Rhonda Parker / Thursday, Oct. 19 @ 1:05 p.m. / Courts
New DNA Evidence Delays Trials in Manila Murder Case
Both trials have been delayed in the cases of four Eureka residents accused of murdering a 20-year-old man who was shot to death during an alleged carjacking near Manila in December 2016.
This morning Judge Christopher Wilson granted defense motions to continue the trial for Catherine Suzanne Lynn Fode and Brandon James Mitchell, and also the separate trial of former co-defendants Tamara Nicole Thomson and Cesar Octavio Valenzuela-Campos.
At issue is new DNA evidence being analyzed by the Department of Justice. That evidence will also require the defense to hire an expert, and all of that is unlikely to happen before Nov. 6, the date both trials were set to begin.
Deputy District Attorney Carolyn Schaffer did not object to the delays, saying evidence is continuing to “trickle in” to her office as well.
All four defendants are accused of killing Tyson Eduardo Claros, with Mitchell named as the shooter and the others as accomplices. Fode was the only one not seen with a gun. The apparent motive was the belief, never proven, that Claros had molested Fode and Mitchell’s 3-year-old daughter.
Thomson, 19, and her boyfriend Valenzuela-Campos, 24, were arrested first and made statements implicating themselves and the others. Because of rules about using a co-defendant’s statement to prove guilt, Thomson and Valenzuela will be tried separately from Fode, 19, and Mitchell, 23.
Fode’s attorney Neal Sanders has also filed a motion to try her separately from Mitchell. That motion is scheduled for argument Nov. 16.
This morning Schaffer told the judge she won’t be using Thomson and Valenzuela’s statements to investigators in her case against the others, but “I’m not saying I won’t use any statements.”
Wilson told the prosecutor she needs to clarify exactly what she intends to use, so the defense can respond.
A fifth defendant, Fode’s 22-year-old boyfriend Hector Godoy-Standley, was found to be developmentally disabled and therefore incompetent to stand trial. He remains in custody while options are considered for his treatment.
Possible new trial dates will be discussed during the Nov. 16 hearing on Sanders’ motion to sever Fode’s case from Mitchell’s.
Mitchell is represented by Deputy Conflict Counsel Marek Reavis, and Eureka attorney David Nims represents Thomson.
Deputy Public Defender Casey Russo, for Valenzuela-Campos, was the only attorney who said he was ready for trial Nov. 6.
- 20-Year-Old Shot Dead in Manila Early This Morning; Victim Found Lying in the Middle of Highway 255
- This Morning’s Manila Homicide Victim ID’d by Sheriff’s Office
- Two Arrested in Eureka in Connection with Yesterday’s Manila Homicide
- Manila Murder Suspects Each Plead Not Guilty in Court Today
- Sheriff’s Deputies Arrest Third Person in Connection With Monday Homicide in Manila
- BOLO: Two More People Wanted by Sheriff’s Office in Connection with Manila Homicide
- Another Two Manila Homicide Suspects Taken Into Custody Last Night
- More Details Emerge in Manila Murder Conspiracy as Three Suspects Appear in Court
- INVESTIGATORS: Manila Murder Conspiracy Driven By Belief That Victim Had Sexually Abused Suspects’ Daughter
- Manila Five Appear in Court This Morning, Their Faces Ranging From Jolly to Somber as Preliminary Hearings Postponed
- Manila Five in Court: Two Confessed to Plot, Three Have Not — Should Their Cases Be Merged?
- ‘Manila Five’ Murder Plot Suspects Will Stand Trial Together; Hearing Scheduled for Next Month
- Surprise in ‘Manila Five’ Murder Plot Trial; Eyewitness Identifies Shooter, and It’s Not the Man Charged With the Crime
- ‘They Set Him Up to Be Killed’: Sheriff’s Investigator Relays Testimony of Jailhouse Informant in Manila Murder Case
- All Five Manila Killing Suspects to Stand Trial for Murder, Carjacking, Judge Rules Today
- Parents of Manila Homicide Victim Discuss the Unproven Molestation Claims that Motivated their Son’s Alleged Killers
- ‘Manila Five’ Murder Trial Scheduled for May; More Charges Added to One Suspect’s Case This Morning
PREVIOUS POSTS ON HECTOR GODOY-STANDLEY:
- One of ‘Manila Five’ Murder Plot Suspects Deemed Mentally Incompetent, Will Not Stand Trial
- Once Suspected in Manila Murder Plot, Hector Godoy-Standley Instead Referred to Facility Serving the Developmentally Disabled
- Alleged Murder Plot Participant Stuck in Legal Limbo, as Regional Center for Developmentally Disabled Adults Declines to Serve Him
- Defendant in Manila Murder Case Has Criminal Proceedings Against Him Suspended, Will Be Committed to a State Hospital