of legislating with a new governor in charge would allow it to pass.
“In terms of how accountable I feel to my community to be transparent: to think that an organization as large as PG&E providing this service doesn’t have to do that, and gets to make decisions that are in a sort of vacuum that we don’t get to see — it’s pretty strange to me that we’re in a time that allows that,” she said.
If RCEA didn’t have to pay the fee, it would be able to charge less than PG&E, around 25% less. The fee increased 230% this year, forcing RCEA’s energy to become more expensive to customers than PG&E’s for the first time in its history.
The fee has been draining RCEA’s coffers, and the agency says if it doesn’t raise its rates, its cash reserves will drop below $26 million. At that point, RCEA may be forced to pay fees to its creditor, The Energy Authority, which it buys power from.
Most customers’ bills will rise about 5-6% a month, which comes out to $7 to $10, effective December 1. (About 90% of Humboldt County residents purchase their power from RCEA.) To offset the cost, RCEA is proposing a new program for its customers enrolled in PG&E’s cost-saving initiatives for lower-income people. Less of the electricity in this program will come from renewable sources — about half, compared to RCEA’s typical 62% — but it’ll be cheaper. Burks said it’ll take between three and five months to develop.
In the meantime, they’ll get a monthly credit that decreases their bills to standard PG&E rates. Around a quarter of RCEA’s customers are enrolled in the programs, Burks said.
Raising prices and continuing to keep four unfilled jobs open will increase earnings by $7 million this fiscal year and $11 million the next, but RCEA still estimates that it won’t make enough money to recoup expenses; it’ll earn just enough to stay above that $26 million mark, but only by about $400,000 by the end of 2027. “We’d see a much quicker decline in our reserves if we did nothing,” Burks said.
Burks said RCEA’s goal is to stabilize its prices. It’s frustrating both for them and their users when they ping-pong up and down, but the circumstances demand it.
“We are very reserved about raising rates,” Burks said. “This is not a great time of year to do it — not that it’s ever good. This isn’t what we want…The deck is stacked against us a little bit right now, and that’s very unfortunate.”
RCEA’s meeting is at 3:30 p.m. today at the Wharfinger Building.