OBITUARY: Rachel Marie (Bozarth) Plympton, 1967-2022

LoCO Staff / Tuesday, Nov. 8, 2022 @ 6:56 a.m. / Obits

Rachel Marie (Bozarth) Plympton, age 54, of Eureka, passed away October 4, 2022, in her home after a hard battle with ALS.

Rachel was born November 23, 1967, and attended public schools, graduating from Foothill High School in Bakersfield in 1985. She went on to attend San Joaquin Valley College, where she graduated with a certificate in Business and Technology in 1988. Bakersfield was her hometown and she lived there until May 23, 2012, settling in Humboldt County. She received an Associate of Arts degree from College of the Redwoods in Eureka and wanted to continue her education at CalPoly Humboldt but got sick. She received straight As in school, even while working and parenting.

Rachel worked in human services in Humboldt County, eventually retiring from the Humboldt County Department of Health and Human Services as a Deputy Public Guardian/ Conservator. Before that, she worked in Adult Protective Services and Social Service Aid. She also worked at Redwood Adult and Teen Challenge. She became an ordained minister and considered that one of her greatest achievements. Many of the students she worked with at RATC called her “Rev Rachel,” short for “Reverend Rachel.”

Rachel loved life and lived it joyfully. She was involved in church and was a member at the Elks Lodge. On January 14, 2021, she married her husband, Greg Plympton. She enjoyed doing everything with him from traveling to riding their motorcycles. She loved her Harley! Greg and Rachel’s last cross-country trip together was an eight-month voyage in their RV coach. She called it “the longest honeymoon ever.” Together they saw the Statue of Liberty, the Mississippi River, the 911 Memorial, the Liberty Bell and more. They revisited Louisiana—one of her favorite places—and she even fulfilled a dream of hers by attending the Grand Ole Opry in Tennessee.

Rachel Plympton is survived by her husband Greg Plympton; children Anthony Burns, James Feemster, Patricia Burns (and Harley Fontaine) and Jack Burns; mother Donna Langley; stepson Joshua Plympton; daughter-in-love Erin Andrade and eight grandchildren. Those grandchildren are A.J., Paislei, Travis, Carmela, Mia, Ember, Lillynne, and Peyton. She is also survived by her sister Diana Messerschmidt, brother-in-law and sister-in-law Dave and Rebecca Grimm, nephews Scott Worthen and Daniel Patchin, aunts, uncles, cousins and many friends. She was preceded in death by her father Christopher Howard Bozarth, her grandson Jaxson Burns and her stepson Justin Plympton.

A memorial service for Rachel is to be held November 12, 2022, at 1 p.m. at the Eureka First Baptist Church. The church is located at 422 Del Norte Street in Eureka. A reception will follow the service.

In lieu of flowers, donations in Rachel’s memory can be sent to Redwood Adult and Teen Challenge, 1435 7th Street, Eureka, California, 95501.

###

The obituary above was submitted on behalf of Rachel Plympton’s loved onesThe Lost Coast Outpost runs obituaries of Humboldt County residents at no charge. See guidelines here. Email news@lostcoastoutpost.com.


MORE →


OBITUARY: Bearl Teasley, 1936-2022

LoCO Staff / Tuesday, Nov. 8, 2022 @ 6:56 a.m. / Obits

Bearl Teasley passed away on October 16 in Rio Dell at the age of 86.

He was a long-time employee of the Pacific Lumber Company, where he retired. While working for PL he lived in Scotia and then moved to Fortuna after retiring, and then to Rio Dell this year where he passed away peacefully.

He also had a wood toy business that saw his toys shipped around the world and you can find many of them still around.

Bearl was well liked in the community and would be the first to volunteer if anyone needed help. He is now back in the loving arms of his wife, Joyce, and in the presence of God. He will forever be in our hearts and will be missed.

He was preceded in death by his wife, Joyce. He is survived by his three sons — Ken, Keith, Mike — and their families.

You can celebrate his life by making a donation to a Alzheimer or cancer charity. Plans for a celebration of his life will be announced when information is available.

###

The obituary above was submitted on behalf of Bearl Teasley’s loved onesThe Lost Coast Outpost runs obituaries of Humboldt County residents at no charge. See guidelines here. Email news@lostcoastoutpost.com.



Hundreds of Eureka High Students Stage Walkout in Support of Beloved Administrator, and They Say His Departure is Part of a Troubling Trend

Ryan Burns / Monday, Nov. 7, 2022 @ 5:08 p.m. / Activism , Education

Photos and video: Andrew Goff

###

At 11:20 Monday morning, roughly 300 Eureka High School students walked out of class and marched up the block to the district administration building, where they proceeded to shout chants and hold up banners in support of a departed administrator.

“We want Ed! We want Ed! We want Ed!” the students chanted in unison.

By all accounts, Ed Sonia forged deep personal bonds with many students in his role as Eureka City Schools athletic director, overseeing more than 70 coaches, 40 volunteers and about 40 percent of the student bodies at Eureka High, Winship Middle School and Zane Middle School. He was also serving as an assistant principal at Eureka High, and in a phone conversation this afternoon he said he was simply spread too thin.

“We had a couple of administrators leave — there’s been a lot of movement [among] the admin team at Eureka High, and I took on a lot of the workload,” Sonia said.

He added that he had informed Interim Eureka High School Principal Rob Standish and other administrators about his dissatisfaction.

I’d gone in to my administration before and told them I was overloaded,” he said. “My principal knew that this was coming to a head. I could only take so much.”

While the administration may not have been surprised at Sonia’s move, the students who walked out today didn’t see it coming.

“We are all very heartbroken,” Eureka High senior Moriah Bowles told the Outpost during today’s protest. “Ed was not only a member of our staff but he was a friend. He was a very close friend.”


Bowles and other students said this is just the latest development in a larger trend of educators and administrators leaving the district for one reason or another. Former teacher and athletic director Kristina Christiansen, for example, stepped down under duress last year after more than two decades at Eureka High. She is now suing Eureka City Schools for harassment, a hostile work environment, sexual discrimination and retaliation.

Other administrators, including former assistant principal Angela Shull and former Eureka High principal Jennifer Johnson, recently left the district Eureka High in favor of other jobs in the area.

“We’ve already had two athletic directors leave — and coaches. We’ve had so many coaches leave because of the treatment,” Bowles said. “And we’re tired of it.”

Leah Gee, a former district employee and mother of a Eureka High student, attended today’s protest, and she said these departures are symptomatic of larger problems in the district.

“We’re not losing people because of the teacher and educator crisis or them burning out on the job,” Gee said. “They’re burning out on the district.”

She blames Superintendent Fred Van Vleck and the district’s board of trustees, which is charged with overseeing him.

“Fred Van Vleck needs to go,” Gee said. “Nobody is checking him. There’s no checks and balances.”

The protesting students swarmed the sidewalk outside the administration building. Several held brightly colored protest signs on butcher paper while others clutched smaller signs hand-lettered on colorful office sheets. 

“What is the common denom?” one sign read.

“Why 2 athletic directors in 1 year?” another asked.

Yet another read, “Why are good people leaving our district?”

Other messages included, “When is enough?” “Fix our environment” and “Take responsibility for your actions.”

The Outpost walked into the administration office during the protest in search of Van Vleck, but we were told by front office staff that he was not available at the time. When we reached out later via email he referred us to Standish, who we spoke to on the phone this afternoon.

“I can say that although I’m proud of the passion our students have for educators, Mr. Sonia resigned of his own accord,” Standish said. “I’ll be acting as interim athletic director as we search for a replacement, and I’ll be doing my best to make sure the sports programs can continue uninterrupted with the help of our amazing coaches and staff.” 

Asked about the larger trend of departures from the district, Standish said, “I really can’t speculate on that.”

At the protest, Eureka High senior Sidney Madsen said she worked directly with Sonia in her role on the Student Advisory Council, which helps to make decisions for the Humboldt-Del Norte (HDN) High School Sports League. 

“And it really hurt that he had to resign because I know that he cares so, so much for his students,” Madsen said. “He would always pull me aside; he would always make a point every single day or every other day to tell me, like, how good I’m doing and how much I mean to him.

Today’s demonstration was a way to return the favor, she said. 

“He cared so much about these kids and his job. Getting no support from the D.O. [district office] really took a toll on him.”

Fellow senior Amaya Gee (Leah Gee’s daughter) agreed, saying Sonia was just “a really cool dude.”

“We just bonded, I guess,” Gee said. She, too, brought up the departure of numerous coaches and teachers from the district.  “And I think this last one really impacted everybody because Ed cared so much about everybody. I think he impacted not only just us but also the parents. He did a lot for our school. I don’t think [the administration] knew how much Ed impacted our school and how much he did for us.”

A few adults stood across the street watching the protest. One, licensed psychologist Michael Morris, said he’d been working with Sonia to incorporate sports psychology into Eureka High’s sports programs.

“Ed just gets it, that we’re here to mentor these young people, that it’s beyond the sport,” Morris said. “These sports are more vehicles for mentoring young people to become these positive members of our society, and he got that. It’s just, it’s such a big loss not to have him anymore. I’m just heartbroken.”

Will Zerlang, a local contractor and parent of an EHS student, said he stepped in to become the coach of the school’s cross country team this year, and he agreed that this is a big deal. 

“Losing Ed obviously is a huge loss for the students because the students love Ed,” Zerlang said. The EHS cross-country won the HDN championship this past weekend, after the squad learned of Sonia’s departure, and Zerlang said they ran for him. He also said Sonia was a huge help to him in his first year of coaching, and his sudden absence complicates the team’s future.

“On the 19th we’re supposed to go take three vans down and rent six hotel rooms [for a competition],” Zerlang said. “Ed was the one who was going to make that happen for me. Now I’ve got to figure out how to [do it].”

Standish sought to reassure people who may be concerned.

“I very much want the public to know that we’re going to continue to work very hard to make sure students have access to athletic endeavors and we’ll support them through that,” he said.

As fall sports come to an end and spring sports ramp up, this is a very busy time for athletics, and Standish said he’s had an “an overwhelming amount of support from coaches as we work through and make sure these programs continue. That’s really what’s important to me right now, keeping them taken care of.”

About 20 minutes into the protest, after the students had marched around the block, they revived their chants of “We want Ed!” A few minutes later, they changed the refrain to “No more Fred! No more Fred! No more Fred!”

On Friday, Standish announced Sonia’s departure with an all-EHS-staff email that began with this: 

I am writing today to announce our Athletic Director and Assisant [sic] Principal Ed Sonia has let me know he no longer has the passion to finish the school year in this postion [sic] and has resigned effective immediatly [sic].  This is unfortuante [sic], but we are appreciative of the work Ed has done.

Sonia said the claim that he has lost his passion is patently false. 

“I never said that,” he told the Outpost. “Every person on that campus knows that’s not true. That’s the opposite of me. My passion for those kids and that department … .” He paused, trying to find the words. “It’s extensive, to say the least.”

Sonia said he didn’t work for the district long enough to address the larger trend of departures, but he feels today’s protest wasn’t all about him

“I think this is much bigger than myself,” he said. “This is maybe the tipping point, I get that. It just happens to be this way because of how I connect with my kids. It just shows I poured my heart into our kids and my programs. It feels good to see it didn’t go unnoticed by the people who mean the most.”

Namely, the students. Below are more photos from today’s protest.

(Click photos to enlarge)





The Last-Minute Voter’s Guide to Actually Filling Out and Turning in Your Damn Ballot!

Hank Sims / Monday, Nov. 7, 2022 @ 2:01 p.m. / Elections

“Voting,” according to the DALL-E artificial intelligence image generator.

Hey, you. Pssssst. Election Day is tomorrow. Remember? It’s getting down to the wire, here. And you haven’t turned in your ballot yet.

So you’re a lazy-ass procrastinator. That’s OK! You’re in fine company. The important thing is to get on it ASAP. Really. Your good friend LoCO is here to help. For the sake of argument, we’re going to assume that you fall into one or both of two categories: People who don’t know how to turn in their vote-by-mail ballot and people who aren’t sure how they should vote.

How do I turn in my ballot?

The very easiest thing to do is just to drop that sucker in the mail! But, careful – you have to make sure that it’s postmarked on or before Election Day! So if you mail it today (Monday), you shouldn’t have a problem. But if you want to mail it tomorrow (Tuesday), you want to make sure that it gets there early enough for the post office people to put that stamp on it! To be safe, take it directly to the post office and put it in their hands.

Alternatively, you can drop your ballot off at any of the county’s 36 polling places – here’s a list – or at one of the drop boxes – here’s that list — or at Elections Office HQ. That’s at 2426 Sixth Street, Eureka.

Lost your vote-by-mail ballot? Then what you’ll want to do is head to your local polling place – here’s that list again – and request a provisional ballot. They’ll set you up.

Who do I vote for?

We’re not going to tell you who to vote for! But we are going to give you some resources to help you figure out who/what you want to vote for.

First: For all those statewide races and propositions, we highly recommend the incredibly useful 2022 Voter’s Guide put together by our friends at CalMatters. This is the home of the “Propositions in a Minute” series of videos so many of you appreciate, and they’ve also got a bunch of stuff on the Governor’s race, and the Secretary of State race, and the race for Attorney General, and etc., etc. They even have the Supreme Court applicants on there. (Though not, alas, the appellate judges. You’re kind of on your own, there, I’m afraid.)

For your local candidates and measures: First of all, you want to check the voter information guide that was mailed to you. (Didn’t get one? You can request an online version here.) That’s going to contain all your official candidate statements and arguments for and against measures.

Second of all: LoCO Elections! Most candidates in most of the most important races have been patiently answering readers’ questions, and you can review those answers at this link.

Third of all: The KEET-TV League of Women Voters candidate forums! You can find recordings of all those great events at this link. Scroll through to find the one you’re looking for.

Fourth of all: If you’re on Facebook, take a scroll through the candidate interviews conducted by Friend o’ the LoCO and Eurovision Song Contest expert John Kennedy O’Connor.

Okay!

You now know as much as you’re ever going to know! Get on it!



Rural Ranchers Face $4,000 Proposed Fine for Violating State Drought Order

Rachel Becker / Monday, Nov. 7, 2022 @ 1:17 p.m. / Sacramento

Jim Scala is a third-generation rancher in rural Siskiyou County’s Montague. He is among the estimated 80 ranchers in the association hit with the proposed fine. Photo by Martin do Nascimento, CalMatters

###

PREVIOUSLY:

###

California’s water officials plan to impose a $4,000 fine on Siskiyou County ranchers for violating orders to cut back their water use during a weeklong standoff last summer.

State officials and the ranchers agree: A $4,000 fine isn’t much of a deterrent to prevent illegal water diversions during California’s droughts. The proposed fine would amount to about $50 per rancher.

A rural water association serving about 80 ranchers and farmers — facing mounting costs from hauling water and purchasing hay to replace dried out pasture — turned on their pumps for eight days in August to divert water from the Shasta River. State and federal officials said the pumping, which violated an emergency state order, threatened the river’s water quality and its salmon and other rare species.

Rick Lemos, a fifth generation rancher and board member of the Shasta River Water Association, said violating the drought order “was the cheapest way I could have got by … When you’re to a point where you have no other choice, you do what you have to do.” He said the alternatives “would have cost us, collectively, a lot more.”

The penalty — $500 per day for eight days of pumping — is the maximum amount the State Water Resources Control Board’s enforcers can seek from the group of Siskiyou County ranchers under the state’s water code. The proposed fine requires a 20-day waiting period or a hearing before it is final.

The small amount and the long delay underscore the limited powers that the state’s water cops have to speedily intervene in conflicts over diversions they have declared illegal.

“They obviously don’t have much enforcement power, because they showed up and told us, ‘Shut your pumps off right now.’ And we said no,” said Lemos. “You would think they’d get an injunction and shut the pumps off, wouldn’t they?”

Julé Rizzardo, the water board’s assistant deputy director of permitting and enforcement for the division of water rights, said the agency’s powers are limited.

“Unfortunately, there are circumstances such as this where the economic gains that folks can get by violating curtailment orders are greater than the potential penalties available to us,” Rizzardo said.

Karuk Tribal Council Member Arron “Troy” Hockaday was disappointed by the fine.

“The punishment doesn’t fit the crime… We’re fighting for the fish. The fish are our life,” Hockaday said.

The penalty, he says, sends a message: “Siskiyou County does not have to listen to what you guys have to say — we’re gonna do what we want. And nothing’s gonna happen to us.“

In addition, the ranchers could face fines of $10,000 a day for future violations.

Under the state’s water code, fines can be larger than $500 a day only after the water board finalizes a cease and desist order, which requires a 20-day waiting period or a hearing. In the case of the Siskiyou County ranchers, Lemos and his neighbors shut their pumps off almost three weeks before the penalty would have increased to $10,000 a day.

“We knew that was coming. That’s why we pumped the water before it happened,” Lemos said.

A heifer and its calf on Scala’s ranch on Aug. 29, 2022. Photo by Martin do Nascimento, CalMatters

Jim Scala, a third-generation rancher who is president of the Shasta River Water Association’s board of directors, said he hopes the association agrees to not pay the fine and fight it instead.

“I don’t want to pay them a dime. I want to take them to court,” Scala said. “Because if we pay them $4,000 or $10,000, that’s like admitting that we were in the wrong.”

The fight began simmering in August 2021, when the water board adopted emergency regulations that allow curtailments of water pumping when flows dip below a certain level to protect the Shasta River’s salmon.

Facing dry conditions and dwindling flows, the state ramped up curtailments in the spring and summer of 2022. In early August, the Shasta River Water Association petitioned the board to continue diverting water to fill stock ponds.

But before the board had responded, the ranchers notified state water officials in an Aug. 17 letter that they planned to violate the curtailment that day.

“I don’t want to pay them a dime. I want to take them to court.”
— Rancher Jim Scala

The river’s flows dropped by nearly two-thirds and stayed there for a week until the farmers and ranchers turned the pumps back off — a “precipitous drop” that state officials said could jeopardize the river’s fish.

The state agency said that it recommends the maximum allowable fine due to the “significant volume diverted in a short period of time, … the impacts to the watershed, the sensitive timing of this violation” before salmon migration, and the continued pumping even after a violation notice and a draft cease and desist order were sent.

The river empties into the larger Klamath and is home to key spawning and rearing grounds for fall-run Chinook salmon and threatened Coho salmon. The water board’s notice Friday said that violating the curtailment resulted in lower flows that could “exacerbate negative water quality issues” and “limit fish mobility and survival.”

“This action has direct impacts on more senior water right holders and sensitive fisheries that the Emergency Regulation intends to protect,” the notice said.

“The punishment doesn’t fit the crime… We’re fighting for the fish. The fish are our life.”
Arron “Troy” Hockaday, Karuk Tribal Council Member 

Such skirmishes could flare more often as climate change brings more severe and frequent droughts to the state. But experts warn that the state’s powers don’t match the urgency of stopping illicit water use.

“The system still allows one rogue user to decide to pay a fine rather than comply with the law,” said Jennifer Harder, a law professor at the University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law. “California is a world-class economy with world-class natural resources. The state agency charged with protecting its water resources should be given world-class tools.”

Rizzardo said the state doesn’t have the resources or data necessary to police 40,000 water rights holders, particularly during a severe drought.

“We empathize. We recognize the hardships. We have been out in the field, to try to understand the situation more holistically,” Rizzardo said. “But we also aren’t going to ignore the blatant violations.”

###

CalMatters.org is a nonprofit, nonpartisan media venture explaining California policies and politics.



Eureka Police Name Decedent in Last Week’s Fatal Collision on Broadway; Investigation Ongoing

LoCO Staff / Monday, Nov. 7, 2022 @ 9:20 a.m. / Traffic

PREVIOUSLY:

###

Press release from the Eureka Police Department:

On November 3, 2022, at about 12:55 p.m., officers with the Eureka Police Department responded to the 2800 block of Broadway for the report of a collision involving two vehicles. The driver of the involved truck was reported to be uninjured while the status of the driver of the sedan was unknown.

Once on scene, and with the assistance of Humboldt Bay Fire and City Ambulance, it was determined that the driver of the sedan was deceased due to injuries sustained during the collision. The Humboldt County Sheriff’s Office Coroner responded to the scene while the investigation continued.

Next of kin has been notified and the driver has been identified as 32-year-old Aldo Emmanuel Zaragoza of Fortuna.

Based on the initial investigation, it appears Zaragoza was traveling southbound on Broadway prior to the collision. For unknown reasons Zaragoza veered across the center turn lane and into northbound oncoming traffic, colliding with the truck. It does not appear drugs or alcohol played a factor in this collision.

This is an ongoing investigation, anyone with information is asked to contact Officer Sollom at jsollom@EurekaCA.gov or (707) 441-4060.



Poverty Drops in California but Only Because of Child Tax Credit, COVID Relief Funds

Wendy Fry / Monday, Nov. 7, 2022 @ 8:38 a.m. / Sacramento

Angela Reyes Melo, 56, waits outside her car before driving to pick up supplies at a food bank on October 28, 2022, in San Diego. Reyes has been living with her son in a loaned car for the past four months. Photo by David Maung for CalMatters.

Poverty fell in California during the COVID pandemic, recent data shows, largely due to state and national safety net programs, especially the expansion of federal child tax credits.

But a deadline to file for those tax credits expires November 17, prompting advocates in California and a few state lawmakers to sound alarms.

“If you haven’t been doing your taxes, now is the time,” said Assemblymember David Alvarez, a San Diego Democrat who held a press conference reminding people to file and claim the tax credits.

“As an advocate for children, and as a parent of two, I know that the need is high right now, especially for families with children as they struggle to keep up with all the inflationary pressures.”

The California Policy Lab, a nonprofit that analyzes public data, estimates about 290,000 California children living at or near poverty could miss out on the 2021 child tax benefit — leaving $928 million on the table, according to Brett Fischer, co-author of its latest report. That’s because 37% of the people who became eligible under the 2021 guidelines — mostly those making little or no income — may be unaware they need to file income tax forms to receive the credit.

“The concern is that a lot of individuals who were eligible for this credit would not end up going through the administrative burdens of applying and filing taxes in order to gain the credits,” said Hilary Hoynes, a public policy and economics professor and the Haas Distinguished Chair in Economic Disparities at the University of California Berkeley.

Tracking poverty

Contrary to many expectations, California’s poverty rate dropped from 16.4% in 2019 to a projected 11.7% in fall 2021, according to research by the Public Policy Institute of California, a non-partisan think tank, and the Stanford Center on Poverty and Inequality. They use the California Poverty Measure, which takes into account this state’s high housing costs and various government-funded anti-poverty programs and payouts.

Based on this measure, about 4.5 million Californians live in poverty, which is pegged at $36,900 annually for a family of four.

Millions more would have been in poverty, statistics show.

The federal government’s poverty rate generally measures income from a person’s work. Under that measure, the number of Californians who fell into the poverty income threshold — say, earning $36,900 or less for a family of four — actually rose from 10.5% in 2018 to 11.6% in 2021.

But that rate doesn’t include such government assistance as child tax credits or public benefits like CalFresh. The government counts those in its supplemental poverty measure, and the Public Policy Institute similarly counts that additional help in its poverty measure.

With that assistance, 3.9 million Californians stayed out of poverty, the institute said.

State unemployment insurance, the expansion of food assistance, utility bill assistance and rental assistance all probably helped avert a bigger crisis, analysts believe.

A spokesperson for Gov. Gavin Newsom credited much of California’s positive poverty numbers to state spending, such as the $18.5 billion the state sent to residents via direct payments, $8 billion in rent relief and $2.8 billion that helped with overdue utility bills.

“California acted swiftly to support Californians hit hardest over the past few years,” said Alex Stack, a spokesperson.

At the federal level, experts said the most impactful poverty relief was the expansion of the child tax credit, which paid families $3,600 for each child under 6, and $3,000 for children ages 6 to 17.

Sleeping in a car

In San Diego, some who received the extra money from the child tax credit say it definitely made a difference.

After sleeping in a borrowed car for four months, Angela Reyes Melo and her teenaged son have squirreled away almost enough money to put down a deposit on an apartment in Lakeside, a rural suburb outside of San Diego. Some of that $3,000 came from the expanded federal child tax credit, she said.

“It saved my life,” said Reyes, who earns about $18,000 a year as a cook while supporting her son whose disability leaves him mostly non-verbal.

Still, she worries about affording that $1,600-a-month apartment and acquiring beds and furniture. But just having a roof over their heads will be a relief, she said, likely safer than sleeping in a car or at some of the shelters.

Recently a man stuck his hand in the car while they were trying to sleep, she said, and people often fight at the temporary shelter in downtown San Diego.

“If you just look at them they start screaming… and try to fight you,” she said.

Reyes also worries that her stash of cash for her apartment is slowly being whittled away by rising food costs. “Just getting everyone a burrito can cost almost $50,” she said, referring to her four-person family.

When more is less

Advocates say there are hundreds of thousands of California families with very low incomes like Angela and her son. Some experts argue that COVID-era stimulus measures should be extended, pointing to the impact they’ve had on these families.

“It’s not rocket science for how to reduce child poverty,” Hoynes said. “We just need to give people money. And that’s what we did.”

But more money can feel like less with inflation. The Bureau of Labor Statistics’ quarterly index shows wages and salaries rose by more than 5% in the fiscal year ending in September — but when adjusted for rising prices, real wages and salaries declined by 3%.

Hoynes said families said they spent relief money on basic needs such as food, school supplies, clothes and bills.

Rosalee Reyes, 29, speaks with a social worker, right, from Father Joe’s Villages, a shelter and social services center, on October 28, 2022, in San Diego. Photo by David Maung for CalMatters

That’s how Rosalee Reyes, 29, said she spent her child tax credit. Reyes, her partner and their 18-month-old baby, Elly Rose, had been living in an apartment but recently moved into a temporary shelter adjacent to San Diego’s Civic Center downtown.

“Kids are very expensive — diapers, wipes, and things like that; the money was gone within a month,” Reyes said.

“We spent it pretty much on basic needs for Elly. At that time I did have an apartment, so it went to things like gas, lights, water … I think they should have kept the credit, because it was helping a lot of families. For people who live paycheck-to-paycheck, that just provided a little extra to get through the rest of the month.”

Poverty rebounds

Carmen Ruiz Valdez, a program coordinator for Dreams for Change agrees. The San Diego-based nonprofit which helps stabilize homeless or very low-income families also assists people trying to collect tax refunds and relief benefits.

Valdez said she recently assisted a father who earned $27,000 a year but was living on the streets with his two children. He was unaware that stimulus funds were available because he had not filed tax returns, Valdez said.

With her help, he found out his family qualified for a $14,553 tax refund. “He had tears in his eyes,” she said.

Most of these COVID-era anti-poverty programs ended in mid-2021. Sarah Bohn, the vice president of research and senior fellow at the Public Policy Institute of California, predicts that new economic data will show a different poverty picture in 2022.

“We’re expecting that when we look at 2022 poverty and income inequality, that it will increase,” she said. “It won’t look as favorable as it does right now.”

###

This article is part of the California Divide project, examining income inequality and economic survival in California.

CalMatters.org is a nonprofit, nonpartisan media venture explaining California policies and politics.