THE ECONEWS REPORT: Project 2025 and the Environment

The EcoNews Report / Saturday, June 29, 2024 @ 10 a.m. / Environment

Special guest Rep. Jared Huffman is heading a task force in the Democratic caucus to address Project 2025, the Heritage Foundation’s policy outline for a second Trump administration. The document is pervaded by anti-science and anti-regulatory animus, with a particular focus on climate science and renewable energy.

Friends of the Eel River Conservation Director Scott Greacen goes deep into these and even darker corners of Project 2025 with Rep. Huffman. We also discuss potential implications of the six-month delay PG&E announced in filing its final license surrender application for the Eel River dams.


MORE →


HUMBOLDT HISTORY: The Bottlin’ Monroe Family! They May Have Been Indifferent Businessmen, Many of Them, But They Made Heavenly Sodas, Ciders and Vinegars

Catherine Monroe Mace / Saturday, June 29, 2024 @ 7:30 a.m. / History

Alonzo Monroe with one of his original “A. Monroe” soda bottles, left, and his son Joseph’s bottle for “Humboldt Artesian Mineral Water” right. Photos via the Humboldt Historian.

My grandfather liked to tell stories. As a child, I visited Humboldt County with my parents, and a full litany of family stories would parade through the allotted time. These stories generated an interest in history, genealogy and “old things” that has lasted my whole life.

With mostly the same few stories told, the people in them became both mythically larger than life and insubstantial as ghosts. But an old glass bottle, thick and aqua-colored, with embossed letters spelling “Monroe,” was tangible and real. I became curious about the story behind these bottles.

It begins with my great-great-grandfather, Alonzo W. Monroe, or A. Monroe as he was known in print. An entrepreneur, he made money to make more money. His enterprises were many and varied. And most came to a hard-luck end.

One enterprise that seemed successful was the Monroe House, a three-story building on the southeast corner of 2nd and E streets in Eureka, where Monroe operated a hotel, dining facility, and liquor shop, and also rented out spaces to other shopkeepers. Successful, that is, until January 3, 1876, when it burned to the ground in a spectacular and uninsured manner. His loss was estimated to be $50,000.

Undefeated, Monroe set sail to San Francisco to raise money for a new building. He came back with enough money to begin rebuilding, this time in brick. The conversations he had and the men with whom he talked in San Francisco are not recorded, but one of them must have prompted him to venture into the bottling of soda waters. As a liquor dealer at the beginning of the temperance movement, Monroe may well have considered that a venture which would move him into the temperance market would be a wise investment.

Just seven weeks after the Monroe House fire, the Daily Humboldt Times carried this prominent advertisement:

HUMBOLDT SODA WORKS!

A. Monroe & Co., Proprietors Having secured at a great cost, the necessary machinery, and secured the sole right for this county of the new patent soda bottle, we are now prepared to manufacture first-class

  • Soda
  • Sarsparilla [sic]
  • Champagne Cider
  • Bottle Ale & Porter, old stock
  • Syrups
  • Sarsparilla [sic]
  • Lemon and Gum

Which will be sold by the Gallon and warranted to be up to the Standard Weight, All orders for any of the above articles can be left at the wholesale liquor store of A. Monroe.

Patrons in the country supplied immediately on notice.

A. Monroe & Co.

###

The new brick Monroe Building opened in May 1876. During the previous four months, Monroe had been doing business at a temporary location two blocks away. In the new building, Monroe located his liquor store in one of the storefronts opening on E street, between Humboldt County Bank and Opera Alley. Along with the new sodas, he supplied wines, liquors, and whiskies from Kentucky and Virginia, and other beverages from E. Martin & Co. of San Francisco.

Monroe had installed his new soda bottling machinery at the Humboldt Brewery, Messrs. Marhoffer and Wenger, proprietors. In an 1876 article about the Humboldt Brewery, the Daily Humboldt Standard found the process of bottling the soda waters to be worthy of a sideline:

The process of bottling the soda water and sarsparilla [sic] is a very interesting one, it being done with Matthews’ Patent Bottler, and the style of stopper used is a decided improvement on the old system of cork and wire or string. The machine used for washing the bottles is an invention of recent date and is a great saver of labor.

A specialty of the company was the Monroe Champagne Cider. The recipe was secret — obtained like a franchise from someone back East. It was said that the franchise was rare and expensive, and once granted must be kept secret. How Monroe became the only purveyor of Champagne Cider on the West Coast under those requirements remains a mystery. The bubbly cider became the fashionable drink for weddings, christenings and other gala events among those in the emerging temperance movement.

Just two years after launching the bottling works, A. Monroe, age 58, began to have small strokes that progressively robbed him of his mental and physical abilities. Two of his sons were enlisted to help with the business. The oldest son, Joseph Porter Monroe, and the third-born son, young John Welton Monroe, worked in the store as well as in the bottling works. The business became A. Monroe and Son under the management of Joseph P. in June 1878. At about this time, the bottle works were moved from the Humboldt Brewery to Washington and A Streets. The old Sanborn maps show a nice residence at this location, so it may have been Joseph’s home, and the bottling works were added to his property, or vice versa.

A. Monroe died on March 20, 1882 at age 62. At this time, there was a temporary cessation of the soda bottling business.

Alonzo Monroe had not formally filed a will, but a holographic will was discovered and admitted to probate April 22, 1882. The inventory taken included an undivided one-half interest in the Soda Works, value estimated to be $400.00. His widow Anna was named executrix and directed by the deceased to “collect the income of my said property; and to sell such of my property as may be unproductive and place the proceeds at interest or otherwise invest them in productive property; and to invest and reinvest my said property and the proceeds thereof or any portion thereof as circumstances may require.” She was to use the income produced to educate the six remaining minor children, John W., included. Joseph P. was said to have previously received his share of the estate — probably the other one-half interest in the soda works.

This Monroe Soda Water box is typical of early-day soda carriers, in which the bottles were stored upside down.

###

On November 1, 1884, Joseph P. Monroe bought the undivided one-half interest in Eureka Soda Works from the estate for $1,000.00, a nice increase in value. John W., who had been working for his father in the actual manufacturing and bottling part of the business, continued to work for his brother at the bottling plant located at A and Washington Streets in Eureka.

That location, just up the hill from Flannigan and Brossman’s Bayside Lumber Company mill, allowed the addition of another product to the inventory. The steam-powered mill, needing water for its operation, had drilled a well to a depth of 175 feet in order to avoid salt water from the bay. The artesian well they got was more than adequate for their needs, although the mineral content would periodically clog the boilers.

At this time, people ingested mineral water as a cure for whatever ailed them, a practice encouraged by doctors. Joseph P. acquired the franchise to sell water from the mill’s well and sold it under the name Humboldt Artesian Mineral Water. When a the mill was running, its machinery would pump the water uphill to the bottling plant, but when the mill was not running, any Monroe sons or nephews who could be found were conscripted to operate a pump at the bottling plant.

For unknown reasons the brothers went their separate ways. In 1887, at the age of 24, John W. moved to Springville and established a new business, the Eel River Valley Soda Works on 12th Street. When Springville became Fortuna, he took the opportunity to change the name to Monroe Bottling Works, Fortuna, CA. John W. was known to have had a good memory, and must have worked at manufacturing the Champagne Cider for his father, for John W. eventually became the exclusive bottler of the popular Champagne Cider. Neither Joseph nor any of the other Monroes had the secret recipe, leading one to wonder if John chose not to share it, and if this had caused a rift between the brothers.

###

Several things came together for John W. when he moved to Fortuna. In February 1889, he married Augusta Schumacher of Garberville, and with the marriage came a connection to south-of-the-bay Humboldters and access to the thriving apple orchards there. This led his business into more apple-based products such as vinegar, apple butter and jellies along with the Champagne Cider, fruit-flavored sodas, nd sarsaparillas. The business boomed. A plant that had originally cost $3000 to construct and equip had to be enlarged and expanded.

The Eel River Advance of May 30, 1896 reported that Bert Elliott had been hired as a road representative and was increasing sales through Sonoma County and San Francisco. John Butler of San Francisco had made a specialty of advertising the products and was handling about fifty dozen cases a month. The Paciftc Vinegar and Pickle works of San Francisco used the sweet and boiled cider in their products. Ihe sweet cider was shipped in bulk as soon as it was made, so as to be received before fermentation began.

These products proved so popular in Humboldt and elsewhere along the west coast from Southern California up into Oregon that John W. brought his brother Charles Albee Monroe into the business. Charles A. had married Anna Doe of Ferndale in August 1889 and moved there. To keep up with demand, an auxiliary to John’s plant was built in Arlynda, and Charles was put in charge of it. Business continued to boom. The 1897 asked farmers not to sell their apple crop until talking to J.W. Monroe. He wanted one hundred tons of apples for the cider business.

“This success brought in another brother, Horace Perry Monroe, as an assistant to Charles. Horace’s son Perry grew up among the bottling plants. Although he was too young during the time spent there to remember much about the Arlynda plant, he was old enough to remember how his uncle John conducted the Fortuna bottling works.

###

John W. may have inherited his father’s talent for seeing an opportunity, but he also inherited the impatience for the usual business details — like bookkeeping. Perry recalled how John carried the business around in his head, transacting business on the basis of friendships and recording scant details in a little black notebook stuck in his hip pocket, with a stubby pencil from his vest. Mornings he would amble down the street in Fortuna and when he would see one of the storekeepers who carried his products, he would have a conversation, such as:

“Sam, how are you doing? Let’s see now—you must be about out of that batch of soda I brought you last week. I’d say you could use about 14 more.”

Sam would say, “OK.”

And John W. would pull out his notebook and write, “Sam 14.” That would be the extent of his business records. No one else looking over the “records” would know what Sam should get or if he should get 14 bottles or 14 cases.

When collection time came, John W. would see Sam and say, “Sam, you owe me ______.” Sam would take his word for it and pay up.

Perry recalled that the cider had a very smooth taste, but with a kick. The cider vinegar was full of pulp, unlike our grocery store vinegars, and no housewife wanted to cook without it.

John W. kept manufacturing records like he did his orders — the formulas for his sodas and the Champagne Cider were in his head. He died suddenly on November 6, 1902 at the age of forty, leaving a wife and six children to mourn him. Along with loss of a brother, the Monroe boys mourned the loss of the lucrative formula for Champagne Cider.

By May 1903, Peter Delaney, proprietor of City Soda Works in Eureka and a primary competitor to Joseph, bought a part interest in the Fortuna business. Delaney stayed in Eureka to operate City Soda Works, and left the day-to-day workings of the Fortuna plant to Horace P. One has to wonder why Joseph did not buy this share of his brother’s business. The company John built was no longer identified with the Monroe brand. Delaney changed the name to the Eel River Valley Bottling Works. The Arlynda plant was dismantled and moved to add to the Fortuna operation. But by 1907, Horace P. had given up the botthng business in favor of real estate and the law.

The Ferndale Mechanical Shop was purchased in 1904 by Monroe Cider Vinegar Co. It was originally built in 1894 by Oluf Andreasen, pictured above at far right, with his two children. 

Charles A. missed the work, or maybe the dependable income of the Arlynda cider works. In 1904, he began again under the name of Monroe Cider and Vinegar Company, Ferndale. He did not have the formula for the Champagne Cider, but he could still supply the sweet and hard ciders, vinegar and apple butter. The company purchased the Mechanical Building on North Main Street and installed bottling equipment.

Another brother, Alonzo Judson Monroe, a lawyer in Eureka, drew up the incorporation papers for the new plant. They needed capital stock of $25,000. This was sold in shares of $10 each. The first offering of stock had raised $8,500 through the sales of fifty shares each to seventeen individuals: James Giacomini, H.C. Blum, G.M. Brice, R.D. Boynton, A.H. Kausen, lames Mullady, loseph Russ, D.A. Francis, Maurice Nielson, CA. Monroe, L.P. Branstetter, lohn Mullady, Henry McDonough, Ira King, Frank Peters, Theodore Rasmussen, and Ben Marolf. The stated purpose of the corporation was written to cover aimost any viable business idea that might occur to the Monroe brothers. Charles A. was both stockholder and manager.

###

All this time, in Eureka, Joseph P. continued his successful run with sodas and mineral water. His plant moved to the 200 block of D Street. With a shrewd bit of marketing, his Humboldt Artesian Mineral Water became famous.

It happened that he sent several cases of said Mineral Water to Chicago, just to “keep the Humboldters healthy” while they promoted their fair county at the Columbian Exposition in 1893. The indefatigable Mrs. R. F. Herrick took as many items as she could to showcase Humboldt County at a booth there. And she probably entered any of the things she could in the competitions at the fair. Humboldt Mineral Water took first prize, causing “an exuberance of joy seldom awakened in the human breast by a beverage of such mild qualities.” Not to be left behind, the California Midwinter International Exposition of 1893-94 awarded the water a gold medal. It, too, acquired a San Francisco distributor, Stephen Jackson, at No. 40 Tliird Street.

An analysis of the water by Prof W. D. Johnston of Cooper Medical College gave these results in grains per imperial gallon:

  • Sodium Chloride: 32.01
  • Calcium Carbonate: 16.37
  • Magnesium: 10.37
  • Sodium: 2.45
  • Silica: 1.32
  • Alumina: .20
  • Iron Oxide: .06

and three not always included in the literature—Sulphates, Organic Matter, and Carbonic Acid. The lemon, orange and strawberry sodas, the sarsaparilla, and the lemonade manufactured by Joseph P. all contained the famous water.

By 1914, it seems like the energy of the remaining Monroes had waned. Charles sold his Ferndale building to Central Creamery Company and moved his whole cider and vinegar company to Eureka, to the E Street dock, a short distance from Joseph P’.s bottling works. Now that the two brothers were within blocks of one another, one can’t help wondering why the two brothers didn’t join in a partnership. By 1911, the City Directory no longer had them listed. Joseph P. moved his bottling operation to F Street near Humboldt Street and ran the business out of his home address for the final eleven years.

###

The year 1922 ended the era of the bottling Monroes. Joseph P. Monroe died on February 6, 1922, leaving his son to sell the remaining stock. The lawyer for the family did not even finish the business of the estate for the family. Alonzo J. Monroe died June 14, 1922. Charles A. Monroe died November 5, 1922.

A. Monroe’s final business venture had proved to be something of a success, though he wasn’t there to enjoy it: it lasted for 46 years through his sons.

###

The story above was originally printed in the Fall 2009 issue of the Humboldt Historian, a journal of the Humboldt County Historical Society. It is reprinted here with permission. The Humboldt County Historical Society is a nonprofit organization devoted to archiving, preserving and sharing Humboldt County’s rich history. You can become a member and receive a year’s worth of new issues of The Humboldt Historian at this link.



OBITUARY: Elissa Christine Henning, 1981-2024

LoCO Staff / Saturday, June 29, 2024 @ 6:56 a.m. / Obits

We are sad to announce the passing of our sister, Elissa, in Arcata on May 30, 2024. She was preceded in death by her parents Stephen and Mary Nesvold.

Elissa was a fun-loving, kind and intelligent woman who brought joy and happiness to everyone around her. She had an infectious smile and a knack for making everyone feel welcome.

Elissa graduated from Ferndale High School as the valedictorian in 1999. While attending Ferndale High she became very decorated in both athletics and academics. She then went on to Sonoma State University where she graduate with a Bachelors of Arts Degree in 2003 with honors Summa Cum Laude. Post graduation she attended Cal Poly Humboldt’s teaching credential program and afterwards she pursued her passion by substitute teaching at Ferndale High School before moving to administration at Cal Poly Humboldt.

While Elissa loved unicorns, white mochas, Taylor Swift and a good theme party, she loved spending time with her family above all else. Any opportunity to spend with her brothers and nieces filled her heart and she would take full advantage and travel distances to not miss those moments. She was a loving sister, devoted daughter and an even better aunt to her nieces.

When she wasn’t visiting family, Elissa enjoyed spending time with friends and her long time boyfriend Jason. They would attend various events such as comedy shows and concerts, and also enjoyed a night in watching movies and hang out with Jason’s children’s Cyrus and Alex.

There was nothing too small for Elissa to appreciate, whether it was getting her a coffee in the morning or just video chatting with her on a Sunday. She expressed her gratitude like no other, her excitement and enthusiasm was one of a kind and something people close to her will never forget.

She is survived by her siblings and father: Justin Mattly (Jessica), Chris Nesvold (Lea), Alex Nesvold (Melissa), Trevor Nesvold (Lea), nieces Skylar Mattly, Finley and Kary-Lynn Nesvold, Father Bill Mclaughlin (Jeanette).

A celebration of life will be held on:

August 3, 2024 at 11 a.m.
Ferndale Firemen’s Pavilion
100 Berding St
Ferndale California

Please wear something fun and colorful or anything: unicorn, crocs or Taylor Swift. She would have wanted a happy colorful event in her honor.

###

The obituary above was submitted on behalf of Elissa Henning’s loved ones. The Lost Coast Outpost runs obituaries of Humboldt County residents at no charge. See guidelines here.



Humboldt Bay Fire Says a Sad Koebaai to Outgoing Chief Sean Robertson; Issues a Hearty Howzit? to Incoming Chief Tim Citro

LoCO Staff / Friday, June 28, 2024 @ 4:11 p.m. / Local Government

Citro (left) and Robertson (mustache). Photo: Humboldt Bay Fire.


Press release from Humboldt Bay Fire:

Humboldt Bay Fire Joint Powers Authority Fire Chief Sean Robertson has announced his retirement beginning December 30, 2024.

Beginning his career as a Volunteer Firefighter in Arcata, Robertson quickly proved himself to be a reliable and skilled professional. Over the past 26 years, his extensive experience and deep knowledge have made him an invaluable asset to Humboldt Bay Fire, Eureka Fire Department, Humboldt No. 1 Fire Protection District, and the community he serves. His tenure has been defined by exemplary leadership, consistently going above and beyond to ensure the safety and well-being of the community while effectively guiding Humboldt Bay Fire.

Humboldt Bay Firefighters Local 652 President Brandon Harlander stated, “Chief Robertson has demonstrated unwavering support for labor rights, creating a collaborative environment that values the contributions of every member of Humboldt Bay Firefighters Local 652. His leadership embodies unity and strength, safeguarding our community with resolve and compassion. We thank Chief Robertson for his exceptional leadership and unwavering commitment to HBFL 652 and Humboldt Bay Fire. We are excited about his upcoming work at College of the Redwoods and are confident that it will further support and enhance the foundation that Chief Robertson and Union leadership have established.”

Sean Robertson stands as a paragon of dedication, leadership, and service. His contributions have left an indelible mark on Humboldt Bay Fire. As he continues his journey, Sean’s legacy will inspire future generations of firefighters and community members, as he becomes the Assistant Professor in Fire Technology at College of the Redwoods. Chief Robertson will be instrumental in developing and maintaining the Fire Technology curriculum, with the goal of achieving State Fire Training accreditation for the current fire academy.“Chief Robertson was appointed Fire Chief by the JPA Board in 2018 and has led the JPA through challenging times, including the Covid pandemic and severe staffing shortages. His strategic planning, department-building efforts, and the strong relationships he has fostered have established a solid foundation for ongoing success. While we will miss Sean and his remarkable leadership, we are excited for him and his future endeavors. We are confident that the organization will continue to move in a positive direction under Tim Citro’s leadership. Chief Citro, with his strong ties to the community and extensive experience working alongside Chief Robertson, has the full confidence of the Board to lead Humboldt Bay Fire effectively into the future,” said Humboldt Bay Fire Board of Directors Chair Jo Wattle.

Humboldt Bay Fire Board of Directors has selected Battalion Chief Tim Citro as the new Fire Chief, succeeding Fire Chief Sean Robertson. Citro will serve as Interim Fire Chief from September 1 through December 29 and will assume the role of Fire Chief starting December 30.

Battalion Chief Citro brings over 30 years of Fire and EMS experience, beginning his career at the age of 14 as a Fire Explorer and Reserve Firefighter with the Healdsburg Fire Department. He later relocated to Humboldt County to attend Cal Poly Humboldt, where he joined the Arcata Volunteer Fire Department. After earning his degree, he worked for City Ambulance of Eureka as an EMT-1 and completed his Paramedic training.

In 1999, he was hired as a Firefighter/Paramedic with the Peninsula Fire District in Lake Almanor, California. A year later, he joined Humboldt No. 1 Fire Protection District, where he has dedicated 25 years, serving in various roles, including Firefighter, Engineer, Captain, Captain/Duty Officer, and Battalion Chief. Citro holds a Bachelor of Arts degree in Geography with a Minor in Geology from Cal Poly Humboldt. He is certified by the California State Board of Fire Services as a Fire Officer and Chief Officer, is a California Licensed Paramedic, and is a graduate of the National Fire Academy’s Executive Fire Officer Program. He has been married to his wife Lauri for 26 years, and they have two adult daughters, Molly and Allissa. He enjoys spending time with his family, traveling, and playing golf in his free time.

“I’m excited for the opportunity to lead the men and women of Humboldt Bay Fire as the next Fire Chief,” Citro said. “I am committed to ensuring that Humboldt Bay Fire continues to add value to the community and improve the quality of life for our customers by delivering the highest level of EMS, Rescue, and Fire services.”

Humboldt Bay Fire extends its heartfelt gratitude to Chief Sean Robertson for his 26 years of exemplary service. His leadership and commitment have significantly shaped the department, and we wish him all the best in his retirement. Chief Robertson “Would like to deeply thank Humboldt Bay Fire for the great privilege and honor of leading and working with such an incredible group of people who inspired me every day through their dedication, professionalism, and commitment to making our community a better place.”




Your Humboldt Summer Can Now Include Trips to Freshwater County Park, Which is Open for the Season

LoCO Staff / Friday, June 28, 2024 @ 1:53 p.m. / Nature

Humboldt County Department of Public Works release:

The Environmental Services Division of the Humboldt County Public Works Department is excited to announce that the swimming area at Freshwater County Park is ready to be enjoyed following installation of the seasonal dam on Freshwater Creek. The dam is expected to stay installed through Labor Day, Monday, Sept. 2 and will be removed prior to the winter wet season.

Hours of Operation

Freshwater Park is open from sunrise to sunset for a day-use fee of $5 per vehicle, or $2 for walk-ins or bike-ins. Annual passes are available for purchase for $45 at the gate house. In addition to the swimming area, amenities at Freshwater Park include an Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) accessible playground, volleyball court, restroom and picnic areas. Parking is available subject to vehicle limits. The Freshwater Park gazebo area is open for group reservations through Saturday, Nov. 30. To make a gazebo reservation, please call 707-445-7651.

Tips for Visiting

The water in the Freshwater Park swimming area is cold, so visitors should prepare accordingly. For the safety of the public, please not use alcohol or drugs, including some prescription drugs, before swimming at Freshwater Park. Small children and inexperienced swimmers should wear a U.S. Coast Guard-approved life jacket or flotation device while swimming. The use of water wings is not recommended for small children.

Park visitors are asked to be courteous to other people at the park and respectful of the wildlife and plant communities. Dogs are not allowed due to the high density of park visitors. Camping, motorcycles, fires and firearms are prohibited.

About the Freshwater Park Swimming Area

Freshwater Park is an eight-acre county park located approximately seven miles from Eureka, at 3100 Freshwater Rd., approximately 3.5 miles southeast of Myrtle Ave. The County of Humboldt has owned and operated Freshwater Park since 1939. Freshwater Creek meanders through the park, and the park’s main attraction during the summer is a swimming area created by a seasonal dam, which has been installed most summers since the 1920s.

Freshwater Creek drains into Humboldt Bay via Eureka Slough and provides productive habitat for salmon and steelhead. Upon installation of the seasonal dam, the pool provides deep, cold water that is an ideal environment for juvenile fish. A concrete fish ladder allows juvenile fish to move freely upstream and downstream of the dam when inflows are sufficient. The concrete fish ladder is adjacent to the dam and viewable by the public.

After several weeks of work by the Humboldt County Parks Division to remove sediment from the fish ladder, removable I-beams and flashboard panels are installed with a crane to form the seasonal dam. The Department of Public Works would like to thank the Humboldt County Roads Bridge Crew, California Department of Fish and Wildlife and the Humboldt County Sheriff’s Work Alternative Program for their tremendous work and partnership to safely install the dam this year.

For more information on Humboldt County parks and trails, please visit the Parks and Trails webpage or call 707-445-7651.



In Its Final Report of the Year, Grand Jury Concludes That the Child Welfare Services Ombudsperson is Falling Short of the Role Defined For it When the County Settled a Big State Lawsuit

Hank Sims / Friday, June 28, 2024 @ 11:17 a.m. / Local Government

This was a solid and very substantive year for the Humboldt County Civil Grand Jury. It ends with an investigation into the Office of the Ombudsperson at the county’s Child Welfare Services office, a division of the county’s Department of Health and Human Services.

The Office of the Ombusdperson was created in 2018 to settle a lawsuit brought against the county by then-California Attorney General Kamala Harris, and the conclusion of this Grand Jury investigation, which you should read in full, is damning:

The Humboldt County Civil Grand Jury concludes that the Child Welfare Services Office of the Ombudsperson does not fulfill its stated mission and instead serves as an ineffective complaint department. By directing the Ombudsperson to not provide resolutions to complainants, management consistently violates CWS Policies & Procedures, and contradicts the 2018 stipulated agreement. The Office of the Ombudsperson is not independent in any way, and the very structure of the office provides opportunities for conflicts of interests.

This was only one of several meaty reports the GJ released this year.

On behalf of the citizens of Humboldt County: Thank you for your service, 2023-24 Grand Jury members. Full list of reports below. If you’re inspired by this work and you have time on your hands, consider putting your name in for the 2024-25 Grand Jury. They need good people. 

###

DOCUMENT:

PREVIOUSLY:

###

Press release from the Humboldt County Civil Grand Jury:

The Humboldt County Civil Grand Jury has released the eighth and final report of their 2023-2024 term, entitled “Child Welfare Services: Office of the Ombudsperson.”

In 2023 the Humboldt County Civil Grand Jury received a complaint regarding Child Welfare Services (CWS), a branch of the Humboldt County Department of Health and Human Services. Among several other issues, the complainant told us that after contacting the CWS Office of the Ombudsperson to lodge a complaint and receive assistance, they never received a reply. The Humboldt County CWS Office of the Ombudsperson was created in 2018 as part of a legal settlement with the State of California that required CWS to establish a complaint office to give a voice to families involved in the Child Welfare Services system.

We investigated the current state of this office and found that it does not follow through on promises made on the CWS website and that current practices violate CWS’s own policies. We found that CWS regularly refers to the Office of the Ombudsperson as “independent” but that in reality it is intricately woven into the CWS structure. We found that CWS is good at keeping records about complaints received but does not provide information about complaint outcomes involving violations of policy, procedure, or civil rights. Moreover, we found that the public has no way to know if these violations have been addressed, individually or systemically.

Crucially, we found that many people who make complaints never learn the outcomes of their complaints from CWS. These complainants are people in difficult situations. They may be at risk of losing their children, may have seen their children be abused by others, or may be abusers themselves. Whatever the case, they contact CWS to find answers, instead finding silence. Our conclusion is that CWS has an Office of the Ombudsperson in name only.

The 2023-2024 term of the Humboldt County Civil Grand Jury comes to a close on June 30. We would like to say “thank you” to the hundreds of people who helped us this year, in all ways, large and small. Without you the Civil Grand Jury, your jury, couldn’t do the work we do.The 2024-2025 term for the Civil Grand Jury is approaching quickly. The Superior Court, of which the Grand Jury is an arm, is in desperate need of jurors. This is a very enriching experience and gives you a chance to learn about and give back to your community.

The time commitment is, at minimum, six hours a week, three hours via a Zoom meeting and three hours at an in-person meeting in Eureka. Later in the term more hours are needed but for the most part these extra commitments can work around your schedule. There is a small stipend (equal to $20 per seven hours) and mileage to and from meetings and interviews are paid for. Applications to serve on the Humboldt County Civil Grand Jury can be found at this link. Additional information provided by the Civil Grand Jurors Association of California can be found at this link.

###

THE 2024 HUMBOLDT COUNTY CIVIL GRAND JURY:



Manila Home Consumed By Fire Last Night; Structure Destroyed, Dogs Perish, Cause Unknown, Says Arcata Fire District

LoCO Staff / Friday, June 28, 2024 @ 8:24 a.m. / Fire

Manila fire. Photo: Arcata Fire District.

Press release from the Arcata Fire District:

On Thursday, June 27 at 11:30 P.M., units from Arcata Fire District, Humboldt Bay Fire Authority, and Westhaven Volunteer Fire Department responded to a reported structure fire (barn on fire) on the 100 Block of Wagon Jack Lane off Fickle Hill Road in Arcata.

The first arriving Arcata Fire unit found a fully involved 20 foot by 30 foot barn. The residents of the property indicated that there were no people inside the building. The structure had already collapsed before fire personnel arrived. Firefighters engaged in a defensive operation, protecting nearby residences.

While fighting this fire, Arcata Fire District, Samoa Fire Protection District, and Humboldt Bay Fire Authority were dispatched to a reported residential structure fire in the Manila area. Some units involved in the barn fire on Fickle Hill were immediately released and responded to the residential fire in Manila.

Samoa Fire Protection District arrived on scene first and reported a fully involved manufactured home with the occupants outside. Humboldt Bay Fire and Arcata Fire District units arrived next and secured a water supply. Units protected nearby structures from radiant heat from the now collapsed manufactured home. While fighting the fire, personnel were advised that the occupant of the home was suffering from smoke inhalation. An ambulance was requested to the scene. Fire personnel rendered aid and evaluated the patient. The patient denied any additional medical treatment. As fire personnel got the fire under control, the scene was investigated for the cause.

During the investigation, firefighters learned that the occupant’s dogs had alerted him to the fire that had started in the kitchen area. The occupant was able to get out, however, his dogs were not and perished in the blaze.

Due to the extent of the damage at both fires, investigators were unable to determine a precise cause for either fire.

Both structure fires were total losses. The estimated loss to the barn on Fickle Hill is approximately $40,000. The loss to the residence in Manila was approximately $90,000. Arcata Fire District extends our thoughts to both families for the losses they suffered as fires can be emotionally traumatic- especially with the loss of pets. Smoke alarms are the best way to be alerted to a fire, allowing occupants to escape.

Thank you to our allied partners Samoa Fire District, Humboldt Bay Fire Authority and Westhaven Volunteer Fire Department who responded to both fires.

###
UPDATE:
A GoFundMe for the victim has been set up here.