Rhonda Parker / Tuesday, Jan. 24 @ 4:47 p.m. / Courts
Manila Five in Court: Two Confessed to Plot, Three Have Not — Should Their Cases Be Merged?
of the five people charged with murdering 20-year-old Tyson Eduardo
Claros have admitted their involvement and pointed fingers at the
other three. But how much of what they said would a jury be allowed
This morning the District Attorney’s Office asked Judge Joyce Hinrichs to merge the case of Tamara Nicole Thomson and her boyfriend Cesar Octavio Valenzuela with that of co-defendants Catherine Suzanne Lynn Fode, Hector Godoy-Standley and Brandon James Mitchell. All are charged with the Dec. 12 armed carjacking that ended with Claros shot multiple times and left dying on state Highway 255. At this point, two separate cases are winding their way through the courts.
Deputy District Attorney Luke Bernthal, arguing for the cases to be joined, said the prosecution is aware of potential issues over the so-called “Aranda Bruton’” rule. It limits how much, if any, of a co-defendant’s incriminating statement can be used in court. But he said his office believes the cases should be heard together.
“This is one murder and one conspiracy.” Bernthal said.
Attorneys representing the five alleged killers are opposed to combining the matters, with Godoy Standley’s lawyer David Celli pointing out that “glaring” legal issues will become apparent.
who confessed their involvement are Thomson, 18, and her boyfriend
Valenzuela, 21. Both said there had been a plan to punish Claros for
molesting Mitchell and Fode’s 3-year-old daughter. Mitchell, Fode and
their alleged cohorts were apparently unhappy that Claros was never
charged with a crime. According to Claros’ family, the molestation
allegation was investigated but no reliable evidence was
Thomson and Valenzuela admitted to investigators that they participated in the fatal plot, which began with Thomson convincing Claros she needed a ride from Eureka to McKinleyville. The driver, Brittany Boyd, was a friend of Claros, but a stranger to all five suspects. Boyd is apparently the only independent eyewitness, and she was only able to identify Thomson.
Valenzuela and Thomson were arrested within hours of the killing and were arraigned a few days later. Based on their statements, the others were arrested over the next few days. The bulk of the evidence seems based on what Valenzuela and Thomson told investigators. Both identified Mitchell, 23, as the shooter.
This morning Judge Hinrichs pointed out that the prosecution filed the motion to join the cases on Jan. 9, and she has received no written opposition from any of the defense lawyers.
Celli responded that the defense is “hamstrung” because the district attorney has turned over so little discovery, or evidence, in the case. Outside the courtroom Celli said that “based on the state of discovery (the motion) is premature.”
The prosecution handed over two small packets of evidence this morning.
As of now two separate preliminary hearings are set for February. Hinrichs told lawyers to have any written opposition to her by Jan. 31.
- 20-Year-Old Shot Dead in Manila Early This Morning; Victim Found Lying in the Middle of Highway 255
- This Morning’s Manila Homicide Victim ID’d by Sheriff’s Office
- Two Arrested in Eureka in Connection with Yesterday’s Manila Homicide
- Manila Murder Suspects Each Plead Not Guilty in Court Today
- Sheriff’s Deputies Arrest Third Person in Connection With Monday Homicide in Manila
- BOLO: Two More People Wanted by Sheriff’s Office in Connection with Manila Homicide
- Another Two Manila Homicide Suspects Taken Into Custody Last Night
- More Details Emerge in Manila Murder Conspiracy as Three Suspects Appear in Court
- INVESTIGATORS: Manila Murder Conspiracy Driven By Belief That Victim Had Sexually Abused Suspects’ Daughter
- Manila Five Appear in Court This Morning, Their Faces Ranging From Jolly to Somber as Preliminary Hearings Postponed